Regulator-dependent temporal dynamics of a restriction-modification system's gene expression upon entering new host cells: single-cell and population studies

Lethal perturbation of an Escherichia coli regulatory network is triggered by a restriction-modification system's regulator and can be mitigated by excision of the cryptic prophage Rac

Bacterial gene regulatory networks orchestrate responses to environmental challenges. Horizontal gene transfer can bring in genes with regulatory potential, such as new transcription factors (TFs), and this can disrupt existing networks. Serious regulatory perturbations may even result in cell death. Here, we show the impact on Escherichia coli of importing a promiscuous TF that has adventitious transcriptional effects within the cryptic Rac prophage. A cascade of regulatory network perturbations occurred on a global level. The TF, a C regulatory protein, normally controls a Type II restriction-modification system, but in E. coli K-12 interferes with expression of the RacR repressor gene, resulting in de-repression of the normally-silent Rac ydaT gene. YdaT is a prophage-encoded TF with pleiotropic effects on E. coli physiology. In turn, YdaT alters expression of a variety of bacterial regulons normally controlled by the RcsA TF, resulting in deficient lipopolysaccharide biosynthesis and cell division. At the same time, insufficient RacR repressor results in Rac DNA excision, halting Rac gene expression due to loss of the replication-defective Rac prophage. Overall, Rac induction appears to counteract the lethal toxicity of YdaT. We show here that E. coli rewires its regulatory network, so as to minimize the adverse regulatory effects of the imported C TF. This complex set of interactions may reflect the ability of bacteria to protect themselves by having robust mechanisms to maintain their regulatory networks, and/or suggest that regulatory C proteins from mobile operons are under selection to manipulate their host's regulatory networks for their own benefit.

Methylome evolution suggests lineage-dependent selection in the gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori

The bacterial pathogen Helicobacter pylori, the leading cause of gastric cancer, is genetically highly diverse and harbours a large and variable portfolio of restriction-modification systems. Our understanding of the evolution and function of DNA methylation in bacteria is limited. Here, we performed a comprehensive analysis of the methylome diversity in H. pylori, using a dataset of 541 genomes that included all known phylogeographic populations. The frequency of 96 methyltransferases and the abundance of their cognate recognition sequences were strongly influenced by phylogeographic structure and were inter-correlated, positively or negatively, for 20% of type II methyltransferases. Low density motifs were more likely to be affected by natural selection, as reflected by higher genomic instability and compositional bias. Importantly, direct correlation implied that methylation patterns can be actively enriched by positive selection and suggests that specific sites have important functions in methylation-dependent phenotypes. Finally, we identified lineage-specific selective pressures modulating the contraction and expansion of the motif ACGT, revealing that the genetic load of methylation could be dependent on local ecological factors. Taken together, natural selection may shape both the abundance and distribution of methyltransferases and their specific recognition sequences, likely permitting a fine-tuning of genome-encoded functions not achievable by genetic variation alone.

DNA Methylation and RNA-DNA Hybrids Regulate the Single-Molecule Localization of a DNA Methyltransferase on the Bacterial Nucleoid

Bacterial DNA methyltransferases (MTases) function in restriction modification systems, cell cycle control, and the regulation of gene expression. DnmA is a recently described DNA MTase that forms N6-methyladenosine at nonpalindromic 5'-GACGAG-3' sites in Bacillus subtilis, yet how DnmA activity is regulated is unknown. To address DnmA regulation, we tested substrate binding in vitro and found that DnmA binds poorly to methylated DNA and to an RNA-DNA hybrid with the DNA recognition sequence. Further, DnmA variants with amino acid substitutions that disrupt cognate sequence recognition or catalysis also bind poorly to DNA. Using superresolution fluorescence microscopy and single-molecule tracking of DnmA-PAmCherry, we characterized the subcellular DnmA diffusion and detected its preferential localization to the replisome region and the nucleoid. Under conditions where the chromosome is highly methylated, upon RNA-DNA hybrid accumulation, or with a DnmA variant with severely limited DNA binding activity, DnmA is excluded from the nucleoid, demonstrating that prior methylation or accumulation of RNA-DNA hybrids regulates the association of DnmA with the chromosome in vivo. Furthermore, despite the high percentage of methylated recognition sites and the proximity to putative endonuclease genes conserved across bacterial species, we find that DnmA fails to protect B. subtilis against phage predation, suggesting that DnmA is functionally an orphan MTase involved in regulating gene expression. Our work explores the regulation of a bacterial DNA MTase and identifies prior methylation and RNA-DNA hybrids as regulators of MTase localization. These MTase regulatory features could be common across biology. IMPORTANCE DNA methyltransferases (MTases) influence gene expression, cell cycle control, and host defense through DNA modification. Predicted MTases are pervasive across bacterial genomes, but the vast majority remain uncharacterized. Here, we show that in the soil microorganism Bacillus subtilis, the DNA MTase dnmA and neighboring genes are remnants of a phage defense system that no longer protects against phage predation. This result suggests that portions of the bacterial methylome may originate from inactive restriction modification systems that have maintained methylation activity. Analysis of DnmA movement in vivo shows that active DnmA localizes in the nucleoid, suggesting that DnmA can search for recognition sequences throughout the nucleoid region with some preference for the replisome. Our results further show that prior DNA methylation and RNA-DNA hybrids regulate DnmA dynamics and nucleoid localization, providing new insight into how DNA methylation is coordinated within the cellular environment.

Unveil the Secret of the Bacteria and Phage Arms Race

Bacteria have developed different mechanisms to defend against phages, such as preventing phages from being adsorbed on the surface of host bacteria; through the superinfection exclusion (Sie) block of phage's nucleic acid injection; by restricting modification (R-M) systems, CRISPR-Cas, aborting infection (Abi) and other defense systems to interfere with the replication of phage genes in the host; through the quorum sensing (QS) enhancement of phage's resistant effect. At the same time, phages have also evolved a variety of counter-defense strategies, such as degrading extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) that mask receptors or recognize new receptors, thereby regaining the ability to adsorb host cells; modifying its own genes to prevent the R-M systems from recognizing phage genes or evolving proteins that can inhibit the R-M complex; through the gene mutation itself, building nucleus-like compartments or evolving anti-CRISPR (Acr) proteins to resist CRISPR-Cas systems; and by producing antirepressors or blocking the combination of autoinducers (AIs) and its receptors to suppress the QS. The arms race between bacteria and phages is conducive to the coevolution between bacteria and phages. This review details bacterial anti-phage strategies and anti-defense strategies of phages and will provide basic theoretical support for phage therapy while deeply understanding the interaction mechanism between bacteria and phages.

Synergy and regulation of antiphage systems: toward the existence of a bacterial immune system?

Bacteria encode a vast repertoire of diverse antiphage defense systems. Recent studies revealed that different defense systems are often encoded within the same genome, raising the question of their possible interactions in a cell. Here, we review the known synergies and coregulations of antiphage systems. The emerging complexities suggest a potential existence of an additional level of organization of antiviral defense in prokaryotes. We argue that this organization could be compared with immune systems of animals and plants. We discuss this concept and explore what it could mean in bacteria.

Cells with stochastically increased methyltransferase to restriction endonuclease ratio provide an entry for bacteriophage into protected cell population

The action of Type II restriction-modification (RM) systems depends on restriction endonuclease (REase), which cleaves foreign DNA at specific sites, and methyltransferase (MTase), which protects host genome from restriction by methylating the same sites. We here show that protection from phage infection increases as the copy number of plasmids carrying the Type II RM Esp1396I system is increased. However, since increased plasmid copy number leads to both increased absolute intracellular RM enzyme levels and to a decreased MTase/REase ratio, it is impossible to determine which factor determines resistance/susceptibility to infection. By controlled expression of individual Esp1396I MTase or REase genes in cells carrying the Esp1396I system, we show that a shift in the MTase to REase ratio caused by overproduction of MTase or REase leads, respectively, to decreased or increased protection from infection. Consistently, due to stochastic variation of MTase and REase amount in individual cells, bacterial cells that are productively infected by bacteriophage have significantly higher MTase to REase ratios than cells that ward off the infection. Our results suggest that cells with transiently increased MTase to REase ratio at the time of infection serve as entry points for unmodified phage DNA into protected bacterial populations.

Heterogeneity of Subcellular Diffusion in Bacteria Based on Spatial Segregation of Ribosomes and Nucleoids

It has long become clear that in spite of generally lacking internal membrane systems, bacteria contain well-structured subcellular structures of usually filamentous proteins, and a preferred 3D arrangement of their chromosome(s). Some of these systems are set up by so-called cytoskeletal elements, or by polar landmark proteins, but the mechanism of specific localization is still unclear in most cases. Intriguingly, apart from such spatially organizing systems, the bacterial cytoplasm has unusual properties in terms of the diffusion of molecules, which varies between different sites within the cell. In many bacteria, chromosomes are compacted into centrally located nucleoids, being orderly folded as opposed to consisting of random coils of DNA. In these bacteria, there is a separation of transcription and translation, such that transcription by RNA polymerase occurs on the nucleoids, and translation takes place mostly at the cell poles and directly underneath the cell membrane, because 70S ribosomes accumulate at sites surrounding the nucleoids. Interestingly, accumulation of ribosomes appears to slow down diffusion of enzymes, noticeable for larger enzyme complexes, while nucleoids provide areas of confined motion for DNA-binding proteins, yet acceleration zones for non-DNA-binding proteins. Crowded regions at the cell poles set up zones of higher concentration of the translation machinery, shortening diffusion distances for rate-limiting translation factor/ribosome interactions, and of metabolic enzymes, possibly speeding up pathways containing low concentrations of metabolites. Thus, heterogeneous diffusion adds another layer of subcellular organization on top of cytoskeletal elements.