A bacterial three-hybrid assay detects Escherichia coli Hfq-sRNA interactions in vivo

Generation of single-cysteine E. coli ProQ variants to study RNA-protein interaction mechanisms

ProQ is a FinO-domain protein found in E. coli and other proteobacteria that has a global RNA-binding profile. In order to probe the detailed mechanism of RNA interactions, we have developed a collection of 13 E. coli ProQ variants that possess single-cysteine residues at varied positions on the surface of the N-terminal FinO domain and retain the ability to bind well to RNA. This set of variant ProQ proteins will support future biochemical and biophysical studies to map the orientation of bound RNAs to different sites around the ProQ protein, shedding light on the mechanism of ProQ-RNA interactions.

Biochemical and genetic dissection of the RNA-binding surface of the FinO domain of Escherichia coli ProQ

RNA-binding proteins play important roles in bacterial gene regulation through interactions with both coding and noncoding RNAs. ProQ is a FinO-domain protein that binds a large set of RNAs in Escherichia coli, though the details of how ProQ binds these RNAs remain unclear. In this study, we used a combination of in vivo and in vitro binding assays to confirm key structural features of E. coli ProQ's FinO domain and explore its mechanism of RNA interactions. Using a bacterial three-hybrid assay, we performed forward genetic screens to confirm the importance of the concave face of ProQ in RNA binding. Using gel shift assays, we directly probed the contributions of ten amino acids on ProQ binding to seven RNA targets. Certain residues (R58, Y70, and R80) were found to be essential for binding of all seven RNAs, while substitutions of other residues (K54 and R62) caused more moderate binding defects. Interestingly, substitutions of two amino acids (K35, R69), which are evolutionarily variable but adjacent to conserved residues, showed varied effects on the binding of different RNAs; these may arise from the differing sequence context around each RNA's terminator hairpin. Together, this work confirms many of the essential RNA-binding residues in ProQ initially identified in vivo and supports a model in which residues on the conserved concave face of the FinO domain such as R58, Y70, and R80 form the main RNA-binding site of E. coli ProQ, while additional contacts contribute to the binding of certain RNAs.

Biochemical and genetic dissection of the RNA-binding surface of the FinO domain of Escherichia coli ProQ

RNA-binding proteins play important roles in bacterial gene regulation through interactions with both coding and non-coding RNAs. ProQ is a FinO-domain protein that binds a large set of RNAs in Escherichia coli , though the details of how ProQ binds these RNAs remain unclear. In this study, we used a combination of in vivo and in vitro binding assays to confirm key structural features of E. coli ProQ's FinO domain and explore its mechanism of RNA interactions. Using a bacterial three-hybrid assay, we performed forward genetic screens to confirm the importance of the concave face of ProQ in RNA binding. Using gel shift assays, we directly probed the contributions of ten amino acids on ProQ binding to seven RNA targets. Certain residues (R58, Y70, and R80) were found to be essential for binding of all seven RNAs, while substitutions of other residues (K54 and R62) caused more moderate binding defects. Interestingly, substitutions of two amino acids (K35, R69), which are evolutionarily variable but adjacent to conserved residues, showed varied effects on the binding of different RNAs; these may arise from the differing sequence context around each RNA's terminator hairpin. Together, this work confirms many of the essential RNA-binding residues in ProQ initially identified in vivo and supports a model in which residues on the conserved concave face of the FinO domain such as R58, Y70 and R80 form the main RNA-binding site of E. coli ProQ, while additional contacts contribute to the binding of certain RNAs.

A translational repression reporter assay for the analysis of RNA-binding protein consensus sites

RNA-binding proteins are essential regulators of RNA processing and function. Translational repression assays can be used to study how they interact with specific RNA sequences by insertion of such a consensus sequence into the 5' untranslated region of a reporter mRNA and measuring reporter protein translation. The straightforward set-up of these translational repression assays avoids the need for the isolation of the protein or the RNA providing speed, robustness and a low-cost method. Here, we report the optimization of the assay to function with linear RNA sequences instead of the previously reported hairpin type sequences to allow the study of a wider variety of RNA-binding proteins. Multiplication of a consensus sequence strongly improves the signal allowing analysis by both fluorescence intensity measurements and flow cytometry.

A bacterial three-hybrid assay for forward and reverse genetic analysis of RNA-protein interactions

This protocol describes a bacterial three-hybrid (B3H) assay, an in vivo system that reports on RNA-protein interactions and can be implemented in both forward and reverse genetic experiments. The B3H assay connects the strength of an RNA-protein interaction inside of living Escherichia coli cells to the transcription of a reporter gene (here, lacZ). We present protocols to (1) insert RNA and protein sequences into appropriate vectors for B3H experiments, (2) detect putative RNA-protein interactions with both qualitative and quantitative readouts and (3) carry out forward genetic mutagenesis screens. The B3H assay builds on a well-established bacterial two-hybrid system for genetic analyses. As a result, protein-protein interactions can be assessed in tandem with RNA interactions with a bacterial two-hybrid assay to ensure that protein variants maintain their functionality. The B3H system is a powerful complement to traditional biochemical methods for dissecting RNA-protein interaction mechanisms: RNAs and proteins of interest do not need to be purified, and their interactions can be assessed under native conditions inside of a living bacterial cell. Once cloning has been completed, an assay can be completed in under a week and a screen in 1-2 weeks.

Identification of host factors binding to dengue and Zika virus subgenomic RNA by efficient yeast three-hybrid screens of the human ORFeome

Flaviviruses such as the dengue (DENV) and the Zika virus (ZIKV) are important human pathogens causing around 100 million symptomatic infections each year. During infection, small subgenomic flavivirus RNAs (sfRNAs) are formed inside the infected host cell as a result of incomplete degradation of the viral RNA genome by cellular exoribonuclease XRN1. Although the full extent of sfRNA functions is to be revealed, these non-coding RNAs are key virulence factors and their detrimental effects on multiple cellular processes seem to consistently involve molecular interactions with RNA-binding proteins (RBPs). Discovery of such sfRNA-binding host-factors has followed established biochemical pull-down approaches skewed towards highly abundant proteins hampering proteome-wide coverage. Yeast three-hybrid (Y3H) systems represent an attractive alternative approach. To facilitate proteome-wide screens for RBP, we revisited and improved existing RNA-Y3H methodology by (1) implementing full-length ORF libraries in combination with (2) efficient yeast mating to increase screening depth and sensitivity, and (3) stringent negative controls to eliminate over-representation of non-specific RNA-binders. These improvements were validated employing the well-characterized interaction between DDX6 (DEAD-box helicase 6) and sfRNA of DENV as paradigm. Our advanced Y3H system was used to screen for human proteins binding to DENV and ZIKV sfRNA, resulting in a list of 69 putative sfRNA-binders, including several previously reported as well as numerous novel RBP host factors. Our methodology requiring no sophisticated infrastructure or analytic pipeline may be employed for the discovery of meaningful RNA-protein interactions at large scale in other fields.

Optimization of a bacterial three-hybrid assay through in vivo titration of an RNA-DNA adapter protein

Noncoding RNAs regulate gene expression in every domain of life. In bacteria, small RNAs (sRNAs) regulate gene expression in response to stress and are often assisted by RNA-chaperone proteins, such as Hfq. We have recently developed a bacterial three-hybrid (B3H) assay that detects the strong binding interactions of certain E. coli sRNAs with proteins Hfq and ProQ. Despite the promise of this system, the signal-to-noise has made it challenging to detect weaker interactions. In this work, we use Hfq-sRNA interactions as a model system to optimize the B3H assay, so that weaker RNA-protein interactions can be more reliably detected. We find that the concentration of the RNA-DNA adapter is an important parameter in determining the signal in the system and have modified the plasmid expressing this component to tune its concentration to optimal levels. In addition, we have systematically perturbed the binding affinity of Hfq-RNA interactions to define, for the first time, the relationship between B3H signal and in vitro binding energetics. The new pAdapter construct presented here substantially expands the range of detectable interactions in the B3H assay, broadening its utility. This improved assay will increase the likelihood of identifying novel protein-RNA interactions with the B3H system and will facilitate exploration of the binding mechanisms of these interactions.

Determinants of RNA recognition by the FinO domain of the Escherichia coli ProQ protein

The regulation of gene expression by small RNAs in Escherichia coli depends on RNA binding proteins Hfq and ProQ, which bind mostly distinct RNA pools. To understand how ProQ discriminates between RNA substrates, we compared its binding to six different RNA molecules. Full-length ProQ bound all six RNAs similarly, while the isolated N-terminal FinO domain (NTD) of ProQ specifically recognized RNAs with Rho-independent terminators. Analysis of malM 3′-UTR mutants showed that tight RNA binding by the ProQ NTD required a terminator hairpin of at least 2 bp preceding an 3′ oligoU tail of at least four uridine residues. Substitution of an A-rich sequence on the 5′ side of the terminator to uridines strengthened the binding of several ProQ-specific RNAs to the Hfq protein, but not to the ProQ NTD. Substitution of the motif in the malM-3′ and cspE-3′ RNAs also conferred the ability to bind Hfq in E. coli cells, as measured using a three-hybrid assay. In summary, these data suggest that the ProQ NTD specifically recognizes 3′ intrinsic terminators of RNA substrates, and that the discrimination between RNA ligands by E. coli ProQ and Hfq depends both on positive determinants for binding to ProQ and negative determinants against binding to Hfq.

Genetic identification of the functional surface for RNA binding by Escherichia coli ProQ

The FinO-domain-protein ProQ is an RNA-binding protein that has been known to play a role in osmoregulation in proteobacteria. Recently, ProQ has been shown to act as a global RNA-binding protein in Salmonella and Escherichia coli, binding to dozens of small RNAs (sRNAs) and messenger RNAs (mRNAs) to regulate mRNA-expression levels through interactions with both 5′ and 3′ untranslated regions (UTRs). Despite excitement around ProQ as a novel global RNA-binding protein, and its potential to serve as a matchmaking RNA chaperone, significant gaps remain in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms ProQ uses to interact with RNA. In order to apply the tools of molecular genetics to this question, we have adapted a bacterial three-hybrid (B3H) assay to detect ProQ’s interactions with target RNAs. Using domain truncations, site-directed mutagenesis and an unbiased forward genetic screen, we have identified a group of highly conserved residues on ProQ’s NTD as the primary face for in vivo recognition of two RNAs, and propose that the NTD structure serves as an electrostatic scaffold to recognize the shape of an RNA duplex.

The Development of RNA-KISS, a Mammalian Three-Hybrid Method to Detect RNA-Protein Interactions in Living Mammalian Cells

RNA-protein interactions are essential for the regulation of mRNA and noncoding RNA functions and are implicated in many diseases, such as cancer and neurodegenerative disorders. A method that can detect RNA-protein interactions in living mammalian cells on a proteome-wide scale will be an important asset to identify and study these interactions. Here we show that a combination of the mammalian two-hybrid protein-protein detection method KISS (kinase substrate sensor) and the yeast RNA three-hybrid method, utilizing the specific interaction between the MS2 RNA and MS2 coat protein, is capable of detecting RNA-protein interactions in living mammalian cells. For conceptional proof we used the subgenomic flavivirus RNA (sfRNA) of the dengue virus (DENV), a highly structured noncoding RNA derived from the DENV genome known to target host cell proteins involved in innate immunity and antiviral defense, as bait. Using RNA-KISS, we could confirm the previously established interaction between the RNA-binding domain of DDX6 and the DENV sfRNA. Finally, we performed a human proteome-wide screen for DENV sfRNA-binding host factors, identifying several known flavivirus host factors such as DDX6 and PACT, further validating the RNA-KISS method as a robust and high-throughput cell-based RNA-protein interaction screening tool.

The binding of Class II sRNA MgrR to two different sites on matchmaker protein Hfq enables efficient competition for Hfq and annealing to regulated mRNAs

MgrR is an Hfq-dependent sRNA, whose transcription is controlled by the level of Mg²⁺ ions in Escherichia coli MgrR belongs to Class II sRNAs because its stability in the cell is affected by mutations in Hfq differently than canonical, Class I sRNAs. Here, we examined the effect of mutations in RNA binding sites of Hfq on the kinetics of the annealing of MgrR to two different target mRNAs, eptB and ygdQ, by global data fitting of the reaction kinetics monitored by gel electrophoresis of intermediates and products. The data showed that the mutation on the rim of the Hfq ring trapped MgrR on Hfq preventing the annealing of MgrR to either mRNA. The mutation in the distal face slowed the ternary complex formation and affected the release of MgrR-mRNA complexes from Hfq, while the mutation in the proximal face weakened the MgrR binding to Hfq and in this way affected the annealing. Moreover, competition assays established that MgrR bound to both faces of Hfq and competed against other sRNAs. Further studies showed that uridine-rich sequences located in less structurally stable regions served as Hfq binding sites in each mRNA. Overall, the data show that the binding of MgrR sRNA to both faces of the Hfq ring enables it to efficiently anneal to target mRNAs. It also confers on MgrR a competitive advantage over other sRNAs, which could contribute to efficient cellular response to changes in magnesium homeostasis.