Effect of amniotic fluid volume on neonatal outcome in diamniotic twin pregnancies

Amniotic fluid volume and pregnancy outcomes in twin pregnancies: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Objective

To analyse amniotic fluid volume (AFV), specifically oligohydramnios or polyhydramnios, and associated pregnancy and neonatal outcomes in twin gestations through systematic review and meta-analysis.

Methods

We utilised systematic review methodology to identify items within published and grey literature resources. Prospective and retrospective studies with a control group were included. Inclusion criteria were as follows: studies in English, twin pregnancy in which AFVs and associated pregnancy and/or neonatal outcomes were evaluated. Exclusion criteria included the presence of an anomalous fetus, chromosome abnormality, monochorionic diamniotic twin pregnancy complicated by twin-twin transfusion syndrome or twin-reversed arterial perfusion, twin gestations undergoing therapeutic interventions (i.e. fetoscopic laser photocoagulation and serial amniocentesis) and monochorionic monoamniotic twin pregnancy.

Results

The literature search identified 1068 abstracts, only four met criteria for inclusion and analysis. The pooled data (two studies per outcome) revealed no significant difference in rate of pre-term delivery (OR: 2.94; CI: 0.20-43.81), pre-term delivery less than 32 weeks (OR: 1.97; CI: 0.43-9.12), umbilical cord pH < 7 (OR: 2.66; CI: 0.22-32.51), rate of stillbirth (OR: 4.13; CI: 0.40-42.70), neonatal death (OR: 1.48; CI: 0.05-43.94), rate of NICU admission (OR: 1.38; CI: 0.61-3.11) or rate of small-for-gestational-age (SGA) infants (OR: 1.39; CI: 0.33-5.94).

Conclusion

Based on the pooled data (two studies per outcome), there was no difference in the fate of pre-term delivery, umbilical cord pH < 7, stillbirth, neonatal death or SGA infants. What is disturbing is the lack of studies (1946-2020) that analysed the association between AFV and pregnancy outcomes in twin pregnancies.

A systematic review of amniotic fluid assessments in twin pregnancies

The objectives of this systematic review were to examine the reproducibility of sonographic estimates of amniotic fluid volume (AFV) in twin pregnancies, compare the association of sonographic estimates of AFV with dye-determined AFV, and correlate AFV with antepartum, intrapartum, and perinatal outcomes in twin pregnancies. Studies were included if they were adequately powered and investigated antepartum, intrapartum, and/or perinatal adverse outcome parameters in twin gestations. Studies with comparable populations and exclusion criteria were merged into forest plots. Data comparing the accuracy of AFV assessment, correlation of AFV with gestational age, and adverse outcomes were tabulated. Five of the 6 studies investigating AFV by the amniotic fluid index as a function of gestational age reported data fitting a quadratic equation, with fluid volumes peaking at mid gestation and then declining. This trend was less pronounced when AFV was assessed by the single deepest pocket (2 of 4 studies reporting a quadratic fit). Polyhydramnios was associated with prematurity in 2 of 4 studies (1 amniotic fluid index and 1 single deepest pocket), and oligohydramnios was associated with prematurity in 1 single deepest pocket study. Stillbirth was the only intrapartum outcome reported in more than 1 study. Perinatal outcomes associated with polyhydramnios included neonatal death (P < .05 in 1 of 2 studies), low Apgar scores (1 of 2 studies), neonatal intensive care unit admission (1 of 2 studies), and low birth weight (2 of 3 studies).

Association and prediction of amniotic fluid measurements for adverse pregnancy outcome: systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Measurements of amniotic fluid volume are used for pregnancy surveillance despite a lack of evidence for their predictive ability.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the association and predictive value of ultrasound measurements of amniotic fluid volume for adverse pregnancy outcome.

SEARCH STRATEGY

Electronic databases (inception to October 2011), reference lists, hand searching of journals, contact with experts.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Studies comparing measurements of amniotic fluid volume with adverse outcome, excluding pre-labour ruptured membranes or congenital/structural anomalies.

DATA COLLECTION

Data on study characteristics, design, quality. Random effects meta-analysis to estimate summary odds ratios (prognostic association) and summary sensitivity, specificity and likelihood ratios (predictive ability).

MAIN RESULTS

Forty-three studies (244,493 fetuses) were included demonstrating a strong association between oligohydramnios (varying definitions) and birthweight <10th centile (summary odds ratio [OR] 6.31, 95% confidence interval [95% CI] 4.15-9.58; high-risk population [author definition] n = 6 studies, 28,510 fetuses), and mortality (neonatal death any population summary OR 8.72, 95% CI 2.43-31.26; n = 6 studies, 55,735 fetuses; and perinatal mortality high-risk population summary OR 11.54, 95% CI 4.05-32.9; n = 2 studies, 27;891 fetuses). There was a strong association between polyhydramnios (maximum pool depth >8 cm or amniotic fluid index ≥25 cm) and birthweight >90th centile (OR 11.41, 95% CI 7.09-18.36; n = 1 study, 3960 fetuses). Despite strong associations, predictive accuracy for perinatal outcome was poor.

AUTHOR'S CONCLUSION

Current evidence suggests that oligohydramnios is strongly associated with being small for gestational age and mortality, and polyhydramnios with birthweight >90th centile. Despite strong associations with poor outcome, they do not accurately predict outcome risk for individuals.

The ultrasound estimation of amniotic fluid volume in diamniotic twin pregnancies and prediction of peripartum outcomes

OBJECTIVE

To determine ultrasonic estimations of amniotic fluid in diamniotic twins across gestation using the single deepest pocket (SDP) technique and correlate volumes to intrapartum and neonatal outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective observational study using diamniotic dichorionic and diamniotic monochorionic pregnancies. Intrapartum and neonatal outcomes were evaluated.

RESULTS

Between April 2004 and April 2006, 299 women were recruited. There was no significant relationship between SDP and gestational age. Statistically significant differences by SDP groups (for low, normal, and high volumes) include preterm delivery (P = .043; 56, 62, and 86%), abnormal labor tracing (P = .013; 5, 8, and 27%), fetal labor intolerance (P = .026; 6, 9, and 27%), Apgar scores at 5 minutes (P = .028; 17, 10, and 27%) and any neonatal complications (P = .002; 28, 21, and 55%).

CONCLUSION

The SDP is constant between 17 and 37 weeks. Fetal labor intolerance and adverse neonatal outcomes are greater in a twin with hydramnios.

Dye-determined amniotic fluid volume and intrapartum/neonatal outcome

OBJECTIVE

To ascertain if a dye-determined amniotic fluid volume was predictive of intrapartum and perinatal outcome.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The low and normal amniotic fluid volumes (< 5th percentile and > or =5th percentile for gestational age) and the raw dye-determined amniotic fluid distributions were correlated with 10 clinical outcome measures in 74 pregnancies.

RESULTS

In this observational study, median gestational age at delivery was 36 weeks (range 26 to 41) and 16 deliveries were for fetal distress (14 Cesarean and two forceps). There were no differences between the outcomes of pregnancies with low and normal amniotic fluid volumes for any of the clinical outcomes (variable decelerations influencing delivery, p=0.381; late decelerations, p=0.875; Cesarean births for fetal intolerance of labor, p=0.259; intrauterine growth restriction, p=0.998; or umbilical cord arterial pH< 7.2, p=0.259). Analogous results were obtained when the gestational age-adjusted amniotic fluid volumes were compared directly between the pregnancies with normal and abnormal outcomes. There was no difference between the mean amniotic fluid volumes in those pregnancies with variable decelerations influencing delivery (p=0.287), late decelerations (p=0.555), Cesarean births for fetal intolerance of labor (p=0.310), intrauterine growth restriction (p=0.267) or umbilical cord arterial pH< 7.2, and the pregnancies without these intrapartum events. Reduced variability was more commonly observed in pregnancies with higher amniotic fluid volumes (p=0.038, 771 ml, 95% CI 468 to 1269, compared to those without normal variability 444 ml, 95% CI 374 to 526).

CONCLUSIONS

Dye-determined amniotic fluid volume does not appear to be predictive of adverse intrapartum and neonatal outcome.

Dye-dilution techniques using aminohippurate sodium: do they accurately reflect amniotic fluid volume?

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether the dye-dilution technique using aminohippurate sodium accurately measures amniotic fluid volume.

METHODS

Singleton pregnancies with intact membranes undergoing a Cesarean delivery had their amniotic fluid volume assessed by the dye-dilution technique and direct measurement.

RESULTS

Fifteen women were prospectively assessed. Six patients had their amniocentesis on the delivery table and nine patients at 4-24 h prior to the Cesarean delivery. The six women undergoing an amniocentesis just before delivery had good concordance between the dye-determined and direct measurement of amniotic fluid volume (r = 0.99, p = < 0.001). Among the nine women with varying times from amniocentesis to direct measurement, the correlation was not significant (r = 0.36, p = 0.08). The percentage difference between the dye-determined and directly measured amniotic fluid volume was significantly smaller in the women undergoing amniocentesis just prior to delivery (7%) than in the women with varying times from amniocentesis to delivery (37%, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Dye-determined amniotic fluid volume accurately reflects actual amniotic fluid volume but the dye-determined concentrations, in vivo, may undergo rapid changes.

Amniotic fluid volume assessment in singleton and twin pregnancies

The best method of ultrasonic mensuration to identify abnormal AFV reliably in singletons and the individual sacs of diamniotic twins remains elusive. With respect to twins, localization of the dividing membrane seems to be necessary for AFV assessments of each amniotic cavity. The relationship of ultrasonic estimates, actual AFV, and pregnancy outcome remains undetermined. In the authors' opinion, the subjective assessment in twin gestation may be as accurate as semiquantitative ultrasonic estimates of AFV, similar to the situation in singleton pregnancies. The authors propose that further prospective research address the following questions: (1) What is the appropriate threshold for intervention when AFI decreases to lower ranges? (2) What other factors (e.g., cervical examination, fetal heart rate patterns, underlying obstetric conditions, fetal growth pattern) are important when the AFI falls to low values in making clinical decisions?