Sustainable Apple Disease Management in China: Challenges and Future Directions for a Transforming Industry

Apple Bitter Rot and Glomerella Leaf Spot: A Comprehensive Review of Causal Species and Their Biology, Fungicide Sensitivities, and Management Strategies

Bitter rot and Glomerella leaf spot (GLS) are two distinct diseases of apple fruit and foliage caused by members of the ascomycete fungal genus Colletotrichum. Although GLS is restricted to subtropical and, in some areas, to temperate climates, bitter rot is responsible for significant yield loss worldwide, particularly during the postharvest period. Initially thought to be caused by just two species of Colletotrichum, C. acutatum, and C. gloeosporioides, advances in molecular biology and sequencing techniques enabled the identification of 25 different species capable of causing bitter rot and/or GLS of apple belonging to the C. gloeosporioides species complex (CGSC), C. acutatum species complex (CASC), and C. boninense species complex (CBSC). Three species (C. gloeosporioides, C. fructicola, and C. chrysophilum) of CGSC cause both bitter rot and GLS, 18 species (6 of CGSC and 12 of CASC) only cause bitter rot, and 4 species (C. aenigma and C. asianum of CGSC, C. limetticola of CASC, and C. karsti of CBSC) only cause GLS. These species were found to differ in their geographical distribution, environmental and host tissue preference, pathogenicity, and fungicide sensitivities. In this review, we summarize the distribution, life cycle, and pathogenicity mechanisms of all currently known Colletotrichum species responsible for bitter rot and GLS of apple. Furthermore, we describe known apple defense mechanisms and management strategies for the control of these economically significant pathogens and identify gaps in our present understanding for future research.

An integrated approach for assessing the health risks of pesticide residues on apple: From field dynamics to human exposure

The apple (Malus domestica), a cultivated fruit extensively grown in temperate regions worldwide, is abundant in nutrients and phytochemicals that promote health. However, the application of pesticides in apple cultivation raises significant concern regarding their influence on food safety. This study investigated the dynamic behavior of five pesticides, including chlorpyrifos, imidacloprid, acetamiprid, carbendazim, prochloraz, in apple trees, utilizing both field experiments and predictive modeling to analyze their distribution, transfer, and degradation patterns. Results from the field experiment revealed that at harvest, the residue levels of the five pesticides on apple were below international and national maximum residue limits. The dynamiCROP modeling results, corresponding to the field trial findings, demonstrated that these pesticides exhibited comparable dissipation patterns across various environmental compartments. The primary sources of pesticides in apples were the air and the fruit surface up to 10 days after application, while the soil and leaf surface became the main sources over time. The transferred pesticides adhered to the apple fruits at varying rates and persist therein. Choosing pesticides with lower impact scores helped reduce the impacts on human health and the environment. The assessment of health risks associated with consuming apples containing pesticide residues suggested that the impact on human health is acceptable. These findings were crucial for apple producers, as they enable the optimization of pesticide application timing to ensure compliance with food safety standards and help improve pesticide management strategies in agriculture. This study is essential for minimizing the environmental impact of pesticides and enhancing sustainable agricultural practices.

Association of Apple Scar Skin Viroid (ASSVd) Infection with an Emerging Disease in 'Saiwaihong' Apples

A novel disease affecting small immature fruits has surfaced in 'Saiwaihong' apples (Malus pumila), a recently developed variety extensively cultivated across more than 20,000 ha in China. In an effort to pinpoint the causal agent(s) responsible for this ailment, RNA sequencing analysis was conducted on four symptomatic and four asymptomatic apple samples. The results revealed a diverse range of viruses and viroids, indicating mixed viral infection in diseased samples. However, a more focused examination involving 152 symptomatic and 122 asymptomatic fruit samples, using RT-PCR and dot-blotting hybridization techniques, highlighted a close association between the disease and the presence of apple scar skin viroid (ASSVd). Among the ASSVd variants obtained from diseased 'Saiwaihong' apples, 20 were identified, and they were either identical or closely related to isolates from various apple varieties cultivated in different regions and countries. This suggests that ASSVd isolates in 'Saiwaihong' might have been introduced from other apple varieties. Furthermore, the analysis indicates the possibility of two separate introductions, as the ASSVd 'Saiwaihong' isolates exhibited two distinct phylogenetic groups. These insights provide valuable guidance for disease control strategies and emphasize the significance of ongoing monitoring for ASSVd, both in its familiar forms and potential new variants.

Identification and pathogenicity of Alternaria and Fusarium species associated with bagged apple black spot disease in Shaanxi, China

Apple is an economically important fruit crop in northern Shaanxi Province in China. In recent years, a new type of apple black spot disease, "bagged apple black spot disease," has occurred in the main apple production area of Yan'an City, Shaanxi Province, during the apple ripening season. It seriously affects the appearance quality and commercial value of apples. In this study, 120 isolates recovered from symptomatic apples were identified based on morphological characteristics, pathogenicity, and multilocus sequence analyses of the internal transcribed spacer of ribosomal DNA (rDNA-ITS), translation elongation factor 1-α (EF1-α), RNA polymerase II subunit B (RPB2), endopolygalacturonase (endo-PG), and anonymous region OPA1-3. Alternaria alternata was the most abundant species (64%), followed by Fusarium acuminatum (36%). Pathogenicity assays were conducted by inoculating them individually and together on detached apples (Venus Golden and Fuji varieties). The results showed that the two fungal species could infect apples individually and together. Co-infection enhanced the disease severity. F. acuminatum led to increased severity and speed of disease development compared to A. alternata. This is the first report of Fusarium and Alternaria co-infection causing apple black spot disease worldwide, and the first report of F. acuminatum affecting apples. The optimal growth of A. alternata occurred at 25-30°C and pH 7; the optimal growth of F. acuminatum occurred at 25°C and pH 7. The results of this study can provide a theoretical basis for exploring the occurrence and epidemiology of apple black spot disease and strategies for its control.

Characterization of Fungal Species Isolated from Cankered Apple Barks Demonstrates the Alternaria alternata Causing Apple Canker Disease

Apple canker disease, also named as apple Valsa canker, is one of the most destructive diseases for apples (Malus domestica Borkh.). Cytospora/Valsa spp. are the dominant causal agent of this disease, but many studies have revealed that fungi from some other genus can also cause typical apple canker symptoms. In this study, we performed fungal pathogen isolation from cankered 'Fuji' apple barks. Six representative morphologically different fungi (Strain 1-6) were further subjected to ITS sequencing and evolutionary analysis. Molecular identification results revealed that Strains 1-6 are Cytospora mali, Fusarium cf. solani, Alternaria alternata, C. mali, Diplodia seriata and F. proliferatum, respectively. All these fungi have been reported to be causal agents of apple diseases. By inoculating fungal plugs onto trunks of 'Fuji' apple trees, the pathogenicity of the six fungi were accessed. Only the inoculations of the two C. mali strains (Strain 1 and Strain 4) and the A. alternata strain (Strain 3) resulted in typical apple canker symptoms in trunks. It is worth noting that Strain 1 caused much more severe canker symptoms and higher pathogenicity incidence than the other two fungi. A. alternata has been identified as a pathogen causing diseases on apple fruits and leaves. By further assessing its pathogenicity on apple fruits and leaves, we verified that it can also cause typical fruit rot and leaf spot symptoms. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on apple canker disease caused by A. alternata in China. Our present study can provide a theoretical foundation for the prevention and control of apple canker disease.

Genome comparisons reveal accessory genes crucial for the evolution of apple Glomerella leaf spot pathogenicity in Colletotrichum fungi

Apple Glomerella leaf spot (GLS) is an emerging fungal disease caused by Colletotrichum fructicola and other Colletotrichum species. These species are polyphyletic and it is currently unknown how these pathogens convergently evolved to infect apple. We generated chromosome-level genome assemblies of a GLS-adapted isolate and a non-adapted isolate in C. fructicola using long-read sequencing. Additionally, we resequenced 17 C. fructicola and C. aenigma isolates varying in GLS pathogenicity using short-read sequencing. Genome comparisons revealed a conserved bipartite genome architecture involving minichromosomes (accessory chromosomes) shared by C. fructicola and other closely related species within the C. gloeosporioides species complex. Moreover, two repeat-rich genomic regions (1.61 Mb in total) were specifically conserved among GLS-pathogenic isolates in C. fructicola and C. aenigma. Single-gene deletion of 10 accessory genes within the GLS-specific regions of C. fructicola identified three that were essential for GLS pathogenicity. These genes encoded a putative non-ribosomal peptide synthetase, a flavin-binding monooxygenase and a small protein with unknown function. These results highlight the crucial role accessory genes play in the evolution of Colletotrichum pathogenicity and imply the significance of an unidentified secondary metabolite in GLS pathogenesis.

Characterization and Pathogenicity of Fungal Species Associated with Dieback of Apple Trees in Northern Italy

Severe dieback symptoms were recently observed on apple (Malus × domestica) trees in Northern Italy, representing a growing concern for producers. Surveys were conducted over a 3-year period (2019 to 2021), and five apple orchards, from 5 to 12 years old, were monitored. A total of 33 fungal isolates isolated from symptomatic plants was selected for characterization. The species identification was achieved through multilocus phylogenetic analyses performed on sequences of three genomic loci (ITS, tub2, and tef1). Morphological features were assessed, and the average growth rate at different temperatures was determined. Seven species were identified in association with dieback of apple trees: Botryosphaeria dothidea, Cadophora luteo-olivacea, Diaporthe rudis, Diplodia seriata, Eutypa lata, Kalmusia longispora, and Paraconiothyrium brasiliense. All the species were pathogenic when inoculated on healthy apple plants. B. dothidea resulted in the most aggressive infections. This study provides an insight into the fungal species diversity associated with apple dieback and provides basis for further investigations to assess the phytosanitary status of plant materials to recommend and implement effective management strategies.

Analysis of Endophytic Bacterial Communities and Investigation of Core Taxa in Apple Trees

ire blight disease, caused by Erwinia amylovora, is a devastating affliction in apple cultivation worldwide. Chemical pesticides have exhibited limited effectiveness in controlling the disease, and biological control options for treating fruit trees are limited. Therefore, a relatively large-scale survey is necessary to develop microbial agents for apple trees. Here we collected healthy apple trees from across the country to identify common and core bacterial taxa. We analyzed the endophytic bacterial communities in leaves and twigs and discovered that the twig bacterial communities were more conserved than those in the leaves, regardless of the origin of the sample. This finding indicates that specific endophytic taxa are consistently present in healthy apple trees and may be involved in vital functions such as disease prevention and growth. Furthermore, we compared the community metabolite pathway expression rates of these endophyte communities with those of E. amylovora infected apple trees and discovered that the endophyte communities in healthy apple trees not only had similar community structures but also similar metabolite pathway expression rates. Additionally, Pseudomonas and Methylobacterium-Methylorobrum were the dominant taxa in all healthy apple trees. Our findings provide valuable insights into the potential roles of endophytes in healthy apple trees and inform the development of strategies for enhancing apple growth and resilience. Moreover, the similarity in cluster structure and pathway analysis between healthy orchards was mutually reinforcing, demonstrating the power of microbiome analysis as a tool for identifying factors that contribute to plant health.

Evaluation of Malus Germplasm Identifies Genetic Sources of Powdery Mildew and Frogeye Leaf Spot Resistance for Apple Breeding

Apple is an important fruit crop of temperate regions. The narrow genetic base of commercially cultivated apples has resulted in its vulnerability to a large number of fungal, bacterial, and viral pathogens. Apple breeders are always seeking new sources of resistance within the cross-compatible Malus species that can be deployed into elite genetic backgrounds. We have evaluated resistance to two major fungal diseases of apples: powdery mildew and frogeye leaf spot, using a germplasm collection of 174 Malus accessions to identify novel sources of genetic resistance. In 2020 and 2021, we evaluated these accessions for the incidence and severity of powdery mildew and frogeye leaf spot diseases at Cornell AgriTech, Geneva, New York, in a partially managed orchard. The severity and incidence of powdery mildew and frogeye leaf spot, as well as weather parameters were recorded in June, July, and August. Total incidence of powdery mildew and frogeye leaf spot infections increased from 33 to 38%, and 56 to 97% in 2020 and 2021, respectively. Our analysis showed that relative humidity and precipitation correlate with powdery mildew and frogeye leaf spot susceptibility. The predictor variables with highest impact to the variability of powdery mildew were accessions and relative humidity in May. A total of 65 Malus accessions were found to be resistant to powdery mildew, and only one accession showed moderate resistance to frogeye leaf spot. Several of these accessions belong to Malus hybrid species and domesticated apples and can therefore be potential sources of novel resistance alleles for apple breeding.

Molecular and Biochemical Characterization of Field Resistant Isolates of Glomerella cingulata to Pyraclostrobin in China

Glomerella leaf spot (GLS) caused by Glomerella cingulata is a destructive disease that results in severe defoliation and fruit spots in apples worldwide. The compound of pyraclostrobin and tebuconazole was registered in 2018 in China to control GLS. In 2020, the high-level resistance of G. cingulata to pyraclostrobin was found in the field in Shandong Province, with a resistance frequency of 4.8%. Except for a significant decrease in virulence, there was no fitness penalty in mycelial growth, sporulation, and stress tolerance of G. cingulata associated with the resistance to pyraclostrobin. No cross-resistance was detected between pyraclostrobin and tebuconazole or bromothalonil. The point mutation GGT (G) → GCT (A) at codon 143 in the Cytochrome b (Cytb) gene was identified in the pyraclostrobin-resistant isolates. Molecular docking analysis suggested that G143A significantly alters the affinity of pyraclostrobin to the Cytb protein. Based on the point mutation (G143A) in the Cytb gene, a cleaved amplified polymorphic sequences method was developed to detect pyraclostrobin resistance in G. cingulata populations. Results of this study will provide valuable information for the scientific management of GLS.

Genome-wide characterization and functional identification of MYB genes in Malus sieversii infected by Valsa mali

Among the most important transcription factors in plants, the v-myb avian myeloblastosis viral oncogene homolog (MYB) regulates the expression network of response genes under stresses such as fungal infection. In China, the canker disease Valsa mali threatens the survival of Malus sieversii, an ancestor of cultivated apples. Using the M. sieversii genome, we identified 457 MsMYB and 128 R2R3-MsMYB genes that were randomly distributed across 17 chromosomes. Based on protein sequence and structure, the R2R3-MsMYB genes were phylogenetically divided into 29 categories, and 26 conserved motifs were identified. We further predicted cis-elements in the 2000-kb promoter region of R2R3-MsMYBs based on the genome. Transcriptome analysis of M. sieversii under V. mali infection showed that 27 R2R3-MsMYBs were significantly differentially expressed, indicating their key role in the response to V. mali infection. Using transient transformation, MsMYB14, MsMYB24, MsMYB39, MsMYB78, and MsMYB108, which were strongly induced by V. mali infection, were functionally identified. Among the five MsMYBs, MsMYB14 and MsMYB78 were both important in enhancing resistance to diseases, whereas MsMYB24 inhibited resistance. Based on the results of this study, we gained a better understanding of the MsMYB transcription factor family and laid the foundation for a future research program on disease prevention strategies in M. sieversii.

MIR390 Is Involved in Regulating Anthracnose Resistance in Apple

As an important cash crop in China, apple has a good flavor and is rich in nutrients. Fungal attacks have become a major obstacle in apple cultivation. Colletotrichum gloeosporioides is one of the most devastating fungal pathogens in apple. Thus, discovering resistance genes in response to C. gloeosporioides may aid in designing safer control strategies and facilitate the development of apple resistance breeding. A previous study reported that 'Hanfu' autotetraploid apple displayed higher C. gloeosporioides resistance than 'Hanfu' apple, and the expression level of mdm-MIR390b was significantly upregulated in autotetraploid plants compared to that in 'Hanfu' plants, as demonstrated by digital gene expression (DGE) analysis. It is still unclear, however, whether mdm-MIR390b regulates apple anthracnose resistance. Apple MIR390b was transformed into apple 'GL-3' plants to identify the functions of mdm-MIR390b in anthracnose resistance. C. gloeosporioides treatment analysis indicated that the overexpression of mdm-MIR390b reduced fungal damage to apple leaves and fruit. Physiology analysis showed that mdm-MIR390b increased C. gloeosporioides resistance by improving superoxide dismutase (SOD) and peroxidase (POD) activity to alleviate the damage caused by O₂^- and H₂O₂. Our results demonstrate that mdm-MIR390b can improve apple plants' anthracnose resistance.

Discovery of Fusarium proliferatum f. sp. malus domestica Causing Apple Replant Disease in China

Apple replant disease (ARD) is the most serious threat facing the apple industry globally. ARD is mainly manifested as decreased plant growth, serious root rot disease, and considerable yield loss. Microbial factors are the dominant factors leading to the occurrence of ARD. Research on soil-borne pathogenic fungi leading to the occurrence of ARD in China is limited. In the present study, we selected 16 replanting orchards from the Northwest Loess region and around the Bohai Gulf. Diseased roots and rhizosphere soil from healthy apple trees and trees showing ARD symptoms were sampled at random. High-throughput sequencing was used to study the fungal communities in the rhizosphere soil, which showed that the composition of the rhizosphere soil fungal community of ARD-symptomatic and healthy apple trees was different. Nectriaceae at the family level and Fusarium at the genus level dominated the rhizosphere soil fungal community in the two regions, while for healthy apple trees, the relative abundance of Mortierella, Minimedusa, Tetracladium, and Chaetomium was higher. Tissue separation and serial dilution were used to separate fungi, and a total of 89 genera and 219 species were obtained, most of which were Fusarium. Fusarium was further confirmed to be the most abundant pathogen species leading to the occurrence of ARD in China through pathogenicity assays. A pathogenicity assay was carried out by the dip-and-cut technique using different host plants. It was found that Fusarium MR5 showed strong aggressiveness to apple rootstocks. Diseased seedlings specifically exhibited chlorosis of the leaves, browning from the edge of the leaf, followed by rolling and yellowing of the leaves, resulting in wilting and eventually death. Strain MR5 was preliminarily identified as F. proliferatum according to the morphological and cultural characteristics. A maximum likelihood analysis of identities based on six gene sequence (ITS, TUB2, IGS, mtSSU, RPB2, and the TEF gene) alignments between the MR5 strain and other strains showed 99 to 100% homology with F. proliferatum. Based on our test results, strain MR5 was identified as F. proliferatum f. sp. malus domestica, which is of great significance for finding new measures to control ARD in China.

In vivo and in vitro antifungal activities of five alkaloid compounds isolated from Picrasma quassioides (D. Don) Benn against plant pathogenic fungi

Highly active and novel antifungal compounds are continuously researched from natural products for pesticide development. Picrasma quassioides (D. Don) Benn, a species of Simaroubaceae, is used in traditional Chinese medicine to treat colds and upper respiratory infections. In this study, the active ingredients of P. quassioides and their antifungal activities against plant pathogenic fungi are investigated to explore the practical application of the plant in the agricultural field. The results showed that the extracts of P. quassioides exhibited highly significant preventive and curative effects on apple valsa canker (AVC) with a reduction of lesion diameter were 80.28% and 83.63%, respectively, and can improve the resistance of apple trees to a pathogen. Five antifungal compounds, namely, canthin-6-one (T1), nigakinone (T2), 4,5-dimethoxycanthin-6-one (T3), 1-methoxycarbonyl-β-carboline (T4), and 1-methoxycarbonyl-3-methoxyl-β-carboline (T5), are isolated from P. quassioides using the bioassay-guided method. This is the first report of 1-methoxycarbonyl-3-methoxyl-β-carboline as a natural product. Canthin-6-one shows strong in vitro inhibitory activity against 11 species of plant pathogenic fungi, and their EC₅₀ values range from 1.49 to 8.80 mg/L. The control efficacy of canthin-6-one at 2000 mg/L are 87.88% and 94.37% against AVC and 80.10% and 84.73% against apple anthracnose (C. gloeosporioides), respectively. Additionally, V. mali is observed after treatment with cannin-6-one, although microscopic. This is the first study on the control of the secondary metabolites of P. quassioides against plant fungal diseases. The results show that P. quassioides is a potential resource for the development of botanical fungicides.