A conserved core element is functionally important for maize mitochondrial promoter activity in vitro

The MITOCHONDRIAL TRANSCRIPT STABILITY FACTOR 4 (MTSF4) is essential for the accumulation of dicistronic rpl5-cob mRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana

The Arabidopsis thaliana genome harbors more than 450 nuclear genes encoding pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins that operate in the RNA metabolism of mitochondria and/or plastids. To date, the molecular function of many PPR proteins is still unknown. Here we analyzed the nucleus-encoded gene At4g19440 coding for a P-type PPR protein. Knockout of this gene interferes with normal embryo development and seed maturation. Two experimental approaches were applied to overcome lethality and to investigate the outcome of At4g19440 knockout in adult plants. These studies revealed changes in the abundance of several mitochondria-encoded transcripts. In particular, steady-state levels of dicistronic rpl5-cob RNAs were markedly reduced, whereas levels of mature ccmC and rpl2-mttB transcripts were clearly increased. Predictions according to the one repeat to one nucleotide code for PPR proteins indicate binding of the At4g19440 protein to a previously detected small RNA at the 3' termini of the dicistronic rpl5-cob transcripts. This potential interaction indicates a function of this protein in 3' end formation and stabilization of these RNA species, whereas the increase in the levels of the ccmC mRNA along with other mitochondria-encoded RNAs seems to be a secondary effect of At4g19440 knockout. Since the inactivation of At4g19440 influences the stability of several mitochondrial RNAs we call this gene MITOCHONDRIAL TRANSCRIPT STABILITY FACTOR 4 (MTSF4). This factor will be an interesting subject to study opposing effects of a single nucleus-encoded protein on mitochondrial transcript levels.

Major contribution of transcription initiation to 5'-end formation of mitochondrial steady-state transcripts in maize

In plant mitochondria, some steady-state transcripts contain primary 5' ends derived from transcription initiation, while the others have processed 5' termini generated by post-transcriptional processing. Differentiation and mapping of the primary and processed transcripts are important for unraveling the molecular mechanism(s) underlying transcription and transcript end maturation. However, previous efforts to systematically differentiate these two types of transcripts in plant mitochondria failed. At present, it is considered that the majority of mature mRNAs may have processed 5' ends in Arabidopsis. Here, by combination of circular RT-PCR, quantitative RT-PCR, RNA 5'-polyphosphatase treatment and Northern blot, we successfully discriminated and mapped the primary and processed transcripts in maize mitochondria. Among the thirty-five mature and eight precursor RNAs analyzed in this study, about one half (21/43) were found to have multiple isoforms. In total, seventy-seven steady-state transcripts were determined, and forty-seven of them had primary 5' ends. Most transcription initiation sites (126/167) were downstream of a crTA-motif. These data suggested a major contribution of transcription initiation to 5'-end formation of steady-state transcripts in maize mitochondria. Moreover, the mapping results revealed that mature RNA termini had largely been formed before trans-splicing, and C→U RNA editing was accompanied with trans-splicing and transcript end formation in maize mitochondria.

In vitro promoter recognition by the catalytic subunit of plant phage-type RNA polymerases

We identified sequence motifs, which enhance or reduce the ability of the Arabidopsis phage-type RNA polymerases RPOTm (mitochondrial RNAP), RPOTp (plastidial RNAP), and RPOTmp (active in both organelles) to recognize their promoters in vitro with help of a 'specificity loop'. The importance of this data for the evolution and function of the organellar RNA polymerases is discussed. The single-subunit RNA polymerase (RNAP) of bacteriophage T7 is able to perform all steps of transcription without additional transcription factors. Dicotyledonous plants possess three phage-type RNAPs, RPOTm-the mitochondrial RNAP, RPOTp-the plastidial RNAP, and RPOTmp-an RNAP active in both organelles. RPOTm and RPOTp, like the T7 polymerase, are able to recognize promoters, while RPOTmp displays no significant promoter specificity in vitro. To find out which promoter motifs are crucial for recognition by the polymerases we performed in vitro transcription assays with recombinant Arabidopsis RPOTm and RPOTp enzymes. By comparing different truncated and mutagenized promoter constructs, we observed the same minimal promoter sequence supposed to be needed in vivo for transcription initiation. Moreover, we identified elements of core and flanking sequences, which are of critical importance for promoter recognition and activity in vitro. We further intended to reveal why RPOTmp does not efficiently recognize promoters in vitro and if promoter recognition is based on a structurally defined specificity loop of the plant enzymes as described for the yeast and T7 RNAPs. Interestingly, the exchange of only three amino acids within the putative specificity loop of RPOTmp enabled the enzyme for specific promoter transcription in vitro. Thus, also in plant phage-type RNAPs the specificity loop is engaged in promoter recognition. The results are discussed with respect to their relevance for transcription in organello and to the evolution of RPOT enzymes including the divergence of their functions.

Mitochondrial run-on transcription assay using biotin labeling

RNA synthesis and different posttranscriptional processes shape the transcriptome of plant mitochondria. It is believed that mitochondrial transcription in plants is not stringently controlled, and that RNA degradation has a major impact on mitochondrial steady-state transcript levels. Nevertheless, the presence of two RNA polymerases with different gene specificities in mitochondria of dicotyledonous species indicates that transcriptional mechanisms may provide a means to control mitochondrial steady-state RNA pools and gene expression. To experimentally assess transcriptional activities in mitochondria, run-on transcription assays have been developed. These assays measure elongation rates for endogenous transcripts in freshly prepared mitochondrial extracts. The mitochondrial run-on transcription protocol described here has been optimized for the model plant Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). It uses mitochondria prepared from soil-grown Arabidopsis plants and employs nonradioactive labeling for the subsequent detection of run-on transcripts.

The transcription machineries of plant mitochondria and chloroplasts: Composition, function, and regulation

Although genomes of mitochondria and plastids are very small compared to those of their bacterial ancestors, the transcription machineries of these organelles are of surprising complexity. With respect to the number of different RNA polymerases per organelle, the extremes are represented on one hand by chloroplasts of eudicots which use one bacterial-type RNA polymerase and two phage-type RNA polymerases to transcribe their genes, and on the other hand by Physcomitrella possessing three mitochondrial RNA polymerases of the phage type. Transcription of genes/operons is often driven by multiple promoters in both organelles. This review describes the principle components of the transcription machineries (RNA polymerases, transcription factors, promoters) and the division of labor between the different RNA polymerases. While regulation of transcription in mitochondria seems to be only of limited importance, the plastid genes of higher plants respond to exogenous and endogenous cues rather individually by altering their transcriptional activities.

Phage-type RNA polymerase RPOTmp performs gene-specific transcription in mitochondria of Arabidopsis thaliana

Transcription of mitochondrial genes in animals, fungi, and plants relies on the activity of T3/T7 phage-type RNA polymerases. Two such enzymes, RPOTm and RPOTmp, are present in the mitochondria of eudicotyledonous plants; RPOTmp is additionally found in plastids. We have characterized the transcriptional role of the dual-targeted RNA polymerase in mitochondria of Arabidopsis thaliana. Examination of mitochondrial transcripts in rpoTmp mutants revealed major differences in transcript abundances between wild-type and rpoTmp plants. Decreased levels of specific transcripts were correlated with reduced abundances of the respiratory chain complexes I and IV. Altered transcript levels in rpoTmp were found to result from gene-specific transcriptional changes, establishing that RPOTmp functions in distinct transcriptional processes within mitochondria. Decreased transcription of specific genes in rpoTmp was not associated with changes in promoter utilization; therefore, RPOTmp function is not promoter specific but gene specific. This implies that additional gene-specific elements direct the transcription of a subset of mitochondrial genes by RPOTmp.

Variable structures of promoters regulating transcription of cp-like tRNA genes and of some native genes on the sunflower mitochondrial genome

Promoter regions regulating the transcription of all cp-like tRNA genes encoded by the sunflower chondriome have been identified. Some of these genes are part of clusters where the first gene is a typical mitochondrial isoform. Promoters regulating the transcription of single cp-like tRNA genes have a variable structure whereas those regulating the transcription of native genes or clusters with typical mitochondrial genes in the first position conform to a similar common structure. The variability of promoter regions described in this paper could be the result of modifications of regions having, at the moment of the cpDNA insertion event, only minimal structural features as promoters.

The complete nucleotide sequence and multipartite organization of the tobacco mitochondrial genome: comparative analysis of mitochondrial genomes in higher plants

Tobacco is a valuable model system for investigating the origin of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in amphidiploid plants and studying the genetic interaction between mitochondria and chloroplasts in the various functions of the plant cell. As a first step, we have determined the complete mtDNA sequence of Nicotiana tabacum. The mtDNA of N. tabacum can be assumed to be a master circle (MC) of 430,597 bp. Sequence comparison of a large number of clones revealed that there are four classes of boundaries derived from homologous recombination, which leads to a multipartite organization with two MCs and six subgenomic circles. The mtDNA of N. tabacum contains 36 protein-coding genes, three ribosomal RNA genes and 21 tRNA genes. Among the first class, we identified the genes rps1 and psirps14, which had previously been thought to be absent in tobacco mtDNA on the basis of Southern analysis. Tobacco mtDNA was compared with those of Arabidopsis thaliana, Beta vulgaris, Oryza sativa and Brassica napus. Since repeated sequences show no homology to each other among the five angiosperms, it can be supposed that these were independently acquired by each species during the evolution of angiosperms. The gene order and the sequences of intergenic spacers in mtDNA also differ widely among the five angiosperms, indicating multiple reorganizations of genome structure during the evolution of higher plants. Among the conserved genes, the same potential conserved nonanucleotide-motif-type promoter could only be postulated for rrn18-rrn5 in four of the dicotyledonous plants, suggesting that a coding sequence does not necessarily move with the promoter upon reorganization of the mitochondrial genome.

Multiple promoters are a common feature of mitochondrial genes in Arabidopsis

Mitochondrial genes in the plant Arabidopsis thaliana are transcribed by two phage-type RNA polymerases encoded in the nucleus. Little is known about cis-elements that are recognized by these enzymes and mediate the transcription of the Arabidopsis mitochondrial genome. Here, 30 transcription initiation sites of 12 mitochondrial genes and gene clusters have been determined using 5′-RACE and ribonuclease protection analysis of primary transcripts labelled in vitro by guanylyltransferase. A total of 9 out of 12 genes were found to possess multiple promoters, revealing for the first time that multiple promoters are a common feature of mitochondrial genes in a dicotyledonous plant. No differences in promoter utilization were observed between leaves and flowers, suggesting that promoter multiplicity reflects a relaxed promoter specificity rather than a regulatory role of promoter selection. Nearly half the identified transcription initiation sites displayed immediately upstream a CRTA core sequence, which was mostly seen within the previously described CRTAAGAGA promoter motif or a novel CGTATATAA promoter element. About as many promoters possessed an ATTA or RGTA core. Our data indicate that the majority of mitochondrial promoters in Arabidopsis deviate significantly from the nonanucleotide consensus derived earlier for dicot mitochondrial promoters.

Functional importance of nucleotide identities within the pea atp9 mitochondrial promoter sequence

Sequences ranging from nucleotide positions -14 to +4 relative to the transcription start site constitute an in vitro functional pea atp9 promoter. A comparison of respective sequence segments surrounding 11 unambiguously identified transcription initiation sites of various dicotyledoneous plant species revealed the highest level of evolutionary fidelity of nucleotide identities within the conserved nonanucleotide motif (CNM), suggesting their importance for promoter function. Using a mitochondrial in vitro transcription system, a detailed analysis by site-directed mutagenesis now reveals that the alteration of nucleotides -6 to -2 and +1 within the CNM indeed reduces promoter activity by more than 80%. Changes of nucleotide identities at the less conserved positions -12 to -9 within the AT-rich region reduced the initiation efficiency by about 70%. The alteration of the highly conserved position -7 has little influence on promoter function, indicating that evolutionary conservation does not always correlate with the functional importance of certain nucleotides. Mutagenesis of nucleotides at positions +3 or +4 reveals a minimal requirement of at least one purine for wild-type transcription initiation efficiency. The assignment of functionally important nucleotide identities should now facilitate an efficient and reliable prediction of other promoters in mitochondria of dicotyledon plants.

RT-PCR analysis of 5' to 3'-end-ligated mRNAs identifies the extremities of cox2 transcripts in pea mitochondria

Gene expression in plant mitochondria is still inadequately analyzed. To learn more about transcription and RNA processing in plant mitochondria, the 5'- and 3'-RNA extremities and the promoters of the cytochrome oxidase gene (cox2) were analyzed in pea. Both 5' and 3' ends of cox2 transcripts were examined by RT-PCR across the ligation site of circularized mitochondrial RNA as template. This approach identified 5' ends a few nucleotides shorter than three major 5' ends mapped by primer extension analysis. Presumably, only monophosphate 5' ends derived from processing can be ligated. In vitro transcription assays using a homologous mitochondrial protein extract from pea strongly suggest the major 5' ends to derive from transcription initiation. The cDNA analysis of the head-to-tail ligated cox2 mRNA identified 3' ends within a thymidine stretch approximately 300 nt downstream of the reading frame in a sequence segment that was not present in the previous investigation of this gene. Nuclease S1 protection experiments confirmed this newly identified 3' terminus and corroborated the validity of this technique in mRNA end analysis. The general use of the circularized RNA (CR)-RT-PCR approach for the simultaneous analysis of the 5' and 3' extremities of mRNA molecules is discussed.

The RNA world of plant mitochondria

Mitochondria are well known as the cellular power factory. Much less is known about these organelles as a genetic system. This is particularly true for mitochondria of plants, which subsist with respect to attention by the scientific community in the shadow of the chloroplasts. Nevertheless the mitochondrial genetic system is essential for the function of mitochondria and thus for the survival of the plant. In plant mitochondria the pathway from the genetic information encoded in the DNA to the functional protein leads through a very diverse RNA world. How the RNA is generated and what kinds of regulation and control mechanisms are operative in transcription are current topics in research. Furthermore, the modes of posttranscriptional alterations and their consequences for RNA stability and thus for gene expression in plant mitochondria are currently objects of intensive investigations. In this article current results obtained in the examination of plant mitochondrial transcription, RNA processing, and RNA stability are illustrated. Recent developments in the characterization of promoter structure and the respective transcription apparatus as well as new aspects of RNA processing steps including mRNA 3' processing and stability, mRNA polyadenylation, RNA editing, and tRNA maturation are presented. We also consider new suggestions concerning the endosymbiont hypothesis and evolution of mitochondria. These novel considerations may yield important clues for the further analysis of the plant mitochondrial genetic system. Conversely, an increasing knowledge about the mechanisms and components of the organellar genetic system might reveal new aspects of the evolutionary history of mitochondria.

Characterization of a DNA-binding protein implicated in transcription in wheat mitochondria

To investigate the transcriptional apparatus in wheat mitochondria, mitochondrial extracts were subjected to column chromatography and protein fractions were analyzed by in vitro transcription and mobility shift assays. Fractions eluting from DEAE-Sephacel between 0.2 and 0.3 M KCl displayed DNA-binding activity and supported specific transcription initiated from a wheat cox2 promoter. The active DEAE-Sephacel pool was further resolved by chromatography on phosphocellulose. Fractions that exhibited DNA-binding activity and that stimulated both specific and nonspecific transcription in vitro were highly enriched in a 63-kDa protein (p63). From peptide sequence obtained from purified p63, a cDNA encoding the protein was assembled. The predicted amino acid sequence (612 amino acid residues, 69 kDa) contains a basic N-terminal targeting sequence expected to direct transport of the protein into mitochondria. The p63 sequence also features an acidic domain characteristic of transcriptional activation factors, as well as sequence blocks displaying limited similarity to positionally equivalent regions in sigma factors from eubacteria related to mitochondria. Recombinant p63 possesses DNA-binding activity, exhibiting an affinity for the core cox2 promoter element and upstream regions in gel shift assays and having the ability to enhance specific transcription in vitro. Transcripts encoding p63 are expressed at an early stage in the germination of isolated wheat embryos, in a temporal pattern parallelling that of newly synthesized precursors of cox2, a mitochondrial gene. Taken together, these data suggest a role for p63 in transcription in wheat mitochondria.

Genomic context influences the activity of maize mitochondrial cox2 promoters

Plant mitochondrial genomes are highly recombinogenic, with a variety of species-specific direct and inverted repeats leading to in vivo accumulation of multiple DNA forms. In maize, the cox2 gene, which encodes subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase, lies immediately downstream of a 0.7-kilobase direct repeat, which is present in two copies in the 570-kilobase master chromosome. Promoters for cox2 exist upstream of both of these copies, in regions we have termed A and B. Three region B promoters are active for cox2 transcription in the master chromosome, whereas two region A promoters are active for cox2 transcription after recombination across the direct repeats. We have measured the proportion of genomes carrying region A or B upstream of cox2 in maize seedlings and found a ratio of approximately 1:6. Promoter strength, based on run-on transcription assays, shows a ratio of 1:4 for region A to region B promoters. These data allowed us to predict the relative contributions of region A and B to mitochondrial transcript accumulation, based on a simple product of genome-form abundance and promoter strength. When promoter use was determined by using quantitative reverse transcriptase-PCR, however, we found that region A promoters were used at an unexpectedly high rate when upstream of cox2 and used less than expected when not upstream of cox2. Thus, the use of this set of promoters seems to respond to genomic context. These results suggest a role for intragenomic and intergenomic recombination in regulating plant mitochondrial gene expression.

Organellar RNA polymerases of higher plants

The nuclear genome of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana contains a small gene family consisting of three genes encoding RNA polymerases of the single-subunit bacteriophage type. There is evidence that similar gene families also exist in other plants. Two of these RNA polymerases are putative mitochondrial enzymes, whereas the third one may represent the nuclear-encoded RNA polymerase (NEP) active in plastids. In addition, plastid genes are transcribed from another, entirely different multisubunit eubacterial-type RNA polymerase, the core subunits of which are encoded by plastid genes [plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP)]. This core enzyme is complemented by one of several nuclear-encoded sigma-like factors. The development of photosynthetically active chloroplasts requires both PEP and NEP. Most NEP promoters show certain similarities to mitochondrial promoters in that they include the sequence motif 5'-YRTA-3' near the transcription initiation site. PEP promoters are similar to bacterial promoters of the -10/-35 sigma 70 type.

Functional analysis of two maize cDNAs encoding T7-like RNA polymerases

We have characterized two maize cDNAs, rpoTm and rpoTp, that encode putative T7-like RNA polymerases. In vivo cellular localization experiments using transient expression of the green fluorescent protein suggest that their encoded proteins are targeted exclusively to mitochondria and plastids, respectively. An antibody raised against the C terminus of the rpoTp gene product identified mitochondrial polypeptides of approximately 100 kD. Their presence was correlated with RNA polymerase activity, and the antibody inhibited mitochondrial in vitro transcription activity. Together, these results strongly suggest that the product of rpoTm is involved in maize mitochondrial transcription. By contrast, immunoblot analysis and an antibody-linked polymerase assay indicated that rpoTp specifies a plastid RNA polymerase component. A quantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction assay was used to study the transcription of rpoTp and rpoTm in different tissues and under different environmental conditions. Although both genes were constitutively expressed, rpoTm transcripts were generally more prevalent in nonphotosynthetic tissues, whereas an increase in rpoTp transcripts paralleled chloroplast development. We suggest that these two genes encode constitutive components of the organelle transcription machinery but that their expression is nonetheless subject to modulation during plant development.

Continuous primary sequence requirements in the 18-nucleotide promoter of dicot plant mitochondria

The nucleotide requirements of mitochondrial promoters of dicot plants were studied in detail in a pea in vitro transcription system. Deletions in the 5' regions of three different transcription initiation sites from pea, soybean, and Oenothera identified a crucial AT-rich sequence element (AT-Box) comprising nucleotide positions -14 to -9 relative to the first transcribed nucleotide. Transversion of the AT-Box sequence to comple- mentary nucleotide identities results in an almost complete loss of promoter activity, suggesting that primary structure rather than a simple accumulation of adenines and thymidines in this region is essential for promoter activity. This promoter segment thus appears to be involved in sequence specific binding of a respective protein factor(s) rather than merely loosening and melting the DNA helix during or for an initiation event. Manipulation of nucleotide identities in the 3' portion of the pea atp9 promoter and the respective 3'-flanking region revealed that essential sequences extend to positions +3/+4 beyond this transcription start site. Efficient transcription initiation at an 18-base pair promoter sequence ranging from nucleotide positions -14 to +4 integrated into different sequence contexts shows this element to be sufficient for autonomous promoter function independent of surrounding sequences.

Compilation and analysis of plant mitochondrial promoter sequences: An illustration of a divergent evolution between monocot and dicot mitochondria

We have analyzed 67 sequences surrounding transcription initiation sites identified in higher plant mitochondria. The sequences were classified, independently for monocots and dicots, according to the presence of the CRTA core element found upstream of the first transcribed nucleotide and previously reported as an essential element of plant mitochondrial consensus promoters. This compilation provides new elements concerning the structure of consensus promoters and the relative importance of non-conserved promoters in plant mitochondria. It can be emphasized that promoter regions exhibit several differences between monocot and dicot mitochondria, presumably reflecting a divergent evolution: The sequences classified among consensus promoters as well as the distance between the first transcribed nucleotide and the core element are highly conserved in dicots while more plasticity is observed in monocots. It also appears that the proportion of promoters with neither the conserved promoter sequence nor any conserved motif is far greater in dicots than in monocots.

The maize mitochondrial cox2 gene has five promoters in two genomic regions, including a complex promoter consisting of seven overlapping units

Plant mitochondrial genes are often transcribed into complex sets of RNAs, resulting from multiple initiation sites and processing steps. To elucidate the role of initiation in generating the more than 10 cox2 transcripts found in maize mitochondria, we surveyed sequences upstream of cox2 for active promoters. Because the cox2 coding region is immediately downstream of a 0.7-kb recombination repeat, cox2 is under the control of two different sets of potential expression signals. Using an in vitro transcription assay, we localized four promoters upstream of the coding region in the so-called master chromosome, and two promoters upstream of the coding region in the recombinant subgenome. Ribonuclease protection analysis of labeled primary transcripts confirmed that all but one of these promoters is active in vivo. Primer extension was used to identify the promoter sequences and initiation sites, which agree with the consensus established earlier for maize mitochondria. This study identified two unusual promoters, the core sequences of which were composed entirely of adenines and thymines, and one of which was a complex promoter consisting of seven overlapping units. Deletion mutagenesis of the complex promoter suggested that each of its units was recognized independently by RNA polymerase. While each active promoter fit the maize core consensus sequence YRTAT, not all such sequences surveyed supported initiation. We conclude that in vitro transcription is a powerful tool for locating mitochondrial promoters and that, in the case of cox2, promoter multiplicity contributes strongly to transcript complexity.

In vitro characterization of the tobacco rpoB promoter reveals a core sequence motif conserved between phage-type plastid and plant mitochondrial promoters

We report here the in vitro characterization of PrpoB-345, the tobacco rpoB promoter recognized by NEP, the phage-type plastid RNA polymerase. Transcription extracts were prepared from mutant tobacco plants lacking PEP, the Escherichia coli-like plastid-encoded RNA polymerase. Systematic dissection of a approximately 1 kb fragment determined that the rpoB promoter is contained in a 15-nucleotide segment (-14 to +1) upstream of the transcription initiation site (+1). Point mutations at every nucleotide reduced transcription, except at the -5 position which was neutral. Critical for rpoB promoter function was a CRT-motif (CAT or CGT) at -8 to -6 (transcription <30%), defining it as the promoter core. The core CAT sequence is also present in the maize rpoB promoter, which is faithfully recognized by tobacco extracts. Alignment of NEP promoters identified a CATA or TATA (=YATA) sequence at the rpoB core position, also present in plant mitochondrial promoters. Furthermore, NEP and the phage T7 RNA polymerase exhibit similar sensitivity to inhibitors of transcription. These data indicate that the nuclear RpoZ gene, identified by sequence conservation with mitochondrial RNA polymerases, encodes the NEP catalytic subunit.