Unsuspected bile duct paucity in donors for living-related liver transplantation: two case reports

Management of adults with Alagille syndrome

Alagille syndrome (ALGS) is a complex rare genetic disorder that involves multiple organ systems and is historically regarded as a disease of childhood. Since it is inherited in an autosomal dominant manner in 40% of patients, it carries many implications for genetic counselling of patients and screening of family members. In addition, the considerable variable expression and absence of a clear genotype-phenotype correlation, results in a diverse range of clinical manifestations, even in affected individuals within the same family. With recent therapeutic advancements in cholestasis treatment and the improved survival rates with liver transplantation (LT), many patients with ALGS survive into adulthood. Although LT is curative for liver disease secondary to ALGS, complications secondary to extrahepatic involvement remain problematic lifelong. This review is aimed at providing a comprehensive review of ALGS to adult clinicians who will take over the medical care of these patients following transition, with particular focus on certain aspects of the condition that require lifelong surveillance. We also provide a diagnostic framework for adult patients with suspected ALGS and highlight key aspects to consider when determining eligibility for LT in patients with this syndrome.

Evaluation of living donors for hereditary liver disease (siblings, heterozygotes)

Living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) is recognised as an alternative treatment modality to reduce waiting list mortality and expand the donor pool. Over recent decades, there have been an increasing number of reports on the use of LT and specifically LDLT for familial hereditary liver diseases. There are marginal indications and contraindications that should be considered for a living donor in paediatric parental LDLT. No mortality or morbidity related to recurrence of metabolic diseases has been observed with heterozygous donors, except for certain relevant cases, such as ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency, protein C deficiency, hypercholesterolemia, protoporphyria, and Alagille syndrome, while donor human leukocyte antigen homozygosity also poses a risk. It is not always essential to perform preoperative genetic assays for possible heterozygous carriers; however, genetic and enzymatic assays must hereafter be included in the parental donor selection criteria in the aforementioned circumstances.

Alagille Syndrome: Current Understanding of Pathogenesis, and Challenges in Diagnosis and Management

Alagille syndrome (ALGS) is a complex heterogenous disease with a wide array of clinical manifestations in association with cholestatic liver disease. Major clinical and genetic advancements have taken place since its first description in 1969. However, clinicians continue to face considerable challenges in the management of ALGS, particularly in the absence of targeted molecular therapies. In this article, we provide an overview of the broad ALGS phenotype, current approaches to diagnosis and with particular focus on key clinical challenges encountered in the management of these patients.

Cholestatic liver diseases of genetic etiology: Advances and controversies

With the application of modern investigative technologies, cholestatic liver diseases of genetic etiology are increasingly identified as the root cause of previously designated "idiopathic" adult and pediatric liver diseases. Here, we review advances in the field enhanced by a deeper understanding of the phenotypes associated with specific gene defects that lead to cholestatic liver diseases. There are evolving areas for clinicians in the current era specifically regarding the role for biopsy and opportunities for a "sequencing first" approach. Risk stratification based on the severity of the genetic defect holds promise to guide the decision to pursue primary liver transplantation versus medical therapy or nontransplant surgery, as well as early screening for HCC. In the present era, the expanding toolbox of recently approved therapies for hepatologists has real potential to help many of our patients with genetic causes of cholestasis. In addition, there are promising agents under study in the pipeline. Relevant to the current era, there are still gaps in knowledge of causation and pathogenesis and lack of fully accepted biomarkers of disease progression and pruritus. We discuss strategies to overcome the challenges of genotype-phenotype correlation and draw attention to the extrahepatic manifestations of these diseases. Finally, with attention to identifying causes and treatments of genetic cholestatic disorders, we anticipate a vibrant future of this dynamic field which builds upon current and future therapies, real-world evaluations of individual and combined therapeutics, and the potential incorporation of effective gene editing and gene additive technologies.

Peritoneal dialysis in an adult patient with tetralogy of Fallot diagnosed with incomplete Alagille syndrome

BACKGROUND

Alagille syndrome is an autosomal dominant disorder usually caused by pathogenic variants of the JAG1 gene. In the past, cholestasis was a condition sine qua non for diagnosis of the syndrome. However, recent advancements in genetic testing have revealed that clinical presentations vary from lack of symptoms, to multiorgan involvement. Tetralogy of Fallot, the most frequent complex congenital heart defect in Alagille Syndrome, very rarely leads to renal failure requiring dialysis - there are only single reports of such cases in the literature, with none of them in Alagille Syndrome.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 41-year-old woman suffering from cyanosis, dyspnea and plethora was admitted to the hospital. The patient suffered from chronic kidney disease and tetralogy of Fallot and had been treated palliatively with Blalock-Taussig shunts in the past; at admission, only minimal flow through the left shunt was preserved. These symptoms, together with impaired mental status and dysmorphic facial features, led to extensive clinical and genetic testing including whole exome sequencing. A previously unknown missense variant c.587G > A within the JAG1 gene was identified. As there were no signs of cholestasis, and subclinical liver involvement was only suggested by elevated alkaline phosphatase levels, the patient was diagnosed with incomplete Alagille Syndrome. End-stage renal disease required introduction of renal replacement therapy. Continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis was chosen and the patient's quality of life significantly increased. However, after refusal of further treatment, the patient died at the age of 45.

CONCLUSIONS

Tetralogy of Fallot should always urge clinicians to evaluate for Alagille Syndrome and offer patients early nephrological care. Although tetralogy of Fallot rarely leads to end-stage renal disease requiring dialysis, if treated palliatively and combined with renal dysplasia (typical of Alagille Syndrome), it can result in severe renal failure as in the presented case. There is no standard treatment for such cases, but based on our experience, peritoneal dialysis is worth consideration. Finally, clinical criteria for the diagnosis of Alagille Syndrome require revision. Previously, diagnosis was based on cholestasis - however, cardiovascular anomalies are found to be more prevalent. Furthermore, the criteria do not include renal impairment, which is also common.

Living donor liver transplantation in Alagille syndrome-Single center experience from south Asia

To analyze the clinical characteristics and the outcomes of living donor liver transplantation in children with Alagille syndrome (AGS). Clinical data of children with AGS who underwent liver transplantation between July 2009 and May 2019 in our unit were retrospectively analyzed. Primary end-points were patient and graft survival. Ten children with AGS underwent living donor liver transplantation at a median age of 28 months (range, 12-84 months). Jaundice was the most common initial symptom and was noted after a median duration of 20 days after birth (range, 7-60 days). Two patients had undergone Kasai porto-enterostomy for misdiagnosis of biliary atresia. The most common indication for transplantation was severe pruritus with poor quality of life. Explant livers in three children showed cirrhosis with early well-differentiated hepatocellular carcinoma. We have 100% patient and graft survival at a mean follow-up of 32 months (range 3-72 months). The median z-score for weight and height at liver transplantation was -2.66 (range: -6.44 to -0.9) and -3.6 (range: -7.96 to -0.93) while at follow-up was -1.7 (range: -3.4 to -0.35) and -2.1 (range: -3.9 to -1.4), respectively. The estimated glomerular filtration rate was normal pretransplant and follow-up. This is the first series of LDLT for Alagille syndrome in the Indian sub-continent. We report excellent post-transplant outcomes in contrast to outcomes reported from Western literature.

Liver transplantation using grafts with rare metabolic disorders

Metabolic diseases that involve the liver represent a heterogeneous group of disorders. Apart from the metabolic defect, the subject's liver functions may be normal. With the increasing need for organs, livers from donors with metabolic diseases other than familial amyloid polyneuropathy might be possibly used for transplantation. However, whether such livers qualify as grafts and how they might impact recipient outcome are still unanswered questions. This review of the literature summarizes current experience in the use of such grafts in the context of cadaveric, domino, and living-related liver transplantation.

Characteristics and outcome of liver transplantation in children with Alagille syndrome: a single-center experience

BACKGROUND

This study was carried out in Chang Gung Memorial Hospital-Kaohsiung Medical Center, Taiwan, with the aim of reviewing the characteristics and the outcome of liver transplantation (LT) in children with Alagille syndrome (AGS).

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of transplant records of children diagnosed with AGS and undergoing LT between 1987 and 2010.

RESULTS

Nine patients underwent living donor LT. Cholestasis and characteristic facies were seen in all patients. Posterior embryotoxon was seen in 4/9 (44.4%), butterfly vertebrae in 3/9 (33.3%), heart defect (pulmonary stenosis in 2) in 3/9 (33.3%), and renal disease in 2/9 (22.2%) patients. Five cases had cholestasis prior to the age of 60 days, whereas four cases had cholestasis after 60 days of age. Iminodiacetic acid scans showed no excretion of isotope into the bowel in four cases and suggested a false diagnosis of biliary atresia. All patients underwent diagnostic laparotomy and liver biopsy. Results of liver biopsy showed characteristic features of paucity of interlobular bile ducts in all patients. Kasai portoenterostomy was not performed in any patient prior to being referred for LT. The mean age at the time of LT was 4.6 years. The 5-year overall survival rate after living donor LT was 88.9%.

CONCLUSION

Our conclusion is that the clinical features of AGS are informative. In addition, histological confirmation is important in the diagnosis. AGS children with severe liver disease had good prognoses with LT.

Outcomes of liver transplantation for patients with Alagille syndrome: the studies of pediatric liver transplantation experience

Alagille syndrome (ALGS) is a multisystem disorder that manifests as childhood cholestasis. Reports of liver transplantation (LT) for patients with ALGS have come largely from single centers, which have reported survival rates of 57% to 79%. The aim of this study was to determine LT outcomes for patients with ALGS. We performed a retrospective analysis of the Studies of Pediatric Liver Transplantation database, which contains information about 3153 pediatric LT recipients. Data were available for 91 patients with ALGS and for 236 age-matched patients with biliary atresia (BA). The frequency of complex cardiac anomalies was lower in the LT group with ALGS versus published ALGS series (5% versus 13%). The pretransplant glomerular filtration rate (GFR) was <90 mL/minute/1.73 m(2) in 18% of the LT patients with ALGS and in 5% of the LT patients with BA (P < 0.001). The height deficit at listing was worse for the ALGS patients (66%) versus the BA patients (22%). The 1-year patient survival rates were 87% for the ALGS patients and 96% for the BA patients (P = 0.002). The deaths in the ALGS group mostly occurred within the first 30 days. No pretransplant factors associated with death were identified in the ALGS group. A survival analysis revealed that biliary (P = 0.02), vascular (P < 0.001), central nervous system (CNS; P < 0.001), and renal complications (P < 0.001) after LT were associated with death in the ALGS group. Renal insufficiency in the ALGS patients worsened after LT, and at 1 year, GFR was <90 mL/minute/1.73 m(2) in 22% of the LT patients with ALGS but in only 8% of the patients with BA (P = 0.0014). More LT pediatric patients with ALGS either were currently receiving special education (50% versus 30% for BA patients, P = 0.02) or had received special education in the past (60% versus 36%, P = 0.01). Vascular, CNS, and renal complications were increased in the ALGS patients after LT, and this reflected multisystem involvement. Although the 1-year survival rate was modestly lower for the ALGS patients versus the BA patients, the clustering of deaths within the first 30 days is notable and warrants increased vigilance and further investigation.

Liver transplantation in children: update 2010

Pediatric liver transplant recipients represent an important target population for primary care health professionals as well as transplant practitioners. With improving patient and graft survival, new concerns now face health care professionals caring for the transplant community, namely the long-term complications of immunosuppressive therapy and the potential for withdrawal of immunosuppression, transplant recipients' quality of life, and the persistent shortage of donor organs leading to morbidity and mortality on the waiting list. These issues require constant collaboration between pediatricians, transplant hepatologists, transplant surgeons, nurses, dieticians, social workers, psychologists, and other supporting services.

Alagille syndrome and liver transplantation

Alagille syndrome is a multisystem disorder in which progressive liver disease with persistent cholestasis and dramatic pruritus often warrant consideration for liver transplantation. The most important part of the transplant assessment is evaluation of the cardiac and renal involvement. Preoperatively, cardiac performance often must be tested with dynamic stress tests, mimicking hemodynamic changes during liver transplant. Many aspects of the syndrome including cholestasis, pruritus, and hypercholesterolemia improve posttransplant, but short stature is rarely significantly affected. One- and 5-year patient and graft survival after liver transplant is comparable to other elective indications, but effects of long-term immunosuppressants on evolution of other components of the syndrome, including vascular, bone, and renal disease, remain largely unknown.

Adult live donor liver transplantation

The increasing awareness of liver diseases and their early detection have led to an increase in the number of transplant waiting list candidates over the past decade. This need has not been matched by the actual number of orthotopic liver transplantations performed. Live donor liver transplantation (LDLT) is an innovative surgical technique intended to expand the available organ donor pool. Although LDLT offers definite advantages to the recipient, it offers none to the donor except for the possibility of psychological well-being. Clinical research studies aimed at the prospective collection of data for donors and recipients need to be conducted.

Progress in living donor liver transplantation

Living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) has the capacity to reduce the current discrepancy between the number of patients on the transplant waiting list and the number of available organ donors. For pediatric patients, LDLT has clearly reduced the number of waiting list deaths, providing compelling evidence for an increase in LDLT programs. This review discusses many of the recent advances in LDLT.

N/A

N/A

Bile duct variations in partial liver transplantations from living-related donors

The aim of this paper was to present anatomic variations of bile ducts and their effect on the perioperative course of living-related donors in partial liver transplantations in children. Liver fragments for partial transplantation were harvested from 41 related donors. Segments II and III were harvested from 35 and segments II, III, and IV from 6 donors. During the procedure, cholangiography through cystic duct was performed revealing a normal anatomy of the bile ducts in 33 (80.5%) cases. The rest of the donors showed anatomic variations. There was only one case of complications related to the bile duct. The intraoperative diagnosis of anatomic variations allowed for safe partial liver harvesting.

Heritable disorders of the bile ducts

Diseases of the bile ducts encompass a wide range of disorders. These include those disorders primarily affecting extra and intrahepatic bile ducts and those that may be classified as panbiliary. The major heritable bile duct disorders are those affecting the intrahepatic ducts, namely syndromic bile duct paucity, or Alagille syndrome, and the fibrocystic cholangiopathies autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease/congenital hepatic fibrosis, and autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease. This discussion focuses on heritable disorders of the bile ducts.

Living-related liver transplantation for Alagille syndrome

Alagille syndrome (AGS) is an autosomal dominant genetic disorder characterized by chronic cholestasis, congenital heart disease, peculiar facies, butterfly-like vertebrae, and posterior embryotoxon. Liver dysfunction is the common presentation of AGS, and liver transplantation may be indicated. This study examines the outcome of living-related liver transplantation (LRLT) for AGS. Twenty patients with AGS (median age 5.0 years, range 0.6-12.9) underwent LRLT at Kyoto University Hospital between June 1990 and February 2002. Five potential donors were excluded because of paucity of intrahepatic bile ducts diagnosed by preoperative liver biopsy and one because of a hepatic vascular anomaly. The overall 5-year patient survival was 80.4%. Three patients died as the result of the following: complications related to surgery, heart failure caused by progressive pulmonary artery stenosis, and a graft with unsuspected bile duct paucity. Liver dysfunction was improved in all successful cases, and catch-up growth occurred in 90% of patients. LRLT is an efficacious treatment modality for AGS if donors are selected by cautious evaluation to rule out unsuspected bile duct paucity.

Alagille syndrome

Alagille syndrome (AGS) was described more than 35 years ago as a genetic entity characterised by five major features: chronic cholestasis owing to paucity of interlobular bile ducts; peripheral pulmonary stenosis; butterfly like vertebral arch defect; posterior embryotoxon and peculiar facies. AGS has long been said to have a relative good prognosis but overall survival at twenty years averages 70%. Complex congenital heart disease and hepatic disease with or without liver transplantation contribute significantly to mortality. JAGGED1 has been identified as a responsible gene by demonstration of mutations in AGS patients. Studies of JAGGED1 expression pattern demonstrate that minor features and almost all the elements in the long list of manifestations described in AGS patients are not coincidental. This suggests that Alagille syndrome definition may be revisited in the light of JAGGED1 mutations.

Recent advances in pediatric liver transplantation

Pediatric liver transplantation has matured into a well-established, highly successful treatment for advanced pediatric liver disease. Recent 1-year success rates range from 85% to 95%. This unprecedented achievement is the result of careful selection criteria and optimal timing of transplantation, technical advances in surgical technique, and improved treatment following transplant. This report highlights many recent published findings representing advances that have led to current successful approaches.

Adult-to-adult live donor liver transplantation: a short-term clinicopathologic study

With the success of pediatric live donor liver transplantation (LDLT) and the continued shortage of cadaveric donors, adult-to-adult LDLT has been performed at some centers, including ours. We performed a detailed histologic review of all liver specimens obtained from 9 adult recipients at and after LDLT and correlated these findings with the patients' course and outcome. Five patients had histologic evidence of biliary tract pathology; 3 of 5 required surgical or radiologic intervention. The other 2 had clinically insignificant biliary disease. Diffuse hepatocytic hemorrhagic necrosis secondary to massive portal blood flow after portal venous revascularization resulted in graft failure and retransplantation in a single patient with severe preoperative portal hypertension. Two perioperative deaths were caused by sepsis and multiorgan failure (day 25) and generalized thrombosis related to factor V Leiden (day 6). The preoperative diagnosis, presence of portal vein thrombosis in the native liver, postoperative cholangiopathy, and subcapsular hemorrhagic necrosis in donor liver wedge biopsies did not affect the short-term outcome. In conclusion, biliary tract pathology is common after adult-to-adult LDLT but does not negatively affect graft or patient survival. Infrequent but catastrophic vascular complications related to portal hemodynamics or thrombosis can result in graft loss and/or patient death.

Alagille syndrome. The widening spectrum of arteriohepatic dysplasia

Alagille syndrome was described more than 35 years ago as a genetic entity characterized by five major features: chronic cholestasis resulting from paucity of interlobular bile ducts, peripheral pulmonary stenosis, butterflylike vertebral arch defect, posterior embryotoxon, and peculiar facies. Recently, JAGGED1 has been identified as a responsible gene by demonstration of mutations in AGS patients. Studies of the JAGGED1 expression pattern demonstrate that minor features and almost all the elements in the long list of manifestations described in AGS patients are not coincidental. This finding suggests that the definition of AGS may be reconsidered in the light of JAGGED1 mutations.

Clinical and molecular genetics of Alagille syndrome

Alagille syndrome (AGS) is a dominantly inherited disorder characterized by bile duct paucity and resultant liver disease in combination with cardiac, skeletal, ocular, and facial abnormalities. Jagged1 (JAG1) has been identified as the AGS disease gene. It encodes a ligand in the Notch signaling pathway that is involved in cell fate determination. AGS is the first developmental disorder to be associated with this pathway. It shows highly variable expressivity, and diagnosis in mildly affected persons can be difficult without molecular analysis. Currently, JAG1 mutations are detected in about 70% of patients with AGS and include total gene deletions as well as protein truncating, splicing, and missense mutations. Mutations are located across the gene within the evolutionarily conserved motifs of the protein. There is no phenotypic difference between patients with deletion of the entire JAG1 gene and those with intragenic mutations. This suggests that haploinsufficiency for JAG1 is a mechanism causing AGS.