NOD2, not yet: con

Genetic literacy and patient perceptions of IBD testing utility and disease control: a randomized vignette study of genetic testing

BACKGROUND

Findings from inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) genome-wide association studies are being translated clinically into prognostic and diagnostic indicators of disease. Yet, patient perception and understanding of these tests and their applicability to providing risk information is unclear. The goal of this study was to determine, using hypothetical scenarios, whether patients with IBD perceive genetic testing to be useful for risk assessment, whether genetic test results impact perceived control, and whether low genetic literacy may be a barrier to patient understanding of these tests.

METHODS

Two hundred fifty seven patients with IBD from the Johns Hopkins gastroenterology clinics were randomized to receive a vignette depicting either a genetic testing scenario or a standard blood testing scenario. Participants were asked questions about the vignette and responses were compared between groups.

RESULTS

Perceptions of test utility for risk assessment were higher among participants responding to the genetic vignette (P < 0.001). There were no significant differences in perceptions of control over IBD after hypothetical testing between vignettes (P = 0.24). Participant responses were modified by genetic literacy, measured using a scale developed for this study. Participants randomized to the genetic vignette who scored higher on the genetic literacy scale perceived greater utility of testing for risk assessment (P = 0.008) and more control after testing (P = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with IBD perceive utility in genetic testing for providing information relevant to family members, and this appreciation is promoted by genetic literacy. Low genetic literacy among patients poses a potential threat to effective translation of genetic and genomic tests.

Genetic dissection of inflammatory bowel disease: unravelling etiology and improving diagnostics

Over the past 10 years, remarkable advances in the mapping and identification of genes involved in susceptibility to inflammatory bowel disease have been witnessed. Most notable among these advances has been the discovery of variants in the CARD15, DLG5, SLC22A4 and SLC22A5 genes, which are associated with increased risk of inflammatory bowel disease or specifically Crohn's disease. These discoveries have provided critical new insights into the molecular pathophysiology of inflammatory bowel disease and the pathways wherein genetic and environmental factors such as enteric bacterial flora may interact to trigger immune dysregulation and intestinal inflammation. This review will outline the discovery of these inflammatory bowel disease-related genes, describe future prospects for further inflammatory bowel disease gene identification, and consider the impact of a genetic understanding of inflammatory bowel disease on future clinical practice.

Estimating risks of common complex diseases across genetic and environmental factors: the example of Crohn disease

BACKGROUND

Progress has been made in identifying mutations that confer susceptibility to complex diseases, with the prospect that these genetic risks might be used in determining individual disease risk.

AIM

To use Crohn disease (CD) as a model of a common complex disorder, and to develop methods to estimate disease risks using both genetic and environmental risk factors.

METHODS

The calculations used three independent risk factors: CARD15 genotype (conferring a gene dosage effect on risk), smoking (twofold increased risk for smokers), and residual familial risk (estimating the effect of unidentified genes, after accounting for the contribution of CARD15). Risks were estimated for high-risk people who are siblings, parents and offspring of a patient with CD.

RESULTS

The CD risk to the sibling of a patient with CD who smokes and carries two CARD15 mutations is approximately 35%, which represents a substantial increase on the population risk of 0.1%. In contrast, the risk to a non-smoking sibling of a patient with CD who carries no CARD15 mutations is 2%. Risks to parents and offspring were lower.

CONCLUSIONS

High absolute risks of CD disease can be obtained by incorporating information on smoking, family history and CARD15 mutations. Behaviour modification through smoking cessation may reduce CD risk in these people.