Traumatic separation of a type I bipartite patella: a report of four knees

"Pediatric Patella fractures - A Systematic review"

BACKGROUND

Patella fractures in the pediatric age group often have a dilemma in their ease of diagnosis and treatment required. Indications for conservative management or surgical intervention in the pediatric population during growth phase are not clearly defined. The current systematic review aims to provide a consensus on the morphological types, treatment options, indications, the outcomes expected and complications and their management.

METHODS

The review was conducted as per the PRISMA guidelines. Inclusion criteria were (a).Articles published in English, (b) Age <18 years, (c) Patellar fractures including osteochondral fractures. Exclusion criteria includes articles with incomplete data, case reports, biomechanical studies, case series with sample size <2, biomechanical studies, reviews, letter to the editor, or editorials and Non-English language.

RESULTS

The review search yielded a total of 18 articles. A total of 288 patients with patellar fractures were included in the review. The average age ranged from 9.6 years to 16 years. The follow-up period ranged from 3 months to 20 years. In total, 49 individuals underwent immobilization with cast or brace application, 4 with spica cast application and 48 with cylindrical cast in extension. Overall, 83 patients in 13 studies underwent surgical fixation most of which underwent wiring.

CONCLUSION

Pediatric patella fracture/dislocations or Osteochondral fractures (OCF) although being a rare event, may be associated with a child with knee injury and swelling. Conservative management in terms of casting and immobilization may be an alternative but surgical intervention should be the primary mode of treatment in such cases.

Accessory fragment migration in a professional baseball player with bipartite patella: A case report

INTRODUCTION

Bipartite patella (BP) is usually recognized as an incidental radiographic finding. Therefore, no reports have observed the process of accessory fragment migration. We present the case of a professional baseball pitcher with significant migration of the fragment during follow-up.

PRESENTATION OF CASE

A 26-year-old man was diagnosed with symptomatic BP and underwent conservative therapy. Eleven months later, he was unable to play baseball because of gradually worsening knee pain without obvious trauma. On radiographs, the accessory fragment which had located at the superolateral pole 11 months earlier migrated posterolaterally. The diagnosis of Saupe's type III BP was established, and open excision of the accessory fragment was performed. Postoperatively, full-weight-bearing walking and range-of-motion exercises were started the day after surgery. Three months after surgery, he could pitch with all his power without pain.

DISCUSSION

Since our patient was a professional baseball right-handed pitcher who needed to step strongly on his left knee during pitching, strong traction force from the vastus lateralis was likely to have been repeatedly applied to the accessory fragment. It might lead to migration of the accessory fragment. The open excision of the accessory fragment was performed because the accessory fragment had migrated away from the patella body.

CONCLUSION

We report a case of professional baseball player with symptomatic BP, in which case the chronological migration of the accessory fragment was observed without obvious trauma. When the accessory fragment is identified without obvious trauma, one of the differential diseases could be a BP.

Treatment of congenital bipartite patella in pediatric population - a systematic review of the published studies

Bipartite patella is an abnormality where patella is incorrectly ossified resulting in fibrocartilaginous synchondrosis. In most cases bipartite patella is asymptomatic and incidental finding but can also be painful especially in adolescents. The aim of our analysis was to determine the preferable treatment for pediatric bipartite patella. We conducted a systematic review based on PubMed and Embase searches. All original articles with reference to treatment in the population of ≤ 20 years of age, were included. Case reports, and articles without individualized data were excluded. In total, the individual data of 126 knees in 116 patients was analyzed. In 77.8% (98/126) of the analyzed knees the result was excellent, and the majority of the knees, 89.7% (105/126) received surgical intervention, and seven different techniques were used. None of operative methods were superior to others. Excellent treatment outcomes were achieved more often in younger patients (p=0.004), and the median duration of symptoms in operatively treated patients was shorter (p=0.018). If operative treatment is used after unsuccessful conservative treatment, it should be considered early in adolescence and also within a relatively short period after the onset of symptoms. The best operative method could not be found. More research and RCTs are needed concerning the conservative methods and different operative techniques.

Pearls and Pitfalls of Imaging of the Developing Pediatric Skeleton: Differentiating Normal and Pathology With MRI

Developmental changes occurring in the pediatric skeleton throughout childhood cause imaging appearances that may be confused with pathology. Knowledge of the typical pattern of red to yellow bone marrow conversion and areas of normal developmental irregular ossification is essential for radiologists interpreting musculoskeletal imaging in children to avoid mistaking normal findings for disease. Here we review the normal conversion of hematopoietic to yellow marrow on pediatric MRI and illustrate how MRI can distinguish the normal areas of irregular ossification from various pathology that can occur at and around growth centers in the developing skeleton.

Arthroscopic Management for Bipartite Patella: A Systematic Review

Background:

Bipartite patella is a rare congenital condition that becomes painful following direct trauma or an overuse injury. If it remains painful despite nonoperative treatment, surgery may be warranted. The current gold standard is open fragment excision or lateral release; however, arthroscopic management is also possible.

Purpose:

To investigate the safety and efficacy of arthroscopic treatment of painful bipartite patella.

Study Design:

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

Methods:

Using Medline and Embase, we systematically reviewed the literature as of March 8, 2020, using the subject headings “bipartite patella” and “arthroscopy” and related key terms. All levels of evidence involving human studies in English were included. Articles were excluded if only the abstract was published or the study was related to nonsurgical treatment or nonrelated diagnoses. Data related to journal/article information, demographic/clinical data, arthroscopic technique, length of follow-up, treatment outcomes, and complications were extracted.

Results:

Eleven articles with 43 patients were included in the review. Most patients (n = 34; 79%) underwent arthroscopic lateral release, while 16% (n = 7) had arthroscopic excision of the accessory fragment and 5% (n = 2) had arthroscopic excision and release. All patients except for one, who experienced postoperative trauma, were pain-free after arthroscopic treatment and were able to return to sports after a mean 2.6 months.

Conclusion:

This review demonstrated that arthroscopic management of painful bipartite patella is a safe and effective alternative to open surgical excision or release. However, all articles were case studies or small case series, owing to the rarity of the condition. In the future, higher-level studies comparing arthroscopic techniques and postoperative rehabilitation programs should be performed.

New variant of bipartite patella with traumatic separation and complete disruption of the extensor mechanism of the knee

Very few case reports have been reported on traumatic separation of the bipartite patella along with quadriceps tendon rupture. These reports relate to separation of superolateral bipartite patella (Saupe type 3). We describe a new variant which to our knowledge has not been described or classified so far, which is purely a superior bipartite patella with traumatic separation and complete functional disruption of the extensor mechanism of the knee in a young patient working in the army which was managed with open reduction and internal fixation along with repair of the extensor mechanism of the knee achieving complete functional recovery.

Small but troublesome: accessory ossicles with clinical significance

Accessory ossicles are supernumerary and inconstant structures that are not caused by fractures. Derived from unfused ossification centers, accessory ossicles were first described by Vesalius in 1543. For centuries, they were believed to be asymptomatic. However, with advances in radiology techniques, many have been associated with painful syndromes. Although the original descriptions date from the sixteenth century, the subject is little discussed and, in some cases, controversial. The objective of this study was to describe the radiological aspects of a series of accessory ossicles and to review the evolution of their various descriptions, in order to revive discussion of the subject.

Clinical Outcome of Arthroscopic Lateral Retinacular Release for Symptomatic Bipartite Patella in Athletes

PURPOSE

To report the results of arthroscopic lateral retinacular release without excision of the accessory fragment for treatment of symptomatic bipartite patella with a minimum 2-year follow-up.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed all cases of symptomatic type III bipartite patella confirmed by radiographs, computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging and treated with arthroscopic lateral release from 2005 to 2015. Patients with history of knee fractures or surgery, concomitant meniscal or anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) procedures, and severe arthritic changes of the patellofemoral joint were excluded. Patients were assessed by Kujala score, visual analog scale (VAS), Tegner Activity Scale (TAS), and time to return to sporting activities.

RESULTS

Ten patients (11 knees) were clinically reassessed after 69.6 ± 33.3 (range: 25-132; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 47.29-91.99) months from surgery. There was a significant improvement in Kujala (P < .05) and VAS scores (P < .05), and no differences were found between pre- and postoperative TAS scores (P > .05). No complications occurred during the follow-up period. All patients returned to sport after 42.3 ± 11.3 (range: 30-60; 95% CI: 34.71-49.84) days after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The arthroscopic lateral retinacular release of a symptomatic type III bipartite patella without excision of the accessory fragment allowed early return to sporting activities, with excellent symptom relief. Patients had significantly improved mean Kujala and VAS scores without a decrease in the mean TAS scores.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, case series.

Successful Treatment of Painful Synchondrosis of Bipartite Patella after Direct Trauma by Operative Fixation: A Series of Six Cases

Introduction:

The patella is the largest sesamoid bone in the body and may have one (77%) or multiple (23%) ossification centres. Patellar and patellofemoral joint abnormalities are a common cause of anterior knee pain but symptomatic bipartite patella is an uncommon problem.

Case Series:

We report a series of six cases of painful synchondrosis in bipartite patellae, all in keen athletes following a direct blow to the anterior aspect of the knee. A complete rupture of the synchondrosis with evidence of retropatellar chondral separation was seen on MRI scan in all cases. Successful surgical fixation was undertaken with complete resolution of symptoms in all patients at an average of three months post-operatively.

Conclusion:

Painful synchondrosis of a bipartite patella in young and active individuals following direct trauma is a relatively rare cause of anterior knee pain, but may be associated with significant morbidity. In cases refractory to non-operative management, successful symptomatic treatment can be achieved by operative fixation.

Traumatic Rupture of an Intermediate Tendon in a Patient with Patellar Duplication

Patellar duplication is a rare asymptomatic condition. The diagnosis is often made following a traumatic event associated with an injury to the knee extensor mechanism. The treatment is often surgical and consists in removal of the smaller part of the patella with tendon reinsertion. The presence and rupture of an intermediate tendon between the two parts of the patella have not been reported in the modern literature. We present a traumatic rupture of an intermediate tendon in a patient with horizontal patellar duplication. The surgical management consisted of tenorrhaphy protected with a figure-of-eight tension band wire approximating the two parts of the patella. The patient recovered full knee range of motion and quadriceps strength at the last 8-month follow-up.

Forensic Identification of Bipartite Patella Misdiagnosed as Patella Fracture

Bipartite patella is recognized as a developmental anomaly of ossification. Most of them are asymptomatic and are discovered incidentally. Bipartite patella is sometimes misdiagnosed as a patella fracture, because the x-ray images of both these conditions may appear very similar. In this case, the patient complained of left knee pain after x-ray films revealed a fracture-like line in the left patella. The patient was then diagnosed as having a patella fracture. In China, the injury degree is categorized as serious injury, minor injury, and trivial injury. As the injury degree of patellar fracture is identified as minor injury, the defendant who injured the patient will be sentenced to prison for ≤3 years. However, the defendant objected to this judgment and applied for the second evaluation of injury degree. On the basis of the site of injury, clinical manifestations, and imaging findings, we diagnosed the patient with bipartite patella which belongs to normal anatomic variant. Therefore, the injury degree of the patient was not minor injury.

Arthroscopic treatment of painful Sinding-Larsen-Johansson syndrome in a professional handball player

Sinding-Larsen-Johansson (SLJ) syndrome is a type of osteochondrosis of the distal pole of the patella most often caused by repeated microtrauma. Here, we describe the case of a professional athlete with painful SLJ syndrome treated arthroscopically. A 29-year-old male professional handball player presented with anterior knee pain that persisted after 4 months of an eccentric rehabilitation protocol and platelet-rich plasma injections. Despite this conservative treatment, the patient could not participate in his sport. The SLJ lesion was excised arthroscopically, which led to complete disappearance of symptoms and return to competitive sports after 5 months.

The management of the painful bipartite patella: a systematic review

PURPOSE

This study aimed to identify the most effective method for the treatment of the symptomatic bipartite patella.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was completed, and all studies assessing the management of a bipartite patella were included. Owing to the paucity of randomised controlled trials, a narrative review of 22 studies was completed. A range of treatments were assessed: conservative measures, open and arthroscopic fixation or excision and soft tissue release and excision.

RESULTS

All of the methods provided results ranging from good to excellent, with acceptable complication rates.

CONCLUSIONS

This is a poorly answered treatment question. No firm guidance can be given as to the most appropriate method of treating the symptomatic bipartite patella. This study suggests that there are a number of effective treatments with acceptable complication rates and it may be that treatments that conserve the patella are more appropriate for larger fragments.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Return to activity among athletes with a symptomatic bipartite patella: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

A bipartite patella is typically rare, but can become symptomatic during overuse activities such as those performed during athletic events. Therefore, this anomaly typically presents in the young, athletic population, often inhibiting athletic activities. Multiple treatment options exist, with nonsurgical management frequently adopted as the initial treatment of choice.

PURPOSE

To determine the most effective intervention in returning athletes with symptomatic bipartite patella to their prior activity levels.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was performed using PRISMA guidelines to identify studies reporting outcomes of athletes' ability to return to activity following treatment for a symptomatic bipartite patella. The type of intervention, type of bipartite classification, outcomes, and complications were recorded.

RESULTS

Twenty articles with a total of 125 patients and 130 knees were identified and included in this review. A total of 105 athletes made a full return to athletic activity following treatment for their painful bipartite patella. One hundred athletes (85.5%) that underwent surgical treatment were able to make a full return to their sport without symptoms, although this varied by surgical procedure performed. Excision of the painful fragment produced the best results in returning athletes to sport, with 91% returning without symptoms and nine percent returning but with residual symptoms.

CONCLUSION

Surgical treatments for symptomatic bipartite patellae are successful at returning athletes to their same level of play, and best outcomes are with excision of the fragment. These results are limited, however, due to the poor quality of original data given the rarity of the anomaly and the underrepresented conservative treatment group.

Bipartite patella causing knee pain in young adults: a report of 5 cases

We report on 5 patients who underwent arthroscopic excision or open reduction and internal fixation for bipartite patella. All patients presented with refractory anterior knee pain. The diagnosis of bipartite patella was made using radiography, and confirmed with magnetic resonance imaging or computed tomographic arthrography. All 5 patients achieved complete resolution of symptoms after surgery, and remained pain-free after a mean followup period of 13 months.

Tibial tubercle fracture in a 14-year-old athlete with bilateral lower pole bipartite patella and osgood-schlatter disease

We present a case of tibial tubercle fracture in a young male athlete with both bilateral bipartite patella at the lower pole (Saupe type I) and Osgood-Schlatter disease. Open reduction and internal fixation were performed to restore the extensor mechanism of the knee.

Patella fracture in a boy with bilateral inferior pole bipartite patellae

We present the case of a 12 year old boy who had bilateral inferior pole fragment (Saupe type 1) bipartite patellae, and who sustained a traumatic separation through the right patella while playing basket ball, the left remaining asymptomatic. We have reviewed and discussed the previously published literature and case reports.

Injury of a bipartite patella in a young upcoming sportsman

The aim of this study was to report the clinical features of a young athletic patient with bipartite patella, and review the literature to discuss the entity of this rare anomaly. In the course of an athletics competition, a 12-year-old top sportsman felt an intense pain around his left knee-cap while taking off from a jumping-board and broke down the competition. X-rays and magnetic resonance imaging showed an isolated distal pole of the patella with just minor diastasis; however, the X-rays did not suggest a recent fracture but rather hint at an atypically injured bipartite patella. A conservative therapy of 5 weeks with brace followed including a ban on sport activities for 12 weeks. Ten weeks later, the radiographs revealed a complete consolidation. Six months after the injury, MRI only presented a generally inconspicuous horizontal sclerosed structure. A fracture or separation of the bipartite patella was retrospectively diagnosed.

Magnetic resonance imaging of anatomical variations in the knee. Part 2: miscellaneous

Magnetic resonance imaging is the modality of choice for investigation of internal derangement of the knee. The reporting radiologist must be familiar with both normal anatomy and anatomical variants within the knee, in order to avoid mis-diagnosis, over-investigation and unnecessary intervention. This article reviews the recognised anatomical variants of the non-ligamentous/musculotendinous structures of the knee, their anatomy, incidence and typical appearances on MRI.

Clinical features and classification of bipartite or tripartite patella

The purposes of this study were to report clinical features of the developmental anomaly of ossification type bipartite or tripartite patella using a large series and to propose a new classification for the developmental anomaly of ossification type bipartite or tripartite patella. The first author prospectively examined 111 patients with symptomatic or asymptomatic bipartite (131 knees) or tripartite (8 knees) patellae. Eighty-six (77%) were male and 25 (23%) were female. Forty-three patients (39%) showed right knee involvement and 40 (36%) showed left, while 28 (25%) showed involvement in both knees. Forty-six bipartite and 4 tripartite patellae (36%) were symptomatic and 85 bipartite and 4 tripartite patellae (64%) were asymptomatic at initial examination. The median age at onset of pain of symptomatic patients (50 knees) was 15.6 ± 8.1 years (range, 10-51 years). The most common symptom was pain at the separated fragments during or after strenuous activity in all 50 knees. Physical examination revealed localized tenderness over the separated fragments in all 50 knees. Bipartite or tripartite patellae were classified by evaluating location and number of fragments. One hundred fifteen knees (83%) were classified as supero-lateral bipartite type, 16 (12%) were lateral bipartite type, 6 (4%) were supero-lateral and lateral tripartite type, and 2 (1%) were supero-lateral tripartite type. For the developmental anomaly of ossification type bipartite or tripartite patella, a classification based on both location and number of fragments is simple and easy to understand and applicable to all types of bipartite or tripartite patella.

Symptomatic bipartite patella: treatment alternatives

Bipartite patella is usually an asymptomatic, incidental finding. However, in adolescents, it may be a cause of anterior knee pain following trauma or a result of overuse or strenuous sports activity. Most patients improve with nonsurgical treatment. Surgery is considered when nonsurgical treatment fails. Excision of the fragment is the most popular surgical option, with good results. However, when the fragment is large and has an articular surface, excision may lead to patellofemoral incongruity. Lateral retinacular release and detachment of the vastus lateralis muscle insertion are other surgical options and are reported to produce good pain relief and union in some patients. These procedures reduce the traction force of the vastus lateralis on the loose fragment. Internal fixation of the separated fragment has limited support in the literature. Understanding the possible consequences of different treatment approaches to painful bipartite patella is necessary to preserve quadriceps muscle strength and patellofemoral joint function.

Separation of a bipartite patella combined with quadriceps tendon rupture: a case report

Separation of a bipartite patella is very rare. We found only seven cases in the literature [Carter SR. Traumatic separation of a bipartite patella. Injury 1989;20:244; Ireland ML, Chang JL. Acute fracture bipartite patella; case report and literature review. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1995; 27:299-302; Ishii M, Yabuno K, Ishikawa T, Tsujino H, Yamaguchi K. A case of bipartite patella separation accompanied by subcutaneous rupture of quadriceps tendon. Seikeigeka (Orthopedic Surgery) 2003;54:1563-5. [In Japanese]; Canizares GH, Selesnick FH. Bipartite patella fracture. Arthroscopy 2003;19:215-7; Okuno H, Sugita T, Kawamata T, Ohnuma M, Yamada N, Yoshizumi Y. Traumatic separation of a type 1 bipartite patella; a report of four knees. Clin Orthop 2004;420:257-60]. Among these cases only one was complicated with quadriceps tendon rupture, and the patient had diabetes as underlying disease [Ishii M, Yabuno K, Ishikawa T, Tsujino H, Yamaguchi K. A case of bipartite patella separation accompanied by subcutaneous rupture of quadriceps tendon. Seikeigeka (Orthopedic Surgery) 2003;54:1563-5. [In Japanese]]. To our knowledge, there have been no reports of this condition in a healthy subject. In this report, we present a case of bipartite patella separation complicated with quadriceps tendon rupture in a patient with no underlying disease. Treatment involving suturing the tendon to the patella and osteosynthesis of the bipartite patella produced a good result.

Traumatic separation of an uncommon bipartite patella type: a case report

The authors report about a case of traumatic separation of a horizontally bipartite patella in a young female soccer player. Unspecific anterior knee pain preceded the fracture, which had occurred after an inadequate trauma. Open reduction and osteosynthesis led to bony union with an excellent clinical outcome at follow-up.

Hemilaterally symptomatic bipartite patella associated with bone erosions arising from a gouty tophus: a case report

Symptomatic bipartite patella in adults is rare. We have treated an unusual case of a bipartite patella in an adult, which became symptomatic in association with cystic degeneration localized to the patella and a gouty tophus. Although the patient had bilateral bipartite patellae, multiplanar reformation with computed tomography (CT-MPR) clearly demonstrated that the bipartite portion of the patella was malaligned at the junction of the accessory bone and patella in the symptomatic knee. Bone erosions were present both in the bipartite fragment and adjacent portion of the patella. After surgical excision of the bipartite fragment, the patient's symptoms have improved. This case illustrates that cyst formation associated with inflammatory arthritis may be a rare cause for a bipartite patella in an adult to become symptomatic.