A controlled surgical approach to annulo-aortic ectasia

A Bentall Is Not a Bentall Is Not a Bentall: The Evolution of Aortic Root Surgery

BACKGROUND

Aortic root pathology had been a known entity with a progressive and catastrophic course, long before the methods to surgically address them were first developed. Once reliable cardiopulmonary bypass was established, surgeons were able to pioneer new operative techniques, and in the half-century to follow, countless modifications and refinements have provided today's surgeons with the surgical approaches that are currently at their disposal.

HISTORY

Denton Cooley and Michael De Bakey reported the first successful surgical intervention for aneurysms involving the ascending aorta in 1956. Nearly a decade later, Hugh Bentall described his modification, and provided a name that would leave a lasting mark on aneurysmal surgery. In the decades to follow, numerous innovative surgeons improved on these original procedures to allow for a more reliable and consistent operation. Further, Tirone David and Sir Magdi Yacoub each described their methods to repair the aortic root while preserving the valve, thus providing their patients with freedom from a prosthetic or mechanical valve and improved quality of life.

CONCLUSIONS

The development of surgical techniques required to successfully care for patients with pathology of the aortic root has evolved considerably since Cooley and De Bakey's original report. Although it is common to hear aortic root replacement referred to as a "Bentall," the methods currently employed have gone through considerable evolution, such that the techniques of today should not be referred to as a Bentall.

"Legs" technique for management of widely separated coronary arteries during ascending aortic repair

BACKGROUND

Widely separated coronary arteries with significantly diseased tissue continues to challenge surgeons repairing ascending aortic aneurysms.

METHODS

Occasional troublesome leaks around coronary ostial anastomoses and Cabrol graft thrombosis prompted a change of our operative management of this condition. Collagen-impregnated 8-mm "legs" grafts are used to connect the coronary arteries to the composite graft. Ten patients, aged 14 to 70 years, underwent the operation.

RESULTS

The first patient is 15 years after the operation and is symptom free. One patient died of an arrhythmia 1 month after discharge. Eight patients are living and well 11/2 to 4 years postoperatively.

CONCLUSIONS

Advantages of direct interposition (legs) grafts are as follows: the coronary arteries are separately perfused and the risk of catastrophic thrombosis from a longer high-volume graft is eliminated. Problems with coronary ostial mobilization are avoided. The technique allows full visualization and hemostatic suture line testing with cardioplegia before aortic declamping. Space constraints with reoperations are easily managed, whereas other techniques may result in graft compression on refilling of the heart and termination of bypass. The technique is carried out with ease and reproducibility, and the availability of new graft material has made it our treatment of choice for ascending aortic composite graft replacement.

The replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve with a new design composite graft: a six-year experience

The problems encountered in coronary artery reattachment when the ascending aorta and aortic valve are replaced with a composite graft induced Gallucci and one of the authors to develop a new aortovalvular prosthesis in clinical practice. The unique transverse ovoidal shape of this graft is intended to conform to the natural aortic root and facilitate the coronary anastomoses and minimize bleeding. We present our 6-year experience with 56 patients operated upon with this prosthesis. In all patients we were able to connect the coronary arteries directly to the graft without complications including hemorrhage or distortion of the coronary ostia. The survivors were evaluated with chest X ray, two-dimensional echocardiography, and conventional or digital subtraction angiography to detect the presence of pseudoaneurysms at the site of the coronary anastomosis, reported by others that have used the composite graft technique. The notable absence of this complication in our patients at a mean follow-up of 41 months (range 3-71) documents that this ovoidal composite graft is a reliable tool in the treatment of aortic root pathology.

Replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve with a composite graft in patients with nondisplaced coronary ostia

Composite graft replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve is indicated for a variety of conditions affecting the aortic root. In most cases, cephalad displacement of the coronary ostia permits direct reimplantation of the ostia into the composite graft. Occasionally, anatomical factors exist that preclude the safe advancement of the ostia to the graft for direct anastomosis. A method for dealing with this problem utilizing a short interposed polytetrafluoroethylene graft between coronary ostia and composite graft is presented.

Replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve with a composite graft. Results in 86 patients

We reviewed our entire experience with composite graft replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve during a 63 month interval ending in December, 1979. Anuloaortic ectasia was the most common indication for operation, followed by aortic dissection (acute and chronic). Hospital mortality was 5% and was related to the preoperative functional status and the duration of intraoperative myocardial ischemia. Reoperation on the ascending aorta for reasons other than postoperative hemorrhage was required in five of the 82 hospital survivors (6%). By actuarial analysis, 90% of hospital survivors were free of any reoperation on the ascending aorta or aortic valve three years postoperatively, and 93% were free of reoperation related specifically to the composite graft. Pseudoaneurysms at the coronary ostia or distal aortic anastomosis were observed in five of 16 patients having postoperative angiography. One of the five patients has required reoperation. Follow-up has averaged 23.5 months (range: 0.2-60 months). Three year actuarial survival for the 86 patients was 81%, for 44 patients with anuloaortic ectasia was 88%, and for 31 patients with aortic dissection was 83%. Composite graft replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve is a satisfactory alternative to supracoronary graft replacement and aortic valve replacement. It offers the advantage of excluding all aneurysmal tissue from the aortic anulus to the innominate artery, thereby eliminating the potential for later development of aneurysms of the sinuses of Valsalva, a known complication of the supracoronary technique. It is the method of choice for patients with anuloaortic ectasia and cephalad displacement of the coronary ostia. It is suitable for many patients with acute or chronic dissection and for patients with sinuses of Valsalva aneurysms following previous operations on the ascending aorta or aortic valve.

Calcification and thickening of the aortic wall complicating aortocoronary grafting: a technical modification

A method to anastomose saphenous vein grafts to a calcified or severely arteriosclerotic ascending aorta is presented. A portion of the aorta is replaced by a synthetic prosthesis from which the grafts are delivered through individual openings.

Surgery of the ascending aorta: five years' experience at a regional cardiac centre

Between 1972 and 1978, 31 patients underwent replacement of the ascending aorta, with or without aortic valve surgery, at the Wessex Regional Cardiac Centre. The commonest indications for operation were aneurysmal dilatation of the ascending aorta causing aortic regurgitation and acute dissection of the ascending aorta. Eleven of the 31 patients had features of Marfan's syndrome. The overall hospital mortality was 19.4%, a figure comparable with those reported in other series; ventricular failure secondary to ischaemia during operation was the commonest cause of death. The long-term symptomatic results were excellent, except in the two patients who underwent resuspension of the aortic valve for aortic regurgiation associated with acute dissections. For aneurysms of the ascending aorta with associated aortic regurgitation, replacement of the valve and ascending aorta with a combined valve prosthesis and synthetic tube graft, with reimplantation of the coronary ostia, is the procedure of choice if the aortic valve ring is diseased. Experience to date indicates that replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve with separate prostheses, leaving the coronary ostia undisturbed, is a satisfactory alternative provided the aortic annulus is of suitable size and quality; this is more likely to be the case in dissections than in aneurysmal dilatation of the ascending aorta. Replacement of the ascending aorta may also be indicated in some cases of dilatation of the ascending aorta secondary to aortic valve disease if the aortic wall is unusually thin.

Replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve with a composite graft: results in 25 patients

Our experience with combined replacement of the ascending aorta and aortic valve with a composite prosthetic valve-Dacron tube graft in 25 patients from September, 1974, to December, 1976, is reviewed. The technique involves suture of the composite graft to the aortic annulus, to the aortic tissue surrounding the coronary ostia, and to the distal ascending aorta, closing the aortic wall over the graft before discontinuing cardiopulmonary bypass. Annuloaortic ectasia was the most common indication for operation (15 patients). Perfusion of the coronary arteries was used in the first 15 patients. In the remaining 20, internal and external myocardial cooling with one period of ischemic arrest (average, 67 minutes) was used. There was 1 hospital death (4%), and there have been 3 late deaths (12%) in the 27-month follow-up period. This technique appears to be applicable to most types of aneurysmal disease of the proximal ascending aorta associated with aortic valve incompetence. All aneurysmal tissue from the aortic annulus to the innominate artery is excluded, bleeding through the graft is eliminated, operative time is reduced, and the late results have been satisfactory to date.