Dobutamine improves the adequacy of gastric mucosal perfusion in epinephrine-treated septic shock

The Effects of Dobutamine in Septic Shock: An Updated Narrative Review of Clinical and Experimental Studies

The key objective in the hemodynamic treatment of septic shock is the optimization of tissue perfusion and oxygenation. This is usually achieved by the utilization of fluids, vasopressors, and inotropes. Dobutamine is the inotrope most commonly recommended and used for this purpose. Despite the fact that dobutamine was introduced almost half a century ago in the treatment of septic shock, and there is widespread use of the drug, several aspects of its pharmacodynamics remain poorly understood. In normal subjects, dobutamine increases contractility and lacks a direct effect on vascular tone. This results in augmented cardiac output and blood pressure, with reflex reduction in systemic vascular resistance. In septic shock, some experimental and clinical research suggest beneficial effects on systemic and regional perfusion. Nevertheless, other studies found heterogeneous and unpredictable effects with frequent side effects. In this narrative review, we discuss the pharmacodynamic characteristics of dobutamine and its physiologic actions in different settings, with special reference to septic shock. We discuss studies showing that dobutamine frequently induces tachycardia and vasodilation, without positive actions on contractility. Since untoward effects are often found and therapeutic benefits are occasional, its profile of efficacy and safety seems low. Therefore, we recommend that the use of dobutamine in septic shock should be cautious. Before a final decision about its prescription, efficacy, and tolerance should be evaluated throughout a short period with narrow monitoring of its wanted and side effects.

Alternatives to norepinephrine in septic shock: Which agents and when?

Vasopressors are the cornerstone of hemodynamic management in patients with septic shock. Norepinephrine is currently recommended as the first-line vasopressor in these patients. In addition to norepinephrine, there are many other potent vasopressors with specific properties and/or advantages that act on vessels through different pathways after activation of specific receptors; these could be of interest in patients with septic shock. Dopamine is no longer recommended in patients with septic shock because its use is associated with a higher rate of cardiac arrhythmias without any benefit in terms of mortality or organ dysfunction. Epinephrine is currently considered as a second-line vasopressor therapy, because of the higher rate of associated metabolic and cardiac adverse effects compared with norepinephrine; however, it may be considered in settings where norepinephrine is unavailable or in patients with refractory septic shock and myocardial dysfunction. Owing to its potential effects on mortality and renal function and its norepinephrine-sparing effect, vasopressin is recommended as second-line vasopressor therapy instead of norepinephrine dose escalation in patients with septic shock and persistent arterial hypotension. However, two synthetic analogs of vasopressin, namely, terlipressin and selepressin, have not yet been employed in the management of patients with septic shock, as their use is associated with a higher rate of digital ischemia. Finally, angiotensin Ⅱ also appears to be a promising vasopressor in patients with septic shock, especially in the most severe cases and/or in patients with acute kidney injury requiring renal replacement therapy. Nevertheless, due to limited evidence and concerns regarding safety (which remains unclear because of potential adverse effects related to its marked vasopressor activity), angiotensin Ⅱ is currently not recommended in patients with septic shock. Further studies are needed to better define the role of these vasopressors in the management of these patients.

Vasopressors and Risk of Acute Mesenteric Ischemia: A Worldwide Pharmacovigilance Analysis and Comprehensive Literature Review

Vasodilatory shock, such as septic shock, requires personalized management which include adequate fluid therapy and vasopressor treatments. While these potent drugs are numerous, they all aim to counterbalance the vasodilatory effects of a systemic inflammatory response syndrome. Their specific receptors include α- and β-adrenergic receptors, arginine-vasopressin receptors, angiotensin II receptors and dopamine receptors. Consequently, these may be associated with severe adverse effects, including acute mesenteric ischemia (AMI). As the risk of AMI depends on drug class, we aimed to review the evidence of plausible associations by performing a worldwide pharmacovigilance analysis based on the World Health Organization database, VigiBase®. Among 24 million reports, 104 AMI events were reported, and disproportionality analyses yielded significant association with all vasopressors, to the exception of selepressin. Furthermore, in a comprehensive literature review, we detailed mechanistic phenomena which may enhance vasopressor selection, in the course of treating vasodilatory shock.

Dose equivalence between metaraminol and norepinephrine in critical care

AIMS

The aim of this study was to determine the conversion dose ratio between continuous infusion metaraminol and norepinephrine in critically ill patients with shock.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was conducted in adult patients with shock admitted to an intensive care unit from 29 October 2018 to 30 October 2019 and who transitioned from metaraminol monotherapy to norepinephrine monotherapy. Mean arterial pressure (MAP) and infusion doses for both drugs were collected at hourly intervals; 2 hours before to 5 hours after switching from metaraminol monotherapy to norepinephrine monotherapy. The conversion dose ratio was defined as the ratio of metaraminol (μg.kg^-1 .min^-1) : norepinephrine (μg.kg^-1 .min^-1 ) required to achieve a similar MAP.

RESULTS

A total of 43 out of 144 eligible patients were included. The median age was 68 years (IQR 56-76) and 22 (51%) were male. There was no significant difference between the baseline MAP during metaraminol monotherapy (median 71 mm Hg, IQR 66-76) and the post-transition MAP during norepinephrine monotherapy (median 70 mm Hg, IQR 66-73) (P = .09). The median conversion dose ratio between metaraminol and norepinephrine was 13 (IQR 7-24). In the sensitivity analyses, the median conversion dose ratio using the maximum and the mean norepinephrine infusion dose was 8 (IQR 5-16) and 12 (IQR 8-23), respectively.

CONCLUSION

A conversion dose ratio of 10:1 (metaraminol μg.kg^-1 .min^-1 :norepinephrine μg.kg^-1 .min^-1 ) may be used in critically ill patients with shock to account for ease of calculations and variability of the conversion ratio in the primary and sensitivity analyses.

Update on Vasopressors and Inotropes in Septic Shock

Vasopressors and inotropes are used in septic shock in patients who remain hypotensive despite adequate fluid resuscitation. The goal is to increase blood pressure to optimize perfusion to organs. Generally, goal-directed therapy to supra-normal oxygen transport variables cannot be recommended due to lack of benefit. Traditionally, vasopressors and inotropes in septic shock have been started in a step-wise fashion starting with dopamine. Recent data suggest that there may be true differences among vasopressors and inotropes on local tissue perfusion as measured by regional hemodynamic and oxygen transport. When started early in septic shock, norepinephrine decreases mortality, optimizes hemodynamic variables, and improves systemic and regional (eg, renal, gastric mucosal, splanchnic) perfusion. Epinephrine causes a greater increase in cardiac index (CI) and oxygen delivery (DO2 ) and increases gastric mucosal flow, but increases lactic acid and may not adequately preserve splanchnic circulation owing to its predominant vasoconstrictive alpha (α ) effects. Epinephrine may be particularly useful when used earlier in the course of septic shock in young patients and those who do not have any known cardiac abnormalities. Unlike epinephrine, dopamine does not preferentially increase the proportion of CI that preferentially goes to the splanchnic circulation. Dopamine is further limited because it cannot increase CI by more than 35% and is accompanied by tachycardia or tachydysrhythmias. Dopamine, as opposed to norepinephrine, may worsen splanchnic oxygen consumption (VO2 ) and oxygen extraction ratio (O2 ER). Low-dose dopamine has not been shown to consistently increase the glomerular filtration rate or prevent renal failure, and, indeed, worsens splanchnic tissue oxygen use. Routine use of concurrently administered dopamine with vasopressors is not recommended. Phenylephrine should be used when a pure vasoconstrictor is desired in patients who may not require or do not tolerate the beta (β ) effects of dopamine or norepinephrine with or without dobutamine. Patients with high filling pressure and hypotension may benefit from the combination of phenylephrine and dobutamine. Investigational approaches to vasopressor-refractory hypotension in septic shock include the use of vasopressin and corticosteroids.

Effects of dobutamine on systemic, regional and microcirculatory perfusion parameters in septic shock: a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind, crossover study

PURPOSE

The role of dobutamine during septic shock resuscitation is still controversial since most clinical studies have been uncontrolled and no physiological study has unequivocally demonstrated a beneficial effect on tissue perfusion. Our objective was to determine the potential benefits of dobutamine on hemodynamic, metabolic, peripheral, hepatosplanchnic and microcirculatory perfusion parameters during early septic shock resuscitation.

METHODS

We designed a randomized, controlled, double-blind, crossover study comparing the effects of 2.5-h infusion of dobutamine (5 mcg/kg/min fixed-dose) or placebo in 20 septic shock patients with cardiac index ≥2.5 l/min/m(2) and hyperlactatemia. Primary outcome was sublingual perfused microvascular density.

RESULTS

Despite an increasing cardiac index, heart rate and left ventricular ejection fraction, dobutamine had no effect on sublingual perfused vessel density [9.0 (7.9-10.1) vs. 9.1 n/mm (7.9-9.9); p = 0.24] or microvascular flow index [2.1 (1.8-2.5) vs. 2.1 (1.9-2.5); p = 0.73] compared to placebo. No differences between dobutamine and placebo were found for the lactate levels, mixed venous-arterial pCO2 gradient, thenar muscle oxygen saturation, capillary refill time or gastric-to-arterial pCO2 gradient. The indocyanine green plasma disappearance rate [14.4 (9.5-25.6) vs. 18.8 %/min (11.7-24.6); p = 0.03] and the recovery slope of thenar muscle oxygen saturation after a vascular occlusion test [2.1 (1.1-3.1) vs. 2.5 %/s (1.2-3.4); p = 0.01] were worse with dobutamine compared to placebo.

CONCLUSIONS

Dobutamine failed to improve sublingual microcirculatory, metabolic, hepatosplanchnic or peripheral perfusion parameters despite inducing a significant increase in systemic hemodynamic variables in septic shock patients without low cardiac output but with persistent hypoperfusion.

[Diagnosis and management of acute mesenteric ischemia]

The prevalence of significant splanchnic arterial stenoses is increasing, but remains mostly asymptomatic due to abundant collateral circulation. Acute insufficiency of mesenteric arterial blood flow accounts for 60 to 70% of cases of mesenteric ischemia and results mostly from a superior mesenteric embolus. Despite major advances have been achieved in understanding the pathogenic mechanisms of bowel ischemia, its prognosis remains dismal with mortality rates about 60%. The diagnosis of acute mesenteric ischemia depends upon a high clinical suspicion, especially in patients with known risk factors. Rapid diagnosis is essential to prevent intestinal infarction. However, early signs and symptoms of mesenteric ischemia are non specific, and definitive diagnosis often requires radiologic examinations. Early and liberal implementation of angiography has been the major advance over the past 30 years which allowed increasing diagnostic accuracy of acute mesenteric ischemia. CT and MR-based angiographic techniques have emerged as alternatives less invasive and more accurate to analyse splanchnic vessels and evaluate bowel infarction. The goal of treatment of patients with acute mesenteric ischemia is to restore intestinal oxygenation as quickly as possible after initial management that includes rapid hemodynamic monitoring and support. Surgery should not be delayed in patients suspected of having intestinal necrosis.

Septic shock resuscitation: what goals and how to achieve them?

The need to achieve adequate tissue oxygen delivery early in patients with septic shock is well established. However, it is less well recognized that tissue hypoperfusion can exist despite normalization of systemic hemodynamics. Efforts to resuscitate septic patients until adequate tissue perfusion has been achieved can potentially improve outcome. In a multicenter study, 130 patients with septic shock were resuscitated within 12 hours of diagnosis using a protocol including goals for mean arterial and pulmonary artery occluded pressures, urinary output, arterial pH, and hemoglobin goals. They were then randomly assigned to further resuscitation with either a cardiac index (≥ 3 l/minute per m²) or a gastric mucosal pH (≥ 7.32) target. The intensive care unit length of stay and 28-day mortality did not differ between groups, but more patients in the cardiac index group were in the target range, both at baseline and after resuscitation, as compared with the gastric mucosal pH group. In contrast to cardiac index, gastric mucosal pH at baseline and at 24 and 48 hours predicted mortality. Whether other targets for the chosen variables, or different and – in particular – earlier resuscitation efforts would have favored one group cannot be concluded from the data provided.

[Microcirculation of intensive care patients. From the physiology to the bedside]

The microcirculation is unique in its anatomy and physiology and is a self-contained organ system within the human body. It is the site where gas exchange and nutrient supply takes place, but it is also the site which experiences pathological alterations during various shock states and therefore compromises the oxygen supply to tissues and organs. Systemic inflammation for example leads amongst others to increased heterogeneous blood flow, formation of interstitial edema, altered viscosity, leukocyte activation, disturbances in the coagulation system, and to a breakdown of the endothelial barrier function. These alterations inevitably lead to limitations of the oxygen supply to tissues. Without interruption of these pathomechanisms, the dysfunction of the microcirculation will consequently result in organ dysfunction. In this review article a short description of the microcirculatory physiology, the interaction between the macrocirculation and the microcirculation, as well as microcirculatory alterations generated by a systemic inflammatory response will be given. Finally, various therapy options will be described, which, experimentally, can lead to an improvement in microcirculatory dysfunction.

Review article: inotrope and vasopressor use in the emergency department

Shock is a common presentation to the ED, with the incidence of septic shock increasing in Australasia over the last decade. The choice of inotropic agent is likely dependent on previous experience and local practices of the emergency and other critical care departments. The relatively short duration of stay in the ED before transfer leaves little room for evaluating the appropriateness of and response to the agent chosen. Delays in transfer to inpatient facilities means that patients receive advanced critical care within the ED for longer, requiring initiation and titration of vasoactive agents in the ED. This article discusses the general concepts of shock and the indicators for inotrope and vasopressor use, revises the various agents available and reviews the current evidence for their use.

Acute hypercapnia improves indices of tissue oxygenation more than dobutamine in septic shock

RATIONALE

Hypercapnia has similar hemodynamic effects to those of a dobutamine infusion and may have relevance in the management of septic shock.

OBJECTIVES

To compare the effects induced by hypercapnia with those of dobutamine in a clinically relevant model of septic shock.

METHODS

Fecal peritonitis was induced in 21 anesthetized, invasively monitored, mechanically ventilated female sheep. A combination of Ringer's lactate and 6% hydroxyethyl starch solution was titrated to maintain constant cardiac filling throughout the experiments. Two hours after feces spillage, animals were randomized to one of three groups (each, n = 7): (1) hypercapnia: carbon dioxide given to maintain partial pressure of carbon dioxide between 55 and 65 mm Hg throughout the experiment; (2) dobutamine: dobutamine infused intravenously (7 microg/kg/min); (3) control: no treatment. In the dobutamine and control groups, the partial pressure of carbon dioxide was kept between 35 and 45 mm Hg. All animals were monitored until spontaneous death.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The animals in the hypercapnia group had significantly lower arterial pH than the other two groups (P < 0.05). Hypercapnic and dobutamine-treated animals developed significantly higher heart rate, cardiac index, and oxygen delivery, and lower lactate concentrations than control animals (P < 0.05). Hypercapnic animals had lower post mortem lung wet/dry ratio than the control animals (P < 0.05). The alveolar-arterial oxygen partial pressure difference and shunt fraction were significantly lower in hypercapnic animals than in the other groups (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

In this clinically relevant ovine model of septic shock, hypercapnia had similar effects to dobutamine on hemodynamic variables and lactic acidosis. Hypercapnia improved tissue oxygenation and reduced lung edema formation more than dobutamine administration.

Metabolic effects of vasoactive agents

After adequate volume resuscitation, the mainstay of therapy in critically ill patients with shock is treatment with vasoactive substances to restore haemodynamics or to improve regional perfusion. These agents include adrenoceptor agonists with inotropic combined with either vasoconstricting or vasodilating effects, and predominantly vasodilating drugs such as prostacyclin and related compounds. However, vasoactive agents not only affect the cardiovascular system, but also have profound metabolic effects. The interdependence of vasoactive drugs with metabolism may be relevant regarding adequate oxygen and substrate delivery to cover actual organ needs. Therefore, the profiles of these metabolic effects have to be considered during their therapeutic administration.

Dobutamine Improves Liver Function after Hemorrhagic Shock through Induction of Heme Oxygenase-1

RATIONALE

Induction of heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) protects the liver against reperfusion injury after hemorrhagic shock. Previous data suggest that the beta(1)-adrenoceptor agonist dobutamine induces HO-1 in hepatocytes.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the functional significance of dobutamine pretreatment for liver function after hemorrhagic shock in vivo.

METHODS

Anesthetized rats received either Ringer's (Vehicle/Shock), 10 microg/kg/min of the beta(1)-adrenoceptor agonist dobutamine (Dob/Shock), or 10 microg/kg/min dobutamine and 500 microg/kg/min of the beta(1)-adrenoceptor antagonist esmolol (Dob/Esmolol/Shock) for 6 h. Hemorrhagic shock was induced thereafter (mean arterial pressure, 35 mm Hg for 90 min). Animals were resuscitated with shed blood and Ringer's. In addition, the HO pathway was blocked after dobutamine pretreatment with 10 micromol/kg tin-mesoporphyrin-IX (Dob/SnMP/Shock) or animals received 100 mg/kg of the carbon monoxide donor dichloromethane (DCM/Shock).

MEASUREMENTS

Hepatocellular metabolism and liver blood flow were measured by plasma disappearance rate of indocyanine green (PDR(ICG)) as a sensitive marker of liver function.

MAIN RESULTS

Pretreatment with dobutamine induced HO-1 in pericentral hepatocytes and improved PDR(ICG) (Vehicle/Shock: 11.7 +/- 8.12%/min vs. Dob/Shock: 19.7 +/- 2.46%/min, p = 0.006). Blockade of the HO pathway after preconditioning and the combined pretreatment with dobutamine and esmolol decreased PDR(ICG) (Dob/SnMP/Shock: 12.6 +/- 4.24%/min, p = 0.011; Dob/Esmolol/Shock: 10.2 +/- 4.34%/min, p = 0.008). Pretreatment with a carbon monoxide donor improved PDR(ICG) (DCM/Shock: 18 +/- 3.19%/min, p = 0.022) compared with Vehicle/Shock.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest a beta(1)-adrenoceptor-dependent hepatic up-regulation of HO-1 and a better maintained hepatocellular function after hemorrhagic shock in animals pretreated with dobutamine. The improved hepatocellular function may be in part mediated by carbon monoxide because of up-regulation of HO-1. Pretreatment with dobutamine might be a potential means of pharmacologic preconditioning before ischemia-reperfusion of the liver.

Effects of vasopressin, norepinephrine, and l-arginine on intestinal microcirculation in endotoxemia*

OBJECTIVE

The effects of vasopressin, norepinephrine, and L-arginine alone or combined on intestinal microcirculation were evaluated in the septic mouse by intravital microscopy, with which we measured the erythrocyte flux and velocity in villus tip arterioles and the density of perfused villi.

DESIGN

Controlled animal study.

SETTING

University research laboratory.

SUBJECTS

Female BALB/c mice weighing between 18 and 21 g.

INTERVENTIONS

Anesthetized and ventilated mice received at t0 an intravenous injection of Escherichia coli endotoxin (2 mg/kg bolus intravenously), inducing after 1 hr (t60) a decrease in mean arterial blood pressure to 40-50 mm Hg associated with a significant decrease in erythrocyte flux and velocity in villus tip arterioles and in the density of perfused villi. The mice then received a randomly different treatment for endotoxin-induced shock. Treatments consisted in continuous intravenous infusion for 1 hr with either saline (control group), norepinephrine, vasopressin, L-arginine, vasopressin+L-arginine, or norepinephrine+L-arginine. The doses of vasopressors (used alone or combined with L-arginine) were titrated to restore mean arterial pressure to the baseline level.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

At the end of the treatment (t120), we observed in the control group further decreases in arteriolar flux and velocity and in the density of perfused villi. In the groups treated by a vasopressor alone, mean arterial pressure returned to baseline and there were no additional decreases in arteriolar flux and velocity or in the density of perfused villi. However, these latter three variables did not return to their preshock baseline values. Even though L-arginine did not restore mean arterial pressure, the infusion of L-arginine alone prevented the decrease in flux or erythrocyte velocity occurring between t60 and t120 and conserved to some extent the density of perfused villi compared with that in the control groups. In addition, we found that simultaneous administration of norepinephrine or vasopressin with L-arginine improved all microcirculation variables more efficiently than either vasopressor alone.

CONCLUSIONS

From these data, we conclude that a) restoring mean arterial pressure after 1 hr of endotoxemia was not sufficient to restore ad integrum intestinal mucosa microvascular perfusion; b) L-arginine could have a beneficial effect at the microcirculatory level, which was independent of mean arterial pressure; and c) administration of L-arginine combined with the maintenance of perfusion pressure by vasopressive drugs allowed a better preservation of intestinal microcirculation at an early stage of endotoxemia.

[Microcirculatory monitoring of sepsis]

Microcirculatory dysfunctions play a central role in the pathophysiology of sepsis and shock. Modern methods enable microvascular monitoring in man and offer the possibility to test the effect of novel therapeutical strategies for sepsis. Furthermore, these techniques may be future tools for the monitoring of critically ill patients. In this review, we will describe four microvascular monitoring devices and give an overview of the microcirculatory changes observed during the course of sepsis. Laser Doppler fluxmetry is an easy to use noninvasive technique to measure tissue perfusion enabling monitoring of the effect of different catecholamines on the gastric perfusion during sepsis. Increased microvascular permeability and altered blood flow in septic patients can be quantified by venous congestion plethysmography. Alterations in sublingual microvascular blood flow are detected by intravital microscopy in septic patients and were identified as an outcome predictor. Furthermore, the role of gastrointestinal pCO2-tonometry for microcirculatory monitoring of the perfusion of splanchnic organs during sepsis is discussed. The true clinical value of these techniques has yet to be established and will depend on larger clinical trials showing an impact on diagnostics and patient management.

Bench-to-bedside review: Is there a place for epinephrine in septic shock?

The use of epinephrine in septic shock remains controversial. Nevertheless, epinephrine is widely used around the world and the reported morbidity and mortality rates with it are no different from those observed with other vasopressors. In volunteers, epinephrine increases heart rate, mean arterial pressure and cardiac output. Epinephrine also induces hyperglycemia and hyperlactatemia. In hyperkinetic septic shock, epinephrine consistently increases arterial pressure and cardiac output in a dose dependent manner. Epinephrine transiently increases lactate levels through an increase in aerobic glycolysis. Epinephrine has no effect on splanchnic circulation in dopamine-sensitive septic shock. On the other hand, in dopamine-resistant septic shock, epinephrine has no effect on tonometric parameters but decreases fractional splanchnic blood flow with an increase in the gradient of mixed venous oxygen saturation (SVO₂) and hepatic venous oxygen saturation (SHO₂). In conclusion, epinephrine has predictable effects on systemic hemodynamics and is as efficient as norepinephrine in correcting hemodynamic disturbances of septic shock. Moreover, epinephrine is cheaper than other commonly used catecholamine regimens in septic shock. The clinical impact of the transient hyperlactatemia and of the splanchnic effects are not established.

Inotropes and vasopressors in adults and foals

Successful treatment with inotropes and vasopressors depends on an understanding of the interplay of flow, pressure, and resistance in the cardiovascular system and an appreciation of the pathophysiologic mechanisms leading to inadequate tissue perfusion. Any treatment strategy is necessarily a compromise between the requirements of different vascular beds.Furthermore. the underlying hemodynamic derangements can change rapidly. Therefore. inotropes and vasopressors should be titrated to measures of improved hemodynamic status, and the treatments should be frequently reviewed.

Dobutamine compensates deleterious hemodynamic and metabolic effects of vasopressin in the splanchnic region in endotoxin shock

BACKGROUND

Vasopressin is a potent vasopressor in septic shock, but it may impair splanchnic perfusion. We compared the effects of vasopressin alone and in combination with dobutamine on systemic and splanchnic circulation and metabolism in porcine endotoxin shock.

METHODS

Twelve pigs were randomized to receive either vasopressin (VASO, n = 6) or vasopressin in combination with dobutamine (DOBU, n = 6) during endotoxin shock (E. coli endotoxin infusion). Endotoxin infusion rate was increased to induce hypotension after which vasoactive drugs were started. We aimed to keep systemic mean arterial pressure (MAP) >70 mmHg by vasopressin; the goal of dobutamine infusion was to prevent decrease in cardiac output often associated with vasopressin infusion. Regional blood flows, oxygen delivery and consumption, arterial and regional lactate concentrations were measured.

RESULTS

Mean arterial pressure >70 mmHg was achieved in both the VASO and DOBU groups. After the primary decrease of cardiac output by vasopressin, systemic blood flow remained stable in vasopressin-treated animals. However, vasopressin as a monotherapy decreased portal venous blood flow. This was prevented by dobutamine. Vasopressin also induced splanchnic lactate release and arterial hyperlactatemia, which were not observed when dobutamine was combined with vasopressin.

CONCLUSION

Dobutamine prevents adverse hemodynamic and metabolic effects of vasopressin in septic shock.

Postoperative management in patients with complex congenital heart disease

Life-threatening problems occur in the neonate and infant after cardiac surgery because of the interplay of diminished cardiac output (CO), increased metabolic demand, inflammatory responses to cardiopulmonary bypass, and maladaptive responses to stress. Therefore, the postoperative management of patients with complex congenital heart defects is directed at optimization of oxygen delivery to maintain end-organ function and promote wound healing. Traditionally, assessment of circulation in the postoperative congenital heart patient has depended on indirect assessment of CO using parameters such as blood pressure, pulses, capillary refill, and urine output. Because of the limitations of indirect and observer-dependent assessment of CO, we rely on objective measures of tissue oxygen levels for the complex postoperative patient. We have found that continuous monitoring of the mixed venous saturation (SvO2) allows for identification of acute changes in systemic oxygen delivery and frequently precedes other indicators of decreased CO. The postoperative patient can be expected to have a period of decreasing CO, and the need for intervention should be anticipated because critical low output syndrome will develop in a subset of patients. Strategies for postoperative care are developed based on the diagnosis and procedure, but optimizing SvO2 is a consistent goal. A uniform approach to airway maintenance, vascular access, and drug infusions, all universal concerns during the perioperative period, minimizes the potential for these predictable and necessary interventions to result in morbidity or mortality. Management of the postoperative single ventricle patient targets stabilization of the systemic vascular resistance through the use of vasodilators to improve systemic perfusion and simplify ventilator management. Management of any individual patient should be driven by objective analysis of available data and must include efforts to re-evaluate the treatment plan as well as to identify unanticipated problems.

Acute decompensated heart failure: a contemporary approach to pharmacotherapeutic management

Hospital admissions for acute decompensated heart failure (ADHF) have increased precipitously during the past few decades and are projected to continue to increase in the future. To optimize patient outcomes and reduce the costs associated with this disorder, evidenced-based pharmacotherapy is essential. Continuous infusions of loop diuretic therapy rather than bolus dosing may enhance efficacy and reduce the extent of diuretic resistance. Nesiritide is a pharmacologically novel preload and afterload reducer but based on clinical trial evidence should be reserved for those unable to take or with resistance to intravenous nitrate therapy. Catecholamine- and phosphodiesterase-based inotropic therapies are efficacious, but the increased risk of arrhythmogenesis and the potential for negative survival effects limit their use. The experimental agent levosimendan is a positive inotropic agent but does not increase myocyte calcium concentrations as do catecholamines or phosphodiesterase inhibitors. Clinical trial evidence demonstrates a positive survival benefit for levosimendan versus dobutamine.

Gas tonometry for evaluation of gastrointestinal mucosal perfusion: experimental and clinical sepsis¹. part 2

Substantial clinical and animal evidences indicate that the mesenteric circulatory bed, particularly the gut mucosa, is highly vulnerable to reductions in oxygen supply and prone to early injury in the course of hemodynamic changes induced by sepsis and septic shock. Gut hypoxia or ischemia is one possible contributing factor to gastrointestinal tract barrier dysfunction that may be associated with the development of systemic inflammatory response and multiple organ dysfunction syndrome, the principal cause of death after sepsis. Monitoring gut perfusion during experimental and clinical sepsis may provide valuable insights over new interventions and therapies highly needed to reduce multiple organ dysfunction and sepsis-related morbidity and mortality. We present our experience with gas tonometry as a monitor of the adequacy of gastrointestinal mucosal perfusion in experimental models sepsis and with the use of vasoactive agents for hemodynamic management in patients with septic shock.

Continuous monitoring of gastric intraluminal carbon dioxide pressure, cardiac output, and end-tidal carbon dioxide pressure in the perioperative period in patients receiving cardiovascular surgery using cardiopulmonary bypass

OBJECTIVE

To verify the hypothesis that the gastric intraluminal PCO2 (PgCO2) changes independently of the change in cardiac output (CO) during and after cardiovascular surgery using cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB), and that the elevation of PgCO2 affects the patients' morbidity.

DESIGN

Prospective, noninterventional study.

SETTING

Medical/surgical intensive care unit and operating theater of a university hospital.

PATIENTS

Sixteen adults patients receiving elective cardiovascular surgery using CPB.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

After induction of anesthesia, the patients were fitted with a gastric tube equipped at the tip with a CO2 sensor (ion-selective field effect transistor) that can continuously measure real-time PgCO2, and a pulmonary artery catheter capable of monitoring continuous CO (CCO) and end-tidal CO2. Data from the devices was uploaded to a personal computer every 2 mins until the catheter was pulled off based on clinical judgment (PgCO2 values were blinded to everyone except the investigator). One patient expired as a result of multiple organ failure subsequent to sepsis, and postoperative morbidity assessed by the peak SOFA (sequential organ failure assessment) score (mean +/- SD 6.9 +/- 3.5; range, 2-13) was correlated with the peak PgCO2 during intensive care unit stay (mean +/- SD 74.1 +/- 30.7 mm Hg; range, 45-169 mm Hg) (p < .01, by regression analysis). The peak PgCO2 during surgery (mean +/- SD 71.1 +/- 18.1 mm Hg; range, 44-115 mm Hg) had no correlation with the postoperative morbidity. From analysis of CCO before, during, and after returning from the above 60 mm Hg of PgCO2, PgCO2 changed independently of CCO.

CONCLUSIONS

PgCO2 changed independently of CCO, and its postoperative elevation was related to morbidity, even in the group of patients with a good outcome. Continuous monitoring of PgCO2 is useful for the detection of morbidity and can be expected to help elucidate the pathophysiology of change of PgCO2.

Indocyanine green elimination rate detects hepatocellular dysfunction early in septic shock and correlates with survival

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether indocyanine green clearance is an early indicator of hepatocellular injury in septic shock and to assess its predictive value.

DESIGN

Observational study with prospective data collection.

SETTING

Traumatology and critical care unit in a city hospital, staffed by traumatology and intensive care clinicians.

PATIENTS

Twelve patients in septic shock who survived at least 2 months (group S) and nine patients who died within 2 wks (group N).

INTERVENTIONS

Routine resuscitation from septic shock (surgery, fluid loading, and administration of catecholamines and antibiotic drugs).

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Pulmonary artery occlusion pressure, cardiac index, oxygen delivery index, oxygen consumption index, and the indocyanine green elimination rate constant (KICG; or the slope of the loge [indocyanine green concentration] vs. time curve) 3-9 mins after injection were measured within 12 hrs of the onset of hypotension, then at 24 hrs, and every 24 hrs thereafter. Alanine aminotransferase and total bilirubin were measured on day 0 and day 1. Volume of fluid administered and duration of shock were the same in survivors and nonsurvivors. The oxygen consumption index was higher in survivors at 12 hrs, but no intergroup difference in pulmonary artery occlusion pressure, cardiac index, or oxygen delivery index was significant at any time point. KICG in nonsurvivors was lower than in survivors both initially and after 24 hrs, and it was subnormal in all patients except one survivor (p <.05). The KICG increased between 24 and 120 hrs in 11 survivors but progressively decreased and remained below 0.05 in seven nonsurvivors. The remaining two nonsurvivors died within 24 hrs of the initial measurement of KICG, which was >0.05. Alanine aminotransferase and total bilirubin were less sensitive measures of hepatic dysfunction in the first 24 hrs than the KICG.

CONCLUSIONS

The KICG can identify reversible liver injury in septic shock, suggesting good prognosis. Either failure to increase the KICG within 120 hrs or an extremely low KICG is a poor prognostic sign.

Lactate is correlated with the indocyanine green elimination rate in liver resection for cirrhotic patients

The role of lactate in liver ischemia-reperfusion injury in cirrhosis has not been clarified. Fifty patients with hepatocellular carcinoma who underwent partial liver resection under Pringle's maneuver were included in this study. We performed the indocyanine green clearance test before the operation and three times during the surgery to calculate its elimination rate. Blood lactate and base excess were measured at the corresponding times. Systolic and diastolic systemic arterial pressure, heart rate, cardiac index, and esophageal temperature were monitored. Aminotransferase levels were recorded the day before the operation, 1 h after the operation, and on the first and third postoperative days. We calculated the increase or decrease in lactate levels during the preischemic, ischemic, and postischemic phases, and examined the correlation between these results and the changes in indocyanine green elimination rate and some clinical factors. The lactate levels increased before reperfusion and began to decrease after reperfusion. The lactate increase and decrease during the ischemic and postischemic phases correlated with the change in indocyanine green elimination rate (P < 0.0001 and P = 0.02 for the respective phases). The lactate increase during the preischemic phase correlated with the duration of the preischemic phase (P < 0.0001). In cirrhotic patients who undergo liver resection with Pringle's maneuver and who do not show postoperative liver failure, the blood lactate profile might be a reliable indicator of liver metabolic capacity during surgery.

IMPLICATIONS

In cirrhotic patients who underwent liver resection with Pringle's maneuver, the lactate increase and decrease during the ischemic and postischemic phases correlated with the change in the indocyanine green elimination rate. The blood lactate profile might be a reliable indicator of liver metabolic capacity during surgery.

Peri-operative blood lactate levels in recipients of living-related liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

The role of changes in peri-operative blood lactate levels in recipients of living-related liver transplants has not yet been clarified.

METHODS

Forty-three recipients were included in this study. Blood lactate, plasma total bilirubin, aminotransferase, body temperature, and gastric mucosal PCO2 levels were measured at six time points during surgery: just before the initiation of surgery, just after dissection of the hepatic vasculature, at the end of the anhepatic phase, and 30, 60, and 120 min after reperfusion. We calculated the rate of lactate accumulation during the pre-anhepatic and anhepatic phases and the elimination rate during reperfusion (neohepatic phase), and examined the correlation between these results and the clinical findings.

RESULTS

The rate of lactate elimination during the neohepatic phase was correlated with the ratio of graft weight to standard liver volume (P<0.0001). There was also a significant correlation between the rate of lactate accumulation during the pre-anhepatic phase and the preoperative total bilirubin levels (P=0.0008).

CONCLUSIONS

Each pre-anhepatic, anhepatic, and neohepatic phase had a characteristic blood lactate profile. The graft size strongly affected lactate levels during the early neohepatic phase.

Pharmacologic issues in the management of septic shock

Despite our increased understanding of the biochemistry and physiology of sepsis, the treatment of septic shock remains a challenge. Initial management of septic shock entails urgent and emergent stabilization of the patient followed by broad-spectrum, empiric antibiotic therapy. After volume resuscitation, vasopressors or inotropic therapy or both may be necessary to restore perfusion. Adjunctive therapies and monitoring strategies may be helpful in preventing complications in the intensive care setting. Additional research and clinical trials are needed to identify supportive interventions that may affect the outcome of the septic patient.

Resuscitation of critically ill patients based on the results of gastric tonometry: a prospective, randomized, controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether additional therapy aimed at correcting low gastric intramucosal pH (pHi) improves outcome in conventionally resuscitated, critically ill patients.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, controlled study.

SETTING

General intensive care unit (ICU) of a university teaching hospital.

PATIENTS

A total of 210 adult patients, with a median Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score of 24 (range, 8-51).

INTERVENTIONS

All patients were resuscitated according to standard guidelines. After resuscitation, those patients in the intervention group with a pHi of <7.35 were treated with additional colloid and then dobutamine (5 microg/kg/min then 10 microg/kg min) until 24 hrs after enrollment.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

There were no significant differences (p > .05) in ICU mortality (39.6% in the control group vs. 38.5% in the intervention group), hospital mortality (45.3% in the control group vs. 42.3% in the intervention group), and 30-day mortality (43.7% in the control group vs. 40.2 in the intervention group); survival curves; median modified maximal multiorgan dysfunction score (10 points in the control group vs. 13 points in the intervention group); median modified duration of ICU stay (12 days in the control group vs. 11.5 days in the intervention group); or median modified duration of hospital stay (60 days in the control group vs. 42 days in the intervention group). A subgroup analysis of those patients with gastric mucosal pH of > or =7.35 at admission revealed no difference in ICU mortality (10.3% in the control group vs. 14.8% in the intervention group), hospital mortality (13.8% in the control group vs. 29.6% in the intervention group), or 30-day mortality (10.3% in the control group vs. 26.9% in the intervention group).

CONCLUSIONS

The routine use of treatment titrated against pHi in the management of critically ill patients cannot be supported. Failure to improve outcome may be caused by an inability to produce a clinically significant change in pHi or because pHi is simply a marker of disease rather than a factor in the pathogenesis of multiorgan failure.

Accuracy of mucosal pH and mucosal-arterial carbon dioxide tension for detecting mesenteric hypoperfusion in acute canine endotoxemia

OBJECTIVE

To determine the level of mucosal-arterial Pco2 (Pco2 gap) that is both sensitive and specific for the detection of mesenteric hypoperfusion as defined by either a >50% reduction in portal blood flow or release of lactate by the gut.

DESIGN

Animal experiment.

SUBJECTS

Seven anesthetized, intubated, mechanically ventilated, and surgically instrumented mongrel dogs.

INTERVENTION

Escherichia coli endotoxin (1 mg/kg) given intravenously for 5 mins.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Tonometric Pco2, arterial blood gases, arterial and portal venous lactates, and portal and systemic hemodynamic variables were measured. Mucosal pH (pHi) was calculated according to the manufacturers' instructions. From these data, receiver operating characteristics were calculated. Although animals were resuscitated to maintain a constant cardiac output, portal flow decreased from 350+/-101 to 152+/-75 mL/min (p<.01) and the gut released lactate into the portal circulation in all animals. Pco2 gap increased from 13.1+/-3.9 to 40.2+/-39.2 torr (p<.01) and was inversely correlated with portal blood flow (r2 = .20; p<.05). For detection of a >50% reduction in portal blood flow, a Pco2 gap of 20 torr yielded a maximum accuracy of 67% (sensitivity, 55%; specificity, 73%) and was less accurate than a pHi of 7.20, which yielded a maximum accuracy of 76% (sensitivity, 90%; specificity, 70%), although this difference was not significant (p = .24). There was also a correlation between pHi and portal blood flow (r2 = .31; p<.01). For detection of lactate release by the gut, a Pco2 gap of 20 torr was also 67% accurate (sensitivity, 53%; specificity, 78%), whereas a pHi of 7.10 achieved an accuracy of 64% (sensitivity, 40%; specificity, 83%), which was not significantly different.

CONCLUSION

Pco2 gap measurements are neither sensitive nor specific for mesenteric hypoperfusion with regard to total gut blood flow reductions of >50% or the release of lactate into the portal circulation.

Effects of dobutamine on gastric mucosal perfusion and hepatic metabolism in patients with septic shock

We prospectively evaluated the effects of dobutamine on gastric mucosal perfusion and hepatocytic clearance in patients with septic shock. After resuscitation with volume expansion and norepinephrine (12 patients) as needed, 14 hemodynamically stable patients (median age: 60 yr, median SAPS II score: 47) were given an infusion of 7.5 microg/kg/min dobutamine for 1 h. Gastric mucosal perfusion and hepatocytic clearance were assessed with tonometry and indocyanine green (ICG) elimination, respectively. All measurements were made before dobutamine infusion, after 1 h of dobutamine infusion, and 1 h after the infusion ended. Cardiac output (thermodilution technique) increased with dobutamine from a baseline median level of 4.0 L/min/m(2) (range: 1.7 to 7.4 L/min/m(2)) to 5.0 L/min/m(2) (range: 3.5 to 8.9 L/min/m(2)) (p = 0.004) and returned to baseline levels after dobutamine infusion ended. The gastric-arterial PCO(2) difference decreased from a baseline median level of 13 mm Hg (range: 5 to 54 mm Hg) to 7 mm Hg (range: 5 to 48 mm Hg) (p = 0.005). ICG elimination was low in all patients at baseline (median plasma disappearance rate: 12.2%; range: 7.6 to 16.2%) and did not change significantly during or after dobutamine infusion. In summary, dobutamine increases gastric mucosal perfusion but does not alter hepatocytic clearance in patients with septic shock. The absence of a beneficial effect of dobutamine on hepatocytic clearance may be related to profound alterations in hepatocellular metabolism during septic shock.

Alpha1-adrenoceptor antagonist effect of (+/-)-dobutamine in rat isolated gastric artery preparation

(+/-)-Dobutamine at concentrations < or =10(-5) M did not evoke contractions of rat gastric artery segments. However, when the tissues were contracted with methoxamine, (+/-)-dobutamine evoked concentration-dependent relaxation. The relaxant responses were not significantly affected by propranolol. In the same preparation, propranolol competitively antagonized isoprenaline-induced relaxation with a -log K(B) value of 7.90+/-0.26. (+/-)-Dobutamine did not relax arterial ring segments precontracted with vasopressin (10(-7) M). (+/-)-Dobutamine antagonized noradrenaline-induced contractions of the gastric artery segments. The pA2 value was 6.93+/-0.20, and the slope of the Schild regression line was 1.22+/-0.14. This value (slope) was not significantly different from 1, indicating competitive antagonism. Pretreatment of gastric artery segments with dobutamine before phenoxybenzamine (PBZ) protected against inactivation of alpha1-adrenoceptors by PBZ. The dose ratio of prazosin (3x10(-9) M) and (+/-)-dobutamine (10(-5) M) in combination was close to the expected sum of their individual dose ratios minus 1, indicating interaction with a common site. It was therefore concluded that (+/-)-dobutamine evoked relaxation of rat gastric artery segments by an action not involving beta-adrenoceptor activation but by blocking alpha1-adrenoceptors.

A dobutamine test can disclose hepatosplanchnic hypoperfusion in septic patients

In 36 hemodynamically stable septic patients, we explored whether changes in gastric mucosal-arterial PCO(2) gradient (PCO(2)gap) induced by a short-term dobutamine infusion may reveal hepatosplanchnic hypoperfusion. Hepatosplanchnic blood flow (HSBF) was determined by the continuous indocyanine green infusion technique and gastric mucosal PCO(2) (Pg(CO(2))) by saline tonometry. In each patient, hemodynamic measurements, blood samples, and Pg(CO(2)) determinations were performed three times: first at baseline (DOB 0), second during a dobutamine infusion at a dose of 5 microgram/kg/min (DOB 5), and third at a dose of 10 microgram/kg/min (DOB 10). The results were analyzed by Wilcoxon's matched-pairs signed rank test and are presented as medians with ranges. The PCO(2)gap decreased preferentially in groups of patients with inadequate hepatosplanchnic perfusion, i.e., with a low fractional HSBF (HSBF/CI), defined as the ratio of the HSBF to the simultaneous cardiac index, or a high gradient between the mixed venous blood and the suprahepatic blood O(2) saturations (DSvh(O(2))). In the 11 patients with a DSvh(O(2)) above 20% at baseline, PCO(2)gap decreased from 12.1 (6.3 to 19.5) mm Hg at DOB 0 to 6.2 (2.5 to 19. 3) mm Hg at DOB 5 (p < 0.001 versus DOB 0), and to 4.2 (0.1 to 35.9) mm Hg at DOB 10 (p < 0.05 versus DOB 5), whereas in the 25 patients with a DSvh(O(2)) below 20% at baseline, PCO(2)gap did not change significantly. At no time was the PCO(2)gap correlated with HSBF/CI or DSvh(O(2)). We conclude that although the PCO(2)gap does not correlate well with global indexes of gut oxygenation, such a simple dobutamine infusion test could identify patients with inadequate hepatosplanchnic perfusion.