High-dose methotrexate and asparaginase for the treatment of children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: why and how?

Folinic acid over rescue of high dose methotrexate: How problematic citations conserve discredited concepts

BACKGROUND

The outdated axiom that the dose of Folinic acid (FA) rescue used after high dose Methotrexate (HDMTX) should be kept to a minimum in order to prevent a reduction of prognosis ("over rescue") continues to be expressed even though the concept has been seriously challenged. Study aim The ways "problematic citations" are used to support an old theory, such as this, was examined.

RESULTS

Ten patterns of "problematic citation" use were identified. In 8 of these patterns the articles used were scientifically sound and the problem was with the articles citing them. However in 2 other pattens, the articles and their conclusions were flawed and citing them, apparently, resulted from accepting the presented data or conclusions as sound and valid. The patterns were 1. Claims based on data that are not present in the cited article. 2. Selective inclusion of data from cited articles. 3. Citation of misleading data presented only in the abstract. 4. Reporting trends as statistically significant. 5. Copying the citations used by others without checking the article. 6. Acceptance of illusionary truth in spite of knowledge to the contrary. 7. Citation of reports not relevant to the population under discussion 8. Presenting opinions as facts without any citation. 9. Selective presentation of data sets that support the thesis while ignoring the data sets that show the opposite results. 10. Use of a title expressing what the authors intended to show but not what was found.

IMPLICATIONS

The containing acceptance of this old insupportable conjecture, in part, because of "problematic citations" has resulted in unnecessary neurocognitive damage to patients and may have resulted in the misconception that it is the outcome of HDMTX that may have lead to its abandonment in favour of more toxic therapies. Realisation that this is a significant problem in data analysis should lead authors and reviewers to be even more carefully in checking all references. The importance of high-quality reviews is clearly evident. The effect of "Canonization of false facts" is a serious impairment to the acceptance of new hypotheses that better express reality and could lead to improved treatment results. Authors are advised only to cite articles they have read in entirety not relying on the title, abstract or previous use and to check the content of citations before submission.

Folate During Antifolate Chemotherapy: What We Know... and Do Not Know

The nutrient folate is essential for normal cell growth and development. Enzymes that require folate as a cofactor have been common targets for chemotherapeutic agents. Limited clinical guidance is available regarding optimal levels of dietary or supplemental folate intake during antifolate chemotherapy to meet the goals of minimizing treatment-related toxicity yet preserving treatment effectiveness. Patients with higher folate intake may experience less treatment-related toxicities; however, the concern is that folate may interfere with the effectiveness of the antifolate treatment and possibly support tumor growth. This article will review folate and antifolate metabolism and review the current body of knowledge regarding the interactions between folates and antifolates. Future research in this area should include evaluation of pretreatment folate status and dietary and supplemental folate intake before, during, and after treatment.

Challenging the clinical relevance of folinic acid over rescue after high dose methotrexate (HDMTX)

THE HYPOTHESIS

The use of adequate folinic acid rescue (in clinically relevant doses) after high dose methotrexate will prevent neurotoxicity without reducing treatment results.

METHODS

A literature search was performed to test the hypothesis that no evidence for the existence of folinic acid over-rescue of high-dose methotrexate (MTX) in clinically relevant situations exists (evidence that too much folinic acid reduced cure rate).

EMPIRICAL DATA

Examples of folinic acid over-rescue after lower doses of MTX were found and has been cited as evidence of over rescue of high dose MTX. Mega doses of folinic acid, used when toxic levels of MTX occurred, also could neutralize the MTX effect. Data were found to support the contention that higher levels of MTX require disproportionally higher folinic acid doses for rescue. Careful examination of the available studies after HDMTX yielded more convincing alternative explanations for reduction in cure rate than over rescue. Little convincing evidence for the existence of over rescue after HDMTX was found.

DISCUSSION

The rescue of high-dose MTX with an appropriate dose of folinic acid that can prevent toxicity, especially neurotoxicity, was not shown to reduce the therapeutic effect. No evidence was found that higher doses of folinic acid after high dose MTX reduces the therapeutic effect.

CONSEQUENCES OF THE HYPOTHESIS

Acceptance of the hypothesis can prevent harm being caused (especially brain damage) by reversing the trend of dose reduction in FA rescue. The recognition that the use of higher folinic acid doses is safe, can prevent neurotoxicity, and does not reduce prognosis has important implications for the development of effective non toxic treatment protocols.

Peg-asparaginase for acute lymphoblastic leukemia

IMPORTANCE OF THE FIELD

Asparaginase is a prominent component of pediatric and adolescent treatment for acute lymphoblastic leukemia. These treatment regimens are now being employed in adults. Knowledge of the efficacy and toxicity of asparaginase preparations is essential when using these treatments. AREAS COVERED BY THIS REVIEW: The search terms used were asparaginase, leukemia, pegylated, oncaspar, adolescent and young adult. Literature was searched in Pubmed/Medline with no limitations on year of publication. Abstracts from the American Society of Hematology meetings and the American Society of Clinical Oncology were searched from 2004 - 2008 using the same terms.

WHAT THE READER WILL GAIN

The reader will gain knowledge of the tolerability and efficacy of pegylated asparaginase when treating acute lymphoblastic leukemia.

TAKE HOME MESSAGE

Pegylated asparaginase is generally well tolerated in adult patients with efficacy that appears to be at least equivalent to native asparaginase preparations.

Pretreatment Plasma Folate Modulates the Pharmacodynamic Effect of High-Dose Methotrexate in Children with Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia and Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma: “Folate Overrescue” Concept Revisited

Background: To evaluate the influence of pretreatment plasma folate concentrations on methotrexate exposure in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia/non-Hodgkin lymphoma treated with high-dose methotrexate, we assessed time profiles of plasma homocysteine, folate, and vitamin B12 concentrations in children treated with high-dose methotrexate with leucovorin rescue.

Methods: We analyzed 98 treatment courses. The study endpoints were to determine how methotrexate exposure is related to homocysteine accumulation and whether it is influenced by pretreatment plasma folate.

Results: Peak concentrations of homocysteine increased from the start of the intravenous infusion through cessation of methotrexate therapy up to time point t42, when this trend was reversed by administration of folinic acid. The area under the curve (AUC) for plasma homocysteine showed decreasing course-to-course tendencies with a statistically significant decrease only between courses 1 and 2 (P ≤0.05), indicating decreased whole-body homocysteine accumulation in response to administration of consecutive methotrexate courses. Therapeutic courses with low initial folate concentrations (≤10 nmol/L) gave significantly higher responses in homocysteine accumulation expressed both as hcysAUC0–66 h and the peak t42 homocysteine concentrations than did courses with initial folate >10 nmol/L. Correspondingly, in the courses with low initial folate, peak plasma concentrations of methotrexate were significantly higher than in courses with high precourse concentrations of plasma folate.

Conclusion: Endogenous pretreatment plasma folate modulates the magnitude of the methotrexate effect, providing support for a “folate overrescue” concept.