The role of bone graft force in stabilizing the multilevel anterior cervical spine plate system

Cadaveric biomechanical studies of ADDISC total lumbar disc prosthesis

BACKGROUND

Most total disc replacements provide excessive mobility and not reproduce spinal kinematics, inducing zygapophyseal joint arthritic changes and chronic back pain. In cadaveric lumbosacral spines, we studied if a new lumbar disc prosthesis kinematics mimics the intact intervertebral disc.

METHODS

In eight cold preserved cadaveric lumbosacral spines, we registered the movement ranges in flexion, extension, right and left lateral bending, and rotation in the intact status, post-discectomy, and after our prosthesis implantation, comparing them for each specimen.

FINDINGS

Comparing the intact lumbosacral spine with the L4-L5 prosthesis implanted specimens, we saw statistically significant differences in lateral bending and right rotation but not in the full range of rotation. Analyzing segments, we also noticed statistically significant differences at L4-L5 in flexion-extension and rotation. On the other hand, the L4-L5 discectomy, compared to the baseline spine condition, showed a statistically significant mobility increase in flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation, with an abnormal instantaneous center of rotation, which destabilizes the segment partly due to anterior annulus surgical removal. Disc prosthesis implantation reversed these changes in instantaneous center of rotation, but the prosthesis failed to restore the initial range of motion due to the destabilization of the ligaments in the operated disc.

INTERPRETATION

The ADDISC total disc replacement reproduces the intact disc kinematics and Instantaneous Center of Rotation, but the prosthesis fails to restore the initial range of motion due to ligament destabilization. More studies will be necessary to define a technique that restores the damaged ligaments when implanting the prosthesis.

Cervical non-fusion using biomimetic artificial disc and vertebra complex: technical innovation and biomechanics analysis

Background

Changes in spinal mobility after vertebral fusion are important factors contributing to adjacent vertebral disease (ASD). As an implant for spinal non-fusion, the motion-preserving prosthesis is an effective method to reduce the incidence of ASD, but its deficiencies hamper the application in clinical. This study designs a novel motion-preserving artificial cervical disc and vertebra complex with an anti-dislocation mechanism (MACDVC-AM) and verifies its effect on the cervical spine.

Methods

The MACDVC-AM was designed on the data of healthy volunteers. The finite element intact model, fusion model, and MACDVC-AM model were constructed, and the range of motion (ROM) and stress of adjacent discs were compared. The biomechanical tests were performed on fifteen cervical specimens, and the stability index ROM (SI-ROM) were calculated.

Results

Compared with the intervertebral ROMs of the intact model, the MACDVC-AM model reduced by 28–70% in adjacent segments and increased by 26–54% in operated segments, but the fusion model showed the opposite result. In contrast to the fusion model, the MACDVC-AM model diminished the stress of adjacent intervertebral discs. In biomechanical tests, the MACDVC-AM group showed no significant difference with the ROMs of the intact group (p > 0.05). The SI-ROM of the MACDVC-AM group is negative but close to zero and showed no significant difference with the intact group (p > 0.05).

Conclusions

The MACDVC-AM was successfully designed. The results indicate that the MACDVC-AM can provide physiological mobility and stability, reduce adjacent intervertebral compensatory motion, and alleviate the stress change of adjacent discs, which contributes to protect adjacent discs and reduce the occurrence of ASD.

Drynaria fortunei J. Sm. improves the bone mass of ovariectomized rats through osteocalcin-involved endochondral ossification

AIM OF THIS STUDY

Our previous study showed that Drynaria fortunei J. Sm. (Kunze), a traditional Chinese medical herb, can promote osteoblast differentiation and maturation. This study was further aimed to confirm the traditional effects of Kunze on the bone mass of ovariectomized rats.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Female Wistar rats were given an ovariectomy and then administered the water extract of Kunze (WEK). Systemic and tissue toxicities of WEK were assessed. A biomechanical test, bone mineral contents, and bone histomorphometry were analyzed to determine the effects of the WEK on the bone mass. Levels of osteocalcin (OCN) in bone tissues were determined by immunohistochemistry and immunoblotting. The effects of naringin, one of the bioactive compounds of the WEK, on the bone mass were evaluated.

RESULTS

A bilateral ovariectomy in rats caused a time-dependent decrease in levels of serum 17β-estradiol. Exposure of ovariectomized rats to the WEK at 0.5 and 1g/kg body weight/day for 1, 2, 3, and 6 months did not induce systemic or tissue toxicities. Biomechanical testing and a bone mineral content analysis showed that the ovariectomy decreased the bone torsion force and bone ash in time-dependent manners. In comparison, after exposure to the WEK, the ovariectomy-induced reductions in the bone torsion force and bone ash were significantly alleviated. In parallel, results of a bone histomorphometric assay further revealed that the ovariectomy caused significant diminution in the production of prehypertrophic chondrocytes and trabecular bone but enhanced hypertrophic chondrocyte numbers in the growth plate. However, exposure to the WEK lowered ovariectomy-induced changes in these cellular events. As to the mechanism, the WEK increased OCN biosynthesis in bone tissues of ovariectomized rats. Administration of naringin to ovariectomized rats caused significant amelioration of the bone strength, bone mineral contents, and trabecular bone amounts.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that the WEK can translationally promote the bone mass in ovariectomized rats through stimulating OCN-involved endochondral ossification.

Biomechanical effect of 4-rod technique on lumbosacral fixation: an in vitro human cadaveric investigation

STUDY DESIGN

An in vitro biomechanical study of 3 lumbosacral fixation techniques in human cadaveric lumbar-pelvic spine models.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the in vitro biomechanical effect of a novel 4-rod lumbosacral reconstruction technique with conventional techniques in a human cadaveric lumbopelvic model, and to evaluate the benefit of adding supplementary rod fixation.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Spinopelvic fixation involving the sacrum remains a difficult clinical challenge. Numerous lumbopelvic reconstruction methods based on the Galveston 2-rod technique have been proposed. Recently, a novel technique using supporting longitudinal rods across the lumbopelvic junction was reported. However, no comparative in vitro biomechanical testing was performed to evaluate the benefit of adding supplementary fixation at the L5-S1 levels.

METHODS

Seven fresh-frozen cadaveric lumbar-pelvic spines were prepared and tested for bone mineral density. The intact cadavers underwent a flexibility test, followed by insertion of the instrumented construct. Three constructs were tested: S1 screws alone (group 1), S1 screws plus iliac screws (group 2), and the 4-rod technique (group 3). Rotational angles of the L1-S1 and L5-S1 segments were measured to study the stability of the 3 lumbosacral fixation constructs compared with the intact spine. Nondestructive, multidirectional flexibility tests that included 4 loading methods followed by a destructive flexural load to failure were performed using an material testing machine. The lumbosacral peak range of motion (ROM) (millimeters or degrees) and ultimate failure load (Nm) of the 3 reconstruction techniques were statistically compared using a 1-way analysis of variance combined with a Student-Newman-Keuls post hoc test.

RESULTS

The average bone mineral density of the 7 specimens was 0.81 ± 0.09 g/cm. The ROM of the 3 fixation constructs was significantly smaller than that of the intact group in all 6 directions (P < 0.05). In lateral bending, the ROM of groups 2 and 3 was significantly smaller than that of group 1 (P < 0.05), but groups 2 and 3 were not significantly different from each other (P > 0.05). In flexion-extension, the ROM of groups 1 and 3 was significantly smaller than group 2 (P < 0.05), but groups 1 and 3 were not significantly different from each other (P > 0.05). In axial rotation, the ROM of group 3 was significantly smaller than those of groups 1 and 2 (P < 0.05), but groups 1 and 2 were not significantly different from each other (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The 4-rod technique achieved stable biomechanical effects in lumbosacral fixation. At the L5-S1 junction, the 4-rod technique demonstrated better stability than the constructs using S1 screws or S1 screws plus iliac screws..

Implications of the center of rotation concept for the reconstruction of anterior column lordosis and axial preloads in spinal deformity surgery

OBJECT

In thoracolumbar deformity surgery, anterior-only approaches are used for reconstruction of anterior column failures. It is generally advised that vertebral body replacements (VBRs) should be preloaded by compression. However, little is known regarding the impact of different techniques for generation of preloads and which surgical principle is best for restoration of lordosis. Therefore, the authors analyzed the effect of different surgical techniques to restore spinal alignment and lordosis as well as the ability to generate axial preloads on VBRs in anterior column reconstructions.

METHODS

The authors performed a laboratory study using 7 fresh-frozen specimens (from T-3 to S-1) to assess the ability for lordosis reconstruction of 5 techniques and their potential for increasing preloads on a modified distractable VBR in a 1-level thoracolumbar corpectomy. The testing protocol was as follows: 1) Radiographs of specimens were obtained. 2) A 1-level corpectomy was performed. 3) In alternating order, lordosis was applied using 1 of the 5 techniques. Then, preloads during insertion and after relaxation using the modified distractable VBR were assessed using a miniature load-cell incorporated in the modified distractable VBR. The modified distractable VBR was inserted into the corpectomy defect after lordosis was applied using 1) a lamina spreader; 2) the modified distractable VBR only; 3) the ArcoFix System (an angular stable plate system enabling in situ reduction); 4) a lordosizer (a customized instrument enabling reduction while replicating the intervertebral center of rotation [COR] according to the COR method); and 5) a lordosizer and top-loading screws ([LZ+TLS], distraction with the lordosizer applied on a 5.5-mm rod linked to 2 top-loading pedicle screws inserted laterally into the vertebra). Changes in the regional kyphosis angle were assessed radiographically using the Cobb method.

RESULTS

The bone mineral density of specimens was 0.72 ± 22.6 g/cm(2). The maximum regional kyphosis angle reconstructed among the 5 techniques averaged 9.7°-16.1°, and maximum axial preloads averaged 123.7-179.7 N. Concerning correction, in decreasing order the LZ+TLS, lordosizer, and ArcoFix System outperformed the lamina spreader and modified distractable VBR. The order of median values for insertion peak load, from highest to lowest, were lordosizer, LZ+TLS, and ArcoFix, which outperformed the lamina spreader and modified distractable VBR. In decreasing order, the axial preload was highest with the lordosizer and LZ+TLS, which both outperformed the lamina spreader and the modified distractable VBR. The technique enabling the greatest lordosis achieved the highest preloads. With the ArcoFix System and LZ+TLS, compression loads could be applied and were 247.8 and 190.6 N, respectively, which is significantly higher than the insertion peak load and axial preload (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Including the ability for replication of the COR in instruments designed for anterior column reconstructions, the ability for lordosis restoration of the anterior column and axial preloads can increase, which in turn might foster fusion.

Corpectomy versus discectomy for the treatment of multilevel cervical spine pathology: a finite element model analysis

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

After multilevel fusions, construct failure because of pseudoarthrosis and instrumentation complications is a well-recognized clinical problem. Little is known about the biomechanics governing the cervical spine after different anterior reconstruction techniques, specifically the number of bone grafts and screws used and whether discectomies versus corpectomies have been performed. A few research groups have compared the efficacy of corpectomy and discectomy procedures under common testing conditions; however, no quantitative stress measurements at graft-end plate and bone-screw interfaces have been reported to date.

PURPOSE

To test the hypothesis that increasing the number of bone grafts and screws would yield a more stable construct and decrease the stresses at the graft-end plate and bone-screw interfaces.

STUDY DESIGN

Stability of fusion constructs with three different multilevel reconstruction techniques.

METHODS

A previously validated C3-T1 intact finite element model was modified to evaluate three different anterior C4-C7 fusion models: a two-level corpectomy alone (one graft and four screws), a corpectomy-discectomy (two grafts and six screws), and a three-level discectomy alone (three grafts and eight screws). Two unicortical screws were placed parallel to the corresponding end plates inside the vertebral bodies-C4 and C7 for the corpectomy alone; C4, C6, and C7 for the corpectomy-discectomy; and C4, C5, C6, and C7 for the discectomy alone. Range of motion, graft stresses, end plate stresses, and bone-screw stresses were evaluated.

RESULTS

Although total construct motion decreased with an increasing number of bone grafts and screws, this was not significantly different between reconstruction techniques. Stresses in the bone grafts, end plates, and bone near screws decreased as a result of increasing the number of bone grafts and screws, thereby confirming the present study hypothesis.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the chances of pseudarthrosis have been shown to be lower after multilevel cervical corpectomy versus discectomy, because of fewer bone-graft interfaces required for healing, this benefit should be weighed against the higher bone-screw stresses, operating time, blood loss, and costs associated with corpectomy. Future biomechanical studies focusing on corpectomy and discectomy procedures in similar testing protocols are warranted to compare the findings presented here.

Anterior cervical interbody constructs: effect of a repetitive compressive force on the endplate

Graft subsidence following anterior cervical reconstruction can result in the loss of sagittal balance and recurring foraminal stenosis. This study examined the implant-endplate interface using a cyclic fatigue loading protocol in an attempt to model the subsidence seen in vivo. The superior endplate from 30 cervical vertebrae (C3 to T1) were harvested and biomechanically tested in axial compression with one of three implants: Fibular allograft; titanium mesh cage packed with cancellous chips; and trabecular metal. Each construct was cyclically loaded from 50 to 250 N for 10,000 cycles. Nondestructive cyclic loading of the cervical endplate-implant construct resulted in a stiffer construct independent of the type of the interbody implant tested. The trabecular metal construct demonstrated significantly more axial stability and significantly less subsidence in comparison to the titanium mesh construct. Although the allograft construct resulted in more subsidence than the trabecular metal construct, the difference was not significant and no difference was found when comparing axial stability. For all constructs, the majority of the subsidence during the cyclic testing occurred during the first 500 cycles and was followed by a more gradual settling in the remaining 9,500 cycles.

Challenges to bone formation in spinal fusion

Spinal arthrodesis continues to expand in clinical indications and surgical practice. Despite a century of study, failure of bone formation or pseudarthrosis can occur in individual patients with debilitating clinical symptoms. Here we review biological and technical aspects of spinal fusion under active investigation, describe relevant biomechanics in health and disease, and identify the possibilities and limitations of translational animal models. The purpose of this article is to foster collaborative efforts with researchers who model bone hierarchy. The induction of heterotopic osteosynthesis requires a complex balance of biologic factors and operative technique to achieve successful fusion. Anatomical considerations of each spinal region including blood supply, osteology, and biomechanics predispose a fusion site to robust or insufficient bone formation. Careful preparation of the fusion site and appropriate selection of graft materials remains critical but is sometimes guided by conflicting evidence from the long-bone literature. Modern techniques of graft site preparation and instrumentation have evolved for every segment of the vertebral column. Despite validated biomechanical studies of modern instrumentation, a correlation with superior clinical outcomes is difficult to demonstrate. In many cases, adjuvant biologic therapies with allograft and synthetic cages have been used successfully to reproduce the enhancement of fusion rates observed with cancellous and tricortical autograft. Current areas of investigation comprise materials science, stem cell therapies, recombinant growth factors, scaffolds and biologic delivery systems, and minimally invasive surgical techniques to optimize the biologic response to intervention. Diverse animal models are required to approach the breadth of spinal pathology and novel therapeutics.

Evaluation of arthrodesis and cervical alignment in the surgical results of cervical discectomy using polymethylmetacrylate

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Surgical treatment of cervical radiculopathy with or without myelopathy is a controversy issue, although anterior discectomy is the most common form of treatment.

METHOD

We present the evaluation of the arthrodesis' rate and cervical alignment in 48 patients with cervical degenerative disease (CDD) submitted to anterior cervical discectomy with interposition of polymethylmetacrylate (PMMA). Odom and Nürick scales were used to evaluation of functional status before and after surgery. Cervical spine X-rays were used to access arthrodesis and alignment, at least 2 years after the procedure.

RESULTS

Excellent and good results (Odom I and II) were obtained in 91% of the patients with radiculopathy and in 69% of those with myelopathy. Using the chi square test of independence (1% of significance), there was no association between excellent and good clinical results with the presence of arthrodesis verified in cervical X-rays. The presence of cervical alignment had association with good results, whereas the misalignment was associated with unfavorable outcomes. Two patients died: one cervical hematoma and other from graft migration with cord compression.

CONCLUSIONS

Cervical alignment was more important than fusion to achieve good surgical results in CDD.

“Skip” corpectomy in the treatment of multilevel cervical spondylotic myelopathy and ossified posterior longitudinal ligament

Object

The authors reviewed the results of “skip” corpectomy in 29 patients with multilevel cervical spondylotic myelopathy (CSM) and ossified posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL).

Methods

The skip corpectomy technique, which is characterized by C-4 and C-6 corpectomy, C-5 osteophytectomy, and C-5 vertebral body preservation, was used for decompression in patients with multilevel CSM and OPLL. All patients underwent spinal fixation using C4–5 and C5–6 grafts, and anterior cervical plates were fixated at C-3, C-5, and C-7.

Results

The mean preoperative Japanese Orthopaedic Association score increased from 13.44 ± 2.81 to 16.16 ± 2.19 after surgery (p < 0.05). The cervical lordosis improved from 1.16 ± 11.74° to 14.36 ± 7.85° after surgery (p < 0.05). The complications included temporary hoarseness in 3 cases, dysphagia in 1 case, C-5 nerve palsy in 1 case, and C-7 screw pullout in 1 case. The mean follow-up was 23.2 months. The final plain radiographs showed improved cervical lordosis and fusion in all cases.

Conclusions

The authors conclude that the preservation of the C-5 vertebral body provided an additional screw purchase and strengthened the construct. The results of the current study demonstrated effectiveness and safety of the skip corpectomy in patients with multilevel CSM and OPLL.

Comparative biomechanical study of cervical spine stabilisation by cage alone, cage with plate, or plate-cage: a porcine model

PURPOSE

To compare stability and subsidence associated with 3 types of cervical spine stabilisation.

METHODS

The C3 to C4 vertebrae of 28 Polish pigs were used. Pigs with intact vertebrae (group 1) underwent standard anterior cervical discectomy (group 2), followed by stabilisation using a cage alone (group 3), a cage with plate (group 4), or a plate-cage (group 5). Cervical spine stability and subsidence were compared in all 5 groups.

RESULTS

Stability was significantly increased after stabilisation by a cage with plate or a plate-cage, but not by a cage alone. The difference between stabilisation by a cage with plate and a plate-cage was not significant. Subsidence was maximal after the cage-alone stabilisation (3.1 mm), being 1.6 mm after the cage-with-plate and plate-cage stabilisations.

CONCLUSION

Additional plating as a supplement to anterior interbody cervical cage stabilisation significantly improves segmental stability and subsidence.

A preliminary biomechanical evaluation in a simulated spinal fusion model

Object

A preliminary in vitro biomechanical study was conducted to determine if the pressure at a bone graft–mortise interface and the load transmitted along a ventral cervical plate could be used as parameters to assess fusion status.

Methods

An interbody bone graft and a ventral plate were placed at the C3–4 motion segment in six fresh cadaveric goat spines. Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) was used to simulate early bone fusion at the bone graft site. The loads along the plate and the simultaneous pressures induced at the graft–endplate interfaces were monitored during simulated stages of bone healing. Each specimen was nondestructively tested in compression loading while the pressures and loads at the graft site were recorded continuously. Each specimen was tested under five conditions (Disc, Graft, Plate, PMMA, and Removal).

Results

The pressure at the interface of the bone graft and vertebral endplate did not change significantly with the addition of the ventral plate. The interface pressure and segmental stiffness did increase following PMMA augmentation of the bone graft (simulating an intermediate phase of bone fusion). The load transmitted along the ventral plate in compression increased after the addition of the bone graft, but decreased after PMMA augmentation. Thus, there was an increase in pressure at the graft–endplate interface and a decrease in load transferred along the ventral plate after the simulation of bone fusion. Upon removal of the ventral plate, the simulated fusion bore most of the axial load, thus explaining a further increase in graft site pressure.

Conclusions

These observations support the notions of load sharing and the redistribution of loads occurring during and after bone graft incorporation. In the clinical setting, these parameters may be useful in the assessment of fusion after spine surgery. Although feasibility has been demonstrated in this preliminary study, further research is needed.

Biomechanical study of anterior cervical corpectomy and step-cut grafting with bioabsorbable screws fixation in cadaveric cervical spine model

STUDY DESIGN

An in vitro biomechanical study.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the initial stability of a novel construct in a 1-level cadaveric cervical spine model by comparing it with a conventional method.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Lots of endeavors have been made to enhance fusion rates and reduce complications in the anterior cervical spine procedure.

METHODS

There were 12 fresh human cadaveric cervical spines (C3-C7) randomly divided into 2 groups: group 1, 1-level corpectomy of C5 and step-cut grafting with bioabsorbable screw fixation (SCAS); and group 2, 1-level corpectomy of C5 and strut grafting with anterior plate fixation (SP). For each specimen, the intact underwent a flexibility test first, followed by the instrumented construct. Rotational angles of the C4-C6 segment were measured to study the immediate stability of anterior cervical corpectomy and SCAS, compared with the intact and anterior cervical corpectomy and SP.

RESULTS

Both anterior cervical corpectomy with SCAS and with SP significantly (P < 0.01) decreased the motions of C4-C6 in all 6 degrees of freedom after instrumentation. Compared with anterior cervical corpectomy and SP, anterior cervical corpectomy and SCAS had higher stability (P < 0.05) in extension, and comparable stability (P > 0.05) in flexion and axial rotation, but lower stability (P <or= 0.05) in lateral bending.

CONCLUSION

Anterior cervical corpectomy and SCAS, a novel method of anterior cervical spine decompression and reconstruction, was introduced. The in vitro biomechanical study showed that anterior cervical corpectomy and SCAS had sufficient immediate stability except for the lateral bending, compared with anterior cervical corpectomy and SP, in a 1-level cadaveric cervical spine model. However, an animal experimental in vivo evaluation of anterior cervical corpectomy and SCAS still has to be performed.

Successful outcome of six-level cervicothoracic corpectomy and circumferential reconstruction: case report and review of literature on multilevel cervicothoracic corpectomy

The authors report the successful outcome of a six-level corpectomy across the cervico-thoracic spine with circumferential reconstruction in a patient with extensive osteomyelitis of the cervical and upper thoracic spine. To the authors’ knowledge, this is the first report of a corpectomy extending across six levels of the cervico-thoracic spine. Clinical relevance: the authors recommend anterior cage and plate-assisted reconstruction and additional posterior instrumentation using modern spinal surgical techniques and implants.

Maintenance of graft compression in the adult cervical spine

It is generally advised that the graft inserted in adult cervical spine should be pre-loaded with a compressive force or that the screws are inserted in a divergent orientation, in order to maximise compression and the chance of graft incorporation (Truumees et al. in Spine 28:1097-1102, 2003). However, there is little evidence that a compressive force is maintained once the force applicator has been removed, or that the divergent screws enhance compression. This study compared the maintenance of applied pre-load force, across cervical spine graft, between standard anterior plating technique with pre-load and divergent screws and a novel plate technique, which allows its application prior to removal of the force applicator. Six intact adult cadaveric human cervical spines were exposed by standard surgical technique. A Casper type distracter was inserted across the disc space of interest, the disc was removed. In 14 experiments, following the disc removal, an autologous iliac crest bone graft was inserted under distraction, together with a strain gauge pressure transducer. A resting output from the transducer was recorded. The voltage output has a linear relationship with compressive force. A standardised compressive force was applied across the graft through the "Casper type" distracter/compressor (7.5 kg, torque). The pre-load compressive force was measured using a torque drill. Then two different procedures were used in order to compare the final applied strain on the bone graft. In eight experiments (procedure 1), the "Casper type" distracter/compressor was removed and a standard anterior cervical plate with four divergent screws was inserted. In six experiments (procedure 2), a novel plate design was inserted prior to removal of the distracter/compressor, which is not possible with the standard plate design. A final compressive force across the graft was measured. For the standard plate construct (procedure 1), the applied compression force is significantly greater than resting (SO/SC)--P=0.01, but the compression force is not maintained once the compressor is removed (SO/SR)--P=0.27. Final bone graft compression after plate insertion is not significantly different to the resting state (SO/SF)--P=0.16 (Wilcoxon's sign test for paired observation). Application of the plate tended to offload the graft; the final compressive force is 170+/-100% less than the resting force. None of the applied force was maintained (mean 9.5+/-8.8%). For the new plate (procedure 2), the end compressive force (SF) measured across the graft was greater than the resting force (SO) (P<0.001). Further, the novel plate application increased the compressive force on the graft by 712+/-484%. The final bone graft compression using a novel plate, which allows its application prior to removal of the force applicator, is significant (SO/SF)--P=0.01. Here, 77+/-10% of the applied pre-load was maintained. The difference between the plates is significant (P<0.001). Conclusions are as follows: (1) Applied pre-load is not maintained across a graft once the force applicator is removed. (2) Divergent screws with a plate do not compress graft and rather tend to offload it. (3) Compressive force may be maintained if the plate is applied prior to the force applicator removal.

Cortical margining capabilities of fins associated with ventral cervical spine instrumentation

Fins incorporated into the design of a dynamic cervical spine implant have been employed to enhance axial load- bearing ability, yet their true biomechanical advantages, if any, have not been defined. Therefore, the goal of this study was to assess the biomechanical and axial load-bearing contributions of the fin components of the DOC ventral cervical stabilization system. Eighteen fresh cadaveric thoracic vertebrae (T1-T3) were obtained. Three test conditions were devised and studied: Condition A (DOC implants with fins were placed against the superior endplate and bone screws were not inserted); Condition B (DOC implant without fins was placed and bone screws were inserted); and Condition C (DOC implant with fins were placed against the superior endplate and bone screws were inserted). Specimens were tested by applying a pure axial compressive load to the superior platform of the DOC construct, and load-displacement data were collected. Condition C specimens had the greatest stiffness (459 +/- 80 N/mm) and yield load (526 +/- 168 N). Condition A specimens were the least stiff (266 +/- 53 N/mm), and had the smallest yield loads (180 +/- 54 N). The yield load of condition A plus condition B was approximately equal to that of condition C, with condition A contributing about one-third and condition B contributing two-thirds of the overall load-bearing capacity. Although the screws alone contributed to a substantial portion of axial load-bearing ability, the addition of the fins further increased load-bearing capabilities.

Limitations of the cervical porcine spine in evaluating spinal implants in comparison with human cervical spinal segments: a biomechanical in vitro comparison of porcine and human cervical spine specimens with different instrumentation techniques

STUDY DESIGN

Porcine and human cervical spine specimens were in vitro biomechanically compared with different instrumentation techniques.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate whether subaxial porcine cervical spines are a valid model for implant testing in a single level corpectomy.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Biomechanical in vitro tests are widely used for implant tests, mainly with human spine specimens. The availability of human cadavers is limited and the properties of the specimen regarding age, bone mineral density, and grade of degenerative changes is inhomogeneous.

METHODS

Six porcine and six human cervical specimens were loaded nondestructively with pure moments: 1) in an intact state; 2) after a corpectomy of C5 and substitution by a cage with integrated force sensor; 3) after additional instrumentation with a posterior screw and rod system with: a) lateral mass and b) pedicle screws; 4) after instrumentation with an anterior plate; and 5) with a circumferential instrumentation. The unconstrained motion and the axial loads occurring in the corpectomy gap were measured, as well as the bone mineral density of the specimen before testing.

RESULTS

The range of motion in the intact state, as well as for the different instrumentations, was comparable for flexion-extension. In lateral bending and axial rotation, marked differences in the intact state as well as for pedicle screw instrumentations occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

The subaxial porcine cervical spine is a potential model in flexion-extension because of its biomechanical similarity. For lateral bending and axial rotation, the marked differences severly restrict the comparability.

Results of surgical treatment for degenerative cervical myelopathy: anterior cervical corpectomy and stabilization

STUDY DESIGN

This retrospective study involves 26 patients with degenerative cervical myelopathy who were surgically treated by anterior corpectomy, titanium mesh cage (TMC) filled with autogenous bone, and anterior plate +/- posterolateral plate and fusion.

OBJECTIVES

This study was conducted to determine the indications, efficacy, and complication rate associated with performing corpectomy to achieve anterior decompression of neural elements or for removing anterior lesions.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

This retrospective study involves patients with degenerative cervical myelopathy who were surgically treated by > or =2-level anterior corpectomy, TMC filled with autogenous bone, and anterior plate +/- posterolateral plate and fusion. The purpose was to evaluate and compare the results in terms of neurologic recovery and function and effectivity of TMC as a structural support.

METHODS

Twenty-six patients with degenerative cervical myelopathy who had surgical treatment and average 30 months (range, 24-52 months) follow up were included. The mean age was 64.9 years (range, 55-74 years) and average period between myelopathic symptoms and surgery was 2.8 years (range, 6 months-5 years). Preoperative evaluation of every patient consisted of anterior-posterior, lateral, bilateral oblique, flexion, and extension radiographs, computed tomography reconstructions and magnetic resonance imaging of the cervical spine, Doppler ultrasound of the carotid arteries, vertebral artery magnetic resonance angiography, neurologic examination, and electromyography. Degree of pre- and postoperative myelopathy was determined according to the scoring systems developed by Nurick and Japanese Orthopedic Association (JOA). Twelve patients had a mild balance problem and difficulty while walking but were able to perform their daily activities. Fourteen patients had spastic quadriparesis ambulating on either crutches or with wheelchairs. Of these, 11 experienced bladder disturbance as well. Surgical treatment in 18 patients consisted of anterior decompressive corpectomy, structural TMC, and anterior plate stabilization in 14 patients who had 2-level corpectomy. Posterior plate stabilization without laminectomy was added to this procedure in another 4 patients who had 3- or more level corpectomy. The remaining 8 patients had first laminectomy and posterolateral plate, then anterior corpectomy, TMC, and anterior plate on the same stage. Corpectomy levels were between C3 and T1, and anterior corpectomy, structural TMC, and anterior plating was the procedure that all patients had in common.

RESULTS

Mean sagittal Cobb angle (C2-C7) was 9 degrees (range, 0-23 degrees) before surgery, 17.1 degrees (range, 11-22 degrees) on the third postoperative month, and 16.9 degrees (range, 10-22 degrees) at last follow-up. The difference in sagittal alignment on the third month and last follow up was not statistically significant (P > 0.05). Average preoperative Nurick score was 3.5 (range, 2-5) and JOA score was 7 (range, 1-14). Major and statistically significant neurologic recovery was within the first 3 months, and average Nurick and JOA scores at 3 months were 2 (range, 0-3) and 11 (range, 8-17) (P < 0.001), respectively. All patients had improved neurologic status at final follow up. As confirmed by plain radiographs and computed tomography reconstructions, solid fusion was achieved across the TMC with no settling or migration, and we had no implant-related complication or failure. As major complications, 1 (3.8%) early deep posterior infection developed but responded to early debridement and antibiotics. Also, 3 patients (11.5%) had transient C5 nerve root injury. At final follow up, all patients were able to ambulate without support and maintain their daily activities.

CONCLUSIONS

Anterior decompression provides good neurologic recovery in patients with degenerative cervical myelopathy. TMC provides good structural support, and solid fusion can be achieved with TMC and anterior plate (for < or =2-level corpectomy) and/or posterior plate (> or =3-level corpectomy). There is increased risk of C5 nerve root injury when first laminectomy and posterolateral plate stabilization are performed.

Treatment of multilevel cervical fusion with cages

BACKGROUND

Multilevel cervical discectomy usually requires plate and screw fixation for maintaining the spinal curvature, and increasing the graft fusion rate. However, the use of plate and screw fixation may cause a few complications, such as screw breakage, screw pullout, esophagus perforation, and cord or nerve root injury. In this study, we try to use cages to replace plate function in multilevel cervical fusion.

METHODS

From January 1997 to June 2001, there were 180 consecutive cases of multilevel cervical degenerative disease. We randomized them into three groups: Group A (60 patients) underwent anterior discectomy and polyetheretherketone (PEEK) fusion, Group B (50 patients) underwent anterior discectomy, autogenous iliac crest graft (AICG) fusion and plate fixation, and Group C (70 patients) underwent anterior discectomy and AICG only. X-ray of cervical spine was taken every 3 months until fusion was complete. Spinal curvature was measured by lateral view of X-ray. The functional and working status were evaluated by Prolo scale. Blood loss and operation time were recorded, respectively.

RESULTS

The total complication rates were 3.3%, 16%, and 54.3% in Groups A, B, and C respectively. The graft complications were evaluated by radiographic findings (graft collapse, nonunion, or dislodged graft). However, only 37.1% of patients (13/35) with graft complications had clinical symptoms (severe neck pain, radicular pain, or neurologic deficits). The fusion rate was better, and the time to fusion was sooner in Groups A and B than Group C, p < 0.001 (chi(2) test). PEEK cage is statistically better than plating group in total complications, p < 0.05. Graft collapse and nonunion were the major graft complications in Group C (AICG without plating). Screw pullout, and screw breakage were the main causes of plating complication. Blood loss was minimum in Group A, p < 0.05. Spinal lordosis increased by a mean of 4.61 +/- 2.93 mm and 1.68 +/- 5.02 mm in Groups A and B, respectively, but spinal kyphosis increased by a mean of -2.09 +/- 4.77 mm in Group C. Group A had a statistically better Prolo scale than Group C, p < 0.0001.

CONCLUSIONS

Both PEEK cage without plating and AICG with plating are good methods for interbody fusion in multilevel cervical degenerative diseases. They increase spinal lordosis and graft fusion rate, and cause fewer surgical complications. However, PEEK cage is preferred in our study for multilevel fusion, because it has the fewest complication rates and the least amount of blood loss.

A new computer-aided technique for analysis of lateral cervical radiographs in postoperative patients with degenerative disease

STUDY DESIGN

Radiographs were measured by four independent observers and remeasured by three of the observers.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the reliability of a new computer-aided measurement technique.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Many studies have reported sagittal-plane distance and angle measurements in the cervical spine. Common measurement methods involve manual line drawing on lateral radiographs with manual or computer-aided distance and angle computation. In patients with anterior cervical fusion, changes in bony geometry could present difficulties for many existing methods.

METHODS

Digitized lateral cervical radiographs are imported into a graphics software package. Outlines of the vertebral bodies and spinous processes are traced on the best-quality film and transformed to match the bony geometry on each remaining radiograph from the same patient. Intervertebral distance and angulation are calculated from centers of mass of the outlined elements. Segmental measurements were collected for 27 lateral radiographs from nine patients with anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Intraclass and interclass correlation coefficients were calculated and used to compute standard errors of measurement.

RESULTS

High intraclass and interclass correlations (ICCs) and low measurement errors were calculated for both distance and angle measurements. Intraexaminer mean ICCs were 0.92 for interbody distance and 0.93 for segmental angle, with standard errors of measurement (SEMs) of 3.26% interbody distance (approximately 0.65 mm) and 1.20 degrees sagittal-plane rotation. Mean interexaminer ICCs were 0.91 for interbody distance and 0.86 for segmental angle, with SEMs of 3.58% interbody distance (approximately 0.72 mm) and 1.77 degrees sagittal-plane rotation.

CONCLUSIONS

The measurement method is reliable for both interbody distance and segmental angles within and among examiners. Whereas many existing measurement methods require normal radiographs to locate specific anatomic points, given intact spinous processes, the present method functions even with various radiographic abnormalities and in the presence of surgical decompression, degenerative disease, and cervical hardware. Because it does not rely on specific anatomic points, the present method is robust with respect to changes in the bony anatomy over time.

The biomechanical effects of cervical multilevel oblique corpectomy

STUDY DESIGN

A repeated-measures flexibility test was performed in vitro using human cadaveric spines.

OBJECTIVES

To compare changes in cervical biomechanics associated with multilevel oblique corpectomy and standard grafted corpectomy with or without plating.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Standard multilevel plated and unplated corpectomies are susceptible to instability in vitro. The authors are unaware of any previous research on the biomechanics of multilevel oblique corpectomy. METHODS.: Six human cadaveric cervical spine specimens (C3-T1) were tested: 1) normal; 2) after 2-level multilevel oblique corpectomy; 3) after expanding multilevel oblique corpectomy to represent standard grafted and plated corpectomy; and 4) after removing the anterior plate. Pure moments were applied to induce flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation while recording motion stereophotogrammetrically.

RESULTS

Compared to normal, the range of motion after multilevel oblique corpectomy increased 15% during flexion, 18% during extension, 11% during lateral bending, and 18% during axial rotation. These increases were about one-third of the increases observed after standard corpectomy without plating. Multilevel oblique corpectomy caused few alterations in locations of axes of rotation and coupling patterns, whereas standard corpectomy with or without plating significantly altered these parameters in several instances.

CONCLUSIONS

Multilevel oblique corpectomy (without graft) induced significantly less instability and altered kinematics less than standard unplated corpectomy with graft. Multilevel oblique corpectomy allowed significantly more motion than standard plated corpectomy with graft. However, the goal of standard corpectomy is fusion. Our results indicate that plating significantly limits spinal mobility after 2-level corpectomy, improving the environment for fusion.

Biomechanical analysis of multilevel cervical corpectomy and plate constructs

OBJECT

The authors compared the biomechanical stability of two multilevel cervical constructs involving the placement of equal size anterior cervical plates (ACPs) after decompressive surgery: the first is placed after three-level corpectomy with strut graft and the second after two-level corpectomy and aggressive discectomy with strut graft. In addition, both constructs were evaluated with and without the application of a screw attaching the ACP to the strut graft to determine whether the additional screw enhanced stability in any mode of loading.

METHODS

Nondestructive repeated-measures in vitro flexibility tests were performed in human cadaveric cervical spines. Nonconstraining pure moments of up to 1.5 Nm were applied while recording three-dimensional angular motion stereophotogrammetrically at each level from C4-5 to C7-T1. Nine specimens underwent the three-level corpectomy/strut graft procedure and eight specimens the two-level corpectomy/discectomy strut graft procedure. Failures during testing eliminated two of the former specimens and three of the latter specimens from analysis. The construct applied after the two-level procedure allowed a significantly smaller normalized neutral zone during flexion-extension than the three-level construct (p = 0.04). Normalized elastic zone and range of motion were consistently smaller in the two- than in the three-level construct, but the differences were not significant. Addition of a screw to the strut graft significantly reduced motion in the three-level procedure-treated specimens during flexion and lateral bending but had no effect on two-level corpectomy-treated specimens.

CONCLUSIONS

The construct associated with the two-level corpectomy/discectomy provided better immediate postoperative stability than that associated with the three-level corpectomy. The addition of a screw to the strut graft conferred stability on the three-level construct but not the two-level construct.

Biomechanical comparison of the stable efficacy of two anterior plating systems

OBJECTIVE

To compare the immediate stable efficacy and load sharing effect of two types of anterior cervical screw-plating instrumentations: the Morscher Synthes titanium locking screw-plate system and the Caspar trapezoidal screw-plate system.

DESIGN

Fresh porcine cervical spines with intact, two surgery unstable models, and then reconstructed with or without screw-plating instruments were compared in three physiological loading conditions.

BACKGROUND

Two markedly instrumentation systems--Morscher Synthes titanium cervical locking screw-plate and Caspar trapezoidal screw-plate systems are commonly used in management of complex cervical spine disorders. Although the biomechanical study showed that the lower cost Caspar system performed superior in extension before and after plate fatigue, the clinic evaluations of two systems were contradictory. So (1) does the titanium cervical locking plate system pay for its higher cost? and (2) what is the load sharing character of strut graft in one level corpectomy?

METHODS

Eight fresh ligamentous porcine cervical spines from C3 to C7 were undergone axial compression, rotation and sagittal flexion tests. The biomechanical experiment was sequentially repeated for the intact, C5-6 discectomy, C5 corpectomy, and then stabilized by either type of plate fixation devices with or without polymethylmethacrylate bone cement grafting. Strains measured by an extensometer across the operated motion segment were used as the index of stability.

RESULTS

Analysis of the strain data showed both types of anterior fixation plate systems provided adequate-restored stability for the spinal column only aided with polymethylmethacrylate construction. Statistically, there was no significant difference in biomechanical evaluation for the stability effect between much cost Morscher Synthes plate and Caspar plate system (p<0.005). The spinal disc bore as much as 75% of axial loading. While the strut graft functioned as the disc substitute and spacer, it bore more than 90% of axial loading. In high degree of flexion, the transmitted compressive load was shifted anteriorly to the screw-plate. This might unload the polymethylmethacrylate graft and resulted in the strut graft in tensile fatigue failure.

CONCLUSIONS

Statistically both systems showed similar stable efficacy, however, the Morscher Synthes cervical locking plate system might provide better stable effect in higher degrees of flexion motion. The strut graft played as the major load-bearing role in axial compression and sagittal flexion, while in axial rotation, the applied torque was mainly resisted by facet joint and screw-plate system complex.

RELEVANCE

The minor discrepancy of two plating systems may be due to the nature of plate geometry and design but not the material properties. Combination of bone graft and either plating systems provides adequate fusion stability under physiological loadings. The high degree flexion may cause the posterior portion of polymethylmethacrylate graft in tensile fracture and then result in polymethylmethacrylate failure in clinic observation.

Anterior cervical plate fixation: biomechanical effectiveness as a function of posterior element injury

OBJECT

The primary goal of this study was to determine if the stabilization provided to the spine by anterior cervical fixation with plating (ACFP) was dependent on the degree of posterior element injury. The secondary goal was to evaluate the effectiveness of additional posterior screw/rod stabilization in these injuries.

METHODS

Following ACFP with interbody bone graft and stepwise transection of the posterior ligaments and facets at C5-6, eight fresh-frozen human C4-7 spine segments were loaded using pure moments of +/- 1.5 Nm in flexion-extension, axial rotation, and lateral bending in the intact state. Posterior screw/rod fixation was performed after complete ligamentous destruction and complete removal of the facets. Repeated-measures analysis of variance and pairwise Student-Newman-Keuls tests were used to detect changes in the range of motion (ROM) and neutral zone (NZ). Statistical significance was assumed at a 95% level. Significant increases in ROM occurred in each loading direction after transection of the capsular ligaments (p < 0.001) and again following facetectomy (p < 0.001) compared with the ACFP condition. Additional posterior fixation resulted in a significant decrease in ROM in all loading directions (p < 0.001). There was a significant increase in NZ for complete ligamentous destruction compared with ACFP (p < 0.05) and facetectomy compared with ACFP (p < 0.05) for flexion-extension. In lateral bending, a significant increase in NZ was found for facetectomy compared with ACFP (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Capsular ligaments and articular facets are important structures in limiting three-dimensional vertebral motion in the presence of an anterior plate. Supplementary posterior fixation does reduce motion for all injury conditions.

Initial stability of cervical spine fixation: predictive value of a finite element model. Technical note

The purpose of this study was to generate a validated finite element (FE) model of the human cervical spine to be used to analyze new implants. Digitized data obtained from computerized tomography scanning of a human cervical spine were used to generate a three-dimensional, anisotropic, linear C5-6 FE model by using a software package (ANSYS 5.4). Based on the intact model (FE/Intact), a second was generated by simulating an anterior cervical fusion and plate (ACFP) C5-6 model in which monocortical screws (FE/ACFP) were used. Loading of each FE model was simulated using pure moments of +/- 2.5 Nm in flexion/extension, axial left/right rotation, and left/right lateral bending. For validation of the models, their predicted C5-6 range of motion (ROM) was compared with the results of an earlier, corresponding in vitro study of six human spines, which were tested in the intact state and surgically altered at C5-6 with the same implants. The validated model was used to analyze the stabilizing effect of a new disc spacer, Cenius (Aesculap AG, Tuttlingen, Germany), as a stand-alone implant (FE/Cenius) and in combination with an anterior plate (FE/Cenius+ACFP). In addition, compression loads at the upper surface of the spacer were investigated using both models. As calculated by FE/Intact and FE/ACFP models, the ROM was within 1 standard deviation of the mean value of the corresponding in vitro measurements for each loading case. The FE/Cenius model predicted C5-6 ROM values of 5.5 degrees in flexion/extension, 3.1 degrees in axial rotation (left and right), and 2.9 degrees in lateral bending (left and right). Addition of an anterior plate resulted in a further decrease of ROM in each loading case. The FE/Cenius model predicted an increase of compression load in flexion and a decrease in extension, whereas in the FE/Cenius+ACFP model an increase of graft compression in extension and unloading of the graft in flexion were predicted. The current FE model predicted ROM values comparable with those obtained in vitro in the intact state as well as after simulation of an ACFP model. It predicted a stabilizing potential for a new cage, alone and in combination with an anterior plate system, and predicted the influence of both loading modality and additional instrumentation on the behavior of the interbody graft.

The stabilizing axial spinal pillar in the lumbar spine

STUDY DESIGN

A theoretical model of spinal stability is proposed.

OBJECTIVE

To present a biomechanical study in vitro using flexibility and loading tests of the normal lumbar spine and of two lumbar models of spinal stability in order to determine which of the lumbar middle-column model and the personal suggested model of lumbar central axial pillar is more resistant and stable.

SETTING

Hospital 'Sf.Treime', Iasi, Romania.

METHODS

Twenty-three fresh human cadaveric lumbar spines were tested with flexibility and loading tests of the intact lumbar functional units and of two types of spinal model specimens: 10 lumbar middle-column models and 13 lumbar central pillar model specimens. Parameters of vertebral motion and vertebral compression were compared to determine the differences between the types of spinal models.

RESULTS

The flexibility tests show a significant increase in motion of the lumbar middle-column model specimens compared to the lumbar central pillar model specimens. The lumbar central pillar model specimens are three times more stable compared to the middle-column models. The compression tests show that the lumbar central axial pillar model specimens were more resistant, on average by 10% (30% maximum) compared to the other model.

CONCLUSIONS

The lumbar model formed by the axial overlapping of the posterior half moon of vertebral body continued by the pedicles and the articular processes is more stable and more resistant compared to the middle-column model of the three-columns theory of Denis. In the lumbar spine this central axis spinal pillar is the structure of spinal stability and resistance, and I propose this central axial spinal pillar as the stabilizing structure for all the spine.

Biomechanical evaluation of stand-alone interbody fusion cages in the cervical spine

STUDY DESIGN

An in vitro biomechanical investigation of the immediate stability in cervical reconstruction.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to compare the segmental stability afforded by the interbody fusion cage, the anterior locking plate, and the "gold standard" autograft.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Recently, interbody fusion cage devices have been developed and used for cervical reconstruction, but to the authors' knowledge no studies have investigated the biomechanical properties of the stand-alone interbody cage device in the cervical spine.

METHODS

Using six human cervical specimens, nondestructive biomechanical testing were performed, including axial rotation (+/-1.5 Nm, 50 N preload), flexion/extension (+/-1.5 Nm) and lateral bending (+/-1.5 Nm) loading modes. After C4-C5 discectomy, each specimen was reconstructed in the following order: RABEA cage (cage), tricortical bone graft (autograft), cervical spine locking plate system (plate). Unconstrained three-dimensional segmental range of motion at C4-C5 and above and below were evaluated.

RESULTS

In flexion/extension, the plate demonstrated significantly lower range of motion than did the cage and the autograft (P < 0.005), and the cage showed a significantly higher range of motion than did the intact spine (P < 0.05). Under axial rotation, the plate indicated a significantly lower range of motion than did all other groups (P < 0.05). No significant differences were indicated in lateral bending. Adjacent to C4-C5, an increased range of motion was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

The increased motion adjacent to C4-C5 may provide an argument for acceleration of disc degeneration. From the biomechanical point of view, this study suggests that the cervical interbody fusion cage should be supplemented with additional external or internal supports to prevent excessive motion in flexion-extension.

Biomechanical evaluation of occipitocervical fixation devices

Human cadaveric occipitocervical specimens were implanted with three types of instrumentation. The devices were tested biomechanically under three modes of loading to determine the stiffness of spinal constructs and the failure mechanisms of the constructs under extreme flexion. The devices tested were the AXIS Fixation System (with custom plate), the Y-Plate, and the Luque rectangle. No significant differences in stiffness among the devices were found under compression and flexion. The stiffnesses of the plate systems were statistically higher than the Luque rectangle in extension and torsion. In extreme flexion, the plate systems failed by fracture of the C2 pedicles. Modern plate systems, for occipitocervical fixation, provide more stiffness and stability than traditional wiring techniques. This study provides surgeons with information on the relative merits of modern plate and screw systems compared with traditional rod and wire constructs.