Phytoplasmas Associated with Elm Yellows: Molecular Variability and Differentiation from Related Organisms

Bois noir management in vineyard: a review on effective and promising control strategies

Among grapevine yellows, Bois noir (BN), associated with 'Candidatus Phytoplasma solani', represents the biggest threat in the main wine-growing areas worldwide, causing significant losses in berry quality and yields. BN epidemiology involves multiple plant hosts and several insect vectors, making considerably complex the development of effective management strategies. Since application of insecticides on the grapevine canopy is not effective to manage vectors, BN management includes an integrated approach based on treatments to the canopy to make the plant more resistant to the pathogen and/or inhibit the vector feeding, and actions on reservoir plants to reduce possibilities that the vector reaches the grapevine and transmit the phytoplasma. Innovative sustainable strategies developed in the last twenty years to improve the BN management are reviewed and discussed.

Multiple-Genome-Based Simple Sequence Repeat Is an Efficient and Successful Method in Genotyping and Classifying Different Jujube Germplasm Resources

Jujube (Ziziphus jujuba Mill.) is a commercially important tree native to China, known for its high nutritional value and widespread distribution, as well as its diverse germplasm resources. Being resilient to harsh climatic conditions, the cultivation of jujube could provide a solution to food insecurity and income for people of arid and semi-arid regions in and outside of China. The evaluation of germplasm resources and genetic diversity in jujube necessitates the use of Simple Sequence Repeat (SSR) markers. SSR markers are highly polymorphic and can be used to evaluate the genetic diversity within and between cultivars of Chinese jujube, and are important for conservation biology, breeding programs, and the discovery of important traits for Chinese jujube improvement in China and abroad. However, traditional methods of SSR development are time-consuming and inadequate to meet the growing research demands. To address this issue, we developed a novel approach called Multiple-Genome-Based SSR identification (MGB-SSR), which utilizes the genomes of three jujube cultivars to rapidly screen for polymorphic SSRs in the jujube genome. Through the screening process, we identified 12 pairs of SSR primers, which were then used to successfully classify 249 jujube genotypes. Based on the genotyping results, a digital ID card was established, enabling the complete identification of all 249 jujube plants. The MGB-SSR approach proved efficient in rapidly detecting polymorphic SSRs within the jujube genome. Notably, this study represents the first successful differentiation of jujube germplasm resources using 12 SSR markers, with 4 markers successfully identifying triploid jujube genotypes. These findings offer valuable information for the classification of Chinese jujube germplasm, thereby providing significant assistance to jujube researchers and breeders in identifying unknown jujube germplasm.

When a Palearctic bacterium meets a Nearctic insect vector: Genetic and ecological insights into the emergence of the grapevine Flavescence dorée epidemics in Europe

Flavescence dorée (FD) is a European quarantine grapevine disease transmitted by the Deltocephalinae leafhopper Scaphoideus titanus. Whereas this vector had been introduced from North America, the possible European origin of FD phytoplasma needed to be challenged and correlated with ecological and genetic drivers of FD emergence. For that purpose, a survey of genetic diversity of these phytoplasmas in grapevines, S. titanus, black alders, alder leafhoppers and clematis were conducted in five European countries. Out of 132 map genotypes, only 11 were associated to FD outbreaks, three were detected in clematis, whereas 127 were detected in alder trees, alder leafhoppers or in grapevines out of FD outbreaks. Most of the alder trees were found infected, including 8% with FD genotypes M6, M38 and M50, also present in alders neighboring FD-free vineyards and vineyard-free areas. The Macropsinae Oncopsis alni could transmit genotypes unable to achieve transmission by S. titanus, while the Deltocephalinae Allygus spp. and Orientus ishidae transmitted M38 and M50 that proved to be compatible with S. titanus. Variability of vmpA and vmpB adhesin-like genes clearly discriminated 3 genetic clusters. Cluster Vmp-I grouped genotypes only transmitted by O. alni, while clusters Vmp-II and -III grouped genotypes transmitted by Deltocephalinae leafhoppers. Interestingly, adhesin repeated domains evolved independently in cluster Vmp-I, whereas in clusters Vmp-II and-III showed recent duplications. Latex beads coated with various ratio of VmpA of clusters II and I, showed that cluster II VmpA promoted enhanced adhesion to the Deltocephalinae Euscelidius variegatus epithelial cells and were better retained in both E. variegatus and S. titanus midguts. Our data demonstrate that most FD phytoplasmas are endemic to European alders. Their emergence as grapevine epidemic pathogens appeared restricted to some genetic variants pre-existing in alders, whose compatibility to S. titanus correlates with different vmp gene sequences and VmpA binding properties.

Phytoplasma associated with witches'-broom disease of Ulmus minor MILL . in the Czech Republic: Electron microscopy and molecular characterization

Visual inspections of elm trees in south Moravia in 1997-2007 revealed a rare occurrence of plants with smaller and cowl-forming leaves on some twigs, i.e. a feature resembling witches'-broom disease observed on the end of twigs. The presence of phytoplasma-like bodies was observed by transmission electron microscopy of phloem tissue. On the other hand, no phytoplasmas were found in asymptomatic trees. Nucleic acids extracted from these plants were used in nested-PCR assays with primers amplifying 16S rRNA sequences specific for phytoplasmas. Sequence analyses of the 16S-23S ribosomal operon (1852 bp) allowed for the classification of the detected phytoplasmas in the elm yellows group, but its position remained on the boundary of the 16SrV-A and 16SrV-C ribosomal subgroups. Sequence analyses of the ribosomal protein of the rpl22-rps3 and secY genes lead to further classification and revealed the phytoplasmas' affiliations to the 'Candidates Phytoplasma ulmi'. Some exceptions in unique oligonucleotide sequences defined for 'Ca. Phytoplasma ulmi' were found in the Czech isolate. This is the northernmost confirmed occurrence of phytoplasma on elm trees within Europe.

Classification of phytoplasma strains in the elm yellows group (16SrV) and proposal of 'Candidatus Phytoplasma ulmi' for the phytoplasma associated with elm yellows

Elm yellows group (16SrV) phytoplasmas, which are associated with devastating diseases in elm, grapevine, blackberry, cherry, peach and several other plant species in America, Europe and Asia, represent one of the most diverse phytoplasma clusters. On the basis of phylogenetic analysis of 16S rDNA sequences, elm yellows group phytoplasmas form a discrete subclade within the phytoplasma clade. Three phylogenetic parameters, namely 16S rRNA, ribosomal protein and secY genes, have been evaluated for their usefulness in differentiating elm yellows group phytoplasmas. RFLP analysis of 16S rRNA sequences differentiated the elm yellows group phytoplasmas into five subgroups. Twelve RFLP subgroups were differentiated on the basis of ribosomal protein and 13 were differentiated using secY gene sequences. Phylogenetic analysis of the ribosomal protein genes and secY gene alone or in combination indicated that the subgroups constitute 12 genetically distinct lineages, each of which appears to have evolved under different ecological constraints such as specific vector or plant hosts. On the basis of unique DNA and biological properties, it is proposed that the elm yellows phytoplasma EY1(T) represents a novel taxon, 'Candidatus Phytoplasma ulmi'.

A New Member of the Clover Proliferation Phytoplasma Group (16SrVI) Associated with Elm Yellows in Illinois

A disease with symptoms similar to elm yellows (EY) was noticed in the early 1990s in suburban Chicago, IL. More than 1,000 mature American elms (Ulmus americana) have since died. Infected trees varied in the incidence and severity of canopy yellowing, leaf epinasty, butterscotch discoloration, and wintergreen odor of the phloem, but all developed a sparse and clumpy crown, uniformly necrotic phloem, and died within 2 years of showing canopy symptoms. Because symptoms were expressed irregularly and phytoplasma detection results by a commercial diagnostic company were inconsistent, a study was initiated to determine if EY phytoplasma was the causal agent. Polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) methods using universal or EY phytoplasma specific primers were employed to detect putative phytoplasma(s) associated with 10 trees of varied disease severity within the outbreak region and 10 asymptomatic trees from an uninfected area (controls). Nested PCR using universal primers revealed that 90% of trees from the outbreak region were positive for phytoplasma while asymptomatic elms from another location (controls) tested negative. Phytoplasma-positive trees ranged in disease severity from 1 (asymptomatic) to 5 (near death). Inner bark samples chiseled from the lower trunk had higher phytoplasma detection rates than foliage or drill shavings. RFLP analyses and DNA sequencing of 16S rDNA indicated that the phytoplasma recovered from dying elms in Arlington Heights is not related to the reference EY phytoplasma (group16SrV). It is most closely related to clover proliferation (CP) phy-toplasma (group 16SrVI), and we have designated it Illinois Elm Yellows (ILEY) phytoplasma, and assigned it to a new taxonomic subgroup (16SrVI-C). EY phytoplasma was not detected in any samples, but two ILEY phytoplasma positive trees also were positive for aster yellows (AY) phytoplasma. ILEY phytoplasma was not detected in local leafhopper populations trapped in elm trees between May and September 2000. This is the first report of a phytoplasma related to CP phytoplasma causing elm yellows disease symptoms.

Erigeron Witches'-Broom Phytoplasma in Brazil Represents New Subgroup VII-B in 16S rRNA Gene Group VII, the Ash Yellows Phytoplasma Group

A previously undescribed phytoplasma, Erigeron witches'-broom phytoplasma, was detected in diseased plants of Erigeron sp. and Catharanthus roseus exhibiting symptoms of witches'-broom and chlorosis in the state of São Paulo, Brazil. On the basis of restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of 16S rDNA amplified in the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), Erigeron witches'-broom phytoplasma was classified in group 16SrVII (ash yellows phytoplasma group), new subgroup VII-B. Phylogenetic analysis of 16S rDNA sequences indicated that this phytoplasma represents a new lineage that is distinct from that of described strains of ash yellows phytoplasma. Erigeron witches'-broom phytoplasma is the first member of the ash yellows phytoplasma group to be recorded in Brazil.

Genetic variability among flavescence dorée phytoplasmas from different origins in Italy and France

Flavescence dorée is a devastating disease of grapevine widespread in several countries in EU such as France, Italy and Spain. Genetic variability among 17 Italian and 3 French FD strains was investigated by RFLP analyses based on a fragment of the ribosomal protein operon and on the non-ribosomal DNA fragment FD9. RFLP analysis of the PCR amplified ribosomal protein fragment, coding for the 3' end of rpl22 and the entire rps3 genes, differentiated 4 rp-subgroups among the FD strains and 4 subgroups among the reference strains belonging to elm yellows group (16SrV). Sequencing and phylogenetic analysis of the same ribosomal protein DNA fragment validated the delineation of 4 distinct FD strain types derived by RFLP analyses. The results supported the differentiation based on analysis of the non-ribosomal DNA fragment FD9. The phylogenetic analysis further revealed relationships and a probable evolutionary trend among the FD strains and the other representatives of elm yellows group. All the FD strains together with the reference strains ALY, RuS and JWB formed a cluster very well distinct from the EY/ULW cluster. Moreover, ALY was shown to be more closely related to three FD strain types: the Lombardia/Piemonte, the French FD70, and the French FD88/Italian FD-D strain clusters.

Detection and Characterization of a Lethal Yellowing (16SrIV) Group Phytoplasma in Canary Island Date Palms Affected by Lethal Decline in Texas

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays were used to detect phytoplasmas in Canary Island date (Phoenix canariensis) palms displaying symptoms similar to lethal yellowing (LY) disease in Corpus Christi, TX. An rDNA product (1.8 kb) was amplified consistently from 10 of 11 palms by PCR employing phytoplasma universal rRNA primer pair P1/P7. Also, AluI endonu-clease digests and sequencing of P1/P7 products revealed that nontarget Bacillus megaterium-related rDNA sequences of similar size were co-amplified along with phytoplasma rDNA from 10 palms. A 1,402-bp product was obtained from all 11 symptomatic palms when initial P1/P7 products were reamplified by PCR employing nested LY phytoplasma group-specific 16S rRNA primer pair LY16Sf/LY16Sr. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of nested PCR products revealed that palm-infecting phytoplasmas were uniform and most similar to strains composing the coconut lethal yellowing phytoplasma (16SrIV) group. Sequence analysis of 16S rDNA determined the Texas Phoenix palm decline (TPD) phytoplasma to be phylogenetically closest to the Carludovica palmata leaf yellowing (CPY) phytoplasma. rDNA profiles of strains TPD and CPY obtained with AluI were co-identical and distinct from other known 16SrIV group phytoplasmas. On this basis, both strains were classified as members of a new subgroup, 16SrIV-D.

Detection and Characterization of an Elm Yellows (16SrV) Group Phytoplasma Infecting Virginia Creeper Plants in Southern Florida

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) employing phytoplasma-specific ribosomal RNA primer pair P1/P7 consistently amplified a product of expected size (1.8 kb) from 29 of 36 symptom-less Virginia creeper (Parthenocissus quinquefolia) plants growing in southern Florida. Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of P1/P7-primed PCR products indicated that most phytoplasmas detected in Virginia creeper were similar to phytoplasmas composing the elm yellows (16SrV) group. This relationship was verified by reamplification of P1/P7 products using an elm yellows (EY) group-specific rRNA primer pair fB1/rULWS1. rDNA products (1,571 bp) were generated by group-specific PCR from 28 phytoplasma-positive plants and 1 negatively testing plant identified by earlier P1/P7-primed PCR. Analysis of 16S rDNA sequences determined the Virginia creeper (VC) phytoplasma to be phylogenetically closest to the European alder yellows (ALY) agent, an established 16SrV-C subgroup strain. However, presence or absence of restriction sites for endonucleases AluI, BfaI, MspI, RsaI, and TaqI in the 16S rRNA and 16-23S rRNA intergenic spacer region of the VC phytoplasma collectively differentiated this strain from ALY and other 16SrV group phytoplasmas. Failure to detect the VC phytoplasma by PCR employing nonribosomal primer pair FD9f/FD9r suggests that this newly characterized agent varies from known European grapevine yellows (flavescence dorée) phyto-plasmas previously classified as 16SrV subgroup C or D strains.

Revised Subgroup Classification of Group 16SrV Phytoplasmas and Placement of Flavescence Dorée-Associated Phytoplasmas in Two Distinct Subgroups

The subgroup classification of phytoplasmas in 16S rRNA group 16SrV (elm yellows phytoplasma group) was revised and extended on the basis of enzymatic restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of ribosomal (r) DNA and analysis of putative restriction sites in nucleotide sequences. A 1.85 kbp fragment of the rRNA operon from flavescence dorée (FD) phytoplasma strain FD70 from France was amplified and cloned, and its nucleotide sequence determined (GenBank acc. no. AF176319). Placement of FD70 in subgroup V-C was verified by analysis of amplified DNA and of the cloned sequence. Hemp dogbane phytoplasma HD1 (AF122912), a member of subgroup V-C, was distinguished from other subgroup V-C phytoplasmas by putative restriction site differences in the 16S-23S rRNA spacer region. A previously published FD phytoplasma sequence (GenBank accession no. X76560) differed from FD70 sequence AF176319 by at least eight nucleotide substitutions and differences in putative restriction sites. The X76560 FD phytoplasma was classified in a new subgroup (V-D). Based on analyses of 16S rDNA GenBank sequence Y16395, Rubus stunt phytoplasma was classified in new subgroup V-E. The revised classification was supported by sequence similarities, group 16SrV-characteristic sequences, and a phylogenetic tree constructed on the basis of 16S rDNA sequences.

Responses of Six Eurasian Ulmus Cultivars to a North American Elm Yellows Phytoplasma

Elms (genus Ulmus) of six clonal cultivars representing Eurasian species and hybrids were grafted when 2 to 3 years old with bark patches from U. rubra infected with an elm yellows phytoplasma or were left untreated as controls. The cultivars were U. glabra × minor 'Pioneer', U. minor × parvifolia 'Frontier', U. parvifolia 'Pathfinder', U. wilsoniana 'Prospector', and the complex hybrids 'Homestead' and 'Patriot'. Trees were evaluated for infection and symptoms 1 or 2 years after inoculation. Infection was detected via the 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindol e·2HCl (DAPI) fluorescence test in 26 of 86 grafted trees representing five cultivars. Infection of selected trees was confirmed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of a fragment of phytoplasmal rDNA, and the phytoplasma was identified by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis of the amplified DNA using restriction enzymes AluI, RsaI, and TaqI. Elm yellows phytoplasma was also identified by nested PCR and RFLP analysis in two of seven inoculated, healthy-appearing, DAPI-negative trees and one noninoculated control tree. All RFLP profiles were identical to that of reference strain EY1. Phytoplasma-associated symptoms, observed in five cultivars, included suppressed growth, progressive size reduction of apical shoots and leaves, chlorosis, foliar reddening, witches'-brooms, and dieback. Phyto-plasma was not detected in cv. Homestead. Possible resistance of this cultivar to elm yellows phytoplasma was indicated by localized phloem necrosis in stems below inoculum patches.

Characterization of X-Disease Phytoplasmas in Chokecherry from North Dakota by PCR-RFLP and Sequence Analysis of the rRNA Gene Region

Genetic variation of X-disease phytoplasma strains from chokecherry (ChX) in North Dakota and nearby sites, and their relatedness with three standard strains of the X-disease phytoplasma group, eastern X-disease (CX), western X-disease (WX), and goldenrod yellows (GR1) phyto-plasmas, were studied. Primer pairs were developed to amplify the 23S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene and the 16S/23S spacer region. The rRNA genes (16S rRNA, 23S rRNA, and two ribosomal protein [rp] genes) and the 16S/23S spacer region were amplified by polymerase chain reactions. The restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) patterns of 16S rRNA, 23S rRNA, and rp genes, generated by digestion with four restriction enzymes (AluI, HpaII, MseI, and RsaI), showed no difference among 43 ChX phytoplasma isolates. Sequencing of the 441-bp 16S/23S spacer region revealed variation at four positions among 12 ChX phytoplasma strains. A tRNA^Ile and other conserved sequences were identified in the spacer region. Among X-disease subgroups, RFLP analysis indicated that ChX is similar to WX, closely related to CX, and easily distinguished from GR1. Sequencing indicated that ChX is closer to CX than to WX. Together, the analyses indicated that ChX phytoplasmas are genetically different from the standard strains of other X-disease phytoplasma subgroups.