Quantitative Twitch Monitoring: What Works Best and How Do We Know?

Evolution of a laboratory mechanomyograph

Mechanomyography is currently the accepted laboratory reference standard for quantitative neuromuscular blockade monitoring. Mechanomyographs are not commercially available. Previously, a mechanomyograph was built by our laboratory and used in several clinical studies. It was subsequently redesigned to improve its usability and functionality and to accommodate a wider range of hand sizes and shapes using an iterative design process. Each version of the redesigned device was initially tested for usability and functionality in the lab with the investigators as subjects without electrical stimulation. The redesigned devices were then assessed on patients undergoing elective surgery under general anesthesia without neuromuscular blocking drugs. Since the patients were not paralyzed, the expected train-of-four ratio was 1.0. The device accuracy and precision were represented by the train-of-four ratio mean and standard deviation. If issues with the device's useability or functionality were discovered, changes were made, and the redesign processes repeated. The final mechanomyograph design was used to collect 2,362 train-of-four ratios from 21 patients. The mean and standard deviation of the train-of-four ratios were 0.99 ± 0.030. Additionally, the final mechanomyograph design was easier to use and adjust than the original design and fit a wider range of hand sizes. The final design also reduced the frequency of adjustments and the time needed for adjustments, facilitating data collection during a surgical procedure.

Tolerance to preoperative placement of electrodes for neuromuscular monitoring using the Tetragraph™

Background

Quantitative train-of-four (TOF) monitoring has recently been shown to be feasible in infants and children using a novel electromyography (EMG)-based monitor with a pediatric-sized self-adhesive sensor. However, placement of the sensor and initiation of TOF monitoring may require additional time in the operating room (OR), delaying workflow and the time to induction of anesthesia. The current study evaluates the feasibility of placing the self-adhesive sensor in the preoperative holding area in pediatric patients before arrival to the OR.

Methods

Consented pediatric patients undergoing inpatient surgery requiring the administration of NMBAs were enrolled. The EMG electrode was placed along the ulnar nerve on the volar aspect of the distal forearm to provide neurostimulation. After the induction of anesthesia, monitoring was initiated and TOF recording started before the administration of the NMBA. A Likert score (0-10) was used to assess ease of placement, tolerability of the monitor during the preoperative period, and its ability to generate a recorded response in the OR.

Results

The final study cohort included 40 patients with a median age of 3.7 years. Fourteen patients (35%) pulled off the sensor before arrival to the OR and 26 patients (65%) arrived at the OR with the sensor intact and functioning. Older children were more likely to maintain the sensor until arrival to the OR compared to younger patients (median age of 5.24 versus 1 year, P = 0.0521). A median age of 3.7 years correlated with an 80% chance of arriving in the OR with the sensor intact. Application ease and tolerance of the sensor were higher in the group that maintained the sensor until OR arrival.

Conclusion

In patients more than 4 years of age, placement of the self-adhesive sensor for EMG-based TOF monitoring may be feasible. However, in younger patients, additional interventions may be required to achieve a similar success rate.

A compressomyograph train of four monitoring device

The monitoring of the neuromuscular blockade is critical for patient's safety during and after surgery. The monitoring of neuromuscular blockade often requires the use of Train of Four (TOF) technique. During a TOF test two electrodes are attached to the ulnar nerve, and a series of four electric pulses are applied. The electrical stimulation causes the thumb to twitch, and the amount of twitch varies depending on the amount of neuromuscular blockade in patient's system. Current medical devices used to assist anesthesiologists to perform TOF monitoring often require free hand movement and do not provide accurate or reliable results. The goal of this work is to design, prototype and test a new medical device that provides reliable TOF results when thumb movement is restricted. A medical device that uses a pressurized catheter balloon to detect the response thumb twitch of the TOF test is created. An analytical model, numerical study, and mechanical finger testing were employed to create an optimum design. The design is tested through a pilot human subjects study. No significant correlation is reported with subjects' properties, including hand size.

Comparative performance of stimpod electromyography with mechanomyography for quantitative neuromuscular blockade monitoring

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare the Stimpod electromyograph neuromuscular blockade monitor to mechanomyography, which is widely considered to be the reference standard.

METHODS

The Stimpod electromyograph was used with its designated electrode array on the same hand as the mechanomyograph. Pairs of train-of-four measurements were recorded every 0.5-2 min. When the train-of-four count was zero on the electromyograph monitor, pairs of post tetanic count measurements were recorded every 2.5 min, instead of train-of-four measurements. Measurements were recorded from immediately after induction of anesthesia until just before emergence. Stimulation current was set to 60 mA with a duration of 200 microsec. The mechanomyography recording system recorded each twitch waveform for analysis. High resolution electromyograph waveforms were also recorded using a datalogger accessory provided by the manufacturer, facilitating inspection of individual waveforms. The administration of neuromuscular blocking drugs was left up to the discretion of the anesthesia care team.

RESULTS

Twenty-three patients contributed 1,088 data pairs suitable for analysis. Bland-Altman analysis of 415 pairs of train-of-four ratios showed a bias of 0.028 and limits of agreement of -0.18 and 0.24. Two hundred seventy-three train-of-four count data pairs were compared by Cohen's quadratically weighted kappa which was calculated to be 0.44, indicating moderate agreement. Three hundred thirty-eight post tetanic count data pairs were compared by Cohen's quadradically weighted kappa which was calculated to be 0.80, indicating substantial agreement.

CONCLUSION

The electromyograph produced results that were comparable to the mechanomyograph.

Intraoperative electromyographic monitoring in children using a novel pediatric sensor

Background

Train-of-four (TOF) monitoring is essential in optimizing perioperative outcomes as a means to assess the depth of neuromuscular blockade and confirm recovery following the administration of neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBAs). Quantitative TOF monitoring has been limited in infants and children primarily due to lack of effective equipment. The current study evaluates a novel electromyography (EMG)-based TOF monitor with a recently developed pediatric-sized self-adhesive sensor in infants and children.

Methods

Consented pediatric patients undergoing inpatient surgery requiring the administration of NMBAs were enrolled. The EMG electrode was placed along the ulnar nerve on the volar aspect of the distal forearm. The muscle action potentials from the adductor pollicis muscle were recorded throughout surgery at 20-second intervals. Data from the monitor's built-in memory card were later retrieved and analyzed.

Results

The final study cohort included 51 patients who ranged in age from 0.2 to 7.9 years and in weight from 4.2 to 36.0 kilograms. Thirty patients weighed less than 15 kgs. Supramaximal stimulus current intensity (mA) at a pulse width of 200 μsec was 30 mA in 8%; 40 mA in 29%; 50 mA in 16%; and 60 mA in 20% of the patients. Supramaximal stimulus current intensity (mA) at a pulse width of 300 μsec was 50 mA in 4%; 60 mA in 24%. The muscle action potential baseline amplitude was 8.7 ± 3.3 mV and recovered to 7.2 ± 3.7 mV after antagonism of neuromuscular blockade. The average baseline TOF ratio was 100 ± 3% and recovered to 98 ± 7% after antagonism of neuromuscular blockade. No technical issues were noted with application of the sensor or subsequent use of the monitor.

Conclusion

Neuromuscular monitoring can be performed intraoperatively in pediatric patients who are less than 8 years of age using a novel commercially available EMG-based monitor with a recently developed pediatric sensor. The novel sensor allows use of an EMG-based monitor in infants and children in whom acceleromyography or subjective (visual) observation of the TOF response may not be feasible. Automatic detection of neuromuscular stimulating parameters (supramaximal current intensity level, baseline amplitude of the muscle action potential) was feasible in pediatric patients of all sizes including those weighing less than 15 kilograms or when there was limited access to the extremity being monitored.

The impact of electrosurgical devices on electromyography-based neuromuscular monitoring during abdominal laparotomy: a case series

The present study aimed to evaluate the effect of electrosurgical devices on neuromuscular monitoring using an electromyography (EMG)-based neuromuscular monitor during abdominal laparotomy. Seventeen women (aged 32-64 years) undergoing gynecological laparotomy under total intravenous general anesthesia were enrolled in the study. A TetraGraph™ was placed to stimulate the ulnar nerve and to monitor the abductor digiti minimi muscle. After device calibration, train-of-four (TOF) measurements were repeated at intervals of 20 s. Rocuronium 0.6 to 0.9 mg/kg was administered for induction, and additional doses of 0.1 to 0.2 mg/kg were administered to maintain TOF counts ≤ 2 during the surgery. The primary outcome of the study was the ratio of measurement failure. The secondary outcomes of the study were the total number of measurements, the number of measurement failures, and the most extended consecutive number of measurement failures. The data are expressed as median (range). Of the 3091 (1480-8134) measurements, the number of measurement failures was 94 (60-200), resulting in a failure ratio of 3.5% (1.4-6.5%). The most extended consecutive number of measurement failures was 8 (4-13). All attending anesthesiologists were able to maintain and reverse neuromuscular blocks under EMG guidance. This prospective observational study demonstrated that the use of EMG-based neuromuscular monitoring does not seem to be heavily affected by electrical interference during lower abdominal laparotomic surgery. Trial registration This trial was registered in the University Hospital Medical Information Network under registration number UMIN000048138 (registration date; June 23, 2022).

Feasibility of intraoperative quantitative neuromuscular blockade monitoring in children using electromyography

Background:

Quantitative train-of-four (TOF) monitoring remains essential in optimizing anesthetic outcomes by assessing the depth and recovery from neuromuscular blockade. Despite this, residual neuromuscular blockade, defined as a TOF ratio <0.90, remains a concern in both adult and pediatric patients. Quantitative TOF monitoring has seen limited use in infants and children primarily due to a lack of effective equipment. This study evaluates a new electromyography (EMG)-based TOF monitor in pediatric patients undergoing inpatient surgical procedures including laparoscopic (restricted arm access) surgery.

Methods:

Pediatric patients undergoing inpatient surgery requiring the administration of neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBAs) were enrolled. The EMG electrodes were placed along the ulnar nerve on the volar aspect of the arm to provide neurostimulation. The muscle action potentials from the abductor digiti minimi muscle were recorded. Neuromuscular responses were recorded by the device throughout surgery at 20-s intervals until after tracheal extubation. Data recorded on the monitor's built-in memory card were later retrieved and analyzed.

Results:

The study cohort included 100 pediatric patients (62% male). The average age was 11 years (IQR: 8, 13) and the average weight was 39.6 kg (30, 48.7). Automatic detection of supramaximal stimulus was obtained in 95% of patients. The muscle action potential mean baseline amplitude (in mV) was 7.5 mV (6, 9.2). The baseline TOF ratio was 100% (100, 104). After administration of a neuromuscular blocking agent, monitoring of the TOF ratio was successful in 93% of the patients. After antagonism of neuromuscular blockade, monitoring was possible in 94% of patients when using an upgraded algorithm. The baseline amplitude recovered to 6.5 mV (5, 7.8), and the TOF ratio recovered to a mean of 90.1% (90,97) before tracheal extubation.

Conclusion:

Our results indicate that neuromuscular monitoring can be performed intraoperatively in pediatric patients weighing between 20 and 60 kg using the new commercially available EMG-based monitor. Automatic detection of neuromuscular stimulating parameters (supramaximal current intensity level and baseline amplitude of the muscle action potential) by an adult neuromuscular monitor is feasible in pediatric patients receiving nondepolarizing neuromuscular blocking agents.