Anxious genes, emerging themes. Commentary on Belzung "The genetic basis of the pharmacological effects of anxiolytics" and Olivier et al. "The 5-HT(1A) receptor knockout mouse and anxiety"

Atypical anxiolytic-like response to naloxone in benzodiazepine-resistant 129S2/SvHsd mice: role of opioid receptor subtypes

RATIONALE

Mice of many 129 substrains respond to environmental novelty with behavioural suppression and high levels of anxiety-like behaviour. Although resistant to conventional anxiolytics, this behavioural phenotype may involve stress-induced release of endogenous opioids.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the effects of opioid receptor blockade on behavioural reactions to novelty stress in a chlordiazepoxide-resistant 129 substrain.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Experiment 1 contrasted the effects of the broad-spectrum opioid receptor antagonist naloxone (1.0-10.0 mg/kg) in C57BL/6JOlaHsd and 129S2/SvHsd mice exposed to the elevated plus-maze. Experiments 2-4 examined the responses of 129S2/SvHsd mice to the mu-selective opioid receptor antagonist beta-funaltrexamine (2.5-10.0 mg/kg), the delta-selective antagonist naltrindole (2.5-10.0 mg/kg) and the kappa-selective antagonist nor-binaltorphimine (2.5-5.0 mg/kg).

RESULTS

129 mice displayed higher levels of anxiety-like behaviour and lower levels of general exploration relative to their C57 counterparts. Although naloxone failed to alter the behaviour of C57 mice, both doses of this antagonist produced behaviourally selective reductions in open-arm avoidance in 129 mice. Surprisingly, none of the more selective opioid receptor antagonists replicated this effect of naloxone: beta-funaltrexamine was devoid of behavioural activity, naltrindole suppressed rearing (all doses) and increased immobility (10 mg/kg), while nor-binaltorphimine (5 mg/kg) nonspecifically increased percent open arm entries.

CONCLUSIONS

Recent evidence suggests differential involvement of opioid receptor subtypes in the anxiolytic efficacy of diverse compounds including conventional benzodiazepines. The insensitivity of 129 mice to the anxiolytic action of chlordiazepoxide, coupled with their atypical anxiolytic response to naloxone (but not more selective opioid receptor antagonists), suggests an abnormality in anxiety-related neurocircuitry involving opioid-GABA interactions.

N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea mouse mutants in the dissection of behavioural and psychiatric disorders

Twin and adoption studies have consistently implicated genetics in the aetiology of psychiatric and behavioural disorders. The identification of the genes and molecular pathways that are associated with these traits using linkage studies has been difficult because psychiatric disorders are almost always non-mendelian, heterogeneous, involve multiple genetic loci and are influenced significantly by environmental factors. Mouse models that are based on intermediate signatures of psychiatric disease and pharmacological responsiveness hold promise as a complementary approach to dissecting the molecular basis of neurobehavioural disorders. This has been made possible by the development and refinement of gene targeting technologies and the use of super-efficient chemical mutagens. N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) mutagenesis in the mouse, when coupled to a battery of sensitive behavioural screens, is an effective way of creating and identifying novel mouse behavioural mutants. Here, the concept of screening for ENU mutants is introduced while progress with two behavioural screens, an "anxiety" screen and a circadian screen, are presented. It is hoped that the study of mouse mutants that have arisen from these screens will provide new insights into the genetic basis of abnormal behaviour and that they might lead to the development of novel therapeutic compounds for human psychiatric disease.

Absence of anxiolytic response to chlordiazepoxide in two common background strains exposed to the elevated plus-maze: importance and implications of behavioural baseline

Although genetic background is acknowledged as a potentially important determinant of mutant phenotypes, publications on genetically modified mice far outnumber those on progenitor strains. We have recently reported major differences in basal anxiety levels (elevated plus-maze & light/dark exploration) among three strains (C57BL/6JOlaHsd, 129/SvEv and 129S2/SvHsd) employed as progenitor stock in European laboratories (Rodgers et al. in press). Furthermore, the phenotypes of these inbred strains differed significantly from that of an outbred strain (Swiss-Webster) commonly used in behavioural pharmacology. In view of these findings, the present study assessed possible differences in the anxiolytic efficacy of chlordiazepoxide (0, 7.5 & 15.0 mg/kg, IP) in three of these strains (Swiss-Webster (SW), C57BL/6JOIaHsd (C57) & 129S2/SvHsd (129)). Experimentally naive mice were exposed to the elevated plus-maze, sessions were videotaped and behaviour analysed using ethological software. The performance of control subjects confirmed significant strain differences in basal levels of activity (SW > C57 > 129) and anxiety-related behaviours (129 = SW > C57), with hypolocomotion dominating the 129 profile. SW mice displayed an anxioselective response to both doses of chlordiazepoxide (CDP), with significant reductions in open arm avoidance and risk assessment observed in the absence of any change in general activity. In direct contrast, the lower dose of CDP (7.5 mg/kg) was without effect in either inbred strain, whereas treatment with 15.0 mg/kg induced a profile indicative of muscle relaxation/mild sedation in C57 mice and virtually abolished all behavioural activity in 129 mice. Although the absence of an anxiolytic response to CDP in C57 mice may be attributed to their low basal anxiety levels, the profile of 129 mice strongly suggests an abnormality in benzodiazepine/GABAA receptor function. The implications of these findings for research on mutant mice are discussed.

Contrasting phenotypes of C57BL/6JOlaHsd, 129S2/SvHsd and 129/SvEv mice in two exploration-based tests of anxiety-related behaviour

Knockout mice are typically generated on a mixed genetic background and, as such, detailed behavioural characterisation of these background strains is essential to the valid interpretation of mutant phenotypes. In this context, recent research has revealed significant differences in anxiety-like behaviour among the most commonly used background strains (C57BL/6J and various 129 substrains), leading to the possibility that at least certain mutant phenotypes may not after all be due to the targeted mutation. However, these findings derive largely from behavioural test batteries in which there may well be an experiential confound, while the widely reported hypolocomotor profile of most 129 substrains may compromise the principal indices of anxiety-like behaviour. In the present study, we have compared the behavioural profiles of three commonly used background strains (C57BL/6JOlaHsd, 129/SvEv and 129S2/SvHsd) in two of the most popular animal models of anxiety-the elevated plus-maze (EPM) and light/dark exploration (LDE) tests. Naive animals were used for each procedure, ethological scoring methods were employed throughout, and the inbred phenotypes were also compared with that of an outbred strain (Swiss-Webster) widely employed in test validation and behavioural pharmacology. Our results show that, despite their hypolocomotor profile, both 129 substrains display higher levels of anxiety-like behaviour (conventional and/or ethological measures) relative to the C57BL/6JOlaHsd strain. Furthermore, all three inbred strains were less active in both tests when compared with the outbred Swiss-Webster strain. However, whereas C57BL/6JOlaHsd mice displayed lower levels of anxiety-like behaviour than their Swiss-Webster counterparts (both tests), 129S2/SvHsd (but not 129/SvEv) mice exhibited evidence of higher anxiety, particularly in the LDE test. The implications of these findings are discussed in relation to both the behavioural and pharmacological phenotyping of mutant mice.