In vitro and in vivo self-cleavage of a viroid RNA with a mutation in the hammerhead catalytic pocket

A Novel Self-Cleaving Viroid-Like RNA Identified in RNA Preparations from a Citrus Tree Is Not Directly Associated with the Plant

Viroid and viroid-like satellite RNAs are infectious, circular, non-protein coding RNAs reported in plants only so far. Some viroids (family Avsunviroidae) and viroid-like satellite RNAs share self-cleaving activity mediated by hammerhead ribozymes (HHRzs) endowed in both RNA polarity strands. Using a homology-independent method based on the search for conserved structural motifs of HHRzs in reads and contigs from high-throughput sequenced RNAseq libraries, we identified a novel small (550 nt) viroid-like RNA in a library from a Citrus reticulata tree. Such a viroid-like RNA contains a HHRz in both polarity strands. Northern blot hybridization assays showed that circular forms of both polarity strands of this RNA (tentatively named citrus transiently-associated hammerhead viroid-like RNA1 (CtaHVd-LR1)) exist, supporting its replication through a symmetric pathway of the rolling circle mechanism. CtaHVd-LR1 adopts a rod-like conformation and has the typical features of quasispecies. Its HHRzs were shown to be active during transcription and in the absence of any protein. CtaHVd-LR1 was not graft-transmissible, and after its first identification, it was not found again in the original citrus source when repeatedly searched in the following years, suggesting that it was actually not directly associated with the plant. Therefore, the possibility that this novel self-cleaving viroid-like RNA is actually associated with another organism (e.g., a fungus), in turn, transiently associated with citrus plants, is proposed.

A life of research on circular RNAs and ribozymes: towards the origin of viroids, deltaviruses and life

The first examples of circular RNAs (circRNAs) were reported in the '70s as a family of minimal infectious agents of flowering plants; the viroids and viral satellites of circRNA. In some cases, these small circular genomes encode self-cleaving RNA motifs or ribozymes, including an exceptional circRNA infecting not plants but humans: the Hepatitis Delta Virus. Autocatalytic ribozymes not only allowed to propose a common rolling-circle replication mechanism for all these subviral agents, but also a tentative link with the origin of life as molecular fossils of the so-called RNA world. Despite the weak biologic connection between angiosperm plants and the human liver, diverse scientists, and most notably Ricardo Flores, firmly supported an evolutionary relationship between plant viroids and human deltavirus agents. The tireless and inspiring work done by Ricardo's lab in the field of infectious circRNAs fuelled multiple hypotheses for the origin of these entities, allowing advances in other fields, from eukaryotic circRNAs to small ribozymes in genomes from all life kingdoms. The recent discovery of a plethora of viral-like circRNAs with ribozymes in disparate biological samples may finally allow us to connect plant and animal subviral agents, confirming again that Ricardo's eye for science was always a keen eye.

Viroid Diseases in Pome and Stone Fruit Trees and Koch's Postulates: A Critical Assessment

Composed of a naked circular non-protein-coding genomic RNA, counting only a few hundred nucleotides, viroids-the smallest infectious agents known so far-are able to replicate and move systemically in herbaceous and woody host plants, which concomitantly may develop specific diseases or remain symptomless. Several viroids have been reported to naturally infect pome and stone fruit trees, showing symptoms on leaves, fruits and/or bark. However, Koch's postulates required for establishing on firm grounds the viroid etiology of these diseases, have not been met in all instances. Here, pome and stone fruit tree diseases, conclusively proven to be caused by viroids, are reviewed, and the need to pay closer attention to fulfilling Koch's postulates is emphasized.

Hammerhead Ribozymes in Archaeal Genomes: A Computational Hunt

Hammerhead ribozymes (HHRs) are small self-cleaving RNAs, first discovered in viroids and satellite RNAs of plant viruses. They are composed of a catalytic core of conserved nucleotides flanked by three helices. More recently, hammerhead-encoding sequences have been identified in the genomes of many eukaryotes, prokaryotes and other non-viral species regulating various functions. In this study we have explored the Archaeal domain to identify HHRs using three different bioinformatics approach. Our study reveals four putative hits of HHRs type I and type II in the group Thaumarchaeota and Euryarchaeota in the Archaeal domain, one of which is the instance of HHR 1 in C. symbiosum A, already identified in a previous study. These HHRs are very similar to those previously described in terms of the conservation of their catalytic core. Based on 3-D structure analysis and free energy, these instances were concluded as putative HHRs. Our findings reveal that the catalytic core contains the conserved motifs that are essential for cleavage activity, but there are some instances in which compensatory core variations are present. However, no instances of HHRs have been found in Crenarchaeota. This study reveals a very scarce presence of HHRs in Archaea which suggests the involvement of other ncRNA elements in gene regulatory system like RNase P which are abundantly found in the Archaeal domain.

A recombinant RNA bacteriophage system to identify functionally important nucleotides in a self-cleaving ribozyme

Background

RNA bacteriophages like Qbeta and MS2 are well known for their high mutation rate, short infection cycle and strong selection against foreign inserts. The hammerhead ribozyme (HHRz) is a small self-cleaving RNA molecule whose active residues have previously been identified by mutational analysis of each individual base. Here the functionally important bases of HHRz were determined in a single screening experiment by inserting the HHRz into the genome of MS2.

Findings

The minimal HHRz of satellite Tobacco ringspot virus was cloned into the genome of RNA bacteriophage MS2. Sequence analysis of the surviving phages revealed that the majority had acquired single base-substitutions that apparently inactivated the HHRz. The positions of these substitutions exactly matched that of the previously determined core residues of the HHRz.

Conclusions

Natural selection against a ribozyme in the genome of MS2 can be used to quickly identify nucleotides required for self-cleavage.

Deep-sequencing of the peach latent mosaic viroid reveals new aspects of population heterogeneity

Viroids are small circular single-stranded infectious RNAs characterized by a relatively high mutation level. Knowledge of their sequence heterogeneity remains largely elusive and previous studies, using Sanger sequencing, were based on a limited number of sequences. In an attempt to address sequence heterogeneity from a population dynamics perspective, a GF305-indicator peach tree was infected with a single variant of the Avsunviroidae family member Peach latent mosaic viroid (PLMVd). Six months post-inoculation, full-length circular conformers of PLMVd were isolated and deep-sequenced. We devised an original approach to the bioinformatics refinement of our sequence libraries involving important phenotypic data, based on the systematic analysis of hammerhead self-cleavage activity. Two distinct libraries yielded a total of 3,939 different PLMVd variants. Sequence variants exhibiting up to ∼17% of mutations relative to the inoculated viroid were retrieved, clearly illustrating the high level of divergence dynamics within a unique population. While we initially assumed that most positions of the viroid sequence would mutate, we were surprised to discover that ∼50% of positions remained perfectly conserved, including several small stretches as well as a small motif reminiscent of a GNRA tetraloop which are the result of various selective pressures. Using a hierarchical clustering algorithm, the different variants harvested were subdivided into 7 clusters. We found that most sequences contained an average of 4.6 to 6.4 mutations compared to the variant used to initially inoculate the plant. Interestingly, it was possible to reconstitute and compare the sequence evolution of each of these clusters. In doing so, we identified several key mutations. This study provides a reliable pipeline for the treatment of viroid deep-sequencing. It also sheds new light on the extent of sequence variation that a viroid population can sustain, and which may give rise to a quasispecies.

G17-modified hammerhead ribozymes are active in vitro and in vivo

Natural hammerhead ribozymes (HHRz) feature tertiary interactions between hairpin loops or bulges in two of three helices that surround the catalytic core of conserved nucleotides. Their conservation was originally established on minimal versions lacking the tertiary interactions. While those sequence requirements in general also apply to natural versions, we show here differences for the HHRz cleavage site N17. A guanosine at this position strongly impairs cleavage activity in minimal versions, whereas we observe for the G17 variants of four tertiary stabilized HHRz significant cleavage and ligation activity in vitro. Kinetic analyses of these variants revealed a reduced rate and extent of cleavage, compared with wild-type sequences, while variants with distorted tertiary interactions cleaved at a reduced rate, but to the same extent. Contrary to this, G17 variants exhibit similar in vitro ligation activity as compared with the respective wild-type motif. To also address the catalytic performance of these motifs in vivo, we have inserted HHRz cassettes in the lacZ gene and tested this β-galactosidase reporter in Dictyostelium discoideum. In colorimetric assays, we observe differences in the enzymatic activity of β-galactosidase, which correlate well with the activity of the different HHRz variants in vitro and which can be unambiguously attributed to ribozyme cleavage by primer extension analysis.

Loop-mediated isothermal amplification for the rapid detection of Chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid (CChMVd)

Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) is an established nucleic acid amplification method offering rapid, sensitive, and convenient diagnosis of infectious diseases. Chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid (CChMVd) causes one of the most serious viral diseases in chrysanthemum in Korea. A sensitive LAMP assay was developed for rapidly detecting CChMVd infection. The assay was based on a set of four primers matching the specific region of the CChMVd genome. The CChMVd LAMP primer sets were designed using the sequences from nonsymptomatic and symptomatic CChMVd isolates in Korea. The efficiency and specificity of this method were optimized using Bst DNA polymerase, which allowed for increased viroid detection sensitivity. The reaction was carried out at 65 °C for 90 min, and was improved by adding SYBR Green I dye to the inside of the reaction tube lid prior to amplification. The results indicate that this LAMP method will be useful for chrysanthemum viroid disease monitoring and detecting CChMVd infectious disease.

The ubiquitous hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA motif capable of endonucleolytic (self-) cleavage. It is composed of a catalytic core of conserved nucleotides flanked by three helices, two of which form essential tertiary interactions for fast self-scission under physiological conditions. Originally discovered in subviral plant pathogens, its presence in several eukaryotic genomes has been reported since. More recently, this catalytic RNA motif has been shown to reside in a large number of genomes. We review the different approaches in discovering these new hammerhead ribozyme sequences and discuss possible biological functions of the genomic motifs.

Identification of hammerhead ribozymes in all domains of life reveals novel structural variations

Hammerhead ribozymes are small self-cleaving RNAs that promote strand scission by internal phosphoester transfer. Comparative sequence analysis was used to identify numerous additional representatives of this ribozyme class than were previously known, including the first representatives in fungi and archaea. Moreover, we have uncovered the first natural examples of "type II" hammerheads, and our findings reveal that this permuted form occurs in bacteria as frequently as type I and III architectures. We also identified a commonly occurring pseudoknot that forms a tertiary interaction critical for high-speed ribozyme activity. Genomic contexts of many hammerhead ribozymes indicate that they perform biological functions different from their known role in generating unit-length RNA transcripts of multimeric viroid and satellite virus genomes. In rare instances, nucleotide variation occurs at positions within the catalytic core that are otherwise strictly conserved, suggesting that core mutations are occasionally tolerated or preferred.

Idiosyncratic cleavage and ligation activity of individual hammerhead ribozymes and core sequence variants thereof

The hammerhead ribozyme is a small RNA endonuclease found in sub-viral plant pathogens, in transcripts from certain animal satellite DNAs and encoded at distinct loci of Arabidopsis thaliana. Kinetic analyses of tertiary stabilised ribozymes from peach latent mosaic viroid (PLMVd), Schistosoma mansoni and A. thaliana revealed a ten-fold difference in cleavage rates. Core nucleotide variations affected cleavage reactions least in the A. thaliana ribozyme, and most in the S. mansoni ribozyme. The reverse ligation reaction was catalysed efficiently by the PLMVd and A. thaliana ribozymes. The different behaviour of the individual hammerhead ribozymes is discussed in terms of structure and function.

Effects of the trinucleotide preceding the self-cleavage site on eggplant latent viroid hammerheads: differences in co- and post-transcriptional self-cleavage may explain the lack of trinucleotide AUC in most natural hammerheads

Eggplant latent viroid (ELVd) can form stable hammerhead structures in its (+) and (-) strands. These ribozymes have the longest helices I reported in natural hammerheads, with that of the ELVd (+) hammerhead being particularly stable (5/7 bp are G-C). Moreover, the trinucleotide preceding the self-cleavage site of this hammerhead is AUA, which together with GUA also found in some natural hammerheads, deviate from the GUC present in most natural hammerheads including the ELVd (-) hammerhead. When the AUA trinucleotide preceding the self-cleavage site of the ELVd (+) hammerhead was substituted by GUA and GUC, as well as by AUC (essentially absent in natural hammerheads), the values of the self-cleavage rate constants at low magnesium of the purified hammerheads were: ELVd-(+)-AUC approximately ELVd-(+)-GUC>ELVd-(+)-GUA> ELVd-(+)-AUA. However, the ELVd-(+)-AUC hammerhead was the catalytically less efficient during in vitro transcription, most likely because of the transient adoption of catalytically-inactive metastable structures. These results suggest that natural hammerheads have been evolutionary selected to function co-transcriptionally, and provide a model explaining the lack of trinucleotide AUC preceding the self-cleavage site of most natural hammerheads. Comparisons with other natural hammerheads showed that the ELVd-(+)-GUC and ELVd-(+)-AUC hammerheads are the catalytically most active in a post-transcriptional context with low magnesium.

Peripheral regions of natural hammerhead ribozymes greatly increase their self-cleavage activity

Natural hammerhead ribozymes are mostly found in some viroid and viroid-like RNAs and catalyze their cis cleavage during replication. Hammerheads have been manipulated to act in trans and assumed to have a similar catalytic behavior in this artificial context. However, we show here that two natural cis-acting hammerheads self-cleave much faster than trans-acting derivatives and other reported artificial hammerheads. Moreover, modifications of the peripheral loops 1 and 2 of one of these natural hammerheads induced a >100-fold reduction of the self-cleavage constant, whereas engineering a trans-acting artificial hammerhead into a cis derivative by introducing a loop 1 had no effect. These data show that regions external to the central conserved core of natural hammerheads play a role in catalysis, and suggest the existence of tertiary interactions between these peripheral regions. The interactions, determined by the sequence and size of loops 1 and 2 and most likely of helices I and II, must result from natural selection and should be studied in order to better understand the hammerhead requirements in vivo.

Advances in the Development of Ribozymes and Antisense Oligodeoxynucleotides as Antiviral Agents for Human Papillomaviruses

Urogenital human papillomavirus (HPV) infections are the most common viral sexually transmitted disease in women. On a worldwide basis cervical cancer is the second most prevalent cancer of women. Although HPV infection is not sufficient to induce cancer, the causal relation between high-risk HPV infection and cervical cancer is well established. Over 99% of cervical cancers are positive for high-risk HPV. Therefore, there is a need for newer approaches to treat HPV infection. Two novel approaches for inactivating gene expression involve ribozymes and oligonucleotides. Methods for identification of target genes involved in neoplastic transformation and tumour growth have been established, and these will lead to therapeutic approaches without any damage to normal cellular RNA molecules, which is often associated with conventional therapeutics. Ribozymes and oligonucleotides represent rational antiviral approaches for inhibiting the growth of cervical lesions and carcinomas by interfering with E6/E7 RNA production. The E6 and E7 genes of high-risk HPVs cooperate to immortalize primary epithelial cells and because they are found in cervical cancer are considered the hallmark of cervical cancer. The use and modification of ribozymes and antisense oligodeoxynucleotides can inhibit the growth of HPV-16 and HPV-18 immortalized cells, and tumour cells by eliminating E6/E7 transcript. Hammerhead and hairpin ribozymes have been widely studied because of their potential use for gene therapy and their place as therapeutic tools for cervical cancer is being evaluated. Although antiviral ribozymes and anti-sense molecules have been effective as in vitro or in vivo inhibitors of high-risk HPV-positive cells, none is currently in clinical trial. There are, however, a number of other antisense therapies in Phase I–III clinical trial for several oncogenes.

Distribution of hammerhead and hammerhead-like RNA motifs through the GenBank

Hammerhead ribozymes previously were found in satellite RNAs from plant viroids and in repetitive DNA from certain species of newts and schistosomes. To determine if this catalytic RNA motif has a wider distribution, we decided to scrutinize the GenBank database for RNAs that contain hammerhead or hammerhead-like motifs. The search shows a widespread distribution of this kind of RNA motif in different sequences suggesting that they might have a more general role in RNA biology. The frequency of the hammerhead motif is half of that expected from a random distribution, but this fact comes from the low CpG representation in vertebrate sequences and the bias of the GenBank for those sequences. Intriguing motifs include those found in several families of repetitive sequences, in the satellite RNA from the carrot red leaf luteovirus, in plant viruses like the spinach latent virus and the elm mottle virus, in animal viruses like the hepatitis E virus and the caprine encephalitis virus, and in mRNAs such as those coding for cytochrome P450 oxidoreductase in the rat and the hamster.

Avsunviroidae family: viroids containing hammerhead ribozymes

This chapter focuses on the second viroid family, whose members are also referred to as hammerhead viroids, taking into account their most outstanding feature. If the word “small” is the first to come to mind when considering viroids, perhaps the second word is “hammerhead,” because this class of ribozymes, which because of its structural simplicity has an enormous biotechnological potential, is described in avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd) as well as in a viroid-like satellite RNA. The most outstanding feature of the Avsunviroidae members is their potential to adopt hammerhead structures in both polarity strands and to self-cleave in vitro accordingly. Viroids differ from viruses not only in their genome size but also in other fundamental aspects, prominent among which is the lack of messenger activity of both viroid RNAs and their complementary strands.

Rapid generation of genetic heterogeneity in progenies from individual cDNA clones of peach latent mosaic viroid in its natural host

Viroids, small single-stranded circular RNAs endowed with autonomous replication, are unique systems to conduct evolutionary studies of complete RNA genomes. The primary structure of 36 progeny variants of peach latent mosaic viroid (PLMVd), evolved from inoculations of the peach indicator GF-305 with four individual PLMVd cDNAs differing in their pathogenicity, has been determined. Most progeny variants had unique sequences, revealing that the extremely heterogeneous character of PLMVd natural isolates most probably results from the intrinsic ability of this RNA to accumulate changes, rather than from repeated inoculations of the same individual trees under field conditions. The structure of the populations derived from single PLMVd sequences differed according to the observed phenotype. Variant gds6 induced a reproducible symptomatic infection and gave rise to a more uniform progeny that preserves some parental features, whereas variant gds15, which induced a variable phenotype, showed a more complex behaviour, generating two distinct progenies in symptomatic and asymptomatic individual plants. Progenies derived from variants esc10 and Is11, which incited latent infections, followed a similar evolutionary pattern, leading to a population structure consisting of two main groups of variants, one of which was formed by variants closely related to the parental sequence. The evolution rate exhibited by PLMVd, considerably higher than that reported for potato spindle tuber viroid, may contribute to the fluctuating symptomatology of the severe PLMVd natural isolates. However, the polymorphism observed in PLMVd progenies does preserve some structural and functional elements previously proposed for this viroid, supporting the fact that they act as constraints limiting the genetic divergence of PLMVd quasispecies generated de novo.