Do sacrificial bonds affect the viscoelastic and fracture properties of bone?

Phosphorylation of Extracellular Bone Matrix Proteins and Its Contribution to Bone Fragility

Phosphorylation of bone matrix proteins is of fundamental importance to all vertebrates including humans. However, it is currently unknown whether increase or decline of total protein phosphorylation levels, particularly in hypophosphatemia-related osteoporosis, osteomalacia, and rickets, contribute to bone fracture. To address this gap, we combined biochemical measurements with mechanical evaluation of bone to discern fracture characteristics associated with age-related development of skeletal fragility in relation to total phosphorylation levels of bone matrix proteins and one of the key representatives of bone matrix phosphoproteins, osteopontin (OPN). Here for the first time, we report that as people age the total phosphorylation level declines by approximately 20% for bone matrix proteins and approximately 30% for OPN in the ninth decade of human life. Moreover, our results suggest that the decline of total protein phosphorylation of extracellular matrix (ECM) contributes to bone fragility, but less pronouncedly than glycation. We theorize that the separation of two sources of OPN negative charges, acidic backbone amino acids and phosphorylation, would be nature's means of assuring that OPN functions in both energy dissipation and biomineralization. We propose that total phosphorylation decline could be an important contributor to the development of osteoporosis, increased fracture risk and skeletal fragility. Targeting the enzymes kinase FamC20 and bone alkaline phosphatase involved in the regulation of matrix proteins' phosphorylation could be a means for the development of suitable therapeutic treatments. © 2018 American Society for Bone and Mineral Research.

Sex dependent mechanical properties of the human mandibular condyle

The mandibular condyle consists of articular cartilage and subchondral bone that play an important role in bearing loads at the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) during static occlusion and dynamic mastication. The objective of the current study was to examine effects of sex and cartilage on 1) static and dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) based dynamic energy storage and dissipation for the cartilage-subchondral bone construct of the human mandibular condyle, and 2) their correlations with the tissue mineral density and trabecular morphological parameters of subchondral bone. Cartilage-subchondral bone constructs were obtained from 16 individual human cadavers (9 males, 7 females, 79.00±13.10 years). After scanning with micro-computed tomography, the specimens were subjected to a non-destructive compressive static loading up to 7N and DMA using a cyclic loading profile (-5±2N at 2Hz). After removing the cartilage from the same specimen, the series of loading experiments were repeated. Static stiffness (K) and energy dissipation (W), and dynamic storage (K'), loss (K'') stiffness, and energy dissipation (tan δ) were assessed. Gray values, which are proportional to degree of bone mineralization, and trabecular morphological parameters of the subchondral bone were also measured. After removal of the cartilage, static energy dissipation significantly decreased (p<0.009) but dynamic energy dissipation was not influenced (p>0.064). Many subchondral bone properties were significantly correlated with the overall mechanical behavior of the cartilage-subchondral bone constructs for males (p<0.047) but not females (p>0.054). However, after removal of cartilage from the constructs, all of the significant correlations were no longer found (p>0.057). The current findings indicate that the subchondral bone is responsible for bearing static and dynamic loading in males but not in females. This result indicates that the female condyle may have a mechanically disadvantageous TMJ loading environment.

Bone microdamage, remodeling and bone fragility: how much damage is too much damage?

Microdamage resulting from fatigue or 'wear and tear' loading contributes to bone fragility; however, the full extent of its influence is not completely understood. Linear microcracks (∼50-100 μm) and diffuse damage (clusters of sublamellar-sized cracks) are the two major bone microdamage types, each with different mechanical and biological consequences. Healthy bone, due to its numerous microstructural interfaces and its ability to affect matrix level repair, deals effectively with microdamage. From a material standpoint, healthy bone behaves much like engineering composites like carbon-fiber reinforced plastics. Both materials allow matrix damage to form during fatigue loading and use microstructural interfaces to dissipate energy and limit microcrack propagation to slow fracture. The terms fracture toughness and 'toughening mechanism', respectively, describe mechanical behavior and microstructural features that prevent crack growth and make it harder to fracture a material. Critically, toughness is independent of strength. In bone, primary toughening features include mineral and collagen interfaces, lamellae and tissue heterogeneity among osteons. The damage tolerance of bone and other composites can be overcome with sustained loading and/or matrix changes such that the microstructure no longer limits microcrack propagation. With reduced remodeling due to aging, disease or remodeling suppression, microdamage accumulation can occur along with loss of tissue heterogeneity. Both contribute additively to reduced fracture toughness. Thus, the answer to the key question for bone fragility of how much microdamage is too much is extremely complex. It ultimately depends on the interplay between matrix damage content, internal repair and effectiveness of matrix-toughening mechanisms.

In vitro bone exposure to strontium improves bone material level properties

In rats treated with strontium ranelate, the ultimate load of intact bone is increased and associated with changes in microstructure and material level properties. Evaluation by micro-computed-tomography-based finite element analysis has shown that these changes independently contribute to the improvement of bone strength induced by strontium ranelate treatment. However, the mechanism by which Sr ion acts on bone material level properties remains unknown. The vertebrae of intact female rats were exposed overnight to 0.5, 1 or 2M chloride salt solutions of Sr, Ca and Ba. The latter two were used to assess the specificity of Sr. Bone material level properties were evaluated by measuring hardness, elastic modulus and working energy in a nanoindentation test. Wavelength dispersive X-ray spectroscopy provided semi-quantitative elemental analysis and mapping. Incubation with Sr rendered bone stiffer, harder and tougher. Among the divalent ions tested, Sr had the greatest effect. Sr affinity was also assessed on in vivo treated bone specimens. After in vitro exposure, the highest improvements were observed in ovariectomized rats. However, anti-osteoporotic treatments did not influence the capacity of Sr to modify bone material level properties. Our findings demonstrated that in vitro incubation with Sr selectively improved bone material level properties, which may contribute to the macroscopic increase of bone properties observed under Sr therapy.

Physiologic load-bearing characteristics of autografts, allografts, and polymer-based scaffolds in a critical sized segmental defect of long bone: an experimental study

Background

To address the challenge of treating critical sized intercalary defects, we hypothesized that under physiologic cyclic loading, autografts, allografts, and scaffolds loaded with and without human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) would have different biomechanical characteristics.

Methods

Using a rat femoral defect model, 46 rats were assigned to four groups, ie, autograft (n = 12), allograft (n = 10), scaffold (n = 13), and scaffold with hMSCs (n = 11). The scaffold groups used a 5 mm segment of scaffold composed of 80% poly-ε-caprolactone and 20% hydroxyapatite. Rats were sacrificed 4 months postoperatively, and the repairs were assessed radiographically and biomechanically.

Results

Autograft and allograft groups exhibited the most bridging callus, while the scaffold/hMSCs group had more callus than the scaffold repairs. Although signs of radiographic healing did not accurately reflect restoration of mechanical properties, addition of hMSCs on the scaffold enhanced bone formation. The scaffold alone group had significantly lower elastic and viscous stiffness and higher phase angles than other repairs and the contralateral controls. Addition of hMSCs increased the elastic and viscous stiffness of the repair, while decreasing the phase angle.

Conclusion

Further comparative analysis is needed to optimize clinical use of scaffolds and hMSCs for critical sized defect repairs. However, our results suggest that addition of hMSCs to scaffolds enhances mechanical simulation of native host bone.

Determinants of microdamage in elderly human vertebral trabecular bone

Previous studies have shown that microdamage accumulates in bone as a result of physiological loading and occurs naturally in human trabecular bone. The purpose of this study was to determine the factors associated with pre-existing microdamage in human vertebral trabecular bone, namely age, architecture, hardness, mineral and organic matrix. Trabecular bone cores were collected from human L2 vertebrae (n = 53) from donors 54–95 years of age (22 men and 30 women, 1 unknown) and previous cited parameters were evaluated. Collagen cross-link content (PYD, DPD, PEN and % of collagen) was measured on surrounding trabecular bone. We found that determinants of microdamage were mostly the age of donors, architecture, mineral characteristics and mature enzymatic cross-links. Moreover, linear microcracks were mostly associated with the bone matrix characteristics whereas diffuse damage was associated with architecture. We conclude that linear and diffuse types of microdamage seemed to have different determinants, with age being critical for both types.

A viscoelastic, viscoplastic model of cortical bone valid at low and high strain rates

The stress-strain behavior of cortical bone is well known to be strain-rate dependent, exhibiting both viscoelastic and viscoplastic behavior. Viscoelasticity has been demonstrated in literature data with initial modulus increasing by more than a factor of 2 as applied strain rate is increased from 0.001 to 1500 s(-1). A strong dependence of yield on strain rate has also been reported in the literature, with the yield stress at 250 s(-1) having been observed to be more than twice that at 0.001 s(-1), demonstrating the material viscoplasticity. Constitutive models which capture this rate-dependent behavior from very low to very high strain rates are required in order to model and simulate the full range of loading conditions which may be experienced in vivo; particularly those involving impact, ballistic and blast events. This paper proposes a new viscoelastic, viscoplastic constitutive model which has been developed to meet these requirements. The model is fitted to three sets of stress-strain measurements from the literature and shown to be valid at strain rates ranging over seven orders of magnitude.

Cartilage stress-relaxation is affected by both the charge concentration and valence of solution cations

OBJECTIVE

Understanding the mechanical functions of specific cartilage molecules such as aggrecan is important for understanding both healthy cartilage and disease progression. Cartilage is primarily composed of chondrocytes and an extracellular matrix consisting of multiple biopolymers, ions, and water. Aggrecan is one matrix biopolymer which consists of a core protein and multiple anionic glycosaminoglycans. Previous research has demonstrated that the stiffness of extracted aggrecan decreases under increased solution cation concentration, and the purpose of this study was to determine whether changes in solution ion concentration resulted in changes in tissue-level viscoelastic properties.

METHODS

Middle-zone explants of bovine calf patellofemoral cartilage were harvested and cultured overnight before mechanical testing. Repeated stress-relaxation and cyclical loading tests were performed after equilibration in solutions of 0.15 M and 1 M NaCl and 0.075 M and 0.5 M CaCl(2). A stretched exponential model was fit to the stress-relaxation data. Storage and loss moduli were determined from the cyclical loading data.

RESULTS

Changes in ionic strength and species affected both stress-relaxation and cyclical loading of cartilage. Stress-relaxation was faster under higher ionic strength. CaCl(2) concentration increases resulted in decreased peak stress, while NaCl increases resulted in decreased equilibrium stress. Storage and loss moduli were affected differently by NaCl and CaCl(2).

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that cartilage stress-relaxation proceeds faster under higher concentrations of solution cations, consistent with the theory of polymer dynamics. These data demonstrate the complexity of cartilage mechanical properties and suggest that aggrecan stiffness may be important in tissue-level cartilage viscoelastic properties.

The effect of yield damage on the viscoelastic properties of cortical bone tissue as measured by dynamic mechanical analysis

We have previously shown, using Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA), that the presence of a defect in cortical bone tissue affects the apparent viscoelastic properties of that bone. However, mechanically induced damage is more complex than a machined defect making it difficult to predict its effect on bone viscoelasticity. We performed DMA measurements before and after introduction of yield damage into cortical bone beams from sheep radii. The specimens were placed in a DMA machine and baseline measurements of storage modulus (E1) and loss factor (tandelta) were performed using a 3-point bending configuration for a frequency range of 1-10 Hz. Measurements were done in all four bending directions (cranial, caudal, medial, and lateral) in random order. After subjecting the specimens to monotonic yield damage in a servohydraulic testing machine with the load applied to the cranial surface, oscillatory tests were repeated. To supplement results from the current experiment, additional analyses were performed on data from experiments where bone was either cut or fatigue-loaded between viscoelasticity measurements. Introduction of mechanical damage increased tan delta and frequency sensitivity of E1, consistent with the assertion that increased energy dissipation in damaged bone might contribute to its increased resistance to fatigue and fracture.