Immunosuppressive therapy: a potential alternative to bone marrow transplantation as initial therapy for acquired severe aplastic anemia in childhood?

First-line allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation of HLA-matched sibling donors compared with first-line ciclosporin and/or antithymocyte or antilymphocyte globulin for acquired severe aplastic anemia

BACKGROUND

Acquired severe aplastic anemia is a rare and potentially fatal disease, which is characterized by hypocellular bone marrow and pancytopenia. The major signs and symptoms are severe infections, bleeding, and exhaustion. First-line allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) of a human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-matched sibling donor (MSD) is a treatment for newly diagnosed patients with severe aplastic anemia. First-line treatment with ciclosporin and/or antithymocyte or antilymphocyte globulin (as first-line immunosuppressive therapy) is an alternative to MSD-HSCT and is indicated for patients where no MSD is found.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the effectiveness and adverse events of first-line allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation of HLA-matched sibling donors compared to first-line immunosuppressive therapy including ciclosporin and/or antithymocyte or antilymphocyte globulin in patients with acquired severe aplastic anemia.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the electronic databases MEDLINE (Ovid), EMBASE (Ovid), and The Cochrane Library CENTRAL (Wiley) for published articles from 1946 to 22 April 2013. Further searches included trial registries, reference lists of recent reviews, and author contacts.

SELECTION CRITERIA

The following prospective study designs were eligible for inclusion: randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and non-randomized controlled trials if the allocation of patients to treatment groups was consistent with 'Mendelian randomization'. We included participants with newly diagnosed severe aplastic anemia who received MSD-HSCT or immunosuppressive therapy without prior HSCT or immunosuppressive therapy, and with a minimum of five participants per treatment group. We did not apply limits on publication year or languages.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two review authors abstracted the data on study and patient characteristics and assessed the risk of bias independently. We resolved differences by discussion or by appeal to a third review author. The primary outcome was overall mortality. Secondary outcomes were treatment-related mortality, graft failure, no response to first-line immunosuppressive therapy, graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD), relapse after initial successful treatment, secondary clonal and malignant disease, health-related quality of life, and performance score.

MAIN RESULTS

We identified three trials that met the inclusion criteria. None of these trials was a RCT. 302 participants are included in this review. The three included studies were prospectively conducted and had features consistent with the principle of 'Mendelian randomization' as defined in the present review. All studies had a high risk of bias due to the study design. All studies were conducted more than 10 years ago and may not be applicable to the standard of care of today. Primary and secondary outcome data showed no statistically significant difference between treatment groups. We present results for first-line allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation of an HLA-matched sibling donor, which we denote as the MSD-HSCT group, versus first-line treatment with ciclosporin and/or antithymocyte or antilymphocyte globulin, which we denote as the immunosuppressive therapy group in the following section.The pooled hazard ratio for overall mortality for the MSD-HSCT group versus the immunosuppressive therapy group was 0.95 (95% confidence interval 0.43 to 2.12, P = 0.90, low quality evidence). Therefore, overall mortality was not statistically significantly different between the groups. Treatment-related mortality ranged from 20% to 42% for the MSD-HSCT group and was not reported for the immunosuppressive therapy group (very low quality evidence). The authors reported graft failure from 3% to 16% for the MSD-HSCT group and GVHD from 26% to 51% (both endpoints not applicable for the immunosuppressive therapy group, very low quality evidence). The authors did not report any data on response and relapse for the MSD-HSCT group. For the immunosuppressive therapy group, the studies reported no response from 15% (not time point stated) to 64% (three months) and relapse in one of eight responders after immunosuppressive therapy at 5.5 years (very low quality evidence). The authors reported secondary clonal disease or malignancies for the MSD-HSCT group versus the immunosuppressive therapy group in 1 of 34 versus 0 of 22 patients in one study and in 0 of 28 versus 4 of 86 patients in the other study (low quality evidence). None of the included studies addressed health-related quality of life. The percentage of the evaluated patients with a Karnofsky performance status score in the range of 71% to 100% was 92% in the MSD-HSCT group and 46% in the immunosuppressive therapy group.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

There are insufficient and biased data that do not allow any conclusions to be made about the comparative effectiveness of first-line allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation of an HLA-matched sibling donor and first-line treatment with ciclosporin and/or antithymocyte or antilymphocyte globulin (as first-line immunosuppressive therapy). We are unable to make firm recommendations regarding the choice of intervention for treatment of acquired severe aplastic anemia.

Immunosuppressive therapy without hematopoietic growth factor exposure in pediatric acquired aplastic anemia

Immunosuppressive therapy (IST) is recommended for children with acquired aplastic anemia (AA) who lack a human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-matched sibling donor for hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). Hematopoietic growth factors have often been included in IST supportive care, but prolonged exposure may increase the risk of secondary clonal evolution. The authors evaluated response, survival, and the incidence of clonal evolution following cyclosporine-based IST without hematopoietic growth factor exposure in a population-based pediatric cohort, identified retrospectively. Forty-five patients with a median age of 7.3 years (range 1.2-17.0 years) were included. Partial (PR) and complete (CR) response was achieved in 82% and 64%, at a median of 55 days (range 11-414 days) and 7.6 months (range 2.8-82.2 months), respectively. Patients with associated seronegative hepatitis had an increased likelihood of PR and CR on multivariate analyses (PR: hazard ratio [HR] 3.15, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.40, 7.11; CR: HR 2.99, 95% CI 1.35, 6.62), whereas older children were less likely to achieve IST response than children younger than 5 years at diagnosis. Five- and 10-year overall survival was 96% ± 4% and 90% ± 7%, respectively, and 5-year failure-free survival was 63% ± 8%. There was no infection-related mortality, although 16.4% of patients had at least 1 episode of documented bacteremia. The 5-year cumulative incidence of relapse was 12.9% and of clonal evolution was 3.2%. The authors conclude that children with AA who receive IST without hematopoietic growth factor support have excellent response and survival outcomes and a low incidence of clonal evolution.

First-line matched related donor hematopoietic stem cell transplantation compared to immunosuppressive therapy in acquired severe aplastic anemia

Introduction

Acquired severe aplastic anemia (SAA) is a rare and progressive disease characterized by an immune-mediated functional impairment of hematopoietic stem cells. Transplantation of these cells is a first-line treatment option if HLA-matched related donors are available. First-line immunosuppressive therapy may be offered as alternative. The aim was to compare the outcome of these patients in controlled trials.

Methods

A systematic search was performed in the bibliographic databases MEDLINE, EMBASE, and The Cochrane Library. To show an overview of various outcomes by treatment group we conducted a meta-analysis on overall survival. We evaluated whether studies reported statistically significant factors for improved survival.

Results

26 non-randomized controlled trials (7,955 patients enrolled from 1970 to 2001) were identified. We did not identify any RCTs. Risk of bias was high except in 4 studies. Young age and recent year of treatment were identified as factors for improved survival in the HSCT group. Advanced age, SAA without very severe aplastic anemia, and combination of anti-lymphocyte globulin with cyclosporine A were factors for improved survival in the IST group. In 19 studies (4,855 patients), summary statistics were sufficient to be included in meta-analysis. Considerable heterogeneity did not justify a pooled estimate. Adverse events were inconsistently reported and varied significantly across studies.

Conclusions

Young age and recent year of treatment were identified as factors for improved survival in the transplant group. Advanced age, SAA without very severe aplastic anemia, and combination of anti-lymphocyte globulin with cyclosporine A were factors for improved survival in the immunosuppressive group. Considerable heterogeneity of non-randomized controlled studies did not justify a pooled estimate. Adverse events were inconsistently reported and varied significantly across studies.

Outcomes of matched sibling and alternative donor stem cell transplantation for 26 children with severe aplastic anemia

In this study, we reported the outcomes of hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) as a treatment modality for pediatric patients admitted over the past 20 years in a single institute. From January 1989 to January 2007, 26 patients with a median age of 8 years underwent 14 matched sibling donor (MSD) and 12 alternative donor (AD) transplantations. Two patients received second transplantation successfully after primary graft failure and late graft rejection. Two patients who received transplantation from matched unrelated donors (MUD) died of sepsis, and one of them also had a graft failure at death. The overall 5-year survival rate was 92.1%: 83.3% for AD transplantation and 100% for MSD transplantation. Grade II acute graft versus host disease (GVHD) developed in 3 patients, and extensive chronic GVHD developed in 2 patients. An interval of more than 6 months from diagnosis to transplantation was the major poor prognostic factor for our patients' survival. Thus, in our experience, HSCT from a MSD remains the first choice of treatment for pediatric patients with severe aplastic anemia. For patients without MSD, transplantation from an AD can also result in long-term survival. Earlier transplantation after diagnosis can also result in better outcomes.

Outcome of unrelated donor stem cell transplantation for children with severe aplastic anemia

For children with severe aplastic anemia (SAA) who fail immunosuppressive therapy and lack a human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-matched sibling donor, unrelated donors provide a source of hematopoietic stem cells. Data from 195 children with acquired SAA who underwent unrelated donor transplantation between 1989 and 2003 were analyzed. Neutrophil recovery (86% at day-28) was higher with total body irradiation-containing conditioning regimen and in younger recipients (aged < or =16 years) receiving grafts from older donors (aged >40 years). Recovery was lower after mismatched transplants and transplantations prior to 1997. Mortality rates were higher after mismatched transplants, in recipients with a poor performance score, and when the interval between diagnosis and transplantation was longer than 4 years. When restricted to donor-recipient pairs with allele-level HLA typing (8-loci; n = 118), mortality rates were also higher after mismatched transplants and older recipients receiving grafts from older donors; 5-year probabilities of overall survival after HLA-A, -B, -C, -DRB1 matched and mismatched transplants adjusted for donor and recipient age were 57% and 39%, respectively (P = 0.008). The data suggest that unrelated donor transplantation is an acceptable alternative for children; early referral for transplantation and identification of an HLA-matched (allele-level) donor offers the best outcome.

Favorable outcome with allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation in pediatric acquired aplastic anemia patients

The data of allogeneic HSCT in nine children with acquired AA between June 1998 and July 2006 were analyzed retrospectively. The median duration of time to neutrophil and platelet engraftment was 18 and 25 days, respectively. None of the patients had primary graft failure. Two (22.2%) patients developed acute GVHD and of these, one (11.1%) was Grade 1, and the other (11.1%) was Grade 3. Although the study group was composed of higher risk patients, including six of nine resistant to previous immunosuppressive treatment, eight had multiple not irradiated or filtered transfusion histories and one of the cases was only 5/6 HLA-compatible with his donor, the five-yr overall and EFS was 100%, and all recipients are alive without any graft failure. This may be attributed to the dose adjusted use of ATG according to individual transfusion history and gradual tapering of CsA and cessation at least nine months after allogeneic HSCT.

Preceding immunosuppressive therapy with antithymocyte globulin and ciclosporin increases the incidence of graft rejection in children with aplastic anaemia who underwent allogeneic bone marrow transplantation from HLA-identical siblings

The incidence of graft rejection was determined in 66 children with acquired aplastic anaemia (AA) following bone marrow transplantation (BMT) from a related donor. Eleven of 65 evaluable patients experienced either early or late rejection. Multivariate analysis identified previous immunosuppressive therapy with antithymocyte-globulin (ATG) and ciclosporin (CsA) as a risk factor for graft rejection (relative risk: 16.6, P = 0.001). Patients who received ATG and CsA had a significantly lower probability of failure-free survival than those who did not (69.7 +/- 6.2% vs. 87.9 +/- 8.0%, P = 0.044). These results suggest that BMT should be instituted immediately in children with severe AA who have human leucocyte antigen-identical siblings.

Successful treatment of severe aplastic anemia in children using standardized immunosuppressive therapy with antithymocyte globulin and cyclosporine A

BACKGROUND

Given the heterogeneity of published data in US children, we sought to evaluate outcomes of a standardized immunosuppressive therapy (IST) regimen for severe aplastic anemia (SAA) at The Children's Hospital (Denver, CO).

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the records of 16 children diagnosed from 1990 to 2003 and treated by IST, among whom 14 received the standardized regimen of antithymocyte globulin (ATG) and cyclosporine A (CsA). Serial hematologic parameters, complications, transfusion requirements, and time to response were assessed.

RESULTS

One child who died from a pre-existing Aspergillus infection prior to expected IST response was excluded from the analysis. Overall (transfusion-independent) response to IST was 100% (13/13), without any relapses or clinically evident leukemic/myelodysplastic transformations after a median follow-up time of 4.4 years (range: 10 months-13.3 years).

CONCLUSIONS

This report documents excellent outcome using combination ATG and CsA IST for pediatric SAA.

The impact of Asian descent on the incidence of acquired severe aplastic anaemia in children

Previous studies have suggested an increased incidence of acquired severe aplastic anaemia in Asian populations. We evaluated the incidence of aplastic anaemia in people of Asian descent, using a well-defined paediatric (0-14 years) population in British Columbia, Canada to minimize environmental factors. The incidence in children of East/South-east Asian descent (6.9/million/year) and South Asian (East Indian) descent (7.3/million/year) was higher than for those of White/mixed ethnic descent (1.7/million/year). There appeared to be no contribution by environmental factors. This study shows that Asian children have an increased incidence of severe aplastic anaemia possibly as a result of a genetic predisposition.

Immunosuppressive treatment of acquired aplastic anemia and immune-mediated bone marrow failure syndromes

Modern therapeutic strategies for the treatment of acquired aplastic anemia are based on the current understanding of its pathophysiology as well as empiric observations. Most cases of aplastic anemia appear to be the result of immune-mediated destruction of hematopoietic cells, which can be approached by stem cell transplantation in younger patients with appropriate histocompatible donors or by immunosuppression to reduce T-cell activity. Popular treatment regimens combine antithymocyte globulin with cyclosporine. Although a majority of patients respond with improved blood counts and achieve transfusion-independence, late clonal complications of myelodysplasia and cytogenetic abnormalities occur in a substantial minority of cases. Additionally, there is no clear algorithm for the treatment of refractory disease. Newer methods of treatment, including high-dose cyclophosphamide and the development of potentially tolerizing combinations of drugs. are under study. Effective therapies for aplastic anemia might also be applied to other T-cell mediated, organ-specific human diseases.

Improved survival in severe acquired aplastic anemia of childhood

Multi-agent immunosuppressive therapy has produced improved survival for severe acquired aplastic anemia in children. Recently, some investigators have suggested that immunosuppressive therapy may replace bone marrow transplantation as first-line therapy for this disorder. To assess its validity, we compared the outcomes of bone marrow transplantation vs immunosuppressive therapy in one institution from 1987 to 1997. We studied 46 consecutive patients less than 18 years of age who presented between January 1987 and April 1997. Inherited marrow failure syndromes and myelodysplastic syndromes were excluded. Patients received immunosuppressive therapy vs bone marrow transplantation based on availability of HLA-matched donors. The main outcome measures were survival, complete marrow and hematological remission, or partial remission but achieving independence from transfusional support. Twenty patients received multi-agent immunosuppressive therapy (cyclosporine, antithymocyte globulin and methylprednisolone); 11 attained complete remission and three partial remission for a transfusion-independent survival of 70%. Six patients died of infectious and hemorrhagic complications. Twenty-six patients were transplanted and 24 (93%) achieved complete remission; one achieved a PR, 25 remain transfusion independent with a median follow-up of 5.9 years or 70 months. One patient developed AML 34 months after successful transplant and one patient died due to graft failure and complications of transplant. There has been a striking improvement in survival for pediatric patients treated with multi-agent immunosuppression in the last decade. However, transplantation results have also improved and this remains the definitive first-line therapy for severe acquired aplastic anemia in this age group.

Long-term outcome of acquired aplastic anaemia in children: comparison between immunosuppressive therapy and bone marrow transplantation

A total of 100 children under the age of 17 years with acquired aplastic anaemia (AA) were initially treated with immunosuppressive therapy (IST) (n = 63) or bone marrow transplantation (BMT) (n = 37) from an HLA-matched family donor. The projected 10-year survival rates were 55 +/- 8% and 97 +/- 3% respectively (P = 0.004). Because the IST group included 11 non-responders who were salvaged by BMT from an HLA-matched unrelated donor, we compared failure-free survival (FFS) between the groups. The probability of FFS at 10 years was 97 +/- 3% for the BMT group, compared with 40 +/- 8% for the IST group (P = 0.0001). Seven patients evolved to myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) with monosomy 7 and the estimated cumulative incidence of MDS 10 years after diagnosis was 20 +/- 7% in the IST group. We compared the outcome of children treated with IST during the two consecutive periods of 1983-91 (group A, n = 40) and 1991-8 (group B, n = 23) to assess the impact of combined therapy with antithymocyte globulin and cyclosporin. The probability of FFS at 7 years follow-up was the same in the two groups (50 +/- 8% vs. 40 +/- 15%, P = 0.40). We recommend BMT as first-line therapy in paediatric severe AA patients with an HLA-matched family donor. Alternative donor BMT is recommended as salvage therapy in patients who relapse or do not respond to initial IST.

Hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation using unrelated cord-blood versus matched sibling marrow in pediatric bone marrow failure syndrome: one center's experience

Hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation (HSCT) is an effective mode of therapy in pediatrics for the treatment of both malignant and non-malignant disorders. We compared the course of children transplanted with unrelated umbilical cord blood (UCB) to those transplanted with allogeneic sibling bone marrow (BM) for bone marrow failure syndromes. Thirteen patients with a median age of 6.3 years were transplanted for the following diseases between April 1992 and November 1997: myelodysplastic syndromes, aplastic anemia, Diamond-Blackfan anemia, myelofibrosis, paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria, osteopetrosis and dyskeratosis congenita. The stem cell source was BM in ten patients and UCB in three. We retrospectively examined the conditioning regimens, stem cell source and dose, days to engraftment, survival and complication rate to see whether there was a significant advantage in using one source over the other. The median time to an absolute neutrophil count > 500 per microL was 25 days for UCB patients and 16 days for BM patients. The median time to a platelet count > 20,000 per microL was 55 days for UCB patients and 22 days for BM patients. The 100-day mortality was 66% in UCB patients and 20% in BM patients. The overall mortality rates were 66% and 40%, respectively. Three patients died prior to engraftment. Seven patients (54%) were still alive as of May 1999 with a median follow-up of 1574 days post-transplant. The patients transplanted with BM had faster engraftment and lower rates of graft-versus-host disease, 100-day mortality and overall mortality. HLA-matched sibling BM is preferred as a source but transplantation using unrelated UCB is still an option in treating pediatric bone marrow failure syndromes.

Improved prognosis for acquired aplastic anaemia

This study compared the prognosis of patients treated for aplastic anaemia at Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children from 1973-88 (group A; n = 38) with a more recent cohort from 1989-96 (group B; n = 37). The two groups were similar in terms of clinical history, age, and severity of aplasia. The main treatment differences included the use of androgen treatment in group A (21 of 38 patients) but not in group B, and the addition of cyclosporin A to immunosuppressive treatment for 14 patients in group B. Actuarial survival at eight years' follow up was significantly better for group B (84%; 95% CI, 68% to 93%) than for group A (45%; 95% CI, 30% to 60%), because of improved outcome for both immunosuppressive treatment (86% v 39%) and bone marrow transplantation (93% v 56%). There was no evidence for late clonal disorders or secondary malignancies in survivors in either group. The prognosis for aplastic anaemia has improved greatly in recent years so that over 80% of children are long term survivors.

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for severe aplastic anemia: the Hong Kong scenario

Severe aplastic anemia (SAA) is a disease associated with high mortality. For young patients with HLA identical siblings, allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) offers the best chance of cure. Favourable results have also been reported using immunosuppressive therapy (IST). Transplantation is usually favoured for patients below 45 years of age. We report our experience of 11 allogeneic and one syngeneic BMT for adult Chinese patients with SAA, over a 4-year period from 1991 to 1995. Ten of the 12 (83 per cent) patients had received and failed prior IST including anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG) before being referred for BMT. Neutrophil and platelet engraftment was successful in 11 of them (92 per cent) and nine were completely transfusion independent after transplantation. Their overall 3-year survival was 67 per cent. The compromised overall result was due to a number of cases transplanted after a long time delay. No patient transplanted beyond 3 years from the initial time of diagnosis of SAA achieved long-term marrow engraftment, and they all eventually succumbed. On univariate analysis, a longer time delay and hence a larger amount of blood products exposure, were highly significantly statistically associated with inferior marrow engraftment and patient survival. Other factors including age, iron status, infused cell dose and the conditioning protocol were not found to significantly affect engraftment and survival. Graft versus host disease was clinically mild or absent in most patients. This may be related to ethnicity or previous ATG exposure. In conclusion, early allogeneic BMT was a safe and effective treatment in our small series of patients with SAA failing IST.