Evaluation of human cytomegalovirus gene expression in thoracic organ transplant recipients using nucleic acid sequence-based amplification

Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction to evaluate human cytomegalovirus lytic gene expression

This paper describes the development of four Reverse Transcriptase-Polymerase Chain Reaction (RT-PCR) assays devised to evaluate lytic (UL123, immediate-early; UL54, early; UL65, late; and UL99, true late) human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) transcripts. Subsequently, the assays have been validated evaluating the HCMV lytic gene expression in 28 samples (peripheral blood leukocytes, PBLs) from 14 renal transplant recipients. Although the assessment of HCMV transcriptional profile could be useful to evaluate viral reactivation state, further studies on dynamics of viral transcripts in different clinical settings are needed to determine the role of transcriptional profiling in virological monitoring and therapeutic management in immunocompromised patients.

Evaluation of two set of primers for detection of immediate early gene UL123 of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV)

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) is a widespread agent causing a life-long persistent and generally asymptomatic infection in immunocompetent individuals. In contrast, immunocompromised subjects are the most susceptible group to experience HCMV disease. First genes to be expressed during the replication cycle are the immediate early (IE) genes, the products of which have pleiotropic effects on host cell metabolism. Aim of this study was to compare two set of primers in the optimization and standardization of a RT-PCR assay for qualitative detection of mRNA encoded by the IE gene UL123 (IE1). The RT-PCR assays were then used to evaluate the UL123 gene expression in 29 peripheral blood leukocyte (PBL) samples obtained from 14 renal transplant recipients. In particular, 21/29 (72.4%) were positive with set A of primers vs. 24/29 (82.8%) with set B. Only one sample were negative with set B and positive with set A. Twenty-four of 29 samples (82.8%) were pp65-antigaenemia positive: 21 mRNA-UL123 positive with set A vs. 22 with set B; all viraemia-positive patients were mRNA-UL123 positive with both set A and B. Five of 29 samples were pp65-antigaenemia negative: 1 mRNA-UL 123 positive with set A vs. 2 with set B; all of them were viraemia-negative. These two RT-PCR assays could provide a reliable, rapid and sensitive system enabling the detection and identification of UL123 transcripts and could be usefully employed to study the pathogenesis of HCMV-related diseases.

Clinical utility of CMV early and late transcript detection with NASBA in bronchoalveolar lavages

BACKGROUND

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection can cause severe disease in immunocompromised individuals, with CMV pneumonia, most commonly seen in lung or bone marrow transplant recipients, carrying a particularly high fatality rate. Early and accurate diagnosis of CMV pneumonia is therefore critical.

OBJECTIVES

Current diagnostic tests for CMV pneumonia in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) specimens are either insensitive or poor prognostic indicators of disease. We therefore examined nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NASBA) assays for CMV transcripts in BAL for the prediction of CMV pneumonia and associated diseases.

STUDY DESIGN

A total of 220 BAL specimens from lung transplant recipients and other patients with suspected viral pneumonia were studied. Ninety-nine samples had previously tested positive for CMV by shell vial (SV) culture, while the other 121 had tested negative. All specimens were assayed for CMV pp67 and immediate early (IE) transcripts by NASBA. Results were correlated with evidence of concurrent or subsequent CMV pneumonia, rejection, and infection with other microbes.

RESULTS

From a total of 220 BAL specimens, 27 tested positive for pp67 mRNA, 25 tested positive for IE mRNA, and 17 tested positive for both. Only 10 specimens tested positive for CMV by either or both NASBA assays while testing negative by SV assay. However, 74 specimens were SV positive but negative in both NASBA assays. Detection of CMV by any of the three methods was associated with an increased prevalence of pneumonia (i.e., pulmonary interstitial inflammation with radiographic or clinical evidence of lung injury), but not with pulmonary CMV pathology. Detection of CMV by SV was associated with moderate to severe graft rejection. There was no evidence of increased bacterial or fungal pulmonary infections associated with a positive CMV result by any of the three assays.

CONCLUSIONS

Detection of either CMV pp67 or IE mRNA transcripts by NASBA in BAL specimens can occasionally identify CMV infections that are negative by conventional shell vial culture, but does not have sufficient sensitivity or positive predictive value to be employed routinely for pre emptive management of pulmonary CMV disease in transplant recipients.

A prospective study comparing cytomegalovirus antigenemia, DNAemia and RNAemia tests in guiding pre-emptive therapy in thoracic organ transplant recipients

We evaluated the usefulness of DNAemia and mRNAemia tests in guiding the pre-emptive therapy against cytomegalovirus (CMV) infections in thoracic organ transplant recipients using antigenemia test as the reference. Seven lung (LTR) and 14 heart (HTR) transplant recipients were prospectively monitored for CMV by antigenemia, DNAemia (Cobas Amplicor PCR Monitor) and pp67-mRNAemia (NASBA) tests. However, only the antigenemia test guided pre-emptive therapy with cut-off levels of >or=2 and >or=5-10 pp65-positive leukocytes/50 000 leukocytes in the LTRs and HTRs, respectively. CMV DNAemia was detected in 26/28 (93%) and RNAemia in 17/28 (61%) of the CMV antigenemias requiring antiviral therapy (P = 0.01). Optimal DNAemia levels (sensitivity/specificity) estimated from receiver-operating characteristic curve to achieve maximal sum of sensitivity and specificity were 400 (75.9/92.7%), 850 (91.3/91.3%) and 1250 (100/91.5%) copies/ml for the antigenemia of 2, 5 and 10 pp65-positive leukocytes, respectively. The sensitivities of nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NASBA) were 25.9%, 43.5% and 56.3% in detecting the same cut-off levels of antigenemia. In thoracic organ transplant recipients, the Cobas PCR assay is comparable with the antigenemia test in guiding pre-emptive therapy against CMV infections when threshold levels of over 5 pp65-antigen-positive leukocytes are used as the reference. In contrast, the low sensitivity of NASBA limits its usefulness in the guidance of pre-emptive therapy.

CYTOMEGALOVIRUS INFECTION IN ORGAN-TRANSPLANT RECIPIENTS: DIAGNOSTIC VALUE OF PP65 ANTIGEN TEST, QUALITATIVE POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION (PCR) AND QUANTITATIVE TAQMAN PCR

BACKGROUND

The human cytomegalovirus (CMV) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in transplant patients. In this study, we compared the diagnostic value of pp65 antigen test, qualitative nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and quantitative Taqman PCR in predicting the clinical outcome of CMV infection.

METHODS

A total of 169 samples derived from 59 organ-transplant recipients (kidney n= 46, liver n= 11, kidney and pancreas n= 2) were analyzed. Peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) were isolated using dextran gradient centrifugation, and 2 x 10 cells were analyzed for pp65 antigen by immunofluorescence. A crude DNA extract obtained from the same number of cells was used for qualitative nested PCR and quantitative Taqman PCR analysis. RESULTS.: The correlation coefficient of pp65 antigen test and Taqman PCR was R= 0.699 (P = 0.001). With cut-off values for pp65 antigen test set at greater than 10 positive nuclei per 2 x 10 PBL, sensitivity was 91%, and positive predictive value (PPV) was 70%. When the corresponding cut-off value for Taqman PCR was applied (>125000 genome copies per 2 x 10 PBL), a sensitivity of 83% and a PPV of 68% were found. Both assays allowed for the monitoring of successful antiviral therapy. Although qualitative nested PCR was highly sensitive (95%), it was less useful in predicting CMV disease (PPV 47%) and in therapy control.

CONCLUSION

Our data show that pp65 antigen test and Taqman PCR are almost equivalent in the monitoring of CMV infection and disease when identical cell numbers are used for both assays.

Distinguishing cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection and disease with CMV nucleic acid assays

Human cytomegalovirus (CMV) continues to be a significant cause of morbidity and mortality among transplant recipients. Molecular assays have been developed for the detection and quantification of CMV nucleic acid. In evaluating the clinical utility of these assays, correlations with clinical outcome are essential. The Amplicor CMV Monitor and NucliSens CMV pp67 tests were compared to the CMV antigenemia assay for 45 transplant recipients and 1 patient with Wegener's granulomatosis. Twenty-three patients remained antigenemia negative throughout the monitoring period, none of whom developed CMV disease. In this patient group, both the Amplicor and NucliSens assays showed very high specificity; only 1 of the 324 specimens assayed by NucliSens and none of the 303 specimens assayed by Amplicor were positive. Twenty-three patients were antigenemia positive during the monitoring period, 12 of whom developed 13 episodes of symptomatic CMV disease. In this patient group, the NucliSens assay was positive at or before the development of symptoms in 12 of the 13 episodes of CMV disease. All eight patients with symptomatic CMV disease who were tested by the Amplicor assay were positive at or before the development of disease. For the 11 asymptomatic patients, the NucliSens assay was positive less frequently than the antigenemia or Amplicor assays. The NucliSens assay was more likely to be positive at higher antigenemia or viral load levels. Both the NucliSens and Amplicor assays appear to have clinical utility in monitoring patients for CMV disease.

Multiplex real-time NASBA for monitoring expression dynamics of human cytomegalovirus encoded IE1 and pp67 RNA

BACKGROUND

The monitoring for HCMV mRNA expression in whole blood provides an accurate and informative diagnostic approach.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A multiplex real-time NASBA with three molecular beacons (MR-NASBA) was developed for the simultaneous detection and quantification of HCMV-encoded immediate early-1 (IE1) and late pp67 mRNA. The assay was evaluated using RNA from in vitro HCMV-infected cells and sequential whole blood samples (100 microl) of HCMV infected lung transplant recipients.

RESULTS

The MR-NASBA showed equal performance compared with standard NASBA assays (sensitivity of 1-3 x 10(3) RNA molecules in 100 microl blood and a linear range of 10(3)-10(6) RNA molecules). The standard IE1 Q-RNA provides a reliable internal system control. No interference was observed between the individual beacon signals. The simultaneous 'one-tube' quantification of IE1-RNA levels combined with qualitative detection of pp67-RNA is feasible without loss of assay performance in clinical whole blood specimens. CONCLUSION AND COMMENTS: MR-NASBA may be suitable for monitoring HCMV-activity in transplant recipients to aid in fine-tuning of antiviral intervention in high risk populations employing a traffic light diagnostic approach: no HCMV RNA signal (green light: safe) reflects absent or fully latent infection requiring no antiviral intervention; an 'IE1-RNA only' signal (yellow light: alert) indicates an emerging or subclinical active infection, opting for preemptive treatment in high risk populations; simultaneous 'IE1-RNA plus pp67-RNA' detection (red light:danger) indicates disseminating productive infection requiring immediate antiviral treatment.

Different profiles of cytomegalovirus RNA transcripts and anti-cytomegalovirus IgM antibodies in renal transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

A difference in anti-cytomegalovirus IgM antibody profile has been found between sera from acutely cytomegalovirus (CMV)-infected patients and sera from CMV-infected patients with subclinical infection.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study is to investigate whether such different IgM antibody responses are correlated with differences in the expression of CMV immediate early and late mRNAs.

STUDY DESIGN

We have investigated the anti-CMV IgM response in 46 renal transplant recipients by employing two commercially available IgM kits (AxSYM and IMX) as well as two novel enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs), which were developed using recombinant ppUL32 (pp150) and pUL80a (p38), respectively. The results were compared with four direct CMV diagnostic tests: pp65 antigenemia, viral culture and nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NASBA), detecting either CMV immediate early 1 (IE1) mRNA (IE1-NASBA), or CMV pp67 (late) mRNA (pp67-NASBA).

RESULTS

Analysis of all CMV-infected recipients (n=28) showed that in 16 recipients (group I) more than one direct test became positive after transplantation, while in the other 12 recipients (group II), IE1-NASBA was the only direct test to become positive. In group I, 100, 81, 100 and 50% of the recipients were IgM-positive with AxSYM, IMX, p38 and pp150, respectively. In group II, 100, 83, 17 and 83% of the recipients were IgM-positive with AxSYM, IMX, p38 and pp150, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data indicate that the IgM-response against p38 and pp150 differs significantly (P<0.01) between group I recipients with productive CMV infection, and group II recipients with a non-productive CMV infection which may be of diagnostic and prognostic relevance.

Direct quantification of human cytomegalovirus immediate-early and late mRNA levels in blood of lung transplant recipients by competitive nucleic acid sequence-based amplification

The dynamics of active human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) infection was monitored by competitive nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NASBA) assays for quantification of IE1 (UL123) and pp67 (UL65) mRNA expression levels in the blood of patients after lung transplantation. RNA was isolated from 339 samples of 13 lung transplant recipients and analyzed by the quantitative IE1 and pp67 NASBA in parallel with pp65 antigenemia and serology. Rapid increases in IE1 RNA exceeding 10(4) copies per 100 microl of blood were associated with active infection, whereas lower levels were suggestive for abortive, subclinical viral activity. Any positive value for pp67 RNA was indicative for active infection, and quantification of pp67 mRNA did not give additional diagnostic information. The onset of IE1-positive NASBA preceded pp67 NASBA and was earlier than the pp65 antigenemia assay, confirming previous studies with qualitative NASBA. Effective antiviral treatment was reflected by a rapid disappearance of pp67 mRNA, whereas IE1 mRNA remained detectable for longer periods. Quantification of IE1 might be relevant to monitor progression of HCMV infection but should be validated in prospective studies.