In vitro transcription close to the melting point of DNA: analysis of Thermotoga maritima RNA polymerase-promoter complexes at 75 degrees C using chemical probes

Interplay between the trigger loop and the F loop during RNA polymerase catalysis

The trigger loop (TL) in the RNA polymerase (RNAP) active center plays key roles in the reactions of nucleotide addition and RNA cleavage catalyzed by RNAP. The adjacent F loop (FL) was proposed to contribute to RNAP catalysis by modulating structural changes in the TL. Here, we investigate the interplay between these two elements during transcription by bacterial RNAP. Thermodynamic analysis of catalysis by RNAP variants with mutations in the TL and FL suggests that the TL is the key element required for temperature activation in RNAP catalysis, and that the FL promotes TL transitions during nucleotide addition. We reveal characteristic differences in the catalytic parameters between thermophilic Thermus aquaticus and mesophilic Deinococcus radiodurans RNAPs and identify the FL as an adaptable element responsible for the observed differеnces. Mutations in the FL also significantly affect the rate of intrinsic RNA cleavage in a TL-dependent manner. In contrast, much weaker effects of the FL and TL mutations on GreA-assisted RNA cleavage suggest that the FL-dependent TL transitions are not required for this reaction. Thus, functional interplay between the FL and TL is essential for various catalytic activities of RNAP and plays an adaptive role in catalysis by thermophilic and mesophilic enzymes.

RNA polymerase-promoter interactions determining different stability of the Escherichia coli and Thermus aquaticus transcription initiation complexes

Transcription initiation complexes formed by bacterial RNA polymerases (RNAPs) exhibit dramatic species-specific differences in stability, leading to different strategies of transcription regulation. The molecular basis for this diversity is unclear. Promoter complexes formed by RNAP from Thermus aquaticus (Taq) are considerably less stable than Escherichia coli RNAP promoter complexes, particularly at temperatures below 37°C. Here, we used a fluorometric RNAP molecular beacon assay to discern partial RNAP-promoter interactions. We quantitatively compared the strength of E. coli and Taq RNAPs partial interactions with the −10, −35 and UP promoter elements; the TG motif of the extended −10 element; the discriminator and the downstream duplex promoter segments. We found that compared with Taq RNAP, E. coli RNAP has much higher affinity only to the UP element and the downstream promoter duplex. This result indicates that the difference in stability between E. coli and Taq promoter complexes is mainly determined by the differential strength of core RNAP–DNA contacts. We suggest that the relative weakness of Taq RNAP interactions with DNA downstream of the transcription start point is the major reason of low stability and temperature sensitivity of promoter complexes formed by this enzyme.

The anaerobe-specific orange protein complex of Desulfovibrio vulgaris hildenborough is encoded by two divergent operons coregulated by σ54 and a cognate transcriptional regulator

Analysis of sequenced bacterial genomes revealed that the genomes encode more than 30% hypothetical and conserved hypothetical proteins of unknown function. Among proteins of unknown function that are conserved in anaerobes, some might be determinants of the anaerobic way of life. This study focuses on two divergent clusters specifically found in anaerobic microorganisms and mainly composed of genes encoding conserved hypothetical proteins. We show that the two gene clusters DVU2103-DVU2104-DVU2105 (orp2) and DVU2107-DVU2108-DVU2109 (orp1) form two divergent operons transcribed by the σ(54)-RNA polymerase. We further demonstrate that the σ(54)-dependent transcriptional regulator DVU2106, located between orp1 and orp2, collaborates with σ(54)-RNA polymerase to orchestrate the simultaneous expression of the divergent orp operons. DVU2106, whose structural gene is transcribed by the σ(70)-RNA polymerase, negatively retrocontrols its own expression. By using an endogenous pulldown strategy, we identify a physiological complex composed of DVU2103, DVU2104, DVU2105, DVU2108, and DVU2109. Interestingly, inactivation of DVU2106, which is required for orp operon transcription, induces morphological defects that are likely linked to the absence of the ORP complex. A putative role of the ORP proteins in positioning the septum during cell division is discussed.

Lineage-specific amino acid substitutions in region 2 of the RNA polymerase sigma subunit affect the temperature of promoter opening

Highly conserved amino acid residues in region 2 of the RNA polymerase sigma subunit are known to participate in promoter recognition and opening. We demonstrated that nonconserved residues in this region collectively determine lineage-specific differences in the temperature of promoter opening.

Dependence of the E. coli promoter strength and physical parameters upon the nucleotide sequence

The energy of interaction between complementary nucleotides in promoter sequences of E. coli was calculated and visualized. The graphic method for presentation of energy properties of promoter sequences was elaborated on. Data obtained indicated that energy distribution through the length of promoter sequence results in picture with minima at -35, -8 and +7 regions corresponding to areas with elevated AT (adenine-thymine) content. The most important difference from the random sequences area is related to -8. Four promoter groups and their energy properties were revealed. The promoters with minimal and maximal energy of interaction between complementary nucleotides have low strengths, the strongest promoters correspond to promoter clusters characterized by intermediate energy values.

Mechanistic differences in promoter DNA melting by Thermus aquaticus and Escherichia coli RNA polymerases

Formation of strand-separated, functional complexes at promoters was compared for RNA polymerases from the mesophile Escherichia coli and the thermophile Thermus aquaticus. The RNA polymerases contained sigma factors that were wild type or bearing homologous alanine substitutions for two aromatic amino acids involved in DNA melting. Substitutions in the sigmaA subunit of T. aquaticus RNA polymerase impair promoter DNA melting equally at temperatures from 25 to 75 degrees C. However, homologous substitutions in sigma70 render E. coli RNA polymerase progressively more melting-defective as the temperature is reduced below 37 degrees C. The effects of the mutations on the mechanism of promoter DNA melting were investigated by studying the interaction of wild type and mutant RNA polymerases with "partial promoters" mimicking promoter DNA where the nucleation of DNA melting had taken place. Because T. aquaticus and E. coli RNA polymerases bound these templates similarly, it was concluded that the different effects of the mutations on the two polymerases are exerted at a step preceding nucleation of DNA melting. A model is presented for how this mechanistic difference between the two RNA polymerase could explain our observations.

Cold sensitivity of thermophilic and mesophilic RNA polymerases

RNA polymerase from mesophilic Deinococcus radiodurans displays the same cold sensitivity of promoter opening as RNA polymerase from the closely related thermophilic Thermus aquaticus. This suggests that, contrary to the accepted view, cold sensitivity of promoter opening by thermophilic RNA polymerases may not be a consequence of their thermostability.

Inactivation and destruction by KMnO4 of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase open transcription complex: recommendations for footprinting experiments

Potassium permanganate oxidation of pyrimidine residues in single-stranded DNA is commonly used in footprinting studies on formation of open transcription complex (RPo) by RNA polymerases (RNAP) at cognate promoters. Our own experience and literature search led us to conclude that KMnO4 doses often used in such studies might cause multiple-hit oxidation of promoter DNA and oxidative damage to RNAP in RPo and lead to false interpretation of footprints. We have therefore studied as a function of KMnO4 dose (i) transcription activity of RPo formed by Escherichia coli RNAP at a model cognate promoter Pa and (ii) RPo's structural integrity, by gel electrophoresis and footprinting assays. Kinetics of formation of this complex and melting of DNA in the transcription bubble region were thoroughly characterized by us previously. Here we show that (i) RPo becomes completely inactivated at oxidant doses much lower than those needed to cause a detectable footprint of the melted DNA region, (ii) footprinting patterns of the melted promoter region remain practically unaffected by RNAP oxidation within a range of low oxidant doses causing single-hit oxidation of DNA, and (iii) at higher oxidant doses, corresponding to multiple-hit DNA oxidation, the gross structure of RPo changes progressively until its complete collapse and dissociation into constituent components, so that only approximate interpretation of the footprinting data for the melted DNA region is possible. A protocol for accurate RPo footprinting with low single-hit KMnO4 doses and interpretation of the footprinting data in terms of kinetics of oxidation of pyrimidine residues in promoter DNA is recommended.

A "master" in base unpairing during isomerization of a promoter upon RNA polymerase binding

Isomerization of a closed to open complex of a promoter upon RNA polymerase binding involves base unpairing at the -10 region. After potassium permanganate sensitivity of unpaired thymine residues, we studied base unpairing at the -10 region during isomerization upon RNA polymerase binding at the P1 and P3 promoters of the gal operon. Substitution of adenine by 2-amino purine (2-AP) at the invariable A small middle dotT base pair at the -11 position of P1 and P3 prevented unpairing not only at that position but also at the other downstream positions, suggesting a "master" role of the adenine base at -11 of the template strand in overall base unpairing. 2-AP at -11 did not inhibit the formation of RNA polymerase small middle dotpromoter complex and subsequent isomerization of the polymerase. Substitution of adenine by 2-AP at several other positions did not affect thymine unpairing. Changing the position of the amino group from C6 in adenine to C2 in 2-AP is mutational only at the master switch position, -11.

Cell-free transcription at 95 degrees: thermostability of transcriptional components and DNA topology requirements of Pyrococcus transcription

Cell-free transcription of archaeal promoters is mediated by two archaeal transcription factors, aTBP and TFB, which are orthologues of the eukaryotic transcription factors TBP and TFIIB. Using the cell-free transcription system described for the hyperthermophilic Archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus by Hethke et al., the temperature limits and template topology requirements of archaeal transcription were investigated. aTBP activity was not affected after incubation for 1 hr at 100 degrees. In contrast, the half-life of RNA polymerase activity was 23 min and that of TFB activity was 3 min. The half-life of a 328-nt RNA product was 10 min at 100 degrees. Best stability of RNA was observed at pH 6, at 400 mm K-glutamate in the absence of Mg(2+) ions. Physiological concentrations of K-glutamate were found to stabilize protein components in addition, indicating that salt is an important extrinsic factor contributing to thermostability. Both RNA and proteins were stabilized by the osmolyte betaine at a concentration of 1 m. The highest activity for RNA synthesis at 95 degrees was obtained in the presence of 1 m betaine and 400 mm K-glutamate. Positively supercoiled DNA, which was found to exist in Pyrococcus cells, can be transcribed in vitro both at 70 degrees and 90 degrees. However, negatively supercoiled DNA was the preferred template at all temperatures tested. Analyses of transcripts from plasmid topoisomers harboring the glutamate dehydrogenase promoter and of transcription reactions conducted in the presence of reverse gyrase indicate that positive supercoiling of DNA inhibits transcription from this promoter.

DNA bending and wrapping around RNA polymerase: a "revolutionary" model describing transcriptional mechanisms

A model is proposed in which bending and wrapping of DNA around RNA polymerase causes untwisting of the DNA helix at the RNA polymerase catalytic center to stimulate strand separation prior to initiation. During elongation, DNA bending through the RNA polymerase active site is proposed to lower the energetic barrier to the advance of the transcription bubble. Recent experiments with mammalian RNA polymerase II along with accumulating evidence from studies of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase indicate the importance of DNA bending and wrapping in transcriptional mechanisms. The DNA-wrapping model describes specific roles for general RNA polymerase II transcription factors (TATA-binding protein [TBP], TFIIB, TFIIF, TFIIE, and TFIIH), provides a plausible explanation for preinitiation complex isomerization, suggests mechanisms underlying the synergy between transcriptional activators, and suggests an unforseen role for TBP-associating factors in transcription.

Promoter opening via a DNA fork junction binding activity

The rate-limiting step in transcriptional initiation typically is opening the promoter DNA to expose the template strand. Opening is tightly regulated, but how it occurs is not known. These experiments identify an activity, recognition of specific DNA fork junctions, and suggest that it is critical to bacterial promoter opening. This activity is both sequence and structure specific; it recognizes the bases that constitute the upstream double-stranded/single-stranded boundary of the open complex. Promoter mutations known to reduce opening rates lead to comparable reductions in fork junction binding affinity. The activity acts to establish the upstream boundary of melted DNA and works in conjunction with two single-stranded DNA binding activities that recognize separately the two melted strands. The junction binding activity is contained within the sigma factor component of the holoenzyme. The activity occurs in both a typical prokaryotic transcription system and in a eukaryotic-like bacterial system that responds to enhancers and needs ATP. Thus DNA opening catalyzed by fork junction binding may occur in a variety of systems in which DNA must be opened to be copied.

Reverse gyrase from the hyperthermophilic bacterium Thermotoga maritima: properties and gene structure

The hyperthermophilic bacterium Thermotoga maritima MSB8 possesses a reverse gyrase whose enzymatic properties are very similar to those of archaeal reverse gyrases. It catalyzes the positive supercoiling of the DNA in an Mg2+- and ATP-dependent process. Its optimal temperature of activity is around 90 degrees C, and it is highly thermostable. We have cloned and DNA sequenced the corresponding gene (T. maritima topR). This is the first report describing the analysis of a gene encoding a reverse gyrase in bacteria. The T. maritima topR gene codes for a protein of 1,104 amino acids with a deduced molecular weight of 128,259, a value in agreement with that estimated from the denaturing gel electrophoresis of the purified enzyme. Like its archaeal homologs, the T. maritima reverse gyrase exhibits helicase and topoisomerase domains, and its sequence matches very well the consensus sequence for six reverse gyrases now available. Phylogenetic analysis shows that all reverse gyrases, including the T. maritima enzyme, form a very homogeneous group, distinct from the type I 5' topoisomerases of the TopA subfamily, for which we have previously isolated a representative gene in T. maritima (topA). The coexistence of these two distinct genes, coding for a reverse gyrase and an omega-like topoisomerase, respectively, together with the recent description of a gyrase in T. maritima (O. Guipaud, E. Marguet, K. M. Noll, C. Bouthier de la Tour, and P. Forterre, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94:10606-10611, 1977) addresses the question of the control of the supercoiling in this organism.

A mutant RNA polymerase that forms unusual open promoter complexes

We describe a mutant Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) that forms stable open promoter complexes even at -20 degrees C but with a shortened melted region that extends downstream to only position -7. In the presence of initiating transcription substrates, the mutant RNAP undergoes a temperature-dependent isomerization, resulting in a promoter complex that is indistinguishable from the wild-type RNAP-promoter complex, with the melted region extended downstream to position +4. We propose that the open complex formed by the mutant RNAP represents an intermediate on the normal promoter-opening pathway and that our results support earlier findings that initial promoter opening occurs in the upstream region of the -10 promoter consensus element and subsequently extends downstream to encompass the transcription start site.

DNA-melting at the Bacillus subtilis flagellin promoter nucleates near -10 and expands unidirectionally

A central step in promoter activation by RNA polymerase (RNAP) is the localized separation of the DNA strands to form the transcription bubble. We have used potassium permanganate footprinting to monitor DNA strand-separation by the Bacillus subtilis sigmaD RNAP at the strong promoter, Phag, directing transcription of flagellin. The susceptibility of individual thymine bases to permanganate oxidation is influenced by temperature, Mg2+, nucleotides, and the RNAP delta subunit. In the absence of delta, sigmaD RNAP establishes a partially opened complex even at 0 degrees C with permanganate reactivity localized between -11 and -4 (RP(-4)). The region of strand separation expands to near -1 at 20 degrees C (RP(-1)) and to +3 at 40 degrees C (RP(+3)). The delta subunit inhibits the downstream propagation of the transcription bubble and thereby increases the concentration of early intermediates in the melting pathway. Indeed, E delta sigmaD forms a distinct nucleated complex (RPn) at 0 degrees C with a structural distortion localized to an AT base step within the -10 element. We propose a model for promoter melting in which strand separation nucleates within the conserved -10 consensus and subsequently propagates downstream. Mg2+ and nucleoside triphosphates (NTPs) favor the downstream propagation of the transcription bubble and strongly stimulate the RP(-1) to RP(+3) conversion. The NTP effects are apparently mediated by binding of substrate to the initiating NTP site: purines are more effective than pyrimidines and GMP alone can greatly increase the level of DNA-melting. The binding of substrates, but not Mg2+ alone, can effectively overcome the anti-melting effect of delta.

Influence of Mg2+ and temperature on formation of the transcription bubble

The transcription bubble formed in the binding complex of T7A1 promoter upon Escherichia coli RNA polymerase was analyzed by chemical probes, namely by single-strand specific reagents, to map the unpaired bases in the bubble, and by FeEDTA, to analyze the accessibility of the DNA backbone. The latter probe could also be used as a local hydroxyl radical probe placed close to the Mg2+-binding site in the active center. The data show that the transcription bubble consists of two parts, an Mg2+-dependent part and an Mg2+-independent part, both having individual transition temperatures. The data further suggest that formation of a transcription active open complex is preceded by a transition state complex having enhanced affinity for those Mg2+ ions presumably participating in the formation of the catalytic site. Our data also suggests that the three catalytically active Mg2+ ions in RNA polymerase are functionally not equivalent. One/two of the three Mg2+ ions are responsible for the polymerization, the other two/one for enlargement of the transcription bubble.

A cell-free transcription system for the hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus

We describe here the establishment of a cell-free transcription system for the hyperthermophilic Archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus using the cloned glutamate dehydrogenase (gdh) gene as template. The in vitro system that operated up to a temperature of 85 degrees C initiated transcription 23 bp downstream of a TATA box located 45 bp upstream of the translational start codon of gdh mRNA, at the same site as in Pyrococcus cells. Mutational analyses revealed that this TATA box is essential for in vitro initiation of transcription. Pyrococcus transcriptional components were separated into at least two distinct transcription factor activities and RNA polymerase. One of these transcription factors could be functionally replaced by Methanococcus aTFB and Thermococcus TATA bind- ing protein (TBP). Immunochemical analyses demonstrated a structural relationship between Pyrococcus aTFB and Thermococcus TBP. These findings indicate that a TATA box and a TBP are essential components of the Pyrococcus transcriptional machinery.