Characterization of Erwinia chrysanthemi from a Bacterial Heart Rot of Pineapple Outbreak in Hawaii

Mitigating the repercussions of climate change on diseases affecting important crop commodities in Southeast Asia, for food security and environmental sustainability—A review

Southeast Asia is a fertile land with a warm and humid climate which tends to accommodate various food crops. The development and advancement of the agricultural sector not only allows the countries in the region to feed the increasing population, but are also able to boost the nation's economy through exportation of the crops. Some of the well-known and economically-significant plant commodities found in the region include rice, oil palm, rubber, coconut, banana, sugarcane, pineapple, black pepper, maize, cocoa, durian, and jackfruit. Due to the high production of crops, Southeast Asia is able to stand among the top world producers of these commodities. Nevertheless, the widespread of pathogenic microorganisms has posed a serious threat to the industry over the years; with hundreds of millions of money wasted and total yield being lost due to the devastating diseases associated with each type of the plants. A lot of attention and effort have been continuously devoted to find effective plant management strategies to combat plant diseases, starting from traditional physical and chemical methods to the increasing discoveries on biological approaches made in recent decades. Due to the challenges and limitations faced by conventional approaches and the rising awareness toward the environment, more work has been focused on establishing the application of beneficial microorganisms to tackle plant diseases through direct mechanisms. Thus, by bringing the common plant commodities in Southeast Asia, their associated diseases and various physical, chemical and biological control measures together, this review aims to provide clearer insights and practical information to those who seek to limit the damages caused by plant diseases.

First Report of Bacterial Pineapple Heart Rot Caused by Dickeya zeae in Puerto Rico

In Puerto Rico, the agricultural production of pineapple (Ananas comosus (L.) Merr.) comprises nearly 5,000 tons harvested annually from over 250 ha (USDA 2018). With an annual income of approximately $3 million USD, pineapple ranks fourth in importance among Puerto Rican crops (USDA 2018). Recently, the pineapple industry on the island underwent a change from growing a local cultivar known as "Cabezona" to cultivar MD2, introduced from Hawaii around 1996 (SEA 2015), because this cultivar produces fruit more than once during a single growing season. In August 2018 (when the rainy season normally starts in Puerto Rico), soft rot symptoms appeared at commercial fields in Manatí (WGS 84 Lat 18.42694, Lng -66.44779) and persisted through 2019. Symptoms observed in the field included foliar water-soaked lesions with gas-filled blisters, especially at the base of the leaf. Leaves exhibited brown discoloration and a fetid odor (rot) at the basal portion of the plant. Finally, leaves collapsed at the center of the pineapple crown, effectively killing the apex and preventing the fruit from developing. Disease incidence ranged from 25% to 40% depending on the weather and season; when there was more rain, there was higher disease incidence. Symptomatic leaves were collected in February 2019, disinfected with 70% ethanol, and rinsed with sterile distilled water. Tissue sections (5mm2) were placed in nutrient agar. Bacterial colony-forming units (CFU) were a translucent cream color, circular, with a flat convex surface and wavy edge. Biochemical analysis showed that bacteria were Gram-negative, oxidase positive, catalase positive, and facultatively anaerobic. Pathogenicity was tested on leaves of one-and-a-half-year-old pineapple seedlings in humid chambers. Bacteria were grown on sterile nutrient agar for 3 days at 25 ± 2°C. Inoculation assays (three replications) were performed using 1X108 CFU/ml of bacteria suspended in sterile water and applied with a cotton swab to leaves wounded with a needle. The inoculated tissue was incubated at 28°C and kept in a dark environment. Negative controls were inoculated with sterile water. Five days after inoculation, foliar water-soaked lesions were observed, followed by the formation of brown leaf tissue and gas-filled blisters, the same symptoms observed in the field. A partial DNA sequence of the 16S rRNA gene of the bacterial isolate and the re-isolated bacteria were amplified using primers 27F and 1492R (Lane et al. 1985) and sequenced. The isolate was determined to the genus Dickeya through a BLAST® search against sequences available in the database of the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI). This partial 16S rRNA sequence of the bacterial isolate was deposited in GenBank® at NCBI (Accession no. MT672704). To determine the identity of the Dickeya species, we sequenced the genes dnaA, gyrB, dnaX, and recN (Marrero et al. 2013) for the bacterial isolate (GenBank accession nos. OM276852, OM276853, OM276854, and OM276855) and conducted a Multilocus Sequence Analysis including reference Dickeya sequences of Marrero et al., 2013. The Phylogenetic analysis (using WinClada) resolved the Puerto Rican isolate as belonging to a clade broadly ascribable to D. zeae, most closely related to strains isolated from earlier Hawaiian pineapple bacterial heart rot outbreaks. Dickeya zeae was responsible for bacterial heart rot of pineapple in Malaysia and was later reported as the causal agent for outbreaks in Costa Rica and Hawaii (Kaneshiro et al. 2008; Sueno et al. 2014; Ramachandran et al. 2015). D. zeae had not previously been reported as causing bacterial heart rot in pineapples in Puerto Rico and this study points to a close relationship with strains first detected in Hawaii and which should further be explored to determine the precise nature of this relationship. This information should facilitate the adoption of effective control measures for this disease on the island, promote more effective methods of preventing future introductions of pathogens, and encourage further investigations into the occurrence of D. zeae on the island.

Bacillus cereus for Controlling Bacterial Heart Rot in Pineapple var. MD2

Bacterial heart rot (BHR) disease caused by pathogenic bacteria, Dickeya zeae, is one of the destructive diseases of pineapple worldwide. This study explored the potential of Bacillus cereus against the BHR pathogen in vitro and in vivo. The BHR causal pathogen was isolated from symptomatic pineapple plants, demonstrating water-soaked and rotten basal tissues. Biological control agent (BCA) was isolated from asymptomatic pineapple leaves, later confirmed as B. cereus, and subsequently tested for the antagonistic activity against the BHR pathogen via disc diffusion assay and glasshouse trial. B. cereus showed the ability to inhibit the growth of BHR pathogen with 18.10 ± 0.36 mm of inhibition zone in diameter. The ability of B. cereus against the BHR pathogen was further confirmed via the glasshouse trial with five treatments. The results showed that treatments with B. cereus inoculation recorded lower disease severity index of 0.04 ± 0.01 than the positive control treatment with pathogen alone (0.53 ± 0.04). This finding indicated that B. cereus has a great potential as BCA against BHR disease in pineapple var. MD2, however, the effectiveness of this isolate needs to be further tested under actual field conditions.

Genome-Informed Recombinase Polymerase Amplification Assay Coupled with a Lateral Flow Device for In-Field Detection of Dickeya Species

Dickeya spp. cause blackleg and soft rot diseases of potato and several other plant species worldwide, resulting in high economic losses. Rapid detection and identification of the pathogen is essential for facilitating efficient disease management. Our aim in this research was to develop a rapid and field-deployable recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) assay coupled with a lateral flow device (LFD) that will accurately detect Dickeya spp. in infected plant tissues without the need for DNA isolation. A unique genomic region (mglA/mglC genes) conserved among Dickeya spp. was used to design highly specific robust primers and probes for an RPA assay. Assay specificity was validated with 34 representative strains from all Dickeya spp. and 24 strains from other genera and species; no false positives or negatives were detected. An RPA assay targeting the internal transcribed spacer region of the host genome was included to enhance the reliability and accuracy of the Dickeya assay. The detection limit of 1 fg was determined by both sensitivity and spiked sensitivity assays; no inhibitory effects were observed when 1 µl of host sap, macerated in Tris-EDTA buffer, was added to each reaction in the sensitivity tests. The developed RPA assay is rapid, highly accurate, sensitive, and fully field deployable. It has numerous applications in routine diagnostics, surveillance, biosecurity, and disease management.

Calcium Regulation of Bacterial Virulence

Calcium (Ca²⁺) is a universal signaling ion, whose major informational role shaped the evolution of signaling pathways, enabling cellular communications and responsiveness to both the intracellular and extracellular environments. Elaborate Ca²⁺ regulatory networks have been well characterized in eukaryotic cells, where Ca²⁺ regulates a number of essential cellular processes, ranging from cell division, transport and motility, to apoptosis and pathogenesis. However, in bacteria, the knowledge on Ca²⁺ signaling is still fragmentary. This is complicated by the large variability of environments that bacteria inhabit with diverse levels of Ca²⁺. Yet another complication arises when bacterial pathogens invade a host and become exposed to different levels of Ca²⁺ that (1) are tightly regulated by the host, (2) control host defenses including immune responses to bacterial infections, and (3) become impaired during diseases. The invading pathogens evolved to recognize and respond to the host Ca²⁺, triggering the molecular mechanisms of adhesion, biofilm formation, host cellular damage, and host-defense resistance, processes enabling the development of persistent infections. In this review, we discuss: (1) Ca²⁺ as a determinant of a host environment for invading bacterial pathogens, (2) the role of Ca²⁺ in regulating main events of host colonization and bacterial virulence, and (3) the molecular mechanisms of Ca²⁺ signaling in bacterial pathogens.

Development of a Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification Assay for the Detection of Dickeya spp

Dickeya and Pectobacterium spp. are responsible for soft-rotting diseases of several plant species, some with overlapping host range. On potato, symptoms caused by these pathogens cannot be clearly differentiated. Disease results in the downgrading and rejection of potato seed, thus requiring additional phytosanitary restrictions across Northern Europe and other parts of the world. In an effort to provide a more timely and accurate diagnostic to distinguish these two groups of pathogens, a method for detecting Dickeya spp. using loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) was developed. The LAMP assay can be used to test crude extracts prepared directly from symptomatic lesions. The entire test can be completed in less than 30 min, making it faster than the current diagnostic standard, the pelADE conventional polymerase chain reaction. Additionally, the LAMP assay was able to detect Dickeya DNA in samples spiked with varying amounts of Pectobacterium DNA, thus demonstrating the highly specific and sensitive nature of the assay, which can be applied on survey samples with mixed soft-rotting bacterial populations.

Diversity of Dickeya Strains Collected from Pineapple Plants and Irrigation Water in Hawaii

Bacterial heart rot caused by a yet undetermined species of Dickeya was first observed in December 2003 in Oahu, HI, on a pineapple cultivar (Ananas comosus 'PRI 73-114') recently imported from Central America. Identical symptoms were later seen in the same plantation in fields that had been planted with propagules from the Philippines. Dickeya strains isolated from symptomatic plants and irrigation water collected over subsequent years were identified using bacteriological tests and partial 16S ribosomal DNA sequencing and characterized using repetitive sequence-based polymerase chain reaction (rep-PCR) with the BOXA1R primer (BOX-PCR), pathogenicity on pineapple leaves, and reactivity with two monoclonal antibodies (MAbs). Strains exhibited variability in pathogenicity and in reactivity with MAbs. BOX-PCR separated the plant-isolated Dickeya strains into seven haplotypes that were placed into four fingerprint groups (A to D). Strains from the A and B groups were isolated from the Central American stocks, whereas strains in the D group were identified from Philippine material. Strains from the C group were isolated from both planting materials. Most strains from water sources were placed into three haplotypes that loosely formed group E. BOX-PCR polymorphisms between the Dickeya strains isolated from foreign pineapple plants, a local collection of Dickeya strains, and strains from the plantation's water sources support the possibility that at least two separate introductions of genetically distinct strains occurred via imported planting stocks.

Phylogeny and classification of Dickeya based on multilocus sequence analysis

Bacterial heart rot of pineapple reported in Hawaii in 2003 and reoccurring in 2006 was caused by an undetermined species of Dickeya. Classification of the bacterial strains isolated from infected pineapple to one of the recognized Dickeya species and their phylogenetic relationships with Dickeya were determined by a multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA), based on the partial gene sequences of dnaA, dnaJ, dnaX, gyrB and recN. Individual and concatenated gene phylogenies revealed that the strains form a clade with reference Dickeya sp. isolated from pineapple in Malaysia and are closely related to D. zeae; however, previous DNA-DNA reassociation values suggest that these strains do not meet the genomic threshold for consideration in D. zeae, and require further taxonomic analysis. An analysis of the markers used in this MLSA determined that recN was the best overall marker for resolution of species within Dickeya. Differential intraspecies resolution was observed with the other markers, suggesting that marker selection is important for defining relationships within a clade. Phylogenies produced with gene sequences from the sequenced genomes of strains D. dadantii Ech586, D. dadantii Ech703 and D. zeae Ech1591 did not place the sequenced strains with members of other well-characterized members of their respective species. The average nucleotide identity (ANI) and tetranucleotide frequencies determined for the sequenced strains corroborated the results of the MLSA that D. dadantii Ech586 and D. dadantii Ech703 should be reclassified as Dickeya zeae Ech586 and Dickeya paradisiaca Ech703, respectively, whereas D. zeae Ech1591 should be reclassified as Dickeya chrysanthemi Ech1591.

Specificity of monoclonal antibodies to strains of Dickeya sp. that cause bacterial heart rot of pineapple

During a severe outbreak of bacterial heart rot that occurred in pineapple plantations on Oahu, Hawaii, in 2003 and years following, 43 bacterial strains were isolated from diseased plants or irrigation water and identified as Erwinia chrysanthemi (now Dickeya sp.) by phenotypic, molecular, and pathogenicity assays. Rep-PCR fingerprint patterns grouped strains from pineapple plants and irrigation water into five genotypes (A-E) that differed from representatives of other Dickeya species, Pectobacterium carotovorum and other enteric saprophytes isolated from pineapple. Monoclonal antibodies produced following immunization of mice with virulent type C Dickeya sp. showed only two specificities. MAb Pine-1 (2D11G1, IgG1 with kappa light chain) reacted to all 43 pineapple/water strains and some reference strains (D. dianthicola, D. chrysanthemi, D. paradisiaca, some D. dadantii, and uncharacterized Dickeya sp.) but did not react to reference strains of D. dieffenbachiae, D. zeae, or one of the two Malaysian pineapple strains. MAb Pine-2 (2A7F2, IgG3 with kappa light chain) reacted to all type B, C, and D strains but not to any A or E strains or any reference strains except Dickeya sp. isolated from Malaysian pineapple. Pathogenicity tests showed that type C strains were more aggressive than type A strains when inoculated during cool months. Therefore, MAb Pine-2 distinguishes the more virulent type C strains from less virulent type A pineapple strains and type E water strains. MAbs with these two specificities enable development of rapid diagnostic tests that will distinguish the systemic heart rot pathogen from opportunistic bacteria associated with rotted tissues. Use of the two MAbs in field assays also permits the monitoring of a known subpopulation and provides additional decision tools for disease containment and management practices.

Biochemical characterization of Gram-positive and Gram-negative plant-associated bacteria with micro-Raman spectroscopy

Raman spectra of Gram-positive and Gram-negative plant bacteria have been measured with micro-Raman spectrometers equipped with 785 and 514.5 nm lasers. The Gram-positive bacteria Microbacterium testaceum, Paenibacillus validus, and Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. michiganensis have strong carotenoid bands in the regions 1155-1157 cm(-1) and 1516-1522 cm(-1) that differentiate them from other tested Gram-negative bacteria. In the Raman spectrum of Gram-positive bacteria Bacillus megaterium excited with 785 nm laser, the Raman bands at 1157 and 1521 cm(-1) are weak in intensity compared to other Gram-positive bacteria, and these bands did not show significant resonance Raman enhancement in the spectrum recorded with 514.5 nm laser excitation. The Gram-positive bacteria could be separated from each other based on the bands associated with the in-phase C=C (v(1)) vibrations of the polyene chain of carotenoids. None of the Gram-negative bacteria tested had carotenoid bands. The bacteria in the genus Xanthomonas have a carotenoid-like pigment, xanthomonadin, identified in Xanthomonas axonopodis pv. dieffenbachiae, and it is a unique Raman marker for the bacteria. The representative bands for xanthomonadin were the C-C stretching (v(2)) vibrations of the polyene chain at 1135-1136 cm(-1) and the in-phase C=C (v(1)) vibrations of the polyene chain at 1529-1531 cm(-1), which were distinct from the carotenoid bands of other tested bacteria. The tyrosine peak in the region 1170-1175 cm(-1) was the only other marker present in Gram-negative bacteria that was absent in all tested Gram-positives. A strong-intensity exopolysaccharide-associated marker at 1551 cm(-1) is a distinguishable feature of Enterobacter cloacae. The Gram-negative Agrobacterium rhizogenes and Ralstonia solanacearum were differentiated from each other and other tested bacteria on the basis of presence or absence and relative intensities of peaks. The principal components analysis (PCA) of the spectra excited with 785 nm laser differentiated the various strains of bacteria based on the unique pigments these bacteria do or do not possess. Raman spectroscopy of diverse plant bacteria that are pathogenic and non-pathogenic to plants, and isolated from plants and soil, indicates the possibilities of using the method in understanding plant-bacterial interactions at the cellular level.