Randomized trial of chemotherapy versus chemotherapy plus radiotherapy for stage III-IV A & B Hodgkin's disease

Efficacy and safety of front-line treatments for advanced Hodgkin lymphoma: a systematic literature review

OBJECTIVE

To assess evidence on the safety and efficacy of ABVD (doxorubicin [Adriamycin®], bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine), BEACOPP (bleomycin, etoposide, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone), and A+AVD (brentuximab vedotin, with doxorubicin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine) for advanced-stage Hodgkin lymphoma (HL).

METHODS

A systematic literature review (SLR) was conducted on 29 July 2016 (updated 26 July 2018) to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and non-RCTs assessing the treatment of newly-diagnosed advanced-stage HL with ABVD and BEACOPP (and their variants), and A+AVD.

RESULTS

The SLR identified 62 RCTs and 42 non-RCTs. Five-year overall survival rates for ABVD and BEACOPP were 60-97% and 84-99%, and 5-year progression-free survival rates were 58-81% and 83-96%, respectively. Both regimens were associated with tolerability issues and side effects. Discontinuation or dose reduction of bleomycin resulted in fewer adverse events, without significantly affecting efficacy. A head-to-head trial demonstrated improved efficacy for A+AVD vs ABVD, with an acceptable tolerability profile. No data from head-to-head trials comparing A+AVD with BEACOPP were available, and an indirect treatment comparison was not feasible.

CONCLUSION

New therapies, such as A+AVD, maintain the efficacy observed with current treatments, and may provide a more tolerable treatment option for patients with advanced-stage HL.

Relapse analysis of irradiated patients within the HD15 trial of the German Hodgkin Study Group

PURPOSE

To determine, in the setting of advanced-stage of Hodgkin lymphoma (HL), whether relapses occur in the irradiated planning target volume and whether the definition of local radiation therapy (RT) used by the German Hodgkin Study Group (GHSG) is adequate, because there is no harmonization of field and volume definitions among the large cooperative groups in the treatment of advanced-stage HL.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

All patients with residual disease of ≥ 2.5 cm after multiagent chemotherapy (CTX) were evaluated using additional positron emission tomography (PET), and those with a PET-positive result were irradiated with 30 Gy to the site of residual disease. We re-evaluated all sites of disease before and after CTX, as well as the PET-positive residual tumor that was treated in all relapsed patients. Documentation of radiation therapy (RT), treatment planning procedures, and portal images were carefully analyzed and compared with the centrally recommended RT prescription. The irradiated sites were compared with sites of relapse using follow-up computed tomography scans.

RESULTS

A total of 2126 patients were enrolled, and 225 patients (11%) received RT. Radiation therapy documents of 152 irradiated patients (68%) were analyzed, with 28 irradiated patients (11%) relapsing subsequently. Eleven patients (39%) had an in-field relapse, 7 patients (25%) relapsed outside the irradiated volume, and an additional 10 patients (36%) showed mixed in- and out-field relapses. Of 123 patients, 20 (16%) with adequately performed RT relapsed, compared with 7 of 29 patients (24%) with inadequate RT.

CONCLUSIONS

The frequency and pattern of relapses suggest that local RT to PET-positive residual disease is sufficient for patients in advanced-stage HL. Insufficient safety margins of local RT may contribute to in-field relapses.

The cyclophosphamide equivalent dose as an approach for quantifying alkylating agent exposure: a report from the Childhood Cancer Survivor Study

BACKGROUND

Estimation of the risk of adverse long-term outcomes such as second malignant neoplasms and infertility often requires reproducible quantification of exposures. The method for quantification should be easily utilized and valid across different study populations. The widely used Alkylating Agent Dose (AAD) score is derived from the drug dose distribution of the study population and thus cannot be used for comparisons across populations as each will have a unique distribution of drug doses.

METHODS

We compared the performance of the Cyclophosphamide Equivalent Dose (CED), a unit for quantifying alkylating agent exposure independent of study population, to the AAD. Comparisons included associations from three Childhood Cancer Survivor Study (CCSS) outcome analyses, receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curves and goodness of fit based on the Akaike's Information Criterion (AIC).

RESULTS

The CED and AAD performed essentially identically in analyses of risk for pregnancy among the partners of male CCSS participants, risk for adverse dental outcomes among all CCSS participants and risk for premature menopause among female CCSS participants, based on similar associations, lack of statistically significant differences between the areas under the ROC curves and similar model fit values for the AIC between models including the two measures of exposure.

CONCLUSION

The CED is easily calculated, facilitating its use for patient counseling. It is independent of the drug dose distribution of a particular patient population, a characteristic that will allow direct comparisons of outcomes among epidemiological cohorts. We recommend the use of the CED in future research assessing cumulative alkylating agent exposure.

Second malignancy risk associated with treatment of Hodgkin's lymphoma: meta-analysis of the randomised trials

BACKGROUND

Despite several investigations, second malignancy risks (SMR) following radiotherapy alone (RT), chemotherapy alone (CT) and combined chemoradiotherapy (CRT) for Hodgkin's lymphoma (HL) remain controversial.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We sought individual patient data from randomised trials comparing RT versus CRT, CT versus CRT, RT versus CT or involved-field (IF) versus extended-field (EF) RT for untreated HL. Overall SMR (including effects of salvage treatment) were compared using Peto's method.

RESULTS

Data for between 53% and 69% of patients were obtained for the four comparisons. (i) RT versus CRT (15 trials, 3343 patients): SMR were lower with CRT than with RT as initial treatment (odds ratio (OR) = 0.78, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.62-0.98 and P = 0.03). (ii) CT versus CRT (16 trials, 2861 patients): SMR were marginally higher with CRT than with CT as initial treatment (OR = 1.38, CI 1.00-1.89 and P = 0.05). (iii) IF-RT versus EF-RT (19 trials, 3221 patients): no significant difference in SMR (P = 0.28) although more breast cancers occurred with EF-RT (P = 0.04 and OR = 3.25).

CONCLUSIONS

Administration of CT in addition to RT as initial therapy for HL decreases overall SMR by reducing relapse and need for salvage therapy. Administration of RT additional to CT marginally increases overall SMR in advanced stages. Breast cancer risk (but not SMR in general) was substantially higher after EF-RT. Caution is needed in applying these findings to current therapies.

Long-term results and competing risk analysis of the H89 trial in patients with advanced-stage Hodgkin lymphoma: a study by the Groupe d'Etude des Lymphomes de l'Adulte (GELA)

From 1989 to 1996, 533 eligible patients with stage IIIB/IV Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) were randomly assigned to receive 6 cycles of hybrid MOPP/ABV (mechlorethamine, vincristine, procarbazine, prednisone/Adriamycin [doxorubicin], bleomycin, vinblastine; n = 266) or ABVPP (doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, procarbazine, prednisone; n = 267). Patients in complete remission (CR) or partial response of at least 75% after 6 cycles received 2 cycles of consolidation chemotherapy (CT) (n = 208) or subtotal nodal irradiation (RT) (n = 210). A better survival probability was observed after ABVPP alone: the 10-year overall survival (OS) estimates were 90% for ABVPP×8, 78% for MOPP/ABV×8, 82% for MOPP/ABV with RT, and 77% for ABVPP×6 with RT (P = .03); and the 10-year disease-free survival (DFS) estimates were 70%, 76%, 79%, and 76%, respectively (P = .09). The 10-year DFS estimates for patients treated with consolidation CT or RT were 73% and 78% (P = .07), and OS estimates were 84% and 79%, respectively (P = .29). These results showed that RT was not superior to consolidation CT after a doxorubicin-induced CR in patients with advanced HL. An analysis of competing risks identified age more than 45 years as a significant risk factor for death, relapse, and second cancers. Prospective evaluation of late adverse events may improve the management of patients with HL.

Chemotherapy, radiotherapy and combined modality for Hodgkin's disease, with emphasis on second cancer risk

BACKGROUND

Second malignancies (SM) are a major late effect of treatment for Hodgkin's disease (HD). Reliable comparisons of SM risk between alternative treatment strategies are lacking.

OBJECTIVES

Radiotherapy (RT), chemotherapy (CT) and combined chemo-radiotherapy (CRT) for newly-diagnosed Hodgkin's disease are compared with respect to SM risk, overall (OS) and progression-free (PFS) survival. Further, involved-field (IF-)RT is compared to extended-field (EF-)RT.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, PubMed, EMBASE, CancerLit, LILACS, relevant conference proceedings, trials lists and publications.

SELECTION CRITERIA

RCTs accruing 30+ patients and completing accrual before/during 2000, comparing at least two treatment modalities for newly-diagnosed HD.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Individual patient data were collected and assessed for data quality. Trialists submitted additional information concerning methods and data quality. Peto Odds Ratios (OR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated for OS, PFS and SM-free survival. Secondary acute leukemia (AL), non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) and solid tumours (ST) were also analysed separately.

MAIN RESULTS

37 trials (9312 patients) were analysed: 15 (3343) for RT vs. CRT, 16 (2861) for CT vs. CRT, 3 (415) for RT vs. CT and 10 (3221) for IF-RT vs. EF-RT.CRT was superior to RT in terms of OS (OR=0.76, CI=0.66 to 0.89, p=0.0004), PFS (OR=0.49, CI=0.43 to 0.56, p<0.0001) and SM (OR=0.78. CI=0.62 to 0.98, p=0.03). The superiority of CRT also applied to early and advanced stages (mainly IIIA) separately. Excess SM with RT is due mainly to ST and is apparently caused by greater need for salvage therapy after RT.CRT was superior to CT in terms of PFS (OR=77, CI 0.68 to 0.77, p<0.0001). OS was better with CRT for early stages only (OR=0.62, CI 0.44 to 0.88, p=0.006). SM risk was higher with CRT (OR=1.38, CI 1.00 to 1.89, p=0.05), although not significant for early stages alone. This effect, also seen in AL and ST separately, was due directly to first-line treatment. Data were insufficient to compare RT to CT.EF-RT was superior to IF-RT (each additional to CT in most trials) in terms of PFS (OR=81, CI 0.68 to 0.95, p=0.009) but not OS. No significant difference in SM was observed.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

CRT seems to be optimal for most early stage (I-II) HD patients. For advanced stages (III-IV), CRT better prevents progression/relapse but CT alone seems to cause less SM. RT alone gives a higher overall SM risk than CRT due to increased need for salvage therapy. Reduced SM risk after IF-RT instead of EF-RT could not be demonstrated. Due to the large number of studies excluded because no IPD were received, to the inclusion of many outdated treatments and to the limited amount of long-term data, one must be cautious in applying these results to current therapies.

Quality control of involved-field radiotherapy in patients with advanced Hodgkin's lymphoma (EORTC 20884)

PURPOSE

To evaluate the impact of the quality of involved-field radiotherapy (IFRT) on clinical outcome in patients with advanced Hodgkin's lymphoma (HL) in complete remission (CR) after six to eight cycles of mechlorethamine, vincristine, procarbazine, prednisone-doxorubicin, bleomycin, and vinblastine (MOPP-ABV) chemotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A retrospective review of clinical and radiologic data, radiation charts, simulator films, and megavoltage (MV) photographs was performed. IFRT consisted of 24 Gy to all initially involved nodal areas and 16-24 Gy to all initially involved extranodal sites. Major violations were defined as no or only partial irradiation of an originally involved area, or a total dose <90% of the prescribed dose.

RESULTS

Of the 739 patients who were enrolled in the trial between 1989 and 2000, 57% achieved a CR; 152 of 172 patients randomized to IFRT actually received radiotherapy; and in 135 patients, quality control was performed. The overall major violation rate was 47%, predominantly concerning target volumes. The total dose was correct in 81% of the patients. After a median follow-up of 6.5 years, there was no difference in cumulative failure rate between patients with or without major violations. There was no relationship between incidence or site of relapse and major protocol violations.

CONCLUSION

In advanced-stage HL patients in complete remission after six to eight cycles of MOPP-ABV, the outcome was not influenced by violation of the radiotherapy protocol.

Trials in Advanced Hodgkin's Disease: More than 30 Years Experience of the British National Lymphoma Investigation

Hodgkin's disease demonstrates an exquisite sensitivity to chemotherapy and radiation therapy. This necessitates investigation of modes of delivering these modalities in the best possible fashion to improve outcomes. The British National Lymphoma Investigation (BNLI) has conducted randomized trials in advanced Hodgkin's disease for > 30 years. The results of BNLI studies have demonstrated that MOPP (mechlorethamine/vincristine/procarbazine/prednisone) chemotherapy is superior to MOP (mechlorethamine/vincristine/procarbazine) chemotherapy; that there are no significant differences between MOPP and B-MOPP (MOPP plus bleomycin); that there is no significant benefit from maintenance therapy with lomustine/vinblastine/bleomycin; that LOPP (chlorambucil/vincristine/procarbazine/prednisone) is as effective as MOPP and has less acute toxicity; that alternating therapy with LOPP and EVAP (etoposide/vinblastine/doxorubicin/prednisolone) is superior to EVAP alone or hybrid LOPP and EVA (etoposide/vinblastine/doxorubicin); that alternating therapy with ChlVPP (a substitute for MOPP) and prednisolone/doxorubicin/bleomycin/vincristine/etoposide regimens is superior to the latter regimen alone; that the Stanford V regimen (doxorubicin/vinblastine/mechlorethamine/vincristine/bleomycin/etoposide/prednisone) combined with disciplined radiation therapy is safe and effective; that hybrid therapy with ChlVPP and EVA and alternating therapy with ChlVPP and prednisolone/doxorubicin/bleomycin/vincristine/etoposide are as effective as ABVD (doxorubicin/bleomycin/vinblastine/dacarbazine) alone; and that there is no additional benefit from total nodal irradiation or combined-modality therapy compared with MOPP; and that treatment with high-dose BEAM (carmustine/etoposide/cytarabine/melphalan) and autologous bone marrow transplantation is superior to mini-BEAM (lower-dose BEAM not requiring bone marrow rescue) for poor-risk relapsed and refractory disease.

Progress in the Prognosis of Adult Hodgkin's Lymphoma in the Past 35 Years Through Clinical Trials in Argentina: A GATLA Experience

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the trends in complete remission (CR) rate, disease-free survival (DFS), and overall survival (OS) through 35 years of Grupo Argentino de Tratamiento de la Leucemia Aguda (GATLA) clinical trials. A total of 1,254 adult patients with Hodgkin's Lymphoma were evaluated according to seven consecutive protocols. This 35-year study was divided into three phases. The patients in the first phase (1968-1985) were treated with CVPP (cyclophosphamide/vinblastine/procarbazine/prednisone) plus involved-field radiotherapy (IFRT). In the CVPP regimen, cyclophosphamide and vinblastine were administered intravenously on day 1 and prednisone and procarbazine were administered orally on days 1-14 every 28 days. The second phase (1986-1996) used mainly reinforced CVPP with cyclophosphamide and vinblastine on days 1-8 plus IFRT. The third phase (1997-2003) used ABVD(doxorubicin/bleomycin/vinblastine/dacarbazine) plus IFRT. In clinical stage I/II, the CR rate was 86% in 252 patients treated in the first phase and DFS and OS were 57% and 78% at 5 years and 50% and 71% at 10 years. The second phase had 148 patients with clinical stage I/II disease, and the CR rate was 91%, 5-year DFS and OS were 78% and 90%, and 10-year DFS and OS were 70% and 83%. The third phase had 182 patients with clinical stage I/II disease, and the CR rate was 95%, 5-year DFS and OS were 87% and 96%, and 10-year DFS and OS were not reached. The statistical difference was P = 0.016 in terms of CR and P < 0.001 in terms of DFS and OS. In the first phase of 394 patients with clinical stage III/IV disease, the CR rate was 71%, DFS and OS at 5 years were 37% and 62%, and DFS and OS at 10 years were 32% and 53%. In the second phase of 164 patients with clinical stage III/IV disease, the CR rate was 84%, DFS and OS at 5 years were 66% and 80%, and DFS and OS at 10 years were 60% and 75%. In the third phase of 114 patients with clinical stage III/IV disease, the CR rate was 88% and DFS and OS at 5 years were 60% and 90%. The DFS and OS were not reached at 10 years. The differences among the 3 phases in CR, DFS and OS were highly significant (P < 0.001).

Analysis of treatment results in advanced Hodgkin's disease: the case for adjuvant radiotherapy

PURPOSE

To assess the treatment results in patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease in a single center and to evaluate the clinical and therapeutic prognostic factors, including verification of the significance of the prognostic score.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Treatment results were analyzed in 133 patients with newly diagnosed Stage IIIB and IV Hodgkin's disease. Treatment consisted of six courses of hybrid chemotherapy (mechlorethamine, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone [MOPP]/doxorubicin (adriamycin), bleomycin, and vincristine [ABV]) followed by irradiation (RT) in patients with an indication for RT (84 patients). Chemotherapy was then continued for another two cycles. The indications for consolidation RT included bulky disease and/or partial response after six cycles of chemotherapy. In 31 patients, extended-field RT was performed, and in 53, limited fields were irradiated. The median radiation dose was 39 Gy.

RESULTS

The median follow-up was 78 months. Complete remission after whole treatment was achieved in 88.7% of patients. The actuarial overall survival rate was 78% and 71%, and relapse-free survival rate was 73% and 65% at 5 and 10 years, respectively. The independent adverse prognostic factors in multivariate analysis appeared to be older age, low serum albumin, low serum gammaglobulin, lower number of chemotherapy cycles, and no RT. The value of the prognostic score was confirmed; the higher the prognostic score, the worse the survival.

CONCLUSION

In patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease, consolidation RT improved survival. The best results were achieved with the use of large-volume RT.

Involved-field radiotherapy for advanced Hodgkin's lymphoma

BACKGROUND

The use of involved-field radiotherapy after chemotherapy for advanced Hodgkin's lymphoma is controversial.

METHODS

We randomly assigned patients with previously untreated stage III or IV Hodgkin's lymphoma who were in complete remission after hybrid chemotherapy with mechlorethamine, vincristine, procarbazine, prednisone, doxorubicin, bleomycin, and vinblastine (MOPP-ABV) to receive either no further treatment or involved-field radiotherapy. Radiotherapy consisted of 24 Gy to all initially involved nodal areas and 16 to 24 Gy to all initially involved extranodal sites. Patients in partial remission were treated with 30 Gy to nodal areas and 18 to 24 Gy to extranodal sites.

RESULTS

Of 739 patients, 421 had a complete remission; 161 of these patients were assigned to no further treatment, and 172 to involved-field radiotherapy. The median follow-up was 79 months. The five-year event-free survival rate was 84 percent in the group that did not receive radiotherapy and 79 percent in the group that received involved-field radiotherapy (P=0.35). The five-year overall survival rates were 91 and 85 percent, respectively (P=0.07). Among the 250 patients in partial remission after chemotherapy, the five-year event-free and overall survival rates were 79 and 87 percent, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Involved-field radiotherapy did not improve the outcome in patients with advanced-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma who had a complete remission after MOPP-ABV chemotherapy. Radiotherapy may benefit patients with a partial response after chemotherapy.

Treatment of patients with advanced or bulky Hodgkin disease with a 12-week doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine-like chemotherapy regimen followed by extended-field, full-dose radiotherapy: long-term results of the Groupe Ouest et Est des Leucémies et Autres Maladies de Sang H90-A/B Multicenter Randomized Trial

BACKGROUND

This Phase II study was performed in patients with advanced or bulky Hodgkin disease (HD) to evaluate the results of a 7-drug chemotherapy (CT) regimen that was administered over 12 weeks according to 2 randomized modalities followed by high-dose lymph node irradiation.

METHODS

From 1990 to 1996, 162 patients with HD at clinical stages (CS) I-III with bulky disease (mediastinal mass ratio >or= 0.45 and/or unilateral or bilateral pelvic plus lumboaortic disease; 86 patients) or CS IV (76 patients) were randomized to receive the same cumulated dose of a CT regimen consisting of epirubicin (240 mg/m(2)), bleomycin (60 mg/m(2)), vinblastine (20 mg/m(2)), vincristine (4 mg/m(2)), cyclophosphamide (4000 mg/m(2)), etoposide (900 mg/m(2)), and methotrexate (180 mg/m(2)) plus methylprednisolone (1500 mg/m(2)) over 12 weeks either every 4 weeks (Arm Y, 79 patients) or every 3 weeks (Arm Z, 83 patients). Patients with disease in complete remission (CR) or partial remission after CT received extended-field lymph node irradiation (involved areas, 40 grays [Gy]; noninvolved areas, 30 Gy).

RESULTS

Forty-two percent of patients achieved a post-CT CR, and 86% of patients achieved a CR after the completion of irradiation (there was no difference between Arm Y and Arm Z). Thirty-five patients developed recurrent disease; most of those patients were in post-CT partial remission. The 10-year freedom from first progression rate was 63.9% (there was no difference between Arm Y and Arm Z). Thirty-eight patients died: 24 patients from HD, 3 patients from CT-related early sepsis, 1 patient from radiation-induced pneumonitis, 6 patients from a second malignancy, and 4 patients from causes unrelated to treatment. The overall 10-year survival rate was 76.7%. Survival was slightly higher among patients in Arm Y (83.3%) compared with patients in Arm Z (70.2%; P = 0.12).

CONCLUSIONS

No differences were found when the same amount of CT was delivered in three courses or in four courses. In 1997, because most recurrences of the H90-A/B trial occurred in patients who achieved a post-CT partial remission, the authors decided to reinforce the intensity of the initial CT and designed a new randomized study comparing two modalities of more intensive CT plus consolidative radiotherapy (H97-LM trial).

[The role of radiotherapy in the management of advanced Hodgkin's disease]

The use of radiotherapy in advanced stages of Hodgkin's disease remains controversial. The rationale for its use is based on efficacy at all stages of the disease as well as in patients with recurrent disease, but also on the topography of the recurrences after exclusive chemotherapy (which occur at non irradiated sites in 75% of cases), and on its ability to improve relapse rates as shown in many randomized trials. Unfortunately, this improvement does not translate into higher survival rates because of the increased late morbidity and an inadequate selection of patients who might benefit from irradiation. The benefits of radiotherapy are probably the highest in stage III rather than IV, in patients with scleronodular disease, and in those with mediastinal involvement experiencing a complete response to radiotherapy. A better survival should be observed with the shift towards a decrease of the doses delivered, an improvement of the quality of the irradiation, and a better definition of the volumes to be treated in association with the use of optimal chemotherapies.

Treatment of relapsed Hodgkin's disease: strategies and prognostic factors

The major points in salvage therapy of patients in relapse following combination chemotherapy for advanced disease are: (1) success of any second-line approach is determined by prognostic factors which include age, duration of the initial remission, and quantity of disease at relapse; (2) induction failures (progression without remission or incomplete remission and short initial remission) require innovative therapy which currently entails high-dose chemotherapy with peripheral or bone marrow autologous support; (3) late relapse still retains an order to sensitivity to chemotherapy and can be treated with conventional dose combination with complementary radiation therapy to previously unirradiated bulky sites. The choice of regimen is empiric and can include a repeat of the regimen used for the original remission or induction. The relative advantage of HDC in this favorable group is uncertain.

Ten-year results of a strategy combining three cycles of ABVD and high-dose extended irradiation for treating Hodgkin's disease at advanced stages

BACKGROUND

The treatment of Hodgkin's disease (HD) at advanced stages relies mainly upon multi-agent chemotherapies (CT), while the role of radiation therapy has not been definitely identified. The aim of this report is to analyze the 10-year results of a prospective study including 133 patients with HD clinical stages (CS) IIIA to IVB treated by three monthly courses of ABVD (adriamycin, bleomycin, vinblastin, and dacarbazine) followed by high-dose subtotal or total lymphoid irradiation [(S)TLI].

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From 1 October 1981 to 30 September 1988, 133 adult patients with HD CS IIIA (45), IIIB (33), IVA (seven) and IVB (48) were entered in the non-randomized multicentric prospective trial POF81/34. The number of involved nodal areas (NINA), and the number of visceral sites (NVIS) involved were registered in all patients; patients with bulky mediastinal tumor (BuMT) (mediastinal mass ratio > or = 0.45) were also identified. All patients received three monthly cycles of ABVD. Patients in complete remission (CR) or partial remission (PR) after completion of CT received a (S)TLI including the spleen (involved sites 40 Gy, non-involved 30 Gy); initially involved lung(s) and liver received 18 and 20 Gy, respectively; and patients not in CR or PR after CT or RT received salvage treatments. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify the factors contributing significantly to the prognosis; initial characteristics, as well as status after the three cycles of CT, were entered in the model.

RESULTS

Of the 133 patients, 74 (55.6%) entered in CR after CT and 116 (87.2%) after completion of radiation therapy. Ten-year freedom from progression (FFP), freedom from tumor mortality (FFTM) and survival rates were 70.4%, 78.9% and 70.6%, respectively. According to univariate analysis the NVIS (< or = one vs. > or = two) was the only initial factor simultaneously influencing 10-year FFP (73.9% vs. 38.2%) FFTM (82.5 vs. 34.1%) and survival (73.5% vs. 17.3%) rates; on the other hand, the NINA (< or = four vs. > or = five) influenced FFP (81.4% vs. 60.7%) and FFTM rates (87.3% vs. 71.4%) while symptoms (A vs. B) influenced FFP (80.7% vs. 63.3%) and survival (82.8% vs, 61.2%) rates. Finally, age (< 40 vs. > or = 40) influenced survival rate only (79.2% vs. 50%). According to multivariate analysis, NVIS and NINA had an independent impact on FFP and FFTM, while survival was modified by the NVIS and age. The post-CT status (CR vs. no CR) had a major impact on FFP (85.3% vs. 64.9%) FFTM (92.1% vs. 63.3%) as well as on survival (78.6% vs. 54.7%) rates in both univariate and multivariate analyses. Complications of therapy were mainly due to RT: 11 patients acquired second malignancies, six developed lung fibrosis or severe pulmonary infections, three developed intestinal obstructions and six developed angina pectoris or carotid stenosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Tumor burden (identified by the number of involved nodal areas and the number of visceral sites) and the response to initial CT were the two independent factors influencing the outcome of this group of 133 patients with HD, CSIII and IV treated by three cycles of ABVD followed by high-dose [(S)TLI].

Treatment of Hodgkin's disease: the role of radio- and/or chemotherapy in advanced stages

In recent years, anthracycline-containing single, alternating or "hybrid' combination chemotherapy regimens have achieved superior results in the treatment of patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease to those with single regimens of the MOPP type. A number of studies also suggest the superiority of combined modality regimens with chemotherapy and radiation therapy to chemotherapy alone among this group of patients. These studies and recent analyses of prognostic factors among patients treated with these current treatment approaches have been the subjects of this brief review.

Hodgkin's disease

This synthesis of the literature on radiotherapy for Hodgkin's Disease is based on 104 scientific articles, including 2 meta-analyses, 22 randomized studies, 5 prospective studies, and 58 retrospective studies. These studies involve 38,362 patients. The literature review clearly shows that radiotherapy is a cornerstone of treatment for localized Hodgkin's disease. At early stages, long-term survival is 80% to 90% when treatment is tailored to known prognostic factors. There is a tendency toward increased use of chemotherapy as additional treatment, however no evidence shows that it increases survival. To further improve survival following radiotherapy an attempt is being made to reduce long-term toxicity by better defining the patient groups who require lower radiation volumes, and delivering a dose that is as low as possible to avoid secondary solid tumors or delayed cardiopulmonary or gastrointestinal effects, while not jeopardizing therapeutic results. In advanced disease, radiotherapy may be needed as a complement to chemotherapy to effectively control bulky disease. For recurrent disease, radiotherapy may be considered as relapse treatment or additional therapy in conjunction with high-dose chemotherapy.

Further chemotherapy versus low-dose involved-field radiotherapy as consolidation of complete remission after six cycles of alternating chemotherapy in patients with advance Hodgkin's disease. German Hodgkins' Study Group (GHSG)

OBJECTIVE

It was the aim of this prospective randomized multicenter study to compare chemotherapy and radiotherapy as consolidation treatments in patients achieving complete remission (CR) after 6 cycles of doxorubicin-containing chemotherapy in advanced-stage Hodgkin's disease (HD).

METHODS

A total of 288 previously untreated patients aged 18-60 years with stage IIIB or IV HD received induction chemotherapy with 3 X (COPP + ABVD). Patients achieving CR were eligible for randomisation to either 20 Gy radiotherapy to initially involved fields (RT-arm) or to an additional 1 X (Copp + ABVD) (CT-arm ). Patients with nodal PR were allocated to more intense radiotherapy (IRT-arm: 20 Gy IF, 40 Gy to persisting tumor). Four patients with persisting organ involvement after induction received salvage chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Of 288 patients, 171 (59%) achieved CR after induction chemotherapy. Of these, 100 patients were successfully randomized to RT or CT. In the CT arm relapses were observed on 10 of 49 patients compared with 13 of 51 patients in the RT arm (p = n.s.). Fifty patients refused randomisation and for them a treatment was chosen, and 21 patients refused any further treatment. Of these 21 patients with no consolidation therapy, 9 relapsed, indicating an approximately 3-fold increased relapse risk compared with those receiving either of the consolidation therapies. No relapse was observed in initially involved lung or liver sites. Adverse prognostic factors for freedom from treatment failure and survival were low hemoglobin and large mediastinal mass at initial presentation.

CONCLUSIONS

No statistically significant differences in treatment efficacy were detected between 20 Gy IF radiotherapy and 1X (COPP + ABVD) chemotherapy following CR after six cycles of alternating chemotherapy in patients with advanced-stage HD. However, limited observations in a non-randomized cohort indicate that patients without consolidation treatment of CR after 6 cycles of chemotherapy may have an elevated risk of relapse.

Hybrid MOPP/ABVD and radiotherapy in advanced Hodgkin's disease

BACKGROUND

In patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease (HD), the alternation of MOPP with ABVD or hybrid MOPP/ABVD are associated with a high CR rate and a high probability of 5-year survival. However, even after effective chemotherapy the risk of nodal relapse is not negligible, and not only in initial bulky site(s) of disease. For this reason, in an attempt to prevent relapses after combination chemotherapy alone, we performed a prospective study to evaluate the efficacy and toxic effects of 6 courses of hybrid MOPP/ABVD followed by radiotherapy (RT) in stages II A bulky, II B, III and also in stage IV with bulky disease of residual after chemotherapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From January 1985 to August 1993, 133 patients with HD (128 newly diagnosed, stage II A bulky-IV, 5 in first relapse after RT) were treated according to the following program: 6 courses of the hybrid MOPP/ABVD regimen followed by RT (STNI + spleen in stages II A, II B, III without pelvic lymph node involvement, TNI + spleen in stage III with pelvic lymph node involvement, involved field in stage IV with bulky disease or residual after chemotherapy). The total dose of RT was 4000 cGy to the sites of bulky or residual disease and 2000 cGy to the other sites.

RESULTS

After hybrid MOPP/ABVD, 107 of 130 (82.3%) fully evaluable patients were classified as in CR or CR(U). After completion of RT, 108 patients were in CR and 3 were in PR, for an overall response rate of 85%. With a median follow-up duration of 45 months, the actuarial 5-year survival is 76% and the progression-free survival 68.6%. So far, only 14 patients have relapsed (6 within the irradiation field) and the 5-year relapse-free survival is 82.5%.

CONCLUSION

Six courses of hybrid MOPP/ABVD followed by RT in stages II A bulky, II B, III and in stage IV with bulky disease or residual after chemotherapy produced a high CR rate with low risk of relapse. However, a longer follow-up is necessary to evaluate the late effects of combined therapy.

Modern treatment of malignant lymphomas: a multidisciplinary approach? The Kaplan Memorial Lecture

The aim of this review is to examine critically, in Hodgkin's disease and in non-Hodgkin's lymphomas, (a) whether combined modality treatment is superior to optimal radiotherapy or chemotherapy alone in most stages of the disease; (b) whether its indications could be further expanded by the use of new drug regimens and newer radiation techniques that can now substantially reduce the risk of long-term iatrogenic morbidity; and (c) whether it may become a necessary approach in the future because staging laparotomy and even lymphangiography are progressively falling into disuse. In conclusion, for the next decade or so, I do not foresee a departure from complex treatment programs. Although fewer patients are being referred to major research centers, the treatment of malignant lymphomas is not ready as yet to be relegated to the care of the single physician in a private office or local hospital.