Molecular models of neocarzinostatin damage of DNA: analysis of sequence dependence in 5'GAGCG:5'CGCTC

Neocarzinostatin naphthoate synthase: an unique iterative type I PKS from neocarzinostatin producerStreptomyces carzinostaticus

Enediyne antibiotics are known for their potent antitumor activities. One such enediyne, neocarzinostatin (NCS), consists of a 1:1 complex of non-peptide chromophore (1a), and peptide apoprotein. The structurally diverse non-peptide chromophore is responsible for its biological activity. One of its structural components, the naphthoic acid moiety (2,7-dihydroxy-5-methyl-1-naphthoic acid, 1d) is synthesized by a polyketide synthase (PKS) pathway through condensing six intact acetate units. The 5.45 kb iterative type I PKS, neocarzinostatin naphthoate synthase (NNS), responsible for naphthoic acid moiety biosynthesis, shares sequence homology with 6-methyl salicylic acid synthase of fungi and orsellinic acid synthases (AviM and CalO5) of Streptomyces origin. Cultures of S. lividans TK24 and S. coelicolor YU105 containing plasmids with NNS were able to produce 2-hydroxy-5-methyl-1-naphthoic acid (2a), a key intermediate of naphthoic acid moiety in NCS. In addition to 2a, a novel product, 2-hydroxy-5-hydroxymethyl-1-naphthoic acid (2d) was isolated. This is the first report of a bacterial iterative type I PKS from an enediyne producer which enables the biosynthesis of bicyclic aromatic compounds.

DNA cleavage characteristics of non-protein enediyne antibiotic N1999A2

N1999A2 (NA2) is a new non-protein antitumor antibiotic that contains a stable 9-membered ring enediyne chromophore similar to a neocarzinostatin chromophore (NCS-chr). We have compared DNA cleavage reactions between NA2 and NCS-chr, and also clarified some characteristics of DNA strand scission by NA2. It was found that: (1) NA2 is considerably stable in nature, (2) the compound intercalates into base pairs of a DNA minor groove and decreases its base-attacking frequency in the order of T>A>> C>G, (3) the base-sequence specificity 5(')-GGT/3(')-CCA presented by NA2 is significantly related to recognition of the base pair with the naphthoate moiety, and (4) the different cleavage property between NCS-chr and NA2 is associated with the presence or absence of an aminoglycoside residue. Based on the results of the site-specific cleavage by NA2 for certain bulged DNAs and a fluorescence study of NA2-DNA oligomer complexes, the DNA interaction mode of NA2 has also been examined. These results provide important information to design a new enediyne molecule for a DNA target.

Binding and cleavage characteristics of the complexes formed between the neocarzinostatin chromophore and single site containing oligonucleotides

It is shown by fluorescence spectroscopy that the post-activated form of neocarzinostatin chromophore (NCSi-glu) can form stable complexes with single-site oligonucleotides (SSOs) featuring sequences known to be involved in double stranded (AGC.GCT, AGT.ACT, AGA.TCT, ACA.TGT) or single stranded (AGG.CCT) cleavage (attacked residues in bold). Furthermore, the same SSOs form cleavage productive complexes with native neocarzinostatin chromophore (NCS chrom) over a similar concentration range. The productive complexes yield damage similar to that observed if the same sequence is part of a longer DNA piece. Previously identified double stranded site sequences ATT.AAT and TAT.ATA are shown to contain overlapping attack sites. Binding order preference derived from fluorescence quenching experiments for NCSi-glu is consistent with constants derived by quantitative cleavage affinity binding experiments with NCS chrom. This confirms the similarity in interactions between the NCSi-glu and NCS chrom and justifies the use of NCSi-glu as a stable analog of NCS chrom.

NMR studies of the post-activated neocarzinostatin chromophore-DNA complex. Conformational changes induced in drug and DNA

The glutathione post-activated neocarzinostatin chromophore (NCSi-glu)-DNA complex was studied in detail by 2-D NMR spectroscopy. The complex is a model for understanding the sequence specific cleavage of DNA by the native neocarzinostatin chromophore (NCS chrom), a highly potent enediyne antitumor agent. NMR spectral analysis is presented for the free NCSi-glu, the free DNA duplex and the NCSi-glu-DNA complex. In addition to the previously reported structural details of the complex (Gao, X.; Stassinopoulos, A.; Rice, J. S.; Goldberg, I. H. Biochemistry 1995, 34, 40), we demonstrate that the binding of NCSi-glu in minor groove results in a patch of negatively charged surface covering the otherwise relatively neutral minor groove. The formation of the complex is largely driven by hydrophobic forces and the solvation of the polar surface of the complex. Comparison of the conformations of NCSi-glu and DNA duplex in their free and bound form reveals an induced mutual fit of DNA and NCSi-glu upon complex formation. The reduced NCS chrom represents a DNA binding motif for sequence specific recognition of DNA via intercalation and minor groove interactions.

Selective abstraction of 2H from C-1' of the C residue in AGC.ICT by the radical center at C-2 of activated neocarzinostatin chromophore: structure of the drug/DNA complex responsible for bistranded lesion formation

Glutathione-activated neocarzinostatin chromophore (NCS-Chrom) generates bistranded lesions at AGC.GCT sequences in DNA, consisting of an abasic site at the C residue and a strand break at the T residue on the complementary strand, due to hydrogen atom abstraction from C-1' and C-5', respectively. Earlier work showed that 2H from C-5' of T was selectively abstracted by the radical center at C-6 of activated NCS-Chrom, supporting a proposed model of the active-drug/DNA complex. However, since under the conditions used breaks at the T exceeded their inclusion in bistranded lesions, it was not clear what fraction of the hydrogen transfer represented bistranded lesions. Since virtually all abasic sites at the C are part of a bistranded lesions, hydrogen transfer from C-1' of C into the drug should reflect only the bistranded reaction. Accordingly, a self-complementary oligodeoxynucleotide 5'-GCAGCICTGC-3' was synthesized in which the C contained 2H at the C-1' position. In order to eliminate an 2H isotope effect on the transfer and to increase the extent of the bistranded reaction, an I residue was substituted for the G opposite the C residue. Sequencing gel electrophoretic analysis revealed that under one-hit kinetics, 37% of the damage reaction was associated with abasic site (alkali-labile break) formation at the C residue and 48% with direct strand breaks at the T residue. Thus, 74% of the damage involved a bistranded lesion. 1H NMR spectroscopic analysis of the reacted chromophore showed that 2H had been selectively transferred into the C-2 position to the extent of approximately 22%.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Neocarzinostatin acts as a sensitive probe of DNA microheterogeneity: switching of chemistry from C-1' to C-4' by a G.T mismatch 5' to the site of DNA damage

The diradical form of thiol-activated neocarzinostatin chromophore resides in the minor groove of DNA, where it has access to hydrogen atoms at the C-5', C-1', and C-4' positions of deoxyribose on each strand. In a dodecamer oligodeoxyribonucleotide containing the sequence AGC.GCT, a bistranded lesion staggered two nucleotides in the 3' direction, is generated that consists primarily of an abasic site (2'-deoxyribonolactone) at the C due to 1' chemistry and a direct strand break at the T due to 5' chemistry. Sequencing-gel analysis reveals that 72% of the damage at the C results from 1' chemistry with minor lesions consisting of a strand break due to 5' chemistry (15%) and 4' chemistry (less than 2%) and an abasic site (4'-hydroxylation product) (12%) due to 4' chemistry. Replacement of the G.C base pair 5' to the C by a G.T wobble mismatch results in a remarkable switching of the chemistry of damage at the C from C-1' to C-4'. The 1' chemistry is almost eliminated and replaced by 4' chemistry, so that the latter accounts for 64% of the damage, mainly in the form of the 4'-hydroxylation product (abasic site) and a smaller amount of the DNA fragment with a phosphoglycolate at the 3' end (strand break). Substitution of the radiation sensitizer misonidazole for dioxygen markedly enhances partitioning of the 4' chemistry in favor of the glycolate-containing product. On the complementary strand the G.T mismatch results in an increase in 4' chemistry at the T residue, but 5' chemistry remains the main mechanism. When a G.A mismatch is inserted 5' to the C, there is a marked decrease in all damage at this site without detectable switching of chemistry. These results show that the diradical form of thiol-activated neocarzinostatin chromophore acts as sensitive probe of DNA microheterogeneity.

Neocarzinostatin-mediated DNA damage in a model AGT.ACT site: mechanistic studies of thiol-sensitive partitioning of C4' DNA damage products

Double-strand (DS) DNA damage caused by neocarzinostatin (NCS) has been studied in the trinucleotide AGT-ACT sequence in an AP-1 transcription factor binding site. There are strong similarities between bistranded lesions produced at AGT.ACT and AGC-GCT, including the fact that DS lesions outnumber SS lesions on the AGT and AGC strands, while SS exceed DS on the ACT and GCT strands. Structure-function studies revealed that a variety of different thiols produced bistranded lesions in this model by predominantly C4'-hydrogen atom abstraction (84-93%) at the T of AGT and C5'-hydrogen atom abstraction (87-91%) at the T of ACT. Single-strand (SS) lesions were found to represent a variable mixture of C4' and C5' chemistry. The C4'-hydroxylated abasic site occurred in both SS and DS lesions at both sites and accounted for most of the DS damage at AGT (60-83%); the remaining damage consisted of 3'-phosphoglycolate- and 3'-phosphate-ended fragments. The nature of the thiol was found to affect the partitioning of the breakdown products arising from C4' and, to a lesser extent, C5' hydrogen atom abstraction. Production of 3'-phosphoglycolate residues, restricted mainly to the T of AGT in bistranded lesions, correlated with the incidence of direct DS breaks in the AGT.ACT model and in plasmid DNA and appeared to be influenced by the reducing power of the thiol activator. Furthermore, hydrazine and sodium borohydride both inhibited the formation of glycolate, an effect that was exploited to determine the rate constant for 3'-phosphoglycolate formation: 0.06 min-1 at 0 degree C, pH 7.4. Under anaerobic conditions, the nitroaromatic radiation sensitizer misonidazole caused a large increase in glycolate production in both SS and DS lesions formed by NCS, which suggests that the formation of 3'-phosphoglycolate, like 3'-formylphosphate generated by C5' chemistry, involves an oxyradical intermediate. The pathways for DNA damage involving C4' and C5' hydrogen atom abstraction thus share many common features, several of which are consistent with a mechanism for the production of NCS-mediated bistranded lesions at AGT.ACT that involves a tetraoxide bridge joining the lesions on opposite strands of DNA.

Modulation of neocarzinostatin-mediated DNA double strand damage by activating thiol: deuterium isotope effects

The neocarzinostatin chromophore causes double-strand damage at AGC sequences on DNA by concomitant 1'-oxidation at C and 5'-oxidation at the T on the complementary strand. The extent of this damage is dependent upon the structure of the thiol used for activation. Deuterium isotope effects suggest that this dependence on thiol structure may be due to internal quenching of one radical site of the activated chromophore by the hydrogen atoms of the thiol sidechain. The 12-mer d[GCAAGCGCTTGC] is treated with the neocarzinostatin chromophore and either sodium thioglycolate or [2-2H2]-thioglycolate, and the distribution of strand breaks is determined by gel electrophoresis. Two isotope effects are noted: an overall sequence-independent effect in which deuterated thioglycolate increases total strand damage by a factor of 2, and a sequence-specific effect by which deuteration increases the proportion of alkali-sensitive strand damage at C6 by an additional factor of 1.5. Methyl thioglycolate shows essentially identical behavior to that of thioglycolate anion, ruling out electrostatic effects as major contributors to the effect of thiol structure on the mode of DNA damage observed. A model for NCSC action consistent with these results is discussed.

Influence of thiol structure on neocarzinostatin activation and expression of DNA damage

Neocarzinostatin (NCS) is an enediyne antitumor antibiotic that cleaves DNA following a thiol-induced electronic rearrangement to a diradical form. Structure-function studies with 11 thiol-containing compounds were undertaken to clarify the role of the thiol in NCS-mediated DNA damage. The rates of activation of NCS in the presence of DNA with the various thiols approximated a Brønsted relation (beta = 0.43, r2 = 0.86), which suggests that the basicity/nucleophilicity of the thiol is important to NCS activation. However, an additional contribution to NCS activation may arise from the affinity of the thiol for DNA, since there is a correlation between the concentration of thiol producing maximal DNA damage, assessed by quantitating the topologic forms of plasmid pBR322 following treatment with NCS, and the apparent ability of the thiol to bind to DNA by hydrophobic or electrostatic interactions. The overall second-order rate constants for the activation of NCS were found to be inversely correlated with the thiol optima; a plot of the former versus the reciprocal of the optimal thiol concentration revealed a first-order rate constant of activation of 0.013 s-1 in the presence of DNA. This indicates that maximal DNA damage occurs when NCS is activated with a half-life of 52 s, a relatively slow rate of activation that suggests that NCS binds to DNA before undergoing activation by thiol. Finally, an analysis of strand breaks in pBR322 shows that thiols possessing a carboxylate moiety produce larger quantities of bistranded DNA lesions than their esterified or non-carboxylate-containing counterparts.

Studies on DNA-cleaving agents: computer modeling analysis of the mechanism of activation and cleavage of dynemicin-oligonucleotide complexes

Dynemicin A is a recently identified antitumor antibiotic. Upon activation, dynemicin is reported to cause double-stranded cleavage of DNA, putatively through the intermediacy of a diradical. Computer modeling of this activation and cleavage process is described herein as part of an effort to establish a structural hypothesis for this mechanistic sequence and for the design of simple analogues. Intercalation complexes of duplex dodecamers [d(CGCGAATTCGCG)]2 and [d(GC)6]2 with both enantiomers of dynemicin and of all related mechanistic intermediates are evaluated. Examination of these structures shows that cycloaromatization of dynemicin to a diradical intermediate results in the rotation of the diradical-forming subunit with respect to the intercalation plane that is of an opposite sense for the two dynemicin enantiomers. In addition, the activation of the (2S) enantiomer of dynemicin occurs by a less restricted approach trajectory than the corresponding (2R) enantiomer. In all complexes, the 5'-3' strand is at least 1 A closer than the 3'-5' strand to the diyl intermediate. As a result, complexes are produced in which the diyl moiety is aligned along [(2S)] or across [(2R)] the minor groove, leading to different predictions for the selectivity of radical-initiated, oxidative lesion of DNA. Molecular dynamics simulations are found to support these predictions, including the 3-base-pair offset cleavage reported for dynemicin.

Selective abstraction of 2H from C-5' of thymidylate in an oligodeoxynucleotide by the radical center at C-6 of the diradical species of neocarzinostatin: chemical evidence for the structure of the activated drug-DNA complex

Use has been made of the mechanism of DNA deoxyribose damage by the ene-diyne-containing chromophore of the antitumor antibiotic neocarzinostatin to provide chemical evidence for the structure of the activated drug-DNA complex. Radical centers at C-2 and C-6 of the diradical form of the glutathione-activated chromophore abstract hydrogen atoms from C-1' of the C residue and C-5' of the T residue in AGC.GCT to generate a bistranded lesion consisting of an abasic site at C and a strand break at T. This laboratory has proposed a molecular model for the drug-DNA interaction in which the naphthoate moiety of the chromophore intercalates between A.T and G.C, placing the diradical core in the minor groove, so that the radical centers at C-6 and C-2 are close to C-5' of T and C-1' of C, respectively. To determine which radical center abstracts one of the hydrogen atoms from C-5', the self-complementary oligodeoxynucleotide GCAGCGCTGC was synthesized with 2H at both 5' positions of the T residue and treated with glutathione-activated chromophore. Sequencing-gel electrophoresis showed that drug attack was limited to the T and C residues and that abstraction of 2H from C-5' exhibited a small isotope selection effect of 1.25. 1H NMR spectroscopic examination of the reacted chromophore, isolated by HPLC, indicated that 2H was selectively abstracted by C-6, providing experimental corroboration of the model and further elucidating the chemical mechanism. Since direct strand breakage at the T residue exceeds (44% more) abasic site formation at the C residue, other models of drug-DNA interaction leading to only single-strand breaks are also considered.

A note on graphing helical parameters of dynamics structure of DNA

A graphical procedure for analysis of helical parameters in dynamic structure of DNA is described. The performance of the procedure is illustrated by analysis of a 20 ps dynamics simulation of the non-self-complementary ninemer, 5'CAAACAGGA:5'TCCTGTTTG, which is a part of DNA from lacI gene. The dynamics trajectory of the duplex shows sequence-dependent fluctuations of helical parameters.