"There is power in the blood": a case discussing ethical issues of utility of resources

Transfusion at the border of the "intention-to-treat", in the very aged person and in palliative care: A debate

In both palliative care and in the very aged person i.e. at the end of life, transfusion aims at bringing supportive care; it has indeed no intention to treat. It can occasionally be compassionate as to bring oxygen to a patient or a resident in nursing home wishing to enjoy some exercise or entertainment. Transfusion in this condition is not consensual, for reasons that are medical and/or societal. The present essay aims at discussing the main options to provide transfusion in such extreme, though non-exceptional, conditions.

Transfusion as a Palliative Strategy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The palliative care population is a complex and heterogeneous one. While transfusion therapy is a readily available intervention for many patients, inadequate knowledge for accurately identifying which patient subsets at end-of-life will benefit from a transfusion, along with an unclear understanding of the magnitude of attendant risks of transfusion in those receiving palliative care, complicates the risk-benefit assessment of this therapy. In this brief review, the current literature surrounding transfusion of red cells and platelets in the palliative care patient population will be reviewed and recommendations provided.

RECENT FINDINGS

Benefits of transfusion therapy include subjective relief of fatigue and dyspnea, and improved sense of wellness, amongst other findings. However, these responses are not durable and there are currently no validated, objective metrics that correlate with symptomatic improvements. It is clear that transfusion-associated adverse reactions are underestimated in those receiving palliative care, with reaction rates similar to the general patient population. Additionally, based on the high mortality rates reported soon after transfusion, the impact of these blood components must be considered as an exacerbating or causative factor of mortality when evaluating declining condition or death. Hematinics are rarely assessed in anemic palliative care patients or, when measured, are often not corrected. The decision to transfuse palliative care patients is multifactorial, and benefits, risks, patient wishes, blood component inventories, and alternatives to transfusion should all be considered. There are many unknowns regarding transfusion in palliative care. Critical next steps for optimizing blood component therapy in this population include high-quality trials that help to identify validated measures of objective functional changes that parallel patient-reported outcomes and subsets of patients receiving end-of-life care that will most likely be positively impacted by transfusion therapy.

Does packed red cell transfusion provide symptomatic benefits to cancer palliative patients?: a longitudinal study from a single private oncology center in Nepal

Background

Palliative patients generally present with symptoms of dyspnea, easy fatigability, lethargy and feeling of being unwell which can broadly be attributed to one root cause: cancer-related anemia. So, packed red cell transfusion is often carried out aiming to improve patients’ functional status. Different cut off hemoglobin values have been suggested, with Hb < 9 g/dL the most commonly accepted. The present study aims at evaluating and comparing the benefits in subjective symptoms of fatigue and breathlessness among transfused and non-transfused palliative patients on Day 0 and Day 7.

Methods

Hemoglobin values, anemia related subjective symptoms of fatigue and breathlessness were recorded from 122 patients. The patients were re-evaluated on day-7 post-transfusion. The pre and post-transfusion symptomatic benefit was compared in both transfused and non-transfused palliative care patients.

Results

The currently practiced hemoglobin trigger for packed red cell transfusion is 10 g/dL. The units of packed red cell to be transfused was decided according to the hemoglobin values targeting the rise to > 10 g/dL. A mean 1.36 units were transfused. Statistically significant improvement was observed in patient reported symptoms of fatigue and breathlessness among both transfused and non-transfused palliative patients.

Conclusion

Anemic cancer palliative patients were found to benefit following packed red cell transfusion, suggesting a favorable association between the transfusion and patient-reported fatigue and dyspnea.