A comparison of the fidelity of copying 5-methylcytosine and cytosine at a defined DNA template site

Measurement of deaminated cytosine adducts in DNA using a novel hybrid thymine DNA glycosylase

The hydrolytic deamination of cytosine and 5-methylcytosine drives many of the transition mutations observed in human cancer. The deamination-induced mutagenic intermediates include either uracil or thymine adducts mispaired with guanine. While a substantial array of methods exist to measure other types of DNA adducts, the cytosine deamination adducts pose unusual analytical problems, and adequate methods to measure them have not yet been developed. We describe here a novel hybrid thymine DNA glycosylase (TDG) that is comprised of a 29-amino acid sequence from human TDG linked to the catalytic domain of a thymine glycosylase found in an archaeal thermophilic bacterium. Using defined-sequence oligonucleotides, we show that hybrid TDG has robust mispair-selective activity against deaminated U:G and T:G mispairs. We have further developed a method for separating glycosylase-released free bases from oligonucleotides and DNA followed by GC-MS/MS quantification. Using this approach, we have measured for the first time the levels of total uracil, U:G, and T:G pairs in calf thymus DNA. The method presented here will allow the measurement of the formation, persistence, and repair of a biologically important class of deaminated cytosine adducts.

Modified cytosines versus cytosine in a DNA polymerase: retrieving thermodynamic and kinetic constants at the single molecule level

DNA methylation plays key roles in various areas, such as gene expression, regulation, epigenetics, and cancers. Since 5-methylcytosine (5mC) is commonly present in methylated DNA, characterizing the binding kinetics and thermodynamics of the nucleotide to the enzymatic pocket can help to understand the DNA replication process. Furthermore, 5-carboxycytosine (5caC) is a form that appears through the iterative oxidation of 5mC, and its effect on the DNA replication process is still not well known. Here, we immobilized a DNA polymerase (DNAP) with an orientation control on a tip of an atomic force microscope (AFM), and observed the interaction between the immobilized deoxyguanosine triphosphate (dGTP) on the surface and the DNAP in the presence of a DNA duplex. The interaction probability increased as the concentration of the DNA strand, and the affinity constant between the DNAP and DNA was obtained by fitting the change. Increasing the concentration of dGTP in solution diminished the interaction probability, and a fitting allowed us to retrieve the affinity constant between dGTP and the DNAP holding the DNA in the reaction pocket. Because the dissociation constant could be obtained through the loading rate dependence of the unbinding force value, both affinity and kinetic constants for cytosine (C), 5mC, and 5caC in the DNAP were compared in the light of the steric and electronic effect of the substituents at 5-position of cytosine.

Variants of sequence family B Thermococcus kodakaraensis DNA polymerase with increased mismatch extension selectivity

Fidelity and selectivity of DNA polymerases are critical determinants for the biology of life, as well as important tools for biotechnological applications. DNA polymerases catalyze the formation of DNA strands by adding deoxynucleotides to a primer, which is complementarily bound to a template. To ensure the integrity of the genome, DNA polymerases select the correct nucleotide and further extend the nascent DNA strand. Thus, DNA polymerase fidelity is pivotal for ensuring that cells can replicate their genome with minimal error. DNA polymerases are, however, further optimized for more specific biotechnological or diagnostic applications. Here we report on the semi-rational design of mutant libraries derived by saturation mutagenesis at single sites of a 3’-5’-exonuclease deficient variant of Thermococcus kodakaraensis DNA polymerase (KOD pol) and the discovery for variants with enhanced mismatch extension selectivity by screening. Sites of potential interest for saturation mutagenesis were selected by their proximity to primer or template strands. The resulting libraries were screened via quantitative real-time PCR. We identified three variants with single amino acid exchanges—R501C, R606Q, and R606W—which exhibited increased mismatch extension selectivity. These variants were further characterized towards their potential in mismatch discrimination. Additionally, the identified enzymes were also able to differentiate between cytosine and 5-methylcytosine. Our results demonstrate the potential in characterizing and developing DNA polymerases for specific PCR based applications in DNA biotechnology and diagnostics.

5-methylcytosine-sensitive variants of Thermococcus kodakaraensis DNA polymerase

DNA methylation of cytosine in eukaryotic cells is a common epigenetic modification, which plays an important role in gene expression and thus affects various cellular processes like development and carcinogenesis. The occurrence of 5-methyl-2'-deoxycytosine (5mC) as well as the distribution pattern of this epigenetic marker were shown to be crucial for gene regulation and can serve as important biomarkers for diagnostics. DNA polymerases distinguish little, if any, between incorporation opposite C and 5mC, which is not surprising since the site of methylation is not involved in Watson-Crick recognition. Here, we describe the development of a DNA polymerase variant that incorporates the canonical 2'-deoxyguanosine 5'-monophosphate (dGMP) opposite C with higher efficiency compared to 5mC. The variant of Thermococcus kodakaraensis (KOD) exo- DNA polymerase was discovered by screening mutant libraries that were built by rational design. We discovered that an amino acid substitution at a single site that does not directly interact with the templating nucleobase, may alter the ability of the DNA polymerase in processing C in comparison to 5mC. Employing these findings in combination with a nucleotide, which is fluorescently labeled at the terminal phosphate, indicates the potential use of the mutant DNA polymerase in the detection of 5mC.

Measurement of Postreplicative DNA Metabolism and Damage in the Rodent Brain

The DNA of all organisms is metabolically active due to persistent endogenous DNA damage, repair, and enzyme-mediated base modification pathways important for epigenetic reprogramming and antibody diversity. The free bases released from DNA either spontaneously or by base excision repair pathways constitute DNA metabolites in living tissues. In this study, we have synthesized and characterized the stable-isotope standards for a series of pyrimidines derived from the normal DNA bases by oxidation and deamination. We have used these standards to measure free bases in small molecule extracts from rat brain. Free bases are observed in extracts, consistent with both endogenous DNA damage and 5-methylcytosine demethylation pathways. The most abundant free base observed is uracil, and the potential sources of uracil are discussed. The free bases measured in tissue extracts constitute the end product of DNA metabolism and could be used to reveal metabolic disturbances in human disease.

Direct sensing of 5-methylcytosine by polymerase chain reaction

The epigenetic control of genes by the methylation of cytosine resulting in 5-methylcytosine (5mC) has fundamental implications for human development and disease. Analysis of alterations in DNA methylation patterns is an emerging tool for cancer diagnostics and prognostics. Here we report that two thermostable DNA polymerases, namely the DNA polymerase KlenTaq derived from Thermus aquaticus and the KOD DNA polymerase from Thermococcus kodakaraensis, are able to extend 3'-mismatched primer strands more efficiently from 5 mC than from unmethylated C. This feature was advanced by generating a DNA polymerase mutant with further improved 5mC/C discrimination properties and its successful application in a novel methylation-specific PCR approach directly from untreated human genomic DNA.

Incorporation of zebularine from its 2'-deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate derivative and activity as a template-coding nucleobase

Zebularine (1-(beta-D-ribofuranosyl)-1,2-dihydropyrimidin-2-one) was studied as both a 2 '-deoxyribosyl 5 '-triphosphate derivative and as a template incorporated into an oligonucleotide. Using a novel pyrosequencing assay, zebularine acted as cytosine analog and was incorporated into DNA with a template pairing profile most similar to cytosine, pairing with greatest efficiency opposite guanine in the template strand. Guanine was incorporated with greater affinity than adenine opposite a zebularine in the template strand. Computer modeling of base-pairing structures supported a better fit of zebularine opposite guanine than adenine. Zebularine acts as a cytosine analog, which supports its activity as an inhibitor of cytosine methyltransferase.

Methods for the design and analysis of oligodeoxynucleotide-based DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferase inhibitors

Several second-generation inhibitors of DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases based on studies of modified synthetic oligodeoxynucleoides have been described. As an aid to studies of these inhibitors, we present an electronic structure-based algorithm that can be used as a method for predicting the nature of the expected inhibition by any noncytosine nucleotide target. Targeting by the major human enzyme (hDnmt1) is governed by the presence of a three-nucleotide motif. In hemimethylated DNA, this motif consists of a 5-methylcytosine targeting signal that causes the enzyme to probe the opposite strand for a normally paired guanosine or inosine residue and attempt to methylate the residue 5' to that site. As a demonstration of the method, we apply these rules to the design and characterization of a novel oligodeoxynucleotide inhibitor of hDnmt1. This inhibitor takes advantage of the three-nucleotide recognition motif characteristic of hDnmt1 and shows that the enzyme is inhibited in vitro by non-CG methylation which targets the enzyme to normally basepaired but unproductive nucleotides such as dG, dA, and dT. Kinetic analysis at constant S-adenosyl-L-methionine concentration shows that representative inhibitory oligodeoxynucleotides are best viewed as weakly productive components of systems containing two DNA substrates. This model suggests that the most effective inhibitors are those with very low apparent Vmax and very low Km values. Oligodeoxynucleotides containing mispaired and unproductive targets such as dG, dA, dT, and dU are also inhibitory as secondary substrates for the human enzyme. Biologically, fail-safe mechanisms identified by the ab initio approach appear to be active in preventing potentially mutagenic deamination of dihydrocytosine and enzymatic methylation of dU.

Principal causes of hot spots for cytosine to thymine mutations at sites of cytosine methylation in growing cells. A model, its experimental support and implications

In Escherichia coli and human cells, many sites of cytosine methylation in DNA are hot spots for C to T mutations. It is generally believed that T.G mismatches created by the hydrolytic deamination of 5-methylcytosines (5meC) are intermediates in the mutagenic pathway. A number of hypotheses have been proposed regarding the source of the mispaired thymine and how the cells deal with the mispairs. We have constructed a genetic reversion assay that utilizes a gene on a mini-F to compare the frequency of occurrence of C to T mutations in different genetic backgrounds in exponentially growing E. coli. The results identify at least two causes for the hot spot at a 5meC: (1) the higher rate of deamination of 5meC compared to C generates more T.G than uracil.G (U.G) mismatches, and (2) inefficient repair of T.G mismatches by the very short-patch (VSP) repair system compared to the repair of U. G mismatches by the uracil-DNA glycosylase (Ung). This combination of increased DNA damage when the cytosines are methylated coupled with the relative inefficiency in the post-replicative repair of T.G mismatches can be quantitatively modeled to explain the occurrence of the hot spot at 5meC. This model has implications for mutational hot and cold spots in all organisms.

Overproduction of DNA cytosine methyltransferases causes methylation and C --> T mutations at non-canonical sites

Multicopy clones of Escherichia coli cytosine methyltransferases Dcm and EcoRII methylase (M. EcoRII) cause an approximately 50-fold increase in C --> T mutations at their canonical site of methylation, 5'-CmeCAGG (meC is 5-methylcytosine). These plasmids also cause transition mutations at the second cytosine in the sequences CCGGG at approximately 10-fold lower frequency. Similarly, M. HpaII was found to cause a significant increase in C --> T mutations at a CCAG site, in addition to causing mutations at its canonical site of methylation, CCGG. Using a plasmid that substantially overproduces M. EcoRII, in vivo methylation at CCSGG (S is C or G) and other non-canonical sites could be detected using a gel electrophoretic assay. There is a direct correlation between the level of M. EcoRII activity in cells, the extent of methylation at non-canonical sites and frequency of mutations at these same sites. Overproduction of M. EcoRII in cells also causes degradation of DNA and induction of the SOS response. In vitro, M. EcoRII methylates an oligonucleotide duplex containing a CCGGG site at a slow rate, suggesting that overproduction of the enzyme is essential for significant amounts of such methylation to occur. Together these results show that cytosine methyltransferases occasionally methylate cellular DNA at non-canonical sites and suggest that in E. coli, methylation-specific restriction systems and sequence specificity of the DNA mismatch correction systems may have evolved to accommodate this fact. These results also suggest that mutational effects of cytosine methyltransferases may be much broader than previously imagined.

A mutant HpaII methyltransferase functions as a mutator enzyme

DNA (cytosine-5)-methyltransferases can cause deamination of cytosine when the cofactor S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet) is limiting and thus function as sequence-specific C-->U mutator enzymes. Here we explored whether mutations causing inactivation of the cofactor binding activity of the HpaII methyltransferase, thus mimicking conditions of limiting AdoMet concentration, could convert a DNA methyltransferase to a C-->U mutator enzyme. We created two mutator enzymes from the HpaII methyltransferase (F38S and G40D) which both showed enhanced cytosine deamination activities in vitro and in vivo. Interestingly, the G:U mispairs generated by these enzymes were not repaired completely in bacteria equipped with uracil-DNA glycosylase-initiated repair machinery, giving rise to a potent mutator phenotype. This is the first report showing the creation of mutator enzymes from a DNA methyltransferase and the demonstration of their mutagenicity in living cells.

Mutational spectra in the lacl gene in skin from 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene-treated and untreated transgenic mice

Transgenic mice carrying the bacterial lacl gene in a lambda shuttle vector were used to isolate and characterize background and 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene (DMBA)-induced mutations in skin. Adult male mice were treated once topically with either DMBA or acetone or were left untreated. Seven days later, DMBA treatment had significantly increased the mutant frequency in the skin (mean +/- SEM, 36 +/- 3 x 10(-5)) versus in vehicle-treated (6.4 +/- 1.2 x 10(-5)) and untreated mice (7.1 x 1.0 x 10(-5)). At least 10 mutants from each of three DMBA-treated and three untreated mice were selected for DNA sequence analysis. In each case, the entire 1080-bp target gene was sequenced. Base-pair substitutions predominated (86 of 96 mutations), although frameshift and deletion mutations were also detected. Twelve percent of the mutants carried more than one mutation. In controls, the mutations were predominantly GC-->AT transitions (26 of 42), and no AT-->TA transversions were recovered. In contrast, in the DMBA-treated mice, AT-->TA transversions represented 42% of the mutations (23 of 54) and GC-->AT transitions accounted for only 11%. The AT-->TA transversions occurred mostly at 5'-CA sites. This class of mutation has been recovered frequently in ras genes from DMBA-treated mice and probably represents an early event in carcinogenesis (Nelson MA et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:6398-6402, 1992). Our present results are consistent with the types of DNA damage induced by DMBA. The observation of different mutant frequencies and spectra in treated and control mice demonstrates the utility of this approach in the study of mutagenesis in vivo.

High frequency mutagenesis by a DNA methyltransferase

HpaII methylase (M. HpaII), an example of a DNA (cytosine-5)-methyltransferase, was found to induce directly a high frequency of C-->U transition mutations in double-stranded DNA. A mutant pSV2-neo plasmid, constructed with an inactivating T-->C transition mutation creating a CCGG site, was incubated with M. HpaII in the absence of S-adenosylmethionine (SAM). This caused an approximately 10(4)-fold increase in the rate of reversion when the mutant neo plasmid was transformed into bacteria lacking uracil-DNA glycosylase. The mutation frequency was very sensitive to SAM concentration and was reduced to background when the concentration of the methyl donor exceeded 300 nM. The data support current models for the formation of a covalent complex between the methyltransferase and cytosine. They also suggest that the occurrence of mutational hot spots at CpG sites may not always be due to spontaneous deamination of 5-methylcytosine, but might also be initiated by enzymatic deamination of cytosine and proceed through a C-->U-->T pathway.