Vocal function after vertical partial laryngectomy with glottic reconstruction by false vocal fold flap: durational and frequency measures

Voice Quality Outcomes After Transoral CO2 Laser Cordectomy: A Longitudinal Prospective Study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the evolution of voice quality in patients after type I-VI transoral CO₂ laser cordectomy (TLC) by using validated voice outcome measures over a 12-month period.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective uncontrolled study.

SETTING

Monocenter study.

METHODS

Patients with laryngeal carcinoma who were eligible for type I-IV TLC were prospectively recruited from a tertiary medical center. The following outcomes were assessed throughout the 12-month posttreatment period: Voice Handicap Index (VHI), GRBAS (grade of dysphonia, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, strain), maximal phonation time, fundamental frequency (F0), F0 standard deviation, percentage jitter, percentage shimmer, noise-to-harmonic ratio, and speech fluency. Analyses were performed considering 2 groups of cordectomies: type I-III vs IV-VI.

RESULTS

A total of 131 patients completed the evaluations, totaling 76 type I-III and 55 type IV-VI cordectomies. In type IV-VI, breathiness and maximal phonation time significantly worsened from pretreatment to 1 month posttreatment (P < .05). In the type I-III cordectomy group, VHI, shimmer, roughness, breathiness, and strain significantly improved from pretreatment to 3 months posttreatment, while VHI, F0 standard deviation, shimmer, jitter, grade of dysphonia, roughness, breathiness, and strain improved from baseline to 6 months. Assessments at 12 months posttreatment revealed significant improvements for VHI, shimmer, jitter, noise-to-harmonic ratio, grade of dysphonia, roughness, breathiness, and strain. In the type IV-VI group, VHI significantly improved from baseline to 3, 6, and 12 months posttreatment. Strain improved at 6 and 12 months while roughness improved from baseline to 12 months. Maximal phonation time significantly worsened over the 12-month evaluation period.

CONCLUSION

The effect of TLC on voice quality depends on its type. VHI was identified as the most indicative tool of voice changes irrespective of TLC type.

Open Partial Laryngectomies: History of Laryngeal Cancer Surgery

Historically, surgery was the first-choice therapy for early, intermediate and advanced laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma (LSCC). Partial laryngeal surgery has evolved in recent decades and was influenced by many historic events and the development of new technologies. Partial laryngectomies may be performed by open, endoscopic or transoral robotic approaches. In this historic paper, we describe the evolution of open partial laryngectomy techniques, indications and surgical outcomes. Since the first partial laryngectomy in 1788, many U.S., U.K. and European surgeons, including Henry Sands, Jacob da Silva Solis-Cohen and Theodor Billroth, performed this surgical procedure under local anesthesia for tuberculosis, cancer or syphilis. Partial laryngectomy gained reputation in the medical community in 1888 due to the laryngeal cancer and death of the prince of Prussia, Frederick III. Frederick III’s death represented the turning point in the history of partial laryngectomies, calling attention to the importance of semiotics, biopsy and early diagnosis in laryngeal cancers. Hemi-laryngectomy was indicated/proposed for lateral laryngeal tumors, while thyrotomy was indicated for cancers of the middle part of the vocal fold. The second landmark in the history of partial laryngectomies was the discovery of cocaine, novocaine and adrenaline and the related development of local anesthetic techniques, which, together with the epidemiological and hygienic advances of the 19th century, allowed for better perioperative outcomes. General anesthesia was introduced in the second part of the 20th century and further improved the surgical outcomes. The diagnosis of laryngeal cancer was improved with the development of X-rays and direct laryngoscopies. The 20th century was characterized by the development and improvement of vertical partial laryngectomy procedures and the development of horizontal partial laryngectomies for both supraglottic and glottic regions. The history and the evolution of these techniques are discussed in the present historical paper.

Vestibular fold flap for post-cordectomy laryngeal reconstruction

OBJECTIVES:

The development of techniques causing fewer sequelae without compromising oncologic control has led to better phonation, breathing, and postoperative swallowing in patients submitted to cordectomy. The objective of the present study was to describe post-cordectomy laryngeal reconstruction with a vestibular fold flap and to analyze the resulting laryngeal functions.

STUDY DESIGN:

Prospective study.

METHODS:

Ten patients, 9 males and 1 female, aged 45 to 75 years (mean, 64.5 years), were evaluated. The patients had squamous cell carcinomas in the glottic region and were treated surgically by laryngofissure and cordectomy with the use of a vestibular fold flap for laryngeal reconstruction. The patients were followed up for functional laryngeal analysis that consisted of videolaryngostrobos-copy, endoscopic evaluation of swallowing, and voice recording for perceptive auditory analysis, and for computing purposes.

RESULTS:

No patients depended on tracheostomy during the late postoperative period. No stenosis, anterior synechia, granuloma, or laryngocele were detected, although 1 patient developed immobility in the median position of the operated hemilarynx, which, however, was not sufficient to impair the respiratory function. No alterations in the pharyngeal phase of swallowing were observed by endoscopic evaluation. Using the GRBAS scale, we observed moderate (30%) and severe (20%) dysphonia in 50% of the patients and grade 1 dysphonia (40%) or normal (10%) dysphonia in the remaining ones. Computing analysis revealed the following mean values: fundamental frequency of 177.5 Hz, jitter 1.11%, and shimmer 7.04%.

CONCLUSIONS:

We conclude that reconstruction with a vestibular fold flap permitted the maintenance of the laryngeal functions of breathing and airway protection during swallowing, as well as the maintenance of phonation function, providing perfect voice emission according to perceptive auditory or acoustic analysis in 1 patient and moderate or severe dysphonia in one half of the cases when technical faults occurred.

Voice Outcome of Modified Frontolateral Partial Laryngectomy in Excised Canine Larynges and Finite Element Model

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate vocal parameters after modified frontolateral partial laryngectomy (MFLPL) and frontolateral partial laryngectomy (FLPL) in both excised canine and finite element models.

STUDY DESIGN

FLPL and MFLPL were compared, using a prospective paired case control laboratory study with excised canine larynx and computational modeling.

SETTING

Basic science study conducted in university laboratory.

METHODS

FLPL and MFLPL were performed serially on 9 excised canine larynges. The excised larynx bench apparatus was used to collect phonation threshold pressure (PTP) and high-speed video data. A finite element model was built to compare a normal vocal fold with applied tension, a cut fold with no applied tension (simulating FLPL), and a cut fold with applied tension (simulating MFLPL). Stress values and distributions across the 3 conditions were computed.

RESULTS

The mean PTP increase after MFLPL (15.45-17.46 cmH2O) was not statistically significant. In the excised canine model, fundamental frequency (F0) showed a significant increase for the MFLPL (P = .039). Differences in vibration amplitudes were not statistically significant. Von Mises stress distribution was most similar between the MFLPL model and the normal fold. Maximum von Mises stresses at the midline were 17.56, 21.63, and 5.10 kPa for the normal, MFLPL, and FLPL, respectively, and 47.57, 63.98, and 101.97 kPa at the peripheries.

CONCLUSIONS

From these results, we conclude that MFLPL has the potential to give a better voice outcome while avoiding tracheotomy in partial laryngectomy patients. In vivo study in canines to examine the healing process would lend further evidence-based support for this surgical method.

A modified false vocal fold flap for functional reconstruction after frontolateral partial laryngectomy: a comparison with conventional open resection and laser cordectomy

OBJECTIVE

To describe a modified flap technique (MFT) involving the use of a false vocal fold flap for glottic reconstruction and the removal of arytenoid cartilage and to compare it with conventional frontolateral partial laryngectomy (FLPL) and laser cordectomy (LC).

METHODS

Twenty-eight MFT, 13 FLPL and 12 LC patients completed a standardised questionnaire for assessing aspiration, respiration, quality of life, and subjective voice quality. We analysed vocal function in terms of roughness, breathiness and hoarseness, measured voice range profiles, and performed videoendoscopy.

RESULTS

No patient reported respiratory problems. Aspiration occurred in 33.3% (MFT), 41.6% (FLPL) and 16.6% (LC). Voice quality was rated as good/satisfactory by 17 MFT patients (62%), satisfactory/sufficient by 69% of FLKT patients, and sufficient/poor by 75% of LC patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The modified false vocal fold flap effectively covers defects and creates a neocord that ensures good phonatory rehabilitation and has positive effects on postoperative quality of life.

Vocal therapy with larynx compression after partial laryngectomy

The aim of the study was to establish the effects of the vocal therapy by manual compression of the larynx on dysphonia due to a partial laryngectomy and compare them with the effects of the standard vocal therapy. The prospective study included 66 patients submitted to any partial laryngectomy type. The patients were randomly classified into two groups: Group I (33) receiving the standard vocal therapy, and Group II (33) submitted to larynx compression vocal therapy. The 6-week vocal treatment was performed. The treatment effects were evaluated by subjective and objective voice analysis methods. The subjective and objective acoustic voice analysis revealed a significant influence (p < 0.05) of either of the two vocal therapy modes on initial dysphonia. The larynx compression vocal therapy had better effects on the acoustic parameters: habitual fundamental frequency, mean fundamental frequency, standard deviation of fundamental frequency, maximal fundamental frequency, harmonics-to-noise ratio, and signal-to-noise ratio.

Vertical partial hemilaryngectomy with reconstruction by false cord imbrication

BACKGROUND

To evaluate global survival, disease-free period, complications, evolution and function in vertical partial hemilaryngectomy (VPHL) plus reconstruction with false cord.

METHODS

Descriptive and retrospective study. In aertiary care medical center in Mexico City. Eight patients with early diagnosis of early glottic cancer (T1 and T2), treated with VPHL plus reconstruction with false cord imbrication.

RESULTS

Fifty percent of the patients were clinical stage I, 37.5% stage II and 12.5% stage III. Nasogastric tube was not placed and oral feeding was reinitiated within 3 days on average. Tracheostomy was removed after an average of 2.1 days. Average hospital stay was 3.3 days. Average of the PSS-HNC (Performance Status for Head and Neck Cancer) and Karnofsky Performance Status evaluation was 91 to 97 and 100 at 1 year of evaluation. Voice evaluation demonstrated normal voice in 87.5% of patients. Intensity was below normal with improvement on annual evaluation. Global survival was 100% and disease-free period was 71% at 3 years.

CONCLUSIONS

VPHL with reconstruction by false cord imbrication is an excellent therapeutic option for early glottic cancers. Multiple functional advantages are demonstrated without sacrificing oncological control as well as providing an audible and intelligible voice. In cases of recurrence, various management options are available.

Glottal reconstruction with a tissue engineering technique using polypropylene mesh: a canine experiment

OBJECTIVES

The larynx must be resected in some cases of cancer or stenosis, and various techniques are generally employed to fill the resulting defect. No ideal way, however, has been established to restore vocal function after this form of insult. The aim of this preliminary feasibility study in a canine model was to investigate the effectiveness of a polypropylene-based tissue engineering approach to repair a partial glottal defect.

METHODS

Eight dogs were used in this study. A laryngeal defect involving resection of the left vocal fold was created through a thyroid cartilage window. A scaffold made of polypropylene and collagen was preclotted and wrapped with autologous fascia lata, inserted through the window, and sutured to the laryngeal defect in 5 dogs. The defect was reconstructed with an adjacent sternohyoid muscle flap in 3 control dogs. The surgical site was evaluated 3 months after operation by fiberscopic examination, computed tomographic imaging, histologic evaluation, and study of excised larynges.

RESULTS

On fiberscopic examination, the experimental group implants were completely covered with regenerated mucosa in all cases, and a favorable vocal fold contour was found in 4 of the 5 cases. One case was characterized by a concave vocal fold shape and red granulation. In the control group, the muscle flap was replaced by scarred mucosa with a concave vocal fold contour in 2 cases, and there was soft white granulation at the anterior resected edge in the third case. The histologic data revealed the regeneration of lined epithelium, subepithelial tissue, and muscle structure in both groups. The excised larynx phonatory data revealed reduced vibratory amplitude in the experimental group compared with the control group; however, excised phonation was not achieved in 2 of the 3 cases in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

This polypropylene-based tissue engineering technique appears to be a viable tool for glottal reconstruction; however, additional refinement is required to maximize long-term phonatory function.

Modified frontolateral partial laryngectomy without tracheotomy

Objective: To investigate the feasibility of modified frontolateral partial laryngectomy without tracheotomy for patients with early-stage laryngeal cancer or dysplasia of the true vocal cord.

Study Design: After frontolateral partial laryngectomy, the inner side of the sternohyoid muscle was drawn into the laryngeal lumen to suture it to the incisal margin of the uninjured side and to the false vocal cord on the side of the lesion to ensure the safety without tracheotomy. A reverted sternohyoid fascial flap was used to cover the anterior area to form a new laryngeal lumen in the shape of a ladder.

Subjects and Methods: A total of 65 patients with early glottic carcinomas or severe dysplasia of the true vocal cord were treated with modified frontolateral partial laryngectomy without tracheotomy. Ipsilateral false vocal cord flaps and cervical skin flaps were used in 63 patients and two patients respectively to reconstruct the defect.

Results: Deglutition and phonation were fully recovered after 7 to 10 days postsurgery. The only postoperative complication was subcutaneous emphysema noted in nine patients. The 1-, 3-, and 5-year survival rates were all 100 percent.

Conclusion: Modified frontolateral partial laryngectomy without tracheostomy is an effective surgical method for early glottic carcinomas and severe dysplasia of the true vocal cord.

Microsurgical laryngotracheal reconstruction

Laryngotracheal reconstruction using free-tissue transfer represents one of the new challenges for the head and neck reconstructive surgeon. This article reviews the anatomy and physiology of the larynx and trachea and discusses the clinical context of laryngotracheal reconstruction, particularly with regard to malignant tumors involving the larynx and cervical trachea. It reviews the free-tissue reconstructive options, including the free forearm flap, the temporoparietal flap, and the two-staged procedure described by Delaere.

Laryngeal reconstruction by platysma myofascial flap after vertical partial laryngectomy

BACKGROUND

Many methods of glottic reconstruction have been described for patients undergoing vertical partial laryngectomy to reestablish the glottic integrity.

METHODS

Fifteen patients with T2 squamous cell carcinoma of the glottis were included in this prospective clinical trial. All patients were treated by vertical partial laryngectomy with laryngeal reconstruction by platysma myofascial flap. The surgical procedure and flap design were described. Vocal function was assessed by videolaryngostroboscopy and subjective and objective voice analysis before and after surgery.

RESULTS

Complete neoglottic closure and acceptable voice quality were obtained by platysma myofascial flap in all cases. No statistically significant difference was found between the preoperative and postoperative acoustic parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

Platysma myofascial flap provides the basic requirements for laryngeal reconstruction with its own favorable characteristics and also allows complete glottic closure without interfering with respiration and deglutition. This technique may be an effective alternative achieving an acceptable quality of voice.

Transoral laser microresection for cancer of the larynx involving the anterior commissure

OBJECTIVE

To share the authors' experience of transoral laser microresection in the treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the anterior commissure of the larynx.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review of 39 patients with squamous carcinoma involving the anterior commissure of the larynx, all managed with transoral laser microresection between September 1996 and December 2001. Twenty-three patients had pT1 or pT2 cancers. Sixteen patients had pT3 or pT4 disease, two with N2b neck metastases. Twenty patients had cancers exhibiting spread to the subglottis. Twenty-five patients had received prior treatment(s).

METHODS

Specific data points entered into a portable database were retrospectively verified against the patient's electronic medical record. Sorting and analysis were completed in a desktop spreadsheet. We evaluated tumor recurrence, cause of death, tracheostomy, hospital length of stay, and voice quality.

RESULTS

None of the 17 patients with early cancers (pT1 or pT2a) had local recurrence, and none received postoperative radiotherapy. Five of the 22 patients with intermediate or advanced disease (pT2b/pT3 or pT4 cancer) required second treatments for persistent or recurrent disease. Of these, two had small residual foci amenable to second-stage resection by laser. One patient developed a prelaryngeal soft tissue recurrence and retained his larynx after wide local excision and radiotherapy. Two patients (both previously irradiated) developed delayed recurrences requiring total laryngectomy. Four retreated patients remained alive without disease. One patient died of other causes. Voice remained no worse after transoral laser microresection in 19 patients. It was one level worse (on a scale of 0 to 5) for 16 patients. Eleven patients received temporary tracheotomies, some for airway, some for exposure. Twelve patients left the hospital on a same-day basis. The average hospital stay was 3.3 days.

CONCLUSION

Transoral laser microsurgery is one of the options to be considered for the treatment of squamous cell cancer involving the anterior commissure of the larynx.

Vocal outcome after endoscopic cordectomies for Tis and T1 glottic carcinomas

A cohort of 101 patients with previously untreated glottic cancer (15 Tis, 66 T1a, and 20 T1b) who underwent endoscopic CO2 laser excision between January 1995 and December 1997 was prospectively analyzed. The depth and extension of the excision were graded according to the European Laryngological Society Classification including 5 types of cordectomy. All patients were subsequently examined every 2 months for a period ranging from 30 to 66 months (mean, 48 months). The rates of 5-year overall survival, disease-free survival, ultimate local control with laser alone, and laryngeal preservation were 85%, 87%, 93%, and 95%, respectively. Sixty-nine patients underwent, at least 1 year after surgery, videolaryngostroboscopy combined with perceptual and objective evaluation of the voice, and spirometry. Acoustic parameters were compared with those obtained in a matched control group by Kruskal-Wallis test. No statistically significant difference was found (p > .05) between patients submitted to subepithelial (type I) and subligamental (type II) cordectomies and controls.

Phonatory mechanisms after vertical partial laryngectomy with glottic reconstruction by false vocal fold flap

A prospective randomized study was designed to compare phonatory mechanisms in patients treated with frontolateral partial laryngectomy (FLPL) with or without glottic reconstruction with false vocal fold (FVF) mucosal flap. Objective voice assessment was based on computerized acoustic recordings and videolaryngostroboscopy performed before, 1 year after, and 2 years after surgery. Phonatory mechanisms were studied according to the surgical technique and correlated with acoustic recordings. The results showed that supraglottic structures participated in laryngeal closure and voice production in 80% of cases in which a standard FLPL was performed. The FVF mucosal flap was involved in both laryngeal closure and voice production in 54% of patients treated with glottic reconstruction. The type of laryngeal closure (glottic or supraglottic) statistically influenced the acoustic measurements. As glottic closure is more frequent in patients treated with glottic reconstruction, the authors recommend performing reconstruction of the glottis with an FVF mucosal flap when an FLPL is indicated.