Identification of protein binding sites in genomic DNA by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

Combination of native and denaturing PAGE for the detection of protein binding regions in long fragments of genomic DNA

In traditional electrophoresis mobility shift assay (EMSA) a single (32)P-labeled double-stranded DNA oligonucleotide or a restriction fragment bound to a protein is separated from the unbound DNA by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) under nondenaturing conditions. An extension of this method uses a population of DNA restriction fragments derived from long genomic regions for the identification of fragments containing protein binding regions. Although the method allows simultaneous analysis of large fragments, it is relatively laborious and can be used to detect only fragments containing high affinity protein binding sites. Here we describe an alternative and straightforward strategy which is based on a combination of native and denaturing PAGE. With this strategy restriction fragments, derived from genomic DNA (<10 kb), containing high as well as low affinity protein binding regions may be easily identified.

Combination of native and denaturing PAGE for the detection of protein binding regions in long fragments of genomic DNA

Background

In a traditional electrophoresis mobility shift assay (EMSA) a ³²P-labeled double-stranded DNA oligonucleotide or a restriction fragment bound to a protein is separated from the unbound DNA by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) in nondenaturing conditions. An extension of this method uses the large population of fragments derived from long genomic regions (approximately 600 kb) for the identification of fragments containing protein binding regions. With this method, genomic DNA is fragmented by restriction enzymes, fragments are amplified by PCR, radiolabeled, incubated with nuclear proteins and the resulting DNA-protein complexes are separated by two-dimensional PAGE. Shifted DNA fragments containing protein binding sites are identified by using additional procedures, i. e. gel elution, PCR amplification, cloning and sequencing. Although the method allows simultaneous analysis of a large population of fragments, it is relatively laborious and can be used to detect only high affinity protein binding sites. Here we propose an alternative and straightforward strategy which is based on a combination of native and denaturing PAGE. This strategy allows the identification of DNA fragments containing low as well as high affinity protein binding regions, derived from genomic DNA (<10 kb) of known sequence.

Results

We have combined an EMSA-based selection step with subsequent denaturing PAGE for the localization of protein binding regions in long (up to10 kb) fragments of genomic DNA. Our strategy consists of the following steps: digestion of genomic DNA with a 4-cutter restriction enzyme (AluI, BsuRI, TruI, etc), separation of low and high molecular weight fractions of resultant DNA fragments, ³²P-labeling with Klenow polymerase, traditional EMSA, gel elution and identification of the shifted bands (or smear) by denaturing PAGE. The identification of DNA fragments containing protein binding sites is carried out by running the gel-eluted fragments alongside with the full "spectrum" of initial restriction fragments of known size. Here the strategy is used for the identification of protein-binding regions in the 5' region of the rat p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75NTR) gene.

Conclusion

The developed strategy is based on a combination of traditional EMSA and denaturing PAGE for the identification of protein binding regions in long fragments of genomic DNA. The identification is straightforward and can be applied to shifted bands corresponding to stable DNA-protein complexes as well as unstable complexes, which undergo dissociation during electrophoresis.

Electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) for detecting protein-nucleic acid interactions

The gel electrophoresis mobility shift assay (EMSA) is used to detect protein complexes with nucleic acids. It is the core technology underlying a wide range of qualitative and quantitative analyses for the characterization of interacting systems. In the classical assay, solutions of protein and nucleic acid are combined and the resulting mixtures are subjected to electrophoresis under native conditions through polyacrylamide or agarose gel. After electrophoresis, the distribution of species containing nucleic acid is determined, usually by autoradiography of 32P-labeled nucleic acid. In general, protein-nucleic acid complexes migrate more slowly than the corresponding free nucleic acid. In this protocol, we identify the most important factors that determine the stabilities and electrophoretic mobilities of complexes under assay conditions. A representative protocol is provided and commonly used variants are discussed. Expected outcomes are briefly described. References to extensions of the method and a troubleshooting guide are provided.

Isolation from genomic DNA of sequences binding specific regulatory proteins by the acceleration of protein electrophoretic mobility upon DNA binding

We report an efficient and flexible in vitro method for the isolation of genomic DNA sequences that are the binding targets of a given DNA binding protein. This method takes advantage of the fact that binding of a protein to a DNA molecule generally increases the rate of migration of the protein in nondenaturing gel electrophoresis. By the use of a radioactively labeled DNA-binding protein and nonradioactive DNA coupled with PCR amplification from gel slices, we show that specific binding sites can be isolated from Escherichia coli genomic DNA. We have applied this method to isolate a binding site for FadR, a global regulator of fatty acid metabolism in E. coli. We have also isolated a second binding site for BirA, the biotin operon repressor/biotin ligase, from the E. coli genome that has a very low binding efficiency compared with the bio operator region.

In vivo interaction of the Escherichia coli integration host factor with its specific binding sites

The histone-like protein integration host factor (IHF) of Escherichia coli binds to specific binding sites on the chromosome or on mobile genetic elements, and is involved in many cellular processes. We have analyzed the interaction of IHF with five different binding sites in vitro and in vivo using UV laser footprinting, a technique that probes the immediate environment and conformation of a segment of DNA. Using this generally applicable technique we can directly compare the binding modes and interaction strengths of a DNA binding protein in its physiological environment within the cell to measurements performed in vitro. We conclude that the interactions between IHF and its specific binding sites are identical in vitro and in vivo. The footprinting signal is consistent with the model of IHF-binding to DNA proposed by Yang and Nash (1989). The occupancy of binding sites varies with the concentration of IHF in the cell and allows to estimate the concentration of free IHF protein in the cell.

LAP (NF-IL6) transactivates the collagen alpha 1(I) gene from a 5' regulatory region

Although collagen is known to enhance hepatocyte differentiation and hepatocytes produce collagen in vivo, the transcriptional factors responsible for collagen type I gene expression in hepatic cells are not known. LAP (Liver Activator Protein) is a member of the C/EBP family, which in differentiated hepatocytes contributes to the high levels of liver-specific gene expression. In this study we show that LAP binds to the collagen alpha 1(I) promoter at both reverse CCAAT motifs and activates transcription. Furthermore, an upstream element, collagen element I (-370/-344), which shares homology with the LAP binding cis-element of the albumin promoter (9 of 13 bp) is described. This collagen element I stimulates transcription in both orientations and when placed in front of either a homologous or a heterologous chimeric report construct. These experiments suggest that LAP may be important in the expression of collagen in differentiated hepatocytes through both the promoter and a newly described upstream element.

Growth phase variation of integration host factor level in Escherichia coli

We have measured the intracellular abundance of integration host factor (IHF), a site-specific, heterodimeric DNA-binding protein, in exponential- and stationary-phase cultures of Escherichia coli K-12. Western immunoblot analysis showed that cultures that had been growing exponentially for several generations contained 0.5 to 1.0 ng of IHF subunits per microgram of total protein and that this increased to 5 to 6 ng/microgram in late-stationary-phase cultures. IHF is about one-third to one-half as abundant in exponentially growing cells as HU, a structurally related protein that binds DNA with little or no site specificity. Wild-type IHF is metabolically stable, but deletion mutations that eliminated one subunit reduced the abundance of the other when cells enter stationary phase. We attribute this reduction to the loss of stabilizing interactions between subunits. A mutation that inactivates IHF function but not subunit interaction increased IHF abundance, consistent with results of previous work showing that IHF synthesis is negatively autoregulated. We estimate that steady-state exponential-phase cultures contain about 8,500 to 17,000 IHF dimers per cell, a surprisingly large number for a site-specific DNA-binding protein with a limited number of specific sites. Nevertheless, small reductions in IHF abundance had significant effects on several IHF-dependent functions, suggesting that the wild-type exponential phase level is not in large excess of the minimum required for occupancy of physiologically important IHF-binding sites.

The leucine-responsive regulatory protein: more than a regulator?

The leucine-responsive regulatory protein (Lrp) is the regulator of the recently discovered leucine/Lrp regulon in Escherichia coli. Like other global regulators, it regulates the expression of 35 or more specific target operons. Studies of this global response have led to the suggestion that Lrp--and perhaps some other gene regulators--may also participate in the maintenance of chromosome structure and organization.

Two-dimensional gel selection of protein binding sites on DNA

We have developed a gel electrophoretic approach for visualizing and cloning protein binding sites from complete genomes. This system consists of a simple two-dimensional band shift, in which protein-DNA complexes are retarded in the first dimension, performed at low temperature, and disrupted in the second dimension, performed at high temperature. We present here results obtained with the integration host factor (IHF) and cAMP receptor protein (CRP) proteins of Escherichia coli, and discuss some of the important methodological aspects of the technique.

Use of gel retardation to analyze protein-nucleic acid interactions

Protein-nucleic acid interactions are crucial in the regulation of many fundamental cellular processes. The nature of these interactions is susceptible to analysis by a variety of methods, but the combination of high analytical power and technical simplicity offered by the gel retardation (band shift) technique has made this perhaps the most widely used such method over the last decade. This procedure is based on the observation that the formation of protein-nucleic complexes generally reduces the electrophoretic mobility of the nucleic acid component in the gel matrix. This review attempts to give a simplified account of the physical basis of the behavior of protein-nucleic acid complexes in gels and an overview of many of the applications in which the technique has proved especially useful. The factors which contribute most to the resolution of the complex from the naked nucleic acid are the gel pore size, the relative mass of protein compared with nucleic acid, and changes in nucleic acid conformation (bending) induced by binding. The consequences of induced bending on the mobility of double-strand DNA fragments are similar to those arising from sequence-directed bends, and the latter can be used to help characterize the angle and direction of protein-induced bends. Whether a complex formed in solution is actually detected as a retarded band on a gel depends not only on resolution but also on complex stability within the gel. This is strongly influenced by the composition and, particularly, the ionic strength of the gel buffer. We discuss the applications of the technique to analyzing complex formation and stability, including characterizing cooperative binding, defining binding sites on nucleic acids, analyzing DNA conformation in complexes, assessing binding to supercoiled DNA, defining protein complexes by using cell extracts, and analyzing biological processes such as transcription and splicing.

The role of integration host factor in gene expression in Escherichia coli

Integration host factor is a sequence-specific, histone-like, multifunctional DNA-binding and -bending protein of Escherichia coli. The characterization and functional analysis of this protein has been done mainly in bacteriophage lambda and other mobile genetic elements. Less is known concerning the role of integration host factor (IHF) in E. coli, although it has been implicated in a number of processes in this organism including DNA replication, site-specific recombination, and gene expression. This review presents recent work which suggests that IHF alters the activity of an unusually large number of operons in E. coli. We discuss the possible physiological relevance of the involvement of IHF in gene expression and the hypothesis that IHF is a member of a class of functionally redundant proteins that participate in chromosome structure and multiple processes involving DNA.