Assessment of hip abductor power in patients with foot drop: a simple and useful test to differentiate lumbar radiculopathy and peroneal neuropathy

Can MR neurography of the common peroneal nerve predict a residual motor deficit in patients with foot drop?

OBJECTIVE

To determine if MR neurography of the common peroneal nerve (CPN) predicts a residual motor deficit at 12-month clinical follow-up in patients presenting with foot drop.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective search for MR neurography cases evaluating the CPN at the knee was performed. Patients were included if they had electrodiagnostic testing (EDX) within 3 months of imaging, ankle and/or forefoot dorsiflexion weakness at presentation, and at least 12-month follow-up. Two radiologists individually evaluated nerve size (enlarged/normal), nerve signal (T2 hyperintense/normal), muscle signal (T2 hyperintense/normal), muscle bulk (normal/Goutallier 1/Goutallier > 1), and nerve and muscle enhancement. Discrepancies were resolved via consensus review. Multivariable logistical regression was used to evaluate for association between each imaging finding and a residual motor deficit at 12-month follow-up.

RESULTS

Twenty-three 3 T MRIs in 22 patients (1 bilateral, mean age 52 years, 16 male) met inclusion criteria. Eighteen cases demonstrated common peroneal neuropathy on EDX, and median duration of symptoms was 5 months. Six cases demonstrated a residual motor deficit at 12-month follow-up. Fourteen cases underwent CPN decompression (1 bilateral) within 1 year of presentation. Three cases demonstrated Goutallier > 1 anterior compartment muscle bulk. Multivariable logistical regression did not show a statistically significant association between any of the imaging findings and a residual motor deficit at 12-month follow-up.

CONCLUSION

MR neurography did not predict a residual motor deficit at 12-month follow-up in patients presenting with foot drop, though few patients demonstrated muscle atrophy in this study.

Double Crush Syndrome of the Lower Limb in L5 Radiculopathy and Peroneal Neuropathy: A Case Report

Double crush syndrome (DCS) is a clinical condition involving impingement of the spinal and peripheral nerves. DCS of the lower limbs has been recognized; however, no detailed reports have been published. Herein, we report a rare case of the coexistence of L5 radiculopathy and peroneal nerve entrapment neuropathy. The patient suffered from pain in the left lower leg and left foot combined with muscle weakness in the left leg without a Tinel-like sign in the peroneal tunnel area. MRI showed a deficit in the left L5 nerve root sleeve, and X-ray imaging revealed L5 spondylolysis. Lumbar fusion surgery was performed at L5-S1. Subsequently, the patient’s symptoms were partially improved, but the pain and toe and ankle motor weakness persisted. In addition, a Tinel-like sign appeared at the entrapment point of the peroneal nerve. The entrapped peroneal nerve was decompressed, and the patient’s symptoms improved. The patient had L5 radiculopathy owing to the improvement in his symptoms in the upper leg before and after lumbar surgery. It is unclear why no Tinel-like sign was detected before the first surgery, but we hypothesized that L5 nerve disorder may mask the symptoms triggered by compression of the peroneal nerve due to the complex pathology of DCS and dynamic factors. Distinguishing between radiculopathy and relative peripheral neuropathy should always be a consideration. DCS may mask characteristic symptoms, and it is important to carefully follow up the patient to detect changes in his or her condition.

Drop foot due to lumbar degenerative disease: Painless drop foot is difficult to recover

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the improvement of drop foot following lumbar decompression surgery and determine the prognostic factors that might influence the recovery of drop foot.

SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND DATE

Drop foot is a common but serious problem that can lead to deteriorate patient's daily activities. There are numerous studied regarding the prognostic factors for the recovery of drop foot. However a few reports have been described the pathophysiological etiology of not only drop foot but also Trendelenburg's sign due to the L5 nerve root palsy. Therefore, there is a possibility drop foot caused by peroneal nerve palsy is included. In addition, none have evaluated the presence or absence of radicular leg pain with drop foot patients. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the improvement of paretic leg muscles and determine the prognostic factors that might influence the recovery of drop foot.

METHODS

Fifty-five drop foot patients were included in the study. Prognostic factors were retrospectively studied.Patients were assessed in terms of 10 items: 1) age, 2) sex, 3) diagnosis (LDH or LSS), 4) muscle strength of tibialis anterior, 5) muscle strength of extensor halluces longus, 6) muscle strength of gluteus medius, 7) presence or absence of radicular leg pain, 8) duration before surgery, 9) surgical treatment (spinal fusion or not), 10) anamnesis of diabetes mellitus.

RESULTS

Thirty-two (58.2%) of 55 patients recovered from their drop foot (manual muscle test of tibialis anterior ≥ 4 at final follow-up), while 23 (41.8%) did not (manual muscle test of tibialis anterior ≤ 3 at final follow-up). The strength of all muscles that were innervated and controlled by the L5 nerve root had recovered at the final follow-up when evaluated as averages. Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed significant differences in terms of 2 items: "duration before surgery" and "presence or absence of radicular leg pain".

CONCLUSIONS

"Duration before surgery" and "presence or absence of radicular leg pain" are important to predict the recovery of drop foot. Painless drop foot patients with lumbar degenerative disease are difficult to recover their paralysis.

Drop Foot Secondary to a Peroneal Intraneural Ganglion Connected to the Superior Tibiofibular Joint: A Case Report

Peroneal neuropathy is the most frequent mononeuropathy of the lower extremity. Intraneural ganglion cysts (INGCs) are among rare causes of peroneal nerve palsy. According to the articular (synovial) theory, the articular branch plays the key role in the pathogenesis. Patients present with pain around the fibular head and neck, motor weakness resulting in foot drop and paresthesia in the anterolateral calf and foot. Ultrasonography (US) and MRI are both useful in the diagnosis, but MRI is the best imaging modality in the demonstration of the articular connection and the relation of the cyst with adjacent structures, even without special neurography sequences. We present a 32-year-old male patient referred to our neurosurgery clinic with suspicion of lumbar radiculopathy. He presented with right foot drop which began 3 weeks prior. On examination, there was 90% loss in the ankle dorsiflexion and finger extension. Ankle eversion was also weakened. There was no low back or posterolateral thigh pain to suggest L5 radiculopathy and sciatic neuropathy. Following negative lumbar spine MRI, peripheral neuropathy was concerned. Electrodiagnostic evaluations findings were consistent with acute/subacute common peroneal nerve (CPN) axonal neuropathy. Subsequent MRI of knee showed a homogeneous, thin-walled tubular cystic lesion, extending along the course of the CPN and its articular branch. Full recovery of the neuropathy was achieved with early diagnosis and decompression via microsurgical epineurotomy. The diagnosis of INGC was confirmed by histopathologic examination. INGCs, although rare, should also be considered in the differential diagnosis of peripheral mononeuropathies.

Compression of the S1 Nerve Root by an Extradural Vascular Malformation: A Case Report and Discussion of Atypical Causes of Lumbar Radiculopathy

We present a case of lumbar radiculopathy due to a vascular malformation in the lumbar spine and discuss various causes of atypical lumbar radiculopathy. Lumbar radiculopathy is a condition of neurologic deficits and painful symptoms of the lower extremities due to nerve root compression, most commonly at the L5 and S1 levels. Several factors contribute to lumbar radiculopathy, including intervertebral disc herniation, foraminal stenosis, and spinal instability. There are also a number of atypical causes, including medication side effects or metabolic disorders, which produce symptoms of radiculopathy but do not involve compression of the nerve root. Anatomic variations in the nerve roots or vascular supply surrounding the nerve root may also increase the risk of developing radiculopathy and serve as an obstacle to interpreting imaging during a preoperative workup. A 38-year-old woman presented with sudden onset radicular symptoms in her right lower extremity. Lumbar magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated a right-sided L5-S1 extruded nucleus pulposus. Her symptoms failed to improve after conservative management so she underwent surgical decompression of L4-S1. Intraoperatively, we discovered an extensive, extradural vascular malformation present at the L5-S1 level and believed this to be the true cause of her radiculopathy. This case represents an atypical cause of lumbar radiculopathy and demonstrates the importance of considering atypical causes during diagnostic workup and preoperative planning.

Clinching the cause: A review of foot drop secondary to lumbar degenerative diseases

Foot drop is defined as weakness on dorsiflexion of the foot. The top two most common etiologies for foot drop include lumbar degenerative disease and common peroneal nerve injury. This review provides "updates" on understanding the lumbar etiologies of foot drop. Since the publication of "Preoperative motor strength and time to surgery are the most important predictors of improvement in foot drop due to degenerative lumbar disease" in the Journal of Neurological Sciences, three cohort studies have been published on spinal causes of foot drop. Classification, clinical features, diagnosis, and pathogenesis that may 'clinch' the cause of foot drop are discussed in the context of these recent publications.

Mimickers of lumbar radiculopathy

Orthopaedic surgeons frequently treat patients who report pain that radiates from the back into the lower extremity. Although the most common etiology is either a herniated disk or spinal stenosis, a myriad of pathologies can mimic the symptoms of radiculopathy, resulting in differences in the clinical presentation and the workup. Therefore, the clinician must be able to distinguish the signs and symptoms of lumbar radiculopathy from pathologies that may have a similar presentation. Being cognizant of these other possible conditions enables the physician to consider a breadth of alternative diagnoses when a patient presents with radiating lower extremity pain.

Clinical characteristics of peroneal nerve palsy by posture

Objective

Posture induced common peroneal nerve (CPN) palsy is usually produced during the prolonged squatting or habitual leg crossing while seated, especially in Asian culture and is manifested by the onset of foot drop. Because of its similarity to discogenic foot drop, patients may be diagnosed with a lumbar disc disorder, and in some patients, surgeons may perform unnecessary examinations and even spine surgery. The purpose of our study is to establish the clinical characteristics and diagnostic assessment of posture induced CPN palsy.

Methods

From June 2008 to June 2012, a retrospective study was performed on 26 patients diagnosed with peroneal nerve palsy in neurophysiologic study among patients experiencing foot drop after maintaining a certain posture for a long time.

Results

The inducing postures were squatting (14 patients), sitting cross-legged (6 patients), lying down (4 patients), walking and driving. The mean prolonged neural injury time was 124.2 minutes. The most common clinical presentation was foot drop and the most affected sensory area was dorsum of the foot with tingling sensation (14 patients), numbness (8 patients), and burning sensation (4 patients). The clinical improvement began after a mean 6 weeks, which is not related to neural injury times. Electrophysiology evaluation was performed after 2 weeks later and showed delayed CPN nerve conduction study (NCS) in 24 patients and deep peroneal nerve in 2 patients.

Conclusion

We suggest that an awareness of these clinical characteristics and diagnostic assessment methods may help clinicians make a diagnosis of posture induced CPN palsy and preclude unnecessary studies or inappropriate treatment in foot drop patients.