From 'points' to 'profiles' in intracavitary brachytherapy of cervical cancer

Dosimetric and clinical outcomes of CT based HR-CTV delineation for HDR intracavitary brachytherapy in carcinoma cervix - a retrospective study

Background

Brachytherapy for carcinoma cervix has moved from Point A based planning to optimization of dose based on HR-CTV. Guidelines have been published by GEC ESTRO on HR-CTV delineation based on clinical gynecological examination and MR sequences. These have given significant clinical results in terms of local control. However, many centers around the country and worldwide still use CT based planning, which restricts HR-CTV delineation, as disease and cervix can rarely be differentiated on a planning CT. Various studies have been done to develop CT based contouring guidelines from the available data, but enough evidence is not available on the clinical outcome when treatment is optimized to HR-CTV contoured on CT images. The purpose of this study is to find out the relation between local control and dosimetry of HR-CTV as delineated on CT images.

Materials and methods

Patients of locally advanced carcinoma cervix treated radically with EBRT of 50 Gy in 25# and at least 4 cycles of concurrent weekly Cisplatin having a complete or partial response to EBRT were taken for study. All patients had completed CT based Intracavitary brachytherapy to 21 Gy in 3# of 7 Gy per # with dose prescription at point A and optimizing dose to reduce bladder and rectal toxicity. Follow up data on locoregional recurrence was obtained. HR-CTV delineation was done retrospectively on the treatment plan following guidelines by Viswanathan et al. EQD2 doses for EBRT+BT were calculated for point A and HR-CTV D90. The dosimetric data to HR-CTV and to Point A were then compared with patients with locoregional control and with local recurrence.

Results

48 patients were taken, all had squamous cell carcinoma. The median age was 48 years. 33.33% were stage IIA, the rest were stage IIB. Median follow-up was 30 months with 25% developing recurrence of the disease. HR-CTV D90 EQD2 dose was significantly higher in patients with locoregionally controlled disease than in patients with local recurrence (83.97 Gy₁₀ vs. 77.96 Gy₁₀, p = 0.002). Patients with HR-CTV D90 EQD2 dose greater than or equal to 79.75 Gy 10 had better locoregional control than patients receiving dose less than 79.75 Gy₁₀ (p = 0.015). Kaplan Meier plot for PFS showed significantly improved PFS for patients receiving HR-CTV D90 dose of at least 79.75 Gy₁₀ (log-rank p-value = 0.007). Three year progression free survival was 87.1% in patients receiving HR-CTV D90 dose of at least 79.75 Gy₁₀.

Conclusion

CT based HR-CTV volume delineation with the help of pre brachytherapy clinical diagrams and MRI imaging may be feasible in a select subgroup of patients with complete or near-complete response to external beam radiation.

Inter-application displacement of brachytherapy dose received by the bladder and rectum of the patients with inoperable cervical cancer

BACKGROUND

The aim of the study was to examine on the CT basis the inter-application displacement of the positions D0.1cc, D1cc and D2cc of the brachytherapy dose applied to the bladder and rectum of the patients with inoperable cervical cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This prospective study included 30 patients with cervical cancer who were treated by concomitant chemo-radiotherapy. HDR intracavitary brachytherapy was made by the applicators type Fletcher tandem and ovoids. For each brachytherapy application the position D0.1cc was determined of the bladder and rectum that receive a brachytherapty dose. Then, based on the X, Y, and Z axis displacement, inter-application mean X, Y, and Z axis displacements were calculated as well as their displacement vectors (R). It has been analyzed whether there is statistically significant difference in inter-application displacement of the position of the brachytherapy dose D0.1cc, D1cc and D2cc of the bladder and rectum. The ANOVA test and post-hoc analysis by Tukey method were used for testing statistical importance of differences among the groups analyzed. The difference among the groups analyzed was considered significant if p < 0.05.

RESULTS

There are significant inter-application displacements of the position of the brachytherapy dose D0,1cc, D1cc and D2cc of the bladder and rectum.

CONCLUSIONS

When we calculate the cumulative brachytherapy dose by summing up D0,1cc, D1cc and D2cc of the organs at risk for all the applications, we must bear in mind their inter-application displacement, and the fact that it is less likely that the worst scenario would indeed happen.

Does the evidence support the use of concurrent chemoradiotherapy as a standard in the management of locally advanced cancer of the cervix, especially in developing countries?

Locally advanced cancer of the cervix (FIGO stages III and IVA) is one of the most common malignancies in developing countries. Conventional treatment has been a judicious combination of external radiotherapy and intracavitary brachytherapy. However, prompted by the results of five randomised-controlled trials (RCTs) published in close succession, The National Cancer Institute (NCI) alert in 1999, and two meta-analyses, the management of cancer of the cervix has gradually changed. Concurrent chemoradiotherapy with cisplatin alone, or in combination, is gradually being favoured for the treatment of cancer of the cervix. This overview examines whether the published evidence is sufficiently adequate to justify the use of chemoradiotherapy using cisplatin as standard care in the management of cancer of the cervix, especially in developing countries, where most women present with locally advanced cancer of the cervix. A critical review of the various phase III randomised trials and meta-analyses indicates that, although chemoradiotherapy could be a standard form of treatment for early cancer of the cervix, its role in advanced stages needs further exploration before this could be incorporated into routine clinical care.

Comparative assessment of doses to tumor, rectum, and bladder as evaluated by orthogonal radiographs vs. computer enhanced computed tomography-based intracavitary brachytherapy in cervical cancer

PURPOSE

To carry out a comparative assessment of intracavitary brachytherapy (ICBT) doses to tumor, bladder, and rectum based on orthogonal films and contrast enhanced computed tomography (CECT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fifty-five ICBT procedures with CT/MRI compatible applicator and CECT scans were evaluated. Doses to Point A, International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurement (ICRU) reference points for maximum bladder (B max(ICRU)) and rectum (R max(ICRU)) localized from orthogonal films were compared with CECT delineated tumor, bladder (B max(CECT)), and rectum (R max(CECT)) doses, respectively. The 95th and 90th percentile bladder (B 95(CECT) and B 90(CECT)) and rectal (R 95(CECT) and R 90(CECT)) doses based on CECT were also estimated.

RESULTS

Mean percentage tumor volume encompassed within the prescribed dose of 600 cGy to Point A was 88.8%. Mean B max(ICRU), B max(CECT), R max(ICRU), and R max(CECT) were 631.3 cGy, 1221.4 cGy, 454.8 cGy, and 526.9 cGy, respectively. Paired mean differences were significant between B max(ICRU) and B max(CECT) or B 95(CECT) (both p < 0.001); R max(ICRU) and R max(CECT) (p = 0.005) or R 90(CECT) (p < 0.001), whereas insignificant for B max(ICRU) and B 90(CECT) (p = 0.281), and R max(ICRU) and R 95(CECT) (p = 0.372).

CONCLUSIONS

Prescription based on Point A ICBT doses could lead to uncertainty and underdosage in tumor. ICRU 38 maximum bladder and rectal doses significantly underestimate the maximum doses to these organs and represent the 90th and 95th percentile of the maximum doses to these organs, respectively.