The temperature and type of intracellular ice formation in preimplantation mouse embryos as a function of the developmental stage

An all-37 °C thawing method improves the clinical outcomes of vitrified frozen-thawed embryo transfer: a retrospective study using a case-control matching analysis

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to assess the impact of different temperatures and incubation times on the clinical outcomes of FET cycles during the thawing procedure and to select a better thawing method to improve clinical outcomes.

METHODS

This retrospective study included 1734 FET cycles from January 1, 2020, to January 30, 2022. Embryos vitrified using a KITAZATO Vitrification Kit were thawed at 37 °C in all steps (the case group, denoted the "all-37 °C" group) or at 37 °C and then at room temperature (RT; the control group, denoted the "37 °C-RT" group), according to the kit instructions. The groups were matched 1:1 to avoid confounding.

RESULTS

After case-control matching, 366 all-37 °C cycles and 366 37 °C-RT cycles were included. The baseline characteristics were similar (all P > 0.05) between the two groups after matching. FET of the all-37 °C group yielded a higher clinical pregnancy rate (CPR; P = 0.009) and implantation rate (IR; P = 0.019) than FET of the 37 °C-RT group. For blastocyst transfers, the CPR (P = 0.019) and IR (P = 0.025) were significantly higher in the all-37 °C group than in the 37 °C-RT group. For D3-embryo transfers, the CPR and IR were non-significantly higher in the all-37 °C group than in the 37 °C-RT group (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Thawing vitrified embryos at 37 °C in all steps with shortening wash time can enhance CPR and IR in FET cycles. Well-designed prospective studies are warranted to further evaluate the efficacy and safety of the all-37 °C thawing method.

Equilibrium vitrification of mouse embryos at various developmental stages using low concentrations of cryoprotectants

We previously developed a new vitrification method (equilibrium vitrification) by which two-cell mouse embryos can be vitrified in liquid nitrogen in a highly dehydrated/concentrated state using low concentrations of cryoprotectants. In the present study, we examined whether this method is effective for mouse embryos at multiple developmental stages. Four-cell embryos, eight-cell embryos, morulae, and blastocysts were vitrified with EDFS10/10a, 10% (v/v) ethylene glycol and 10% (v/v) DMSO in FSa solution. The FSa solution was PB1 medium containing 30% (w/v) Ficoll PM-70 plus 0.5 M sucrose. The state of dehydration/concentration was assessed by examining the survival of vitrified embryos after storage at -80°C. When four-cell embryos and eight-cell embryos were vitrified with EDFS10/10a in liquid nitrogen and then stored at -80°C, the survival rate was high, even after 28 days, with relatively high developmental ability. On the other hand, the survival of morulae and blastocysts vitrified in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80°C for four days was low. Therefore, morulae and blastocysts cannot be vitrified in a highly dehydrated/concentrated state using the same method as with two-cell embryos. However, when blastocysts were shrunken artificially before vitrification, survival was high after storage at -80°C for four days with high developmental ability. In conclusion, the equilibrium vitrification method using low concentrations of cryoprotectants, which is effective for two-cell mouse embryos, is also useful for embryos at multiple stages. This method enables the convenient transportation of vitrified embryos using dry ice.

Intracellular ice formation in mouse zygotes and early morulae vs. cooling rate and temperature-experimental vs. theory

In this study, mature female mice of the ICR strain were induced to superovultate, mated, and collected at either zygote or early morula stages. Embryos suspended in 1 M ethylene glycol in PBS containing 10 mg/L Snomax for 15 min, then transferred in sample holder to Linkam cryostage, cooled to and seeded at 7 °C, and then observed and photographed while being cooled to −70 °C at 0.5–20 °C/min. Intracellular ice formation (IIF) was observed as abrupt ‘‘flashing’’. Two types of flashing or IIF were observed in this study. Extracellular freezing occurred at a mean of −7.7 °C. In morulae, about 25% turned dark within ±1 °C of extracellular ice formation (EIF). These we refer to as “high temperature’’ flashers. In zygotes, there were no high temperature flashers. All the zygotes flashed at temperatures well below the temperature for EIF. Presumably high temperature flashers were a consequence of membrane damage prior to EIF or damage from EIF. We shall not discuss them further. In the majority of cases, IIF occurred well below −7.7 °C; these we call ‘‘low temperature’’ flashers. None flashed with cooling rate (CR) of 0.5 °C/min in either zygotes or morulae. Nearly all flashed with CR of 4 °C/min or higher, but the distribution of temperatures is much broader with morulae than with zygotes. Also, the mean flashing temperature is much higher with morulae (−20.9 °C) than with zygotes (−40.3 °C). We computed the kinetics of water loss with respect to CR and temperature in both mouse zygotes and in morulae based on published estimates of Lp and it is Ea. The resulting dehydration curves combined with knowledge of the embryo nucleation temperature permits an estimate of the likelihood of IIF as a function of CR and subzero temperature. The agreement between these computed probabilities and the observed values are good.

Measurement of intracellular ice formation kinetics by high-speed video cryomicroscopy

Quantitative information about the kinetics and cumulative probability of intracellular ice formation is necessary to develop minimally damaging freezing procedures for the cryopreservation of cells and tissue. Conventional cryomicroscopic assays, which rely on indirect evidence of intracellular freezing (e.g., opacity changes in the cell cytoplasm), can yield significant errors in the estimated kinetics. In contrast, the formation and growth of intracellular ice crystals can be accurately detected using temporally resolved imaging methods (i.e., video recording at sub-millisecond resolution). Here, detailed methods for the setup and operation of a high-speed video cryomicroscope system are described, including protocols for imaging of intracellular ice crystallization events, and stochastic analysis of the ice formation kinetics in a cell population. Recommendations are provided for temperature profile design, sample preparation, and configuration of the video acquisition parameters. Throughout this chapter, the protocols incorporate best practices that have been drawn from over a decade of experience with high-speed video cryomicroscopy in our laboratory.

Rectification of the water permeability in COS-7 cells at 22, 10 and 0°C

The osmotic and permeability parameters of a cell membrane are essential physico-chemical properties of a cell and particularly important with respect to cell volume changes and the regulation thereof. Here, we report the hydraulic conductivity, L(p), the non-osmotic volume, V(b), and the Arrhenius activation energy, E(a), of mammalian COS-7 cells. The ratio of V(b) to the isotonic cell volume, V(c iso), was 0.29. E(a), the activation energy required for the permeation of water through the cell membrane, was 10,700, and 12,000 cal/mol under hyper- and hypotonic conditions, respectively. Average values for L(p) were calculated from swell/shrink curves by using an integrated equation for L(p). The curves represented the volume changes of 358 individually measured cells, placed into solutions of nonpermeating solutes of 157 or 602 mOsm/kg (at 0, 10 or 22°C) and imaged over time. L(p) estimates for all six combinations of osmolality and temperature were calculated, resulting in values of 0.11, 0.21, and 0.10 µm/min/atm for exosmotic flow and 0.79, 1.73 and 1.87 µm/min/atm for endosmotic flow (at 0, 10 and 22°C, respectively). The unexpected finding of several fold higher L(p) values for endosmotic flow indicates highly asymmetric membrane permeability for water in COS-7. This phenomenon is known as rectification and has mainly been reported for plant cell, but only rarely for animal cells. Although the mechanism underlying the strong rectification found in COS-7 cells is yet unknown, it is a phenomenon of biological interest and has important practical consequences, for instance, in the development of optimal cryopreservation.

Effect of the expression of aquaporins 1 and 3 in mouse oocytes and compacted eight-cell embryos on the nucleation temperature for intracellular ice formation

The occurrence of intracellular ice formation (IIF) is the most important factor determining whether cells survive a cryopreservation procedure. What is not clear is the mechanism or route by which an external ice crystal can traverse the plasma membrane and cause the heterogeneous nucleation of the supercooled solution within the cell. We have hypothesized that one route is through preexisting pores in aquaporin (AQP) proteins that span the plasma membranes of many cell types. Since the plasma membrane of mature mouse oocytes expresses little AQP, we compared the ice nucleation temperature of native oocytes with that of oocytes induced to express AQP1 and AQP3. The oocytes were suspended in 1.0  M ethylene glycol in PBS for 15  min, cooled in a Linkam cryostage to -7.0  ° C, induced to freeze externally, and finally cooled at 20  ° C/min to -70  ° C. IIF that occurred during the 20  ° C/min cooling is manifested by abrupt black flashing. The mean IIF temperatures for native oocytes, for oocytes sham injected with water, for oocytes expressing AQP1, and for those expressing AQP3 were -34, -40, -35, and -25  ° C respectively. The fact that the ice nucleation temperature of oocytes expressing AQP3 was 10-15  ° C higher than the others is consistent with our hypothesis. AQP3 pores can supposedly be closed by low pH or by treatment with double-stranded Aqp3 RNA. However, when morulae were subjected to such treatments, the IIF temperature still remained high. A possible explanation is suggested.

Stability of mouse oocytes at -80 °C: the role of the recrystallization of intracellular ice

The germplasm of mutant mice is stored as frozen oocytes/embryos in many facilities worldwide. Their transport to and from such facilities should be easy and inexpensive with dry ice at -79 °C. The purpose of our study was to determine the stability of mouse oocytes with time at that temperature. The metaphase II oocytes were cryopreserved with a vitrification solution (EAFS10/10) developed by M Kasai and colleagues. Two procedures were followed. In one, the samples were cooled at 187 °C/min to -196 °C, warmed to -80 °C, held at -80 °C for 1 h to 3 months, and warmed to 25 °C at one of three rates. With the highest warming rate (2950 °C/min), survival remained at 75% for the first month, but then slowly declined to 40% over the next 2 months. With the slowest warming (139 °C/min), survival was only ∼ 5% even at 0 time at -80 °C. In the second procedure, the samples were cooled at 294 °C/min to -80 °C (without cooling to -196 °C) and held for up to 3 months before warming at 2950 °C/min. Survival was ∼ 90% after 7 days and dropped slowly to 35% after 3 months. We believe that small non-lethal quantities of intracellular ice formed during the cooling and that the intracellular crystals increased to a damaging size by recrystallization during the 3 month's storage at -80 °C. From the practical point of view, this protocol yields sufficient stability to make it feasible to ship oocytes worldwide in dry ice.

Comparison between the temperatures of intracellular ice formation in fresh mouse oocytes and embryos and those previously subjected to a vitrification procedure

When cells that have been subjected to supposedly innocuous freezing or vitrification procedures are used as the source material for subsequent experiments, it is important that they possess or exhibit the same relevant properties as fresh cells. In this study, we compared the temperatures of intracellular ice formation (IIF) in previously vitrified mouse oocytes/embryos with those in fresh intact ones. In the case of MII oocytes, 2-cell embryos, 4-6-cell embryos, and morulae, there are no significant differences (p>0.05); namely, -33.3 degrees C (fresh) vs. -35.4 degrees C (vitrified) with MII oocytes, -40.6 degrees C (fresh) vs. -38.7 degrees C (vitrified) with 2-cell embryos, -38.0 degrees C (fresh) vs. -39.4 degrees C (vitrified) with 4-6-cell embryos, -24.5 degrees C (fresh) vs. -24.2 degrees C (vitrified) with morulae. But, in 8-cell embryos, there is a significant difference (p<0.05) between fresh (-37.9 degrees C) and vitrified (-32.9 degrees C). If we include this significant difference, the overall IIF temperature of fresh cells is 0.74 degrees C lower than that of previously vitrified cells. If we exclude it, the IIF temperature for fresh cells is 0.32 degrees C higher than that for previously vitrified cells. Our conclusion then is that there is no difference between the IIF temperatures of fresh and previously vitrified cells.