Patient-based outcomes after Ilizarov surgery in resistant clubfeet

Outcomes of Management of Severe Clubfoot among Children by Ilizarov External Fixator

Introduction

Clubfoot remains the most common birth defect involving the musculoskeletal system. There are various surgical and non-surgical treatment options available for the management of clubfoot. Using the minimally invasive Ilizarov external fixator method has been reported to have good success rates and fewer complications.

Materials and methods

This study aimed at analysing the morphological and functional outcomes of treating severe clubfoot by Ilizarov external fixator among children from July 2017 to March 2020. Thirty-two children who had either failed Ponseti / surgery or neglected with 44 clubfeet of Dieglio type III and type IV were included in the study. A short-leg walking cast was applied for an additional six weeks after removing of Ilizarov frame and additionally followed by an orthosis for another six weeks. Outcomes were measured by the functional rating system by Laaveg and Ponseti and interpretation done at 1 month and 12 months after the ankle-foot arthrosis.

Results

About 86.4% of the patients had good or excellent outcome scores. Pre and post-Demeglio scores and functional rating scores were statistically significant (p<0.001) by using Paired t-test. Complications included superficial pin site infections in 13 feet (29.54%), 5 feet (11.36%) had claw toes, 3 feet (6.81%) had linear skin necrosis and 2 feet (4.54%) had calcaneal fractures which were manageable with minor interventions.

Conclusion

The study findings highlighted that the Ilizarov external fixator method can correct complex foot deformities of severe clubfoot with minimum morbidity. Further larger and long-term studies are needed to investigate the effects of the stiff hindfoot and possible degenerative changes on the function and symptoms of these patients as adults.

Clinico-Radiological and Functional Outcome of Difficult Talipes Equinovarus Deformity Corrected With an Ilizarov Fixator

Relapsed, resistant, and untreated congenital talipes equinovarus poses significant challenges in view of functional outcome following conventional serial casting and soft tissue release procedures. The Ilizarov ring fixator here offers significant possibilities as an extended conservative treatment modality. The aim of the present study was to critically evaluate effectiveness of the Ilizarov ring fixator with regard to radiological, clinical, and functional outcomes, in the difficult clubfeet. The study was carried out on patients presenting with relapsed, resistant, or untreated congenital talipes equinovarus deformity, who underwent deformity correction using the Ilizarov ring fixator application. All patients were reviewed at 6 monthly intervals for over 3 years following fixator removal with an objective clinical, radiological, and functional assessment. Twenty-three patients with 30 clubfeet were enrolled in our study. The mean age was 8.3 ± 3.6 (range 4-17) years. The postoperative clinical, radiological, and functional scores showed statistically significant improvement among all patients when compared with the preoperative data. All 30 feet developed varying complications during treatment with pin track infections being the most common. However, they were managed while continuing the distraction correction process. The Ilizarov ring fixator is an effective and reliable solution for difficult and challenging clubfeet. However, one must be aware of a strict adherence to a bracing protocol to avoid recurrence of deformities. A regular periodical functional and clinical follow up must be ensured among these children for a favorable outcome.

Simultaneous lateral column shortening along with differential distraction by Joshi's external stabilization system for rigid neglected clubfoot correction

Correction of rigid clubfoot in an older child by gradual differential distraction using the Ilizarov's device or Joshi's external stabilization system (JESS) is a time-consuming procedure. We simultaneously combined the lateral column shortening by cuboid wedge resection along with the differential distraction by application of JESS fixator for the treatment of severe, rigid, neglected, or relapsed congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) foot deformity in 30 feet in 18 children with mean age of 5.3 years and mean follow-up of 27.6 months. The mean pretreatment Pirani score was 5.3 which improved to mean Pirani score after treatment of 1.4. Excellent results were obtained in 22 (71.33%) feet, good results in four (13.33%) feet, and poor results in four (13.33%) feet. The average period for distraction in our series was 6.3 weeks, and total average period of fixator in place was 11.2 weeks. To conclude, lateral column shortening with JESS application simultaneously gives early good to excellent short-term results, and the combination of techniques permits rapid correction of deformity, and thus reducing the time for which the fixator is in place and hence has better acceptance by the patient.

Relapse following use of Ponseti method in idiopathic clubfoot

PURPOSE

We assessed the pattern of relapse as well as the correlation between the number of casts required for correction and Pirani and Dimeglio scores at presentation, and age at presentation. We hypothesized that the Ponseti method would be effective in treatment of relapsed clubfoot as well.

METHODS

We evaluated 115 idiopathic clubfeet in 79 children presenting with relapse following treatment by the Ponseti method. The mean age was 33.8 months with mean follow-up of 24 months. All patients were assessed for various patterns of relapsed deformities. Quantification of deformities was done using the Pirani and Dimeglio scores. All relapsed feet were treated by a repeat Ponseti protocol.

RESULTS

Non-compliance to a foot abduction brace was observed to be the main contributing factor in relapse, in 99 clubfeet (86%). Combination of three static deformities (equinus, varus and adduction) together was observed most commonly (38.3% feet). Overall, relapse of equinus deformity was noted most commonly followed by adduction. A painless plantigrade foot was obtained in all 115 feet with a mean of five casts. In all, 71 feet (61.7%) underwent percutaneous tenotomy. A total of 15 feet (13%) required tibialis anterior tendon transfer. Re-relapse rate in group 1 was 21% compared with 12.6% in group 2 and overall 16.5%.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that the Ponseti method is effective and the preferred initial treatment modality for relapsed clubfeet. Surgical intervention should be reserved for residual deformity only after a fair trial of Ponseti cast treatment. Regular follow-up and strict adherence to brace protocol may reduce future relapse rates. Further research is required to identify high-risk feet and develop individualized bracing protocol.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Ilizarov technique combined with limited adjunctive surgical procedures for correction of relapsed talipes equinovarus in children

Objective To evaluate the efficacy and safety of using the Ilizarov invasive distraction technique combined with limited surgical operations in the treatment of relapsed talipes equinovarus in children. Methods This retrospective study analysed the outcomes of paediatric patients with relapsed talipes equinovarus who were treated with the Ilizarov technique with moderate open limited soft tissue or bony operations. The International Clubfoot Study Group (ICFSG) classification system score was used to evaluate the deformities before and after surgery. Results The study evaluated 16 feet in 14 patients (nine boys). The correction time ranged from 6 to 12 weeks. The mean duration of frame application was 5.9 months. The gait was improved significantly in all patients. At final follow-up, the mean ankle dorsiflexion and plantarflexion ranges were 8.3° and 34.6°, respectively. The talocalcaneal angle improved from 10.0° preoperatively to 28.3° postoperatively in the anteroposterior plane; and from 4.1° preoperatively to 42.1° postoperatively in the lateral plane. The differences in the angle of plantarflexion, dorsiflexion, range of motion of the ankle joint and talocalcaneal angles pre- and postoperation were significant. Conclusions These current findings suggest that the Ilizarov technique combined with limited surgery effectively corrects relapsed talipes equinovarus in children.

Ilizarov technique and limited surgical methods for correction of post-traumatic talipes equinovarus in children

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of using Ilizarov invasive distraction technique combined with limited surgical operations in the treatment of post-traumatic talipes equinovarus in children.

METHODS

Eighteen cases of post-traumatic deformed feet in 15 patients who received the treatment of Ilizarov frame application, limited soft-tissue release or osteotomy were selected in this study. After removal of the frame, an ankle-foot orthosis was used continuously for another 6-12 months. Pre- and post-operatively, the International Clubfoot Study Group (ICFSG) score was employed to evaluate the gait and range of motion of the ankle joint. Radiographical assessment was also conducted.

RESULTS

Patients were followed up for 22 (17-32) months. Ilizarov frame was applied for a mean duration of 5.5 (4-9) months. When it was removed, the gait was improved significantly in all the patients. The correction time was 6-8 weeks for patients who underwent soft-tissue release and 8-12 weeks for those with bone osteotomy. At the last follow-up assessment, the differences between pre- and post-operative plantar-flexion angle, dorsiflexion, motion of ankle joint and talocalcaneal angle were significant (all P < 0.05). The observed complications included wire-hole infection in one foot, toe contracture in one, residual deformity in three, recurrence of deformity in two and spastic ischaemia in one foot.

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest that Ilizarov technique combined with limited surgical operation can be considered as an efficient and successful method for correction of post-traumatic talipes equinovarus in children.

Comparative study of complete subtalar release and Joshi's external stabilization system in the management of neglected and resistant idiopathic clubfoot

BACKGROUND

Various procedures have been used for the management of neglected and resistant clubfoot. The aim of our study was to assess the clinical and radiological correction by Joshi's external stabilization system (JESS fixator) and Simons subtalar release in resistant and neglected idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus in children between the ages of 1 and 2 years.

METHODS

A total of 50 resistant and neglected clubfeet were randomly divided into two equal groups of 25 feet each. Group I was treated with JESS fixator and group II was treated with complete subtalar release as described by Simons. Assessment of correction achieved was done both clinically and radiologically. Functional outcome was assessed with Ponseti scale.

RESULTS

The change in clinical deformity and radiological correction of deformity were statistically significant within each group, but not significant when compared to each other. In group I excellent results were obtained in 17 (68%) and good in 8 (32%) of the feet. In group II, excellent results were found in 16 (64%) and good in 9 (36%) feet out of the 25 feet. Pin-site infections were seen in two cases in group I and serious skin problems occurred in two feet in group II.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that there were no statistical significant differences between the outcomes of the two techniques in this short-term follow-up of 2.4 years. Thus, functional distraction using JESS can be utilized as an alternative method in cases of neglected and resistant clubfoot.

Talectomy and tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis with intramedullary nail fixation for treatment of equinus deformity in adults

BACKGROUND

Severe equinovarus foot deformity in adults is a challenging problem. Conservative treatment rarely is effective, and operative options are limited. The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of talectomy and tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis with intramedullary nail fixation for the treatment of severe equinovarus deformity in adults.

METHODS

Twelve patients (average age 39 years, range 15-70 years) with severe equinovarus deformities of the foot were treated with talectomy and tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis with intramedullary nail fixation between March 2010 and February 2013. Average follow-up was 20 months (range 10-37 months).

RESULTS

Tibiocalcaneal fusion was achieved in all patients at an average of 12 weeks (range 8-17 weeks). Preoperatively, all patients had severe, irreducible equinovarus deformities; at last follow-up, almost all feet had mild residual deformity, but were plantigrade and did not require a brace or orthosis. The average AOFAS ankle score improved from 41.1 (range 8-66) preoperatively to 78.4 (range 67-86) postoperatively (P = .02). There was a similar improvement in the average VAS score from 6.3 (range 2-10) preoperatively to 0.8 (range 0-4) postoperatively (P = .02).

CONCLUSION

The combination of talectomy and tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis was effective in correcting severe rigid equinovarus deformity in adults. Removal of the talus resulted in laxity of the soft tissues, making correction of the deformity easier. Tibiocalcaneal arthrodesis achieved a stable foot without the problems associated with talectomy alone.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, case series.

Treatment of the neglected and relapsed clubfoot

Treatment of the neglected and the relapsed clubfoot is one of the most controversial topics in pediatric foot care. This article reviews the breadth of treatment options for practicing podiatrists or orthopedists with a specialty in complex clubfoot treatment. Discussion includes the appropriate circumstances for the use of the different procedures presented and the author's preferred treatment algorithm, based on 15 years of treating neglected, relapsed, and nonidiopathic clubfeet.

Does short-term application of an Ilizarov frame with transfixion pins correct relapsed clubfoot in children?

BACKGROUND

Treatment of relapsed clubfoot after soft tissue release in children is difficult because of the high recurrence rate and related complications. Even though the Ilizarov method is used for soft tissue distraction, there is a high incidence of recurrence after removal of the Ilizarov frame owing to previous contracture of soft tissue and a skin scar.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We asked (1) whether transfixation of midfoot joints by temporary K wires during the consolidation stage after short-term application of an Ilizarov frame would maintain correction of the relapsed clubfoot clinicoradiologically and (2) whether this method would reduce the rate of recurrence and related complications in patients with a skin scar from previous surgery.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed 18 patients (19 feet) with relapsed clubfeet who underwent correction by soft tissue distraction using an Ilizarov ring fixator, between March 2005 and June 2008. The mean age of the patients was 8 ± 2 years (range, 4-15 years). K wire fixation for the midfoot joints combined with a below-knee cast were used during the consolidation stage. The minimum followup was 2 years (mean, 4.5 years; range, 2-6 years).

RESULTS

The average duration of frame application was 5 weeks; the mean duration of treatment was 11 weeks. At last followup, 16 of 19 feet were painless and plantigrade and only three of 19 feet had recurrence. The mean preoperative clinical American Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score had increased at last followup (57 versus 81). The values of the AP talocalcaneal, AP talo-first metatarsal, and lateral calcaneo-first metatarsal angles improved after treatment. The three recurrent clubfeet were treated by corrective osteotomies and Ilizarov frame application.

CONCLUSION

This method could maintain the correction of relapsed clubfoot in children and reduce the recurrence rate and complications regardless of the presence of a skin scar owing to previous surgery.

The management of the neglected congenital foot deformity in the older child with the Taylor spatial frame

BACKGROUND

Neglected or inadequately treated rigid congenitally deformed feet in older children are a nightmarish challenge for the child, the parents, and the orthopaedic surgeon. Because of the multiplicity of spatial deformities exhibited by these feet and legs, it was hypothesized that correction using the Taylor spatial frame (TSF) would decrease morbidity, facilitate correction, and minimize treatment time in children from remote regions with extremely rigid deformed feet.

METHODS

Recent experience with the management of 11 such feet (Dimeglio type IV) in 9 children with an average age of 9.2 years using the TSF has been gratifying. Six children had associated leg length discrepancy, which was corrected by concomitant tibial lengthening. All feet underwent soft tissue releases, whereas forefoot and/or hindfoot osteotomies were performed in 7 feet.

RESULTS

All children attained plantigrade, functional feet, and were fully ambulatory and capable of wearing normal footwear. Complications were minor consisting of pin tract infections, residual metatarsus varus in 3, and wound dehiscence in 1. There were no neurovascular events. This was attributed to the slower 3 plane correction using the TSF technique as well as the elimination of the need for plaster immobilization thus allowing direct monitoring of the foot and limb.

CONCLUSIONS

The rigid foot deformity in the older child can be safely and effectively corrected with the aid of the TSF, which facilitates a 3 plane correction and concomitant limb lengthening.

Resistant clubfoot deformities managed by Ilizarov distraction histogenesis

BACKGROUND

Resistant clubfoot deformities of the foot and ankle remain a difficult problem even for the most experienced surgeon. We report a series of neglected resistant clubfoot deformities treated by limited surgery and Ilizarov distraction histogenesis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty one patients with 27 feet having resistant clubfoot deformities were managed by Ilizarov distraction histogenesis from April 2005 to May 2008. The mean age was 12 years (range 8-20 years). A limited soft tissue dissection like percutaneous Achilles sheath tenotomy and plantar fasciotomy were done. Progressive correction of the deformities was achieved through the standard and simple Ilizarov frame construct setting. After removal of Ilizarov frame, a short leg walking cast was used for an additional 6 weeks, followed by an ankle foot orthrosis for 3 months.

RESULTS

The mean followup period was 18.7 months (range 20-36 months). The mean duration of fixator application was 3.6 months (range 3-5 months). At the time of removal of the fixator, a plantigrade foot was achieved in 25 feet and gait was improved in all patients. There was residual varus hind foot deformity in two patients. Out of 27 feet, 3 (11.11%) were rated as excellent, 17 (62.96%) as good, 5 (18.51%) as fair, and 2 (7.40%) as poor according to Reinkerand Carpenter scale. Excellent and good results (74.07%) were considered satisfactory, while fair and poor results (25.92%) were considered unsatisfactory.

CONCLUSION

The short term clinical and functional results of resistant clubfoot deformities with Ilizarov's external fixator is promising and apparently a good option.

The use of the Ilizarov method in management of relapsed club foot

The aim of this article was to evaluate the results of relapsed club foot management using a simple frame construct of Ilizarov external fixator. Between 2003 and 2008, 18 feet in 13 patients with relapsed club feet were treated by Ilizarov external fixator. All patients underwent previous surgery (1-3 operations). Average patient age at the time of the operation was 5.5 years and the average follow-up period was 15.8 months. Midtarsal osteotomy was undertaken in 3 feet and soft tissue distraction was undertaken in 15 feet with no soft tissue release except in 3 feet that needed tendoachillis lengthening. The average time of fixator application was 4.5 months. Out of 18 feet, 2 (11.1%) were rated as excellent, 11 (61.1%) as good, 4 (22.2%) as fair, and 1 (5.6%) as poor. Excellent and good results (72.2%) were considered satisfactory, while fair and poor results (27.8%) were considered unsatisfactory. Thus, the Ilizarov technique gave satisfactory results in cases of relapsed club foot that were difficult to treat by conventional methods. Longer follow-up is needed to assess the achieved correction and to detect any recurrence of the deformity.

The correction of the relapsed club foot by closed distraction

Correction of a relapsed clubfoot deformity by distraction with an external fixator is a recognized alternative to open surgery. Most published series report a good outcome but none are prospective observational studies using the scoring system of the International Clubfoot Study Group (ICFSG). We present a series of 9 relapsed club feet treated with closed gradual distraction using this scoring method.

Ilizarov external fixation in the correction of severe pediatric foot and ankle deformities

Most of the evidence to date on the Ilizarov method in the management of complex foot and ankle deformities in children is based on expert opinion and retrospective case series. Often the technique is used as a salvage option where conventional techniques are inappropriate or have failed. The decision to use the Ilizarov external fixator to an alternative technique depends on several issues: complexity of the pathology, patient compliance, surgeon skills, and the capacity of the institution to manage patients with multidisciplinary requirements. Nevertheless, the Ilizarov method has proved to be a valuable tool for the satisfactory management of many previously unresolved clinical problems. With greater experience and further developments, the exact place of this powerful treatment modality will become clearer and even more successful.

Relapsed clubfoot correction with soft-tissue release and selective application of Ilizarov technique

The Ilizarov technique is an alternative for the treatment of complex foot deformities in children. The authors retrospectively reviewed children with relapsed clubfoot deformity, treated with soft tissue procedures and additional correction with an Ilizarov frame. Twelve consecutive patients (13 feet) with relapsed clubfoot deformity after previous surgical correction were reviewed. Treatment included open releases. An Ilizarov frame was applied as an adjunct in seven patients (mean age of 7.8 years) with severe deformity where complete intraoperative correction was not achieved. Clinical and radiographic assessment was undertaken. The mean Laaveg–Ponseti score, for the 7 feet treated with the Ilizarov frame, was 85.1 after minimum 4 years follow-up. One recurrence of forefoot deformity required metatarsal osteotomies. Postoperative radiographic measurements revealed values that can be considered as normal. Complications included pin tract infections (12% of inserted wires). Flat-topped talus was observed in 3 feet. Deformity correction was possible when soft tissue procedures were combined with the use of Ilizarov technique, in order to support and gradually improve surgical correction.

V osteotomy and Ilizarov technique for residual idiopathic or neurogenic clubfeet

PURPOSE

To report the treatment outcomes of V osteotomy and Ilizarov technique for residual idiopathic or neurogenic clubfeet.

METHODS

13 patients (14 feet) aged 8 to 18 years underwent V osteotomy via the calcaneus and talus, followed by gradual distraction of soft tissue and bone for foot reconstruction. Eight of the clubfeet were idiopathic and had undergone previous surgeries. The remaining 6 were neurogenic and their pathologies were: Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (n=2), myelomeningocele (n=2), neurofibromatosis (n=1), and distal arthrogryposis (n=1). Three of them had undergone previous surgeries. The Ilizarov frames were retained for 3 to 6 months and the patients were followed up for 1.8 to 8.9 years. Range of movement of the ankle and foot, appearance and position, gait, pain, function, and patient satisfaction were assessed according to the modified clubfoot grading system. The talo-1st metatarsal angle was measured on anteroposterior radiographs.

RESULTS

Scores associated with the appearance and position of the foot, and thus patient satisfaction were significantly improved, but not for range of movement, pain, and function. The mean preoperative and final talo-1st metatarsal angles were 39.7 and 8.7 degrees, respectively (p<0.01). Ten feet achieved the plantigrade position, one had residual equinus, and 3 had residual adduction and supination.

CONCLUSION

Patient satisfaction improved significantly despite no major improvement in pain, function, and range of movement of the ankle and foot. This reflects the importance of the appearance and position of the foot, and justifies the decision to undergo this long and demanding procedure.