Contrast/color card procedure: a new test of young infants' color vision

A pseudoisochromatic test of color vision for human infants

Despite the development of experimental methods capable of measuring early human color vision, we still lack a procedure comparable to those used to diagnose the well-identified congenital and acquired color vision anomalies in older children, adults, and clinical patients. In this study, we modified a pseudoisochromatic test to make it more suitable for young infants. Using a forced choice preferential looking procedure, 216 3-to-23-mo-old babies were tested with pseudoisochromatic targets that fell on either a red/green or a blue/yellow dichromatic confusion axis. For comparison, 220 color-normal adults and 22 color-deficient adults were also tested. Results showed that all babies and adults passed the blue/yellow target but many of the younger infants failed the red/green target, likely due to the interaction of the lingering immaturities within the visual system and the small CIE vector distance within the red/green plate. However, older (17-23 mo) infants, color- normal adults and color-defective adults all performed according to expectation. Interestingly, performance on the red/green plate was better among female infants, well exceeding the expected rate of genetic dimorphism between genders. Overall, with some further modification, the test serves as a promising tool for the detection of early color vision anomalies in early human life.

Retest variability of human infant contrast sensitivity: how many tests are sufficient?

Retest variability of a new infant contrast sensitivity (CS) card procedure was assessed by binocular measurement of a group of 20 6-month-olds twice within a 1-week period. Coefficient of reliability analyses showed that within-subject variability between tests was only slightly less than variation across subjects, which suggests that results from a single test are a poor predictor of an infant's "true" visual functioning. To determine how many tests are needed to estimate when infant CS stabilizes to within an acceptable (0.15 log unit) criterion, a second experiment was conducted in which a small group of subjects was tested repeatedly over a 2-week period. The results showed that averaging performance on 2 to 3 tests was required before an accurate estimate of the subject's performance could be obtained. Our results suggest that caution should be taken in the interpretation of a single measurement of infant visual functioning.

Visual completion of partly occluded grating in infants under 1 month of age

Four groups of eight infants (3 weeks of age on average) were each habituated to one of four displays consisting of a grating of either low (0.4 cpd) or high (1.2 cpd) spatial frequency, whose central portion was covered up with a horizontal occluder which was either narrow (1.33 degrees) or broad (4.17 degrees). These habituation displays are referred to as LN (low spatial frequency grating and narrow occluder), LB (low and broad), HN (high and narrow), and HB (high and broad) displays. Posthabituation-test displays consisted of a complete grating (CG) of the same frequency as the habituated grating along with a separate grating (SG) whose central portion was replaced with a black gap of the same height as the occluder in the habituation displays. Infants habituated to the LN display looked significantly longer at the SG than the CG display during posthabituation-test trials. Infants habituated to the LB and HN displays looked at the CG and SG displays, almost equally. In contrast, infants habituated to the HB display looked longer at the CG than the SG display. These results show that infants under 1 month of age can perceive the continuation of the grating behind the occluder, and that their visual completion on habituation displays can be evoked according to the interaction between the spatial frequency of the grating and the occluder height.

Human newborn color vision: measurement with chromatic stimuli varying in excitation purity

Groups of newborn human infants (N = 180) were habituated to large 16 degrees achromatic ("white") lights of varying luminance (0.35 to 1.16 log cd/m2) and then tested for recovery of habituation to 16 degrees green (dominant lambda = 545 nm), yellow (dominant lambda = 585 nm) or red (dominant lambda = 650 nm) lights which varied in the level of excitation purity (range = 32 to 83%). Results showed that newborns discriminated the chromatic stimuli from white only when excitation purity values exceeded at least 41% for 545-nm green, 47% for 650-nm red, and 65% for 585-nm yellow, limits much higher than those for adults (<1%). Taken together with the results from previous experiments, these saturation discrimination data (with the exception of the yellow data), provide some support for an expanded MacAdam ellipse model of early color discrimination (Brown, 1993; Teller & Lindsey, 1993). This helps reinforce the current view that neonates' vision is based on general rather than selective immaturities or inefficiencies within the requisite optical, photoreceptoral and neural mechanisms.

Systematic measurement of human neonatal color vision

We used a new time-efficient method to evaluate chromatic-achromatic discrimination in newborn (n = 36) and 1-month-old (n = 34) human infants. Results showed that 74% of newborns discriminated a 10.5 x 17.5 deg broadband red patch from all relative luminances of an achromatic background, but only 14% of newborns did so with a blue, 36% with a green, and 25% with a yellow patch. Most infants who "failed" did so at relative luminances very close to the respective photopic luminance match. At 1 month, performance improved somewhat although infants still show clear evidence of discriminating only the red patch. These results, the first to be obtained from individual newborns with a method incorporating a systematic variation of luminance, imply that early color vision is very limited. Possible photoreceptoral and neural bases for these immaturities are discussed.