The biomechanics of ipsilateral intertrochanteric and femoral shaft fractures: a comparison of 5 fracture fixation techniques

Mechanical evaluation of revision surgery for femoral shaft nonunion initially treated with intramedullary nailing: Exchange nailing versus augmentation plating

INTRODUCTION

Exchange nailing (EN) or augmentation plating (AP) has been employed to treat nonunions after intramedullary nailing for femoral shaft fractures. Although instability is a factor in hypertrophic nonunion, mechanical evaluations have been limited because the contribution of the callus to fracture site stability varies with healing. Our previous study illustrated the potential for evaluation using a finite element analysis (FEA) that incorporates callus material properties. This study aimed to mechanically evaluate revision surgery for nonunions using FEA.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A quantitative computed tomography-based FEA was performed on virtual revision models of a patient with suspected nonunion after intramedullary nailing. In addition to the initial nailing model (IN) with an 11-mm diameter (D) and 360-mm length (L), four EN models with D12mm (EN1), D13mm (EN2), D12mm-L400mm (EN3), and D13mm-L400mm (EN4) nails and three AP models with 5- (AP1), 6- (AP2), and 7-hole (AP3) plates were created. As with bone, callus was assigned inhomogeneous material properties derived from density based on an empirical formula. The hip joint reaction force and muscle forces at maximum load during the gait cycle were applied. The volume ratio of the callus at the fracture site with a tensile failure risk of ≥1 (tensile failure ratio) and bone fragment movement were evaluated.

RESULTS

The tensile failure ratio was 11.6 % (IN), 10.1 % (EN1), 6.3 % (EN2), 10.9 % (EN3), 6.2 % (EN4), 6.4 % (AP1), 7.2 % (AP2), and 7.7 % (AP3), respectively. The bone fragment movement showed an opening on the lateral side with the initial intramedullary nailing. However, both revision surgeries reduced the opening, leading to compression except in the EN1 model. The proximal bone fragments were internally rotated relative to the distal fragments, and the rotational instability was more suppressed in models with lower tensile failure ratio.

CONCLUSIONS

For EN, the increase in diameter, not length, is important to suppress instability. AP reduces instability, comparable to a 2 mm increase in nail diameter, and screw fixation closer to the fracture site reduces instability. This study suggest that AP is mechanically equivalent to EN and could be an option for revision surgery for femoral shaft nonunions.

Biomechanical optimization of the far cortical locking technique for early healing of distal femur fractures

This finite element study optimized far cortical locking (FCL) technology for early callus formation in distal femur fracture fixation with a 9-hole plate using FCL screws proximal to, and standard locking screws distal to, the fracture. Analyses were done for 120 possible FCL screw configurations by varying FCL screw distribution and number. A hip joint force of 700 N (i.e. 100% x body weight) was used, which corresponds to a typical 140 N "toe-touch" foot-to-ground force (i.e. 20% x body weight) suggested to patients immediately after surgery. Increased FCL screw distribution (i.e. shorter plate working length) caused a decrease at the medial side and an increase at the lateral side of the axial interfragmentary motion (AIM), mildly affected shaft and condylar cortex Von Mises max stress (σ_MAX), increased plate σ_MAX, and decreased shaft FCL screw and condylar locking screw σ_MAX. Increased FCL screw number decreased AIM and σ_MAX on the shaft cortex, condylar cortex, plate, and FCL screws, but not condylar screws. The optimal FCL screw configuration had 3 FCL screws in plate holes #1, 5, and 6 (proximal to distal) for optimal AIM of 0.2 - 1 mm and reduce shear fracture motion, thereby encouraging early callus formation.

Single lag screw and reverse distal femur locking compression plate for concurrent cervicotrochanteric and shaft fractures of the femur: biomechanical study validated with a clinical series

BACKGROUND

The optimal surgical management of concurrent cervicotrochanteric and shaft fractures of the femur has not been consensual. The authors investigated the reliability of combined single lag screw and reverse distal femur locking compression plate (LCP-DF) by finite element (FE) study and retrospectively described the present technique for these dual fractures.

METHOD

Intact femurs were derived from CT data, and the implant models were created by using CAD software. The fractured femur and implant models were virtually aligned based on the surgical techniques before converting to the FE model. In the FE model, applied boundary conditions included body weight, muscle forces, and constraint of the joints. Regarding clinical series, three patients with these dual fractures of the femur and 2 with cervicotrochanteric fractures with subtrochanteric extension were operated on by the proposed technique. The collected data include operative time, postoperative complications, union times, and clinical outcomes.

RESULTS

Equivalent von Mises stress exhibited on dynamic hip screws with an anti-rotational screw was higher than the other techniques, close to the yield stress of the material. Multiple screw fixation produced better stability for transcervical fractures whereas the proposed technique of combined single lag screw and reverse LCP-DF provided better stability for intertrochanteric fractures. No significant difference in cortical bone stress was found between multiple screw construct and the proposed technique. The proposed technique presented a lower risk of secondary fractures, as the strain energy density (SED) in cancellous bone was lower than multiple screw construct. Regarding clinical series, all fractures were united with a mean union time of-16.1 weeks (range 12-20). There were no any postoperative complications. Regarding the Harris score, 1 was determined to be excellent value, and 4 to be good.

CONCLUSION

By the FE results, a combination of a single lag screw and reverse LCP-DF is an effective technique for fixation of cervicotrochanteric fractures. Empowered by the clinical results, this proposed technique could be an alternative for concurrent cervicotrochanteric and shaft fractures of the femur especially when either single-system or dual-system devices seem not to be suitable.

Biomechanical Consequences of Nail Insertion Point and Anterior Cortical Perforation for Antegrade Femoral Nailing

This biomechanical study assessed the influence of changing antegrade cephalomedullary nail insertion point from anterior to neutral to posterior locations relative to the tip of the greater trochanter with or without anterior cortical perforation in the distal femur. Artificial osteoporotic femurs and cephalomedullary nails were used to create 5 test groups each with 8 specimens: intact femur without a nail or perforation, anterior nail insertion point without perforation, neutral nail insertion point without perforation, posterior nail insertion point without perforation, and posterior nail insertion point with perforation. Nondestructive biomechanical tests were done at 250 N in axial, coronal 3-point bending, sagittal 3-point bending, and torsional loading in order to measure overall stiffness and bone stress. The intact femur group vs. all femur/nail groups had lower stiffness in all loading modes (p ≤ 0.018), as well as higher bone stress in the proximal femur (p ≤ 0.027) but not in the distal femur above the perforation (p = 0.096). Compared to each other, femur/nail groups only showed differences in sagittal 3-point bending stiffness for anterior and neutral vs. posterior nail insertion points without (p ≤ 0.025) and with perforation (p ≤ 0.047). Although it did not achieve statistical significance (p ≥ 0.096), moving the nail insertion point from anterior to neutral to posterior to posterior with perforation did gradually increase bone stress by 45% (proximal femur) and 46% (distal femur). No femur or hardware failures occurred. Moving the nail insertion point and the presence of a perforation had little effect on stiffness, but the increased bone stress may be important as a predictor of fracture. Based on current bone stress results, surgeons should use anterior or neutral nail insertion points to reduce the risk of anterior cortical perforation.

Biomechanical design using in-vitro finite element modeling of distal femur fracture plates made from semi-rigid materials versus traditional metals for post-operative toe-touch weight-bearing

This proof-of-concept study designs distal femur fracture plates from semi-rigid materials vs. traditional metals for toe-touch weight-bearing recommended to patients immediately after surgery. The two-fold goal was to (a) reduce stress shielding (SS) by increasing cortical bone stress thereby reducing the risk of bone absorption and plate loosening, and (b) reduce delayed healing (DH) via early callus formation by optimizing axial interfragmentary motion (AIM). Finite element analysis was used to design semi-rigid plates whose elastic moduli E ensured plates permitted AIM of 0.2 - 1 mm for early callus formation. A low hip joint force of 700 N (i.e. 100% x body weight) was applied, which corresponds to a typical 140 N toe-touch foot-to-ground force (i.e. 20% x body weight) recommended to patients after surgery. Analysis was done using 2 screw materials (steel or titanium) and types (locked or non-locked). Steel and titanium plates were also analyzed. Semi-rigid plates (vs. metal plates) had lower overall femur/plate construct stiffnesses of 508 - 1482 N/mm, higher cortical bone stresses under the plate by 2.02x - 3.27x thereby reducing SS, and lower E values of 414 - 2302 MPa to permit AIM of 0.2 - 1 mm thereby reducing DH.

Application of Fibre Bragg Grating Sensors in Strain Monitoring and Fracture Recovery of Human Femur Bone

Fibre Bragg Grating (FBG) sensors are gaining popularity in biomedical engineering. However, specific standards for in vivo testing for their use are absolutely limited. In this study, in vitro experimental tests were performed to investigate the behaviors and applications of gratings attached to intact and fractured thighbone for a range of compression loading (<300 N) based around some usual daily activities. The wavelength shifts and the corresponding strain sensitivities of the FBG sensors were measured to determine their effectiveness in monitoring the femoral fracture healing process. Four different arrangements of FBG sensors were selected to measure strains at different critical locations on the femoral sawbones surface. Data obtained for intact and plated sawbones were compared using both embedded longitudinal and coiled FBG arrays. Strains were measured close to the fracture, posterior linea aspera and popliteal surface areas, as well as at the proximal and distal ends of the synthetic femur; their responses are discussed herein. The gratings on the longitudinally secured FBG arrays were found to provide high levels of sensitivity and precise measurements, even for relatively small loads (<100 N). Nevertheless, embedding angled FBG sensors is essential to measure the strain generated by applied torque on the femur bone. The maximum recorded strain of the plated femur was 503.97 µε for longitudinal and -274.97 µε for coiled FBG arrays, respectively. These project results are important to configure effective arrangements and orientations of FBG sensors with respect to fracture position and fixation implant for future in vivo experiments.

Biomechanical properties and thermal characteristics of frozen versus thawed whole bone

Biomechanics research often requires cadaveric whole bones to be stored in a freezer and then thawed prior to use; however, the literature shows a variety of practices for thawing. Consequently, this is the first study to report the mechanical properties of fully frozen versus fully thawed whole bone as 'proof of principle'. Two groups of 10 porcine ribs each were statistically equivalent at baseline in length, cross-sectional area, and bone mineral density. The two groups were stored in a freezer for at least 24 h, thawed in air at 23 °C for 4 h while temperature readings were taken to establish the time needed for thawing, and once again returned to the freezer for at least 24 h. Mechanical tests to failure using three-point bending were then done on the 'frozen' group immediately after removal from the freezer and the 'thawed' group when steady-state ambient air temperature was reached. Temperature readings over the entire thawing period were described by the line-of-best-fit formula T = (28.34t - 6.69)/(t + 0.38), where T = temperature in degree Celsius and t = time in hours, such that frozen specimens at t = 0 h had a temperature of -17 °C and thawed specimens at t = 1.75 h reached a steady-state temperature of 20 °C-23 °C. Mechanical tests showed that frozen versus thawed specimens had an average of 32% higher stiffness k, 34% higher ultimate force F_u, 28% lower ultimate displacement δ_u, 40% lower ultimate work W_u, 43% higher elastic modulus E, 37% higher ultimate normal stress σ_u, and 33% higher ultimate shear stress τ_u. Whole ribs failed at midspan primarily by transverse cracking (16 of 20 cases), oblique cracking (three of 20 cases), or surface denting (one of 20 cases), each having unique shapes for force versus displacement graphs differentiated mainly by ultimate force location.

Characteristics and Surgical Outcomes of Intertrochanteric or Subtrochanteric Fractures Associated with Ipsilateral Femoral Shaft Fractures Treated with Closed Intramedullary Nailing: A Review of 31 Consecutive Cases over Four Years at a Single Institution

Purpose

To evaluate the clinical characteristics of intertrochanteric or subtrochanteric fractures associated with ipsilateral femoral shaft fractures and assess the surgical outcomes of a novel, closed intramedullary nailing surgical approach designed to minimize fixation failure.

Materials and Methods

Between May 2013 and April 2017, 31 patients with intertrochanteric or subtrochanteric fractures associated with ipsilateral femoral shaft fractures treated with closed intramedullary nailing or long proximal femoral nail antirotation (PFNA) were enrolled in this study. Preoperative data included age, sex, injury severity score, body mass index, location of shaft fracture, injury mechanism, accompanying traumatic injury, walking ability before injury, and surgical timing. Perioperative outcomes, including follow-up period, types of intramedullary nails, number of blocking screws used, operation time, and blood loss were assessed. Radiologic outcomes, including union rate, time from surgery to union, and femoral shortening, and clinical outcomes, including hip flexion, walking ability, and Harris hip score were also evaluated.

Results

A total of 29 unions (93.5%) were achieved. The time to union was 16.8 months (range, 11–25 months) for hip fractures (15.7 weeks for intertrochanteric fractures and 21.7 weeks for subtrochanteric fractures) and 22.8 months for femoral shaft fractures. There were no significant differences in surgical outcomes between the two groups except for type of intramedullary nail.

Conclusion

Closed intramedullary nailing in the treatment of intertrochanteric or subtrochanteric fractures associated with ipsilateral femoral shaft fractures may be a good surgical option. However, fixation of femoral shaft fractures might not be sufficient depending on the implant design.

Biomechanical Testing of a 3-Hole Versus a 4-Hole Sliding Hip Screw in the Presence of a Retrograde Intramedullary Nail for Ipsilateral Intertrochanteric and Femur Shaft Fractures

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to compare a 3-hole versus a 4-hole sliding hip screw (SHS) in the presence of a retrograde intramedullary (RIM) nail for fixing intertrochanteric and comminuted midshaft femur fractures.

METHODS

Mechanical tests were performed on 10 matched pairs of human cadaveric femurs that were osteotomized and then fixed using a 3-hole SHS versus the traditional "gold standard" 4-hole SHS in the presence of an RIM nail.

RESULTS

Data showed no differences between the 3-hole SHS with RIM nail versus 4-hole SHS with RIM nail for stiffness (281 ± 127 vs. 260 ± 118 N/mm, P = 0.76), clinical failure at 10 mm of hip displacement (2014 ± 363 vs. 2134 ± 614 N, P = 0.52), or ultimate mechanical failure (3476 ± 776 vs. 3669 ± 755 N, P = 0.12).

CONCLUSIONS

For this fracture pattern, a 3-hole SHS with RIM nail may be a suitable surgical alternative to the traditional "gold standard" method because it provides the same biomechanical properties while potentially reducing surgical time, blood loss, and hardware used.

Hot Topics in Biomechanics: Hip Fracture Fixation

Geriatric hip fractures continue to increase in frequency as the population ages, and intertrochanteric femur fractures are a significant part of these injuries. Plate fixation for intertrochanteric fractures of the proximal femur has been in use for many years, and application of the sliding hip screw has also been a mainstay of treatment. Recent data suggest there may be a benefit to using implants that add rotational stability to the proximal intertrochanteric fragment. Although preliminary data are promising, there is need for improved investigation to demonstrate the benefit of these new implant designs. In this era of increasing emphasis on cost, quality, and value, better data are needed to help clinicians determine the best therapy for their patients.

The biomechanical effect of proximal tumor defect location on femur pathological fractures

OBJECTIVES

The femur is the most common long bone affected by cancerous metastasis. Femoral tumor defects are known to induce pain and functional impairment in patients. Although prior studies exist evaluating the clinical and biomechanical effect of tumor defect size, no biomechanical studies have experimentally examined the risk of pathological fracture with respect to the anterior, posterior, medial, and lateral surfaces on which a proximal tumor defect is located on the femur.

METHODS

Circular tumor-like defects of 40-mm diameter were created proximally in the subtrochanteric region on the Anterior (n = 5), Posterior (n = 5), Medial (n = 5), and Lateral (n = 5) sides of 20 synthetic femurs. Intact femurs served as a control group (n = 4). Femurs were tested for lateral, "offset" torsional, and axial stiffness, as well as axial strength.

RESULTS

Lateral stiffnesses (range, 121-162 N/mm) yielded no differences between groups (P = 0.069). "Offset" torsional stiffnesses (range, 135-188 N/mm) demonstrated that the Medial group was less stiff than the Intact, Anterior, and Lateral groups (P ≤ 0.012). Axial stiffnesses (range, 1057-1993 N/mm) showed that the Medial group was less stiff than the Intact group (P = 0.006). Axial strengths (range, 3250-6590 N) for the Medial group were lower than Anterior (P = 0.001) and Posterior (P = 0.001) specimens, whereas the Lateral group had a lower strength than Anterior specimens (P = 0.019). No other statistical differences were noted. Axial failure of Medial and Lateral specimens involved the tumor-like defect in 100% of cases, whereas 100% of Intact femurs and 80% of Anterior and Posterior femur groups failed only through the neck.

CONCLUSIONS

In 2 of 3 test modes, the Medial tumor-like defect group resulted in statistically lower stiffness values compared with Intact femurs and had lower strength than Anterior and Posterior groups in axial failure.

Biomechanical effects of hardware configuration after union of proximal femoral and shaft fractures

OBJECTIVES

The use of two implants to manage concomitant ipsilateral femoral shaft and proximal femoral fractures has been indicated, but no studies address the relationship of dynamic hip screw (DHS) side plate screws and the intramedullary nail where failure might occur after union. This study compares different implant configurations in order to investigate bridging the gap between the distal DHS and tip of the intramedullary nail.

METHODS

A total of 29 left synthetic femora were tested in three groups: 1) gapped short nail (GSN); 2) unicortical short nail (USN), differing from GSN by the use of two unicortical bridging screws; and 3) bicortical long nail (BLN), with two angled bicortical and one unicortical bridging screws. With these findings, five matched-pairs of cadaveric femora were tested in two groups: 1) unicortical long nail (ULN), with a longer nail than USN and three bridging unicortical screws; and 2) BLN. Specimens were axially loaded to 22.7 kg (50 lb), and internally rotated 90°/sec until failure.

RESULTS

For synthetic femora, a difference was detected between GSN and BLN in energy to failure (p = 0.04) and torque at failure (p = 0.02), but not between USN and other groups for energy to failure (vs GSN, p = 0.71; vs BLN, p = 0.19) and torque at failure (vs GSN, p = 0.55; vs BLN, p = 0.15). For cadaveric femora, ULN and BLN performed similarly because of the improvement provided by the bridging screws.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study shows that bicortical angled screws in the DHS side plate are superior to no screws at all in this model and loading scenario, and suggests that adding unicortical screws to a gapped construct is probably beneficial.

Biomechanical Measurements of Surgical Drilling Force and Torque in Human Versus Artificial Femurs

Few experimental studies have examined surgical drilling in human bone, and no studies have inquired into this aspect for a popular commercially-available artificial bone used in biomechanical studies. Sixteen fresh-frozen human femurs and five artificial femurs were obtained. Cortical specimens were mounted into a clamping system equipped with a thrust force and torque transducer. Using a CNC machine, unicortical holes were drilled in each specimen at 1000 rpm, 1250 rpm, and 1500 rpm with a 3.2 mm diameter surgical drill bit. Feed rate was 120 mm/min. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05. Force at increasing spindle speed (1000 rpm, 1250 rpm, and 1500 rpm), respectively, showed a range for human femurs (198.4 ± 14.2 N, 180.6 ± 14.0 N, and 176.3 ± 11.2 N) and artificial femurs (87.2 ± 19.3 N, 82.2 ± 11.2 N, and 75.7 ± 8.8 N). For human femurs, force at 1000 rpm was greater than at other speeds (p ≤ 0.018). For artificial femurs, there was no speed effect on force (p ≥ 0.991). Torque at increasing spindle speed (1000 rpm, 1250 rpm, and 1500 rpm), respectively, showed a range for human femurs (186.3 ± 16.9 N·mm, 157.8 ± 16.1 N·mm, and 140.2 ± 16.4 N·mm) and artificial femurs (67.2 ± 8.4 N·mm, 61.0 ± 2.9 N·mm, and 53.3 ± 2.9 N·mm). For human femurs, torque at 1000 rpm was greater than at other speeds (p < 0.001). For artificial femurs, there was no difference in torque for 1000 rpm versus higher speeds (p ≥ 0.228), and there was only a borderline difference between the higher speeds (p = 0.046). Concerning human versus artificial femurs, their behavior was different at every speed (force, p ≤ 0.001; torque, p < 0.001). For human specimens at 1500 rpm, force and torque were linearly correlated with standardized bone mineral density (sBMD) and the T-score used to clinically categorize bone quality (R ≥ 0.56), but there was poor correlation with age at all speeds (R ≤ 0.37). These artificial bones fail to replicate force and torque in human cortical bone during surgical drilling. To date, this is the largest series of human long bones biomechanically tested for surgical drilling.

A preliminary biomechanical study of cyclic preconditioning effects on canine cadaveric whole femurs

Biomechanical preconditioning of biological specimens by cyclic loading is routinely done presumably to stabilize properties prior to the main phase of a study. However, no prior studies have actually measured these effects for whole bone of any kind. The aim of this study, therefore, was to quantify these effects for whole bones. Fourteen matched pairs of fresh-frozen intact cadaveric canine femurs were sinusoidally loaded in 4-point bending from 50 N to 300 N at 1 Hz for 25 cycles. All femurs were tested in both anteroposterior (AP) and mediolateral (ML) bending planes. Bending stiffness (i.e., slope of the force-vs-displacement curve) and linearity R(2) (i.e., coefficient of determination) of each loading cycle were measured and compared statistically to determine the effect of limb side, cycle number, and bending plane. Stiffnesses rose from 809.7 to 867.7 N/mm (AP, left), 847.3 to 915.6 N/mm (AP, right), 829.2 to 892.5 N/mm (AP, combined), 538.7 to 580.4 N/mm (ML, left), 568.9 to 613.8 N/mm (ML, right), and 553.8 to 597.1 N/mm (ML, combined). Linearity R(2) rose from 0.96 to 0.99 (AP, left), 0.97 to 0.99 (AP, right), 0.96 to 0.99 (AP, combined), 0.95 to 0.98 (ML, left), 0.94 to 0.98 (ML, right), and 0.95 to 0.98 (ML, combined). Stiffness and linearity R(2) versus cycle number were well-described by exponential curves whose values leveled off, respectively, starting at 12 and 5 cycles. For stiffness, there were no statistical differences for left versus right femurs (p = 0.166), but there were effects due to cycle number (p < 0.0001) and AP versus ML bending plane (p < 0.0001). Similarly, for linearity, no statistical differences were noted due to limb side (p = 0.533), but there were effects due to cycle number (p < 0.0001) and AP versus ML bending plane (p = 0.006). A minimum of 12 preconditioning cycles was needed to fully stabilize both the stiffness and linearity of the canine femurs. This is the first study to measure the effects of mechanical preconditioning on whole bones, having some practical implications on research practices.

The biomechanics of three different fracture fixation implants for distal femur repair in the presence of a tumor-like defect

The femur is the most common long bone involved in metastatic disease. There is consensus about treating diaphyseal and epiphyseal metastatic lesions. However, the choice of device for optimal fixation for distal femur metaphyseal metastatic lesion remains unclear. This study compared the mechanical stiffness and strength of three different fixation methods. In 15 synthetic femurs, a spherical tumor-like defect was created in the lateral metaphyseal region, occupying 50% of the circumference of the bone. The defect was filled with bone cement and fixed with one of three methods: Group 1 (retrograde nail), Group 2 (lateral locking plate), and Group 3 (lateral nonlocking periarticular plate). Constructs were tested for mechanical stiffness and strength. There were no differences between groups for axial stiffness (Group 1, 1280 ± 112 N/mm; Group 2, 1422 ± 117 N/mm; and Group 3, 1403 ± 122 N/mm; p = 0.157) and offset torsional strength (Group 1, 1696 ± 628 N; Group 2, 1771 ± 290 N; and Group 3, 1599 ± 253 N; p = 0.816). In the coronal plane, Group 2 (296 ± 17 N/mm) had a higher stiffness than Group 1 (263 ± 17 N/mm; p = 0.018). In the sagittal plane, Group 1 (315 ± 9 N/mm) had a higher stiffness than Group 3 (285 ± 19 N/mm; p = 0.028). For offset torsional stiffness, Group 1 (256 ± 23 N/mm) had a higher value than Group 3 (218 ± 16 N/mm; p = 0.038). Group 1 had equivalent performance to both plating groups in two test modes, and it was superior to Group 3 in two other test modes. Since a retrograde nail (i.e. Group 1) would require less soft-tissue stripping in a clinical context, it may be the optimal choice for tumor-like defects in the distal femur.

The locking attachment plate for proximal fixation of periprosthetic femur fractures--a biomechanical comparison of two techniques

PURPOSE

Mechanical properties of a locking attachment plate construct (LAP-LCP), allowing bicortical screw placement laterally to the prosthesis stem, are compared to a cerclage-LCP construct.

METHODS

Eight right synthetic femora with implanted uncemented hip endoprosthesis were cut distally and fixed with LCP, monocortical locking screws and either LAP (n = 4) or cerclage (n = 4). Cyclic testing was performed with monotonically increasing sinusoidal load until failure. Relative movements at the plate-femur interface were registered by motion tracking. Statistical differences were detected by unpaired t-test and general linear model repeated measures.

RESULTS

Stiffness of the LAP-LCP was significantly higher at the beginning (875.4 N/mm ± 29.8) and after 5000 cycles (1213.0 N/mm ± 101.1) compared to the cerclage-LCP (644.96 N/mm ± 50.1 and 851.9 N/mm ± 81.9), with p = 0.013. Relative movements for AP-bending (B) and axial translation (T) of the LAP-LCP at the beginning (0.07° ± 0.02, 0.20 mm ± 0.08), after 500 cycles (0.16° ± 0.10, 0.26 mm ± 0.07) and after 5000 cycles (0.26° ± 0.11, 0.31 mm ± 0.07) differed significantly from the cerclage-LCP (beg.: 0.26° ± 0.04, 0.28 mm ± 0.05; 500 cyc: 0.47° ± 0.03, 0.53 mm ± 0.07; 5000 cyc.: 0.63° ± 0.18, 0.79 mm ± 0.13), with B: p = 0.02, T: p = 0.04. Relative movements for medial bending were not significantly different between the two constructs. Cycles to failure (criterion 1 mm axial translation) differed significantly between LAP-LCP (19,519 ± 1,758) and cerclage-LCP (11,265 ± 2,472), with p = 0.035.

CONCLUSIONS

Biomechanically, the LAP-LCP construct improves proximal fixation of periprosthetic fractures compared to the cerclage-LCP construct.

A comparative study of ipsilateral intertrochanteric and femoral shaft fractures treated with long proximal femoral nail antirotation or plate combinations

OBJECTIVE

To compare the results of long proximal femoral nail antirotation (PFNA-long) and plate combinations in the treatment of ipsilateral intertrochanteric and femoral shaft fractures.

METHODS

Between March 2004 and April 2009, 23 patients with ipsilateral intertrochanteric and femoral shaft fractures were treated with PFNA-long or plate combinations. The patients were divided into two groups. Group I contained 13 patients who were treated with dynamic hip screws (DHS) combined with compression plate fixation. The 10 patients in Group II were treated with PFNA-long.

RESULTS

The average follow-up was 17.8 and 16.8 months for Groups I and II, respectively. The average union time for intertrochanteric fractures was 17.4 and 16.6 weeks in Groups I and II, respectively, and for femoral shaft fracture 22.2 and 21.5 weeks, respectively. There were nine good, two fair, and two poor functional results in Group I, and eight good, one fair, and one poor in Group II. There was nonunion of two femoral shaft fractures in Group I and one in Group II. There were no significant differences between the two groups in functional outcomes or major complications.

CONCLUSION

Both treatment methods achieve satisfactory functional outcomes in patients with ipsilateral intertrochanteric and femoral shaft fractures. PFNA-long is the better choice for the treatment of complex fractures, having the advantages of minimal exposure, reduced perioperative blood loss, and achievement of biological fixation of both fractures with a single implant.

Biomechanical stress maps of an artificial femur obtained using a new infrared thermography technique validated by strain gages

Femurs are the heaviest, longest, and strongest long bones in the human body and are routinely subjected to cyclic forces. Strain gages are commonly employed to experimentally validate finite element models of the femur in order to generate 3D stresses, yet there is little information on a relatively new infrared (IR) thermography technique now available for biomechanics applications. In this study, IR thermography validated with strain gages was used to measure the principal stresses in the artificial femur model from Sawbones (Vashon, WA, USA) increasingly being used for biomechanical research. The femur was instrumented with rosette strain gages and mechanically tested using average axial cyclic forces of 1500 N, 1800 N, and 2100 N, representing 3 times body weight for a 50 kg, 60 kg, and 70 kg person. The femur was oriented at 7° of adduction to simulate the single-legged stance phase of walking. Stress maps were also obtained using an IR thermography camera. Results showed good agreement of IR thermography vs. strain gage data with a correlation of R(2)=0.99 and a slope=1.08 for the straight line of best fit. IR thermography detected the highest principal stresses on the superior-posterior side of the neck, which yielded compressive values of -91.2 MPa (at 1500 N), -96.0 MPa (at 1800 N), and -103.5 MPa (at 2100 N). There was excellent correlation between IR thermography principal stress vs. axial cyclic force at 6 locations on the femur on the lateral (R(2)=0.89-0.99), anterior (R(2)=0.87-0.99), and posterior (R(2)=0.81-0.99) sides. This study shows IR thermography's potential for future biomechanical applications.

Biomechanical measurements of axial crush injury to the distal condyles of human and synthetic femurs

Few studies have evaluated the ‘bulk’ mechanical properties of human longbones and even fewer have compared human tissue to the synthetic longbones increasingly being used by researchers. Distal femur fractures, for example, comprise about 6% of all femur fractures, but the mechanical properties of the distal condyles of intact human and synthetic femurs have not been well quantified in the literature. To this end, the distal portions of a series of 16 human fresh-frozen femurs and six synthetic femurs were prepared identically for mechanical testing. Using a flat metal plate, an axial ‘crush’ force was applied in-line with the long axis of the femurs. The two femur groups were statistically compared and values correlated to age, size, and bone quality. Results yielded the following: crush stiffness (human, 1545 ± 728 N/mm; synthetic, 3063 ± 1243 N/mm; p = 0.002); crush strength (human, 10.3 ± 3.1 kN; synthetic, 12.9 ± 1.7 kN; p = 0.074); crush displacement (human, 6.1 ± 1.8 mm; synthetic, 2.8 ± 0.3 mm; p = 0.000); and crush energy (human, 34.8 ± 15.9 J; synthetic, 18.1 ± 5.7 J; p = 0.023). For the human femurs, there were poor correlations between mechanical properties versus age, size, and bone quality (R2 ≤ 0.18), with the exception of crush strength versus bone mineral density (R2 = 0.33) and T-score (R2 = 0.25). Human femurs failed mostly by condyle ‘roll back’ buckling (15 of 16 cases) and/or unicondylar or bicondylar fracture (7 of 16 cases), while synthetic femurs all failed by wedging apart of the condyles resulting in either fully or partially displaced condylar fractures (6 of 6 cases). These findings have practical implications on the use of a flat plate load applicator to reproduce real-life clinical failure modes of human femurs and the appropriate use of synthetic femurs. To the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study to have done such an assessment on human and synthetic femurs.

A preliminary biomechanical assessment of a polymer composite hip implant using an infrared thermography technique validated by strain gage measurements

With the resurgence of composite materials in orthopaedic applications, a rigorous assessment of stress is needed to predict any failure of bone-implant systems. For current biomechanics research, strain gage measurements are employed to experimentally validate finite element models, which then characterize stress in the bone and implant. Our preliminary study experimentally validates a relatively new nondestructive testing technique for orthopaedic implants. Lock-in infrared (IR) thermography validated with strain gage measurements was used to investigate the stress and strain patterns in a novel composite hip implant made of carbon fiber reinforced polyamide 12 (CF/PA12). The hip implant was instrumented with strain gages and mechanically tested using average axial cyclic forces of 840 N, 1500 N, and 2100 N with the implant at an adduction angle of 15 deg to simulate the single-legged stance phase of walking gait. Three-dimensional surface stress maps were also obtained using an IR thermography camera. Results showed almost perfect agreement of IR thermography versus strain gage data with a Pearson correlation of R(2) = 0.96 and a slope = 1.01 for the line of best fit. IR thermography detected hip implant peak stresses on the inferior-medial side just distal to the neck region of 31.14 MPa (at 840 N), 72.16 MPa (at 1500 N), and 119.86 MPa (at 2100 N). There was strong correlation between IR thermography-measured stresses and force application level at key locations on the implant along the medial (R(2) = 0.99) and lateral (R(2) = 0.83 to 0.99) surface, as well as at the peak stress point (R(2) = 0.81 to 0.97). This is the first study to experimentally validate and demonstrate the use of lock-in IR thermography to obtain three-dimensional stress fields of an orthopaedic device manufactured from a composite material.

The biomechanical effect of changes in cancellous bone density on synthetic femur behaviour

Biomechanical researchers increasingly use commercially available and experimentally validated synthetic femurs to mimic human femurs. However, the choice of cancellous bone density for these artificial femurs appears to be done arbitrarily. The aim of the work reported in this paper was to examine the effect of synthetic cancellous bone density on the mechanical behaviour of synthetic femurs. Thirty left, large, fourth-generation composite femurs were mounted onto an Instron material testing system. The femurs were divided evenly into five groups each containing six femurs, each group representing a different synthetic cancellous bone density: 0.08, 0.16, 0.24, 0.32, and 0.48 g/cm3. Femurs were tested non-destructively to obtain axial, lateral, and torsional stiffness, followed by destructive tests to measure axial failure load, displacement, and energy. Experimental results yielded the following ranges and the coefficient of determination for a linear regression ( R2) with cancellous bone density: axial stiffness (range 2116.5–2530.6 N/mm; R2 = 0.94), lateral stiffness (range 204.3–227.8 N/mm; R2 = 0.08), torsional stiffness (range 259.9–281.5 N/mm; R2 = 0.91), failure load (range 5527.6–11 109.3 N; R2 = 0.92), failure displacement (range 2.97–6.49 mm; R2 = 0.85), and failure energy (range 8.79–42.81 J; R2 = 0.91). These synthetic femurs showed no density effect on lateral stiffness and only a moderate influence on axial and torsional stiffness; however, there was a strong density effect on axial failure load, displacement, and energy. Because these synthetic femurs have previously been experimentally validated against human femurs, these trends may be generalized to the clinical situation. This is the first study in the literature to perform such an assessment.

Salvage procedures for trochanteric femoral fractures after internal fixation failure: Biomechanical comparison of a plate fixator and the dynamic condylar screw

The aim of this study was the biomechanical evaluation of the reversed less invasive stabilization system (LISS) internal fixation as a joint-preserving salvage procedure for trochanteric fractures. Five LISS plates and five dynamic condylar screws (DCS) were tested using synthetic femora (Sawbones®) with an osteotomy model similar to a type-A2.3 pertrochanteric fracture. The constructs were subjected to axial loading up to 1000 N for five cycles. Then, the force was continuously increased until fixation failure. For the evaluation of the biomechanical behaviour, the stiffness levels were recorded and the osteotomy gap displacement was mapped three-dimensionally. The average stiffness for the constructs with LISS plates was 412 N/mm (with a standard deviation (SD) of 103N/mm) and 572 N/mm (SD of 116 N/mm) for the DCS constructs ( p = 0.051). Local displacement at the osteotomy gap did not yield any significant differences. The LISS constructs failed at a mean axial compression of 2103 N (SD of 519 N) and the DCS constructs at a mean of 2572 N (SD of 372 N) ( p = 0.14). It is concluded that the LISS plate offers a reliable fixation alternative for salvage procedures.

The biomechanics of locked plating for repairing proximal humerus fractures with or without medial cortical support

BACKGROUND

Comminuted proximal humerus fracture fixation is controversial. Locked plate complications have been addressed by anatomic reduction or medial cortical support. The relative mechanical contributions of varus malalignment and lack of medial cortical support are presently assessed.

METHODS

Forty synthetic humeri divided into three subgroups were osteotomized and fixed at 0 degrees, 10 degrees, and 20 degrees of varus malreduction with a locking proximal humerus plate (AxSOS, Global model; Stryker, Mahwah, NJ) to simulate mechanical medial support with cortical contact retained. Axial, torsional, and shear stiffness were measured. Half of the specimens in each of the three subgroups underwent a second osteotomy to create a segmental defect simulating loss of medial support with cortex removed. Axial, torsional, and shear stiffness tests were repeated, followed by shear load to failure in 20 degrees of abduction.

RESULTS

For isolated malreduction with cortical contact, the construct at 0 degrees showed statistically equivalent or higher axial, torsional, and shear stiffness than other subgroups examined. Subsequent removal of cortical support in half the specimens showed a drastic effect on axial, torsional, and shear stiffness at all varus angulations. Constructs with cortical contact at 0 degrees and 10 degrees yielded mean shear failure forces of 12965.4 N and 9341.1 N, respectively, being statistically higher (p < 0.05) compared with most other subgroups tested. Specimens failed primarily by plate bending as the humeral head was pushed down medially and distally.

CONCLUSIONS

Anatomic reduction with the medial cortical contact was the stiffest construct after a simulated two-part fracture. This study affirms the concept of medial cortical support by fixing proximal humeral fractures in varus, if absolutely necessary. This may be preferable to fixing the fracture in anatomic alignment when there is a medial fracture gap.

Biomechanical Measurements of Torsion-Tension Coupling in Human Cadaveric Femurs

The mechanical behavior of human femurs has been described in the literature with regard to torsion and tension but only as independent measurements. However, in this study, human femurs were subjected to torsion to determine if a simultaneous axial tensile load was generated. Fresh frozen human femurs (n=25) were harvested and stripped of soft tissue. Each femur was mounted rigidly in a specially designed test jig and remained at a fixed axial length during all experiments. Femurs were subjected to external and internal rotation applied at a constant angulation rate of 0.1 deg/s to a maximum torque of 12 N m. Applied torque and generated axial tension were monitored simultaneously. Outcome measurements were extracted from torsion-versus-tension graphs. There was a strong relationship between applied torsion and the resulting tension for external rotation tests (torsion/tension ratio=551.7±283.8 mm, R2=0.83±0.20, n=25), internal rotation tests (torsion/tension ratio=495.3±233.1 mm, R2=0.87±0.17, n=24), left femurs (torsion/tension ratio=542.2±262.4 mm, R2=0.88±0.13, n=24), and right femurs (torsion/tension ratio=506.7±260.0 mm, R2=0.82±0.22, n=25). No statistically significant differences were found for external versus internal rotation groups or for left versus right femurs when comparing torsion/tension ratios (p=0.85) or R2 values (p=0.54). A strongly coupled linear relationship between torsion and tension for human femurs was exhibited. This suggests an interplay between these two factors during activities of daily living and injury processes.

Ipsilateral fractures of the femoral neck, shaft and distal end: long-term outcome of five cases

Out of 52 cases of ipsilateral femoral fractures treated at a level I trauma centre between June 1994 and March 2008, the diaphyseal fracture was accompanied by a intracapsular neck fracture in only 20 cases. In the rest of the cases, the diaphyseal fracture was combined with either an extracapsular or pertrochanteric fracture. Five of these patients also had fractures of the distal femur. In three of those patients we began treatment with osteosynthesis of the femoral neck and shaft, using a reconstruction nail, then stabilized the distal fracture with a 95° blade plate or with lag screws. In the other two cases, initial treatment dealt with the distal femoral fracture, stabilizing it with a 95° blade plate, which was also used for stabilization of the diaphyseal fracture. In these patients, the proximal fracture was treated using dynamic hip screws (DHS). All fractures healed, two after initial treatment, while the other three needed one reoperation. The follow-up period was 2-13 years after the injury. The order in which fractures are treated is best left to the discretion of the physician and the circumstances. In our experience, two implants are sufficient for osteosynthesis, one for stabilizing one end of the femur together with the shaft, and the other is used for treating the other end of the femur.

The biomechanical analysis of three plating fixation systems for periprosthetic femoral fracture near the tip of a total hip arthroplasty

Background

A variety of techniques are available for fixation of femoral shaft fractures following total hip arthroplasty. The optimal surgical repair method still remains a point of controversy in the literature. However, few studies have quantified the performance of such repair constructs. This study biomechanically examined 3 different screw-plate and cable-plate systems for fixation of periprosthetic femoral fractures near the tip of a total hip arthroplasty.

Methods

Twelve pairs of human cadaveric femurs were utilized. Each left femur was prepared for the cemented insertion of the femoral component of a total hip implant. Femoral fractures were created in the femurs and subsequently repaired with Construct A (Zimmer Cable Ready System), Construct B (AO Cable-Plate System), or Construct C (Dall-Miles Cable Grip System). Right femora served as matched intact controls. Axial, torsional, and four-point bending tests were performed to obtain stiffness values.

Results

All repair systems showed 3.08 to 5.33 times greater axial stiffness over intact control specimens. Four-point normalized bending (0.69 to 0.85) and normalized torsional (0.55 to 0.69) stiffnesses were lower than intact controls for most comparisons. Screw-plates provided either greater or equal stiffness compared to cable-plates in almost all cases. There were no statistical differences between plating systems A, B, or C when compared to each other (p > 0.05).

Conclusions

Screw-plate systems provide more optimal mechanical stability than cable-plate systems for periprosthetic femur fractures near the tip of a total hip arthroplasty.

The effect of cortex thickness on intact femur biomechanics: A comparison of finite element analysis with synthetic femurs

Biomechanical studies on femur fracture fixation with orthopaedic implants are numerous in the literature. However, few studies have compared the mechanical stability of these repair constructs in osteoporotic versus normal bone. The present aim was to examine how changes in cortical wall thickness of intact femurs affect biomechanical characteristics. A three-dimensional, linear, isotropic finite element (FE) model of an intact femur was developed in order to predict the effect of bicortical wall thickness, t, relative to the femur's mid-diaphyseal outer diameter, D, over a cortex thickness ratio range of 0 ≤ t/ D ≤ 1. The FE model was subjected to loads to obtain axial, lateral, and torsional stiffness. Ten commercially available synthetic femurs were then used to mimic ‘osteoporotic’ bone with t/ D = 0.33, while ten synthetic left femurs were used to simulate ‘normal’ bone with t/ D = 0.66. Axial, lateral, and torsional stiffness were measured for all femurs. There was excellent agreement between FE analysis and experimental stiffness data for all loading modes with an aggregate average percentage difference of 8 per cent. The FE results for mechanical stiffness versus cortical thickness ratio (0 ≤ t/ D ≤ 1) demonstrated exponential trends with the following stiffness ranges: axial stiffness (0 to 2343 N/mm), lateral stiffness (0 to 62 N/mm), and torsional stiffness (0 to 198 N/mm). This is the first study to characterize mechanical stiffness over a wide range of cortical thickness values. These results may have some clinical implications with respect to appropriately differentiating between older and younger human long bones from a mechanical standpoint.

The effect of load application rate on the biomechanics of synthetic femurs

Biomechanical investigations are increasingly using commercially available synthetic femurs as surrogates for human cadaveric femurs. However, the rate of force application in testing these artificial femurs appears to be chosen arbitrarily without much consideration to their visco-elastic time-dependent nature. The aim of this study, therefore, was to examine the effect of loading rate on the mechanical behaviour of synthetic femurs. Ten left, medium, fourth-generation composite femurs (Model 3403, Pacific Research Laboratories, Vashon, WA, USA) were fixed distally into cement-filled steel cubic chambers for mounting into a mechanical tester. In randomized order, each of the ten femurs was loaded at rates of 1, 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, and 60 mm/min to obtain axial, lateral, and torsional stiffness. Axial stiffness showed an aggregate average value of 1742.7 ± 174.7 N/mm with a high linear correlation with loading rate ( R2 = 0.80). Lateral stiffness yielded an aggregate average value of 56.9 ± 10.2 N/mm and was linearly correlated with loading rate ( R2 = 0.85). Torsional stiffness demonstrated an aggregate average value of 176.9 ± 14.5 N/mm with a strong linear correlation with loading rate ( R2 = 0.59). Despite the high correlations between stiffness and speed, practically this resulted in an overall average difference between the lowest and highest stiffness of only 4 per cent. Moreover, no statistical comparisons between loading rates for axial, lateral, or torsional test modes showed differences ( p ≤ 0.843). Future biomechanical investigators utilizing these synthetic femurs need not be concerned with loading rate effects over the range tested presently. This is the first study in the literature to perform such an assessment.

The effect of the screw pull-out rate on cortical screw purchase in unreamed and reamed synthetic long bones

Orthopaedic fracture fixation constructs are typically mounted on to human long bones using cortical screws. Biomechanical studies are increasingly employing commercially available synthetic bones. The aim of this investigation was to examine the effect of the screw pull-out rate and canal reaming on the cortical bone screw purchase strength in synthetic bone. Cylinders made of synthetic material were used to simulate unreamed (foam-filled) and reamed (hollow) human long bone with an outer diameter of 35 mm and a cortex wall thickness of 4 mm. The unreamed and reamed cylinders each had 56 sites along their lengths into which orthopaedic cortical bone screws (major diameter, 3.5 mm) were inserted to engage both cortices. The 16 test groups ( n = 7 screw sites per group) had screws extracted at rates of 1 mm/min, 5 mm/min, 10 mm/min, 20 mm/min, 30 mm/min, 40 mm/min, 50 mm/min, and 60 mm/min. The failure force and failure stress increased and were highly linearly correlated with pull-out rate for reamed ( R2 = 0.60 and 0.60), but not for unreamed ( R2 = 0.00 and 0.00) specimens. The failure displacement and failure energy were relatively unchanged with pull-out rate, yielding low coefficients for unreamed ( R2 = 0.25 and 0.00) and reamed ( R2 = 0.27 and 0.00) groups. Unreamed versus reamed specimens were statistically different for failure force ( p = 0.000) and stress ( p = 0.000), but not for failure displacement ( p = 0.297) and energy (0.054< p<1.000). This is the first study to perform an extensive investigation of the screw pull-out rate in unreamed and reamed synthetic long bone.