Differential evolution of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae DUP240 paralogs and implication of recombination in phylogeny

Chapter 6: The genomes of lager yeasts

Yeasts used in the production of lagers belong to the genus Saccharomyces pastorianus. Species within this genus arose from a natural hybridization event between two yeast species that appear to be closely related to Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces bayanus. The resultant hybrids contain complex allopolyploid genomes and retain genetic characteristics of both parental species. Recent genome analysis using both whole genome sequencing and competitive genomic hybridization techniques has revealed the underlying composition of lager yeasts genomes. There appear to be at least 36 unique chromosomes, many of which are lager specific, resulting from recombination events between the homeologous parental chromosomes. The recombination events are limited to a defined set of genetic loci, which are highly conserved within strains of lager yeasts. In addition to the hybrid chromosomes, several non-reciprocal chromosomal translocations and inversions are also observed. Remarkably, in response to exposure to environmental stresses such as high temperatures and high osmotic pressure, the genomes appear to be highly dynamic and undergo recombination events at defined loci and alterations in the telomeric regions. The ability of environmental stress to alter the structure and composition of the genomes of lager yeasts may point to mechanisms of adaptive evolution in these species.

Lager yeasts possess dynamic genomes that undergo rearrangements and gene amplification in response to stress

A long-term goal of the brewing industry is to identify yeast strains with increased tolerance to the stresses experienced during the brewing process. We have characterised the genomes of a number of stress-tolerant mutants, derived from the lager yeast strain CMBS-33, that were selected for tolerance to high temperatures and to growth in high specific gravity wort. Our results indicate that the heat-tolerant strains have undergone a number of gross chromosomal rearrangements when compared to the parental strain. To determine if such rearrangements can spontaneously arise in response to exposure to stress conditions experienced during the brewing process, we examined the chromosome integrity of both the stress-tolerant strains and their parent during a single round of fermentation under a variety of environmental stresses. Our results show that the lager yeast genome shows tremendous plasticity during fermentation, especially when fermentations are carried out in high specific gravity wort and at higher than normal temperatures. Many localised regions of gene amplification were observed especially at the telomeres and at the rRNA gene locus on chromosome XII, and general chromosomal instability was evident. However, gross chromosomal rearrangements were not detected, indicating that continued selection in the stress conditions are required to obtain clonal isolates with stable rearrangements. Taken together, the data suggest that lager yeasts display a high degree of genomic plasticity and undergo genomic changes in response to environmental stress.

Spontaneous deletions and reciprocal translocations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: influence of ploidy

Studying spontaneous chromosomal rearrangements throws light on the rules underlying the genome reshaping events occurring in eukaryotic cells, which are part of the evolutionary process. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, translocation and deletion processes have been frequently described in haploids, but little is known so far about these processes at the diploid level. Here we investigated the nature and the frequency of the chromosomal rearrangements occurring at this ploidy level. Using a positive selection screen based on a particular mutated allele of the URA2 gene, spontaneous diploid revertants were selected and analysed. Surprisingly, the diploid state was found to be correlated with a decrease in chromosome rearrangement frequency, along with an increase in the complexity of the rearrangements occurring in the target gene. The presence of short DNA tandem repeat sequences seems to be a key requirement for deletion and reciprocal translocation processes to occur in diploids. After discussing the differences between the haploid and diploid levels, some mechanisms possibly involved in chromosome shortening and arm exchange are suggested.

Concerted and birth-and-death evolution of multigene families

Until around 1990, most multigene families were thought to be subject to concerted evolution, in which all member genes of a family evolve as a unit in concert. However, phylogenetic analysis of MHC and other immune system genes showed a quite different evolutionary pattern, and a new model called birth-and-death evolution was proposed. In this model, new genes are created by gene duplication and some duplicate genes stay in the genome for a long time, whereas others are inactivated or deleted from the genome. Later investigations have shown that most non-rRNA genes including highly conserved histone or ubiquitin genes are subject to this type of evolution. However, the controversy over the two models is still continuing because the distinction between the two models becomes difficult when sequence differences are small. Unlike concerted evolution, the model of birth-and-death evolution can give some insights into the origins of new genetic systems or new phenotypic characters.

Yeast evolution and comparative genomics

Recent sequencing efforts and experiments have advanced our understanding of genome evolution in yeasts, particularly the Saccharomyces yeasts. The ancestral genome of the Saccharomyces sensu stricto complex has been subject to both whole-genome duplication, followed by massive sequence loss and divergence, and segmental duplication. In addition the subtelomeric regions are subject to further duplications and rearrangements via ectopic exchanges. Translocations and other gross chromosomal rearrangements that break down syntenic relationships occur; however, they do not appear to be a driving force of speciation. Analysis of single genomes has been fruitful for hypothesis generation such as the whole-genome duplication, but comparative genomics between close and more distant species has proven to be a powerful tool in testing these hypotheses as well as elucidating evolutionary processes acting on the genome. Future work on population genomics and experimental evolution will keep yeast at the forefront of studies in genome evolution.

An evolutionary scenario for one of the largest yeast gene families

The DUP gene family of Saccharomyces cerevisiae comprises 23 members that can be divided into two subfamilies--DUP240 and DUP380. The location of the DUP loci suggests that at least three mechanisms were responsible for their genomic dispersion: nonreciprocal translocation at chromosomal ends, tandem duplication and Ty-associated duplication. The data we present here suggest that these nonessential genes encode proteins that facilitate membrane trafficking processes. Dup240 proteins have three conserved domains (C1, C2 and C3) and two predicted transmembrane segments (H1 and H2). A direct repetition of the C1-H1-H2-C2 module is observed in Dup380p sequences. In this article, we propose an evolutionary model to account for the emergence of the two gene subfamilies.

Paleogenomics or the Search for Remnant Duplicated Copies of the Yeast DUP240 Gene Family in Intergenic Areas

Duplication, resulting in gene redundancy, is well known to be a driving force of evolutionary change. Gene families are therefore useful targets for approaching genome evolution. To address the gene death process, we examined the fate of the 10-member-large S288C DUP240 family in 15 Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains. Using an original three-step method of analysis reported here, both slightly and highly degenerate DUP240 copies, called pseudo-open reading frames (ORFs) and relics, respectively, were detected in strain S288C. It was concluded that two previously annotated ORFs correspond, in fact, to pseudo-ORFs and three additional relics were identified in intergenic areas. Comparative intraspecies analysis of these degenerate DUP240 loci revealed that the two pseudo-ORFs are present in a nondegenerate state in some other strains. This suggests that within a given gene family different loci are the target of the gene erasure process, which is therefore strain dependent. Besides, the variable positions observed indicate that the relic sequence may diverge faster than the flanking regions. All in all, this study shows that short conserved protein motifs provide a useful tool for detecting and accurately mapping degenerate gene remnants. The present results also highlight the strong contribution of comparative genomics for gene relic detection because the possibility of finding short conserved protein motifs in intergenic regions (IRs) largely depends on the choice of the most closely related paralog or ortholog. By mapping new genetic components in previously annotated IRs, our study constitutes a further refinement step in the crucial stage of genome annotation and provides a strategy for retracing ancient chromosomal reshaping events and, hence, for deciphering genome history.

Expansion and contraction of the DUP240 multigene family in Saccharomyces cerevisiae populations

The influence of duplicated sequences on chromosomal stability is poorly understood. To characterize chromosomal rearrangements involving duplicated sequences, we compared the organization of tandem repeats of the DUP240 gene family in 15 Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains of various origins. The DUP240 gene family consists of 10 members of unknown function in the reference strain S288C. Five DUP240 paralogs on chromosome I and two on chromosome VII are arranged as tandem repeats that are highly polymorphic in copy number and sequence. We characterized DNA sequences that are likely involved in homologous or nonhomologous recombination events and are responsible for intra- and interchromosomal rearrangements that cause the creation and disappearance of DUP240 paralogs. The tandemly repeated DUP240 genes seem to be privileged sites of gene birth and death.