Nosocomial legionellosis

Peracetic Acid in the Disinfection of a Hospital Water System Contaminated With Legionella Species

Objective:

To assess the efficacy of an alternative disinfection method for hospital water distribution systems contaminated with Legionella.

Methods:

Disinfection with peracetic acid was performed in a small hospital contaminated with L. pneumophila serotype 1. The disinfectant was used at concentrations of 50 ppm (first three surveillance phases) and 1,000 ppm (fourth surveillance phase) for 30 minutes.

Results:

Environmental monitoring revealed that disinfection was maintained 1 week after treatment; however, levels of recontamination surpassing baseline values were detected after approximately 1 month. Comparison of water temperatures measured at the distal outlets showed a statistically significant association between temperature and bacterial load. The circulating water temperature was found to be lower in the two wards farthest away from the hot water production plant than in other wards. It was thought that the lower water temperature in the two wards promoted the bacterial growth even after disinfection.

Conclusion:

Peracetic acid may be useful in emergency situations, but does not provide definitive protection even if used monthly.

Environmental Cultures and Hospital-Acquired Legionnaires' Disease: A 5-Year Prospective Study in 20 Hospitals in Catalonia, Spain

Objective:

To determine whether environmental cultures forLegionellaincrease the index of suspicion for legionnaires' disease (LD).

Design:

Five-year prospective study.

Setting:

Twenty hospitals in Catalonia, Spain.

Methods:

From 1994 to 1996, the potable water systems of 20 hospitals in Catalonia were tested forLegionella, Cases of hospital-acquired LD and availability of an “in-house”Legionellatest in the previous 4 years were assessed. After the hospitals were informed of the results of their water cultures, a prospective 5-year-study was conducted focusing on the detection of new cases of nosocomial legionellosis and the availability and use of Legionella testing.

Results:

Before environmental cultures were started, only one hospital had conducted active surveillance of hospital-acquired pneumonia and usedLegionellatests includingLegionellaurinary antigen in all pneumonia cases. Only one other hospital had used the latter test at all. In six hospitals,Legionellatests had been completely unavailable. Cases of nosocomial LD had been diagnosed in the previous 4 years in only two hospitals. During prospective surveillance, 12 hospitals (60%) usedLegionellaurinary antigen testing in house and 11 (55%) found cases of nosocomial legionellosis, representing 64.7% (11 of 17) of those with positive water cultures. Hospitals with negative water cultures did not find nosocomial LD.

Conclusions:

The environmental study increased the index of suspicion for nosocomial LD. The number of cases of nosocomial LD increased significantly during the prospective follow-up period, and most hospitals began using theLegionellaurinary antigen test in their laboratories.

Environmental Cultures and Hospital-Acquired Legionnaires' Disease: A 5-Year Prospective Study in 20 Hospitals in Catalonia, Spain

Objective:

To determine whether environmental cultures forLegionellaincrease the index of suspicion for legionnaires' disease (LD).

Design:

Five-year prospective study.

Setting:

Twenty hospitals in Catalonia, Spain.

Methods:

From 1994 to 1996, the potable water systems of 20 hospitals in Catalonia were tested forLegionella, Cases of hospital-acquired LD and availability of an “in-house”Legionellatest in the previous 4 years were assessed. After the hospitals were informed of the results of their water cultures, a prospective 5-year-study was conducted focusing on the detection of new cases of nosocomial legionellosis and the availability and use of Legionella testing.

Results:

Before environmental cultures were started, only one hospital had conducted active surveillance of hospital-acquired pneumonia and usedLegionellatests includingLegionellaurinary antigen in all pneumonia cases. Only one other hospital had used the latter test at all. In six hospitals,Legionellatests had been completely unavailable. Cases of nosocomial LD had been diagnosed in the previous 4 years in only two hospitals. During prospective surveillance, 12 hospitals (60%) usedLegionellaurinary antigen testing in house and 11 (55%) found cases of nosocomial legionellosis, representing 64.7% (11 of 17) of those with positive water cultures. Hospitals with negative water cultures did not find nosocomial LD.

Conclusions:

The environmental study increased the index of suspicion for nosocomial LD. The number of cases of nosocomial LD increased significantly during the prospective follow-up period, and most hospitals began using theLegionellaurinary antigen test in their laboratories.

A TLR6 polymorphism is associated with increased risk of Legionnaires' disease

Legionella pneumophila (Lp), the etiologic agent of Legionnaires’ Disease (LD), is an important cause of community-acquired and nosocomial pneumonia. However, the host immune and genetic determinants of human susceptibility to Lp are poorly understood. Here we show that both TLR6 and TLR1 cooperate with TLR2 to recognize Lp in transfected HEK293 cells. We also perform a human genetic association study of 14 candidate single nucleotide polymorphisms in Toll-like receptors (TLRs) 1, 2, and 6 in 98 LD cases and 268 controls from the Netherlands. No polymorphisms in TLR1 or TLR2 were associated with LD. A TLR6 polymorphism, 359T>C (rs5743808), was associated with an elevated risk of LD in genotypic and dominant (OR 5.83, p=7.9×10⁻⁵) models. The increased risk in persons with 359 TC or CC genotypes was further enhanced among smokers. In a multivariate model, 359T>C was associated with a higher risk of LD (OR 4.24, p=0.04), than any other variable, including age and smoking. Together, these data suggest that the human TLR6 variant, 359T>C, is an independent risk factor for LD.

Assessing risk of health care-acquired Legionnaires' disease from environmental sampling: the limits of using a strict percent positivity approach

BACKGROUND

Elevated percent positivity (≥30%) of Legionella in hospital domestic water systems has been suggested as a metric for assessing the risk of health care-acquired Legionnaires' disease (LD).

METHODS

We examined the validity of this metric by analyzing data from peer-reviewed studies containing reports of Legionella prevalence in hospital water (ie, percent positivity) and temporally matched reports of patients with health care-acquired LD.

RESULTS

Our literature review identified 31 peer-reviewed publications reporting matched data. We abstracted a total of 206 data points, representing 119 hospitals, from these articles. We determined that the proposed 30% positivity metric has 59% sensitivity and 74% specificity (ie, a 41% false-negative rate and a 26% false-positive rate). These notable error rates could have significant implications, given that we identified 16 peer-reviewed articles and 6 government guidance documents that referenced the 30% positivity metric as a risk assessment tool.

CONCLUSIONS

Environmental sampling of hospital water distribution systems for Legionella can be an important component of risk management for LD. However, the possible consequence of using a percent positivity metric with low sensitivity and specificity is that many hospitals might fail to mitigate when a true risk is present, or might unnecessarily allocate limited resources to deal with a negligible risk.

Prevalence study of Legionella spp. contamination in Greek hospitals

Water and swab samples were collected from 13 hospitals and analyzed for Legionella counts. Legionella was detected in eight out of 13 hospitals and in 22 of 130 water and swab-collected samples. A total of 72.7% of the strains were L. pneumophila ser. 1, 22.7% were L. pneumophila ser. 2-14, and 4.5% did not belong to any of these groups. AFLP typing of the L. pneumophila ser. 1 strains generated two distinguishable AFLP types. There was no significant correlation to the sample type with Legionella recovery. Legionella isolation was more likely to occur in the cooling towers than the water system. Water temperatures of 30-40 degrees C seem to favor Legionella growth. Of the 265 serum samples taken from the medical and technical staff for the control of IgG titre, 89.4% were negative, 7.2% were positive, and for 3.4% the result was doubtful. No association between IgG titre and maximum observed level of Legionella occurrence was detected.

[Pathogenesis and environmental factors in ventilator-associated pneumonia]

Respiratory infections in intubated patients can derive from endogenous or exogenous sources. The major route for acquiring endemic ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) is oropharyngeal colonization by endogenous flora and leakage of contaminated secretions into the lower respiratory tract. However, a not inconsiderable percentage of VAP results from exogenous nosocomial colonization, especially pneumonias caused by resistant bacteria such as methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and multiresistant Acinetobacter baumannii or Pseudomonas aeruginosa, as well as by Legionella spp or filamentous fungi, such as Aspergillus. This article reviews the pathogenesis of VAP and the role of the intensive care environment as a source of pathogenic microorganisms.

A proactive approach to prevention of health care-acquired Legionnaires' disease: the Allegheny County (Pittsburgh) experience

BACKGROUND

The Allegheny County Health Department (ACHD) in Pennsylvania distributed the first guidelines for prevention and control of health care-acquired Legionnaires' disease (LD) by 1995. The proactive approach advocated in the guidelines differed notably from that of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) by recommending routine environmental testing of the hospital water distribution system even when cases of health care-acquired Legionnaires' disease had never been identified.

OBJECTIVES

Our purpose was to (1) evaluate the impact of the ACHD guidelines on the Legionella diagnostic and preventive practices of health care facilities in Allegheny and surrounding counties and (2) compare the incidence of health care-acquired LD before and after issuance of the ACHD guidelines.

METHODS

CDC case reports of LD from 1991 to 2001 were tabulated and compiled by the ACHD Infectious Disease Unit and the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology, Inc, Three Rivers Chapter. A survey was distributed to 110 hospitals and long-term care facilities in the region. The results were analyzed as occurring either in the preguideline period (1991-1994) or postguideline period (1995-2001).

RESULTS

A significant decrease in the number of health care-acquired cases was demonstrated between the preguideline (33%) and postguideline (9%) periods (P=.0001). In contrast, community-acquired cases increased from 67% pre guideline to 91% post guideline. A total of 71% of the facilities were colonized with Legionella. Disinfection of the water distribution system was initiated by 44% of facilities. Use of urinary antigen testing significantly increased from 40% pre guideline to 79% post guideline (P=.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Health care-acquired LD declined significantly after the issuance of guidelines for prevention and control of health care-acquired LD. The decline was associated with health care facilities performing routine environmental monitoring of their water distribution systems followed by the initiation of disinfection methods if indicated. Two unanticipated benefits were (1) cases of LD in the community and long-term care facilities were uncovered as a result of increased availability of Legionella tests and (2) litigation and unfavorable publicity involving ACHD hospitals ceased.

Surveillance of hospital water and primary prevention of nosocomial legionellosis: what is the evidence?

Hospital-acquired Legionnaires' disease may be sporadic or may occur as part of an outbreak. As Legionella spp. are ubiquitous in many water systems, it is not surprising that hospital water may be colonized with Legionella pneumophila and other species. However, there is some controversy about the relationship between the presence of legionella in hospital water systems and nosocomial legionellosis. Primary prevention, i.e. measures to prevent legionella in a hospital or healthcare facility with no previous documented cases of nosocomial legionellosis, includes heightened awareness of hospital-acquired Legionnaires' disease with appropriate laboratory diagnostic facilities, and ensuring that the water system is well designed and maintained in accordance with national standards, e.g. the circulating hot water is maintained above 55 degrees C. Secondary prevention, i.e. preventing further cases occurring when a case has been confirmed, should include an investigation to exclude the hospital water system as a source. However, the necessity to sample hospital water routinely to detect legionella outside of outbreaks, i.e. as a component of primary prevention, is unclear. Some studies demonstrate a clear link but others do not. Differences between the patient populations studied, the methods of laboratory diagnosis of clinical cases, the analysis of hospital water and differences in the design of hospital water systems may partly explain this. Whilst further research, probably in the form of multi-centred prospective trials, is needed to confirm the relationship between environmental legionella and hospital-acquired legionellosis, including establishing the relative importance of L. pneumophila group 1 vs. non-group 1 and other Legionella spp., each hospital should consider the spectrum of patients at particular risk locally. Centres with transplant units or other patients with significant immunosuppression should, in the interim, consider routine sampling for legionella in hospital water in addition to other control measures. Therefore, infection control teams must work closely with hospital engineering and technical services departments and hospital management, as well as ensuring that physicians and others have a heightened awareness of hospital-acquired legionellosis.

Legionella waterline colonization: detection of Legionella species in domestic, hotel and hospital hot water systems

AIMS

An evaluation was made of the prevalence of Legionella species in hot water distribution systems in the city of Bologna (Italy) and their possible association with bacterial contamination (total counts and Pseudomonadaceae) and the chemical characteristics of the water (pH, Ca, Mg, Fe, Mn, Cu, Zn and Total Organic Carbon, TOC).

METHODS AND RESULTS

A total of 137 hot water samples were analysed: 59 from the same number of private apartments, 46 from 11 hotels and 32 from five hospitals, all using the same water supply. Legionella species were detected in 40.0% of the distribution systems, L. pneumophila in 33.3%. The highest colonization was found in the hot water systems of hospitals (93.7% of samples positive for L. pneumophila, geometric mean: 2.4 x 10(3) CFU l(-1)), followed by the hotels (60.9%, geometric mean: 127.3 CFU l(-1)) and the apartments with centralized heating (41.9%, geometric mean: 30.5 CFU l(-1)). The apartments with independent heating systems showed a lower level of colonization (3.6% for Legionella species), with no evidence of L. pneumophila. Correlation analysis suggests that copper exerts an inhibiting action, while the TOC tends to favour the development of L. pneumophila. No statistically significant association was seen with Pseudomonadaceae, which were found at lower water temperatures than legionellae and in individual distribution points rather than in the whole network.

CONCLUSIONS

The water recirculation system used by centralized boilers enhances the spreading of legionellae throughout the whole network, both in terms of the number of colonized sites and in terms of CFU count.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

Differences in Legionella colonization between types of buildings are not due to a variation in water supply but to other factors. Besides the importance of water recirculation, the study demonstrates the inhibiting action of copper and the favourable action of TOC on the development of L. pneumophila.

One-year surveillance of legionellosis in burned patients and Legionella environmental monitoring

Burned patients have a theoretically high risk of Legionella infection because burns produce a compromised immune system. Cutaneous surfaces are without protective barriers, and bathing tank water is frequently used for washing and caring. A one-year surveillance study was performed on 65 burned patients by antibody determination and by culture of bronchial aspirates. Environmental culturing for Legionella was done in the patients' care areas every four months during the same period. Low titers ranging from 8 to 32 were found in 30 (46.1%) subjects against 18 antigens including several Legionella species. No increase in antibody titers was shown in 193 patients' sera. Cultures of respiratory samples were negative. L. pneumophila serogroups 4, 5, 6 and 8 and L. rubrilucens were isolated from 55.5% of water samples. Despite no evidence of Legionella infection among patients included in this study, the authors believe it to be advisable to improve control measures in hospital water supplies, used by burned patients, to minimise the risk of legionellosis.

Hospital-acquired legionellosis: solutions for a preventable infection

Hospital-acquired Legionnaires' disease has been reported from many hospitals since the first outbreak in 1976. Although cooling towers were linked to the cases of Legionnaires' disease in the years after its discovery, potable water has been the environmental source for almost all reported hospital outbreaks. Microaspiration is the major mode of transmission in hospital-acquired Legionnaires' disease; showering is not a mode of transmission. Since the clinical manifestations are non-specific, and specialised laboratory testing is required, hospital-acquired legionellosis is easily underdiagnosed. Discovery of a single case of hospital-acquired Legionnaires' disease is an important sentinel of additional undiscovered cases. Routine environmental culture of the hospital water supply for legionella has proven to be an important strategy in prevention. Documentation of legionella colonisation in the water supply would increase physician index of suspicion for Legionnaires' disease and the necessity for in-house legionella test methods would be obvious. Legionella is a common commensal of large-building water supplies. Preventive maintenance is commonly recommended; unfortunately, this measure is ineffective in minimising legionella colonisation of building water supplies. Copper-silver ionisation systems have emerged as the most successful long-term disinfection method for hospital water disinfection systems. There is a need for public-health agencies to educate the public and media that discovery of cases identifies those hospitals as providers of superior care, and that such hospitals are not negligent.