Thyroid cartilage fracture repair in rabbits: comparing healing with wire and miniplate fixation

Repair of displaced thyroid cartilage fracture using miniplate osteosynthesis

Acute laryngeal trauma is estimated to occur in approximately one patient per 14 500 to 42 500 emergency room admissions. If the larynx is injured, its vital functions are affected and can be threatened in case of severe injury. Soft cartilage offers no protective advantage, which is the reason why young as well as older individuals are at risk of thyroid cartilage fracture. Experimentation on cadaver larynx has demonstrated that virtually all laryngeal fractures are longitudinally oriented. Furthermore, muscular pull can contribute to a misalignment of the fractures. As stated by Bent and Porubsky, a fracture is considered severely rather than moderately displaced, if it is freely mobile on physical examination, has more than two fracture lines or demonstrates a displacement greater than the width of the thyroid cartilage on CT imaging. We present two cases of severely displaced thyroid cartilage fracture treated in our department by open reduction and internal fixation using miniplates. Functional and radiological outcomes were excellent.

Laryngeal fractures treated with titanium mesh fixation

The larynx plays a vital role in respiration, swallowing, and vocal function. Thus, laryngeal fractures that are not appropriately managed may lead to permanent dyspnea, dysphagia, and voice disorders. In cases of laryngeal fractures, surgical repair by internal fixation has been performed with materials such as thread, steel wire, and titanium miniplates. However, thyroid and cricoid cartilage have a complicated morphology, and ossification at each site in the cartilage is not uniform; thus, in some cases it is difficult to perform internal fixation with conventional methods. In this case report, we describe two patients who underwent successful fixation of fractures in their laryngeal cartilage after trauma by using titanium mesh with thread and screws. Since optimal reduction and fixation of fractured laryngeal cartilage cannot be performed with conventional methods in patients with unossified cartilage, titanium mesh may be considered a safe and reliable alternative.

[Therapeutic management of dislocated laryngeal fractures]

BACKGROUND

Acute trauma with laryngeal fracture is a rare injury affecting all functions of the larynx. Resuscitation follows the ABC principles for acute trauma life support. The priority has always been the establishment of an adequate and secure airway. To achieve optimal therapeutic long-term results, permanent stabilisation of the airway and good functional restoration of phonation and swallowing are necessary. We describe the therapy and long-term follow-up of two patients who suffered laryngeal fracture.

CASE REPORTS

The first case concerns a 31-year-old woman who suffered polytrauma with laryngotracheal separation in a car accident. The fracture was reduced and fixed utilizing miniplates. After decannulation the patient had a patent airway. She regained normal voice and was able to swallow without difficulty. The other case concerns a 16-year-old boy who suffered a laryngeal fracture in a bicycle accident. He also underwent subsequent operative therapy using adaptation plates. This patient also regained an adequate airway and a good postoperative voice. There were no problems with swallowing.

CONCLUSION

Chondrosynthesis with adaptation plates provides an enduring and exact fixation of laryngeal fractures. In the long term, this leads to a stable recovery of function concerning airway, voice, and swallowing.

Comparison of pullout strength of resorbable screws and titanium screws in human cadaveric laryngeal cartilage

OBJECTIVES

To compare the pullout strength of titanium screws and resorbable screws from human fresh-frozen cadaveric laryngeal cartilage. The importance of drill hole diameter, screw diameter, and whether the drill hole was tapped (resorbable screws only) was also determined.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective.

METHODS

Sixteen cartilage specimens were tested after debridement of connective tissue and perichondrium. Linear pullout strength of screws was measured using a load cell. Titanium and resorbable screw sizes of 1.5 and 2.0 mm were tested using drill hole diameters of 1.1 and 1.5 mm. For the resorbable-tapped group, screw diameters of 1.5 and 2.0 mm were tapped with 1.5 and 2.0 mm taps, respectively. All tested screws were 6 mm in length.

RESULTS

We found a uniformly constant difference between the three screw types (P < .001). Post hoc analysis indicated a significant difference between the resorbable-untapped screw and both the resorbable-tapped screw and the titanium screw. We failed to find a significant difference, however, between the resorbable-tapped screw and the titanium screw. We also found a significant effect in regard to screw size (P = .0133), with post hoc analysis demonstrating the 1.1/1.5 mm combination to be inferior to the 1.1/2.0 and 1.5/2.0 mm combinations. There was no significant difference between the 1.1/2.0- and 1.5/2.0-mm combinations.

CONCLUSIONS

Resorbable screws with untapped drill holes result in higher resistance to linear loads than both titanium screws and resorbable screws with tapped drill holes. The 1.1/2.0- and 1.5/2.0-mm drill/screw combinations are superior to the 1.1/1.5-mm combination when considering untapped resorbable screws.

Repair of a laryngeal fracture using miniplates

Injuries to the larynx (voice box) can lead to loss of vital functions; the airway may be obstructed, the voice distorted or lost, and the protection of the airway during swallowing may fail. In order to preserve these functions, a stable repair that restores the anatomy as closely as possible is needed. The repair should interfere minimally with the neuromuscular functions of the larynx. The case is described of a 59-year-old male who suffered a severe laryngeal fracture in a work-place accident. Utilizing miniplates, the fracture was reduced and fixed in the correct position. After healing, the patient could be decannulated and has regained his voice, swallows without difficulty and has a patent airway. The results have been sustained over a 2-year follow-up.

The management of laryngeal fractures using internal fixation

BACKGROUND

Laryngeal fracture is a rare injury with the potential to affect all functions of the larynx. Restoration of the laryngeal framework is critical for the rehabilitation of laryngeal function.

OBJECTIVE

To ascertain the efficacy of adaptation plate fixation (APF) to repair the laryngeal skeleton.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review of the clinical data of all patients who underwent APF of laryngeal fractures from January 1989 to September 1999.

RESULTS

Our series consisted of 16 men and 4 women presenting with laryngeal fractures caused by blunt (n = 16) or penetrating (n = 4) trauma. Most of these patients presented with severe fractures classified as category III (n = 6), IV (n = 10), or V (n = 1), according to the Schaefer-Fuhrman classification. All patients who required a tracheotomy (n = 13) were de-cannulated. Nineteen of the 20 patients recovered a social voice. The exception was a patient with aphasia secondary to head trauma No patient had aspiration problems. We encountered no complication associated with the use of APF.

CONCLUSION

APF is an effective and well-tolerated method to repair laryngeal fractures.