Metastasizing "benign" fibrous histiocytoma of the skin: a report of two additional cases and review of the literature

Perineural Invasion as a Clue to Malignant Behavior in a Dermatofibroma

Dermatofibroma (DF) represents one of the most common mesenchymal proliferations of the skin. Their recurrence rate, even when incompletely excised, is very low, whereas the atypical, aneurysmal, and cellular variants have recurrence rates of up to 20% each. Extraordinary rare malignant lesions with metastases to lymph nodes and/or lung have been described. We report a 64-year-old woman with a long history (years) of a skin lesion on her right arm that became painful during the last months. Histologically, it consisted of a conventional cellular DF in which perineural invasion was present. Subsequently, the lesion showed a clinically aggressive course with recurrences, sarcomatous transformation, and pulmonary metastases. Given that no predictive morphological features have been identified to separate classical benign DF from rare metastasizing forms, perineural invasion in an otherwise conventional DF could be a histopathologic clue for an adverse prognosis and should provoke a closer clinical follow-up.

Phosphohistone-H3 and Ki67: Useful Markers in Differentiating Dermatofibroma From Dermatofibrosarcoma Protuberans and Atypical Fibrohistiocytic Lesions

Dermatofibromas (DF) are common, benign, skin tumors, usually easily differentiated from dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans (DFSP) by the presence of a relative low cellularity, lesser degree of infiltration of subcutaneous tissue, and immunohistochemical pattern (eg, FXIIIa in DF and CD34 in DFSP). Atypical fibrohistiocytic lesions (AFL) have features intermediate to DF and DFSP (trunk location, storiform pattern, infiltration of the subcutaneous tissue, and focal expression of both CD34 and Factor XIIIa). It is unclear if mitotic counts/degree of proliferation is helpful to distinguish DF from DFSP. To study the mitotic rate and proliferation index in DF, AFL/DFSP, anti-ki67, and anti-PHH3 were performed on 10 cases of DF (including 4 cellular DF), 10 standard DFSP, and 2 AFL. The proliferation index and mitotic figures were counted per square millimeter in a "hotspot" (in a fashion similar to mitotic counts in melanoma). All cases of DF showed much higher Ki67 proliferation index (P = 0.0001) along with increased mitotic figures both on H&E and with anti-PHH3 (P = 0.0001) when compared to AFL/DFSP. Our data indicate that DF has a higher proliferation index and mitotic counts when compared to superficial/peripheral portion of AFL and DFSP. This finding may be helpful in the differential diagnosis among these fibrohistiocytic lesions.

Clinical and histological patterns of dermatofibroma without gross skin surface change: A comparative study with conventional dermatofibroma

BACKGROUND

Dermatofibroma sometimes clinically presents as a nodular lesion without gross skin surface change. Clinicopathologic features of this variant of dermatofibroma have not been evaluated.

AIMS

To assess clinicopathologic features of dermatofibroma presenting as a subcutaneous nodule.

METHODS

This study reviewed the clinical and histological features of 42 cases of subcutaneous dermatofibromas and compared them with 95 cases of conventional dermatofibroma.

RESULTS

Dermatofibroma without gross skin surface change was associated with a shorter pre-diagnosis duration than conventional dermatofibroma. Increase in size during the pre-diagnosis period was significantly more frequent in the conventional type. In addition, these dermatofibromas were more likely than the conventional type to occur in the head and neck region. Although tumor depth was deeper than in the conventional type, less than half of the dermatofibromas without gross skin surface change were found histologically to be "subcutaneous" or "deep-penetrating dermatofibroma". Subcutaneous extension was more frequent in these dermatofibromas while focal stromal hyalinization and hemosiderin deposits were more common in the conventional type.

LIMITATIONS

This study is a retrospective, single center design.

CONCLUSION

The present study suggests that dermatofibroma without gross skin surface change is a variant type with distinct clinical and histological features that distinguish them from conventional dermatofibroma.

Metastasizing "benign" cutaneous fibrous histiocytoma: a clinicopathologic analysis of 16 cases

Cutaneous fibrous histiocytoma (FH) is considered a benign tumor; however, certain types of FH have been shown to have a tendency for local recurrence, and there are rare reported cases of metastasis. In this study, 16 cases of morphologically benign FH with locoregional or distant metastasis were identified in consult files. Pathologic features of primary, recurrent, and metastatic tumors, as well as clinical outcome, were evaluated. Nine were male and 7 were female patients; mean age was 42 years (range, 3 to 68 y). Primary tumors arose on the leg in 5 patients, buttock in 1, trunk in 3, shoulder in 3, neck in 2, and finger in 1. The primary site in 1 case was unknown. Fifteen primary tumors available for review involved the dermis; 6 extended into the superficial subcutis. Tumor size ranged from 1 to 5 cm (median 3.2 cm). Histologically, primary tumors showed characteristic features of FH, being composed in most cases of a polymorphous population of bland spindle and histiocytoid cells in a mixed storiform and fascicular growth pattern with admixed foam cells, multinucleate cells, and inflammatory cells in varying proportions. Histologic variants included 11 cellular (2 with mixed atypical and cellular features), 2 aneurysmal, 1 atypical, and 1 epithelioid type. All tumors showed entrapment of hyalinized collagen bundles. Mitotic activity ranged from <1 to 13/10 HPF. Focal necrosis was seen in 1 primary tumor. Ten patients had local tumor recurrence; 4 patients had multiple local recurrences. Time to first recurrence ranged from 6 weeks to 13 years. The local recurrences of 1 tumor showed increased cytologic atypia, but recurrences were otherwise morphologically similar to primary tumors. Metastases occurred 0 to 180 months after diagnosis (median 17 mo) and involved the lungs (12 patients), lymph nodes (8), soft tissues (6), and liver (1). Five patients developed multiple satellite nodules in the region of the primary tumor. Metastases were morphologically similar to the primary tumors. So far, 6 patients died of disease, with a median time to death of 64 months (range, 10 to 168 mo). Four patients are alive with metastatic disease. Two patients are disease free at last follow-up, and 1 patient died of unrelated disease. Metastasis of morphologically benign cutaneous FH is an extremely rare but clinically aggressive event. Primary tumors tend to be large and cellular, but aggressive behavior cannot be predicted on morphologic grounds alone; however, early or frequent local recurrence may warrant closer clinical follow-up.

Malignant dermatofibroma: clinicopathological, immunohistochemical, and molecular analysis of seven cases

Dermatofibroma (cutaneous fibrous histiocytoma) represents a common benign mesenchymal tumor, and numerous morphological variants have been described. Some variants of dermatofibroma are characterized by an increased risk of local recurrences, and there are a few reported metastasizing cases. Unfortunately, an aggressive behavior cannot be predicted reliably by morphology at the moment, and we evaluated the value of array-comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) in this setting. Seven cases of clinically aggressive dermatofibromas were identified, and pathological and molecular features were evaluated. The neoplasms occurred in four female and in three male patients (mean age was 33 years, range 2-65 years), and arose on the shoulder, buttock, temple, lateral neck, thigh, ankle, and cheek. The size of the neoplasms ranged from 1 to 9 cm (mean: 3 cm). An infiltration of the subcutis was seen in five cases. Two neoplasms were completely excised, whereas an incomplete or marginal excision was reported in the remaining cases. Local recurrences were seen in six cases (time to the first recurrence ranged from 8 months to 9 years). Metastases were noted between 3 months and 8 years after diagnosis in six patients. Two patients died of disease, and two patients are alive with disease. Histologically, the primary tumors showed features of cellular dermatofibroma (four cases), cellular/aneurysmal dermatofibroma (one case), atypical/cellular dermatofibroma (one case), and classical dermatofibroma (one case). Mitotic figures ranged from 3 to 25 per 10 high-power fields, and focal necrosis was present in five cases. Interestingly, malignant transformation from cellular dermatofibroma to an obvious spindle cell/pleomorphic sarcoma was seen in one primary and in one recurrent neoplasm. Five neoplasms showed chromosomal aberrations by array-CGH, suggesting that these changes may represent an additional diagnostic tool in the recognition of cases of dermatofibroma with a metastatic potential.

Subcutaneous dermatofibroma

Dermatofibroma (DF) is usually confined to the dermis and the overlying epidermis is usually hyperplastic. Although DF with deep subcutaneous extension is commonly encountered, purely subcutaneous DF is uncommon. In this review, we describe a case of a 41-year-old male patient who presented with a painless, subcutaneous, hard papule on the left thigh. After the skin had been incised the lesion was totally removed, and histopathology revealed a subcutaneous dermatofibroma.

Cutaneous fibrohistiocytic tumours - an update

The term 'fibrohistiocytic' tumour is a descriptive designation without histogenetic connotation for a group of heterogeneous lesions that share morphological features of histiocytes and fibroblasts on light microscopy. However, over the years it has become apparent that many so-called 'fibrohistiocytic' tumours are largely composed of relatively undifferentiated mesenchymal cells, but can also show areas of myofibroblastic differentiation. This review focuses on the clinical and histological features as well as differential diagnosis of so-called fibrohistiocytic tumours. Special emphasis is given to more recently described histological variants of fibrous histiocytoma, e.g. cellular, epithelioid, aneurysmal and atypical fibrous histiocytoma, to angiomatous and plexiform fibrous histocytoma (plexiform fibrohistiocytic tumour), lesions that are not true variants of fibrous histiocytomas but have erroneously been designated such, and to atypical fibroxanthoma. The literature on metastasizing fibrous histiocytoma is also reviewed.

Deep "benign" fibrous histiocytoma: clinicopathologic analysis of 69 cases of a rare tumor indicating occasional metastatic potential

Benign fibrous histiocytoma (FH) is one of the most common mesenchymal neoplasms of the skin. Several histologic variants of cutaneous FH have been described, some of which also have distinct clinical features including a propensity for local recurrence. Deep benign FH is an uncommon and poorly recognized clinical subtype that arises in subcutaneous or deep soft tissue. Only a single small series of these neoplasms has been published, and their clinical behavior is not well characterized. In this study, we report the clinicopathologic features of 69 deep FH retrieved from our consultation files. The patients included 41 males and 28 females, ranging in age from 6 to 84 years (median, 37 y). The most common anatomic location was the extremities (58%); the remainder arose on the head and neck (22%), trunk (11%), and in the deep soft tissue of the retroperitoneum, mediastinum, or pelvis (9%). All lesions arising in nonvisceral soft tissue were subcutaneous. The tumors ranged from 0.5 to 25 cm in size (median, 3.0 cm) and were well circumscribed grossly and microscopically. All tumors were composed of bland ovoid to spindle cells arranged in a storiform pattern with admixed lymphocytes. Multinucleate giant cells, osteoclastic giant cells, and/or foam cells were present in 59% of cases, whereas the other 41% were cytologically monomorphic, often resembling cellular FH. Other common findings included a hemangiopericytomalike vascular pattern (42%) and stromal hyalinization (39%). Four cases were classified as atypical deep FH due to the presence of scattered markedly pleomorphic spindle cells within an otherwise histologically typical lesion. The median mitotic rate was 3/10 HPF; 10 cases (14%) had >10 mitoses/10 HPF. Necrosis (2 cases) and lymphovascular invasion (1 case) were rare. Immunohistochemistry revealed expression of CD34 in 20/50 cases (40%), smooth muscle actin in 15/40 (38%), and focal desmin in 1/12 (8%). Of the 37 patients for whom clinical follow-up was available (median, 40 mo), 8 (22%) had a local recurrence; in all 8 cases, the tumor had been marginally or incompletely excised. Metastases occurred in 2 patients (5%), both of whom ultimately died of disease; however, this number is likely exaggerated due to consultation bias. The metastasizing tumors were large (6 and 9 cm) and 1 had tumor necrosis but they were otherwise histologically identical to the nonmetastasizing lesions. In summary, deep FH has many histologic features in common with cutaneous cellular FH; however, it usually has a more diffusely storiform pattern than the latter, is well circumscribed, and may have striking hemangiopericytomalike vessels. Similar to the cellular, aneurysmal, and atypical variants of FH, deep FH recurs in approximately 20% of cases and may rarely metastasize.

Mitosis in dermatofibroma: a worrisome histopathologic sign that does not necessarily equal recurrence

BACKGROUND

High mitotic rate is a worrying histopathologic feature that pathologists occasionally face when diagnosing benign fibrous histiocytoma (BFH), that otherwise seem to be benign. The clinical significance of this histologic feature has not been completely studied, because no studies on large series of BFH have been carried out, concerning mitotic rate as the only worrisome morphologic sign, in relation with recurrence.

METHODS

In order to study how common a high mitotic rate is in BFH, which do not present any other worrisome morphological signs, we studied 200 cases from our archives and counted the number of mitosis per 10 high power fields (HPFs) in all of them. We selected those cases that had a mitotic number of 4 or more mitosis per 10 HPF. We also performed the immunohistochemical study with MIB-1 antibody (DakoCytomation, Denmark A/S). The clinical histories of the patients were also reviewed, in order to find out if there had been any recurrence.

RESULTS

Four BFH presented four or more mitosis in ten HPF. None of them had presented any recurrence or metastasis, and the follow-up time was at least for 71 months.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that common BFH can occasionally present a high mitotic rate and still show a benign behavior.