Treatment of femoral shaft aseptic nonunion associated with plating failure: emphasis on the situation of screw breakage

Plate augmentation and hybrid bone grafting are effective treatments for atrophic nonunion of the femur with the original intramedullary nail retained in situ

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the efficacy of plate augmentation and hybrid bone grafting for treating atrophic nonunion of the femur with original intramedullary nail retained in situ.In this study, 36 patients with atrophic nonunion of the femur who underwent surgery using the technique of plate augmentation and a hybrid bone grafting while retaining the original intramedullary nail in situ in Xi'an Honghui Hospital from January 2019 to December 2021 were enrolled. 28 patients who met the inclusion and exclusion criteria were ultimately included in the study. These 28 patients, consisting of 20 males and 8 females with a mean age of 38 years, were evaluated based on factors such as operation time, intraoperative blood loss, the average hospitalization days. Additionally, the results and function of these patients were evaluated by union time, Wu's scores of limb function and incidence of serious complications.All 28 patients achieved bone union at the 12 month follow-up, with an average follow-up time of 14.6 ± 4.2 months.The average operation time was 68.3 ± 11.2 min, and the average intraoperative blood loss was 140 ± 22.6 ml. Patients were hospitalized for an average of 5.8 ± 1.1 days. Full clinical and radiological bone union was achieved on average at 5.1 ± 1.9 months. The mean value of Wu's scores at the 12 month follow-up was significantly higher than before the operation. Limb function was excellent in 27 patients and good in one patient at the 12 month follow-up. However, five patients experienced the lower limb vein thrombosis, including one deep vein thrombosis and four lower limb intermuscular vein thromboses. One patient had a superficial infections of the surgical incision site, while three patients reported pain and numbness where their iliac bone graft was extracted at the 12 month follow-up. The technique of plate augmentation and hybrid bone grafting, combined with retaining the original intramedullary nail in situ has been shown to be a safe, effective, simply and standardizable practice for treating atrophic femoral nonunion with an intact original IMN fixation.

Intramedullary nailing as a treatment for non-unions of femoral shaft fractures after plating failure: A case series

INTRODUCTION

The management of implant failure in femoral shaft fractures remains a challenging problem for orthopaedic surgeons. This series aim to evaluate the effectiveness of intramedullary (IM) nailing for treating femoral shaft nonunions after implant failure.

CASE PRESENTATION

Three patients presented with pain after walking on crutch and limping with history of fixation using plate for femoral shaft fracture. Implant removal was then performed with subsequent refixation using intramedullary nailing with A2FN. The Lower Extremity Functional Score and Visual Analogue Score evaluation showed excellent result in these patients.

CLINICAL DISCUSSION

IM nailing is the mainstay of treatment for patients with femoral shaft fractures. This intervention provides support to fractures and aid in union of fractures. Several advantages have been reported in IM nailing, including shorter length of stay, rapid union, and early functional capacity of the limb. Insertion of IM nailing may preserve anatomical structure in the patients, which leads to better improvement of functional capacity. Nailing also limits soft tissue damage. Thus, in patients presented with previous plate failure similar to our patients, IM nailing with reaming is recommended.

CONCLUSION

Nonunion after femoral shaft plating are common. Nailing conversion is one of available treatment options to achieve maximum recover in this type of case.

Plate augmentation and bone grafting in treatment of femoral shaft nonunion initially fixed by intramedullary nail

INTRODUCTION

This study aims to evaluate the results of plate augmentation and bone grafting without removing the nail in the treatment of nonunited, nailed femoral shaft fractures.

METHODS

Twenty patients with atrophic nonunion femoral shaft fractures initially fixed by intramedullary nail were treated by augmentation plating and iliac bone graft with retention of the nail. Patients were evaluated at regular intervals using an X-ray and Wu scoring system, which assesses clinical and radiological signs of healing.

RESULTS

All 20 patients achieved bony union at a mean time of 4.9 months (3-8 months). According to Wu's score, 12 cases showed excellent results, and 8 cases obtained good results with no complications recorded.

CONCLUSION

augmentation plating and iliac bone graft provide a good and safe method of treatment of previously nailed and non-united femoral shaft fractures.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 4; Case Series.

Use of a Titanium Cage and Intramedullary Nails to Treat Distal Femoral Fracture Nonunion in a Patient with Renal Osteopathy: A Case Report

BACKGROUND Nonunion occurs to approximately 10% of people who suffer from distal femoral fracture, which can be induced by other diseases and medical interventions. CKD and subsequent renal osteopathy are regarded as risk factors for nonunion. Internal fixation is the most widely applied medical procedure to treat distal femoral fracture, the efficiency and stability of which are improved by emerging biological materials. Besides traditional screws and plate, titanium cages and intramedullary nails have been introduced lately to repair nonunion and large bone defects resulting from it, which is a huge challenge for orthopedic surgeons. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on a distal femoral fracture patient with renal osteopathy treated by internal fixation enhancement using a titanium cage and intramedullary nails. CASE REPORT We report the case of an 84-year-old Chinese woman with renal osteopathy who underwent 4 internal fixation operations to treat a distal femoral fracture. The first 3 surgeries used screws and a plate as internal fixation materials to treat the fracture and nonunion, but did not achieve satisfactory outcomes. In the final surgery, a titanium cage and intramedullary nail were used and the patient recovered soon. CONCLUSIONS Doctors should pay attention to patient's primary health conditions, especially renal disorders, before performing surgeries for distal femoral fracture. It is important to select the most appropriate materials and choose the most suitable surgical method in patients with poor health conditions.

Augmentation plating leaving the nail in situ is an excellent option for treating femoral shaft nonunion after IM nailing: a multicentre study

PURPOSE

In recent years, plate augmentation over a retained intramedullary (IM) nail has been shown to be an effective option for managing femur fracture nonunions because it improves the biomechanical environment of the fracture site without causing additional biological damage. In the current study, we present outcome data from 22 consecutive patients treated with plate augmentation for femoral shaft nonunion leaving the nail in situ.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between 2015 and 2018, 22 consecutive patients with femoral shaft aseptic nonunion after IM nailing were treated with plate augmentation over a retained nail at four different institutions. Nonunion was categorized based on its anatomical location and was classified according to the Weber and Cech classification. Cortical defects greater than 1.0 cm, the type of nailing procedure, and the number of previous interventions were recorded. Patients were assessed clinically and radiographically to measure the healing of nonunion sites. The time to fracture union and complications were recorded. Descriptive statistics were used when applicable.

RESULTS

One site location was supra-isthmic, 12 were isthmic, and 9 were infra-isthmic. There were 10 cases of vascular nonunion and 12 cases of avascular nonunion. A cortical defect greater than 1.0 cm was observed in three patients. Antegrade nailing was performed in 11 patients, and retrograde nailing was performed in 11 patients. Reaming was performed in 12 patients. In eight patients, the fracture was openly reduced during the IM nailing index procedure. The average number of previous interventions before augmentation plating was 1.6 (1-4). Bone union was achieved in 19 patients after augmentation plating with an average follow-up of 23.5 months (12-51 months). Excellent and good clinical results were observed in all patients. There was no plate or screw breakage, and no patient developed infection.

CONCLUSION

Augmentation plating leaving the nail in situ is an excellent option for treating femoral shaft nonunion after IM nailing, with a high union rate and few complications. We believe the technique should gradually replace exchange nailing as the standard of care for the majority of femoral shaft nonunions that occur after IM nailing.

Femoral non-union with malalignment: reconstruction and biological stimulation with the chipping technique

INTRODUCTION

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of the chipping technique for the treatment of femoral non-unions associated with malalignment.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 21 femoral non-unions were managed with the chipping procedure and re-fixation. 15 of them had malalignment (angular or rotational deformity or limb length discrepancy). The deformities were simultaneously corrected by a combination of chipping and temporal external fixator. The median age of patients were 41 years (range, 19-73 years). The median time from injury or the final surgery to the initial chipping procedure was 24 months (range: 9-240 months). Femoral non-unions were classified as hypertrophic in 9, oligotrophic in 5 and atrophic in 7. Clinical and radiological assessment was performed.

RESULTS

All femoral non-unions radiographically healed with one (19 cases) or two (2 cases) chipping procedures without bone grafting. Pre-existing angular deformity was corrected from 14° to 2°, external rotation 27° to 0°, and limb length discrepancy 16-7 mm. There were no major complications, although swelling of thigh and anemia was common after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Chipping the non-union site was associated with a favorable outcome. It biologically enhances fracture healing and should be considered as a treatment option for femoral non-unions with malalignment.

Radiological assessment of the PRF/BMSC efficacy in the treatment of aseptic nonunions: A retrospective study on 90 subjects

BACKGROUND

Nonunion is a major orthopaedic concern because of treatment difficulty, high costs and devastating effects on the patients' life quality. Therefore, there is interest in the use of bone substitutes and cell-based strategies to augment fracture repair. We aimed to verify if Platelet Rich Fibrin (PRF) added with bone marrow stromal cells (BMSC) was able to improve the reparative process in the aseptic nonunion, and to establish whether it was worthwhile with atrophic nonunion. The primary outcome was radiological union. As secondary endpoint, the healing time was assessed, and the radiological consolidation grade at each follow-up.

METHODS

We identified 113 subjects with tibia or femur nonunion and retrospectively created two groups. Group A was constituted by 56 subjects who underwent the standard procedure, i.e. Judet decortication with/out internal fixation devices, and opposite cortical homoplastic stick. In 57 patients, the standard procedure was modified by adding PRF and BMSC carried by homologous lyophilised bone chips (group B). The same surgeon performed all the operations. To our knowledge, no data are reported in the literature about such application. Since a "gold standard" for healing quantification does not exist, a new scoring radiological system was applied, at 1.5, 3, 6, 12 and 24 months after treatment.

RESULTS

At the final 24-month follow-up, the radiological union percentage was 94,12 in group B and 95,12% in group A. A decreased healing time was demonstrated in the presence of PRF/BMSC in comparison with the standard procedure. When we compared the radiological scores at each follow-up, we found that the PRF/BMSC combination significantly improved the consolidation grade at 1.5-, 3- and 6-month follow-up in femurs and at 1.5-month follow-up in tibiae. Furthermore, an improved consolidation grade was demonstrated in the atrophic subjects treated with adjuvants compared to atrophic patients treated with the standard procedure at 1.5-month follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

This study supports the concept that the use of PRF/BMSC, during the standard procedure, is effective in shortening nonunion healing time. It could allow an early mobilization of patients, minimizing suffering, and could be an effective tool to reduce the health-care costs resulting from this issue.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic level III.

Operative treatment for femoral shaft nonunions, a systematic review of the literature

The objective of this article is to systematically review the currently available literature to formulate evidence-based guidelines for the treatment of femoral shaft nonunions for clinical practice and to establish recommendations for future research. Articles from PubMed/MEDLINE, Cochrane Clinical Trial Register, and EMBASE, that presented data concerning treatment of nonunions of femoral shaft fractures in adult humans, were included for data extraction and analysis. The search was restricted to articles from January 1970 to March 2011 written in the English, German, or Dutch languages. Articles containing data that were thought to have been presented previously were used once. Reports on nonunion after periprosthetic fractures, review articles, expert opinions, abstracts from scientific meetings, and case reports on 5 or fewer patients were excluded. The data that were extracted from the relevant articles included: type of nonunion, type of initial and secondary treatments, follow-up, union rate, and general complications. Most studies had different inclusion criteria and outcome measures, thus prohibiting a proper meta-analysis. Therefore, only the union rate and number of complications were compared between the different treatments. Methodological quality was assessed by assigning levels of evidence as previously defined by the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine. This systematic review provides evidence in favour of plating if a nail is the first treatment; after failed plate fixation, nailing has a 96 % union rate. After failed nailing, augmentative plating results in a 96 % union rate compared to 73 % in the exchange nailing group.

Relevance of deep decortication and vascularization in a case of post-traumatic femoral non-union treated with grafts, platelet gel and bone marrow stromal cells

PURPOSE

A male patient suffering from non-union of the femoral diaphysis after a traumatic fracture was treated with deep decortication and grafted with lyophilized bone, platelet gel (PG) and autologous bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs). After 40 days from surgery, he was re-operated, due to fracture secondary displacement, caused by inappropriate load during sports activity. In addition to radiographs, two bone biopsies were retrieved: this allowed for a histological evaluation of the early response of host bone to the graft. To our knowledge, there is no report describing such early tissue response.

METHODS

A clinical-radiographic evaluation of the patient and a histomorphometric analysis of the bone biopsies were performed.

RESULTS

An early reparative bone formation was observed adjacent to the osteointegrated graft. Non-resorbed bone chips and large islands of non-vital bone particles, surrounded by fibrous tissue, were observed in a zone of sclerotic diaphyseal bone, that is the process was delayed despite decortication.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings support the concept, until now evidenced only by imaging, that bone chips added with PG and BMSCs are effective in shortening the healing time in fracture non-union. The clinical relevance of deep decortication and vascularization is emphasized.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic studies-investigating the results of treatment, Level V.

Ilizarov external fixation without removal of plate or screws: effect on hypertrophic and oligotrophic nonunion of the femoral shaft with plate failure

Patients with hypertrophic and oligotrophic nonunion of the femoral diaphysis associated with plate failure can be treated by Ilizarov external fixation without plate removal. Advantages of this technique include a lack of damage to the blood supply and simultaneous deformity correction.

Diagnostic and treatment modalities in nonunions of the femoral shaft: a review

Nonunions of the femoral shaft represent a treatment challenge for the orthopaedic surgeon and a serious socioeconomic problem for the patient. Inadequate fracture stability, insufficient blood supply, bone loss or presence of infection are the main reasons for the development of a nonunion. Careful classification and exclusion of infection are crucial for the choice of the proper treatment alternative. Nail dynamization, primary intramedullary nailing or nail exchange, plate osteosynthesis and external fixation along with bone grafting, usage of bone substitutes and electrical stimulation can stimulate osseous union. A review of the aetiology, classification and treatment should prove helpful managing this serious complication.

Intramedullary nailing for the treatment of aseptic femoral shaft non-unions after plating failure: effectiveness and timing

This retrospective, multicentre study aimed to evaluate reamed intramedullary nailing (IMN) for the treatment of 30 cases of aseptic femoral shaft non-union after plating failure. Following nailing, 29 non-unions had healed by a mean 7.93 months. In one case a hypertrophic non-union required renailing after 8 months, using a nail of greater diameter, and united within five further months. Healing times were not related to whether the fracture was open or closed, the type non-union or the type of fracture. The delay from the initial plating to intramedullary nailing had a statistically significant effect on healing time and final outcome. This treatment is cost effective and should be implemented as soon as the non-union is diagnosed.

Intramedullary fixation of failed plated femoral diaphyseal fractures: are bone grafts necessary?

BACKGROUND

Nonunited fracture shaft femur after plate fixation is a common problem in third world countries because of economic reasons. Management of such a problem is still controversial and is associated with many surgical details, due not only to the nonunited fracture itself, but also to the broken implant which is not easy to remove.

METHODS

This study is a randomized prospective study presenting 40 patients with aseptic nonunited fracture shaft femur associated with failed plating managed by the removal of hardware, and intramedullary fixation using an interlocking nail with or without autogenous iliac bone graft.

RESULTS

There was no statistically significant difference between patients with and without iliac autogenous bone graft regarding the demographic data, the preoperative condition, and the postoperative course including time needed for bone union and return to work. The statistically significant difference was in the intraoperative blood loss and the duration of surgery with less blood loss and shorter duration of surgery occurring in the group treated by reamed intramedullary nail without iliac bone graft.

CONCLUSION

In cases with aseptic nonunited fracture shaft femur after failed plating, intramedullary reamed nailing without autogenous bone graft produced similar results as with bone graft, but with less operating time and blood loss.

Plating of Femoral Shaft Fractures: the Experience in an African Teaching Hospital

BACKGROUND

Femoral shaft fractures are common presentation in our trauma units. It is obvious that all these fractures cannot be treated conservatively due to the pressure on trauma beds and thus a suitable method of internal fixation that is feasible in the environment has had to be adopted.

OBJECTIVE

This study is a report of our experience with plate fixation of femoral shaft fracture in our environment.

DESIGN

A retrospective hospital based study.

PATIENT AND METHOD

All patients with femoral shaft fractures stabilized with plates and screws between 1997 and 2004 at the University College Hospital were reviewed. The case notes were retrieved and data extracted from them; all case notes entry gave sufficient information.

RESULTS

The fracture pattern showed 56 cases (35.4%) of Type 32-A, 45 cases (28.5%) of Type 32-B and 57 cases (36.1%) of Type 32-C using AO classification. The outcome of treatment was excellent to good in 125 fractures (77.2%). The average time of healing was 20 weeks (range 16-48). Fracture related complications occurred in nine fractures (5.7%) which included deep infection in four fractures (2.5%) and implant failure in five fractures (3.2%).

CONCLUSION

Femoral shaft plating gives good result if the principles of fixation is carefully followed and in developing countries where initial cost of procurement of equipments for closed nailing may not be forth coming, it thus provide a safe efficient and low cost method of fixation of femoral shaft fracture.

Chipping and lengthening technique for delayed unions and nonunions with shortening or bone loss

Autologous bone graft is usually necessary for reconstruction of nonunions with shortening or bone loss. We developed a new technique to reconstruct such nonunions or delayed unions without bone grafting by chipping and lengthening of bone at the original fracture site. Five in six nonunions with shortening or bone loss could be successfully united without bone graft by using our method. The chipping and lengthening technique, which requires neither bone grafting nor change in the anatomy of muscles, is a useful technique for delayed unions and nonunions accompanied by shortening or bone loss.