Conformation and structural fluctuations of a 218 nucleotides long rRNA fragment: 4-thiouridine as an intrinsic photolabelling probe

A single natural RNA modification can destabilize a U•A-T-rich RNA•DNA-DNA triple helix

Recent studies suggest noncoding RNAs interact with genomic DNA, forming RNA•DNA-DNA triple helices, as a mechanism to regulate transcription. One way cells could regulate the formation of these triple helices is through RNA modifications. With over 140 naturally occurring RNA modifications, we hypothesize that some modifications stabilize RNA•DNA-DNA triple helices while others destabilize them. Here, we focus on a pyrimidine-motif triple helix composed of canonical U•A-T and C•G-C base triples. We employed electrophoretic mobility shift assays and microscale thermophoresis to examine how 11 different RNA modifications at a single position in an RNA•DNA-DNA triple helix affect stability: 5-methylcytidine (m⁵C), 5-methyluridine (m⁵U or rT), 3-methyluridine (m³U), pseudouridine (Ψ), 4-thiouridine (s⁴U), N ⁶-methyladenosine (m⁶A), inosine (I), and each nucleobase with 2'-O-methylation (Nm). Compared to the unmodified U•A-T base triple, some modifications have no significant change in stability (Um•A-T), some have ∼2.5-fold decreases in stability (m⁵U•A-T, Ψ•A-T, and s⁴U•A-T), and some completely disrupt triple helix formation (m³U•A-T). To identify potential biological examples of RNA•DNA-DNA triple helices controlled by an RNA modification, we searched RMVar, a database for RNA modifications mapped at single-nucleotide resolution, for lncRNAs containing an RNA modification within a pyrimidine-rich sequence. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays, the binding of DNA-DNA to a 22-mer segment of human lncRNA Al157886.1 was destabilized by ∼1.7-fold with the substitution of m⁵C at known m⁵C sites. Therefore, the formation and stability of cellular RNA•DNA-DNA triple helices could be influenced by RNA modifications.

Universal and strain specific structure features of segment 8 genomic RNA of influenza A virus-application of 4-thiouridine photocrosslinking

RNA structure in the influenza A virus (IAV) has been the focus of several studies that have shown connections between conserved secondary structure motifs and their biological function in the virus replication cycle. Questions have arisen on how to best recognize and understand the pandemic properties of IAV strains from an RNA perspective, but determination of the RNA secondary structure has been challenging. Herein, we used chemical mapping to determine the secondary structure of segment 8 viral RNA (vRNA) of the pandemic A/California/04/2009 (H1N1) strain of IAV. Additionally, this long, naturally occurring RNA served as a model to evaluate RNA mapping with 4-thiouridine (4sU) crosslinking. We explored 4-thiouridine as a probe of nucleotides in close proximity, through its incorporation into newly transcribed RNA and subsequent photoactivation. RNA secondary structural features both universal to type A strains and unique to the A/California/04/2009 (H1N1) strain were recognized. 4sU mapping confirmed and facilitated RNA structure prediction, according to several rules: 4sU photocross-linking forms efficiently in the double-stranded region of RNA with some flexibility, in the ends of helices, and across bulges and loops when their structural mobility is permitted. This method highlighted three-dimensional properties of segment 8 vRNA secondary structure motifs and allowed to propose several long-range three-dimensional interactions. 4sU mapping combined with chemical mapping and bioinformatic analysis could be used to enhance the RNA structure determination as well as recognition of target regions for antisense strategies or viral RNA detection.

Specific Chemical Approaches for Studying Mammalian Ribosomes Complexed with Ligands Involved in Selenoprotein Synthesis

Chemical approaches are very powerful tools for investigating the molecular structure and architecture of large ribonucleoprotein complexes involving ribosomes and other components of the translation system. Application of RNA nucleotide-specific and cross-linking reagents of a broad specificity range allows the researcher to obtain information on the sites of ligand binding to the ribosome and to each other as well as on the RNA rearrangements caused by the binding. Here, we describe specific chemical approaches including chemical probing and site-directed or bifunctional reagent-mediated cross-linking, which have been used for exploring the mechanism of selenocysteine insertion into a polypeptide chain by mammalian ribosomes.

A novel insight into the mechanism of mammalian selenoprotein synthesis

The amino acid selenocysteine is encoded by UGA, usually a stop codon, thus requiring a specialized machinery to enable its incorporation into selenoproteins. The machinery comprises the tRNA(Sec), a 3'-UTR mRNA stem-loop termed SElenoCysteine Insertion Sequence (SECIS), which is mandatory for recoding UGA as a Sec codon, the SECIS Binding Protein 2 (SBP2), and other proteins. Little is known about the molecular mechanism and, in particular, when, where, and how the SECIS and SBP2 contact the ribosome. Previous work by others used the isolated SECIS RNA to address this question. Here, we developed a novel approach using instead engineered minimal selenoprotein mRNAs containing SECIS elements derivatized with photoreactive groups. By cross-linking experiments in rabbit reticulocyte lysate, new information could be gained about the SBP2 and SECIS contacts with components of the translation machinery at various translation steps. In particular, we found that SBP2 was bound only to the SECIS in 48S pre-initiation and 80S pretranslocation complexes. In the complex where the Sec-tRNA(Sec) was accommodated to the A site but transpeptidation was blocked, SBP2 bound the ribosome and possibly the SECIS element as well, and the SECIS had flexible contacts with the 60S ribosomal subunit involving several ribosomal proteins. Altogether, our findings led to broadening our understanding about the unique mechanism of selenocysteine incorporation in mammals.

Hydrogen bonding and packing density are factors most strongly connected to limiting sites of high flexibility in the 16S rRNA in the 30S ribosome

BACKGROUND

Conformational flexibility in structured RNA frequently is critical to function. The 30S ribosomal subunit exists in different conformations in different functional states due to changes in the central part of the 16S rRNA. We are interested in evaluating the factors that might be responsible for restricting flexibility to specific parts of the 16S rRNA using biochemical data obtained from the 30S subunit in solution. This problem was approached taking advantage of the observation that there must be a high degree of conformational flexibility at sites where UV photocrosslinking occurs and a lack of flexibility inhibits photoreactivity at many other sites that are otherwise suitable for reaction.

RESULTS

We used 30S x-ray structures to quantify the properties of the nucleotide pairs at UV- and UVA-s4U-induced photocrosslinking sites in 16S rRNA and compared these to the properties of many hundreds of additional sites that have suitable geometry but do not undergo photocrosslinking. Five factors that might affect RNA flexibility were investigated - RNA interactions with ribosomal proteins, interactions with Mg2+ ions, the presence of long-range A minor motif interactions, hydrogen bonding and the count of neighboring heavy atoms around the center of each nucleobase to estimate the neighbor packing density. The two factors that are very different in the unreactive inflexible pairs compared to the reactive ones are the average number of hydrogen bonds and the average value for the number of neighboring atoms. In both cases, these factors are greater for the unreactive nucleotide pairs at a statistically very significant level.

CONCLUSION

The greater extent of hydrogen bonding and neighbor atom density in the unreactive nucleotide pairs is consistent with reduced flexibility at a majority of the unreactive sites. The reactive photocrosslinking sites are clustered in the 30S subunit and this indicates nonuniform patterns of hydrogen bonding and packing density in the 16S rRNA tertiary structure. Because this analysis addresses inter-nucleotide distances and geometry between nucleotides distant in the primary sequence, the results indicate regional and global flexibility of the rRNA.

RNA crosslinking methods

RNA-RNA crosslinking provides a rapid means of obtaining evidence for the proximity of functional groups in structurally complex RNAs and ribonucleoproteins. Such evidence can be used to provide a physical context for interpreting structural information from other biochemical and biophysical methods and for the design of further experiments. The identification of crosslinks that accurately reflect the native conformation of the RNA of interest is strongly dependent on the position of the crosslinking agent, the conditions of the crosslinking reaction, and the method for mapping the crosslink position. Here, we provide an overview of protocols and experimental considerations for RNA-RNA crosslinking with the most commonly used long- and short-range photoaffinity reagents. Specifically, we describe the merits and strategies for random and site-specific incorporation of these reagents into RNA, the crosslinking reaction and isolation of crosslinked products, the mapping crosslinked sites, and assessment of the crosslinking data.

Trypanosoma brucei ATPase subunit 6 mRNA bound to gA6-14 forms a conserved three-helical structure

T. brucei survival relies on the expression of mitochondrial genes, most of which require RNA editing to become translatable. In trypanosomes, RNA editing involves the insertion and deletion of uridylates, a developmentally regulated process directed by guide RNAs (gRNAs) and catalyzed by the editosome, a complex of proteins. The pathway for mRNA/gRNA complex formation and assembly with the editosome is still unknown. Work from our laboratory has suggested that distinct mRNA/gRNA complexes anneal to form a conserved core structure that may be important for editosome assembly. The secondary structure for the apocytochrome b (CYb) pair has been previously determined and is consistent with our model of a three-helical structure. Here, we used cross-linking and solution structure probing experiments to determine the structure of the ATPase subunit 6 (A6) mRNA hybridized to its cognate gA6-14 gRNA in different stages of editing. Our results indicate that both unedited and partially edited A6/gA6-14 pairs fold into a three-helical structure similar to the previously characterized CYb/gCYb-558 pair. These results lead us to conclude that at least two mRNA/gRNA pairs with distinct editing sites and distinct primary sequences fold to a three-helical secondary configuration that persists through the first few editing events.

Analysis of ribosomal shunting during translation initiation in eukaryotic mRNAs

In eukaryotes, translation initiation involves recruitment of ribosomal subunits at either the 5' m7G cap structure or at an internal ribosome entry site (IRES). For most mRNAs, the initiation codon is located some distance downstream, necessitating ribosomal movement to this site. Although the mechanistic details of this movement remain to be fully resolved, it appears to be nonlinear for some mRNAs (i.e., ribosomal subunits appear to bypass [shunt] segments of the 5' leader as they move to the initiation codon). This chapter describes various experimental approaches to assess ribosomal shunting and to identify mRNA elements (shunt sites) that facilitate shunting. In addition, we provide an overview of approaches that can be used to investigate the mechanism used by individual shunt sites, along with a detailed protocol for investigating putative base pairing interactions between shunt sites and 18S rRNA.

Conformational energy and structure in canonical and noncanonical forms of tRNA determined by temperature analysis of the rate of s(4)U8-C13 photocrosslinking

Bacterial tRNAs frequently have 4-thiouridine (s(4)U) modification at position 8, which is adjacent to the C13-G22-m(7)G46 base triple in the elbow region of the tRNA tertiary structure. Irradiation with light in the UVA range induces an efficient photocrosslink between s(4)U8 and C13. The temperature dependence of the rate constants for photocrosslinking between the s(4)U8 and C13 has been used to investigate the tRNA conformational energy and structure in Escherichia coli tRNA(Val), tRNA(Phe), and tRNA(fMet) under different conditions. Corrections have been made in the measured rate constants to compensate for differences in the excited state lifetimes due to tRNA identity, buffer conditions, and temperature. The resulting rate constants are related to the rate at which the s(4)U8 and C13 come into the alignment needed for photoreaction; this depends on an activation energy, attributable to the conformational potential energy that occurs during the photoreaction, and on the extent of the structural change. Different photocrosslinking rate constants and temperature dependencies occur in the three tRNAs, and these differences are due both to modest differences in the activation energies and in the apparent s(4)U8-C13 geometries. Analysis of tRNA(Val) in buffers without Mg(2+) indicate a smaller activation energy (~13 kJ mol(-1)) and a larger apparent s(4)U8-C13 distance (~12 A) compared to values for the same parameters in buffers with Mg(2+) (~26 kJ mol(-1) and 0.36 A, respectively). These measurements are a quantitative indication of the strong constraint that Mg(2+) imposes on the tRNA flexibility and structure.

Eukaryotic ribosomal protein RPS25 interacts with the conserved loop region in a dicistroviral intergenic internal ribosome entry site

The intergenic region-internal ribosome entry site (IGR-IRES) of dicistroviruses binds to 40S ribosomal subunits in the absence of eukaryotic initiation factors (eIFs). Although the conserved loop sequences in dicistroviral IGR-IRES elements are protected from chemical modifications in the presence of the 40S subunit, molecular components in the 40S subunit, which interacts with the loop sequences in the IRES, have not been identified. Here, a chemical crosslinking study using 4-thiouridine-labeled IGR-IRES revealed interactions of the IGR-IRES with several 40S proteins but not with the 18S rRNA. The strongest crosslinking signal was identified for ribosomal protein S25 (rpS25). rpS25 is known to be a neighbor of rpS5, which has been shown to interact with a related IGR-IRES by cryo-electron microscopy. Crosslinking analysis with site-directed mutants showed that nucleotides UU_6089–6090, which are located in the loop region in conserved domain 2b in the IRES, appear to interact with rpS25. rpS25 is specific to eukaryotes, which explains why there is no recognition of the IGR-IRES by prokaryotic ribosomes. Although the idea that the IGR-IRES element may be a relict of a primitive translation system has been postulated, our experimental data suggest that the IRES has adapted to eukaryotic ribosomal proteins.

New tertiary constraints between the RNA components of active yeast spliceosomes: a photo-crosslinking study

Elucidation of the three-dimensional (3D) structures of the two sequential active sites in spliceosomes is essential for understanding the mechanism of premessenger RNA splicing. The mechanism is predicted to be catalyzed by the small nuclear RNA (snRNA) components of spliceosomes. To obtain new tertiary constraints between the RNA components, we produced and mapped crosslinks between U6 snRNA and the proximal RNAs of active yeast spliceosomes ("yeast" in this report is Saccharomyces cerevisiae). Thus, specific sites in U6, when substituted with a photoreactive 4-thiouridine or 5-iodouridine, produced spliceosome-dependent crosslinks to U2 snRNA, or in one case, to the pre-mRNA substrate. One set of U2-U6 crosslinks formed before the Prp2p-dependent step of spliceosome assembly, whereas another set formed during or after this step but before the first chemical step of splicing. This latter set of crosslinks formed across U2-U6 helix I. Importantly, this set provides new tertiary constraints for developing 3D models of fully assembled yeast spliceosomes, which are poised for the first chemical step of splicing.

Analysis of a long-range interaction between conserved domains of human telomerase RNA

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein complex responsible for maintaining telomere length of eukaryotic chromosomes. Human telomerase has two main components, the human telomerase reverse transcriptase and the human telomerase RNA (hTR). Two domains of hTR essential for telomerase activity are the template domain, comprised of an 11-nt templating and alignment sequence, and the CR4/CR5 domain. Highly conserved residues in the CR4/CR5 domain form the stem-loop P6.1, which is important for assembly and activity of mammalian telomerase. Here, we have determined that stem-loop P6.1 can participate in a long-range RNA-RNA interaction with the template region of hTR. We characterized this interaction through mobility shift assays, mutation analysis, and UV cross-linking experiments. Mutation analysis revealed that the P6.1 loop nucleotides participate in the interaction with the template. The site of interaction at the template domain was determined via UV cross-linking experiments. These data show that an RNA-RNA interaction exists between two highly conserved regions of hTR that are critical for the higher order folding of telomerase RNA. This interaction argues for the proximity of the template and the CR4/CR5 domain, and provides the basis for a revised model of hTR, partitioning the RNA into a catalytic domain and a localization domain.

Stop codons and UGG promote efficient binding of the polypeptide release factor eRF1 to the ribosomal A site

To investigate the codon dependence of human eRF1 binding to the mRNA-ribosome complex, we examined the formation of photocrosslinks between ribosomal components and mRNAs bearing a photoactivable 4-thiouridine probe in the first position of the codon located in the A site. Addition of eRF1 to the phased mRNA-ribosome complexes triggers a codon-dependent quenching of crosslink formation. The concentration of eRF1 triggering half quenching ranges from low for the three stop codons, to intermediate for s4UGG and high for other near-cognate triplets. A theoretical analysis of the photochemical processes occurring in a two-state bimolecular model raises a number of stringent conditions, fulfilled by the system studied here, and shows that in any case sound KD values can be extracted if the ratio mT/KD<<1 (mT is total concentration of mRNA added). Considering the KD values obtained for the stop, s4UGG and sense codons (approximately 0.06 microM, 0.45 microM and 2.3 microM, respectively) and our previous finding that only the stop and s4UGG codons are able to promote formation of an eRF1-mRNA crosslink, implying a role for the NIKS loop at the tip of the N domain, we propose a two-step model for eRF1 binding to the A site: a codon-independent bimolecular step is followed by an isomerisation step observed solely with stop and s4UGG codons. Full recognition of the stop codons by the N domain of eRF1 triggers a rearrangement of bound eRF1 from an open to a closed conformation, allowing the universally conserved GGQ loop at the tip of the M domain to come into close proximity of the peptidyl transferase center of the ribosome. UGG is expected to behave as a cryptic stop codon, which, owing to imperfect eRF1-codon recognition, does not allow full reorientation of the M domain of eRF1. As far as the physical steps of eRF1 binding to the ribosome are considered, they appear to closely mimic the behaviour of the tRNA/EF-Tu/GTP complex, but clearly eRF1 is endowed with a greater conformational flexibility than tRNA.

Short-range RNA-RNA crosslinking methods to determine rRNA structure and interactions

We describe details of procedures to analyze RNA-RNA crosslinks made by far-UV irradiation (< 300 nm) or made by irradiation with near-UV light (320-365 nm) on RNA containing photosensitive nucleotides, in the present case containing 4-thiouridine. Zero-length crosslinks of these types must occur because of the close proximity of the participants through either specific interactions or transient contacts in the folded RNA structure, so they are valuable monitors of the conformation of the RNA. Procedures to produce crosslinks in the 16S ribosomal RNA and between the 16S rRNA and mRNA or tRNA are described. Gel electrophoresis conditions are described that separate the products according to their structure to allow the determination of the number and frequency of the crosslinking products. Gel electrophoresis together with an ultracentrifugation procedure for the efficient recovery of RNA from the polyacrylamide gels allows the purification of molecules containing different crosslinks. These separation techniques allow the analysis of the sites of crosslinking by primer extension and RNA sequencing techniques. The procedures are applicable to other types of RNA molecules with some differences to control levels of crosslinking and separation conditions.

The polypeptide chain release factor eRF1 specifically contacts the s(4)UGA stop codon located in the A site of eukaryotic ribosomes

It has been shown previously [Brown, C.M. & Tate, W.P. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 33164-33170.] that the polypeptide chain release factor RF2 involved in translation termination in prokaryotes was able to photocrossreact with mini-messenger RNAs containing stop signals in which U was replaced by 4-thiouridine (s4U). Here, using the same strategy we have monitored photocrosslinking to eukaryotic ribosomal components of 14-mer mRNA in the presence of tRNA(f)(Met), and 42-mer mRNA in the presence of tRNA(Asp) (tRNA(Asp) gene transcript). We show that: (a) both 14-mer and 42-mer mRNAs crossreact with ribosomal RNA and ribosomal proteins. The patterns of the crosslinked ribosomal proteins are similar with both mRNAs and sensitive to ionic conditions; (b) the crosslinking patterns obtained with 42-mer mRNAs show characteristic modification upon addition of tRNA(Asp) providing evidence for appropriate mRNA phasing onto the ribosome. Similar changes are not detected with the 14-mer mRNA.tRNA(f)(Met) pairs; (c) when eukaryotic polypeptide chain release factor 1 (eRF1) is added to the ribosome.tRNA(Asp) complex it crossreacts with the 42-mer mRNA containing the s(4)UGA stop codon located in the A site, but not with the s(4)UCA sense codon; this crosslink involves the N-terminal and middle domains of eRF1 but not the C domain which interacts with eukaryotic polypeptide chain release factor 3 (eRF3); (d) addition of eRF3 has no effect on the yield of eRF1-42-mer mRNA crosslinking and eRF3 does not crossreact with 42-mer mRNA. These experiments delineate the in vitro conditions allowing optimal phasing of mRNA on the eukaryotic ribosome and demonstrate a direct and specific contact of 'core' eRF1 and s(4)UGA stop codon within the ribosomal A site.

Determination of tRNA(Phe) nucleotides contacting the subunits of Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase by photoaffinity crosslinking

The nucleotides of tRNA(Phe) interacting with the subunits of Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (the alpha(2)beta(2) heterotetramer) have been determined by photoaffinity crosslinking of randomly s(4)U-monosubstituted tRNA(Phe) transcripts which retain aminoacylation parameters closely similar to those of the native tRNA(Phe). The thiolated transcripts have been fractionated by affinity electrophoresis and separately crosslinked to the enzyme. Sites of crosslinking to the beta subunit have been identified at positions 33 and 39 and crosslinking sites to the alpha subunit have been localized at positions 20, 45 and 47, using alkaline hydrolysis analysis of the crosslinked proteinase K-treated tRNAs. An additional crosslink to the beta subunit, not identified in the full-length crosslinked tRNAs, has been deduced to occur at position 12, based on the analysis of an unusual (fast migrating) crosslinked product. Nucleotide s(4)U8 of native tRNA(Phe) has been shown to form a minor crosslink to the alpha subunit. Four of the seven crosslinking sites, namely nucleotides 8, 12, 20 and 39, are among those shown to be protected against cleavage by iodine in footprinting experiments; in contrast, only nucleotide 12 is among the contact sites defined in the crystal structure. The data of independent biochemical approaches strongly suggest conformational flexibility of the complex under functional conditions, thus reflecting the importance of macromolecular dynamics for the interaction.

Arrangement of the central pseudoknot region of 16S rRNA in the 30S ribosomal subunit determined by site-directed 4-thiouridine crosslinking

The 16S rRNA central pseudoknot region in the 30S ribosomal subunit has been investigated by photocrosslinking from 4-thiouridine (s4U) located in the first 20 nt of the 16S rRNA. RNA fragments (nt 1-20) were made by in vitro transcription to incorporate s4U at every uridine position or were made by chemical synthesis to incorporate s4U into one of the uridine positions at +5, +14, +17, or +20. These were ligated to RNA containing nt 21-1542 of the 16S rRNA sequence and, after gel purification, the ligated RNA was reconstituted into 30S subunits. Long-range intramolecular crosslinks were produced by near-UV irradiation; these were separated by gel electrophoresis and analyzed by reverse transcription reactions. A number of crosslinks are made in each of the constructs, which must reflect the structural flexibility or conformational heterogeneity in this part of the 30S subunit. All of the constructs show crosslinking to the 559-562, 570-571, and 1080-1082 regions; however, other sites are crosslinked specifically from each s4U position. The most distinctive crosslinking sites are: 341-343 and 911-917 for s4U(+5); 903-904 (very strong), 1390-1397, and 1492 for s4U(+14); and 903-904 (moderate) for s4U(+17); in the 1070-1170 region in which there are different patterns for each s4U position. These results indicate that part of the central pseudoknot is in close contact with the decoding region, with helix 27 in the 885-912 interval and with part of domain III RNA. Crosslinking between s4U(+14) and 1395-1397 is consistent with base pairing at U14-A1398.

UV-induced crosslinks in the 16S rRNAs of Escherichia coli, Bacillus subtilis and Thermus aquaticus and their implications for ribosome structure and photochemistry

Sixteen long-range crosslinks are induced in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA by far-UV irradiation. Crosslinking patterns in two other organisms, Bacillus subtilis and Thermus aquaticus, were investigated to determine if the number and location of crosslinks in E.coli occur because of unusually photoreactive nucleotides at particular locations in the rRNA sequence. Thirteen long-range crosslinks in B.subtilis and 15 long-range crosslinks in T.aquaticus were detected by gel electrophoresis and 10 crosslinks in each organism were identified completely by reverse transcription analysis. Of the 10 identified crosslinks in B.subtilis, eight correspond exactly to E.coli crosslinks and two crosslinks are formed close to sites of crosslinks in E.coli. Of the 10 identified crosslinks in T.aquaticus, five correspond exactly to E.coli crosslinks, three are formed close to E.coli crosslinking sites, one crosslink corresponds to a UV laser irradiation-induced crosslink in E.coli and the last is not seen in E.coli. The overall similarity of crosslink positions in the three organisms suggests that the crosslinks arise from tertiary interactions that are highly conserved but with differences in detail in some regions.

Multiple binding modes of substrate to the catalytic RNA subunit of RNase P from Escherichia coli

M1 RNA that contained 4'-thiouridine was photochemically cross-linked to different substrates and to a product of the reaction it governs. The locations of the cross-links in these photochemically induced complexes were identified. The cross-links indicated that different substrates share some contacts but have distinct binding modes to M1 RNA. The binding of some substrates also results in a substrate-dependent conformational change in the enzymatic RNA, as evidenced by the appearance of an M1 RNA intramolecular cross-link. The identification of the cross-links between M1 RNA and product indicate that they are shared with only one of the three cross-linked E-S complexes that were identified, an indication of noncompetitive inhibition by the product. We also examined whether the cross-linked complexes between M1 RNA and substrate(s) or product are altered in the presence of the enzyme's protein cofactor (C5 protein) and in the presence of different concentrations of divalent metal ions. C5 protein enhanced the yield of certain M1 RNA-substrate cross-linked complexes for both wild-type M1 RNA and a deletion mutant of M1 RNA (delta[273-281]), but not for the M1 RNA-product complex. High concentrations of Mg2+ increased the yield of all M1 RNA-substrate complexes but not the M1 RNA-product complex.

rRNA-complementarity in the 5' untranslated region of mRNA specifying the Gtx homeodomain protein: evidence that base- pairing to 18S rRNA affects translational efficiency

Numerous eukaryotic mRNAs contain sequences complementary to segments of the 18S and 28S rRNAs. Previous studies raised the possibility that these complementarities might allow mRNA-rRNA interactions and affect rates of translation. In the present study, we investigated the mRNA encoding the mouse Gtx homeodomain protein. This mRNA contains within its 5' untranslated region (UTR) a segment that is complementary to two regions of the 18S rRNA, located at nucleotides 701-741 and 1104-1136. A Gtx RNA probe containing this complementarity could be photochemically cross-linked to ribosomal subunits through a linkage to 18S rRNA but not to 28S rRNA. Oligonucleotide-directed RNase H digestion of the rRNA and a reverse transcription analysis localized the cross-linked probe to the complementary segment of 18S rRNA at nucleotides 1104-1136 but not at nucleotides 701-741. To determine whether complementarity in the Gtx mRNA affected translation, a mutational analysis was performed with a Gtx-luciferase fusion construct and four related constructs with altered complementarity to the 18S rRNA. These constructs were examined for their ability to be translated in cell-free lysates prepared from P19 embryonal carcinoma and C6 glioma cell lines and after cellular transfection into these same cell lines. In both cell-free translation and transfection studies, the rate of translation decreased more than 9-fold as the degree of complementarity to nucleotides 1104-1136 of the 18S rRNA increased. We hypothesize that segments complementary to rRNA, such as those contained within the Gtx mRNA, form a category of cis-acting regulatory elements in mRNAs that affect translation by base pairing to rRNA within ribosomes.

Neighborhood of 16S rRNA nucleotides U788/U789 in the 30S ribosomal subunit determined by site-directed crosslinking

Site-specific photo crosslinking has been used to investigate the RNA neighborhood of 16S rRNA positions U788/ U789 in Escherichia coli 30S subunits. For these studies, site-specific psoralen (SSP) which contains a sulfhydryl group on a 17 A side chain was first added to nucleotides U788/U789 using a complementary guide DNA by annealing and phototransfer. Modified RNA was purified from the DNA and unmodified RNA. For some experiments, the SSP, which normally crosslinks at an 8 A distance, was derivitized with azidophenacylbromide (APAB) resulting in the photoreactive azido moiety at a maximum of 25 A from the 4' position on psoralen (SSP25APA). 16S rRNA containing SSP, SSP25APA or control 16S rRNA were reconstituted and 30S particles were isolated. The reconstituted subunits containing SSP or SSP25APA had normal protein composition, were active in tRNA binding and had the usual pattern of chemical reactivity except for increased kethoxal reactivity at G791 and modest changes in four other regions. Irradiation of the derivatized 30S subunits in activation buffer produced several intramolecular RNA crosslinks that were visualized and separated by gel electrophoresis and characterized by primer extension. Four major crosslink sites made by the SSP reagent were identified at positions U561/U562, U920/U921, C866 and U723; a fifth major crosslink at G693 was identified when the SSP25APA reagent was used. A number of additional crosslinks of lower frequency were seen, particularly with the APA reagent. These data indicate a central location close to the decoding region and central pseudoknot for nucleotides U788/U789 in the activated 30S subunit.

rRNA complementarity within mRNAs: a possible basis for mRNA-ribosome interactions and translational control

Our recent demonstration that many eukaryotic mRNAs contain sequences complementary to rRNA led to the hypothesis that these sequences might mediate specific interactions between mRNAs and ribosomes and thereby affect translation. In the present experiments, the ability of complementary sequences to bind to rRNA was investigated by using photochemical cross-linking. RNA probes with perfect complementarity to 18S or 28S rRNA were shown to cross-link specifically to the corresponding rRNA within intact ribosomal subunits. Similar results were obtained by using probes based on natural mRNA sequences with varying degrees of complementarity to the 18S rRNA. RNase H cleavage localized four such probes to complementary regions of the 18S rRNA. The effects of complementarity on translation were assessed by using the mRNA encoding ribosomal protein S15. This mRNA contains a sequence within its coding region that is complementary to the 18S rRNA at 20 of 22 nucleotides. RNA from an S15-luciferase fusion construct was translated in a cell-free lysate and compared with the translation of four related constructs that were mutated to decrease complementarity to the 18S rRNA. These mutations did not alter the amino acid sequence or the codon bias. A correlation between complementarity and translation was observed; constructs with less complementarity increased the amount of translation up to 54%. These findings raised the possibility that direct base-pairing of particular mRNAs to rRNAs within ribosomes may function as a mechanism of translational control.

Covalent complex of phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase with 4-thiouridine-substituted tRNA(Phe) gene transcript retains aminoacylation activity

s4U-containing transcripts of tRNA(Phe) gene have been prepared by complete substitution of 16 U residues or by random incorporation of s4U residues followed by affinity electrophoresis isolation of s4U-monosubstituted tRNA transcripts. Both analogs have been cross-linked to Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (PheRS) and the specificity of the cross-linking has been demonstrated. Functional activity of the covalent complex of PheRS with the s4U-monosubstituted transcript has been shown by aminoacylation of 60% of the enzyme-cross-linked tRNA. This is the first instance in which biological activity of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase and cross-linked tRNA in a specific complex has been revealed.

Domain 5 binds near a highly conserved dinucleotide in the joiner linking domains 2 and 3 of a group II intron

Photocrosslinking has identified the joiner between domains 2 and 3 [J(23)] as folding near domain 5 (D5), a highly conserved helical substructure of group II introns required for both splicing reactions. D5 RNAs labeled with the photocrosslinker 4-thiouridine (4sU) reacted with highly conserved nucleotides G588 and A589 in J(23) of various intron acceptor transcripts. These conjugates retained some ribozyme function with the lower helix of D5 crosslinked to J(23), so they represent active complexes. One partner of the gamma x gamma' tertiary interaction (A587 x U887) is also in J(23); even though gamma x gamma' is involved in step 2 of the splicing reaction, D5 has not previously been found to approach gamma x gamma'. Similar crosslinking patterns between D5 and J(23) were detected both before and after step 1 of the reaction, indicating that the lower helix of D5 is positioned similarly in both conformations of the active center. Our results suggest that the purine-rich J(23) strand is antiparallel to the D5 strand containing U32 and U33. Possibly, the interaction with J(23) helps position D5 correctly in the ribozyme active site; alternatively, J(23) itself might participate in the catalytic center.

Thionucleobases as intrinsic photoaffinity probes of nucleic acid structure and nucleic acid-protein interactions

In the past few years thionucleobases have been extensively used as intrinsic photolabels to probe the structure in solution of folded RNA molecules and to identify contacts within nucleic acids and/or between nucleic acids and proteins, in complex nucleoprotein assemblies. These thio residues such as 4-thiouracil found in E. coli tRNA and its non-natural congeners 4-thiothymine, 6-thioguanine and 6-mercaptopurine absorb light at wavelengths longer than 320 nm and, thus, can be selectively photoactivated. Synthetic or enzymatic procedures have been established, allowing the random or site-specific incorporation of thionucleotide(s) within a RNA (DNA) chain which, in most cases, retains unaltered structural and biological properties. Owing to the high photoreactivity of their triplet state (intersystem yield close to unity), 4-thiouracil and 4-thiothymine derivatives exhibit a high photocrosslinking ability towards pyrimidines (particularly thymine) but also purines. From the nature of the photoproducts obtained in base or nucleotide mixtures and in dinucleotides, the main photochemical pathway was identified as a (2 + 2) photoaddition of the excited C-S bond onto the 5, 6 double bond of pyrimidines yielding thietane intermediates whose structure could be characterized. Depending on the mutual orientation of these bonds in the thietanes, their subsequent dark rearrangement yielded, respectively, either the 5-4 or 6-4 bipyrimidine photoadduct. A similar mechanism appears to be involved in the formation of the unique photoadduct formed between 4-thiothymidine and adenosine. The higher reactivity of thymine derived acceptors can be explained by an additional pathway which involves hydrogen abstraction from the thymine methyl group, followed by radical recombination, leading to methylene linked bipyrimidines. The high photocrosslinking potential of thionucleosides inserted in nucleic acid chains has been used to probe RNA-RNA contacts within the ribosome permitting, in particular, the elucidation of the path of mRNA throughout the small ribosomal subunit. Functional interactions between the mRNA spliced sites and U RNAs could be detected within the spliceosome. Analysis of the photocrosslinks obtained within small endonucleolytic ribozymes in solution led to a tertiary folded pseudo-knot structure for the HDV ribozyme and allowed the construction of a Y form of a hammerhead ribozyme, which revealed to be in close agreement with the structure observed in crystals. Thionucleosides incorporated in nucleic acids crosslink efficiently amino-acid residues of proteins in contact with them. Despite the fact that little is known about the nature of the photoadducts formed, this approach has been extensively used to identify protein components interacting at a defined nucleic acid site and applied to various systems (replisome, spliceosome, transcription complexes and ribosomes).

An ultraviolet crosslink in the hammerhead ribozyme dependent on 2-thiocytidine or 4-thiouridine substitution

The hammerhead domain is one of the smallest known ribozymes. Like other ribozymes it catalyzes site-specific cleavage of a phosphodiester bond. The hammerhead ribozyme has been the subject of a vast number of biochemical and structural studies aimed at determining the structure and mechanism of cleavage. Recently crystallographic analysis has produced a structure for the hammerhead. As the hammerhead is capable of undergoing cleavage within the crystal, it would appear that the crystal structure is representative of the catalytically active solution structure. However, the crystal structure conflicts with much of the biochemical data and reveals a catalytic metal ion binding site expected to be of very low affinity. Clearly, additional studies are needed to reconcile the discrepancies and provide a clear understanding of the structure and mechanism of the hammerhead ribozyme. Here we demonstrate that a unique crosslink can be induced in the hammerhead with 2-thiocytidine or 4-thiouridine substitution at different locations within the conserved core. Generation of the same crosslink with different modifications at different positions suggests that the structure trapped by the crosslink may be relevant to the catalytically active solution structure of the hammerhead ribozyme. As this crosslink appears to be incompatible with the crystal structure, this provides yet another indication that the active solution and crystal structures may differ significantly.

Photocross-linking of nucleic acids to associated proteins

Photocross-linking is a useful technique for the partial definition of the nucleic acid-protein interface of nucleoprotein complexes. It can be accomplished by one or two photon excitations of wild-type nucleoprotein complexes or by one photon excitation of nucleoprotein complexes bearing one or more substitutions with photoreactive chromophores. Chromophores that have been incorporated into nucleic acids for this purpose include aryl azides, 5-azidouracil, 8-azidoadenine, 8-azidoguanine, 4-thiouracil, 5-bromouracil, 5-iodouracil, and 5-iodocytosine. The various techniques and chromophores are described and compared, with attention to the photochemical mechanism.

Crosslinking of double-stranded oligonucleotides containing O-methyl-substituted pyrophosphate groups to the HNF1 transcription factor in nuclear cell extract

Probing of the HNF1 (hepatocyte nuclear factor I) DNA-binding region using a set of DNA duplexes containing pyrophosphate or O-methyl-substituted pyrophosphate internucleotide groups at different positions of the HNF1 recognition sequence was performed. The histidine-tagged HNF1/1-281 DNA binding domain and nuclear extract from rat liver were used. We showed that HNF1 from these species specifically binds to modified DNA duplexes. A correlation in binding affinity of both types of duplexes was detected. Crosslinking of the HNF1 DNA-binding domain and HNF1 in nuclear liver extract to DNA duplexes carrying O-methyl-substituted pyrophosphate groups was observed. The crosslinking efficiency of HNF1 in liver extract to substituted pyrophosphate-modified DNA duplex, containing a reactive internucleotide group between nucleotides G and T of the GT dinucleotide immediately 5' to the TAAT recognition sequence, amounts to 40% of the efficiency of non-covalent association. Nonspecific crosslinking of the reactive DNA duplexes to other components of nuclear extract was not observed. These results indicate that DNA duplexes carrying substituted pyrophosphate internucleotide groups can specifically bind and crosslink with DNA-binding proteins, especially transcription factors in crude preparations and could constitute a potential tool to control the expression of disease-causing genes.

The canonical GU dinucleotide at the 5' splice site is recognized by p220 of the U5 snRNP within the spliceosome

Specific recognition of the 5' splice site (5'SS) by the spliceosome components was studied using a simple in vitro system in which a short 5'SS RNA oligonucleotide specifically induces the assembly of snRNP particles into spliceosome-like complexes and actively participates in a trans-splicing reaction. Short-range cross-liking demonstrates that a U5 snRNP protein component, p220 (the human analogue of the yeast Prp8) specifically interacts with the invariant GU dinucleotide at the 5' end of the intron. The GU:p220 interaction can be detected in the functional splicing complex B. Although p220 has been known to contact several nucleotides around the 5' splice junction, the p220:GU dinucleotide interaction described here is remarkably specific. Consistent with the high conservation of the GU, even minor modifications of this element affect recognition of the 5'SS RNA by p220. Substitution of uridine at the GU with base analogues containing a large methyl or iodo group, but not a smaller flouro group at base position 5, interferes with association of 5'SS RNA with snRNP complexes and their functional participation in splicing.

Distribution of cross-links between mRNA analogues and 16 S rRNA in Escherichia coli 70 S ribosomes made under equilibrium conditions and their response to tRNA binding

The interaction between mRNA and Escherichia coli ribosomes has been studied by photochemical cross-linking using mRNA analogues that contain 4-thiouridine (s4U) or s4U modified with azidophenylacyl bromide (APAB), either two nucleotides upstream or eight nucleotides downstream from the nucleotide sequence ACC, the codon for tRNA(Thr). The sequences of the mRNA analogues were described earlier (Stade, K., Rinke-Appel, J., and Brimacombe, R. (1989) Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 9889-9908; Rinke-Appel, J., Stade, K., and Brimacombe, R. (1991) EMBO J. 10, 2195-2202). Under equilibrium conditions, both of these mRNA analogues bind and cross-link to 70 S ribosomes without the presence of tRNA(Thr); however, there are significant increases both in binding and particularly in cross-linking in the presence of the tRNA(Thr). Four regions contain cross-linking sites that increase in the presence of tRNA, C1395, A532, A1196 (and minor sites around these three positions), and C1533/U1532. Three other cross-linking sites, U723, A845, and U1381, show very little change in extent of cross-linking when tRNA is present. A conformational change in the 30 S subunit allowing additional accessibility to the 16 S rRNA by the mRNA analogues upon tRNA binding best explains the behavior of the tRNA-dependent and tRNA-independent mRNA-16 S rRNA cross-linking sites.

Production of double-stranded RNA during synthesis of bromouracil-substituted RNA by transcription with T7 RNA polymerase

Using T7 RNA polymerase we synthesized a short oligoribonucleotide containing bromouracil by in vitro transcription of a synthetic DNA template. Whereas the major transcript obtained had the expected size and was apparently homogeneous on a sequencing gel, additional analysis revealed the presence of double-stranded RNA in this preparation. As this was not observed when the same template was transcribed in the presence of uracil, we hypothesize that bromouracil promoted the apparition of double-stranded 'parasitic' RNA presumably by favouring priming for the RNA-dependent RNA synthesis of the T7 RNA polymerase or by facilitating an end-to-end copy mechanism.

mRNA binding track in the human 80S ribosome for mRNA analogues randomly substituted with 4-thiouridine residues

The interaction between mRNA and 18S rRNA in human 80S ribosomes has been studied using synthetic mRNA analogues randomly substituted with 4-thiouridine, which can be photoactivated for cross-linking. Two mRNA analogues with different sequences have been used for complex formation with ribosomes without or with the presence of a cognate tRNA. Cross-linked 18S rRNA nucleotides were identified by reverse transcription analysis. The base U630 in 18S rRNA was the main target of cross-linking for both of the mRNA analogues studied, and three minor sites of cross-linking, A1060, U1046, and U966, were also identified. Thus, in the case of human 80S ribosomes, the set of nucleotide residues cross-linked to the mRNA analogues is significantly smaller than the twelve sites seen for Escherichia coli with these same two mRNA analogues [Bhangu, R., & Wollenzien, P. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 5937-5944]. The residue U630 is within a highly conserved region corresponding to the 530 loop region of eubacterial 16S rRNA; the cross-link to this site indicates that it plays a key role in interacting with mRNA on 80S ribosomes independently of the presence of a cognate tRNA at the P site.

4-Thiouridine incorporation into the RNA of monkey kidney cells (CV-1) triggers near-UV light long-term inhibition of DNA, RNA and protein synthesis

Monkey kidney cells (CV-1) grown for 4 h in the presence of 0.1 mM 4-thiouridine (s4Urd) incorporate this photoactivable uridine analog in their RNA. A minor, 5-8%, thiolated RNA fraction can be isolated from bulk RNA by affinity chromatography. This RNA fraction contains 1.5-2.5 s4Urd residues per 100 nucleotides and exhibits a broad chain length distribution ranging from 700 to 7000 nucleotides. It is essentially of nuclear origin and amounts to 30% of the RNA synthesized during exposure of cells to s4Urd. Under the same s4Urd labeling conditions, no thiolated pyrimidine residues have been detected in DNA. Irradiation with 365 nm light (45 kJ/m2) of the cells immediately after s4Urd exposure triggers long-term inhibition of DNA, RNA and protein synthesis accompanied by a linear decline (50% in 2 days) in the total cell mass of cultured cells. In contrast, exposure to s4Urd alone results in moderate but reversible inhibitory effects. The available data suggest that s4Urd-induced photolesions in newly synthesized RNA such as RNA-RNA cross-links as well as RNA-protein bridges are directly involved in impairment of essential cellular functions.

Folding of DNA substrate-hairpin ribozyme domains: use of deoxy 4-thiouridine as an intrinsic photolabel

Hairpin ribozymes derived from (-)sTRSV RNA exhibit substantial cleavage activity when wobble GU base pairs are introduced in place of the AU pairs normally involved in helices I and II between substrate and ribozyme. This finding prompted us to synthesize by in vitro transcription a new hairpin ribozyme, active against a 14-mer substrate derived from a conserved HIV sequence. Interactions of the canonical and anti-HIV hairpin ribozymes with non cleavable DNA substrate analogues containing the photoaffinity probe deoxy-4-thiouridine (ds4U) at a single site were investigated. Upon near-UV light irradiation (365 nm), all these substrate analogues were covalently attached to ribozyme via single or multiple crosslinks. In contrast, no crosslinks were detected using either a DNA substrate analogue lacking ds4U or a ds4U containing oligomer unrelated to the substrate sequence. As expected, if the dissociation constant is in the range of 5-15 microM, the yield of crosslinked ribozyme increased markedly with increasing the substrate analogue concentration. The ribozyme residues involved in the crosslinks were determined by RNA sequencing. The pattern of crosslinks obtained with the two ribozyme systems provides additional evidence in support of the consensus secondary structure proposed for the hairpin domain. Minor alternative conformations were detected in the case of the (-)sTRSV system.

Affinity electrophoretic detection of primary amino groups in nucleic acids: application to modified bases of tRNA and to aminoacylation

Thiolation of primary amino groups in tRNA with the heterobifunctional reagent N-succinimidyl 3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate gives rise to species which are retarded during electrophoresis in organomercury-containing polyacrylamide gels. Since such amino groups occur, as far as is known, only as part of the modified bases 3-(3-amino-3-carboxypropyl)uridine and N-2-(5-amino-5-carboxypentyl)cytidine or as the alpha-amino group of aminoacylated tRNAs, this extension of the principle of affinity electrophoresis can be used for the detection and analysis of a specific functional group in both single tRNA species and in a mixed population. The strength of the interaction may be quantified and provides information on the chemical environment/conformation of the derivatized bases.

The mRNA binding track in the Escherichia coli ribosome for mRNAs of different sequences

Interactions between mRNA and rRNA on the 30S ribosomal subunit or 70S ribosome have been determined by photochemical cross-linking experiments using synthetic mRNA analogs substituted with 4-thiouridine. A set of RNA molecules containing different sequences has been used to determine the extent to which binding contacts are sequence dependent. The 16S rRNA and 23S rRNA nucleotides that form a part of the binding site have been identified by reverse transcription. The nucleotides are U1381, G1338, G1300, G1156, A845, U723, G693, A532, G497, U420, G413/A412, and G436 of 16S rRNA and U887 of 23S rRNA. Several additional nucleotides (U1065 of 23S rRNA and A1227, G818, G524, and G423 of 16S rRNA) are seen for some, but not all, of the mRNAs. Results obtained with two mRNAs containing the Shine-Dalgarno sequence were similar to those obtained with mRNAs lacking the Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Eight of these cross-linking sites were also seen when a mixture of RNA was used in which there are 12 random nucleotides preceding and seven random nucleotides succeeding an AUG codon. These results indicate that to a large extent placement of the mRNA in the ribosome does not depend upon its primary sequence.