The Role of Specialty Certification in Career-Long Competence

Emergency physicians perspectives of state continuing medical education requirements for medical licensure

Objectives

This study aims to better understand the perspectives of emergency medicine physicians' on the role that state-mandated, topic-specific continuing medical education (CME) plays in addressing knowledge gaps, its relevance to current emergency practice, its reported burden and costs of CME activities to emergency physicians, and its perceived improvement in patient care.

Methods

A cross-sectional survey was designed by the Coalition of Board-Certified Emergency Physicians (COBCEP) and distributed in February 2023 to all American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM)-certified physicians. Statistical tests of significance (Pearson's chi-square and Fisher's exact test) assessed the cost and time spent on CME as well as the perceived value placed on CME by ABEM-certified physicians to improve patient care. Data were summarized using descriptive statistics.

Results

There were 5562 (13.0%) responses from the 43656 physicians who received the survey-5506 responses were included for analysis. Over half of the physicians (53.0%) had more than 15 years of post-residency practice experience. Most physicians (57.3%) spent less than $5,000 per year on obtaining CME. Most physicians practicing in states with state-mandated, topic-specific CME requirements believed that participation in ABEM continuing certification could be used to reduce the need for state-mandated, topic-specific CME requirements (83.6%) and state-mandated, topic-specific requirements were believed to be unlikely to improve patient care (70.8%).

Conclusions

Although well-intended, state CME requirements may lack relevancy and can, at times, place an undue burden on emergency physicians. Tailoring CME requirements to increase relevance to their patient populations and reduce barriers to completing CME could enhance knowledge translation and improve patient outcomes.

International Medical Graduates and the Physician Workforce

Importance

Physician shortages and the geographic maldistribution of general and specialist physicians impair health care delivery and worsen health inequity in the US. International medical graduates (IMGs) represent a potential solution given their ready supply.

Observations

Despite extensive clinical experience, evidence of competence, and willingness to practice in underserved communities, IMGs experience multiple barriers to entry in the US, including the immigration process, the pathways available for certification and licensing, and institutional reluctance to consider non-US-trained candidates. International medical graduates applying to postgraduate training programs compare favorably with US-trained candidates in terms of clinical experience, prior formal postgraduate training, and research, but have higher application withdrawal rates and significantly lower residency and fellowship match rates, a disparity that may be exacerbated by the recent elimination of objective performance metrics, such as the US Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 score. Once legally in the US, IMGs encounter additional obstacles to board eligibility, research funding, and career progression.

Conclusions and Relevance

International medical graduates offer a viable and available solution to bridge the domestic physician supply gap, while improving workforce diversity and meaningfully addressing the public health implications of geographic maldistribution of general and specialist physicians, without disrupting existing physician stature and salaries. The US remains unable to integrate IMGs until systematic policy changes at the national level are implemented.

Maintenance of Certification-The Value to Patients and Physicians

This Viewpoint discusses the ABIM’s continuing efforts to innovate and streamline maintenance of certification, including the recently launched Longitudinal Knowledge Assessment (LKA), to better accommodate physicians’ schedules and desires for flexibility.