Analysis of pallidotomy lesion positions using three-dimensional reconstruction of pallidal lesions, the basal ganglia, and the optic tract

Correlation of outcome to neurosurgical lesions: confirmation of a new method using data after microelectrode-guided pallidotomy

The purpose of this study was the development of a new method to correlate functional surgery with outcome measures. Lesions following microelectrode guided globus pallidus internus (GPi) pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease are presented to demonstrate this new method in regard to clinical outcome. A clinical series of 26 patients with extensive neurological and neuropsychological data were studied. Three-month postoperative MRI lesion borders at the AC-PC plane were scaled to a standard size, and the lesions were stored in a virtual array with a cell size of one voxel. The average outcome measure for each voxel is presented graphically. Unified Parkinson's disease rating scale (UPDRS) motor scores improved more with posterolateral and centrally located GPi lesions than with anteromedial lesions. A correlation of lesion location to outcome was also visible for subscales of the UPDRS. The distributions were similar for the left and right sides, as well as for ipsi- and contralateral measurements. In general, verbal fluency decreased after lesioning the dominant hemisphere, and posterolateral lesions caused less impairment. This method enables associative analyses between brain area and outcome down to the size of a few voxels. This may be particularly helpful for planning and validating neurosurgical targets for various disorders.

Comparative Evaluation of the Effects of Unilateral Lesion versus Electrical Stimulation of the Globus Pallidus Internus in Advanced Parkinson’s Disease

OBJECTIVE

To perform a prospective analysis on the effects of unilateral lesion versus unilateral electrical stimulation (ES) of the globus pallidus internus (Gpi) in the treatment of bilateral Parkinson's disease (PD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We studied 18 patients with stages III-V on the Hoehn and Yahr (H-Y) scale having prominent rigidity, bradykinesia and gait disturbances. Nine patients were treated with lesions and 9 patients with ES. Both groups were evaluated using the New York Parkinson's Disease Scale, the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale part III, and the H-Y scale and with specific items of tremor, rigidity and bradykinesia independently on each side. Both lesions and electrodes for ES were placed stereotactically in the Gpi as confirmed by postoperative magnetic resonance images. Significance of changes was evaluated with the Wilcoxon test after 3 and 6 months. Significance of intergroup differences was evaluated using the Mann-Whitney U test.

RESULTS

Lesions and ES significantly decreased rigidity (p < 0.01) and bradykinesia (p < 0.005) in the contralateral extremities. ES significantly decreased tremor in the contralateral extremities (p < 0.01) and rigidity and bradykinesia ipsilaterally (p < 0.01) at 3 months. There were no significant intergroup differences. The H-Y scale score showed improvement in self-sufficiency. L-DOPA dose was decreased by 31%.

CONCLUSIONS

ES was a safer procedure and more efficient in controlling PD symptoms. Unilateral lesions and ES may improve bilateral symptoms to the point of making patients self-sufficient.

Deep brain stimulation

During the last decade deep brain stimulation (DBS) has become a routine method for the treatment of advanced Parkinson's disease (PD), leading to striking improvements in motor function and quality of life of PD patients. It is associated with minimal morbidity. The rationale of targeting specific structures within basal ganglia such as the subthalamic nucleus (STN) or the internal segment of the globus pallidus (GPi) is strongly supported by the current knowledge of the basal ganglia pathophysiology, which is derived from extensive experimental work and which provides the theoretical basis for surgical therapy in PD. In particular, the STN has advanced to the worldwide most used target for DBS in the treatment of PD, due to the marked improvement of all cardinal symptoms of the disease. Moreover on-period dyskinesias are reduced in parallel with a marked reduction of the equivalent daily levodopa dose following STN-DBS. The success of the therapy largely depends on the selection of the appropriate candidate patients and on the precise implantation of the stimulation electrode, which necessitates careful imaging-based pre-targeting and extensive electrophysiological exploration of the target area. Despite the clinical success of the therapy, the fundamental mechanisms of high-frequency stimulation are still not fully elucidated. There is a large amount of evidence from experimental and clinical data that stimulation frequency represents a key factor with respect to clinical effect of DBS. Interestingly, high-frequency stimulation mimics the functional effects of ablation in various brain structures. The main hypotheses for the mechanism of high-frequency stimulation are: (1) depolarization blocking of neuronal transmission through inactivation of voltage dependent ion-channels, (2) jamming of information by imposing an efferent stimulation-driven high-frequency pattern, (3) synaptic inhibition by stimulation of inhibitory afferents to the target nucleus, (4) synaptic failure by stimulation-induced neurotransmitter depletion. As the hyperactivity of the STN is considered a functional hallmark of PD and as there is experimental evidence for STN-mediated glutamatergic excitotoxicity on neurons of the substantia nigra pars compacta (SNc), STN-DBS might reduce glutamatergic drive, leading to neuroprotection. Further studies will be needed to elucidate if STN-DBS indeed provides a slow-down of disease progression.

Verbal fluency declines after pallidotomy: an interaction between task and lesion laterality

Verbal fluency declines are commonly reported after pallidotomy in patients with Parkinson's disease. However, it is not clear whether there is an interaction between side of surgery and task format (lexical vs. semantic) or whether error rates (perseverations, intrusions, rule violations) increase after surgery. This study examined verbal fluency before and approximately 4 months after unilateral pallidotomy. The left and right pallidotomy groups were matched on key demographic, cognitive, and disease variables. Pallidotomy resulted in a decline in lexical but not semantic verbal fluency, and this decline was most evident in the left-sided surgery group. Error rates (perseverations, intrusions, and rule violations) were not affected by pallidotomy. Findings support the role of left frontal-basal ganglionic circuits in word retrieval processes and/or lexical search and access.

Hemorrhagic complication of stereotactic surgery in patients with movement disorders

OBJECT

Small, asymptomatic hemorrhages are easier to detect during stereotactic surgery when magnetic resonance (MR) imaging is used for targeting rather than when traditional approaches, such as ventriculography, are performed with contrast material. In the present study the authors examined the actual incidence of intraoperative hemorrhages in patients with movement disorders who had undergone MR imaging-targeted surgery, microelectrode recording (MER)-guided implantation of deep brain stimulation (DBS) electrodes, or radiofrequency-induced coagulation surgery performed.

METHODS

Ninety-six consecutive patients underwent a total of 116 stereotactic operations for movement disorders (57 operations for radiofrequency-induced coagulation and 59 for DBS electrode implantation) between January 1998 and November 2002. The authors investigated the correlation between hemorrhages and other factors including the location of the hemorrhage and the type of surgery performed. Postoperative computerized tomography scans demonstrated the occurrence of intraoperative hemorrhages at 12 locations during 11 procedures (9.5% of all procedures). Nine hemorrhages occurred during 57 coagulation operations (15.8%). Within this group, the frequency of hemorrhages was highest during thalamotomy (five [21.7%] of 23 procedures) and lower during pallidotomy (four [11.8%] of 34 procedures). In contrast, only two intraventricular hemorrhages developed during 59 operations in which DBS electrodes were implanted (3.4%). In no case was hemorrhage detected in the main DBS target, that is, the subthalamic nucleus.

CONCLUSIONS

When small, asymptomatic hemorrhages were included in the estimation, the actual rate of hemorrhage was higher than that previously reported. Judging from the incidence of hemorrhage during coagulation and DBS surgeries, the authors suggest that the heat induced by coagulation may play a larger role than microelectrode penetration in the development of hemorrhage.

Analysis of complications of radiofrequency pallidotomy

OBJECTIVE

To systematically report the complications of pallidotomy and to tentatively determine the incidences of complications of pallidotomy, possible influencing factors, and the acceptability of symptomatic hemorrhage rates for microelectrode-guided pallidotomy.

METHODS

Clinical events were analyzed for 1116 patients with Parkinson's disease who underwent microelectrode-guided pallidotomies at our center. Complications included visual field deficits, weakness, fatigue, hypersomnia, drooling, dysphagia, speech disorders, hiccups, hemorrhage, seizures, apraxia, coma, infection, mental confusion, and impaired memory. Complication rates for bilateral pallidotomy and double-lesion groups were compared with those for unilateral pallidotomy and single-lesion groups, respectively.

RESULTS

Among the total of 1116 patients, the incidences of visual field deficits, weakness, fatigue, hypersomnia, drooling, dysphagia, and speech disorders were 0.4, 4.2, 19.9, 12.4, 7.0, 3.7, and 11.9%, respectively. Symptomatic hemorrhage was observed for 17 patients, apraxia for 3 patients, coma for 2 patients, mental confusion for 24 patients, and impaired memory for 18 of the 1116 patients. The incidences of fatigue, speech disorders, drooling, dysphagia, and hypersomnia were 18.1, 10.3, 5.2, 2.4, and 11.6%, respectively, in the unilateral pallidotomy group and 34.9, 25.5, 22.6, 14.2, and 17.0%, respectively, in the staged pallidotomy group. Of the three patients who underwent simultaneous bilateral pallidotomies (all <50 yr of age), all developed severe fatigue and two exhibited drooling and dysphagia. The incidences of weakness, fatigue, speech disorders, drooling, dysphagia, and hypersomnia were 8.7, 30.4, 18.8, 7.2, 2.9, and 20.3%, respectively, in the double-lesion group and 3.2, 17.2, 9.7, 5.0, 2.3, and 11.5%, respectively, in the single-lesion group.

CONCLUSION

Staged bilateral pallidotomy should be carefully evaluated before decision-making, whereas simultaneous bilateral pallidotomy is undesirable. Our study suggests that the size of the final lesion should be limited, to minimize the risks of complications. The incidence of symptomatic hemorrhage in microelectrode-guided pallidotomy is low and acceptable, because of the benefits of microelectrode-guided pallidotomy.

Declines in switching underlie verbal fluency changes after unilateral pallidal surgery in Parkinson's disease

Declines in verbal fluency are consistently reported in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) after pallidal surgery. In the present study, the clustering and switching components of semantic or category fluency (oral naming of items obtainable in supermarkets) were examined at baseline and four months after unilateral deep brain stimulation or pallidotomy in 45 patients with PD (30 left, 15 right pallidal surgery). Post-operative declines were observed for supermarket fluency total score and switching, but not for average cluster size. These findings support the proposal that semantic fluency decrements after pallidal surgery reflect a disruption of frontal-basal ganglia circuits mediating efficient shifting between semantic categories, or perhaps efficient access to categories, rather than a degradation of semantic stores.

A metaanalysis comparing the results of pallidotomy performed using microelectrode recording or macroelectrode stimulation

OBJECT

There is an active debate regarding whether pallidotomy should be performed using macroelectrode stimulation or the more sophisticated and expensive method of microelectrode recording. No prospective, randomized trial results have answered this question, although personnel at many centers claim one method is superior. In their metaanalysis the authors reviewed published reports of both methods to determine if there is a significant difference in clinical outcomes or complication rates associated with these methods.

METHODS

A metaanalysis was performed with data from reports on the use of unilateral pallidotomy in patients with Parkinson disease (PD) that were published between 1992 and 2000. A Medline search was conducted for the key word "pallidotomy" and additional studies were added following a review of the references. Only those studies dealing with unilateral procedures performed in patients with PD were included. Papers were excluded if they described a cohort smaller than 10 patients or a follow-up period shorter than 3 months or included cases that previously had been reported. The primary end points for outcome were the percentages of improvement in dyskinesias and in motor scores determined by the Unified PD Rating Scale (UPDRS). Complications were categorized as mortality, intracranial hemorrhage, visual deficit, speech deficit, cognitive decline, weakness, and other. There were no significant differences between the two methods with respect to improvements in dyskinesias (p = 0.66) or UPDRS motor scores (p = 0.62). Microelectrode recording was associated with a significantly higher (p = 0.012) intracranial hemorrhage rate (1.3 +/- 0.4%), compared with macroelectrode stimulation (0.25 +/- 0.2%).

CONCLUSIONS

In reports of patients with PD who underwent unilateral pallidotomy, operations that included microelectrode recording were associated with a small, but significantly higher rate of symptomatic intracranial hemorrhage; however, there was no difference in postoperative reduction of dyskinesia or bradykinesia compared with operations that included macroelectrode stimulation.

An analysis of the respective risks of hematoma formation in 361 consecutive morphological and functional stereotactic procedures

OBJECTIVE

The risk of hematoma formation in stereotactic procedures is generally considered to range between 1 and 4%, and it has been speculated that morphological procedures may have a higher risk of bleeding than functional procedures.

METHODS

Between 1989 and 1999, all patients who underwent a stereotactic procedure performed by the same surgeon were enrolled sequentially onto the study. All patients had normal preoperative prothrombin time, partial thromboplastin time, and platelet count. High-resolution computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging with a 1.5-T machine were used for the target definition. None of the patients had an angiogram before surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 361 procedures was performed comprising 175 morphological procedures (139 biopsies, 18 lesion evacuations [cysts, abscesses, and hematomas], and 18 drain implantations) and 186 functional procedures (137 lesions [thalamotomy or pallidotomy], 47 deep brain electrode implantations, and two physiological explorations without lesions or implantations). There were no infections or seizures in either group. Three hematomas (1.7%) occurred in the morphological group, two of them in inflammatory lesions in immunocompromised patients (one death) and one in a pineal tumor. Three hematomas (1.6%) occurred in the functional group (no mortality). There was no statistically significant difference (P > 0.05; Fisher's exact test) in the risk of hematoma formation between morphological and functional stereotactic procedures. The morbidity and mortality related to bleeding also were not statistically different (P > 0.05; Fisher's exact test) between these two groups.

CONCLUSION

In this series, the risk of bleeding was not higher for morphological procedures than for functional procedures. This suggests that the risk of bleeding for stereotactic procedures is related more to the patient than to the type of procedure performed. Our study confirms an overall risk of bleeding of 1.7% for any type of stereotactic procedure, resulting in a mortality of 0.3% and a morbidity of 1.4%.

Pallidotomy for parkinson disease: a review of contemporary literature

OBJECT

The authors conducted an evidence-based review of contemporary published articles on pallidotomy to obtain an appraisal of this procedure in the treatment of Parkinson disease (PD).

METHODS

A search of the Pubmed database performed using the key word "pallidotomy" yielded 263 articles cited between January 1, 1992, and July 1, 1999. Articles that included original, nonduplicated descriptions of patients with PD treated with radiofrequency pallidotomy were selected. In 85 articles identified for critical review, 1959 patients with PD underwent pallidotomies at 40 centers in 12 countries. There were 1735 unilateral (88.6%) and 224 bilateral procedures (11.4%). The mean age of the patients was 61.4+/-3.6 years and the mean duration of PD symptoms in these patients was 12.3+/-1.9 years. Microelectrode recordings were used in 46.2% of cases. Outcomes were objectively documented using the Unified Parkinson Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) in 501 (25.6%) of the cases at 6 months and in 218 (11.1%) of the cases at 1 year. There was a consensus on the benefits of pallidotomy for off period motor function and on period, drug-induced dyskinesias, with variations in the extent of symptomatic benefit across studies. At the 1-year assessment, the mean improvement in the UPDRS motor score during off periods was 45.3% and the mean improvement in contralateral dyskinesias during on periods was 86.4%. The overall mortality rate was 0.4% and the rate of persistent adverse effects was estimated at 14%. Major adverse events, including intracerebral hemorrhages, contralateral weakness, and visual field defects, occurred in 5.3% of patients reported.

CONCLUSIONS

Unilateral pallidotomy is effective and relatively safe in the treatment of PD; however, limited data are available on the long-term outcome of this procedure.

Magnetic resonance imaging stereotactic target localization for deep brain stimulation in dystonic children

OBJECT

The actual distortion present in a given series of magnetic resonance (MR) images is difficult to establish. The purpose of this study was to validate an MR imaging-based methodology for stereotactic targeting of the internal globus pallidus during electrode implantation in children in whom general anesthesia had been induced.

METHODS

Twelve children (mean follow up 1 year) suffering from generalized dystonia were treated with deep brain stimulation by using a head frame and MR imaging. To analyze the influence of distortions at every step of the procedure, the geometrical characteristics of the frame were first controlled using the localizer as a phantom. Then pre- and postoperative coordinates of fixed anatomical landmarks and electrode positions, both determined with the head frame in place, were statistically compared. No significant difference was observed between theoretical and measured dimensions of the localizer (Student's t-test, ¿t¿ > 2.2 for 12 patients) in the x, y, and z directions. No significant differences were observed (Wilcoxon paired-sample test) between the following: 1) pre- and postoperative coordinates of the anterior commissure (AC) (deltax = 0.3+/-0.29 mm and deltay = 0.34+/-0.32 mm) and posterior commissure (PC) (deltax = 0.15+/-0.18 mm and deltay = 0.34+/-0.25 mm); 2) pre- and postoperative AC-PC distance (deltaL = 0.33+/-0.22 mm); and 3) preoperative target and final electrode position coordinates (deltax = 0.24+/-0.22 mm; deltay = 0.19+/-0.16 mm).

CONCLUSIONS

In the authors' center, MR imaging distortions did not induce detectable errors during stereotactic surgery in dystonic children. Target localization and electrode implantation could be achieved using MR imaging alone after induction of general anesthesia. The remarkable postoperative improvement in these patients confirmed the accuracy of the procedure (Burke-Marsden-Fahn Dystonia Rating Scale score delta = -83.8%).

Predictors of neuropsychological outcome in patients following microelectrode-guided pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease

OBJECT

The authors studied neuropsychological performance following microelectrode-guided posteroventral pallidotomy in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) and evaluated correlations with presurgical and surgical factors.

METHODS

Neuropsychological changes 3 months (43 patients) and 12 months (27 patients) after microelectrode-guided pallidotomy for PD are reported in a series of 44 consecutive patients with the disease, who improved neurologically, as measured by the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) in both the "off' (p<0.001) and best "on" (p<0.001) states. Findings of the vocabulary subtest of the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Revised (p<0.01), Letter Fluency (p<0.001), Verbal Fluency for semantic categories (p<0.001), and the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (p<0.01) showed a significant decline in neuropsychological performance in patients 3 months after undergoing left-sided pallidotomy. Impairment in the language domain (semantic fluency) persisted at the 12-month follow-up examination (p<0.01). Visual memory improved after right-sided pallidotomies (p<0.01 after 3 months), with a nonsignificant trend toward persistent improvement 1 year postsurgery (p<0.02 after 12 months). Preoperative semantic fluency was influenced by patient age (p<0.001) and by the width of the third ventricle (p<0.05), as measured by magnetic resonance imaging. A regression model revealed that semantic fluency 3 months postoperatively was significantly affected by the baseline score (p<0.001), side of surgery (p<0.001), handedness (p<0.01), and patient age (p<0.05). However, postoperative lesion volume, lesion location, number of tracks, number of lesions, distance from anatomical landmarks, or UPDRS score did not significantly contribute to neuropsychological outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

Neuropsychological changes in a cohort of patients with PD who underwent pallidotomy and experienced excellent clinical benefits and minimum postoperative complications, emphasize the importance of neuropsychological examinations and further investigation of predictive factors.

Health-related quality of life in Parkinson's disease after pallidotomy and deep brain stimulation

This study explored the multidimensional outcome of three neurosurgical interventions for Parkinson's disease (PD): pallidotomy (N = 23), pallidal deep brain stimulation (DBS) (N = 9), and thalamic DBS (N = 7). All patients completed the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) and the Beck Depression Inventory. Pallidotomy patients also completed the Profile of Mood States, the Beck Anxiety Inventory, and a disease-specific quality of life (QOL) measure, the Parkinson's Disease Questionnaire (PDQ-39). Three months after surgery, all neurosurgical groups showed significant improvements in mood and function, including physical, psychosocial, and overall functioning. Pallidal DBS and pallidotomy patients who completed additional QOL measures reported decreased anxiety and tension, increased vigor, improved mobility and ability to perform activities of daily living, and decreased perceived stigma. Psychosocial dysfunction scores from the SIP were related to depressed mood both at baseline (r = .42) and at followup (r = .45), but the physical dysfunction subscale was not related to mood at either time point, suggesting that disruption of social relationships due to PD may have more impact on affective distress than physical symptoms alone. Results suggest that neurosurgical interventions for PD improve disabling PD motor symptoms and also improve several domains of quality of life.

The impact of lesion laterality on neuropsychological change following posterior pallidotomy: a review of current findings

This paper reviews seven studies evaluating the impact of lesion laterality on the neuropsychological sequelae of posterior pallidotomy for treatment of Parkinson's disease. Left lesions of the internal globus pallidus (GPi) were associated with subtle deficits on measures sensitive to frontal lobe function. The findings of a randomized clinical trial including a patient control group indicated that many of these deficits were transient, resolving by 6 months following surgery. Right GPi lesions were not consistently associated with neuropsychological deficit, except in one study that included a significant proportion of demented patients. It is hypothesized that when neuropsychological decline is present following surgery, this reflects impingement of posterior GPi lesions into proximal regions such as anterior GPi or the external pallidum that participate in cognitive basal ganglia-thalamocortical circuits. The findings from neuroimaging will be important for elucidating the relationship between lesion locus and neuropsychological sequelae.

Pallidotomy microelectrode targeting: neurophysiology-based target refinement

OBJECTIVE

Microelectrode recording can refine targeting for stereotactic radiofrequency lesioning of the globus pallidus to treat Parkinson's disease. Multiple intraoperative microelectrode recording/stimulating tracks are searched and assessed for neuronal activity, presence of tremor cells, visual responses, and responses to kinesthetic input. These physiological data are then correlated with atlas-based anatomic data to approximate electrode location. On the basis of these physiological properties, one or more tracks are selected for lesioning. This study analyzes the track physiological factors that seem most significant in determining the microelectrode recording track(s) that will be chosen for pallidal lesioning.

METHODS

Thirty-six patients with Parkinson's disease underwent microelectrode-guided pallidotomy. Between one and five microelectrode recording tracks were made per patient. Usually, one (n = 23) or two (n = 12) of these tracks were lesioned. Electrode positions in the x (mediolateral) and y (anteroposterior) axes were recorded and related to track neurophysiological findings and final lesion location. The stereotactic location and sequence of microelectrode tracks were recorded and plotted to illustrate individual search patterns. These patterns were then compared with those noted in other patients. Neurophysiological data obtained from recording tracks were analyzed. A retrospective analysis of track electrophysiology was performed to determine the track characteristics that seemed most important in the surgeon's choice of the track to lesion. Track physiological properties included general cell spike amplitude, tremor synchronous neuronal firing, kinesthetically responsive neuronal firing, and optic track responses (either phosphenes reported by the patient during track microstimulation or neuronal firing in response to light stimulus into the patient's eyes). Orthogonally corrected postoperative magnetic resonance images were used to confirm the anatomic lesion locations.

RESULTS

In patients who had a single mapped track lesioned, specific track electrophysiological characteristics identified the track that would be lesioned most of the time (20 of 24 patients). Tracks that exhibited a combination of tremor synchronous firing, joint kinesthesia, and visual responsivity were lesioned 17 (85%) of 20 times. Analysis of intraoperative electrode movement in the x and y axes indicated a significant subset of moves but did not result in microelectrode positioning closer to the subsequently lesioned track. Accuracy of initial electrode movement in the x and y axes was most highly correlated with a measure of first-track electrophysiological activity. The number of microelectrode recording tracks did not correlate with clinical outcome. Anatomic analysis, using postoperative magnetic resonance imaging, revealed that all lesions were placed in the globus pallidus. Most patients (35 of 36) improved after surgery.

CONCLUSION

The level of electrophysiological activity in the first track was the best predictive factor in determining whether the next microelectrode move would be closer to the ultimately lesioned track. The analysis of electrode track location and neurophysiological properties yields useful information regarding the effectiveness of microelectrode searching in the x and y axes. Within an institution, the application of this modeling method may increase the efficiency of the microelectrode refinement process.

Stereotactic pallidotomy performed without using microelectrode guidance in patients with Parkinson's disease: surgical technique and 2-year results

OBJECT

Pallidotomy for the treatment of medically refractory Parkinson's disease (PD) has enjoyed renewed popularity. However, the optimal surgical technique, lesion location, and long-term effectiveness of pallidotomy remain subjects of debate. In this article the authors describe their surgical technique for performing pallidotomy without using microelectrode guidance, and the clinical and radiological results of this procedure.

METHODS

Patients were evaluated preoperatively by using a battery of validated clinical rating scales and magnetic resonance (MR) imaging of the brain. Individuals with severe treatment-refractory idiopathic PD who were believed to be good candidates for surgery underwent computerized tomography scanning- and MR imaging-guided stereotactic pallidotomy. Intraoperative macrostimulation was used to optimize lesion placement and to avoid injury to nearby structures. Lesion location and size were calculated from MR imaging sequences of the brain obtained within the first 24 hours after surgery and again 3 months later. Clinical examinations were conducted at 1.5, 3, 6, 12, and 24 months after surgery. Seventy-five patients (mean age 61 years, range 38-79 years) underwent unilateral pallidotomy. Significant improvements were observed in the "off' period scores for the activities of daily living portion of the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS), the UPDRS motor scores, total "on" time, levodopa-induced dyskinesias, and contralateral tremor. These improvements were maintained 24 months postoperatively. The mean lesion volume measured on the immediate postoperative MR image was 73 +/- 5.4 mm3. Radiological analysis suggests that initial lesion volume does not predict outcome. The only permanent major complication was a single visual field defect.

CONCLUSIONS

Pallidotomy performed without using microelectrode guidance is a safe and effective treatment for selected patients with medically refractory PD.

Electrophysiological versus image-based targeting in the posteroventral pallidotomy

OBJECTIVE

To study the functional accuracy of stereotactic targeting for the posteroventral pallidotomy (PVP), comparing targets chosen on magnetic resonance images (MRI), and fused MRI to computed tomographic (CT) images, with electrophysiologically refined anatomical targets. METHDOS AND MATERIALS: For each of the 10 pallidotomies three sets of targets were collected, beginning with the MRI targets. The second target set was measured on images generated by nonlinear volumetric fusion of MRI images with CT using Image Fusion (Radionics, Inc.). The anatomical target site was then determined electrophysiologically with intraoperative microelectrode recording and macroelectrode stimulation guidance.

RESULTS

Magnetic resonance imaging or MRI-CT fused images alone would not have been sufficiently accurate to preclude visual or motor complications in the posteroventral pallidotomy, based on our target located within 1 mm of the optic tract and within 2 mm of the internal capsule. In 2 of the 10 cases of either MRI or fused images, the targets were dangerously close to the optic tract. Two of 10 of the fused targets were within the internal capsule. The fusion of MRI with CT did not functionally improve the targeting accuracy of MRI, since the means of the MRI targets and the fused targets were statistically the same. Individually, however, the MRI target was different from the fused target in each case by an average radial distance of 3.5 +/- 2.3 mm, but such corrections were not statistically or surgically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

Image-based targeting including MRI or fused MRI-CT data may not be sufficiently accurate to prevent capsular or visual deficits in the posteroventral pallidotomy, necessitating electrophysiological refinement. In this report, the functional accuracy of MRI was not improved by fusion with CT.

Cognitive and behavioral changes after unilateral posteroventral pallidotomy: relationship with lesional data from MRI

We investigated cognitive and behavioral changes after unilateral posteroventral pallidotomy, and their relationship with lesion size and location as identified in magnetic resonance image quantitative analysis. Fifteen consecutive patients with Parkinson's disease were assessed neuropsychologically before and after unilateral posteroventral pallidotomy (five right and 10 left). Immediate postsurgery evaluation (1 week) demonstrated significant worsening of memory, motor learning, motor speed, and verbal fluency. In the 3-month follow up, learning, memory, and speed returned to the presurgical level, but verbal fluency remained below the baseline. Significant improvements were observed in visuospatial functions and obsessive-compulsive behavior. Lesional volume did not correlate with neuropsychologic changes. Left lesions produced more impairment in verbal fluency than right-sided lesions. Regression analysis identified two lesional areas in the pallidum mediale internum. These regions accounted for 68% of the variance in the visuospatial changes.

Posteroventral medial pallidotomy in Parkinson's disease

There has been a resurgence in the use of functional neurosurgery for Parkinson's disease. An important factor that has played a role in this development is the recent understanding of the functional anatomy of the basal ganglia including a knowledge of the changes in the activities of neurons in the internal segment of the globus pallidus (Gpi) and the subthalamic nucleus (STN) in Parkinson's disease as well as the knowledge of the presence of segregated functional loops within the basal ganglia which include a sensory-motor loop that involves the posteromedial globus pallidus rather than the anterior GPi where earlier pallidotomy lesions had been made. Laitinen reintroduced the modern posteroventral medial pallidotomy (PVMP) in 1992. Since then it has become clear that this treatment has major effects on levodopa-induced dyskinesias and, unlike Vim thalamotomy, improves bradykinesia and rigidity as well as tremor. In this report, we review a number of topics related to PVMP including the clinical results of pallidotomy available in the literature as well as an update of our own 2 year follow-up data, studies evaluating factors that might predict the subsequent response to pallidotomy, the neuropsychological effects of the procedure, results of imaging studies including the correlation of clinical effects with lesion location, the question of bilateral pallidotomy and pallidotomy combined with deep brain stimulation and finally whether PVMP is effective in other parkinsonian disorders.

Variability in lesion location after microelectrode-guided pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease: anatomical, physiological, and technical factors that determine lesion distribution

OBJECT

To understand the factors that determine the distribution of lesions after microelectrode-guided pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease, the authors quantitatively characterized lesion location in a cohort of patients who were prospectively followed to determine the effects of pallidotomy on clinical outcome.

METHODS

Thirty-three patients underwent volumetric magnetic resonance (MR) imaging after surgery to allow quantitative lesion localization in relation to conventional intraventricular landmarks and, alternatively, more anatomically relevant landmarks. The validity of the method was verified in a cohort of postpallidotomy patients who underwent concurrent volumetric and stereotactic MR imaging in an external head frame. Lesions were distributed over a considerable distance in the anteroposterior (8.8 mm) and mediolateral (8.7 mm) dimensions in relation to the anterior commissure and wall of the third ventricle, respectively. Less variation was seen in lesion location in the dorsoventral dimension (4.8 mm) in relation to the intercommissural plane.

CONCLUSIONS

Lesion distribution was not random: lesion locations in the anteroposterior and mediolateral dimensions were highly correlated, such that lesions were distributed from anteromedial to posterolateral, parallel to the border of the globus pallidus internus with the obliquely oriented internal capsule. The factors that led to variability in lesion location were variation in third ventricle width and the oblique anteromedial-to-posterolateral course of the internal capsule. This demonstration of variability of lesion location in a cohort of patients who experienced excellent clinical benefits and minimal postoperative complications emphasizes the importance of anatomical variations in determining lesion position and the need for physiological corroboration for correct lesion placement.

Relationship of lesion location to clinical outcome following microelectrode-guided pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease

The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between lesion location and clinical outcome following globus pallidus internus (GPi) pallidotomy for advanced Parkinson's disease. Thirty-three patients were prospectively studied with extensive neurological examinations before and at 6 and 12 months following microelectrode-guided pallidotomy. Lesion location was characterized using volumetric MRI. The position of lesions within the posteroventral region of the GPi was measured, from anteromedial to posterolateral along an axis parallel to the internal capsule. To relate lesion position to clinical outcome, hierarchical multiple regression analysis was used. The variance in outcome measures that was related to preoperative scores and lesion volume was first calculated, and then the remaining variance attributable to lesion location was determined. Lesion location along the anteromedial-to-posterolateral axis within the GPi influenced the variance in total score on the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale in the postoperative 'off' period, and in 'on' period dyskinesia scores. Within the posteroventral GPi, anteromedial lesions were associated with greater improvement in 'off' period contralateral rigidity and 'on' period dyskinesia, whereas more centrally located lesions correlated with better postoperative scores of contralateral akinesia and postural instability/gait disturbance. Improvement in contralateral tremor was weakly related to lesion location, being greater with posterolateral lesions. We conclude that improvement in specific motor signs in Parkinson's disease following pallidotomy is related to lesion position within the posteroventral GPi. These findings are consistent with the known segregated but parallel organization of specific motor circuits in the basal ganglia, and may explain the variability in clinical outcome after pallidotomy and therefore have important therapeutic implications.

Outcomes after stereotactically guided pallidotomy for advanced Parkinson's disease

OBJECT

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a prevalent neurodegenerative disorder that becomes refractory to medication as the disease progresses. Although in the past 5 years increasing numbers of patients have undergone stereotactically guided posteroventral pallidotomy for advanced PD, the safety and efficacy of surgery remains to be documented. The goal in this study was to determine the potential operative morbidity and types of functional outcomes by using validated PD rating scales and a patient survey.

METHODS

In a prospective analysis of a consecutive surgical series the authors evaluated 58 patients with advanced PD who ranged in age from 40 to 79 years (mean 67 years) and who had undergone surgery between 1994 and 1997. They used a patient survey and the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) to study patients during periods of medication administration ("on") and withdrawal ("off"; mean off score before surgery = 96). Temporary surgical morbidity was found in four patients (6.9%), three of whom developed transient dysarthria and one of whom exhibited transient confusion (1.7%). One patient had persistent dysarthria (1.7%). No patient developed a visual field deficit or sustained a brain hemorrhage. All patients were discharged from the hospital within 24 hours. Significant postsurgical improvements were noted in the UPDRS off-period total and motor scores, as well as in tremor, rigidity, bradykinesia, and contralateral dyskinesia (p < 0.005). Improvements persisted in dyskinesia and tremor for the 21 patients who were evaluated past 1 year. The authors found no improvement in any on-period symptoms except dyskinesia. Thirty-one (61 %) of 51 patients surveyed reported functional gains and/or dramatic improvement in symptoms, 17 (33%) reported symptomatic improvement without functional gains, and three (6%) had minimal or no change in symptoms. No change in the mini mental state examination score was noted during follow up. There were no significant postoperative changes in the use of medication.

CONCLUSIONS

In advanced PD associated with either a medically refractory state with significant off periods or levodopa-induced dyskinesias, magnetic resonance imaging-guided pallidotomy with macrostimulation was associated with minimal morbidity and yet significantly reduced dyskinesia and off-period disability. These improvements were of value to the patient and persisted beyond the 1st year.

Ablative surgery and deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease

Surgical options for Parkinson's disease (PD) are rapidly expanding and include ablative procedures, deep brain stimulation, and cell transplantation. The target nuclei for ablative surgery and deep brain stimulation are the motor thalamus, the globus pallidus, and the subthalamic nucleus. Multiple factors have led to the resurgence of interest in the surgical treatment of PD: 1) recognition that long-term medical therapy for PD is often unsatisfactory, with patients eventually suffering from drug-induced dyskinesias, motor fluctuations, and variable responses to medication; 2) greater understanding of the pathophysiology of PD, providing a better scientific rationale for some previously developed procedures and suggesting new targets; and 3) use of improved techniques, such as computed tomography- and magnetic resonance imaging-guided stereotaxy and single-unit microelectrode recording, making surgical intervention in the basal ganglia more precise. We review the present status of ablative surgery and deep brain stimulation for PD, including theoretical aspects, surgical techniques, and clinical results.

Pallidotomy lesion locations: significance of microelectrode refinement

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether stereotactic pallidotomy requires refinement using microelectrode recording to ensure proper lesion placement.

METHODS

The experiment approach was based on retrospective comparisons of microelectrode-refined radiofrequency lesion locations with hypothetical unrefined lesion positions. Actual and hypothetical pallidotomy lesions were classified based on their lesion center (thermocoagulative zone) locations and their total lesion areas (surrounding edematous zone) relative to the pallidal target. Assessments were made using postoperative T2-weighted magnetic resonance axial images, which showed both the lesion and globus pallidus (GP). The magnitude of microelectrode refinement from an initial preoperative starting point determined by computed tomography was calculated using stereotactic coordinates and included corrections for the lesioning tract trajectory angle.

RESULTS

In all 25 patients, the center of the actual pallidotomy lesion was within the GP. Without microelectrode refinement, 13 of 25 hypothetical lesion positions would have been localized such that the lesion center would not have remained in the GP. In eight cases, microelectrode refinement resulted in no significant change in lesion location, but in one case, microelectrode refinement resulted in lesion center placement away from the GP.

CONCLUSION

Kinesthetically driven microelectrode refinement in pallidotomy lesioning seems to be required to ensure proper lesion location within the GP.