Detection, Identification, and Molecular Characterization of the 16SrII-D Phytoplasmas Infecting Vegetable and Field Crops in Oman

A metagenomic investigation of phytoplasma diversity in Australian vegetable growing regions

In this study, metagenomic sequence data was used to investigate the phytoplasma taxonomic diversity in vegetable-growing regions across Australia. Metagenomic sequencing was performed on 195 phytoplasma-positive samples, originating either from historic collections (n=46) or during collection efforts between January 2015 and June 2022 (n=149). The sampled hosts were classified as crop (n=155), weed (n=24), ornamental (n=7), native plant (n=6), and insect (n=3) species. Most samples came from Queensland (n=78), followed by Western Australia (n=46), the Northern Territory (n=32), New South Wales (n=17), and Victoria (n=10). Of the 195 draft phytoplasma genomes, 178 met our genome criteria for comparison using an average nucleotide identity approach. Ten distinct phytoplasma species were identified and could be classified within the 16SrII, 16SrXII (PCR only), 16SrXXV, and 16SrXXXVIII phytoplasma groups, which have all previously been recorded in Australia. The most commonly detected phytoplasma taxa in this study were species and subspecies classified within the 16SrII group (n=153), followed by strains within the 16SrXXXVIII group ('Ca. Phytoplasma stylosanthis'; n=6). Several geographic- and host-range expansions were reported, as well as mixed phytoplasma infections of 16SrII taxa and 'Ca. Phytoplasma stylosanthis'. Additionally, six previously unrecorded 16SrII taxa were identified, including five putative subspecies of 'Ca. Phytoplasma australasiaticum' and a new putative 16SrII species. PCR and sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene was a suitable triage tool for preliminary phytoplasma detection. Metagenomic sequencing, however, allowed for higher-resolution identification of the phytoplasmas, including mixed infections, than was afforded by only direct Sanger sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene. Since the metagenomic approach theoretically obtains sequences of all organisms in a sample, this approach was useful to confirm the host family, genus, and/or species. In addition to improving our understanding of the phytoplasma species that affect crop production in Australia, the study also significantly expands the genomic sequence data available in public sequence repositories to contribute to phytoplasma molecular epidemiology studies, revision of taxonomy, and improved diagnostics.

The observation of taxonomic boundaries for the 16SrII and 16SrXXV phytoplasmas using genome-based delimitation

Within the 16SrII phytoplasma group, subgroups A-X have been classified based on restriction fragment length polymorphism of their 16S rRNA gene, and two species have been described, namely 'Candidatus Phytoplasma aurantifolia' and 'Ca. Phytoplasma australasia'. Strains of 16SrII phytoplasmas are detected across a broad geographic range within Africa, Asia, Australia, Europe and North and South America. Historically, all members of the 16SrII group share ≥97.5 % nucleotide sequence identity of their 16S rRNA gene. In this study, we used whole genome sequences to identify the species boundaries within the 16SrII group. Whole genome analyses were done using 42 phytoplasma strains classified into seven 16SrII subgroups, five 16SrII taxa without official 16Sr subgroup classifications, and one 16SrXXV-A phytoplasma strain used as an outgroup taxon. Based on phylogenomic analyses as well as whole genome average nucleotide and average amino acid identity (ANI and AAI), eight distinct 16SrII taxa equivalent to species were identified, six of which are novel descriptions. Strains within the same species had ANI and AAI values of >97 %, and shared ≥80 % of their genomic segments based on the ANI analysis. Species also had distinct biological and/or ecological features. A 16SrII subgroup often represented a distinct species, e.g., the 16SrII-B subgroup members. Members classified within the 16SrII-A, 16SrII-D, and 16SrII-V subgroups as well as strains classified as sweet potato little leaf phytoplasmas fulfilled criteria to be included as members of a single species, but with subspecies-level relationships with each other. The 16SrXXV-A taxon was also described as a novel phytoplasma species and, based on criteria used for other bacterial families, provided evidence that it could be classified as a distinct genus from the 16SrII phytoplasmas. As more phytoplasma genome sequences become available, the classification system of these bacteria can be further refined at the genus, species, and subspecies taxonomic ranks.

Duplex PCR assay for detection of chickpea chlorotic dwarf virus and peanut witches' broom phytoplasma in chickpea

A duplex PCR assay was standardized by optimizing PCR reaction constituents and cycles for the simultaneous detection of chickpea chlorotic dwarf virus (CpCDV) and a peanut witches' broom (PnWB) phytoplasma associated with the chickpea stunt disease. Coat protein gene and tuf gene specific primers for CpCDV and phytoplasmas were used. Different concentrations of the PCR components such as Taq polymerase, primers and PCR annealing temperature were standardized for the identification of the two agents by a duplex PCR assay. Expected amplicons of 590 bp for CpCDV and 1090 bp for phytoplasmas were consistently amplified from the symptomatic chickpea tissues. That resulted in equally efficient and sensitive in detecting single or mixed infection of CpCDV and PnWB phytoplasma in 148 symptomatic chickpea stunt samples collected in two states of India. The results indicate the robustness in the detection of pathogens present in chickpea showing stunt disease and for theoretical use in epidemiological studies that would help the appropriate disease management strategies.

Witches' Broom Disease of Lime Contributes to Phytoplasma Epidemics and Attracts Insect Vectors

An insect-transmitted phytoplasma causing Witches' Broom Disease of Lime (WBDL) is responsible for the drastic decline in lime production in several countries. However, it is unclear how WBDL phytoplasma (WBDLp) induces witches' broom symptoms and if these symptoms contribute to the spread of phytoplasma. Here we show that the gene encoding SAP11 of WBDLp (SAP11_WBDL) is present in all WBDLp isolates collected from diseased trees. SAP11_WBDL interacts with acid lime (Citrus aurantifolia) TCP transcription factors, specifically members of the TB1/CYC class that have a role in suppressing axillary branching in plants. Sampling of WBDLp-infected lime trees revealed that WBDLp titers and SAP11_WBDL expression levels were higher in symptomatic leaves compared with asymptomatic sections of the same trees. Moreover, the witches' brooms were found to attract the vector leafhopper. Defense genes that have a role in plant defense responses to bacteria and insects are more downregulated in witches' brooms compared with asymptomatic sections of trees. These findings suggest that witches' broom-affected parts of the trees contribute to WBDL epidemics by supporting higher phytoplasma titers and attracting insect vectors.

History and Current Status of Phytoplasma Diseases in the Middle East

Phytoplasmas that are associated with fruit crops, vegetables, cereal and oilseed crops, trees, ornamental, and weeds are increasing at an alarming rate in the Middle East. Up to now, fourteen 16Sr groups of phytoplasma have been identified in association with more than 164 plant species in this region. Peanut witches' broom phytoplasma strains (16SrII) are the prevalent group, especially in the south of Iran and Gulf states, and have been found to be associated with 81 host plant species. In addition, phytoplasmas belonging to the 16SrVI, 16SrIX, and 16SrXII groups have been frequently reported from a wide range of crops. On the other hand, phytoplasmas belonging to 16SrIV, 16SrV, 16SrX, 16SrXI, 16SrXIV, and 16SrXXIX groups have limited geographical distribution and host range. Twenty-two insect vectors have been reported as putative phytoplasma vectors in the Middle East, of which Orosius albicinctus can transmit diverse phytoplasma strains. Almond witches' broom, tomato big bud, lime witches' broom, and alfalfa witches' broom are known as the most destructive diseases. The review summarizes phytoplasma diseases in the Middle East, with specific emphasis on the occurrence, host range, and transmission of the most common phytoplasma groups.

Multilocus gene analysis reveals the presence of two phytoplasma groups in Impatiens balsamina showing flat stem and phyllody

Rose balsam (Impatiens balsamina) is an important ornamental species grown worldwide for its attractive flowers and also having medicinal properties. Flat stem, little leaf, and phyllody symptoms were observed in I. balsamina nurseries in Uttar Pradesh and Tripura states of India during surveys from 2018 to 2020, with an incidence from 6 to 27%. Amplicons of ~ 1.2 kb were amplified in all the tested symptomatic samples of I. balsamina using universal phytoplasma primer pairs from different surveyed locations, but not from the asymptomatic plants. Pairwise sequence comparison, phylogeny, and virtual RFLP analysis of 16S rRNA gene sequences identified the phytoplasmas as 16SrI-B subgroup strain from Tripura (Lembucherra) and 16SrII-D subgroup strain from Uttar Pradesh (Gorakhpur and Faizabad). Phytoplasma presence and identity was further confirmed by amplifying secA, rp, secY, and tuf genes. This is the first report of 16SrI-B and 16SrII-D phytoplasmas detection in I. balsamina in the world.

Assessing the Impact of Climate Change on the Distribution of Lime (16srii-B) and Alfalfa (16srii-D) Phytoplasma Disease Using MaxEnt

Witches' broom disease has led to major losses in lime and alfalfa production in Oman. This paper identifies bioclimatic variables that contribute to the prediction of distribution of witches' broom disease in current and future climatic scenarios. It also explores the expansion, reduction, or shift in the climatic niche of the distribution of the disease across the different geographical areas of the entire country (309,501 km²). The maximum entropy model (MaxEnt) and geographical information system were used to investigate the potential suitability of habitats for the phytoplasma disease. This study used current (1970-2000) and future projected climatic scenarios (2021-2040, 2041-2060, 2061-2080, and 2081-2100) to model the distribution of phytoplasma for lime trees and alfalfa in Oman. Bioclimatic variables were downloaded from WorldClim with ± 60 occurrence points for lime trees and alfalfa. The area under the curve (AUC) was used to evaluate the model's performance. Quantitatively, the results showed that the mean of the AUC values for lime (16SrII-B) and alfalfa (16SrII-D) future distribution for the periods of 2021-2040, 2041-2060, 2061-2080, and 2081-2100 were rated as "excellent", with the values for the specified time periods being 0.859, 0.900, 0.931, and 0.913 for 16SrII-B; and 0.826, 0.837, 08.58, and 0.894 for 16SrII-D respectively. In addition, this study identified the hotspots and proportions of the areas that are vulnerable under the projected climate-change scenarios. The area of current (2021-2040) highly suitable distribution within the entire country for 16SrII-D was 19474.2 km² (7.1%), while for 16SrII-B, an area of 8835 km² (3.2%) was also highly suitable for the disease distribution. The proportions of these suitable areas are very significant from the available arable land standpoint. Therefore, the results from this study will be of immense benefit and will also bring significant contributions in mapping the areas of witches' broom diseases in Oman. The results will equally aid the development of new strategies and the formulation of agricultural policies and practices in controlling the spread of the disease across Oman.

Association of the 16SrII-D Phytoplasma with African Marigold (Tagetes erecta) Phyllody in Oman

The African marigold (Tagetes erecta L.) is an ornamental, herbaceous plant commonly found in Oman. In 2019, African marigold plants showing phyllody and virescence symptoms, which are typical symptoms of phytoplasmas disease, were found in at Sultan Qaboos University in Oman. Transmission electron microscopy of marigold leaf midrib from phyllody disease plants showed the presence of numerous phytoplasma bodies in the sieve tube of all of the symptomatic samples. DNA was extracted from asymptomatic and symptomatic marigold plant samples, followed by PCR of the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) and imp genes. The PCR assays showed that the symptomatic plants are positive for phytoplasma. The DNA sequence analysis and phylogenetic trees showed that the 16S rDNA and imp gene sequences from all marigold phyllody strains shared 100% sequence identity to 16SrII-D subgroup sequences in the GenBank. This is the first report of a phytoplasma of the 16SrII-D subgroup associated with the African marigold (T. erecta) worldwide.

Pest categorisation of the non-EU phytoplasmas of tuber-forming Solanum spp

Following a request from the European Commission, the EFSA Panel on Plant Health performed a pest categorisation of four phytoplasmas of tuber-forming Solanum spp. known to occur only outside the EU or having a limited presence in the EU. The only tuber-forming species of Solanum reported to be phytoplasma infected is S. tuberosum. This opinion covers 'Candidatus Phytoplasma americanum', 'Ca. P. aurantifolia'-related strains (GD32; St_JO_10, 14, 17; PPT-SA; Rus-343F; PPT-GTO29, -GTO30, -SINTV; Potato Huayao Survey 2; Potato hair sprouts), 'Ca. P. fragariae'-related strains (YN-169, YN-10G) and 'Ca. P. pruni'-related strains (Clover yellow edge; Potato purple top AKpot7, MT117, AKpot6; PPT-COAHP, -GTOP). Phytoplasmas can be detected by molecular methods and are efficiently transmitted by vegetative propagation. Phytoplasmas are also transmitted in a persistent and propagative manner by some insects belonging to families within Cicadomorpha, Fulgoromorpha and Sternorrhyncha (order Hemiptera). No transovarial, pollen or seed transmission has been reported. The reported natural host range of the phytoplasmas categorised here varies from restricted ('Ca. P. americanum', and 'Ca. P. fragariae'-related strains) to wide ('Ca. P. aurantifolia'-related strains and 'Ca. P. pruni'-related strains), thus increasing the possible entry pathways in the latter case. S. tuberosum is widely cultivated in the EU. All the categorised phytoplasmas can enter and spread through the trade of host plants for planting, and by vectors. Establishment of these phytoplasmas is not expected to be limited by EU environmental conditions. The introduction of these phytoplasmas in the EU would have an economic impact. There are measures to reduce the risk of entry, establishment, spread and impact. Uncertainties result from limited information on distribution, biology and epidemiology. All the phytoplasmas categorised here meet the criteria evaluated by EFSA to qualify as potential Union quarantine pests, and they do not meet all the criteria to qualify as potential regulated non-quarantine pests, because they do not occur or are not known to be widespread in the EU.

First report of a subgroup 16SrII-D phytoplasma associated with Opuntia cylindrica fasciated disease in Oman

Cacti are evergreen perennial succulent plants that are used as ornamental and hedge plants. The fruits and leaves are also used as forage in some areas (Dewir, 2016). Cactus species are susceptible to several pathogens, including phytoplasma. In March 2020, three cactus plants (Opuntia cylindrica) out of ten (30% incidence) exhibited phytoplasma symptoms, including stunted growth, fasciation in stems and cladodes, color changes of the tips of cladodes to purple, and having clusters of highly proliferating cladodes. The plants were located in the Botanic Garden at Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman (N:23º59'14"; E:58º16'34"). PCR assays were carried out on the DNA samples extracted from young cladodes of three each of symptomatic and asymptomatic plants using phytoplasma-universal 16S rRNA primers, P1/P7 in direct PCR followed by R16F2n/R16R2, P4/P7 in the nested PCR. Distilled water (DW) and Alfalfa witches' broom phytoplasma (AlfWB) were used as negative and positive controls in each assay, respectively. In addition, amplification of the partial translocase protein A (secA) gene in the symptomatic cactus samples was done using SecA-II-F1/SecA-II-R1 (targeting 2140 bp) followed by SecA-II-F1/SecAR4 (targeting 1510 bp) (Al-Subhi et al., 2018). All the symptomatic plants and the positive control were positive for both genes (16S and secA), but no amplification was observed from the asymptomatic samples and DW. Sequence analysis and similarity searches against BLASTn revealed that the phytoplasma 16S rRNA (MT327813) shared 100% sequence identity with that of 'Candidatus Phytoplasma aurantifolia' isolate CB04 (MT555412) from India. The secA gene sequence (MT331815) analysis showed 100% identity with Cicer arietinum phyllody (KX358585). The associated phytoplasma was designated as cactus fasciated phytoplasma (CFP). Phylogenetic trees based on CFP 16Sr rRNA,secA genes, and a combined phylogenetic tree showed clustering of the CFP with the 16SrII-D subgroup phytoplasmas. The association of the aster yellows and peanut witches'-broom phytoplasma groups with other cactus species has already been reported from Lebanon, Mexico, China, Italy and Egypt (Dewir, 2016). The 16SrII phytoplasma in association with O. cylindrica showing fasciated stem has been reported from Egypt (Omar et al., 2014). A series of diverse plant species in association with 16SrII-D phytoplasma has been reported from Oman (Al-Subhi et al., 2018). However, this is the first report of a cactus phytoplasma disease in Oman belonging to the 16SrII-D subgroup phytoplasmas. Some fasciated cactus species are attractive and therefore cultivated as new ornamental plants and transported around the world, which may pose a new threat to other economically important crops.

Pest categorisation of the non-EU phytoplasmas of Cydonia Mill., Fragaria L., Malus Mill., Prunus L., Pyrus L., Ribes L., Rubus L. and Vitis L

Following a request from the European Commission, the EFSA Panel on Plant Health performed a pest categorisation of nine phytoplasmas of Cydonia Mill., Fragaria L., Malus Mill., Prunus L., Pyrus L., Ribes L., Rubus L. and Vitis L. (hereafter "host plants") known to occur only outside the EU or having a limited presence in the EU. This opinion covers the (i) reference strains of 'Candidatus Phytoplasma australiense', 'Ca. P. fraxini', 'Ca. P. hispanicum', 'Ca. P. trifolii', 'Ca. P. ziziphi', (ii) related strains infecting the host plants of 'Ca. P. aurantifolia', 'Ca. P. pruni', and 'Ca. P. pyri', and (iii) an unclassified phytoplasma causing Buckland valley grapevine yellows. Phytoplasmas can be detected by available methods and are efficiently transmitted by vegetative propagation, with plants for planting acting as a major entry pathway and a long-distance spread mechanism. Phytoplasmas are also transmitted in a persistent and propagative manner by some insect families of the Fulgoromorpha, Cicadomorpha and Sternorrhyncha (order Hemiptera). No transovarial, pollen or seed transmission has been reported. The natural host range of the categorised phytoplasmas varies from one to more than 90 plant species, thus increasing the possible entry pathways. The host plants are widely cultivated in the EU. All the categorised phytoplasmas can enter and spread through the trade of host plants for planting, and by vectors. Establishment of these phytoplasmas is not expected to be limited by EU environmental conditions. The introduction of these phytoplasmas in the EU would have an economic impact. There are measures to reduce the risk of entry, establishment, spread and impact. Uncertainties result from limited information on distribution, biology and epidemiology. All the phytoplasmas categorised here meet the criteria evaluated by EFSA to qualify as potential Union quarantine pests, and they do not qualify as potential regulated non-quarantine pests, because they are non-EU phytoplasmas.

Multilocus gene-specific characterization of 'Candidatus Phytoplasma australasia' associated with shoot proliferation disease of small cardamom in India

Symptoms of excessive shoot proliferation were observed in the Njallani cultivar of small cardamom accompanied by stunting of stalks with fewer degenerated capsules at Nedumkandam Panchayat of Idukki district of Kerala in 2017. Five symptomatic Elettaria cardamomum shoot proliferation (ECSP) plant samples were collected and processed for DNA extraction and PCR assays utilizing universal phytoplasma 16S ribosomal-specific primers pair, P1/P7 followed by R16F2n/R16R2. Sequence comparison analysis of the R16F2n/R16R2 region of 16SrRNA gene showed 100% sequence identity with the 'Candidatus Phytoplasma australasia'- related strain. Phylogeny and virtual RFLP analyses of 16S rRNA gene sequences confirmed the association of 'Ca. P. australasia' strain subgroup D with ECSP disease. The association of 16SrII group was further established and validated by amplifying phytoplasma-specific multilocus candidate genes by utilizing specific primers of secA, secY, SAP11, and tuf genes. The multilocus gene sequence comparison analysis again confirmed the association of 'Ca. P. australasia' with the ECSP phytoplasma isolate. This is the first report of phytoplasma association with small cardamom.

Global Status of Phytoplasma Diseases in Vegetable Crops

The presence of phytoplasmas and their associated diseases is an emerging threat to vegetable production which leads to severe yield losses worldwide. Phytoplasmas are phloem-limited pleomorphic bacteria lacking the cell wall, mainly transmitted through leafhoppers but also by plant propagation materials and seeds. Phytoplasma diseases of vegetable crops are characterized by symptoms such as little leaves, phyllody, flower virescence, big buds, and witches' brooms. Phytoplasmas enclosed in at least sixteen different ribosomal groups infecting vegetable crops have been reported thus far across the world. The aster yellows phytoplasma group (16SrI) is presently the prevalent, followed by the peanut witches' broom (16SrII). Wide and overlapping crop and non-crop host ranges of phytoplasmas, polyphagous insect vectors, limited availability of resistance sources and unavailability of environmentally safe chemical control measures lead to an arduous effort in the management of these diseases. The most feasible control of vegetable phytoplasma diseases is a consequence of the development and implementation of integrated disease management programs. The availability of molecular tools for phytoplasma identification at the strain level greatly facilitated this kind of approach. It is moreover essential to understand the molecular basis of phytoplasma-vector interaction, epidemiology and other factors involved in disease development in order to reduce the disease outbreaks. Information on the knowledge about the most widespread phytoplasma diseases in vegetable crops is reviewed here in a comprehensive manner.