A renal disease frequently found at postmortem, but rarely diagnosed in vivo

Cholesterol Crystal Embolism and Chronic Kidney Disease

Renal disease caused by cholesterol crystal embolism (CCE) occurs when cholesterol crystals become lodged in small renal arteries after small pieces of atheromatous plaques break off from the aorta or renal arteries and shower the downstream vascular bed. CCE is a multisystemic disease but kidneys are particularly vulnerable to atheroembolic disease, which can cause an acute, subacute, or chronic decline in renal function. This life-threatening disease may be underdiagnosed and overlooked as a cause of chronic kidney disease (CKD) among patients with advanced atherosclerosis. CCE can result from vascular surgery, angiography, or administration of anticoagulants. Atheroembolic renal disease has various clinical features that resemble those found in other kidney disorders and systemic diseases. It is commonly misdiagnosed in clinic, but confirmed by characteristic renal biopsy findings. Therapeutic options are limited, and prognosis is considered to be poor. Expanding knowledge of atheroembolic renal disease due to CCE opens perspectives for recognition, diagnosis, and treatment of this cause of progressive renal insufficiency.

The challenge of diagnosing atheroembolic renal disease: clinical features and prognostic factors

BACKGROUND

Atheroembolic renal disease (AERD) is caused by showers of cholesterol crystals released by eroded atherosclerotic plaques. Embolization may occur spontaneously or after angiographic/surgical procedures. We sought to determine clinical features and prognostic factors of AERD.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Incident cases of AERD were enrolled at multiple sites and followed up from diagnosis until dialysis and death. Diagnosis was based on clinical suspicion, confirmed by histology or ophthalmoscopy for all spontaneous forms and for most iatrogenic cases. Cox regression was used to model time to dialysis and death as a function of baseline characteristics, AERD presentation (acute/subacute versus chronic renal function decline), and extrarenal manifestations. Three hundred fifty-four subjects were followed up for an average of 2 years. They tended to be male (83%) and elderly (60% >70 years) and to have cardiovascular diseases (90%) and abnormal renal function at baseline (83%). AERD occurred spontaneously in 23.5% of the cases. During the study, 116 patients required dialysis, and 102 died. Baseline comorbidities, ie, reduced renal function, presence of diabetes, history of heart failure, acute/subacute presentation, and gastrointestinal tract involvement, were significant predictors of event occurrence. The risk of dialysis and death was 50% lower among those receiving statins.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinical features of AERD are identifiable. These make diagnosis possible in most cases. Prognosis is influenced by disease type and severity.

Systemic cholesterol embolization syndrome associated with myeloperoxidase-anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody

A 75-year-old man was transferred to our department because of development of severe renal impairment after coronary artery bypass grafting. Hemodialysis was initiated for postsurgical oliguria and lung congestion. On transfer, he showed systemic purpura rashes and diffuse blue mottlings on his toes with marked eosinophilia and an elevated level of C-reactive protein. Cutaneous biopsy revealed cholesterol crystal embolism and leukocytoclastic vasculitis in dermal arterioles. Myeloperoxidase-anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody titer was increased. Upon oral corticosteroid therapy following intravenous pulse steroid therapy, the purpura dramatically diminished, renal function improved, and hemodialysis was discontinued. Active treatment with corticosteroids may be effective for cholesterol embolization syndrome, particularly when clinical and laboratory manifestations mimic systemic vasculitis.

Contrast medium-induced acute renal failure and cholesterol embolism after radiological procedures: incidence, risk factors, and compliance with recommendations

BACKGROUND: After radiological procedures, the incidence of acute renal failure varies greatly, and cholesterol embolism may not always be recognized. Little, if anything, is known about whether recommendations for the prevention of either complication are correctly implemented. METHODS: We performed a prospective epidemiological study in a large population (n=809) of consecutive inpatients in a university hospital. The patients were monitored for risk factors, ongoing medications, and details of preventive measures and of radiological procedures. Contrast nephropathy was defined as a 25% rise in serum creatinine. Cholesterol embolism was defined by the presence of two typical signs. We analyzed the incidence, risk factors, and prevention of contrast nephropathy and cholesterol embolism. RESULTS: The most frequent procedure that our patients underwent was cardiac angiography (50%). The incidence of contrast nephropathy was 7%. We confirmed the classical risk factors (diabetes, dose of contrast medium, and renal insufficiency) and added potentially nephrotoxic medications as an independent risk factor. Fluid therapy, commonly proposed in high-risk patients, was adequately carried out in only 12% of patients. The incidence of cholesterol embolism was 4%, with 10% renal involvement. Arteriosclerosis and renal insufficiency were risk factors, but anticoagulation therapy was not. CONCLUSION: Adequate fluid therapy and discontinuation of nephrotoxic medications should be more systematically implemented in the prevention of contrast nephropathy. Recognition of cholesterol embolism is crucial.

Predictors of renal and patient outcomes in atheroembolic renal disease: a prospective study

Atheroembolic renal disease (AERD) is part of a multisystemic disease accompanied by high cardiovascular comorbidity and mortality. Interrelationships between traditional risk factors for atherosclerosis, vascular comorbidities, precipitating factors, and markers of clinical severity of the disease in determining outcome remain poorly understood. Patients with AERD presenting to a single center between 1996 and 2002 were followed-up with prospective collection of clinical and biochemical data. The major outcomes included end-stage renal disease (ESRD) and death. Ninety-five patients were identified (81 male). AERD was iatrogenic in 87%. Mean age was 71.4 yr. Twenty-three patients (24%) developed ESRD; 36 patients (37.9%) died. Cox regression analysis showed that significant independent predictors of ESRD were long-standing hypertension (hazard ratio [HR] = 1.1; P < 0.001) and preexisting chronic renal impairment (HR = 2.12; P = 0.02); use of statins was independently associated with decreased risk of ESRD (HR = 0.02; P = 0.003). Age (HR = 1.09; P = 0.009), diabetes (HR = 2.55; P = 0.034), and ESRD (HR = 2.21; P = 0.029) were independent risk factors for patient mortality; male gender was independently associated with decreased risk of death (HR = 0.27; P = 0.007). Cardiovascular comorbidities, precipitating factors, and clinical severity of AERD had no prognostic impact on renal and patient survival. It is concluded that AERD has a strong clinical impact on patient and renal survival. The study clearly shows the importance of preexisting chronic renal impairment in determining both renal and patient outcome, this latter being mediated by the development of ESRD. The protective effect of statins on the development of ESRD should be evaluated in a prospective study.

Cholesterol crystal embolism: A recognizable cause of renal disease

Cholesterol crystal embolism, sometimes separately designated atheroembolism, is an increasing and still underdiagnosed cause of renal dysfunction antemortem in elderly patients. Renal cholesterol crystal embolization, also known as atheroembolic renal disease, is caused by showers of cholesterol crystals from an atherosclerotic aorta that occlude small renal arteries. Although cholesterol crystal embolization can occur spontaneously, it is increasingly recognized as an iatrogenic complication from an invasive vascular procedure, such as manipulation of the aorta during angiography or vascular surgery, and after anticoagulant and fibrinolytic therapy. Cholesterol crystal embolism may give rise to different degrees of renal impairment. Some patients show only a moderate loss of renal function; in others, severe renal failure requiring dialysis ensues. An acute scenario with abrupt and sudden onset of renal failure may be observed. More frequently, a progressive loss of renal function occurs over weeks. A third clinical form of renal atheroemboli has been described, presenting as chronic, stable, and asymptomatic renal insufficiency. The renal outcome may be variable; some patients deteriorate or remain on dialysis, some improve, and some remain with chronic renal impairment. In addition to the kidneys, atheroembolization may involve the skin, gastrointestinal system, and central nervous system. Renal atheroembolic disease is a difficult and controversial diagnosis for the protean extrarenal manifestations of the disease. In the past, the diagnosis was often made postmortem. However, in the last decade, awareness of atheroembolic renal disease has improved, enabling us to make a correct premortem diagnosis in a number of patients. Correct diagnosis requires the clinician to be alert to the possibility. The typical patient is a white man aged older than 60 years with a baseline history of hypertension, smoking, and arterial disease. The presence of a classic triad characterized by a precipitating event, acute or subacute renal failure, and peripheral cholesterol crystal embolization strongly suggests the diagnosis. The confirmatory diagnosis can be made by means of biopsy of the target organs, including kidneys, skin, and the gastrointestinal system. Thus, Cinderella and her shoe now can be well matched during life. Patients with renal atheroemboli have a dismal outlook. A specific treatment is lacking. However, it is an important diagnosis to make because it may save the patient from inappropriate treatment. Finally, recent data suggest that an aggressive therapeutic approach with patient-tailored supportive measures may be associated with a favorable clinical outcome.

Progression of renal failure and hypertensive nephrosclerosis

Data provided by end-stage renal disease (ESRD) registries document a progressive and striking increase in the incidence of hypertension-related ESRD over the years, and its prevalence supports the classic statement that the kidney may be a victim of hypertension. Two clinical conditions should be considered separately when the role of hypertension in progressive renal disease is discussed: (a) hypertension and primary renal disease and (b) progressive renal disease in essential hypertension. The appearance of systemic hypertension is one of the major risk factors for the progressive deterioration of primary renal disease both in experimental models and in humans. Strict blood pressure control is able to significantly reduce the disease progression to renal failure. Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors probably show a better nephroprotective action than other antihypertensive agents. Long-lasting hypertension may induce ESRD in some patients through hypertensive nephrosclerosis. In many cases of progressive renal disease associated with essential hypertension, particularly in elderly Caucasians, atheromatous renovascular disease via renal artery stenosis and/or cholesterol microembolization represent the main cause of ESRD.