AFLP Analysis of Phytophthora cactorum Isolates from Strawberry and Other Hosts: Implications for Identifying the Primary Source of Inoculum

The devastating oomycete phytopathogen Phytophthora cactorum: Insights into its biology and molecular features

Phytophthora cactorum is one of the most economically important soilborne oomycete pathogens in the world. It infects more than 200 plant species spanning 54 families, most of which are herbaceous and woody species. Although traditionally considered to be a generalist, marked differences of P. cactorum isolates occur in degree of pathogenicity to different hosts. As the impact of crop loss caused by this species has increased recently, there has been a tremendous increase in the development of new tools, resources, and management strategies to study and combat this devastating pathogen. This review aims to integrate recent molecular biology analyses of P. cactorum with the current knowledge of the cellular and genetic basis of its growth, development, and host infection. The goal is to provide a framework for further studies of P. cactorum by highlighting important biological and molecular features, shedding light on the functions of pathogenicity factors, and developing effective control measures.

TAXONOMY

P. cactorum (Leb. & Cohn) Schröeter: kingdom Chromista; phylum Oomycota; class Oomycetes; order Peronosporales; family Peronosporaceae; genus Phytophthora.

HOST RANGE

Infects about 200 plant species in 154 genera representing 54 families. Economically important host plants include strawberry, apple, pear, Panax spp., and walnut.

DISEASE SYMPTOMS

The soilborne pathogen often causes root, stem, collar, crown, and fruit rots, as well as foliar infection, stem canker, and seedling damping off.

Evaluation of the Ability of Seven Active Ingredients of Fungicides to Suppress Phytophthora cactorum at Diverse Life Stages, and Variability in Resistance Found among Isolates

Phytophthora cactorum is considered an important plant pathogen which is causing major damage to strawberry plants worldwide. In the current study, the ability of the active ingredients of seven different fungicides, azoxystrobin, cymoxanil, dimethomorph, fenamidone, fluopicolide, metalaxyl and propamocarb, to suppress the mycelial growth, sporangial formation and zoospore release of P. cactorum isolates, was tested. The variation in resistance against various fungicides was found among the isolates. The active ingredients are also unequally efficient against different life stages of P. cactorum, which is probably associated with their different modes of action. A significant level of resistance was recorded against metalaxyl and dimethomorph; however, these were totally inefficient against the zoospore release, while azoxystrobin did not inhibit mycelial growth. The only fungicide efficient against all three P. cactorum life stages tested was fluopicolide, although the calculated resistance factor gives evidence of the rise of resistance in the majority of isolates even against this fungicide. Significant differences were found between responses to fungicides of isolates from strawberry and from other host species. Based on the Mahalanobis distances calculated in the discriminant analysis comprising all of the assays performed, the similarities among isolates were estimated.

Detection and Characterization of Quinone Outside Inhibitor-Resistant Phytophthora cactorum and P. nicotianae Causing Leather Rot in Florida Strawberry

Phytophthora cactorum and P. nicotianae cause leather rot (LR) of fruit and Phytophthora crown rot (PhCR) in strawberry. LR occurs sporadically but can cause up to 70% fruit loss when weather is conducive. In Florida's annual strawberry winter production system, PhCR can be severe, resulting in plant stunting, mortality, and severe yield loss. Azoxystrobin is labeled for control of LR but not for PhCR. The aims of this research were to determine the sensitivity of P. cactorum and P. nicotianae isolates from strawberry to azoxystrobin and to investigate mechanisms of quinone-outside-inhibitor resistance present in P. cactorum and P. nicotianae based on the known point mutations within the cytochrome b (cytb) gene. Isolates of both Phytophthora spp. causing LR and PhCR were collected from multiple strawberry fields in Florida between 1997 and 2020. Isolates were tested for sensitivity to azoxystrobin at 0, 0.01, 0.1, 1.0, 10, and 50 μg/ml on potato dextrose agar amended with salicylhydroxamic acid (100 μg/ml). Isolates were separated into two groups - sensitive isolates with the 50% effective concentration (EC₅₀) values <1.0 μg/ml, and resistant isolates having EC₅₀ values >50 μg/ml. P. cactorum and P. nicotianae resistance to azoxystrobin was found for isolates collected after 2010. The first 450 nucleotides of the mitochondrial cytb gene were sequenced from a selection of resistant and sensitive isolates of both species. The G143A mutation reported to confer resistance to azoxystrobin was found in all resistant P. cactorum isolates. However, in P. nicotianae, qualitative resistance was observed, but the isolates lacked all the known mutations in the cytb gene. This is the first report of resistance to azoxystrobin in P. cactorum and P. nicotianae.

Mixed-Mating Model of Reproduction Revealed in European Phytophthora cactorum by ddRADseq and Effector Gene Sequence Data

A population study of Phytophthora cactorum was performed using ddRADseq sequence variation analysis completed by the analysis of effector genes-RXLR6, RXLR7 and SCR113. The population structure was described by F-statistics, heterozygosity, nucleotide diversity, number of private alleles, number of polymorphic sites, kinship coefficient and structure analysis. The population of P. cactorum in Europe seems to be structured into host-associated groups. The isolates from woody hosts are structured into four groups described previously, while isolates from strawberry form another group. The groups are diverse in effector gene composition and the frequency of outbreeding. When populations from strawberry were analysed, both asexual reproduction and occasional outbreeding confirmed by gene flow among distinct populations were detected. Therefore, distinct P. cactorum populations differ in the level of heterozygosity. The data support the theory of the mixed-mating model for P. cactorum, comprising frequent asexual behaviour and inbreeding alternating with occasional outbreeding. Because P. cactorum is not indigenous to Europe, such variability is probably caused by multiple introductions of different lineages from the area of its original distribution, and the different histories of sexual recombination and host adaptation of particular populations.

Phytophthora abietivora, A New Species Isolated from Diseased Christmas Trees in Connecticut, U.S.A

A number of fir species (Abies) are produced as Christmas trees around the world. In particular, Fraser fir (Abies fraseri (Pursh) Poir.) is popular as it yields high-quality Christmas trees in temperate North America and Europe. A Phytophthora sp. causing root rot on Fraser fir was isolated from a Christmas tree farm in Connecticut, U.S.A., and found to be new to science according to morphological and molecular phylogenetic analysis using multilocus DNA sequences from ITS, Cox1, β-Tub, Nadh1, and Hsp90 loci. Thus, it was described and illustrated as Phytophthora abietivora. An informative Koch's postulates test revealed that P. abietivora was the pathogen causing root rot of Fraser fir.

Expression of the GAF Sensor, Carbohydrate-Active Enzymes, Elicitins, and RXLRs Differs Markedly Between Two Phytophthora cactorum Isolates

The phytopathogen Phytophthora cactorum infects economically important herbaceous and woody plant species. P. cactorum isolates differ in host specificity; for example, strawberry crown rot is often caused by a specialized pathotype. Here we compared the transcriptomes of two P. cactorum isolates that differ in their virulence to garden strawberry (Pc407: high virulence; Pc440: low virulence). De novo transcriptome assembly and clustering of contigs resulted in 19,372 gene clusters. Two days after inoculation of Fragaria vesca roots, 3,995 genes were differently expressed between the P. cactorum isolates. One of the genes that were highly expressed only in Pc407 encodes a GAF sensor protein potentially involved in membrane trafficking processes. Two days after inoculation, elicitins were highly expressed in Pc407 and lipid catabolism appeared to be more active than in Pc440. Of the carbohydrate-active enzymes, those that degrade pectin were often more highly expressed in Pc440, whereas members of glycosyl hydrolase family 1, potentially involved in the metabolism of glycosylated secondary metabolites, were more highly expressed in Pc407 at the time point studied. Differences were also observed among the RXLR effectors: Pc407 appears to rely on a smaller set of key RXLR effectors, whereas Pc440 expresses a greater number of RXLRs. This study is the first step toward improving understanding of the molecular basis of differences in the virulence of P. cactorum isolates. Identification of the key effectors is important, as it enables effector-assisted breeding strategies toward crown rot-resistant strawberry cultivars.

An Assessment of the Genetic Diversity in a Field Population of Phytophthora nicotianae with a Changing Race Structure

One hundred fifty-three isolates of Phytophthora nicotianae that were collected over a 4-year period from a single field were subjected to amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analysis to investigate the effect of different types of resistance in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) on genetic diversity in the pathogen population. No race 1 isolates were detected in the field prior to initiating the study, but the race was present in multiple plots by the end of the 4-year period. There were 102 race 0 isolates and 51 race 1 isolates characterized. Seventy-six of the 153 isolates had a unique AFLP profile, whereas the remaining 77 isolates were represented by 27 AFLP profiles shared by at least two isolates. Isolates of both races were found in both the unique and shared AFLP profile groups. Twenty-three of the AFLP profiles were detected in multiple years, indicating a clonal component to the pathogen population. Race 1 isolates that were detected over multiple years were always obtained from the same plot. No race 1 profile was found in more than one plot, confirming the hypothesis that the multiple occurrences of the race throughout the field were the result of independent events and not pathogen spread. Three identical race 0 AFLP profiles occurred in noncontiguous plots, and in each case, the plots contained the same partially resistant variety. Cluster analysis provided a high level of bootstrap support for 41 isolates in 19 clusters that grouped primarily by race and rotation treatment. Estimates of genetic diversity ranged from 0.365 to 0.831 and varied depending on tobacco cultivar planted and race. When averaged over all treatments, diversity in race 1 isolates was lower than in race 0 isolates at the end of each season. Deployment of single-gene resistance initially decreased genetic diversity of the population, but the diversity increased each year, indicating the pathogen was adapting to the host genotypes deployed in the field.

Baseline and Differential Sensitivity to Two QoI Fungicides Among Isolates of Phytophthora cactorum That Cause Leather Rot and Crown Rot on Strawberry

Sensitivities of 89 isolates of Phytophthora cactorum, the causal agent of crown rot and leather rot on strawberry plants, from seven states (Florida, Maine, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, South Carolina, and New York) to the QoI fungicide azoxystrobin were determined based on mycelium growth and zoospore germination. Radial growth of mycelia on lima bean agar amended with azoxystrobin at 0.001, 0.01, 0.1, 1.0, 10, and 30 μg/ml and salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM) at 100 μg/ml was measured after 6 days. Effect on zoospore germination was evaluated in aqueous solutions of azoxystrobin at 0.005, 0.01, 0.05, 0.1, 0.5, and 1.0 μg/ml in 96-well microtiter plates by counting germinated and nongerminated zoospores after 4 h at room temperature. SHAM was not used to evaluate zoospore sensitivity. The effective dose to reduce mycelium growth by 50% (ED₅₀) ranged from 0.16 to 12.52 μg/ml for leather rot isolates and 0.10 to 15 μg/ml for crown rot isolates. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test showed significant differences (P < 0.001) between the two distributions. Zoospores were much more sensitive to azoxystrobin than were mycelia. Differences between sensitivity distributions for zoospores from leather rot and crown rot isolates were significant at P = 0.05. Estimated ED₅₀ values ranged from 0.01 to 0.24 μg/ml with a median of 0.04 μg/ml. Experiments with pyraclostrobin, another QoI fungicide, demonstrated that both mycelia and zoospores of P. cactorum were more sensitive to pyraclostrobin than to azoxystrobin. Sensitivities to azoxystrobin and pyraclostrobin were moderately but significantly correlated (r = 0.60, P = 0.0001).

Genetic diversity and population differentiation of chestnut blight fungus, Cryphonectria parasitica, in China as revealed by RAPD

Seventeen Cryphonectria parasitica populations sampled from six regions in China were investigated using RAPD. Across all 169 isolates from the 17 populations evaluated, 52 of the 71 markers (73%) were polymorphic, total genetic diversity (h) was 0.1463, and Shannon's index was 0.2312. Diversity within populations accounted for 74% of total genetic diversity, and genetic differentiation among populations was 0.26 (G (ST) = 0.26). Gene flow was 1.4 among the populations; higher gene flow was found among populations within regions and among regions [N (m) (G (SR)) = 2.8 and N (m) (G (RT)) = 3.5]. The unweighted pair group mean analysis (UPGMA) dendrogram revealed two distinct clusters: the northern China group and the southern China group. The spatial autocorrelation analysis revealed that the variation at most loci was randomly distributed and lacked spatial structure, but several loci and closer distances were spatially structured. Human activity and habitat could also be important factors affecting genetic structure among C. parasitica populations in China. Genetic diversity was highest in Southwest China, descending in an orderly fashion to Northeast China. This pattern indicated that Southwest China might be the center of origin of C. parasitica in China. The present study provides useful information for understanding the origin and spread of chestnut blight fungus in China and valuable data for formulating relevant strategies for controlling the disease in China.

Genetic and Pathogenic Variation in Phytophthora cactorum Affecting Fruit and Nut Crops in California

Isolates of Phytophthora cactorum and 15 other species of Phytophthora were characterized according to their genomic DNA, pathogenicity, and sensitivity to mefenoxam. Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analysis was completed for 132 isolates of P. cactorum (30 from almond, 86 from strawberry, 5 from walnut, and 11 from other hosts) and 22 isolates of 15 other Phytophthora spp. from various hosts. All 16 Phytophthora spp. were distinguishable by unique AFLP banding patterns. Cluster analysis of the AFLP data revealed high coefficients of genetic similarity (>0.9) among all California isolates of P. cactorum. Analysis of molecular variance indicated that, among all 132 isolates of P. cactorum, 30.8 and 24.5% of the AFLP variation was associated with hosts and geographical sources of isolates, respectively, whereas 15.0% of the variation was associated with isolate niche (i.e., an aerial plant part, portion of the root system, or soil). Among the 86 isolates of P. cactorum from strawberry, characterization by source in the production system (i.e., fruiting field or plant nursery) did not account for a significant proportion of the variation (0.6%, P = 0.204). In pathogenicity tests on strawberry plants (cv. Diamante) in a greenhouse, isolates of P. cactorum from hosts other than strawberry and an isolate from a strawberry fruit caused only negligible amounts of disease, but isolates from strawberry root systems were highly aggressive. On excised shoot segments of almond (cv. Drake), all isolates of P. cactorum originally from almond were pathogenic, and 8 of 17 isolates of the pathogen from other hosts caused significantly less disease than the almond isolates. All 132 isolates of P. cactorum were sensitive to mefenoxam at 1 ppm. Populations of P. cactorum in California apparently are mefenoxam sensitive and exhibit host specificity with relatively minor variation in genomic DNA. The genetic variation observed in P. cactorum included significant geographical and host origin components, which has implications for disease management approaches.