Protection against retroviruses are owing to a different form of immunity. An RNA-based molecular immunity hypothesis

On the general theory of the origins of retroviruses

Background

The order retroviridae comprises viruses based on ribonucleic acids (RNA). Some, such as HIV and HTLV, are human pathogens. Newly emerged human retroviruses have zoonotic origins. As far as has been established, both repeated infections (themselves possibly responsible for the evolution of viral mutations (Vm) and host adaptability (Ha)); along with interplay between inhibitors and promoters of cell tropism, are needed to effect retroviral cross-species transmissions. However, the exact modus operadi of intertwine between these factors at molecular level remains to be established. Knowledge of such intertwine could lead to a better understanding of retrovirology and possibly other infectious processes. This study was conducted to derive the mathematical equation of a general theory of the origins of retroviruses.

Methods and results

On the basis of an arbitrarily non-Euclidian geometrical "thought experiment" involving the cross-species transmission of simian foamy virus (sfv) from a non-primate species Xy to Homo sapiens (Hs), initially excluding all social factors, the following was derived. At the port of exit from Xy (where the species barrier, SB, is defined by the Index of Origin, IO), sfv shedding is (1) enhanced by two transmitting tensors (Tt), (i) virus-specific immunity (VSI) and (ii) evolutionary defenses such as APOBEC, RNA interference pathways, and (when present) expedited therapeutics (denoted e²D); and (2) opposed by the five accepting scalars (At): (a) genomic integration hot spots, gIHS, (b) nuclear envelope transit (NMt) vectors, (c) virus-specific cellular biochemistry, VSCB, (d) virus-specific cellular receptor repertoire, VSCR, and (e) pH-mediated cell membrane transit, (↓_pH CMat). Assuming As and Tt to be independent variables, IO = Tt/As. The same forces acting in an opposing manner determine SB at the port of sfv entry (defined here by the Index of Entry, IE = As/Tt). Overall, If sfv encounters no unforeseen effects on transit between Xy and Hs, then the square root of the combined index of sfv transmissibility (√|RTI|) is proportional to the product IO* IE (or ~Vm* Ha* ∑Tt*∑As*Ω), where Ω is the retrovirological constant and ∑ is a function of the ratio Tt/As or As/Tt for sfv transmission from Xy to Hs.

Conclusions

I present a mathematical formalism encapsulating the general theory of the origins of retroviruses. It summarizes the choreography for the intertwined interplay of factors influencing the probability of retroviral cross-species transmission: Vm, Ha, Tt, As, and Ω.

RNAi as an antiviral therapy

There are a dozen or so viruses that will continue to be a serious global health threat for many years to come, mainly due to their chronic nature. These include hepatitis C virus (HCV), human papillomavirus viruses (HPVs), West Nile virus and human herpes viruses (i.e., HSV, CMV, EBV, HHV-8, etc.). However, HIV-1 infections will remain at the top of the list due to its high prevalence and the significant mortality and morbidity from AIDS. The development of a suitable vaccine against HIV-1 remains an important area of public interest. The initial hope of identifying the specific anti-HIV-1 antigenic epitopes that can protect HIV-1-infected individuals and serve as a potential vaccine has been replaced by the realisation that we have yet to identify a clear correlation of protective immunity against HIV-1 infection. Understanding the anti-HIV-1 protective factors and their potential role in the development of a vaccine or inexpensive therapy remains one of the major obstacles in HIV-1 research. In the last quarter century--since the realisation of AIDS--previous studies have established that the role of humoral or cellular immune responses in protecting human hosts against HIV-1 have been inconclusive. Moreover, most of the publicized and awaited clinical trials on vaccines have failed. The recent discovery of RNA interference (RNAi) has raised the possibility of developing a new generation of vaccines that can stymie human viruses, particularly HIV-1 replication at various stages of its life cycle at the intracellular level. Various transcripts in the HIV-1 life cycle can be targeted, and specific small double-stranded RNAs (small interfering RNAs) can be developed against these HIV-1-specific targets. However, some recent data suggests that RNAi-based therapeutics against this virus should be viewed with strong caution. Specifically, there are multiple factors that make HIV-1 a difficult infection to 'cure' because of HIV-1 latency. The changing nature of HIV-1 genomes and the possible presence of microRNAs within the HIV-1 genes can suppress RNAi directed against HIV-1 gene targets. Thus, HIV-1 would be a difficult epidemic to overcome by RNAi-based therapeutics.

RNA interference: the molecular immune system

Introduction of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) into cells expressing a homologous gene triggers RNA interference (RNAi), or RNA-based gene silencing (RBGS). The dsRNA degrades corresponding host mRNA into small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) by a protein complex containing Dicer. siRNAs in turn are incorporated into the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) that includes helicase, RecA, and exo- and endo-nucleases as well as other proteins. Following its assembly, the RISC guides the RNA degradation machinery to the target RNAs and cleaves the cognate target RNA in a sequence-specific, siRNA-dependent manner. RNAi has now been documented in a wide variety of organisms, including plants, fungi, flies, worms, and more recently, higher mammals. In eukaryotes, dsRNA directed against a range of viruses (i.e., HIV-1, RSV, HPV, poliovirus and others) and endogenous genes can induce sequence-specific inhibition of gene expression. In invertebrates, RNAi can be efficiently triggered by either long dsRNAs or 21- to 23-nt-long siRNAs. However, in jawed vertebrates, dsRNA longer than 30 bp can induce interferon and thus trigger undesirable side effects instead of initiating RNAi. siRNAs have been shown to act as potent inducers of RNAi in cultured mammalian cells. Many investigators have suggested that siRNAs may have evolved as a normal defense against endogenous and exogenous transposons and retroelements. Through a combination of genetic and biochemical approaches, some of the mechanisms underlying RNAi have been described. Recent data in C. elegans shows that two homologs of siRNAs, microRNAs (miRNAs) and tiny noncoding RNAs (tncRNAs) are endogenously expressed. However, many aspects of RNAi-induced gene silencing, including its origins and the selective pressures which maintain it, remain undefined. Its evolutionary history may pass through the more primitive immune functions of prokaryotes involving restriction enzymes that degrade plasmid DNA molecules that enter bacterial cells. RNAi has evolved further among eukaryotes, in which its wide distribution suggests early origins. RNAi seems to be involved in a variety of regulatory and immune functions that may differ among various kingdoms and phyla. We present here proposed mechanisms by which RBGS protects the host against endogenous and exogenous transposons and retroelements. The potential for therapeutic application of RBGS technology in treating viral infections such as HIV is also discussed.