Improved method for selecting RNA-binding activities in vivo

Dissecting nucleic acid-protein interactions using challenge phage

The bacteriophage P22-based challenge system is a sophisticated genetic tool for the characterization of sequence-specific recognition of DNA and RNA in vivo. The construction of challenge phage follows simple phage lysate preparations and detection of constructs by positive selection methods for plaques on selective strains. The challenge phage system is a powerful tool for the characterization of protein-DNA and protein-RNA interactions in vivo. The challenge phage has been further developed to characterize the interactions of multiple proteins in heteromultimeric complexes that are required for DNA binding. Under appropriate conditions, expression of the ant gene determines the lysis-lysogeny decision of P22. This provides a positive selection for and against DNA binding: repression of ant can be selected by requiring growth of lysogens, and mutants that cannot repress ant can be selected by requiring lytic growth of the phage. Thus, placing ant gene expression under the control of a specific DNA-protein interaction provides very strong genetic selections for regulatory mutations in the DNA-binding protein and DNA-binding site that either increase or decrease the apparent strength of a DNA-protein interaction in vivo. Furthermore, the challenge phage contains a kanamycin-resistance element that can be used to either directly select for lysogeny or to determine the frequency of lysogeny for a given protein-DNA interaction to measure the efficiency of DNA binding in vivo. Selection for lysogeny can be used to isolate DNA-binding proteins with altered or enhanced DNA-binding specificities. The challenge phage selection provides a general method for identifying critical residues involved in DNA-protein interactions. Challenge phage selections have been used to genetically dissect many different prokaryotic and eukaryotic DNA-binding interactions.

A novel glutamine-RNA interaction identified by screening libraries in mammalian cells

The arginine-rich motif provides a versatile framework for RNA recognition in which few amino acids other than arginine are needed to mediate specific binding. Using a mammalian screening system based on transcriptional activation by HIV Tat, we identified novel arginine-rich peptides from combinatorial libraries that bind tightly to the Rev response element of HIV. Remarkably, a single glutamine, but not asparagine, within a stretch of polyarginine can mediate high-affinity binding. These results, together with the structure of a Rev peptide-Rev response element complex, suggest that the carboxamide groups of glutamine or asparagine are well-suited to hydrogen bond to G-A base pairs and begin to establish an RNA recognition code for the arginine-rich motif. The screening approach may provide a relatively general method for screening expression libraries in mammalian cells.

Translationally repressive RNA structures monitored in vivo using temperate DNA bacteriophages

The RNA challenge phage system enables genetic selection of proteins with RNA-binding activity in bacteria. These phages are modified versions of the temperate DNA bacteriophage P22 in which post-transcriptional regulatory events control the developmental fate of the phage. The system was originally developed to identify novel RNA ligands that display reduced affinity for the R17/MS2 coat protein, as well as to select for suppressor coat proteins that recognize mutant RNA ligands. During the course of evaluating whether the HIV-1 Rev protein could direct lysogen development for bacteriophage derivatives that encode Rev response element (RRE) RNA sequences, two examples of RRE RNA ligands that interfere with challenge phage development were identified. In the phage examples described, RRE RNA secondary structure prevents Ant protein biosynthesis and lytic development. Phage lysogen formation occurs efficiently in recipient cells, independent of the expression status of the Rev protein or trans-acting competitor RRE RNA ligands. These studies provide the first example whereby RNA challenge phages may be applied to study RNA folding events and RNA structural interactions in an in vivo context.

Functional recognition of fragmented operator sites by R17/MS2 coat protein, a translational repressor

The R17/MS2 coat protein serves as a translational repressor of replicase by binding to a 19 nt RNA hairpin containing the Shine-Dalgarno sequence and the initiation codon of the replicase gene. We have explored the structural features of the RNA operator site that are necessary for efficient translational repression by the R17/MS2 coat protein in vivo . The R17/MS2 coat protein efficiently directs lysogen formation for P22 R17 , a bacteriophage P22 derivative that carries the R17/MS2 RNA operator site within the P22 phage ant mRNA. Phages were constructed that contain fragmented operator sites such that the Shine-Dalgarno sequence and the initiation codon of the affected gene are not located within the RNA hairpin. The wild-type coat protein directs efficient lysogen formation for P22 phages that carry several fragmented RNA operator sites, including one in which the Shine-Dalgarno sequence is positioned 4 nt outside the coat protein binding site. Neither the wild-type R17/MS2 coat protein nor super-repressor mutants induce lysogen formation for a P22 phage encoding an RNA hairpin at a distance of 9 nt from the Shine-Dalgarno sequence, implying that a discrete region of biological repression is defined by the coat protein-RNA hairpin interaction. The assembly of RNA species into capsid structures is not an efficient means whereby the coat protein achieves translational repression of target mRNA transcripts. The R17/MS2 coat protein exerts translational regulation that extends considerably beyond the natural biological RNA operator site structure; however, the coat protein still mediates repression in these constructs by preventing ribosome access to linear sequence determinants of the translational initiation region by the formation of a stable RNA secondary structure. An efficient translational regulatory mechanism in bacteria appears to reside in the ability of proteins to regulate RNA folding states for host cell and phage mRNAs.

Molding a peptide into an RNA site by in vivo peptide evolution

Short peptides corresponding to the arginine-rich domains of several RNA-binding proteins are able to bind to their specific RNA sites with high affinities and specificities. In the case of the HIV-1 Rev-Rev response element (RRE) complex, the peptide forms a single alpha-helix that binds deeply in a widened, distorted RNA major groove and makes a substantial set of base-specific and backbone contacts. Using a reporter system based on antitermination by the bacteriophage lambda N protein, it has been possible to identify novel arginine-rich peptides from combinatorial libraries that recognize the RRE with affinities and specificities similar to Rev but that appear to bind in nonhelical conformations. Here we have used codon-based mutagenesis to evolve one of these peptides, RSG-1, into an even tighter binder. After two rounds of evolution, RSG-1.2 bound the RRE with 7-fold higher affinity and 15-fold higher specificity than the wild-type Rev peptide, and in vitro competition experiments show that RSG-1.2 completely displaces the intact Rev protein from the RRE at low peptide concentrations. By fusing RRE-binding peptides to the activation domain of HIV-1 Tat, we show that the peptides can deliver Tat to the RRE site and activate transcription in mammalian cells, and more importantly, that the fusion proteins can inhibit the activity of Rev in chloramphenicol acetyltransferase reporter assays. The evolved peptides contain proline and glutamic acid mutations near the middle of their sequences and, despite the presence of a proline, show partial alpha-helix formation in the absence of RNA. These directed evolution experiments illustrate how readily complex peptide structures can be evolved within the context of an RNA framework, perhaps reflecting how early protein structures evolved in an "RNA world."