Developmentally regulated loss and reappearance of immunoreactive somatic histone H1 on chromatin of bovine morula-stage nuclei following transplantation into oocytes

Simultaneous Inhibition of Histone Deacetylases and RNA Synthesis Enables Totipotency Reprogramming in Pig SCNT Embryos

Combining somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) with genome editing technologies has emerged as a powerful platform for the creation of unique swine lineages for agricultural and biomedical applications. However, successful application of this research platform is still hampered by the low efficiency of these technologies, particularly in attaining complete cell reprogramming for the production of cloned pigs. Treating SCNT embryos with histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACis), such as Scriptaid, has been routinely used to facilitate chromatin reprogramming after nuclear transfer. While increasing histone acetylation leads to a more relaxed chromatin configuration that facilitates the access of reprogramming factors and DNA repair machinery, it may also promote the expression of genes that are unnecessary or detrimental for normal embryo development. In this study, we evaluated the impact of inhibiting both histone deacetylases and RNA synthesis on pre- and post-implantation development of pig SCNT embryos. Our findings revealed that transcription can be inhibited for up to 40 h of development in porcine embryos, produced either by activation, fertilization or SCNT, without detrimentally affecting their capacity to form a blastocyst and their average number of cells at this developmental stage. Importantly, inhibiting RNA synthesis during HDACi treatment resulted in SCNT blastocysts with a greater number of cells and more abundant transcripts for genes related to embryo genome activation on days 2, 3 and 4 of development, compared to SCNT embryos that were treated with HDACi only. In addition, concomitant inhibition of histone deacetylases and RNA synthesis promoted the full reprograming of somatic cells, as evidenced by the normal fetal and full-term development of SCNT embryos. This combined treatment may improve the efficiency of the genome-editing + SCNT platform in swine, which should be further tested by transferring more SCNT embryos and evaluating the health and growth performance of the cloned pigs.

Enhancement of Chromatin and Epigenetic Reprogramming in Porcine SCNT Embryos—Progresses and Perspectives

Over the last 25 years, cloned animals have been produced by transferring somatic cell nuclei into enucleated oocytes (SCNT) in more than 20 mammalian species. Among domestic animals, pigs are likely the leading species in the number of clones produced by SCNT. The greater interest in pig cloning has two main reasons, its relevance for food production and as its use as a suitable model in biomedical applications. Recognized progress in animal cloning has been attained over time, but the overall efficiency of SCNT in pigs remains very low, based on the rate of healthy, live born piglets following embryo transfer. Accumulating evidence from studies in mice and other species indicate that new strategies for promoting chromatin and epigenetic reprogramming may represent the beginning of a new era for pig cloning.

Chromatin remodeling in Drosophila preblastodermic embryo extract

Chromatin is known to undergo extensive remodeling during nuclear reprogramming. However, the factors and mechanisms involved in this remodeling are still poorly understood and current experimental approaches to study it are not best suited for molecular and genetic analyses. Here we report on the use of Drosophila preblastodermic embryo extracts (DREX) in chromatin remodeling experiments. Our results show that incubation of somatic nuclei in DREX induces changes in chromatin organization similar to those associated with nuclear reprogramming, such as rapid binding of the germline specific linker histone dBigH1 variant to somatic chromatin, heterochromatin reorganization, changes in the epigenetic state of chromatin, and nuclear lamin disassembly. These results raise the possibility of using the powerful tools of Drosophila genetics for the analysis of chromatin changes associated with this essential process.

Real-time observation of nucleoplasmin-mediated DNA decondensation and condensation reveals its specific functions as a chaperone

Fertilization requires decondensation of promatine-condensed sperm chromatin, a dynamic process serving as an attractive system for the study of chromatin reprogramming. Nucleoplasmin is a key factor in regulating nucleosome assembly as a chaperone during fertilization process. However, knowledge on nucleoplasmin in chromatin formation remains elusive. Herein, magnetic tweezers (MT) and a chromatin assembly system were used to study the nucleoplasmin-mediated DNA decondensation/condensation at the single-molecular level in vitro. We found that protamine induces DNA condensation in a stepwise manner. Once DNA was condensed, nucleoplasmin, polyglutamic acid, and RNA could remove protamine from the DNA at different rates. The affinity binding of the different polyanions with protamine suggests chaperone-mediated chromatin decondensation activity occurs through protein-protein interactions. After decondensation, both RNA and polyglutamic acid prevented the transfer of histones onto the naked DNA. In contrast, nucleoplasmin is able to assist the histone transfer process, even though it carries the same negative charge as RNA and polyglutamic acid. These observations imply that the chaperone effects of nucleoplasmin during the decondensation/condensation process may be driven by specific spatial configuration of its acidic pentamer structure, rather than by electrostatic interaction. Our findings offer a novel molecular understanding of nucleoplasmin in sperm chromatin decondensation and subsequent developmental chromatin reprogramming at individual molecular level.

Germline-specific H1 variants: the "sexy" linker histones

The eukaryotic genome is packed into chromatin, a nucleoprotein complex mainly formed by the interaction of DNA with the abundant basic histone proteins. The fundamental structural and functional subunit of chromatin is the nucleosome core particle, which is composed by 146 bp of DNA wrapped around an octameric protein complex formed by two copies of each core histone H2A, H2B, H3, and H4. In addition, although not an intrinsic component of the nucleosome core particle, linker histone H1 directly interacts with it in a monomeric form. Histone H1 binds nucleosomes near the exit/entry sites of linker DNA, determines nucleosome repeat length and stabilizes higher-order organization of nucleosomes into the ∼30 nm chromatin fiber. In comparison to core histones, histone H1 is less well conserved through evolution. Furthermore, histone H1 composition in metazoans is generally complex with most species containing multiple variants that play redundant as well as specific functions. In this regard, a characteristic feature is the presence of specific H1 variants that replace somatic H1s in the germline and during early embryogenesis. In this review, we summarize our current knowledge about their structural and functional properties.

Chemically induced enucleation of activated bovine oocytes: chromatin and microtubule organization and production of viable cytoplasts

As the standard enucleation method in mammalian nuclear transfer is invasive and damaging to cytoplast spatial organization, alternative procedures have been developed over recent years. Among these techniques, chemically induced enucleation (IE) is especially interesting because it does not employ ultraviolet light and reduces the amount of cytoplasm eliminated during the procedure. The objective of this study was to optimize the culture conditions with demecolcine of pre-activated bovine oocytes for chemically IE, and to evaluate nuclear and microtubule organization in cytoplasts obtained by this technique and their viability. In the first experiment, a negative effect on oocyte activation was verified when demecolcine was added at the beginning of the process, reducing activation rates by approximately 30%. This effect was not observed when demecolcine was added to the medium after 1.5 h of activation. In the second experiment, although a reduction in the number of microtubules was observed in most oocytes, these structures did not disappear completely during assessment. Approximately 50% of treated oocytes presented microtubule reduction at the end of the evaluation period, while 23% of oocytes were observed to exhibit the complete disappearance of these structures and 28% exhibited visible microtubules. These findings indicated the lack of immediate microtubule repolymerization after culture in demecolcine-free medium, a fact that may negatively influence embryonic development. However, cleavage rates of 63.6–70.0% and blastocyst yield of 15.5–24.2% were obtained in the final experiment, without significant differences between techniques, indicating that chemically induced enucleation produces normal embryos.

Reprogramming mammalian somatic cells

Somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), the technique commonly known as cloning, permits transformation of a somatic cell into an undifferentiated zygote with the potential to develop into a newborn animal (i.e., a clone). In somatic cells, chromatin is programmed to repress most genes and express some, depending on the tissue. It is evident that the enucleated oocyte provides the environment in which embryonic genes in a somatic cell can be expressed. This process is controlled by a series of epigenetic modifications, generally referred to as "nuclear reprogramming," which are thought to involve the removal of reversible epigenetic changes acquired during cell differentiation. A similar process is thought to occur by overexpression of key transcription factors to generate induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), bypassing the need for SCNT. Despite its obvious scientific and medical importance, and the great number of studies addressing the subject, the molecular basis of reprogramming in both reprogramming strategies is largely unknown. The present review focuses on the cellular and molecular events that occur during nuclear reprogramming in the context of SCNT and the various approaches currently being used to improve nuclear reprogramming. A better understanding of the reprogramming mechanism will have a direct impact on the efficiency of current SCNT procedures, as well as iPSC derivation.

Chemically assisted enucleation results in higher G6PD expression in early bovine female embryos obtained by somatic cell nuclear transfer

Despite extensive efforts, low efficiency is still an issue in bovine somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT). The hypothesis of our study was that the use of cytoplasts produced by chemically assisted enucleation (EN) would improve nuclear reprogramming in nuclear transfer (NT)-derived embryos because it results in lower damage and higher cytoplasm content than conventional EN. For that purpose, we investigated the expression of two X-linked genes: X inactive-specific transcript (XIST) and glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD). In the first experiment, gene expression was assessed in day-7 female blastocysts from embryonic cell NT (ECNT) groups [conventional, ECNT conv; chemically assisted, ECNT deme (demecolcine)]. Whereas in the ECNT conv group, only one embryo (25%; n=4) expressed XIST transcripts, most embryos showed XIST expression (75%; n=4) in the ECNT deme group. However, no significant differences in transcript abundance of XIST and G6PD were found when comparing the embryos from all groups. In a second experiment using somatic cells as nuclear donors, we evaluated gene expression profiles in female SCNT-derived embryos. No significant differences in relative abundance (RA) of XIST transcripts were observed among the groups. Nonetheless, higher (p<0.05) levels of G6PD were observed in SCNT deme and in vitro-derived groups in comparison to SCNT conv. To know whether higher G6PD expression in embryos derived from SCNT chemically assisted EN indicates higher metabolism in embryos considered of superior quality or if the presence of higher reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels generated by the increased oxygen consumption triggers G6PD activation, the expression of genes related to stress response should be investigated in embryos produced by that technique.

Evidence for conserved DNA and histone H3 methylation reprogramming in mouse, bovine and rabbit zygotes

BACKGROUND

In mammals the parental genomes are epigenetically reprogrammed after fertilization. This reprogramming includes a rapid demethylation of the paternal (sperm-derived) chromosomes prior to DNA replication in zygotes. Such active DNA demethylation in the zygote has been documented for several mammalian species, including mouse, rat, pig, human and cow, but questioned to occur in rabbit.

RESULTS

When comparing immunohistochemical patterns of antibodies against 5-methyl-cytosine, H3K4me3 and H3K9me2 modifications we observe similar pronuclear distribution and dynamics in mouse, bovine and rabbit zygotes. In rabbit DNA demethylation of the paternal chromosomes occurs at slightly advanced pronuclear stages. We also show that the rabbit oocyte rapidly demethylates DNA of donor fibroblast after nuclear transfer.

CONCLUSION

Our data reveal that major events of epigenetic reprogramming during pronuclear maturation, including mechanisms of active DNA demethylation, are apparently conserved among mammalian species.

Role of histone methylation in zygotic genome activation in the preimplantation mouse embryo

Numerous previous studies demonstrated that gene expression was influenced by histone modifications. However, little information is available about the relation of histone methylation with embryonic gene expression. Here, we examine the significance of histone H3 dimethyl-lysine 4 (H3K4me2) during mouse zygotic genome activation (ZGA) by inhibiting demethylation with the specific histone H3 lysine 4 demethylase inhibitor bisguanidine 1c (1c). A 1c treatment of one-cell embryos did not significantly affect the level of eIF-4C transcripts but did affect Oct4 levels by the two-cell stage. Furthermore, 1c treatment significantly inhibited cleavage of the embryos to the four-cell stage (from 82.7% to 18.2%), and the inhibitory effect was identified to be irreversible. These results suggest that histone methylation may be closely correlated with the formation of a transcriptionally repressive state during ZGA and that the repressive state actually dictates the appropriate pattern of gene expression required for further development.

Telophase-stage host ooplasts support complete reprogramming of roscovitine-treated somatic cell nuclei in cattle

Nuclear-cytoplasmic incompatibilities are known to play a significant role in the developmental outcome of embryos produced by nuclear transfer, particularly when metaphase arrested oocytes are used as hosts for interphase donor nuclei. To further our understanding of how cell cycle coordination affects somatic cell cloning, somatic cells at different stages of the cell cycle were fused to host oocytes either before (metaphase II, M-II) or after (telophase II, T-II) activation. To obtain cells at different stages of the cell cycle, fetal fibroblast (FF) and granulosa cells (GC) were treated with roscovitine, an inhibitor of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) resulting in a large percentage of cells in S/G(2)-phase. In contrast to the M-II group, which did better with confluent cells, embryos reconstructed with T-II cytoplasts resulted in higher rates of blastocyst formation when fused to cells recovered at 16-24 h after passage. Embryos reconstructed with FF treated with roscovitine and T-II cytoplasts (Rosc/T-II) resulted in similar blastocyst rate compared to those produced with confluent cells and M-II cytoplasts (Conf/M-II). Transfer of blastocysts to surrogate heifers resulted pregnancies and birth of healthy calves from Rosc/T-II and Conf/M-II reconstructed embryos. These results indicate that, when combined with nuclear donor cells at specific cell cycle stages, M-II and T-II bovine oocytes are similarly effective in supporting the reprogramming of somatic cell nuclei.

Immunolocalization of the High-Mobility Group N2 protein and acetylated histone H3K14 in early developing parthenogenetic bovine embryos derived from oocytes of high and low developmental competence

This study investigated differences in the distribution of acetylated histone H3 at Lysine 14 (H3K14ac) and the High-Mobility Group N2 (HMGN2) protein in the chromatin of early- (before 24 hr) and late-cleaved (after 24 hr) bovine embryos derived from small- (1-2 mm) and large-follicles (4-8 mm). The presence of HMGN2 and H3K14ac has been associated with different nuclear functions including chromatin condensation, transcription, DNA replication and repair. In vitro matured oocytes were parthenogenetically activated (PA) and cultured in synthetic oviduct fluid medium. Early- and late-cleaved embryos were fixed at 36, 50, 60, 70 and 80 hr after PA to detect the presence of H3K14ac and HMGN2. The rates of nuclear maturation (81.1% vs. 58.7%), early cleavage (46.9% vs. 38.9%), and development to blastocyst stage (34.3% vs. 18.9%) were higher (P < 0.05) in oocytes derived from large- compared to small follicles. The proportion of positively stained nuclei at 50 and 60 hr after PA was higher for both H3K14ac (27.2% vs. 4.8% and 64.3% vs. 30%) and HMGN2 (47% vs. 21.3% and 60.6% vs. 46%) in early versus late cleaved embryos derived from small- versus large-follicles, respectively. However, the rate of positive nuclei in early-cleaved embryos from small-versus large-follicles was similar for HMGN2 (87% vs. 93%) but lower for H3K14ac (51% vs. 64.4%) at 80 hr after PA. These data suggest that less developmentally competent embryos derived from small follicles had an altered chromatin remodeling process at the early stages of development compared to those derived from large follicles that are more competent to support development to blastocyst stage.

Early zygotes are suitable recipients for bovine somatic nuclear transfer and result in cloned offspring

Cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) subverts sperm-mediated fertilization that normally leads to physiological activation of the oocyte. Therefore, artificial activation is required and it is presently unclear what developmental consequences this has. In this study, we aimed to improve cattle cloning efficiency by utilizing a more physiological method of activating SCNT reconstructs. We carried outin vitrofertilization (IVF) of zona-intact bovine oocytes before SCNT. We removed the zona pellucida 4 h after insemination, stained the fertilized eggs with Hoechst 33342 and mechanically removed both male and female chromatin. The enucleated pre-activated cytoplasts were fused with male adult ear skin fibroblasts (‘IVF-NT’ group). Chemically activated SCNT embryos, produced according to our standard operating procedure for zona-free SCNT, served as controls. After 7 days,in vitrodevelopment to blastocysts of morphological grade 1–3 or grade 1–2 was very similar in both groups (39 vs 40% and 20 vs 21% respectively). However, post-implantation development was improved after sperm-mediated activation. Across four replicate runs, pregnancy establishment at day 35 was significantly higher for IVF-NT than for control SCNT embryos (30/49 = 61 vs 17/41 = 42% respectively;P< 0.05). Development into calves at term or weaning was also higher in the IVF-NT group compared with control SCNT (9/49 = 18 vs 3/41 = 7% and 6/49 = 12 vs 3/41 = 7%;P= 0.11 and 0.34 respectively).

Are there any normal clones?

An exhaustive study of the fidelity of a clone to its parent is prohibitive because of cost and the necessary scope of experimental design. Therefore, these data must be gathered from existing observational evidence. This in itself cannot provide a definitive accounting of the abnormalities and variation found among clones or between clones and parents because there is no standardization in the data points collected between one study and another. This literature survey shows that clone developmental abnormalities, variation among clones, and variation between clone and parent are prevalent at most stages of development (cleavage, placental, fetal, neonatal, maturity), and that occasionally the observed variation greatly exceeds that which might be expected. Some variation can be explained by differences in protocols and procedures between studies. The choice of nuclear donor cell is particularly influential of variation observed between a clone and its parent. In general, however, it appears that there is an inherent stochastic response to nuclear transfer that results in clone infidelity and variation. The survey of characteristics of clone infidelity to parent and documentation of abnormalities provided here should not be viewed as exhaustive or limiting in the recording of such data from future studies. Because controlled hypothesis testing of clone fidelity or clone health may not be possible, meticulous documentation of such observational evidence is a valuable contribution to the field.

Characterization of linker histone H1FOO during bovine in vitro embryo development

Linker histones H1 are involved in various mechanisms, such as chromatin organization and gene transcription. In different organisms, a unique subtype can be found in the oocyte, however its function remains unclear. To assess the potential involvement of this oocyte linker histone (H1FOO) in chromatin modulation, we have cloned and sequenced the bovine H1FOO cDNA and followed its mRNA profile by quantitative RT-PCR in the oocyte and throughout bovine early embryo development. The highest level of mRNA was found in the germinal vesicle (GV) oocyte and diminished constantly throughout embryo development. In the 16-cell embryo and blastocyst, respectively, the mRNA levels were 200 and 2,000 times lower than in the GV oocyte. A specific antibody raised against bovine H1FOO was used to establish protein distribution in the oocyte and preimplantation embryo by immunocytochemistry. In the GV and metaphase II (MII) oocyte, as well as in the 1-, 2- and 4-cell embryo, H1FOO was localized in the cytoplasm and nucleus. The protein was uniformly spread within the cytoplasm, while it was concentrated onto the chromatin in the nucleus. In the 8- to 16-cell embryo, H1FOO's presence diminished in the cytoplasm, although it was still strongly expressed in nucleus. In the morula and blastocyst stages, the protein was totally lacking. By its position on chromatin, H1FOO could not only be involved in chromatin conformation but could also participate in activation or repression of genes during oogenesis and embryo development before embryonic genome activation.

Inheritable histone H4 acetylation of somatic chromatins in cloned embryos

A viable cloned animal indicates that epigenetic status of the differentiated cell nucleus is reprogrammed to an embryonic totipotent state. However, molecular events regarding epigenetic reprogramming of the somatic chromatin are poorly understood. Here we provide new insight that somatic chromatins are refractory to reprogramming of histone acetylation during early development. A low level of acetylated histone H4-lysine 5 (AcH4K5) of the somatic chromatin was sustained at the pronuclear stage. Unlike in vitro fertilized (IVF) embryos, the AcH4K5 level remarkably reduced at the 8-cell stage in cloned bovine embryos. The AcH4K5 status of somatic chromatins transmitted to cloned and even recloned embryos. Differences of AcH4K5 signal intensity were more distinguishable in the metaphase chromosomes between IVF and cloned embryos. Two imprinted genes, Ndn and Xist, were aberrantly expressed in cloned embryos as compared with IVF embryos, which is partly associated with the AcH4K5 signal intensity. Our findings suggest that abnormal epigenetic reprogramming in cloned embryos may be because of a memory mechanism, the epigenetic status itself of somatic chromatins.

An interclass nuclear transfer between fowl and mammal: In vitro development of chicken-to-cattle interclass embryos and the detection of chicken genetic complements

An attempt was made to develop an interclass somatic cell nuclear transfer method as an alternative means of establishing chicken embryonic stem cells. Chicken-to-cattle interclass embryos that activated calcium ionophore, cycloheximide, and cytochalasin D were developed into blastocysts, and the developing interclass embryos had chicken genetic complements.

Review: Genetic and Epigenetic Aspects of Cloning and Potential Effects on Offspring of Cloned Mammals

Although the biological mechanisms by which host cytoplasm and donor nuclei interact to produce a developmentally competent reconstructed embryo remain largely unknown, some advances have been made to our understanding of the genetic and epigenetic factors involved in the of reprogramming of the donor nucleus. Genetic alterations, which comprise changes to the genetic information in both the nuclear and cytoplasm compartments, are passed on to subsequent generations at fertilization and are a potential source of variation among cloned animals and their offspring. Apart from the major chromosomal anomalies found in developmentally arrested embryos and fetuses, less detrimental rearrangements and/or mutations are likely to go unnoticed in most donor cell karyotypes, suggesting that such problems could lead to inheritable anomalies among clones and their offspring. Mitochondrial DNA is also relevant to cloning because most animals inherit most or all of their mitochondria from the host oocyte. Epigenetic alterations to the DNA or to the histone packaging proteins are independent of gene sequences. Aberrant epigenetic events may lead to variable gene expression or mitosis and consequent effects on development and phenotype. Although much of the epigenetic marking is reset during embryogenesis and development, the impact of epimutations on progeny remains unexplored.

Rapid H1 linker histone transitions following fertilization or somatic cell nuclear transfer: evidence for a uniform developmental program in mice

H1 linker histones (H1s) are key regulators of chromatin structure and function. The functions of different H1s during early embryogenesis, and mechanisms regulating their associations with chromatin are largely unknown. The developmental transitions of H1s during oocyte growth and maturation, fertilization and early embryogenesis, and in cloned embryos were examined. Oocyte-specific H1FOO, but not somatic H1s, associated with chromatin in oocytes (growing, GV-stage, and MII-arrested), pronuclei, and polar bodies. H1FOO associated with sperm or somatic cell chromatin within 5 min of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) or somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), and completely replaced somatic H1s by 60 min. The switching from somatic H1s to H1FOO following SCNT was developmentally regulated. H1FOO was replaced by somatic H1s during the late two- and four-cell stages. H1FOO association with chromatin can occur in the presence of a nuclear envelope and independently of pronucleus formation, is regulated by factors associated with the spindle, and is likely an active process. All SCNT constructs recapitulated the normal sequence of H1 transitions, indicating that this alone does not signify a high developmental potential. A paucity of all known H1s in two-cell embryos may contribute to precocious gene transcription in fertilized embryos, and the elaboration of somatic cell characteristics in cloned embryos.

Rapid replacement of somatic linker histones with the oocyte-specific linker histone H1foo in nuclear transfer

The most distinctive feature of oocyte-specific linker histones is the specific timing of their expression during embryonic development. In Xenopus nuclear transfer, somatic linker histones in the donor nucleus are replaced with oocyte-specific linker histone B4, leading to the involvement of oocyte-specific linker histones in nuclear reprogramming. We recently have discovered a mouse oocyte-specific linker histone, named H1foo, and demonstrated its expression pattern in normal preimplantation embryos. The present study was undertaken to determine whether the replacement of somatic linker histones with H1foo occurs during the process of mouse nuclear transfer. H1foo was detected in the donor nucleus soon after transplantation. Thereafter, H1foo was restricted to the chromatin in up to two-cell stage embryos. After fusion of an oocyte with a cell expressing GFP (green fluorescent protein)-tagged somatic linker histone H1c, immediate release of H1c in the donor nucleus was observed. In addition, we used fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), and found that H1foo is more mobile than H1c in living cells. The greater mobility of H1foo may contribute to its rapid replacement and decreased stability of the embryonic chromatin structure. These results suggest that rapid replacement of H1c with H1foo may play an important role in nuclear remodeling.

Nuclear reprogramming in mammalian somatic cell nuclear cloning

Nuclear cloning is still a developing technique used to create genetically identical animals by somatic cell nuclear transfer into unfertilized eggs. Despite an intensive effort in a number of laboratories, the success rate of obtaining viable offspring from this technique remains less than 5%. In the past few years many investigators reported the reprogramming of specific nuclear activities in cloned animals, such as genome-wide gene expression patterns, DNA methylation, genetic imprinting, histone modifications and telomere length regulation. The results highlight the tremendous difficulty the clones face to reprogram the original differentiation status of the donor nuclei. Nevertheless, nuclei prepared from terminally differentiated lymphocytes can overcome this barrier and produce apparently normal mice. Study of this striking nuclear reprogramming activity should significantly contribute to our understanding of cell differentiation in more physiological settings.

The first half-century of nuclear transplantation

Fifty years after Briggs and King first succeeded in obtaining normal tadpoles from transplanted embryo nuclei in vertebrates, two general principles have emerged from work in amphibia and mammals. One is the conservation of the genome during cell differentiation. A small percentage of adult or differentiated cells have totipotent nuclei, and a much higher percentage of cells committed to one pathway of cell differentiation have multipotent nuclei. The other is the remarkable reprogramming capacity of cell, and especially egg, cytoplasm. The eventual identification of reprogramming molecules and mechanisms could facilitate a route toward cell replacement therapy in humans.

Transgene expression of green fluorescent protein and germ line transmission in cloned calves derived from in vitro-transfected somatic cells

In vitro transfection of cultured cells combined with nuclear transfer currently is the most effective procedure to produce transgenic livestock. In the present study, bovine primary fetal fibroblasts were transfected with a green fluorescent protein (GFP)-reporter transgene and used as nuclear donor cells in oocyte reconstructions. Because cell synchronization protocols are less effective after transfection, activated oocytes may be more suitable as hosts for nuclear transfer. To examine the role of host cytoplasm on transgene expression and developmental outcome, GFP-expressing fibroblasts were fused to oocytes reconstructed either before (metaphase) or after (telophase) activation. Expression of GFP was examined during early embryogenesis, in tissues of cloned calves, and again during embryogenesis, after passage through germ line using semen from the transgenic cloned offspring. Regardless of the kind of host cytoplasm used, GFP became detectable at the 8- to 16-cell stage, approximately 80 h after reconstruction, and remained positive at all later stages. After birth, although cloned calves obtained through both procedures expressed GFP in all tissues examined, expression levels varied both between tissues and between cells within the same tissue, indicating a partial shutdown of GFP expression during cellular differentiation. Moreover, nonexpressing fibroblasts derived from transgenic offspring were unable to direct GFP expression after nuclear transfer and development to the blastocyst stage, suggesting an irreversible silencing of transgenes. Nonetheless, GFP was expressed in approximately half the blastocysts obtained with sperm from a transgenic clone, confirming transmission of the transgene through the germ line.

Chromatin as a regulative architecture of the early developmental functions of mammalian embryos after fertilization or nuclear transfer

Nuclear transfer of a somatic nucleus into an enucleated oocyte has demonstrated in several mammalian species that the chromatin of a differentiated nucleus can be reprogrammed so as to be able to direct the full development of the reconstructed embryo. This review focus on the timing of the early events that allow the return of somatic chromatin to a totipotent state. Our understanding of the modifications associated with chromatin remodeling is limited by the low amount of biological material available in mammals at early developmental stages and the fact that very few genetic studies have been conducted with nuclear transfer embryos. However, the importance of several factors such as the covalent modifications of DNA through the methylation of CpG dinucleotides, the exchange of histones through a reorganized nuclear membrane, and the interaction between cytoplasmic oocyte components and nuclear complexes in the context of nuclear transfer is becoming clear. A better characterization of the changes in somatic chromatin after nuclear transfer and the identification of oocyte factors or structures that govern the formation of a functional nucleus will help us to understand the relationship between chromatin structure and cellular totipotency.

Epigenetic reprogramming in mammalian nuclear transfer

With the exception of lymphocytes, the various cell types in a higher multicellular organism have basically an identical genotype but are functionally and morphologically different. This is due to tissue-specific, temporal, and spatial gene expression patterns which are controlled by genetic and epigenetic mechanisms. Successful cloning of mammals by transfer of nuclei from differentiated tissues into enucleated oocytes demonstrates that these genetic and epigenetic programs can be largely reversed and that cellular totipotency can be restored. Although these experiments indicate an enormous plasticity of nuclei from differentiated tissues, somatic cloning is a rather inefficient and unpredictable process, and a plethora of anomalies have been described in cloned embryos, fetuses, and offspring. Accumulating evidence indicates that incomplete or inappropriate epigenetic reprogramming of donor nuclei is likely to be the primary cause of failures in nuclear transfer. In this review, we discuss the roles of various epigenetic mechanisms, including DNA methylation, chromatin remodeling, imprinting, X chromosome inactivation, telomere maintenance, and epigenetic inheritance in normal embryonic development and in the observed abnormalities in clones from different species. Nuclear transfer represents an invaluable tool to experimentally address fundamental questions related to epigenetic reprogramming. Understanding the dynamics and mechanisms underlying epigenetic control will help us solve problems inherent in nuclear transfer technology and enable many applications, including the modulation of cellular plasticity for human cell therapies.

Gene expression and chromatin structure in the pre-implantation embryo

The pre-implantation period of mammalian development includes the formation of the zygote, the activation of the embryonic genome (EGA), and the beginning of cellular differentiation. During this period, protamines are replaced by histones, the methylated haploid parental genomes undergo demethylation following formation of the diploid zygote, and maternal control of development is succeeded by zygotic control. Superimposed on this activation of the embryonic genome is the formation of a chromatin-mediated transcriptionally repressive state requiring enhancers for efficient gene expression. The development of this transcriptionally repressive state most likely occurs at the level of chromatin structure, because inducing histone hyperacetylation relieves the requirements for enhancers. Characterization of zygotic mRNA expression patterns during the pre-implantation period and their relationship to successful development in vitro and in vivo will be essential for defining optimized culture conditions and nuclear transfer protocols. The focus of this review is to summarize recent advances in this field and to discuss their implications for developmental biology.

Chromatin remodeling in nuclear cloning

Nuclear cloning is a procedure to create new animals by injecting somatic nuclei into unfertilized oocytes. Recent successes in mammalian cloning with differentiated adult nuclei strongly indicate that oocyte cytoplasm contains unidentified remarkable reprogramming activities with the capacity to erase the previous memory of cell differentiation. At the heart of this nuclear reprogramming lies chromatin remodeling as chromatin structure and function define cell differentiation through regulation of the transcriptional activities of the cells. Studies involving the modification of chromatin elements such as selective uptake or release of binding proteins, covalent histone modifications including acetylation and methylation, and DNA methylation should provide significant insight into the molecular mechanisms of nuclear dedifferentiation and redifferentiation in oocyte cytoplasm.

Factors controlling the loss of immunoreactive somatic histone H1 from blastomere nuclei in oocyte cytoplasm: a potential marker of nuclear reprogramming

Nuclei of differentiated cells can acquire totipotency following transfer into the cytoplasm of oocytes. While the molecular basis of this nuclear reprogramming remains unknown, the developmental potential of nuclear-transfer embryos is influenced by the cell-cycle stage of both donor and recipient. As somatic H1 becomes immunologically undetectable on bovine embryonic nuclei following transfer into ooplasm and reappears during development of the reconstructed embryo, suggesting that it may act as a marker of nuclear reprogramming, we investigated the link between cell-cycle state and depletion of immunoreactive H1 following nuclear transplantation. Blastomere nuclei at M-, G1-, or G2-phase were introduced into ooplasts at metaphase II, telophase II, or interphase, and the reconstructed embryos were processed for immunofluorescent detection of somatic histone H1. Immunoreactivity was lost more quickly from donor nuclei at metaphase than at G1 or G2. Regardless of the stage of the donor nucleus, immunoreactivity was lost most rapidly when the recipient cytoplast was at metaphase and most slowly when the recipient was at interphase. When the recipient oocyte was not enucleated, however, immunoreactive H1 remained in the donor nucleus. The phosphorylation inhibitors 6-DMAP, roscovitine, and H89 inhibited the depletion of immunoreactive H1 from G2, but not G1, donor nuclei. In addition, immunoreactive H1 was depleted from mouse blastomere nuclei following transfer into bovine oocytes. Finally, expression of the developmentally regulated gene, eIF-1A, but not of Gapdh, was extinguished in metaphase recipients but not in interphase recipients. These results indicate that evolutionarily conserved cell-cycle-regulated activities, nuclear elements, and phosphorylation-linked events participate in the depletion of immunoreactive histone H1 from blastomere nuclei transferred in oocyte cytoplasm and that this is linked to changes in gene expression in the transferred nucleus.

Reprogramming of telomerase activity and rebuilding of telomere length in cloned cattle

Nuclear reprogramming requires the removal of epigenetic modifications imposed on the chromatin during cellular differentiation and division. The mammalian oocyte can reverse these alterations to a state of totipotency, allowing the production of viable cloned offspring from somatic cell nuclei. To determine whether nuclear reprogramming is complete in cloned animals, we assessed the telomerase activity and telomere length status in cloned embryos, fetuses, and newborn offspring derived from somatic cell nuclear transfer. In this report, we show that telomerase activity was significantly (P < 0.05) diminished in bovine fibroblast donor cells compared with embryonic stem-like cells, and surprisingly was 16-fold higher in fetal fibroblasts compared with adult fibroblasts (P < 0.05). Cell passaging and culture periods under serum starvation conditions significantly decreased telomerase activity by approximately 30-50% compared with nontreated early passage cells (P < 0.05). Telomere shortening was observed during in vitro culture of bovine fetal fibroblasts and in very late passages of embryonic stem-like cells. Reprogramming of telomerase activity was apparent by the blastocyst stage of postcloning embryonic development, and telomere lengths were longer (15-23 kb) in cloned fetuses and offspring than the relatively short mean terminal restriction fragment lengths (14-18 kb) observed in adult donor cells. Overall, telomere lengths of cloned fetuses and newborn calves ( approximately 20 kb) were not significantly different from those of age-matched control animals (P > 0.05). These results demonstrate that cloned embryos inherit genomic modifications acquired during the donor nuclei's in vivo and in vitro period but are subsequently reversed during development of the cloned animal.

Reprogramming of telomerase activity and rebuilding of telomere length in cloned cattle

Nuclear reprogramming requires the removal of epigenetic modifications imposed on the chromatin during cellular differentiation and division. The mammalian oocyte can reverse these alterations to a state of totipotency, allowing the production of viable cloned offspring from somatic cell nuclei. To determine whether nuclear reprogramming is complete in cloned animals, we assessed the telomerase activity and telomere length status in cloned embryos, fetuses, and newborn offspring derived from somatic cell nuclear transfer. In this report, we show that telomerase activity was significantly (P < 0.05) diminished in bovine fibroblast donor cells compared with embryonic stem-like cells, and surprisingly was 16-fold higher in fetal fibroblasts compared with adult fibroblasts (P < 0.05). Cell passaging and culture periods under serum starvation conditions significantly decreased telomerase activity by approximately 30-50% compared with nontreated early passage cells (P < 0.05). Telomere shortening was observed during in vitro culture of bovine fetal fibroblasts and in very late passages of embryonic stem-like cells. Reprogramming of telomerase activity was apparent by the blastocyst stage of postcloning embryonic development, and telomere lengths were longer (15-23 kb) in cloned fetuses and offspring than the relatively short mean terminal restriction fragment lengths (14-18 kb) observed in adult donor cells. Overall, telomere lengths of cloned fetuses and newborn calves ( approximately 20 kb) were not significantly different from those of age-matched control animals (P > 0.05). These results demonstrate that cloned embryos inherit genomic modifications acquired during the donor nuclei's in vivo and in vitro period but are subsequently reversed during development of the cloned animal.