Measurement of human lumbar spine ligaments during loaded and unloaded motion

Comparison of lumbar proprioception as measured in unrestrained standing in individuals with disc replacement, with low back pain, and without low back pain

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional laboratory study.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether individuals with spinal pain and those who have undergone spinal surgery have difficulty discriminating small movement differences using a spinal proprioception test for active flexion movements.

BACKGROUND

Structures contributing to proprioception may be affected during disc replacement surgery. Postsurgical assessment of proprioceptive ability to make discriminations in the range used for maintaining upright postural stability is needed to inform postoperative rehabilitation.

METHODS

Proprioceptive sensitivity to differences between lumbar spine movements of 11 degrees, 13 degrees, 15 degrees, 17 degrees, and 19 degrees of forward flexion was measured in unrestrained standing, with vision of the target obscured. Individuals after disc replacement (n=16), with disc degeneration and discogenic back pain (n=19), and without back pain (n=18) performed 50 movement trials and stated the amount of movement performed for each trial (11 degrees, 13 degrees, 15 degrees, 17 degrees, or 19 degrees).

RESULTS

The pattern of discrimination scores between adjacent lumbar flexion movement pairs shown by the individuals in the discogenic back pain group differed significantly from the disc replacement and healthy control groups (P=.024), which were not significantly different from each other. Although mean discrimination scores averaged over all movement pairs did not differ significantly between the groups, participants with discogenic back pain discriminated between the 2 smallest lumbar flexion movements significantly better than those in the other 2 groups (P=.013).

CONCLUSION

The greater sensitivity of the individuals with disc pain to discriminate between the 2 smallest flexion movements was interpreted as a contrast effect arising from differences between the groups in usual upright posture, with disc replacement restoring the same pattern of posture as seen for healthy controls.

Calculation of dynamic spinal ligament deformation

OBJECTIVE

Previous methods to determine spinal ligament deformation have included either custom-designed transducers or computational methods using rigid body transformation of kinematic data. Goals of the present study were to describe a computational methodology to determine dynamic deformations of an arbitrarily oriented ligament in a spine specimen and its associated errors.

METHODS

Calculation of ligament deformation in a spinal segment with vertebral motion tracking flags utilized digital stereophotography, lateral neutral posture radiograph, and detailed quantitative anatomy to develop geometrical relationships between flag markers and ligament attachment points. A custom jig, consisting of two flags each with four markers, was constructed to quantify errors associated with computed ligament deformation, flag marker translation, and flag rotation.

RESULTS

Average error in ligament deformation was dependent upon motion direction and ranged between 0.03 mm (SD 0.45 mm) and 0.28 mm (SD 0.18 mm). Average error for flag marker translation ranged between 0.02 mm (SD 0.14 mm) and 0.11 mm (SD 0.39 mm), and for flag rotation ranged between -0.06 degrees (SD 0.17 degrees ) and 0.07 degrees (SD 0.12 degrees ).

CONCLUSIONS

Accuracy of the present technique was equivalent to or greater than that of previous methods. The present technique utilized relatively cost-effective digital stereophotography, and may be used to calculate strain in ligaments not readily accessible for transducer application. The methodology has wide-spread applicability for analyses of dynamic or static spinal or other ligament strains, and may be used to determine spinal canal and intervertebral foramen narrowing and area reduction.

Biomechanical role of lumbar spine ligaments in flexion and extension: determination using a parallel linkage robot and a porcine model

STUDY DESIGN

Porcine lumbar spine specimens were cyclically loaded in flexion and extension with a pure moment. The resistance to flexion and extension of the individual spinal elements was quantified using a sequential resection procedure.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the biomechanical contribution of the individual posterior spinal ligaments, including the interconnections between the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments, to resisting flexion-extension moments applied to the lumbar spine.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Numerous experimental studies have performed repeated tests with sequential resection to determine the role of spinal ligaments. Most studies have not maintained the kinematics across trials, and therefore these studies have assessed the kinematics and kinetics of injured spines rather than delineating the mechanics of individual ligaments.

METHODS

The L4-L5 motion pathway for pure moment loading (between in 16 Nm of flexion and 12 Nm of extension) of porcine spinal specimens was learned and replayed using a parallel-linkage robot. Each specimen was tested 6 times, with sequential resections performed as follows: intact, cut interconnections between the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments, supraspinous ligament removed, interspinous ligament removed, ligamentum flavum cut, and facet joints removed. The kinematic pathway was repeated for each of these tests, and, accordingly, the changes in loads between trials reflected the mechanics of the cut/removed structures.

RESULTS

The interaction between the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments is a significant contributor to the flexion resistance of the porcine lumbar spine, resisting 10.5% of the peak flexion moment. This contribution is similar to the interspinous ligament (11.3%) and almost as large as the supraspinous ligament (14%) and facet joints (14.2%). The supraspinous/interspinous ligament complex was the largest contributor to the resistance of flexion motion (35.9%), followed by the intervertebral disc (25.2%) and the ligamentum flavum (24.7%). The only structures involved in resisting extension were the facet joint complexes, intervertebral disc, and possibly the spinous processes.

CONCLUSIONS

The supraspinous/interspinous ligament complex is the largest contributor to resisting applied flexion moments in the porcine lumbar spine.

Immunohistochemical analysis of the extracellular matrix in the posterior capsule of the zygapophysial joints in patients with degenerative L4-5 motion segment instability

OBJECT

Although the hypertrophied shape of the zygapophysial joints in degenerative instability of the lumbar spine is well known, its underlying pathophysiological mechanism is unclear. The authors sought to provide evidence that there is increased fibrocartilaginous metaplasia in the posterior joint capsule resulting from greater mechanical loading; the authors suggest that these capsular changes are central to understanding the altered joint shape.

METHODS

The LA-5 posterior articular complex was removed in 14 patients undergoing fusion for degenerative instability. After methanol-assisted fixation, cryosections were immunolabeled for a wide range of extracellular matrix molecules. These were collagens (Types I, II, III, V, and VI), glycosaminoglycans (chondroitin 4 and 6 sulfates; dermatan- and keratan-sulfate), and proteoglycans (versican, tenascin, aggrecan, and its associated link protein). The grade of degeneration of the articular complexes was assessed radiologically and histologically.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study provide molecular evidence for an altered loading history on the joint capsule. The pronounced loss of intervertebral disc height that occurred in all patients with severe degeneration of the lumbar motion segment promotes an increased range of axial rotation that places the posterior capsule under greater mechanical load. Compared with normal joints studied previously, the posterior capsules involved in these degenerative joint complexes were hypertrophied and fibrocartilaginous throughout. Cartilaginous metaplasia was especially pronounced at the attachment sites (entheses) where the fibrocartilage now extended beyond the original level of the joint space, and capped the osseous spurs arising from these attachment sites.

An immunohistochemical study of the dorsal capsule of the lumbar and thoracic facet joints

STUDY DESIGN

The molecular composition of the extracellular matrix in the dorsal capsules of lumbar and thoracic facet joints was analyzed immunohistochemically.

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether the immunohistochemical profile of the lumbar joint capsule suggests a role of the capsule in limiting axial rotation of the lumbar motion segment.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

During axial rotation of the lumbar vertebrae, the axis of rotation shifts toward the facet joints in the direction of rotation. Thus, the capsule of the opposing joint should become tensed and wrap around the inferior articular process. Previous studies suggest that wrap-around ligaments are fibrocartilaginous. However, thoracic joint capsules are largely shielded from such loading and should be purely fibrous.

METHODS

Dorsal capsules were removed from lumbar and thoracic facet joints of six adult cadavers. Specimens were immunolabeled with monoclonal antibodies for collagens, chondroitin, dermatan and keratan sulfates, versican, tenascin, aggrecan and link protein. Antibody binding was detected using the Vectastain ABC 'Elite' peroxidase kit (Vector Laboratories, Inc., Burlingame, CA).

RESULTS

Both lumbar and thoracic joint capsules immunolabelled for most glycosaminoglycans and for Type I, III and VI collagens. However, labeling for Type II collagen, chondroitin-6-sulfate, aggrecan, and link protein was restricted to lumbar capsules. Such labeling was constantly seen at entheses and occasionally in the midsubstance.

CONCLUSIONS

The molecular composition of the lumbar joint capsule suggests that it acts as a fibrocartilaginous, 'wrap-around' ligament that withstands compression in addition to tension during torsional movements of the lumbar spine. It wraps around the inferior articular process as rotation occurs and limits further movement.

Preliminary design and experimental studies of a novel soft implant for correcting sagittal plane instability in the lumbar spine

STUDY DESIGN

A novel soft implant design for resisting the instability of the lumbar spine in the sagittal plane was mechanically tested.

OBJECTIVES

To ascertain whether a soft preformed implant made of differing grades of silicone would contribute to stabilizing the lumbar spine in the sagittal plane.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Methods of stabilizing the lumbar spine in patients who present with chronic low back pain have usually concentrated on rigidly fixing the associated segment. This has many inherent problems with both the surgical methods and the long-term rigidity at and away from the stabilized site. To the authors knowledge, no "soft" interspinous spacer that would allow a certain amount of flexion but still stabilize the movements associated with instability at the level of the lesion has been investigated mechanically as an alternative to rigid fixation or prosthetic replacement.

METHODS

The apparatus was designed to allow a cadaveric lumbar motion segment to be tested in compression at four angles of flexion with loads up to 700 N. The intradiscal pressure and sagittal plane stiffness were recorded during loading, with and without various sizes of the soft silicone implants placed between the spinous processes.

RESULTS

Insertion of the silicone implants between the spinous processes reduced the intradiscal pressure under load at the angles of flexion tested. The size of the interspinous space determines the optimal diameter of the implant that afforded sagittal stability, the load-bearing contribution of the implant, and the prevention of disc space narrowing at the level investigated.

CONCLUSIONS

A circular silicone spacer placed between the spinous processes appears to contribute to the stability of the cadaveric lumbar spine. There are many attractions to using a simple, soft implant that can be placed with minimal surgery between the spinous processes.

Spinal ligament transducer based on a hall effect sensor

A spinal ligament transducer (SLT) was developed to measure in situ spinal ligament elongation during the simulation of whiplash trauma with a cadaveric spine specimen. The SLT was designed to be affixed to two K-wires drilled into the bone at the approximate points of ligament origin and insertion. The transducer is low cost and is capable of measuring the linear distance between the K-wires in the range 4-12 mm with the root mean square (RMS) accuracy of 0.025 mm.

Structure on the capsular ligaments of the facet joints

Microscopic studies showed that the capsular ligaments were mostly composed of collagenous tissue. The collagen fiber bundles were found to be crimped at right angles to their long axis. The collagen fibrils were connected transversely by proteoglycan filaments which were regularly associated with their periodicity. Among the collagen fiber bundles were varying quantities of elastic fibers and numerous fibroblasts. The highest concentration of elastic fibers was found in the posterior and inferior aspects of the capsular ligaments. These findings are discussed in relation to the mechanical behavior of the capsular ligaments.

Development of a computer model to predict strains in the individual fibers of a ligament across the ligamentous occipito-atlanto-axial (C0-C1-C2) complex

A fresh ligamentous occipito-atlanto-axial (C0-C1-C2) complex was appropriately prepared and serially sectioned into thin slices along the transverse planes. The bony outlines from these slices were digitized and assembled in the proper manner to obtain a three-dimensional model of the complex using the AutoCAD system. Various ligaments were identified on the model and strains in individual fibers of a ligament were predicted based on the principles of rigid body mechanics. The ligament behaviors in axial rotation, flexion, and extension modes were analyzed. The capsular ligament fibers were predicted to undergo strains in all modes. Furthermore, these ligaments experienced the largest strain among the ligaments analyzed. Fibers within a ligament were found to respond differently; some were more active than the others and some did not experience any strain at all. A differential behavior in the right and left side alar ligament fibers was also found in axial rotation. The transverse ligament was predicted to wrap around the dens during axial rotation. The strain within a fiber was found to be a function of the initial length (ligament laxity) and its distance from the center of rotation.