The Relationship Between Gait, Gross Motor Function, and Parental Perceived Outcome in Children With Clubfeet

Assessment of Gross Motor Skills in Ponseti-treated Children With Idiopathic Clubfoot at 3 Years Old: Insights from the Peabody Developmental Motor Scale 2

BACKGROUND

Congenital talipes equinovarus, or clubfoot, can lead to lifelong functional impairments, including diminished gross motor skills (GMS), if left untreated. The Ponseti method corrects idiopathic clubfoot through casting and bracing. Given the importance of GMS in childhood development, this technique must be optimized to support childhood and long-term health outcomes. This study examined immediate posttreatment GMS in 3-year-old children treated with Ponseti, hypothesizing that they would perform on par with their nonclubfoot peers.

METHODS

Data from 45 children (33 to 46 mo of age) treated for idiopathic clubfoot were analyzed. The Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, 2nd edition, was used to assess GMS, and logistic regression identified factors influencing Gross Motor Quotient (GMQ) scores.

RESULTS

Approximately half (n=22) of the patients exhibited below-average GMS (11th to 25th percentile), with 11 scoring below the 10th percentile. Initial deformity severity, gender, and cast numbers did not impact GMQ. Repeat percutaneous tenotomy was associated with lower GMQs. Brace compliance significantly reduced odds of low GMQs by up to 80%. Age at testing and additional surgery were also linked to below-average and poor GMQs.

CONCLUSIONS

GMS appeared to be impaired in almost half of the 3-year-old patients treated for idiopathic clubfoot, so our hypothesis was disproven. Repeat percutaneous tenotomy was associated with lower GMS, necessitating future recognition of patients who might be at risk of relapse. Brace noncompliance emerged as a significant risk factor, emphasizing early identification of these patients and education for their parents. This study offers a benchmark for clinicians and parents, but research on long-term outcomes is needed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II, prospective cohort study.

Clubfoot patients show more anterior-posterior displacement during one-leg-standing and less ankle power and plantarflexor moment during one-leg-hopping than typically developing children

BACKGROUND

Clubfoot patients show good-to-excellent foot correction after the Ponseti method. Nevertheless, underlying functional problems that limit motor abilities such as one-leg-standing and one-leg-hopping still persist. These restrictions have been proposed to arise due to problems with maintaining balance and the limited force-generating capacity of clubfoot patients. More insight is needed to understand the underlying limiting factors to improve overall motor ability in clubfoot patients.

RESEARCH QUESTION

The aim of this study was to determine the differences between clubfoot patients and typically developing children (TDC) in force and balance parameters during walking, one-leg-standing and hopping.

METHODS

Three-dimensional motion analysis was performed in 19 TDC and 16 idiopathic Ponseti-treated clubfoot patients between 5-9 years old. Kinematic and kinetic parameters were calculated during walking and one-leg-hopping. To describe the balance parameters, center of pressure (CoP) data was assessed during walking, one-leg-hopping and one-leg-standing. Mean group values were calculated and compared using nonparametric statistical tests. A general linear model with repeated measures was used to determine which activity showed the largest group differences.

RESULTS

Clubfoot patients showed lower peak plantarflexor moment and peak ankle power absorption and generation during one-leg-hopping compared to TDC. Furthermore, clubfoot patients showed a lower hop length and velocity than TDC. The difference in peak plantarflexor moment and ankle power between the study groups was larger during one-leg-hopping than during walking. Finally, clubfoot patients showed a higher anterior-posterior CoP range during one-leg-standing.

SIGNIFICANCE

Deviations in force parameters seemed to limit one-leg-hopping in clubfoot patients, and impaired anterior-posterior static balance was thought to be the underlying cause of problems with one-leg-standing. Furthermore, one-leg-hopping was more sensitive to distinguish between clubfoot patients and TDC than walking. Individualized physiotherapy targeting static balance and force parameters, with extra emphasis on including eccentric contractions, might improve the overall motor abilities of clubfoot patients.

Functional Outcome of Varus Derotation Osteotomy in Legg-Calve-Perthes Disease: Can It Be Justified in Late-Presenting Disease?

BACKGROUND

Legg-Calve-Perthes disease (LCPD) in children older than seven years has often been associated with accelerated progress and poor outcome. The results of varus derotation osteotomy (VDRO) of the proximal femur in this cohort are not consistently predictable. This study was aimed at assessing the functional outcome of VDRO for hip containment in children with late-presenting LCPD.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A quasi-prospective observational study was conducted to determine the functional outcomes of children with late-presenting unilateral LCPD who underwent VDRO between 2016 and 2021, with a minimum follow-up of two years. A retrospective chart review followed by a patient/parent-reported outcome measure using the Paediatric Outcome Data Collection Instrument (PODCI) was utilised.

RESULTS

Thirteen children were included in this study, with a mean age of 8.30 years (range: 7-12 years; SD: -1.493). Three children were in the early stages of the disease, modified Elizabethtown I and IIA (1 and 2, respectively). The majority of the children were in Stage IIB of the modified Elizabethtown staging (n=6), followed by Stage IIIA (n=4). The two children presenting in Stage IV of the disease were excluded from the analysis. The mean standardised and normative PODCI scores for transfer and mobility were 98.23 and 48.03, respectively. The mean standardised and normative PODCI scores for sports and physical were 93.15 and 49.76, respectively. Neither of the scores showed a statistically significant difference between the late and early stages of the disease (Transfer and Basic Mobility Scale: Standardised (p=0.273), Normative (p=0.268); Sports and Physical Functioning Scale: Standardised (p=0.618), Normative (p=0.631)). However, a higher mean PODCI score was noted for the early stages. There was no statistically significant difference between the median score and the duration since surgery. However, there was a moderate negative correlation between the time scores and the times since surgery for the late stages of the disease, viz. Stage IIB and IIIA (Transfer and Basic Mobility Scale: Standardised (-0.445), Normative (-0.450); Sports and Physical Functioning Scale: Standardised (-0.228), Normative (-0.228)). This correlation, however, did not reach a statistical significance.

CONCLUSION

VDRO can be regarded as a functionally rewarding option for femoral head containment in late-presenting LCPD across the evolutionary stages of the disease.

What is New in Pediatric Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle

BACKGROUND

This paper aims to report on the last 5 years of relevant research on pediatric foot and ankle pathology with specific focus on clubfoot, congenital vertical talus, toe walking, tarsal coalitions, pes planovalgus with or without accessory navicular, foot and ankle trauma, and talar dome osteochondritis dessicans.

METHODS

The Browzine platform was used to review the table of contents for all papers published in the following target journals related to the treatment of pediatric foot and ankle conditions. Search results were further refined to include clinical trials and randomized controlled trials published from March 1, 2015 to November 15, 2021.

RESULTS

A total of 73 papers were selected for review based on new findings and significant contributions in treatment of clubfoot, congenital vertical talus, toe walking, tarsal coalitions, pes planovalgus with or without accessory navicular, foot and ankle trauma, and talar dome osteochondritis dessicans. Also included were several papers that did not fit into any of these categories but provided new insight into specific foot and ankle pathologies.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment strategies for children with foot and ankle pathology are continually evolving. We review many of the most recent publications with the goal of improving understanding of these pathologies and highlighting current best practices.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Early developmental milestones in patients with idiopathic clubfoot treated by Ponseti method

BACKGROUND

Idiopathic clubfoot, also referred to as congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV), is one of the most common lower limb deformities observed in newborns, leading to significant functional impairment if untreated. The aims of this study were to (1) assess the developmental milestones in patients with CTEV treated by the Ponseti technique, and to compare them to the unaffected controls; (2) evaluate the possible correlation between developmental milestones, severity of the deformity, and number of casts.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-nine subjects were divided into two groups, CTEV group (43 patients; 72 feet) and control group (36 patients). Age, sex, affected side, attainment of babbles (BAL), independent gait (IG), and combined word (CW) were recorded for all patients. In patients with CTEV, Pirani Score (PRS), number of casts (NC), and clinical outcome were collected according to the Clubfoot Assessment Protocol (CAP), The American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Score (AOFAS), and Foot and Ankle Disability Index (FADI).

RESULTS

IG was achieved later later than the unaffected controls by 12/43 patients (27.9%) with CTEV and 3/36 patients in the control group (8.3%) (p = 0.04) and in a mean time of 16.8 ± 3.5 months and 13.2 ± 2.7 months, respectively (p = 0.001). In the CTEV group the mean value of CAP was 98.6 ± 4.7, of AOFAS of 98.4 ± 4.4 and of FADI equal to 99.9 ± 0.44. There were no statistically significant differences for BAL and CW; and no correlation with PRS, NC, or clinical score were identified.

CONCLUSION

CTEV patients managed by the Ponseti technique achieve independent gait later than the unaffected controls, although they do so within the age limit of developmental. On the other hand, the Ponseti treatment has no impact on attainment of language development.

Long-term follow-up of children with a surgically treated clubfoot: Assessing the multi-segment-foot motions, dynamic plantar pressures, and functional outcomes

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to compare surgically treated clubfoot with typically developing (TD) children using plantar pressure, multi-segment-foot kinematic analysis, and multiple functional outcomes in comprehensive and long-term study. Methods: 26 patients with 45 clubfeet and 23 TD children with 45 normal feet were evaluated. Most clubfoot patients had a complete subtalar release and a few patients had a posterior medial-lateral release at the mean age of 5 years and 6 months. The mean age at follow-up for clubfoot was 12 years and 5 months. Subjects underwent physical and radiographic examination, plantar pressure analysis, multi-segment-foot motion analysis, AAOS Foot & Ankle Questionnaire (AAOS-FAQ), the Pediatric Outcomes Data Collection Instrument (PODCI), and the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL).

RESULTS

Clubfoot patients scored significantly worse than TD on the AAOS-FAQ (90.9 vs.99.9 for pain and comfort), the CBCL Problems scale (23.1 vs.6.3), and several subscales of the PODCI (86.5 vs.96.7 for Sports and Physical Functioning) (P<0.05). Peak pressure at the lateral heel (25.6 vs.29.6 N/cm²), contact area at the 1 st metatarsal head (1 st MT) (6.0 vs. 7.2 cm²) and the pressure time integral at the 1 st MT (5.2 vs. 11.0 N/cm² ∗ s) were significantly lower for the clubfoot group compared to the TD foot group (P<0.05). Maximum dorsiflexion of the 1 st metatarsal-hallux (1 st MT-Hal) (17.5° vs. 34.8°) during stance phase (ST), supination of the 1 st MT-Hal during swing phase (SW) (4° vs. 7°), maximum plantarflexion of the ankle during ST (-6.8° vs.-11.2°), and maximum varus of the ankle during SW (4.4° vs. 6.9°) were also lower for clubfoot except for maximum dorsiflexion of the navicular-1 st MT (P<0.05).

CONCLUSION

This study supports evidence that surgically treated clubfoot continues to have residual deformity of forefoot, overcorrection of hindfoot, stiffness, and a decrease in physical functioning. This comprehensive study accurately portrays postsurgical clubfoot function with objective means through appropriate technologies. A plantar pressure redistributed and finite element analysis designed orthosis may be of importance in the improvement of the foot and ankle joint function for ambulatory children with a relapse of clubfoot deformity.

Using the PODCI to Measure Motor Function and Parent Expectations in Children With Cerebral Palsy

OBJECTIVE

Involving parents in the evaluation of their child with cerebral palsy (CP) is associated with enhanced neurodevelopmental outcomes. The pediatric outcomes data collection instrument (PODCI) is a patient-reported outcome measure primarily used to assess motor function following orthopedic surgical intervention or for older children with more independent motor function. The PODCI expectations scale has infrequently been reported in previous studies. This study aims to determine the relationship between parent-reported motor performance using the PODCI and motor capacity assessed by pediatric therapists for young children with CP across all ability levels and to explore the use of the PODCI expectations scale for quantifying therapy-related parent expectations.

METHODS

This prospective cohort study included 108 participants with CP, 2 to 8 years of age, gross motor function classification systems (GMFCS) levels I to V. Measures included the PODCI, gross motor function measure (GMFM), and GMFCS.

RESULTS

There were moderate (r = 0.513) to large (r = 0.885) relationships between PODCI and GMFM scores. PODCI scores were significantly different across GMFCS levels. Weak, significant relationships (r = -0.28) were found between function expectations scores and measures of function.

CONCLUSION

The PODCI, GMFM, and GMFCS provide different, but strongly related, information about the abilities of young children. The GMFM measures motor capacity. Parents report daily function and health-related quality of life for their child using the PODCI. Parent expectations for intervention outcomes may relate to a child's motor function.

IMPACT

These study results are consistent with those for older children with greater independent mobility, indicating an opportunity for expanded use of the PODCI for measuring motor performance for younger children with CP across all ability levels. A strategy is provided for using the PODCI expectations scale to quantify parent therapy-related expectations in future research and clinical settings. Therapy-related expectations may relate to child outcomes.

This is a narrative review of the functional evaluation of clubfoot treatment with gait analysis

Clinicians worldwide have embraced Ponseti’s nonoperative approach in the treatment of clubfoot, primarily due to ubiquitous reports of successful outcomes. A crucial component in this measured success, has come from researchers assessing long-term physical function following nonoperative treatment. Gait analysis has been instrumental in objectively evaluating lower extremity kinematics and kinetics while plantar pressures demonstrate the load bearing patterns experienced in the foot. As technology improves, our ability to evaluate function can take place both in the laboratory setting, and in the community. For over 20 years, our institution has been studying the gait patterns of children treated for clubfoot. After adopting the nonoperative approach, we established a prospective research program that has allowed us to study functional outcomes in the very young walker, through growth to adolescents, and finally at skeletal maturity. We have seen over 450 children treated for clubfoot in the Movement Science Lab, for over 1,250 gait assessments over the span of this study. Early results in 105 children (154 feet) treated nonoperatively for clubfoot, showed 56% of children had normal sagittal plane ankle kinematics, however an incidence of 48% of Ponseti feet had increased dorsiflexion in stance phase, leading us to wonder if this was the result of the tenotomy. Intermediate follow up at age 5 years, showed that the incidence of increased dorsiflexion was reduced (24%) and ankle power did not appear to be affected (P>0.05 compared to controls). The research highlighted in this paper presents the application of functional evaluation through growth and the long-term effects of nonoperative treatment on gait and function. This is a review of the functional outcome studies from our experience at Scottish Rite for Children.

The Influence of Achilles Tenotomy and Compliance with Foot Abduction Orthosis on the Relapse Rate of Ponseti Treatment for Idiopathic Clubfoot: A Regional Study

The Ponseti method for treating idiopathic clubfoot is based on gradual manipulations and corrective plaster castings followed by a years-long period of use of a foot orthosis. The role of surgery is limited. The factors that may affect outcome and their influence are subject of controversy. The aim of the study is to systematically and objectively evaluate the results of Ponseti treatment in our region of Southern Israel and focus on the role of the Achilles tenotomy and compliance to foot orthosis as factors that may influence outcome. The use of Ponseti method was retrospectively studied (level of evidence IV) by searching computerized medical files and clinical photos. The severity of deformity was evaluated by Dimeglio score (D-score) at baseline and at last examination. During 2006-2014, 57 children with idiopathic clubfoot (total 90 feet) were enrolled. An Achilles tenotomy was performed in 55/90 (61.1%) of the feet. If the D-score was 15 or higher there was a 20% increase in the incidence of Achilles tenotomy. The parental compliance had a weak protective effect against relapse. The treatment of idiopathic clubfoot by the Ponseti method was successful and reliable, proving efficiency and universality of the method. A dominant predictor for relapse was not seen. An incidental observation was that extended time in cast may buffer the adverse effects of low compliance rate. Although the initial severity, or compliance to braces are important, there may be other factors that affect the outcome such as, accuracy of the casting technique, time in the cast, access to a dedicated clubfoot clinic, cooperation with nurses and pediatricians, economic status that allows purchase of new generation of braces, cultural perception, and education level of the patient population are some examples.

Gross motor skill development is similar in children post Ponseti casting for congenital talipes equinovarus compared to typically developing children: a systematic review

This review aimed to investigate gross motor skill development in children with congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) following the Ponseti method of casting and bracing. Summary of evidence revealed through a systematic search of electronic databases completed in May 2019. A Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses statement was used to report and conduct the study. The McMaster Critical Review Form was used to critically appraise included studies and a descriptive synthesis of the results is reported. Inclusion criteria for studies included participants aged above 4 years, with a diagnosis of CTEV, treated via the Ponseti method and followed up with valid gross motor outcome measures. The comparator was a control group of typically developing children, or reference data. The searches resulted in 619 unique articles. Eight studies (retrospective cohort/case control studies) met inclusion criteria. There were nine different outcome measures used with 29 domains being relevant to this review. Synthesis of the findings found no significant difference between the gross motor skills of children with CTEV treated with Ponseti and typically developing children. The balance domains of three measures were consistently lower for the CTEV group versus controls/normative data. Yet, it is still demonstrated that most gross motor skills are within the typically developing range. It must be considered, however, that there is a spectrum of severity of CTEV and overall gross motor function should be monitored.

Foot function during gait and parental perceived outcome in older children with symptomatic club foot deformity

Aims

To assess if older symptomatic children with club foot deformity differ in perceived disability and foot function during gait, depending on initial treatment with Ponseti or surgery, compared to a control group. Second aim was to investigate correlations between foot function during gait and perceived disability in this population.

Methods

In all, 73 children with idiopathic club foot were included: 31 children treated with the Ponseti method (mean age 8.3 years; 24 male; 20 bilaterally affected, 13 left and 18 right sides analyzed), and 42 treated with primary surgical correction (mean age 11.6 years; 28 male; 23 bilaterally affected, 18 left and 24 right sides analyzed). Foot function data was collected during walking gait and included Oxford Foot Model kinematics (Foot Profile Score and the range of movement and average position of each part of the foot) and plantar pressure (peak pressure in five areas of the foot). Oxford Ankle Foot Questionnaire, Disease Specific Index for club foot, Paediatric Quality of Life Inventory 4.0 were also collected. The gait data were compared between the two club foot groups and compared to control data. The gait data were also correlated with the data extracted from the questionnaires.

Results

Our findings suggest that symptomatic children with club foot deformity present with similar degrees of gait deviations and perceived disability regardless of whether they had previously been treated with the Ponseti Method or surgery. The presence of sagittal and coronal plane hindfoot deformity and coronal plane forefoot deformity were associated with higher levels of perceived disability, regardless of their initial treatment.

Conclusion

This is the first paper to compare outcomes between Ponseti and surgery in a symptomatic older club foot population seeking further treatment. It is also the first paper to correlate foot function during gait and perceived disability to establish a link between deformity and subjective outcomesCite this article: Bone Joint Open 2020;1-7:384-391.

Can Repeated Ponseti Management for Relapsed Clubfeet Produce the Outcome Comparable With the Case Without Relapse? A Clinical Study in Term of Gait Analysis

BACKGROUND

The prevention and treatment of relapsed clubfoot remained challenging tasks. There were controversies as to treatment options and management, such as complete subtalar release, application of an Ilizarov external frame, or repeated Ponseti method; and different options were available in different treatment centers. This study was designed to evaluate the clinical outcome of relapsed clubfeet treated by repeated Ponseti method in comparison with the cases without relapse in term of gait analysis and to clarify the clinical efficacy of repeated Ponseti method in treating the relapsed clubfeet.

METHODS

Thirty-seven patients (53 feet) were retrospectively identified from our database according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Among the 37 patients, 17 cases (25 relapsed clubfeet) were assigned to group I, whereas 20 cases (28 clubfeet without relapse) were assigned to group II. Clinical examination, gait analysis, and kinematic gait deviation criteria from Texas Scottish Rite Hospital for Children were used for evaluation.

RESULTS

There was statistically significant difference in the parameters of foot length, stride length, and single limb support time (%gait cycle) between the 2 groups (P<0.05). No statistically significant difference was found in the kinematic parameters of total hip, knee, and ankle excursion, peak knee and ankle flexion and extension, and internal foot progression (P>0.05). There was no statistically significant difference in peak hip, knee, and ankle flexion moment, peak knee valgus moment, and peak ankle power (P>0.05). No statistically significant difference was found in equinus and calcaneus gait, increased ankle dorsiflexion, foot drop, and internal foot progression angle (P>0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Repeated Ponseti method for relapsed clubfeet can yield good or excellent clinical results. We recommend repeated Ponseti method as the treatment choice for relapsed clubfeet in the early stage.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III-retrospective comparative study.

Gross Motor Skills in Children With Idiopathic Clubfoot and the Association Between Gross Motor Skills, Foot Involvement, Gait, and Foot Motion

BACKGROUND

Little is known regarding gross motor skills (GMS) in children with idiopathic clubfoot (IC). This study describes GMS, specifically foot involvement and asymmetries, and analyses the association between GMS, gait, and foot status in children with IC.

METHODS

Gross motor tasks and gait were analyzed in children with IC and typically developed (TD) children. GMS were assessed using videotapes and the Clubfoot Assessment Protocol (CAP). The Gait Deviation Index (GDI) and GDI-Kinetic were calculated from gait analyses. Children were divided into bilateral, unilateral clubfoot, or TD groups. To analyze asymmetries, feet within each group were further classified into superior or inferior foot, depending on their CAP scores. Correlations identified associations between CAP and GDI, GDI-Kinetic, passive foot motion, and Dimeglio Classification Scores at birth in the clubfeet.

RESULTS

In total, 75 children (mean age, 5 years) were enrolled (bilateral n=22, unilateral clubfoot n=25, TD=28). Children with clubfeet demonstrated significantly lower GMS, gait, and foot motion compared with TD children. One leg standing and hopping deviated in 84% and 91%, respectively, in at least one foot in children with clubfoot. Gross motor asymmetries were evident in both children with bilateral and unilateral involvement. In children with unilateral clubfoot, contralateral feet showed few deviations in GMS compared with TD; however, differences existed in gait and foot motion. The association between GMS and gait, foot motion, and initial foot status varied between poor and moderate.

CONCLUSIONS

Gross motor deficits and asymmetries are present in children with both bilateral and unilateral IC. Development of GMS of the contralateral foot mirrors that of TD children, but modifies to the clubfoot in gait and foot motion. The weak association with gait, foot motion, and initial clubfoot severity indicates that gross motor measurements represent a different outcome entity in clubfoot treatment. We therefore, recommend gross motor task evaluation for children with IC.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II-prognostic studies.

Functional physiotherapy method results for the treatment of idiopathic clubfoot

BACKGROUND

Idiopathic clubfoot is a congenital deformity of multifactorial etiology. The initial treatment is eminently conservative; one of the methods applied is the Functional physiotherapy method (FPM), which includes different approaches: Robert Debré (RD) and Saint-Vincent-de-Paul (SVP) among them. This method is based on manipulations of the foot, bandages, splints and exercises adapted to the motor development of the child aimed to achieve a plantigrade and functional foot. Our hypothesis was that the SVP method could be more efficient than the RD method in correcting deformities, and would decrease the rate of surgeries.

AIM

To compare the RD and SVP methods, specifically regarding the improvement accomplished and the frequency of surgery needed to achieve a plantigrade foot.

METHODS

Retrospective study of 71 idiopathic clubfeet of 46 children born between February 2004 and January 2012, who were evaluated and classified in our hospital according to severity by the Dimeglio-Bensahel scale. We included moderate, severe and very severe feet. Thirty-four feet were treated with the RD method and 37 feet with the SVP method. The outcomes at a minimum of two years were considered as very good (by physiotherapy), good (by percutaneous heel-cord tenotomy), fair (by limited surgery), and poor (by complete surgery).

RESULTS

Complete release was not required in any case; limited posterior release was done in 23 cases (74%) with the RD method and 9 (25%) with the SVP method (P < 0.001). The percutaneous heel-cord tenotomy was done in 2 feet treated with the RD method (7%) and 6 feet (17%) treated with the SVP method (P < 0.001). Six feet in the RD group (19%) and twenty-one feet (58%) in the SVP group did not require any surgery (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Our study provides evidence of the superiority of the SVP method over the RD method, as a variation of the FPM, for the treatment of idiopathic clubfoot.

Functional Outcomes Following Treatment for Clubfoot: Ten-Year Follow-up

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to assess function, at the age of 10 years, of children initially treated nonoperatively for clubfoot with either the Ponseti or French physiotherapy program and to compare outcomes in feet that had undergone only nonoperative treatment with those that required subsequent surgery.

METHODS

Gait analysis, isokinetic ankle strength, parent-reported outcomes, and daily step activity data were collected when patients who had been treated for idiopathic clubfoot reached the age of 10 years. Patients who had undergone only nonoperative treatment were compared with those who subsequently underwent extra-articular surgery or intra-articular surgery (posterior release or posteromedial release). The clubfoot groups were compared with age-matched controls.

RESULTS

Of 263 treated clubfeet in 175 patients, 148 had only been treated nonoperatively, 29 underwent extra-articular surgery, and 86 underwent intra-articular surgery (posterior release in 42 and posteromedial release in 44). Significant abnormalities were found in ankle kinetics and isokinetic ankle strength in the feet treated with intra-articular surgery compared with the nonoperatively treated feet (p < 0.017). Compared with controls (n = 40 feet), all groups showed reduced ankle plantar flexion during gait, resulting in a deficit of 9% to 14% for dynamic range of motion, 13% to 20% for ankle moment, and 13% to 23% for power (p < 0.013). Within the intra-articular group, feet that underwent posteromedial release had decreased plantar flexion strength (15%; p = 0.008), dorsiflexion strength (6%; p = 0.048), and parent-reported global function scores (p = 0.032) compared with the posterior release group. The patients with clubfoot took 10% fewer steps (p = 0.015) and had 11% less total ambulatory time (p = 0.001) than the controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Examination of patients when they had reached the age of 10 years showed better ankle power and isokinetic strength for clubfeet treated without surgery compared with those that underwent intra-articular surgery for residual deformity or recurrence. Compared with controls, both nonoperatively and surgically treated clubfeet had significant limitations in ankle plantar flexion resulting in decreased range of motion, moment, and power. Gastrocnemius-soleus complex strength was decreased after both nonoperative and surgical treatment of clubfeet. Although activity was diminished in the clubfoot population, no differences in function were perceived by the patients' parents.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Gross Motor Function at 10 Years of Age in Children With Clubfoot Following the French Physical Therapy Method and the Ponseti Technique

PURPOSE

To evaluate gross motor skills [Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency, 2nd ed (BOT-2)] of patients with idiopathic clubfoot initially treated nonoperatively with either the French functional physical therapy (PT) method or the Ponseti technique, at age 10 years.

METHODS

The BOT-2 was administered by trained physical therapists on patients with idiopathic clubfoot at age 10 years. The cohort was divided by initial treatment method (PT or Ponseti), and compared. Subsequent analyses included comparisons of: initial clubfoot severity (Dimeglio scores: ≤13 vs. >13), laterality (unilateral vs. bilateral), and surgical versus nonoperative outcome.

RESULTS

Of the 183 patients tested, 172 were included. The Ponseti and PT groups did not significantly differ according to age, height, weight, body mass index, ankle dorsiflexion, sex, average initial Dimeglio score, laterality, or surgical versus nonsurgical outcome. Overall, patients with treated clubfoot had average gross motor BOT-2 scores compared with age-matched peers. Patients in the PT group scored higher on Running Speed/Agility (P=0.019), Body Coordination percentile rank (P=0.038), and Strength and Agility percentile rank (P=0.007) than patients treated by the Ponseti technique. Patients with bilateral clubfoot scored significantly lower on the Balance subtest (P<0.01), and Body Coordination percentile rank (P<0.01), than those with unilateral clubfoot. Patients who required surgery scored significantly lower on the Balance subtest (P=0.04) than those who did not require surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Clubfoot may impair balance in 10 year olds with bilateral involvement and those requiring surgery. Future research should evaluate whether components of the PT method may improve gross motor outcomes as a supplement to the Ponseti technique.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level II.

Gait kinetics in children with clubfeet treated surgically or with the Ponseti method: A meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Currently, the Ponseti method is the gold standard for treatment of clubfeet. For long-term functional evaluation of this method, gait analysis can be performed. Previous studies have assessed gait differences between Ponseti treated clubfeet and healthy controls.

RESEARCH QUESTION/PURPOSE

The aims of this systematic review were to compare the gait kinetics of Ponseti treated clubfeet with healthy controls and to compare the gait kinetics between clubfoot patients treated with the Ponseti method or surgically.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed in Embase, Medline Ovid, Web of Science, Scopus, Cochrane, Cinahl ebsco, and Google scholar, for studies reporting on gait kinetics in children with clubfeet treated with the Ponseti method. Studies were excluded if they only used EMG or pedobarography. Data were extracted and a risk of bias was assessed. Meta-analyses and qualitative analyses were performed.

RESULTS

Nine studies were included, of which five were included in the meta-analyses. The meta-analyses showed that ankle plantarflexor moment (95% CI -0.25 to -0.19) and ankle power (95% CI -0.89 to -0.60, were significantly lower in the Ponseti treated clubfeet compared to the healthy controls. No significant difference was found in ankle dorsiflexor and plantarflexor moment, and ankle power between clubfeet treated with surgery compared to the Ponseti method.

SIGNIFICANCE

Differences in gait kinetics are present when comparing Ponseti treated clubfeet with healthy controls. However, there is no significant difference between surgically and Ponseti treated clubfeet. These results give more insight in the possibilities of improving the gait pattern of patients treated for clubfeet.

Motor abilities in 182 children treated for idiopathic clubfoot: a comparison between the traditional and the Ponseti method and controls

PURPOSE

The aim of the study was to examine motor abilities in children treated for idiopathic clubfoot with either the traditional extensive surgery method or the Ponseti method, and compare their motor skills with a control group without clubfoot.

METHODS

A total of 89 children treated according to the traditional method (mean age 9.0 years, 7 to 10) and 93 treated ad modum Ponseti (mean age 8.8 years, 7 to 10) were recruited from a multicentre clinical study in Norway. A total of 45 age-matched children without clubfoot were recruited from a nearby school. They were all assessed with the Movement Assessment Battery for Children - Second Edition (MABC-2), which evaluates motor performance. We applied Analysis of Covariance for comparison of the two treatment methods and adjusted for gender, laterality, comorbidity, achillotomy or more extended surgery, physiotherapy and the age when the child walked independently.

RESULTS

We found no significant difference in any of the various components or the total score of the MABC-2 between patients treated with the two different methods. In all, 76% of the children treated according to the traditional method and ad modum Ponseti, and 96% in the control group, respectively, were classified as having normal motor abilities.

CONCLUSION

About three-quarters of children aged nine years and treated for idiopathic clubfoot had normal motor abilities. We found similar results in patients treated with the traditional method and the Ponseti method.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II.

Pedobarographic Analysis following Ponseti Treatment for Unilateral Neglected Congenital Clubfoot

Recent trends have led to an interest in Ponseti treatment for correcting neglected congenital clubfoot. Although good clinical and functional outcomes have been reported, the plantar pressure distribution after the treatment of neglected clubfoot has not been explored yet. The present study aimed to investigate whether plantar pressures normalized following Ponseti treatment in patients with neglected congenital clubfoot. Pedobarographic, clinical, and functional examinations were performed in 22 children (aged, 91.0 ± 40.3 months) with unilateral neglected congenital clubfeet, treated using Ponseti method at 27.8 ± 12.1 months of age. Plantar pressure parameters were recorded using a Footscan pressure plate. The contact time, contact area, peak pressure, and pressure-time integral were determined. The data of the affected feet were compared with those of the unaffected feet and healthy controls. Although clinical and functional examinations showed satisfactory results according to the Dimeglio and Pirani scores, considerable differences in plantar pressure parameters were identified among the affected feet, unaffected feet, and healthy controls. Internal foot progression angle and a load transfer from the medial forefoot and hindfoot to the lateral forefoot and midfoot were observed in the affected feet. Future studies should attempt to investigate the factors accounting for plantar pressure deviations and the possible effect of these deviations on the lower limb musculoskeletal development of children.

Clubfoot Does Not Impair Gross Motor Development in 5-Year-Olds

PURPOSE

To evaluate the gross motor development of 5-year-olds using the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, 2nd Edition (PDMS-2), test after initial nonoperative management of clubfoot as infants.

METHODS

The PDMS-2 Stationary, Locomotion, and Object Manipulation subtests were assessed on 128 children with idiopathic clubfeet at the age of 5 years. Children were categorized by their initial clubfoot severity as greater than 13, unilateral or bilateral involvement, and required surgery.

RESULTS

Children with treated clubfeet had average gross motor scores (99 Gross Motor Quotient) compared with age-matched normative scores. Children with more severe clubfeet required surgery significantly more than children with less severe scores (P < .01). Peabody scores were not significantly different according to initial clubfoot severity, unilateral versus bilateral involvement, and surgical versus nonsurgical outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

Clubfoot does not significantly impair gross motor development in 5-year-olds.

What is new in idiopathic clubfoot?

Idiopathic clubfoot has a tremendous worldwide prevalence. If left untreated, the deformity has severely disabling effects on mobility and quality of life. Given its prevalence and significance, numerous studies are published on this condition every year. In this article, we attempt to highlight important themes and findings of studies published on idiopathic clubfoot over the past 3 years.