Mutational analysis of vaccinia virus topoisomerase identifies residues involved in DNA binding

Inhibition of Poxvirus Gene Expression and Genome Replication by Bisbenzimide Derivatives

Virus infection of humans and livestock can be devastating for individuals and populations, sometimes resulting in large economic and societal impact. Prevention of virus disease by vaccination or antiviral agents is difficult to achieve. A notable exception was the eradication of human smallpox by vaccination over 30 years ago. Today, humans and animals remain susceptible to poxvirus infections, including zoonotic poxvirus transmission. Here we identified a small molecule, bisbenzimide (bisbenzimidazole), and its derivatives as potent agents against prototypic poxvirus infection in cell culture. We show that bisbenzimide derivatives, which preferentially bind the minor groove of double-stranded DNA, inhibit vaccinia virus infection by blocking viral DNA replication and abrogating postreplicative intermediate and late gene transcription. The bisbenzimide derivatives are potent against vaccinia virus and other poxviruses but ineffective against a range of other DNA and RNA viruses. The bisbenzimide derivatives are the first inhibitors of their class, which appear to directly target the viral genome without affecting cell viability.

IMPORTANCE Smallpox was one of the most devastating diseases in human history until it was eradicated by a worldwide vaccination campaign. Due to discontinuation of routine vaccination more than 30 years ago, the majority of today's human population remains susceptible to infection with poxviruses. Here we present a family of bisbenzimide (bisbenzimidazole) derivatives, known as Hoechst nuclear stains, with high potency against poxvirus infection. Results from a variety of assays used to dissect the poxvirus life cycle demonstrate that bisbenzimides inhibit viral gene expression and genome replication. These findings can lead to the development of novel antiviral drugs that target viral genomes and block viral replication.

Characterization of DNA Binding by the Isolated N-Terminal Domain of Vaccinia Virus DNA Topoisomerase IB

Vaccinia TopIB (vTopIB), a 314-amino acid eukaryal-type IB topoisomerase, recognizes and transesterifies at the DNA sequence 5'-(T/C)CCTT↓, leading to the formation of a covalent DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl²⁷⁴)-enzyme intermediate in the supercoil relaxation reaction. The C-terminal segment of vTopIB (amino acids 81-314), which engages the DNA minor groove at the scissile phosphodiester, comprises an autonomous catalytic domain that retains cleavage specificity, albeit with a cleavage site affinity lower than that of the full-length enzyme. The N-terminal domain (amino acids 1-80) engages the major groove on the DNA face opposite the scissile phosphodiester. Whereas DNA contacts of the N-terminal domain have been implicated in the DNA site affinity of vTopIB, it was not known whether the N-terminal domain per se could bind DNA. Here, using isothermal titration calorimetry, we demonstrate the ability of the isolated N-terminal domain to bind a CCCTT-containing 24-mer duplex with an apparent affinity that is ∼2.2-fold higher than that for an otherwise identical duplex in which the pentapyrimidine sequence is changed to ACGTG. Analyses of the interactions of the isolated N-terminal domain with duplex DNA via solution nuclear magnetic resonance methods are consistent with its DNA contacts observed in DNA-bound crystal structures of full-length vTopIB. The chemical shift perturbations and changes in hydrodynamic properties triggered by CCCTT DNA versus non-CCCTT DNA suggest differences in DNA binding dynamics. The importance of key N-terminal domain contacts in the context of full-length vTopIB is underscored by assessing the effects of double-alanine mutations on DNA transesterification and its sensitivity to ionic strength.

Diverse energetic effects of charge reversal mutations of poxvirus topoisomerase IB

A key aspect of the reaction mechanism of type IB topoisomerases is the controlled unwinding of DNA supercoils while the enzyme is transiently bound to one strand of the DNA duplex via a phosphotyrosyl linkage. In this complex, the mobile segment of the bound DNA downstream from the site of cleavage must rotate around the helical axis, requiring that interactions with the enzyme must break and re-form multiple times during the course of removing supercoils. A crystal structure of variola virus type IB topoisomerase (vTopo) bound to DNA shows several positively charged side chains that interact with the downstream mobile and upstream rigid segments, suggesting that these groups may play a role in catalysis, including the processive unwinding of supercoils. We have mutated three such residues, R67, K35, and K271, to Ala and Glu and determined the energetic effects of these mutations at each point along the reaction coordinate of vTopo. R67 interacts with a phosphate group in the rigid DNA segment across from the site of DNA strand cleavage. The ~30-fold damaging effects of the R67A and R67E mutations were primarily on the phosphoryl transfer step, with little effect on enzyme-DNA binding, or the processivity of supercoil unwinding. Removal of the K35 interaction shows mutational effects similar to those of R67, even though this residue interacts with the mobile segment 3 bp from the cleavage site. The two mutations of K271, which interacts with the mobile region even further from the site of covalent linkage, show significant effects not only on phosphoryl transfer but also on downstream DNA strand positioning. Moreover, supercoil unwinding measurements indicate that the K271A and K271E mutations increase the average number of supercoils that are removed during the lifetime of the covalent complex, enhancing the processivity of supercoil unwinding. These measurements support the proposal that the processivity of supercoil unwinding can be regulated by electrostatic interactions between the enzyme and the mobile DNA phosphate backbone.

Structural studies of type I topoisomerases

Topoisomerases are ubiquitous proteins found in all three domains of life. They change the topology of DNA via transient breaks on either one or two of the DNA strands to allow passage of another single or double DNA strand through the break. Topoisomerases are classified into two types: type I enzymes cleave one DNA strand and pass either one or two DNA strands through the break before resealing it, while type II molecules cleave both DNA strands in concert and pass another double strand through the break followed by religation of the double strand break. Here we review recent work on the structure of type I enzymes. These structural studies are providing atomic details that, together with the existing wealth of biochemical and biophysical data, are bringing our understanding of the mechanism of action of these enzymes to the atomic level.

Chemical and traditional mutagenesis of vaccinia DNA topoisomerase provides insights to cleavage site recognition and transesterification chemistry

Vaccinia DNA topoisomerase IB (TopIB) relaxes supercoils by forming and resealing a covalent DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. Here we gained new insights to the TopIB mechanism through "chemical mutagenesis." Meta-substituted analogs of Tyr(274) were introduced by in vitro translation in the presence of a chemically misacylated tRNA. We report that a meta-OH reduced the rate of DNA cleavage 130-fold without affecting the rate of religation. By contrast, meta-OCH(3) and NO(2) groups elicited only a 6-fold decrement in cleavage rate. We propose that the meta-OH uniquely suppresses deprotonation of the para-OH nucleophile during the cleavage step. Assembly of the vaccinia TopIB active site is triggered by protein contacts with a specific DNA sequence 5'-C(+5)C(+4)C(+3)T(+2)T(+1)p downward arrowN (where downward arrow denotes the cleavage site). A signature alpha-helix of the poxvirus TopIB ((132)GKMKYLKENETVG(144)) engages the target site in the major groove and thereby recruits catalytic residue Arg(130) to the active site. The effects of 11 missense mutations at Tyr(136) highlight the importance of van der Waals interactions with the 3'-G(+4)pG(+3)p dinucleotide of the nonscissile strand for DNA cleavage and supercoil relaxation. Asn(140) and Thr(142) donate hydrogen bonds to the pro-(S(p))-oxygen of the G(+3)pA(+2) phosphodiester of the nonscissile strand. Lys(133) and Lys(135) interact with purine nucleobases in the major groove. Whereas none of these side chains is essential per se, an N140A/T142A double mutation reduces the rate of supercoil relaxation and DNA cleavage by 120- and 30-fold, respectively, and a K133A/K135A double mutation slows relaxation and cleavage by 120- and 35-fold, respectively. These results underscore functional redundancy at the TopIB-DNA interface.

Vaccinia topoisomerase mutants illuminate roles for Phe59, Gly73, Gln69 and Phe215

Vaccinia topoisomerase provides a model system for structure-function analysis of the type IB topoisomerase family. Here we performed an alanine scan of eight positions in the beta4 and beta5 strands of the N-terminal domain (Leu57, Ile58, Phe59, Val60, Gly61, Ser62, Gln69 and Gly73) and eight positions in the alpha8-alpha9 loop of the C-terminal catalytic domain (Ser241, Ile242, Ser243, Pro244, Leu245, Pro246, Ser247, and Pro248). Mutants F59A, G73A, and Q69A displayed rate defects in relaxing supercoiled DNA that were attributed to effects on DNA binding rather than transesterification chemistry. Replacing Gln69 conservatively with Asn, Glu or Lys failed to restore relaxation activity. Gln69 is located along a concave DNA-binding surface of the N-terminal domain and it makes direct contact with the +2A base of the 5'-CCCTT/3-GGGAA target site for DNA cleavage. Gly73 is located at the junction between the N-terminal domain and catalytic domain and it is likely to act as a swivel for the large domain movements that coordinate DNA ingress and closure of the topoisomerase clamp around the duplex. Previous alanine scanning had identified Phe215 in helix alpha7 of the catalytic domain as contributing to DNA relaxation activity. Here we find that F215L resembles F215A in its diminished relaxation activity and its sensitivity to inhibition by salt. The Phe215 side chain makes van der Waals contacts to Ile98, Met121 and Phe101, which we propose stabilize a three helix bundle and promote clamp closure.

Nonpolar nucleobase analogs illuminate requirements for site-specific DNA cleavage by vaccinia topoisomerase

Vaccinia DNA topoisomerase forms a covalent DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate at a specific target site 5'-C(+5)C(+4)C(+3)T(+2)T(+1)p downward arrow N(-1) in duplex DNA. Here we study the effects of nonpolar pyrimidine isosteres difluorotoluene (F) and monofluorotoluene (D) and the nonpolar purine analog indole at individual positions of the scissile and nonscissile strands on the rate of single-turnover DNA transesterification and the cleavage-religation equilibrium. Comparison of the effects of nonpolar base substitution to the effects of abasic lesions reported previously allowed us to surmise the relative contributions of base-stacking and polar edge interactions to the DNA transesterification reactions. For example, the deleterious effects of eliminating the +2T base on the scissile strand were rectified by introducing the nonpolar F isostere, whereas the requirement for the +1T base was not elided by F substitution. We impute a role for +1T in recruiting the catalytic residue Lys-167 to the active site. Topoisomerase is especially sensitive to suppression of DNA cleavage upon elimination of the +4G and +3G bases of the nonscissile strand. Indole provided little or no gain of function relative to abasic lesions. Inosine substitutions for +4G and +3G had no effect on transesterification rate, implying that the guanine exocyclic amine is not a critical determinant of DNA cleavage. Prior studies of 2-aminopurine and 7-deazaguanine effects had shown that the O6 and N7 of guanine were also not critical. These findings suggest that either the topoisomerase makes functionally redundant contacts with polar atoms (likely via Tyr-136, a residue important for precleavage active site assembly) or that it relies on contacts to N1 or N3 of the purine ring. The cleavage-religation equilibrium is strongly skewed toward trapping of the covalent intermediate by elimination of the +1A base of the nonscissile strand; the reaction equilibrium is restored by +1 indole, signifying that base stacking flanking the nick is critical for the religation step. Our findings highlight base isosteres as valuable tools for the analysis of proteins that act on DNA in a site-specific manner.

Crystal structure of a bacterial type IB DNA topoisomerase reveals a preassembled active site in the absence of DNA

Type IB DNA topoisomerases are found in all eukarya, two families of eukaryotic viruses (poxviruses and mimivirus), and many genera of bacteria. They alter DNA topology by cleaving and resealing one strand of duplex DNA via a covalent DNA-(3-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. Bacterial type IB enzymes were discovered recently and are described as poxvirus-like with respect to their small size, primary structures, and bipartite domain organization. Here we report the 1.75-A crystal structure of Deinococcus radiodurans topoisomerase IB (DraTopIB), a prototype of the bacterial clade. DraTopIB consists of an amino-terminal (N) beta-sheet domain (amino acids 1-90) and a predominantly alpha-helical carboxyl-terminal (C) domain (amino acids 91-346) that closely resemble the corresponding domains of vaccinia virus topoisomerase IB. The five amino acids of DraTopIB that comprise the catalytic pentad (Arg-137, Lys-174, Arg-239, Asn-280, and Tyr-289) are preassembled into the active site in the absence of DNA in a manner nearly identical to the pentad configuration in human topoisomerase I bound to DNA. This contrasts with the apoenzyme of vaccinia topoisomerase, in which three of the active site constituents are either displaced or disordered. The N and C domains of DraTopIB are splayed apart in an "open" conformation, in which the surface of the catalytic domain containing the active site is exposed for DNA binding. A comparison with the human topoisomerase I-DNA cocrystal structure suggests how viral and bacterial topoisomerase IB enzymes might bind DNA circumferentially via movement of the N domain into the major groove and clamping of a disordered loop of the C domain around the helix.

A poxvirus-like type IB topoisomerase family in bacteria

We report that diverse species of bacteria encode a type IB DNA topoisomerase that resembles vaccinia virus topoisomerase. Deinococcus radiodurans topoisomerase IB (DraTopIB), an exemplary member of this family, relaxes supercoiled DNA in the absence of a divalent cation or ATP. DraTopIB has a compact size (346 aa) and is a monomer in solution. Mutational analysis shows that the active site of DraTopIB is composed of the same constellation of catalytic side chains as the vaccinia enzyme. Sequence comparisons and limited proteolysis suggest that their folds are conserved. These findings imply an intimate evolutionary relationship between the poxvirus and bacterial type IB enzymes, and they engender a scheme for the evolution of topoisomerase IB and tyrosine recombinases from a common ancestral strand transferase in the bacterial domain. Remarkably, bacteria that possess topoisomerase IB appear to lack DNA topoisomerase III.

Vaccinia topoisomerase mutants illuminate conformational changes during closure of the protein clamp and assembly of a functional active site

We present a mutational analysis of vaccinia topoisomerase that highlights the contributions of five residues in the catalytic domain (Phe-88 and Phe-101 in helix alpha1, Ser-204 in alpha5, and Lys-220 and Asn-228 in alpha6) to the DNA binding and transesterification steps. When augmented by structural information from exemplary type IB topoisomerases and tyrosine recombinases in different functional states, the results suggest how closure of the protein clamp around duplex DNA and assembly of a functional active site might be orchestrated by internal conformational changes in the catalytic domain. Lys-220 is a constituent of the active site, and a positive charge at this position is required for optimal DNA cleavage. Ser-204 and Asn-228 appear not to be directly involved in reaction chemistry at the scissile phosphodiester. We propose that (i) Asn-228 recruits the Tyr-274 nucleophile to the active site by forming a hydrogen bond to the main chain of the tyrosine-containing alpha8 helix and that (ii) contacts between Ser-204 and the DNA backbone upstream of the cleavage site trigger a separate conformational change required for active site assembly. Mutations of Phe-88 and Phe-101 affect DNA binding, most likely at the clamp closure step, which we posit to entail a distortion of helix alpha1.

Melanoplus sanguinipes entomopoxvirus DNA topoisomerase: site-specific DNA transesterification and effects of 5'-bridging phosphorothiolates

Melanoplus sanguinipes entomopoxvirus (MsEPV) encodes a 328 amino acid polypeptide related to the type I topoisomerases of six other genera of vertebrate and insect poxviruses. The gene encoding MsEPV topoisomerase was expressed in bacteria, and the recombinant protein was purified by ion-exchange chromatography and glycerol gradient sedimentation. MsEPV topoisomerase, a monomeric protein, catalyzed the relaxation of supercoiled plasmid DNA at approximately 0.6 supercoils/s. Like other poxvirus topoisomerases, the MsEPV enzyme formed a covalent adduct with duplex DNA at the target sequence CCCTT downward arrow. The kinetic and equilibrium parameters of the DNA transesterification reaction of MsEPV topoisomerase were k(cl) = 0.3 s(-1) and K(cl) = 0.25. The introduction of a 5'-bridging phosphorothiolate at the scissile phosphate increased the cleavage equilibrium constant from 0.25 to >/=30. Similar phosphorothiolate effects were observed with vaccinia topoisomerase. Kinetic analysis of single-turnover cleavage and religation reactions established that the altered equilibrium was the result of a approximately 10(-4) decrement in the rate of topoisomerase-catalyzed attack of 5'-SH DNA on the DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. 5'-bridging phosphorothiolates at the scissile phosphate and other positions within the CCCTT element had no significant effect on k(cl).

Structural insights into the function of type IB topoisomerases

Topoisomerases relax the DNA superhelical tension that arises in cells as a result of several nuclear processes, including transcription, replication and recombination. Recently determined crystal structures of human topoisomerase I in complex with DNA and of the 27 kDa catalytic domain of the vaccinia virus topoisomerase have advanced our understanding of the eukaryotic type IB topoisomerases. These recent structural results provide insights into functional aspects of these topoisomerases, including their DNA binding, strand cleavage and religation activities, as well as the mechanism that these enzymes use to relax DNA superhelical tension. In addition, two proposed models of the anticancer drug camptothecin bound to a covalent complex of human topoisomerase I and DNA suggest a structural basis for the mode of action of the drug.

The genome of Melanoplus sanguinipes entomopoxvirus

The family Poxviridae contains two subfamilies: the Entomopoxvirinae (poxviruses of insects) and the Chordopoxvirinae (poxviruses of vertebrates). Here we present the first characterization of the genome of an entomopoxvirus (EPV) which infects the North American migratory grasshopper Melanoplus sanguinipes and other important orthopteran pests. The 236-kbp M. sanguinipes EPV (MsEPV) genome consists of a central coding region bounded by 7-kbp inverted terminal repeats and contains 267 open reading frames (ORFs), of which 107 exhibit similarity to previously described genes. The presence of genes not previously described in poxviruses, and in some cases in any other known virus, suggests significant viral adaptation to the arthropod host and the external environment. Genes predicting interactions with host cellular mechanisms include homologues of the inhibitor of apoptosis protein, stress response protein phosphatase 2C, extracellular matrixin metalloproteases, ubiquitin, calcium binding EF-hand protein, glycosyltransferase, and a triacylglyceride lipase. MsEPV genes with putative functions in prevention and repair of DNA damage include a complete base excision repair pathway (uracil DNA glycosylase, AP endonuclease, DNA polymerase beta, and an NAD+-dependent DNA ligase), a photoreactivation repair pathway (cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer photolyase), a LINE-type reverse transcriptase, and a mutT homologue. The presence of these specific repair pathways may represent viral adaptation for repair of environmentally induced DNA damage. The absence of previously described poxvirus enzymes involved in nucleotide metabolism and the presence of a novel thymidylate synthase homologue suggest that MsEPV is heavily reliant on host cell nucleotide pools and the de novo nucleotide biosynthesis pathway. MsEPV and lepidopteran genus B EPVs lack genome colinearity and exhibit a low level of amino acid identity among homologous genes (20 to 59%), perhaps reflecting a significant evolutionary distance between lepidopteran and orthopteran viruses. Divergence between MsEPV and the Chordopoxvirinae is indicated by the presence of only 49 identifiable chordopoxvirus homologues, low-level amino acid identity among these genes (20 to 48%), and the presence in MsEPV of 43 novel ORFs in five gene families. Genes common to both poxvirus subfamilies, which include those encoding enzymes involved in RNA transcription and modification, DNA replication, protein processing, virion assembly, and virion structural proteins, define the genetic core of the Poxviridae.

Intragenic suppressors of mutant DNA topoisomerase I-induced lethality diminish enzyme binding of DNA

Eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I (Top1p) catalyzes changes in DNA topology and is the cellular target of the antitumor drug camptothecin (Cpt). Mutation of several conserved residues in yeast top1 mutants is sufficient to induce cell lethality in the absence of camptothecin. Despite tremendous differences in catalytic activity, the mutant proteins Top1T722Ap and Top1R517Gp cause cell death via a mechanism similar to that of Cpt, i.e. stabilization of the covalent enzyme-DNA intermediate. To establish the interdomainal interactions required for the catalytic activity of Top1p and how alterations in enzyme structure contribute to the cytotoxic activity of Cpt or specific DNA topoisomerase I mutants, we initiated a genetic screen for intragenic suppressors of the top1T722A-lethal phenotype. Nine single amino acid substitutions were defined that map to the conserved central and C-terminal domains of Top1p as well as the nonconserved linker domain of the protein. All reduced the catalytic activity of the enzyme over 100-fold. However, detailed biochemical analyses of three suppressors, top1C273Y,T722A, top1G295V,T722A, and top1G369D,T722A, revealed this was accomplished via a mechanism of reduced affinity for the DNA substrate. The mechanistic implications of these results are discussed in the context of the known structures of yeast and human DNA topoisomerase I.

Vaccinia virus DNA topoisomerase: a model eukaryotic type IB enzyme

Vaccinia topoisomerase has proven to be an instructive model system for mechanistic studies of the type IB family of DNA topoisomerases. The catalytically relevant functional groups at the active site and the circumferential topoisomerase-DNA interface were correctly surmised by mutational and footprint analysis of vaccinia topoisomerase in advance of structure determinations by X-ray crystallography. It is now evident from multiple crystal structures that the catalytic domains of type IB topoisomerases and site specific recombinases derive from a common ancestral strand transferase capable of forming a DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. A constellation of conserved amino acids catalyzes attack of the tyrosine nucleophile on the scissile phosphate. Domain dynamics and DNA-induced conformational changes within the catalytic domain are likely to play a role in triggering strand scission and coordinating the strand exchange or strand passage steps.

A catalytic domain of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I

Eukaryotic type IB topoisomerases catalyze the cleavage and rejoining of DNA strands through a DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. The 314-amino acid vaccinia topoisomerase is the smallest member of this family and is distinguished from its cellular counterparts by its specificity for cleavage at the target sequence 5'-CCCTT downward arrow. Here we show that Topo-(81-314), a truncated derivative that lacks the N-terminal domain, performs the same repertoire of reactions as the full-sized topoisomerase: relaxation of supercoiled DNA, site-specific DNA transesterification, and DNA strand transfer. Elimination of the N-terminal domain slows the rate of single-turnover DNA cleavage by 10(-3.6), but has little effect on the rate of single-turnover DNA religation. DNA relaxation and strand cleavage by Topo-(81-314) are inhibited by salt and magnesium; these effects are indicative of reduced affinity in noncovalent DNA binding. We report that identical properties are displayed by a full-length mutant protein, Topo(Y70A/Y72A), which lacks two tyrosine side chains within the N-terminal domain that contact the DNA target site in the major groove. We speculate that Topo-(81-314) is fully competent for transesterification chemistry, but is compromised with respect to a rate-limiting precleavage conformational step that is contingent on DNA contacts made by Tyr-70 and Tyr-72.

Conservation of structure and mechanism between eukaryotic topoisomerase I and site-specific recombinases

Vaccinia DNA topoisomerase breaks and rejoins DNA strands through a DNA-(3'-phosphotyrosyl)-enzyme intermediate. A C-terminal catalytic domain, Topo(81-314), suffices for transesterification chemistry. The domain contains a constellation of five amino acids, conserved in all eukaryotic type IB topoisomerases, that catalyzes attack of the tyrosine nucleophile on the scissile phosphate. The structure of the catalytic domain, consisting of ten alpha helices and a three-strand beta sheet, resembles the catalytic domains of site-specific recombinases that act via a topoisomerase IB-like mechanism. The topoisomerase catalytic pentad is conserved in the tertiary structures of the recombinases despite scant sequence similarity overall. This implies that the catalytic domains of type IB topoisomerases and recombinases derive from a common ancestral strand transferase.